News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by Overdrivr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:12AM (#50494492)
It's because the hard part of making software is not coding, but deciding what's worth building (even with LLMs), appropriately modelling the problem and designing the solution (at a conceptual, architectural level). And there has been strictly zero progress on this and IMO this isn't something LLMs are strucurally capable of doing.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jmathai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:19AM (#50494811)
Software I’ve written has marginally been improving both as LLMs and their tooling has improved and my ability utilize them has increased.

I think marginally is an understatement though because it feels like it is compounding. I don’t know other people’s experience but I’m building software that would not have existed before LLMs and coding agents arrived.

And this software is without a doubt better from the end users perspective. Maybe the code is crap, who knows? I don’t look at it. I judge based on 25 years of writing software by hand, deploying it to real users, and being a user myself.

I hope there is a resurgence of indie software like existed in the early 2000s.

There’s no hope for enterprise software. It will always be terrible.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by elvis10ten on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:21AM (#50495156)
> Maybe the code is crap, who knows? I don’t look at it

I implore you to look at it! I recently vibed too close to the sun: I knew at a high-level what I was doing, but never looked at the code.

Two weeks after and 50k LOC, I’m having a look and I can’t believe my eyes. There are whole failure modes that don’t need to exist. Moreover, how can I sale this software in good faith, when something happens and I’m largely a meat proxy because I don’t know how the code works?

I will go through the entirety of the code with my naked eyes, and make improvements (with AI).

But this time, I won’t fall for the illusion of “productivity”.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by whatisthiseven on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:30AM (#50495489)
Looking really isn't necessary.

If you get into the regular habit of having the LLM look for issues with the code base it will find them: structural, bugs, design pattern issues, duplicate code, or same functionality not sharing a single path.

Honestly it feels like working with a real codebase. Tech debt always builds up, and yes the AI does it, too. It does notice if you ask to look.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by elvis10ten on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:02AM (#50496006)
I do this, but it’s a constant loop of liability.

When I wrote features by hand, I used to have like 2-5 bugs. Most of which were just human clumsiness.

When I started using AI and remained in the driving seat, most of the human clumsiness bugs went away.

Now, when I vibe, all I have are my verification loops and asking Opus5.5 to find and fix bugs.

Opus tells me it’s done. Only for me to start a new loop and it finds 10 more things or maybe I go in myself and it says “oh you are right”.

For me, this is not progress. I would rather spend an extra 1 or 2 hours a day in the driving seat building software that is correct and that is so simple that cost of changes is low.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by elvis10ten on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:08AM (#50496028)
Also, LLMs don’t typically know when they are climbing a local-maxima. They would add a shit ton of changes to improve the things that you measure, while other aspects suffer.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:27AM (#50496144)
> having the LLM look for issues with the code base it will find them:

It wrote them to begin with. Now you're handing of this discovery to literally the same LLMs that wrote this.

Oh, they will find some issues. Are you sure they will fix them and/or rewrite them without introducing more issues? How do you know if "looking is not necessary"?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by whatisthiseven on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:37AM (#50496555)
I know it isn't necessary because 6 months ago it became largely redundant for me to look: there wasn't enough for me to criticize.

I have automated the entirety of testing and Claude can validate it's own inputs. I then focus on marking requirements fulfilled, or bugs found. The bugs it does find are usually on the side of incomplete requirements. The few technical ones were due to a lack of testing. And I am not perfect, so I would have made all kinds of bugs myself.

If you keep to a mindset of, and build processes for, the management of software development rather than coding, results are better. No this isn't a magic prompt like "make no mistakes".

It is approaching the project with the mindset of knowing the limitations of the tools like one would a junior/mid engineer, and then mitigating. This is dependent on the codebase, product, and desired requirements for what processes to use and to what degree.

If you find yourself still needing to look, you have insuffiently automated the creation and validation of written software.

Its solved. Adapt and learn to use them effectively or get left behind; seems to be the unfortunate reality.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by skydhash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:42AM (#50497398)
A lot of statements with no evidence to back them. I won’t ask for a link. But did you measure the bugs (reported by customers) and the time taken to fix them, feature usage,… Or is it self patting in the back with LoC and PR counts?
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by whatisthiseven on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:19PM (#50498743)
Yes, an entire codebase written prior to AI existing has been made far better. More features that players report work (and I play it myself). Far more performance in a measurable way that is obvious to me and players. It can support larger maps, while running well in excess of 120fps when prior it couldn't get past 20fps. This was multiple performance issues that needed resolving. Not once did I look at the solutions that improved performance. I had Claude do byte and object level comparisons between versions to catch regression. I then played it myself to much joy.

When I release features, players report minor bugs, which I can fix in minutes by simply dumping their complaint into claude.

I worked on this codebase prior to LLMs and made slow progress, with many bugs. I did not know how to approach the performance problems, nor was I able to refactor the project to effectively have test and production environments reproducible. Claude did just fine.

It is 350k LoC, with over 138k as an Elixir app, 60k in tests/scripts, 65k Vue components, 45k JS, and more.

Coding is solved. Many people can't manage software engineering effectively. I don't know how much larger or how much more comparison is needed before this is accepted. Maybe it is "circular" reasoning like the dead comment says.

But it literally just works for me.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by zeroc8 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:40AM (#50505454)
It works for me too. And I am keeping things very simple. Tell it what to do next. Check result. Rinse and repeat until I'm happy with the outcome. I do check the code diffs in produces, but only to get a rudimentary idea what it did. The results speak for themselves.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:27PM (#50499441)
> Its solved. Adapt and learn to use them effectively or get left behind; seems to be the unfortunate reality.

Every time. Every single time. People who say they never look at code anymore always say the trite things about "management of software development", how they have no issues, and that if you have issues, it's the problem with your skills with a side of snide remarks about your intelligence.

And then you press them for details.

After a few rounds of more and more trite answers they either go away or it turns out that their "automated everything" and "processes" and "coding is solved" are:

- a bunch of "make no mistakes" aka untold numbers of random markdown files aka skills, "guidelines", "memories", "ADRs", "technical docs" etc. Which are routinely ignored by any and all models.

- a bunch of tools that can't or don't catch all the mistakes the models routinely make. E.g. there are very few tools that reliably detect code duplication (especially code duplication with subtle changes in behavior), or reliably detect bad data access patterns, or reliably detect suboptimal algorithms etc.

- an overreliance on tests. The very same tests that are written by the very same very models

---

As a related aside.

I have multiple tools from linters to semantic analysis running as routine checks, and still. Here are the responses by Claude for some of the things I caught it doing in just the past few days:

- "The [test data] generator can sometimes fail, and create duplicated data, so I increased the number of times it runs to 100" (instead of fixing it)

- "The tests check this in an indirect way. They send megabytes of data and watch the memory of the whole VM. Unrelated processes change that number. The direct check is the number of body bytes that the server read. Do you want me to rewrite these tests" (Claude wrote all these tests to begin with)

- "The previous research covered only a few CSS files. It did not cover the design system documents, the components, or the pages that already use them." (so much for "No this isn't a magic prompt like 'make no mistakes'" as it had an explicit requirement to use the design system)

- "The too_large_message/1 helper has three copies, two of them private, with no good reason for them..."

And that's just some I documented for myself.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by whatisthiseven on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:48PM (#50501269)
Read here for a summary of the codebase: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498743

I don't use memories, markdown files, guidelines, etc.

I design the software like I would as an principal engineer and dictate the high level requirements. Opus 5.5 really does just work. 10 months ago this wasn't quite true, it required more steering of the technical requirements.

I don't know why your results are different. I run a live multi-week long campaign game that streams updates over WSS from an Elixir app. I can literally see if Claude is doing as it claimed. It is trivial to verify when it gets it wrong.

I dunno what everyone else is using to get such poor results.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:06PM (#50501457)
> Read here for a summary of the codebase: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50498743

It doesn't have a summary of the codebase. Or at least a useful summary.

> I design the software like I would as an principal engineer and dictate the high level requirements

Let me quote myself:

--- start quote ---

And then you press them for details.

After a few rounds of more and more trite answers...

--- end quote ---

This is now your third reply with trite answers (two to me and one to a sibling comment).

> I don't know why your results are different.

Because I actually look at code it produces.

> It is trivial to verify when it gets it wrong.

Yes. Yes it is.

E.g. in my codebase it is trivial to verify that it does 15 reads from the database on a page when just 2 or 3 would be enough. How do I know it? I check the logs, or see it in the REPL (I also use Elixir).

It's also trivial to see when it does shit like "oh I didn't read the design system". Because I actually see what it's doing.

It's trivial to see a bunch of other issues it routinely produces because tools like these exist: https://github.com/elixir-vibe/ex_dna and https://github.com/Cinderella-Man/credence (or even my own vibe-coded https://github.com/dmitriid/llamex and https://github.com/dmitriid/ex_css_analyzer)

> And if 350k LoC isn't enough for your use-case. Well, that wasn't quite achievable 12 months ago, but it was 8 months ago. In another year, I imagine if my codebase grew to 1M+ LoC, the latest models would still be keeping up.

Yeah yeah. "Keeping up". Where by "keeping up" you mean "I duplicated the code 15 times, and "I didn't read even half of what is needed to do this task".

It works for you because you give it only the most superficial tests. Wouldn't surprise me if you can cut all of that code in half and raise the fps 5-fold. But for that you actually have to look at the code.

----

BTW lol at the tests. Literally 10 minutes ago it produced this amazing test: https://x.com/dmitriid/status/2121723533567115357

I mean. Nothing wrong with it is there? The code works. I can see it work in my browser. What other checks do I need lol.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by whatisthiseven on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:27PM (#50502615)
> This is now your third reply with trite answers

Have a fourth, then.

I hope you continue to ship for use-cases your users care about in your work, and continue to find satisfaction in software engineering.

I am.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:31AM (#50506123)
Yup. As trite as before.

All I can say is: there's a reason your software had multiple performance issues, couldn't support larger maps, and couldn't get past 20fps. It's the same reason why you're so impressed with the results and don't look at code anymore.

Adieu.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bigstrat2003 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:15AM (#50504454)
> I know it isn't necessary because 6 months ago it became largely redundant for me to look: there wasn't enough for me to criticize.

Every model, including $latest_model, makes mistakes and hallucinates things. If you aren't looking at the code, you are producing bad software, end of story.

> Its solved. Adapt and learn to use them effectively or get left behind; seems to be the unfortunate reality.

Ah, there's the FOMO push. It just isn't an AI bro post without false claims of "you're going to be left behind!".

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by shinycode on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:32AM (#50495506)
I’m shipping more code in a week than I ever did in a year. It’s impossible to read it all. But I agree that there is critical paths to analyze and decisions that are taken without our consent. I ask the agent to document every decision he makes without my consent and write it in the PR content when he’s done. Context, ADR, rules etc makes the agent quite good at following good practices but it’s a lot of work and reviews first to build and maintain the feedback loop. Good tests help also to avoid reading code. But once in a while it’s important to read critical paths to fix deviations.

What I’m most anxious about is that, because I don’t read code, if I don’t have access to an agent for any reason I’ll have a hard time fixing a critical bug because I don’t have a mental model anymore of how things work. And that’s not professional and I can’t sell that software.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by srdjanr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:52AM (#50495618)
How could you not have access to an agent that's good enough for an emergency fix? Even open source models should be good enough if OpenAI, Anthropic and Google models are all unavailable, and open source models have plenty of hosts.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jghn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:09AM (#50497156)
> ’m shipping more code in a week than I ever did in a year.

I think this is a growing problem. I pulled back. I'm much faster than I used to be. BUT, I also forcibly insert myself into the loop. I've thoroughly iterated on a design with the LLM before starting. I've personally looked at and often iterated on every line of code before merging. I regularly walk through the generated code base, both with and without LLM assistance, in order to ensure I have a solid mental picture of what's there.

This behavior has been informed by seeing things go to hell, both for myself and with other people, clients, open source projects, etc

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by cedarbyte482 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:59AM (#50504979)
You could consider a framework like zeroshot
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by chamomeal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:37AM (#50495869)
My main issue isn’t even the code quality. It’s that the more I vibe a codebase, the less ideas I have about how to improve it and extend it.

When you have a deep understanding of something, you just can’t help thinking about all the ways you could improve it. Maybe you realize it could be generalized, or that a different problem you’ve had could be solved with a similar technique. Sometimes you get oh “OH DUH” moment where you realize you were making the slightly wrong thing this whole time, and NOW you know EXACTLY what to make.

With LLMs I just get basically what I asked for, and then I’m done. Obviously this is sick and I love it.

But for a lot of my projects recently, I fall into this trap

- I have a problem, I think a program could help. But I want to know if there’s a viable approach before I invest a bunch of time by myself, so I boot up claude

- LLM writes the entire program, I don’t know what’s going on in there

- the program kinda solves the problem or it doesn’t. At this point I already have something that has vaguely confirmed or denied the viability of solving the problem, so I think “welp I’m not gonna spend a whole week of my life reading an LLMs output”, and that’s that

I rarely have cool insights about the problem after that. In the olden days, even if my approach didn’t work, I would come away with a new understanding of that problem, and all similar types of problems. “Oh that’s why people say cache invalidation is unsolved”. “Oh that’s why generics can’t infer xyz”

Don’t really get that when you vibecode. But the siren song of just having something that works is so sweet, and I can never ever resist it

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by elvis10ten on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:15AM (#50496062)
> the less ideas I have about how to improve it and extend it.

This! Especially this! is the real reason I started building my own commercial software again.

I’m betting that the details will still continue to matter.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by rererereferred on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:22AM (#50496471)
Sell it as if you were Ikea selling furniture, not a craftsman selling furniture.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by elvis10ten on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:25AM (#50496830)
Ahaha! At that point, I would rather just start making actual furniture! It wouldn’t have the same risks and I can live with myself.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by KellyCriterion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:25AM (#50496482)
>I implore you to look at it!

Absolutely true! Some month ago I discovered huge memleaks by coincidence because Opus nailed tons of LINQ calls together and duplicated data as hell.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ngc248 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:34AM (#50495213)
Coding with LLMs is like what they were telling about self-driving cars, you need to keep your hands on the steering wheel always ready to take over. On one of our recent projects, we decided to allow the AI to do everything, we had setup an AI constitution, a good set of instructions etc. The code would start out good, but would veer towards a bug ridden ending, this happened 3 times. also the LLM kept saying it updated, when it hadnt etc so many issues. the best way to use these is you define the structure and skeleton yourself and ask it fill in the code. even then the code written is too complex and readability is low.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bigstrat2003 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:21AM (#50504485)
> Coding with LLMs is like what they were telling about self-driving cars, you need to keep your hands on the steering wheel always ready to take over.

It is. And the trouble is, once you do that, the speed gains evaporate. It takes just as long to carefully review the LLM's code as it would've to write it yourself, because the typing wasn't what took time, but the understanding of the problem. The only way to get productivity gains from an LLM is to vibe code, at which point the quality of your software craters.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by evolve2k on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:02AM (#50495344)
Sounds like Technical Debt is being ignored "Because AI".

"Technical debt is a qualitative description of the cost to maintain a system that is attributable to choosing an expedient solution for its development.

While an expedited solution can accelerate development in the short term, the resulting low quality may increase future costs if left unresolved."

source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technical_debt

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by XorNot on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:38AM (#50495880)
Except we can at this point reasonably expect future AIs to be better at solving the technical debt then people.

AI is right now buying down huge amounts of technical debt (see the flurry of CVEs). But we're already onto the self-improvement treadmill: future more capable systems will be better at solving any issues introduced today - it's literally not worth the time worrying about now (this is the same reason you don't get a cancer prognosis over a longer then 10 year time frame - the expectation is future treatments will be better).

The technical debt my code written in Opus 5.5 might have is already going to be handled by Fable 5.2, for example. It's going to be better and faster then I am. But also: if the rate of technical debt production from AI is even slightly lower, then it gets more and more manageable in a future where nothing changes but the increasing volume of AI compute is concentrated on less and less of it.

I mean certainly it would be nice if I could implement a feature without Claude finding a security bug and tripping cyber protections every couple of hours.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:25AM (#50496131)
> Except we can at this point reasonably expect future AIs to be better at solving the technical debt then people.

No, we can't. We can believe this will be the case

> The technical debt my code written in Opus 5.5 might have is already going to be handled by Fable 5.2, for example.

"Let's generate more and mire garbage in hopes that there will be some magical tech that solves the issues" is not that good of a strategy.

E.g. even for the amazing magical benchmark-shattering Fable 5.5 Anthropic's guidance is still the same: your CLAUDE.md should bot exceed 200 lines and claude only reads 200 lines of memory index because otherwise it quickly loses adherence.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by XorNot on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:46AM (#50496238)
Just a year or two ago people were confidently predicting the end of transformer usefulness due to whatever the limits of the time were.

Like all problems, we'll solve them when we get there but its not like anyone has an abundance of useful alternative advice: I'm getting useful software out now, whether I have to fix it later has the same problem it has always had - when we need to, we'll do it.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by troupo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:05AM (#50496367)
> Like all problems, we'll solve them when we get there

It's already here

> its not like anyone has an abundance of useful alternative advice

Yes, the advice is the same: look at the code produced and understand it.

> whether I have to fix it later has the same problem it has always had - when we need to, we'll do it.

Yet you don't. You're quite literally saying "who cares some future model will solve this for me".

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by HowTheStoryEnds on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:41AM (#50496212)
But will you be able to afford the later models that absolve you of the encrued debt? That is not a given.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by XorNot on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:06AM (#50497136)
Sure: we'll deal with it when it happens, if it happens.

But the model I buy today is cheaper in terms of capability then the one I could've bought a year ago.

But software can be "done". There isn't an endlessly acruing technical debt, the product can be finished.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by TobiasJacob on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:42AM (#50495554)
Sometimes I'm wondering if I am actually more productive or just building a lot of stuff nobody needs at home.

Yes my frontend is nicer. I do not hang myself up debugging a small issue for hours. I also don't have to search questions online, and get even complicated answers fairly quick.

But I'm not sure if I ended up being so much productive, or I'm just building a lot of open source stuff nobody needs. Last year i would have solved a narrower problem and relied on others to contribute the rest.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by thephyber on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:56AM (#50495641)
> There’s no hope for enterprise software. It will always be terrible.

Why hope for a resurgence of indie software without also a revolution in enterprise?

If there ever was a time for either entrenched players to improve their UI/UX (using LLMs) or for rival upstarts to build lots of feature parity, now seems like it would be the time.

Perhaps if Agents are given some autonomy to buy enterprise software trials it would be easier to break the stranglehold of the biggest vendors.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jmathai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:08PM (#50500835)
I’m just not that interested in enterprise software. I had to use Concur this week and it was horrendous. The only reason I use it is because I have to. And I get paid for the hours I waste on it. My employer has deemed that to be a good use of their money. That’s fine with me.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by TheCapeGreek on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:19AM (#50495760)
Enterprise software will remain terrible for all the usual enterprise reasons, 100%.

Where I'm finding AI exceptionally useful is now being able to address tech debt and developer experience for my team WITHOUT having to argue for spots in the backlog to do it.

So, if nothing else, it sucks a lot less to work on enterprise software if you can let a team lead or principal engineer loose from the PM to just fix things.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ajasmin on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:36AM (#50495868)
It’s not clear to me how AI fix the technical dept problem. I’m no stranger to nonsense like review comments being ignored or technical task not making it on the agile board.

But, how is AI fixing this? Unless the perverse answer is: no one’s reviewing code anymore so I can just merge my technical fix.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by dale_glass on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:45AM (#50496231)
You can use AI not only to write code from scratch.

So "Where does this function get called from", "What does this function do?", "Rewrite this function as-is with better variable names", "Make a document outlining the structure of this project", or "Review this PR and watch out for any places that may be lacking the fix" are all reasonable things to ask of an AI.

When you're in a big project and aren't sure where this is supposed to go or how things get A from B, AI can be extremely helpful.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by KellyCriterion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:23AM (#50496474)
So you are uploading all the source from your "big project" into OpenAnthroogle's solutions?

In which sector is your company active where this is allowed? Or do you run on your own infra?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by dale_glass on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:30AM (#50496507)
In a sector where the source code ends up in a public github repo anyway.

Yes, I imagine this is trickier in more sensitive applications, but I'm sure this isn't a new concern. AWS has Private Cloud, surely you can get a LLM with whatever assurances a more sensitive project needs at this point. But in my current environment that's not really a concern, so I've not personally looked into it.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by curt15 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:30AM (#50496879)
> So "Where does this function get called from", "What does this function do?", "Rewrite this function as-is with better variable names", "Make a document outlining the structure of this project", or "Review this PR and watch out for any places that may be lacking the fix" are all reasonable things to ask of an AI.

Nit: not all of those questions require statistical language models. IDEs like IntelliJ have been adept at syntactical queries and refactors for many years using purely deterministic data structures and algorithms.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by dale_glass on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:06AM (#50497135)
Certainly! There's more than one way to do some things. Of course things like renaming are all well supported by pre-AI tech. But you do run into situations where LLMs are very helpful.

Like if you have some code that's been intentionally obfuscated, or made by somebody who names everything "a", "b" and "c", a LLM is likely to be of at least some help.

And yeah, you can do things like finding all the places where func() is called, but a LLM can also be helpful in saying where something needs to be done, which is a much fuzzier task.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by skydhash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:53AM (#50497503)
> LLM can also be helpful in saying where something needs to be done

Usually, If you don’t know that, you shouldn’t modify the system either. Just because you know how to unscrew a bold, you shouldn’t go about removing the head cover of an engine. Locating the area of interest takes a lot less time than actually understanding how it integrate, the guarantees provided by other systems and the guarantees that it offers.

Modularity in software architecture. By reducing the links between parts of the code, it’s easier for someone else to navigate the system and answer these questions. But it does require careful design and caring about the code.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by dale_glass on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:39AM (#50497875)
Everyone's got to start somewhere. Ideally you'd want to start from documentation and a mentor explaining everything, but sometimes you don't get that. The previous dev is long gone, the docs are clearly insufficient, or it's a dead open source project you're resurrecting. Got to make do and fumble around until you get stuff working.

In my own projects I'm also quite capable of forgetting stuff. Double checking with a LLM whether I forgot about one of the more obscure corners doesn't hurt.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by matsemann on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:32AM (#50495847)
> Im building software that would not have existed before LLMs and coding agents arrived.

That can be a sign that what you're now building is perhaps not worth building? At least my experience from dayjob, we're building more and faster, but it's either things we really shouldn't do (stuck in backlog forever for a reason), or things that just complicate the main product when features get added willy nilly.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by wongarsu on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:21AM (#50496107)
https://xkcd.com/1205/ applies, but five minutes of my time now goes a lot further than it went back when that comic came out. There are now a lot more cases where I can spend 5 minutes to shave a couple seconds (often minutes!) off a monthly task, or half an hour to make a task I only have to do today faster and less tedious. Changing the time invested into building a tool by an order of magnitude makes more than an order of magnitude of change in the number of tools that are suddenly worth the effort to build

Of course this calculus drastically changes when maintainability and other stakeholders come into the picture. There vision an architecture are more important than adding features. Architecture isn't too hard to solve, but sadly good product owners have always been hard to find

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by le-mark on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:34AM (#50495859)
> I hope there is a resurgence of indie software like existed in the early 2000s.

I have the opposite view. Why would anyone build and sell software now when anyone can one shot anything? Genuinely interested in people’s thoughts.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by Kurtz79 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:01AM (#50496341)
I have been struggling with the same thought for months.

The value added by commercial software will have to be much higher than what it is now, or most companies will have little reason not to code their own, fully customized to their own needs.

But it is really hard to imagine what the future of software will be, even in 2/3 years time. We live in wild times.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by mejutoco on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:08AM (#50496377)
Why would anyone buy bread when anyone can make bread?
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by KellyCriterion on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:15AM (#50496434)
Because as a company you want to concentrate on your core business process and not want to become a software company:

A company usually wants support / integratoin / maintenance / updates / new features etc. - for sure there will be some companies building 100% on their own, and yes I guess this number will increase but I do not see any mid-level company or above replacing Oracle or Salesforce or Microsoft with their homegrown solution.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by Kiln6125 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:46AM (#50496604)
Have you truly one shot something you use day to day? I find that getting to the "long tail" can happen exceptionally fast these days, but I am continuously tinkering and honing (with positive results mind you) at projects that are MVP level. MVP is close to one-shot, but of course I don't think many of us tend to use "minimum" products day to day. Now the focus shifts to maintaining and building out upon that foundation.

Which is to say, the form of your statement I'd agree with is: if anyone can make an MVP in a few days, what use is an MVP?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jmathai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:00AM (#50497091)
I have. Others use it every day as well. I wrote this at 45 one shot prompts but it’s now at over a hundred.

A church is going to pilot it to 450 people. Some people actually do find it useful.

https://jaisenmathai.com/articles/sojourn-for-ios-was-45-one...

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by hahn-kev on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:07PM (#50503592)
That's... Not what one shot means. If you break it down like that then anything can be one shot and then it's meaningless
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ModernMech on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:29AM (#50496871)
The answer for a lot of things is, probably that's not something you can make money on by selling anymore. But the fact AI has made things easier for most people doesn't mean the barrier to entry has been lowered to 0 for everyone. My mom could probably use AI to write a compiler but first she'd have to even understand what a compiler is.

And the fact that some apps can be made in one prompt doesn't mean every app can. I've been working on a fully AI generated project for 8 months, it's taken billions of tokens and continuous prompting. The amount of human time spent on this project is just as much as I'd spend before AI, just now the project is much larger in scope. So even if some people have the ability, they still might not want to spend their precious human time on it.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jmathai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:03AM (#50497109)
For me, writing code was always just a means to building something. I enjoyed the intellectual challenge of coding but it wasn’t why I did it.

I agree that the ease at which it can be created feels a little…how do you say it…demoralizing.

In the long run, I don’t think this will be a net positive. But in the scope of this conversation about absolute productivity and code quality I seem to disagree with a lot of HN.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by quantum_state on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:20AM (#50497222)
If technical debt is assessed and revealed as part of financial audit, it would create economic pressure for enterprises to take technical debt seriously. Given software is a key component of almost all enterprises, GAAP should be enhanced to include technical debt as a line item in the balance sheet.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ucyo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:31AM (#50494876)
Do you have recommendations for this? Ideally books
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by filipn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:14AM (#50495119)
If people knew what is worthwhile building, they wouldn't write a book about it. It's like writing a book on how to make money in the stock market.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by phtrivier on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:38AM (#50495878)
Arguably, a lot of books are written about that, by two different kind of people who did made money on the market : those that made a lucky bet, beat the market, and are trying to explain how to become a young billionaire yourself (I don't have exemple in mind, because those are not worth much any way - see below); and those that just invested cautiously enough to _follow_ the market, not make anything dumb, and make enough money to be an old millionaire yourself (Charlie Munger, Mr Money mustache, etc...)

The former are fun but irreproducible ; the latter are boring (index funds, sobriety, compound interest, don't be stupid, and some luck to avoid the bad timing of the crashes) unless the author adds some snark (again, Munger)

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jodrellblank on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:49AM (#50495932)
The latter are the former just on a longer timescale. You say "some luck to avoid bad timing" but ask yourself how many people in the 1950s - 2020s were doing what Buffet and Munger were doing, namely reading a lot of company balance sheets and announcements, trying to stick to decent and well-run companies with good business models, buying when cheap opportunities present, and waiting a lot.

I expect it will be more than 2 people trying that, and almost all of them didn't become multi-billionaires.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by phtrivier on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:48AM (#50496254)
What I meant is that, if you you don't need to withdraw a lot from your savings exactly at the time of a crash, than "just following the market" works. And, crashes happen regularly, but scarcely enough that you may very well retire in between them.

So it's the difference between "depending on things being average" and "depending on things being exceptional".

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by neomantra on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:04AM (#50495350)
It is quite dated (1994), but just this week I was feeling very thankful to the authors of Taligent's Guide to Designing Programs [1], a book I read and lived. It comes from an era when software architect and programmer were different jobs (things seemed to change soon after?), which parallels modern LLM use. The C++ version there is quite old, but the concepts are timeless.

[1] https://root.cern.ch/TaligentDocs/TaligentOnline/DocumentRoo...

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by fulafel on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:37AM (#50495873)
For those unfamiliar, Taligent was (among other things) a very well funded C++ app platform that never shipped, and its failures have been much analysed.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by neomantra on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:29AM (#50496503)
Yeah, it was weird that I was reading so much about designing software in a system I could never touch. It might be part of why OSS and access to computing is important to me; we had to buy our C++ compilers then.

It was my first years of being a "software engineer", versus the solo hacker kid who liked making art of over phone lines. So I devoured books which would teach me how to make software with other people and for other people.

Books like the "BeOS Filesystem book" (Practice File System Design) was another classic from the era [1]. It was like today's LLM white papers, learning how a company did something unique, except companies seldom published them because it was a time of IP hoarding.

Unfortunately the books that eventually became the most practical were those by Sutters and Meyers; compendiums on the warts and jewels of C++ that you needed to know to be good at programming in it. Such nitty gritty, much of which was eventually fixed by language design. I really don't miss having to know all that, freeing my mind to consider architecture, design, and delivery.

[1] https://www.nobius.org/dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bob1029 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:39AM (#50495884)
[delayed]
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by interstice on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:47AM (#50495923)
This assumes the customer has a clear vision and doesn't need help with not creating logical paradoxes within their own business model.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by newsclues on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:55AM (#50495969)
I want a meal assembled by a professional chef, not a machine that chops food at my dumbass requests.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by flohofwoe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:58AM (#50495981)
The old gamedev wisdom is: ask your players what feels wrong, but not what the solution should be.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by mpweiher on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:37AM (#50496190)
"Listen to your customers, but ignore what they say"
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by Myrmornis on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:03AM (#50496011)
A sample size of 1 real customer is worse than a sample of N >> 1 customers imagined by someone who knows the field.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by prmph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:04AM (#50496357)
[delayed]
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by christophilus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:45AM (#50496598)
No it doesn’t. Frequent interaction with customers is how you arrive at good ideas and insights that the customers themselves never would have had.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jdee on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:53AM (#50496639)
Can I interest you in a faster horse?
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by aerhardt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:32AM (#50497302)
If you're referring to the famous Henry Ford quote ("If I had asked people what they wanted, they would've said faster horses") I'll first note the obvious: Ford didn't invent the car.

Second, I'll concede anyway that revolutionary innovation happens primarily top-down. Common folk don't know anything about the state of combustion engines or transformer architectures, or how those can be composed into new categories of product.

Third, odds are if you're building software, you're doing nothing of that sort, but rather dealing with infinitely more modest innovation. You would be, in fact, improving a horse, if that were at all possible.

Fourth, when improving the proverbial horse, you'd better very well have an outstanding sensitivity to the finer problems that customers face. Whether you develop that sensitivity by "asking" or "feeling" is another question. But asking may not be a bad idea at all.

Fifth, I'll close with an anecdote. The worst seed-stage software startup tire-fire I've seen in the last year was led by a CEO that published the Henry Ford quote, verbatim. I'll generalize by saying that I've seen pretty much everyone around me with "the don't ask, envision" attitude fail, while the people who ask or are otherwise exceptionally attuned to the customer problem do much better on average.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by skydhash on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:32AM (#50497305)
I believe the core drive of the automobile was to have a machine-powered carriage. No one wanted faster horses, and it would require taking care of the horses.

The quote is a great example of imagining user needs instead of just asking them.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by citizenkeen on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:40AM (#50498387)
Faster horse, etc.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bitwize on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:45AM (#50496600)
Exactly how "The Homer" was developed.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by xnx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:03PM (#50499225)
> AI has absolutely nothing to do with any of this

You don't think that AI can (or soon will) be able to talk to the customer and discover what they want?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bigstrat2003 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:10AM (#50504424)
LLMs can't even write code decently. The idea that they can do requirements discovery and design is laughable.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by glimshe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:03AM (#50496010)
I remember that back in the 80s, when I was still deciding what I wanted to do when I grew up, there was a distinction between a "programmer" and a "systems analyst".

The systems analyst analyzed the problem that needed to be solved and designed a solution involving a computer, including system modules, inputs, outputs, etc.

The programmer, supposedly a lower paid profession, transformed that into Computer code. I remember someone telling me that wasn't the best choice.

I think this distinction still survives in government labor statistics.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by prmph on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:59AM (#50496331)
Then we have/had "Software Engineer", then "software Architect", etc.

Words are just words. In tech especially, it seems anyone can call themselves whatever they want.

Someone who chooses to call themselves "programmer" can be more engineering-minded and see the big picture better than someone that calls themselves an engineer.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ModernMech on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:19AM (#50496452)
It's not about what people call themselves, it appears there are actually distinct roles here, and AI is automating only one of them (for now).
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by retwakm4 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:23AM (#50496823)
I prefer to call myself a programmer because I don't think we (as a class) consistently perform a lot of the types of duties (both ethical ones and just basic job performance ones) that would be required of a lot of engineering disciplines.

I also started out in systems programming and we still call ourselves programmers there, when there is a lot of systems "engineering" (aka trying not to blow up the system with your code running in supervisor state) going on.

So I'll keep to calling myself programmer amongst my non software engineering friends. It just seems more humble.

That being said, writing the code has like others have pointed out, never been the largest part of the job in my experience.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bitwize on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:00AM (#50497088)
Programmers ysed to laugh at "software architects" for producing lots of documentation and no code.

Who's laughing now? Who still has a job now?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bigstrat2003 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:11AM (#50504435)
Programmers are still doing just fine at any organization with a brain in the leadership seat. LLMs write much worse code than humans, and you absolutely cannot just let them run amok. This kills the product quality, and loses customers.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bitwize on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:02AM (#50507955)
> LLMs write much worse code than humans

As of September, this is objectively false. When "programming in the small", frontier LLMs write better code than 80%-90% of human devs and are much more thorough about checking their work than most human devs. They are also starting to exhibit signs of good judgement in design and architecture, not just implementation, which is why you need a software architect in order to steer things, but hands-on-keyboard programmers? Yeah, you need far fewer of those now.

When "programming in the large", yeah, they're not there yet. But that's coming.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by microtonal on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:39AM (#50496573)
The systems analyst analyzed the problem that needed to be solved and designed a solution involving a computer, including system modules, inputs, outputs, etc.

I think both definitions are still too narrow for what I do daily. I fully agree that we still need humans to decide what to build, how it should all fit together, etc.

But both definitions do not really take into account the huge social dimension of being a good (computer) engineer in a company. You have to translate requests from a wild variety of users into what this means for a system. You have to recognize and explain that what they need is not always what they think they need. You have to be able to say "no" to things. All these things are very hard for an LLM (reading humans, not literally following requests).

Then there are social aspects like building consensus within a project, building a user base of many people that are initially skeptical, using existing relations with people and other companies to slowly adopt what you are building, etc.

Programming used to be a large chunk of the work. I thoroughly enjoyed this aspect of the work when I was younger, but at some point I started enjoying system design and everything around it more. So in that sense, programming with LLMs is much nicer (though I still review every single line of code and often have to go through a couple of iterations because even Opus 5.5 often doesn't get it 'right' in the first take). But the remaining part of the work is extremely hard for an LLM to replace.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by parasti on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:13AM (#50497187)
> You have to be able to say "no" to things.

How do you justify saying "no" when there is a magic machine invented 3 years ago that'll do it? Your gut says it's a maintenance nightmare, your LLM says it's already done implementing it.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by xorcist on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:55AM (#50496650)
We might be the same generation, I recognize the two roles. What I also remember is just empirically how much better the "programmers" were at doing the "system analysts" job. Way, way better. Then we stopped educating system analysts and now the job title is not heard of anymore.

I regularly meet (recently examined) people who are trained "software architects". Common among them is that they are often delay projects championing their pet idea, sometimes bringing negative value to the project. The best programmers are just so much better software architects also. So I expect history to repeat at this point.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by EarthBlues on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:59AM (#50497083)
Programmers are better architects because their decisions are continually informed by experience from the "sharp end" of the system. LLMs don't really have experiences, I dont think its the same. Our profession will likely shake out a lot of people in the coming years. What will be left may not be a classic "systems analyst" or "architect" role. I think the people who stay in this field will have to move both up and down the abstraction stack simultaneously -- our job will become a lot more "real", physical, relational, risk-oriented. I dont think there's good reason to believe LLMs can supply the need for prudence in the fields where software is deployed.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ctkhn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:36AM (#50497350)
You do need to stay in touch with the sharp end to stay sharp yourself. I've had a lot of managers and directors in my career who as they have moved up in companies, longer write any code, and seem to not really get how our systems work even though they are in charge. I had a few managers in the past who were "non technical" and had never written code in their life, and they were the absolute worst of the bunch. There is a little bit of truth to the otherwise very corny comic with the guy with an enormous head saying "at the library" when asked where he works out. https://i.pinimg.com/736x/3c/69/3a/3c693a6f9e3f6949192ce613e...
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by saltcured on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:09PM (#50498642)
In my opinion, a lot of that "no longer getting it" is because of the social/fashion trends that continually disrupt programming.

You don't forget CS concepts so easily, but all the syntactic tricks of new language variants and working set vocabulary of APIs, data formats, and frameworks keeps churning away from whatever you last had contacted in a real, hands-on way.

It is fascinating, wondering where this is going as programmers turn into their own middle managers on top of agents. Particularly, the school who claim that you don't really need to understand all the code and instead treat it like a black-box experiment. If this fad takes over the main stage, then everyone becomes one of those less technical managers.

But, in this new scenario, there is no human in the loop to inject judgement calls and "manage up" anymore. There is no programmer culture except the models and agents, which don't really have the same social connections to drive a programming culture. What will happen? A culture per agent product? Per enterprise client of the agent vendor? Per agent operator? Per codebase?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ohyes on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:18AM (#50506047)
I don’t think we get new things. Right now they’re great at popular languages and frameworks. If those change? There’s not enough training data. It could generate the data and train itself but where’s the incentive. It certainly can’t learn a new language right away the way even a junior programmer can. It will constantly hallucinate and not improve.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by torginus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:41AM (#50497384)
Weird how these fads just disappear overnight, 1984 style.

About half a year ago I noticed there were no people called 'Agile something' at our org, so I asked about it. They looked at me like I was a space alien. I remember, it was like 3 years ago that management bet the house on 'Agile transformation' talking about how Agile practices are the bread and butter of a good organization.

Now they're talking about AI the same way.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ctkhn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:52AM (#50497495)
To be fair there is something to the idea of moving to agile from waterfall practices, the same way going on any diet in general makes you think about what you're eating and helps you lose weight. Unfortunately it's usually just a way for the same management (who have fostered bad practices) to hire a new set of consultants and look like they're doing something without actually fixing anything.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by torginus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:02PM (#50501948)
Yes, that something is about moving from a management class composed mostly of senior engineers to Agile cultists whose core tenet is that they do not know anything about engineering, and do not wish to, because as long as the principles of Agile are followed correctly, it doesn't matter if your company makes software or matresses.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ahartmetz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:55AM (#50498510)
It's fun to remind people of past hypes and how they disappeared. Some don't seem to get the connection to the current thing. (Note, I'm not saying AI is nothing.)
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by somesortofthing on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:17PM (#50499891)
"Don't try to completely plan out huge software projects and commit to rigid delivery timelines in advance," "Split work into manageable tasks", "Run daily meetings to keep managers(and sometimes coworkers) in the decision loop and surface blockers", etc. are iron laws everyone instinctively recognizes are there for a reason. The explicit framework fell away because its principles became ubiquitous - nobody needs to hire Agile™ consultants to tell their SWEs and managers to do things the way they've been doing them for their whole career.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ElevenLathe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:03PM (#50501428)
You say this like its universal, but my ostensibly Agile org is currently planning the work we will be delivering Q1 of 2028 because that is how long our [proposed work] -> [approved work] -> [finished work] pipeline runs.

The memo has NOT gotten around, though AI now makes it easier to make all the various slide decks and schedule all the 50+ person meetings that power this process.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by fcarraldo on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:09PM (#50513914)
Sounds like Scaled Agile Framework aka SAFe or something similar? A total consulting scam sold to clueless execs (I worked for some, these processes are a nightmare)
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by derefr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:47AM (#50498446)
> Common among them is that they are often delay projects championing their pet idea, sometimes bringing negative value to the project.

Negative value to the project, perhaps; but if these "software architects" are kept around despite several rounds of this, it may be because they're providing positive value to the company, in terms of:

- being able to provide the executive team corroborating evidence to show to investors to convince them that they're acting strategically in the market; or

- where the existence of the project, no matter how failed, serves as collateral to get breathless puff-piece articles written about the company in places where dumb CTOs/CIOs who make IT buying decisions will read them (and not necessarily buy the product that came out of that project — hopefully not! — but remember the company itself the next time they're comparing vendors for something else.)

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by locknitpicker on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:01AM (#50496694)
> The systems analyst analyzed the problem that needed to be solved and designed a solution involving a computer, including system modules, inputs, outputs, etc.

This is a holdout from the time when the whole software development field was still stuck with the idea that waterfall/big design up front was an adequate way of doing things.

The belief was that, like any engineering field, systems would first be designed in detail before anyone could even open an IDE.

This approach was quickly proven to be wrong, expensive, and fruitless. Agile started to emerge as an effective approach to the problem of developing and maintaining software systems. The uselessness of the system analyst role, when contrasted with the fact that mere programmers could easily implement features without guidance from an enlightened individual far removed from the problem domain, was readily noted.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bitwize on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:15AM (#50496780)
The software methodology of the future will look a lot like Milt Bryce's PRIDE.

Milt realized as early as the 1970s, if not long before, that programmers had way too much power in an organization because most organizations adopted a "tool-oriented approach" to computer technology: here's a tool, how do we make use of it? They let the programmers run wild, and the result was software that was a buggy mess. What's needed is a management-oriented approach in which the management of the company calls the shots on what's needed for the company to function.

In PRIDE, the systems analyst is centered. This is explicitly a business role, not a technical role, and their job is to understand the business in such a way that the information systems (not programs, nor apps) that drive the business can be described in diagrams and text. Only once the requirements, definitions of terms, and data definitions have been established and standardized can the implementation phase begin. Bryce estimated that if you're not spending 65% of the effort in systems analysis and only 15% of the effort in programming, you're doing it wrong.

This is how grown-ups did information systems for decades. And then the internet happened, "hacker culture" happened, and the programmers were back in the driver's seat, producing things like "Agile".

Now we have AI, and to quote another commenter elsewhere in the thread, the programmers have had their tails cut off. That 15% number asymptotically approaches zero. But the systems analysis still needs to be done, and for the foreseeable future anyway, that needs a human touch.

Become a business person, not a "software engineer". They are the ones who will drive things forward in the agentic era.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by rpdillon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:18AM (#50497711)
Sounds a lot like waterfall.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bitwize on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:06AM (#50498117)
"Waterfall" is a pastiche of mature development practices used by Agilists to sell their programmer-centric snake oil. It's basically a phased development process kinda like PRIDE, but it explicitly doesn't incorporate feedback between the phases. PRIDE explicitly allows, for instance, new requirements discovered during the design phase to feed back into the analysis phase. But it is explicitly based on the idea that "A system is a product that can be designed and manufactured, just like any other product." And that the exact same management principles from the manufacturing and construction industries apply to information systems development. It is always a phased process that starts with requirements—identifying what the needs are, followed by design—producing a blueprint of how those needs will be met. This is how bridges, buildings, cars, and consumer goods are built; why not systems? Milt Bryce used to say, "If this country built bridges the way it builds systems, we'd be a nation run by ferryboats."

A counter to this is "requirements change quickly, therefore the system needs to change quickly too." But the actual case is: most organizations don't really know how to do systems analysis. So this results in one of two scenarios: either the organization wastes a lot of time and money in the analysis phase struggling to do what they cannot, or they punt on requirements analysis altogether and wait for requirements to surface at implementation time. This is called "Agile" today, but was described by Milt in 1983: "do a superficial feasibility study, do some quick and dirty systems design, spend a lot of time in programming, install prematurely so you can irritate the users sooner, and then keep working on it till you get something accomplished."

PRIDE is like a textbook on how to build a system, from requirements analysis through design, implementation, and maintenance. It was the first methodology for doing so, and it transformed information systems from arcane art into a proven, repeatable science. It should be the industry standard, but is now at risk of being forgotten, largely due to programmers holding the industry hostage.

AI is taking programmers out of the equation. PRIDE is relevant again.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by rpdillon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:33AM (#50498335)
Ah, so more like spiral development. I don't think we know what development methodologies will be relevant; things are changing too quickly. Your comments come off as a bit over-confident, given the level of uncertainty about this topic, but I appreciate you mentioning the methodology, since I suspect we'll draw on those lessons as we formulate the new best practices.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by teyc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:53PM (#50501860)
[delayed]
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by yasnu5 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:45AM (#50497931)
Sounds like I should just take a shotgun retirement
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jdlshore on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:05AM (#50498113)
The systems analyst (and related role, business analyst) disappeared because it didn’t work. The cycle times were too long and the resulting software too poor.

Maybe that will change with LLMs, but you’ve got the causality arrow backwards. Systems analysts didn’t disappear because of Agile; Agile exists because that way of working didn’t work.

Source: I was on the front lines of the first Agile wave starting in late 1999.

(And then what people actually adopted as “Agile” generally wasn’t what was created by the first wave of the Agile community, but that’s a whole ‘nother topic.)

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by derefr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:41AM (#50498392)
What you're describing is an "IT systems analyst", or rather, the term "systems analyst" as it evolved into a particular niche usage within IT.

But there's a more general kind of "systems analyst" that still survives (and is mostly what the BLS stats refer to): a person whose job is to map out the current business domain of a system (consisting of not just computers, but also people, infrastructure, institutions, etc.) and identify where it will need to be modified (but not necessarily how it will need to be modified) to make it capable of being put to use in a certain way for a given plan/mission.

Systems analysts in this sense tend to be one of the actual workhorse jobs inside "management consulting" firms and "think tanks." Governments, militaries, and large bureaucracies with many independent business units (think IBM) are their customers.

Systems analysis is sometimes done structurally over an entire organization: someone at a very high level has some new vision for an initiative, and hires these companies/think-tanks to help them determine how to "align" their organizational architecture with what a military might call a new "doctrine" or a company might call a new "paradigm." In these cases, the systems analyst performs the first step of that alignment: understanding "the system as it is today", and identifying what parts of it are already aligned vs. which parts will need to change. Their output is a report to the person driving the process.

But structural analysis is more often applied to specific strategic/business units, as the result of that strategic/business unit being chosen to execute a given strategic mission, as an enablement process to get that unit into the specific shape it needs to be in to execute that mission. In this case, there is likely an assigned "mission {planner, architect}" (who may also become the mission's director; or who may hire for such a director role and then depart to go plan the next mission.) The systems analyst works for/with the mission planner as their "eyes and ears", interacting with the business unit to gather information for the planner to use.

In both the structural and strategic cases, there are usually also one or more systems engineers who determine the "how" for implementation of these changes. (A mission planner is usually a very senior systems engineer themselves.)

However, unlike the systems analyst, who is considered more trustworthy to central leadership when they exist outside of the system they're analyzing (and so mostly work for external firms like think-tanks rather than for the orgs themselves), there's much less of a motivation to separate out systems engineering in that manner. So systems engineers (including mission planners!) tend to be regular [if high-paid] career employees of the central organization. These folks are frequently "general staff" in a military (with no real analogous term, AFAIK, for the equivalent people within a conglomerate's parent company.)

Due to their value coming in part from existing in separate firms that can negotiate on their behalf, systems analysts in this sense are well-paid indeed! But also worked hard, bounced around, and signing NDAs constantly. And possibly a bit bitter, in that they often see how things are broken with no chance to be part of the fix.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by dante54 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:09AM (#50504727)
You just described my consulting gigs. I however specialize in data, so its a bit easier to get proofs. However, getting business requirements is a pain, conversely I almost entirely handle implementation albeit with some supervision from the aforementioned no to so technical managers.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by rangestransform on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:01PM (#50502868)
Ahh the infamous “computer systems analyst” TN (NAFTA work permit) category that nobody really understands what the hell it’s supposed to be

This is not legal advice but allegedly lawyers were instructing CSA category TN applicants to never ever mention that they are “coding” or “programming”

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ChrisMarshallNY on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:20AM (#50496101)
So far, that's been my experience. My work still needs my architectural guidance, but I can rely on the LLM to do a decent (not exceptional) job on the details, as long as I am willing to break the tasks down to a small enough level.

I believe that LLMs will, eventually, reach a level where they can provide decent architecture, but I suspect that will suffer the same issues affecting code generation. It will be "decent," but not "awesome." I think exceptional people will still be able to beat LLMs at architectural design.

The issue is that the definition of "exceptional," means that it doesn't happen very often, and most people manage to convince themselves that they are the exception.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by moezd on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:23AM (#50496120)
Just because you have a CNC machine, you shouldn't run it 24/7 cutting and drilling holes into wood, that is waste.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by analog31 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:57AM (#50497069)
The waste is letting the machine sit idle and paying interest on it. We now have the equivalent of Uber for CNC, with services such as Xometry. You send in your drawings, and the supplier farms them out to any shop that has idle capacity. This is convenient for the customer if we don't know precisely which shop has the right machine for the job (e.g., laser cutting, milling, 3d-printing, etc).

I don't know if this is a perfectly fair of their business model, but it has that feel in terms of dealing with them.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by moezd on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:31AM (#50497297)
If you have customers who know exactly what to build, then by all means, run it 25 hours per day if you can. But this is rarely the case for the majority of the people. In the end, you just end up with too many offcuts.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by analog31 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:10AM (#50498149)
Indeed and it also occurred to me that metal and wood don't mix in a machine shop because of the different needs for lubrication and cleaning.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by krainboltgreene on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:15AM (#50497684)
That's really funny to say because being able to do that is exactly why the industrialization of society became a revolutionary force.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by yasnu5 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:46AM (#50497938)
But if we aren't running it 24/7, we'll lose out against the shops that are!
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by amelius on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:39AM (#50498378)
Haha, CNC shops are actually optimizing so that they can run their machines all the time.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by qalmakka on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:30AM (#50496157)
This. The manpower was rarely the bottleneck. Good ideas were and still are
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by boringg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:10AM (#50496401)
And execution of those good ideas
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by kylecazar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:32AM (#50496521)
Personalities in tech/VC been saying the opposite for years. That ideas are cheap and execution is everything.

Now that execution is more of a commodity, everyone seems to be saying execution is cheap and ideas are everything.

I don't disagree with you. I'm just noting an observed 180.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by master_crab on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:44AM (#50496593)
I’ve never been one to trust the VC crowd without knowing where their money lay.

There were usually three or four startups chasing the same business case pre-AI.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by planb on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:57AM (#50496671)
No. Execution isn’t just writing the code. It’s caring about the details.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by kylecazar on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:42AM (#50496965)
That's fair. Execution is more than getting the code written, it includes all of the many decisions you make (big and small) along the way
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by qalmakka on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:23AM (#50496825)
> That ideas are cheap and execution is everything.

Derivative ideas? Like "let's make a $thing with $variant"? Yes those are cheap, and AI made them pointless to pursue because most people can now whip up a hacked up variant of $thing with GPT and be happy with it, until they realise that it didn't add that much value to begin with.

But good, truly good ideas? Those that turn everything around? Those are cheap in the sense that your brain doesn't consume that much energy having them, but they are rare.

LLMs kind of confirmed we're indeed constrained by ideas: the homepage of HN isn't full of things like "we reimplemented X in Y" because we were full of revolutionary ideas to begin with. IMHO LLMs have further hampered the spread of truly great ideas - because nowadays if you have a truly great idea you have a fork:

- your idea can be quickly implemented by an LLM. You do it, and then everybody simply copies it using their LLM. - your idea requires time, iterations, ... so the LLM speeds up delivering it, but only a bit. We're still on a path similar than before - even before you could just hire more people and try to deliver stuff faster, as long as you had all already clearly planned beforehand.

So yes LLM are a big boon to productivity, but IMHO cast a long shadow of "why would I do it at all" on things. In the before times, I'd spend my day coding a dumb library for fun, just to brag about it a bit on Github and HN. But given that nowadays LLMs have reduced the value of code to ~0, the one thing that still has value is the idea behind. Which now people have less incentive to put out in the first place.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by aerhardt on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:47AM (#50497451)
I'm not going to get into the debate of ideas vs execution. It's pretty much imponderable. Both are necessary conditions, who cares in what proportion of importance.

I'll just observe that execution remains ridiculously difficult despite AI. Even building the software itself. Then there's all the other stuff, mostly relationships (with investors, customers, employees, lawmakers, society at large) to which AI contributes nearly zero or may even cause damage if used recklessly. The amount of posts I'm seeing from VCs complaining about vibeslop decks!

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by bellgrove on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:12AM (#50497179)
Completely agree. In my experience, Claude is great at producing working code — but whether that code is readable or designed to be easily extensible still requires heavy guidance. Anecdotally, I've found several of my colleagues experience a growing fatigue with increased PR volume sent to review, reading through AI generated descriptions and design documents, and generally from having more distance from the enjoyable (subjectively) hands-on work of coding.

AI has already delivered huge productivity gains in my opinion; the whole StackOverflow/Google search part of my life is gone. Instead I get answers from Claude tailored to my specific environment, use-case, problem, etc. Writing well-defined, simple code with lots of prior art in the same repo is easily handed off. But the AI industry and a lot of leadership in big tech seems to be expecting further miracles from AI. Maybe one day a CEO or CPO will just be able to speak their thoughts and a fleet of agents will implement it flawlessly, but we are nowhere near that reality right now.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by Fripplebubby on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:52AM (#50497487)
> In my experience, Claude is great at producing working code — but whether that code is readable or designed to be easily extensible still requires heavy guidance

I think this is a different point, though. OP is saying, we haven't really made progress on the problem of figuring out what to build (and just as importantly - what not to build) and how to convey that effectively and set up the right feedback loops to get AI to actually deliver on that. Whereas you're saying, "Yes, I agree, the code that the agent writes has flaws in readability and design". If we can get the first part actually solved (and I'm not sure what an answer looks like - other than what we have today, which is that The Market ultimately dictates whether you've built the right thing, built enough, not built too much), then nobody other than the AI agent actually cares about solving your problem (readable, maintainable code) anymore. Or to put it another way, it's only in the agent's interest to solve that problem, for the same reason that today it's in the SWE's interest to solve that problem, rather than the product manager or the business owner.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by cookiengineer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:07AM (#50497612)
> And there has been strictly zero progress on this and IMO this isn't something LLMs are structurally capable of doing.

Totally agree with this.

I see the future of what an IDE is more like an "architecture designing interface" which designs tests, architectural decisions, type systems, and contracts between components. Tasks then should be delegated in their implementations to agents so they are just responsible for the "wiring parts together" tasks.

Currently I imagine it as something similar to how workflows are usually designed around strong types and schema validations in safety-critical areas like ASPICE, Ada Spark, etc.

That's mostly why I don't use existing agentic environments and started earlier this year to experiment with my own one, where I try to enforce the design and architecture related tasks through capabilities mapped on tools for each of the task-scoped roles involved.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by jstimpfle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:16AM (#50497696)
To me it's been a great aid as a rubber duck and general research tool. Totally agree that it can barely help coming up with a good architecture. But it's quite capable of understanding an existing or a suggested one, even somewhat capable (though clearly not surpassing the best humans) at evaluating it.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by hackeraccount on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:34AM (#50497830)
Such a cruel age we live in. I thought I wasn't Picasso or Shakespeare because I didn't have a sense of meter or perspective. Those things are necessary but not sufficient. I'm not those people not because I'm too lazy to learn the skills but because I've got nothing to say.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by 9rx on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:48AM (#50497950)
The even bigger problem is hardware constraints. We have already done just about everything the current hardware is capable of (that we can think of). Only small potato problems that we didn't consider important before remain. AI can help complete those, but it isn't going to receive much fanfare, given that it wasn't considered terribly important to begin with. Unless you live deep within a niche, you're never going to notice.

When AI solves hardware design, then we might see some new room for software again.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by mupuff1234 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:51AM (#50497980)
> And there has been strictly zero progress on this and IMO this isn't something LLMs are structurally capable of doing

Making architectural mistakes is now exponentially cheaper - as you can refactor the entire code base in a day.

So even if LLMs are not quite there yet in terms of architecture, they definitely lessen the time one needs to spend on making the right choices.

and in areas like FE for more internal tools design really becomes a non issue.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by osigurdson on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:18AM (#50498216)
Pre LLM, it was only possible to try out a small number of ideas because the time cost was so high. Now we can try many more ideas but so far there isn't one that people can point to as the "killer vibe coded app" or even one that is moderately useful to a broad audience it seems.

The logical conclusion (so far - maybe tomorrow we'll see something great) is the ability to try things quickly doesn't improve outcomes. But then you either have to assume that whatever the state was in ~2022 was somehow optimal or that making it harder to create software would actually be better. Alternately it could be that there are no more good ideas left and no more code needs to be written.

While all of the above seem absurd, it would be hilarious if the last one turned out to be true: supply goes to infinity and demand goes to zero at exactly the same time.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by andai on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:43AM (#50498404)
That's half research, half experimentation. Why would llms be bad at any of that? They're already better than us at both halves.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by adventured on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:57AM (#50498529)
There were three really hard parts to creating software for other people.

1) Knowing what to build, keeping the design appropriate, not over-engineering the spec, not prematurely optimizing, et al. Note that this is different from just having an idea about a product.

2) Making it.

3) Getting people to use it. Nobody gives a shit about your software. Getting them to even try it is extraordinarily difficult in most cases. Selling is hard work. This will get a lot more difficult.

#2 has had the difficulty dialed back in many cases. In exchange #3 will increase drastically.

Absolutely nothing has gotten easier net. If anything the total will become harder net, the difficulty of acquiring users will get harder beyond the extent to which making it gets easier - users will trust software even less in the future, and the popular AI systems (personal agents or whatever they end up being called) will reduce the amount of software the typical user ever needs across a lifetime (narrowing the market).

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by InsidiousWombat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:42PM (#50502722)
Even then we should see more improvements just by LLM ability to quickly come up with prototypes so many potential solutions can be checked quickly.

...the problem is instead of doing that people take the first prototype and ship it

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by nextaccountic on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:06AM (#50505611)
> appropriately modelling the problem and designing the solution (at a conceptual, architectural level). And there has been strictly zero progress on this and IMO this isn't something LLMs are strucurally capable of doing.

I'm surprised people are agreeing with this take. LLMs can model things at a conceptual level, and they are actually better than some software developers at this task (though, not better than experienced developers). There has been progress on this specific ability.