I do not believe that mathieuh considers Mandela's "not always nonviolent" stance to be a negative.
I think the idea is more along the lines of "violence had its place in that conflict, it was for a good cause, and it worked."
Injecting my own opinion here: I think that if we forget the usefulness of violence then we may risk failing to repeat Mandela's success, should the need ever arise. Nonviolence is great, but only when it works. When it doesn't, violence should be embraced. We should embrace whatever is necessary to get the job done, nonviolence should be seen as a (typically very effective) means to an end, not an end in itself.
Re:South Africa's Nelson Mandela dies
by eruditely on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:53PM
(#6858584)
Except it is you who is projecting his value system over who you are responding to. Nobody implied 'violence' was wrong in this context, violence is at many times necessary and was so in mandela's case, he had to do what he had to do to achieve progress, and when it wasn't necessary he did, but when it was he did as well.
We cannot allow people to only paint him as peaceful completely simply because non-violent struggle is not what brought about long-term peace. Both did.
No one's perfect but it's unreasonable to only focus on the negative.