Now that execution is more of a commodity, everyone seems to be saying execution is cheap and ideas are everything.
I don't disagree with you. I'm just noting an observed 180.
There were usually three or four startups chasing the same business case pre-AI.
Derivative ideas? Like "let's make a $thing with $variant"? Yes those are cheap, and AI made them pointless to pursue because most people can now whip up a hacked up variant of $thing with GPT and be happy with it, until they realise that it didn't add that much value to begin with.
But good, truly good ideas? Those that turn everything around? Those are cheap in the sense that your brain doesn't consume that much energy having them, but they are rare.
LLMs kind of confirmed we're indeed constrained by ideas: the homepage of HN isn't full of things like "we reimplemented X in Y" because we were full of revolutionary ideas to begin with. IMHO LLMs have further hampered the spread of truly great ideas - because nowadays if you have a truly great idea you have a fork:
- your idea can be quickly implemented by an LLM. You do it, and then everybody simply copies it using their LLM. - your idea requires time, iterations, ... so the LLM speeds up delivering it, but only a bit. We're still on a path similar than before - even before you could just hire more people and try to deliver stuff faster, as long as you had all already clearly planned beforehand.
So yes LLM are a big boon to productivity, but IMHO cast a long shadow of "why would I do it at all" on things. In the before times, I'd spend my day coding a dumb library for fun, just to brag about it a bit on Github and HN. But given that nowadays LLMs have reduced the value of code to ~0, the one thing that still has value is the idea behind. Which now people have less incentive to put out in the first place.
I'll just observe that execution remains ridiculously difficult despite AI. Even building the software itself. Then there's all the other stuff, mostly relationships (with investors, customers, employees, lawmakers, society at large) to which AI contributes nearly zero or may even cause damage if used recklessly. The amount of posts I'm seeing from VCs complaining about vibeslop decks!