News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by xorcist on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:55AM (#50496650)
We might be the same generation, I recognize the two roles. What I also remember is just empirically how much better the "programmers" were at doing the "system analysts" job. Way, way better. Then we stopped educating system analysts and now the job title is not heard of anymore.

I regularly meet (recently examined) people who are trained "software architects". Common among them is that they are often delay projects championing their pet idea, sometimes bringing negative value to the project. The best programmers are just so much better software architects also. So I expect history to repeat at this point.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by EarthBlues on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:59AM (#50497083)
Programmers are better architects because their decisions are continually informed by experience from the "sharp end" of the system. LLMs don't really have experiences, I dont think its the same. Our profession will likely shake out a lot of people in the coming years. What will be left may not be a classic "systems analyst" or "architect" role. I think the people who stay in this field will have to move both up and down the abstraction stack simultaneously -- our job will become a lot more "real", physical, relational, risk-oriented. I dont think there's good reason to believe LLMs can supply the need for prudence in the fields where software is deployed.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ctkhn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:36AM (#50497350)
You do need to stay in touch with the sharp end to stay sharp yourself. I've had a lot of managers and directors in my career who as they have moved up in companies, longer write any code, and seem to not really get how our systems work even though they are in charge. I had a few managers in the past who were "non technical" and had never written code in their life, and they were the absolute worst of the bunch. There is a little bit of truth to the otherwise very corny comic with the guy with an enormous head saying "at the library" when asked where he works out. https://i.pinimg.com/736x/3c/69/3a/3c693a6f9e3f6949192ce613e...
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by saltcured on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:09PM (#50498642)
In my opinion, a lot of that "no longer getting it" is because of the social/fashion trends that continually disrupt programming.

You don't forget CS concepts so easily, but all the syntactic tricks of new language variants and working set vocabulary of APIs, data formats, and frameworks keeps churning away from whatever you last had contacted in a real, hands-on way.

It is fascinating, wondering where this is going as programmers turn into their own middle managers on top of agents. Particularly, the school who claim that you don't really need to understand all the code and instead treat it like a black-box experiment. If this fad takes over the main stage, then everyone becomes one of those less technical managers.

But, in this new scenario, there is no human in the loop to inject judgement calls and "manage up" anymore. There is no programmer culture except the models and agents, which don't really have the same social connections to drive a programming culture. What will happen? A culture per agent product? Per enterprise client of the agent vendor? Per agent operator? Per codebase?

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ohyes on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:18AM (#50506047)
I don’t think we get new things. Right now they’re great at popular languages and frameworks. If those change? There’s not enough training data. It could generate the data and train itself but where’s the incentive. It certainly can’t learn a new language right away the way even a junior programmer can. It will constantly hallucinate and not improve.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by torginus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:41AM (#50497384)
Weird how these fads just disappear overnight, 1984 style.

About half a year ago I noticed there were no people called 'Agile something' at our org, so I asked about it. They looked at me like I was a space alien. I remember, it was like 3 years ago that management bet the house on 'Agile transformation' talking about how Agile practices are the bread and butter of a good organization.

Now they're talking about AI the same way.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ctkhn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:52AM (#50497495)
To be fair there is something to the idea of moving to agile from waterfall practices, the same way going on any diet in general makes you think about what you're eating and helps you lose weight. Unfortunately it's usually just a way for the same management (who have fostered bad practices) to hire a new set of consultants and look like they're doing something without actually fixing anything.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by torginus on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:02PM (#50501948)
Yes, that something is about moving from a management class composed mostly of senior engineers to Agile cultists whose core tenet is that they do not know anything about engineering, and do not wish to, because as long as the principles of Agile are followed correctly, it doesn't matter if your company makes software or matresses.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ahartmetz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:55AM (#50498510)
It's fun to remind people of past hypes and how they disappeared. Some don't seem to get the connection to the current thing. (Note, I'm not saying AI is nothing.)
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by somesortofthing on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:17PM (#50499891)
"Don't try to completely plan out huge software projects and commit to rigid delivery timelines in advance," "Split work into manageable tasks", "Run daily meetings to keep managers(and sometimes coworkers) in the decision loop and surface blockers", etc. are iron laws everyone instinctively recognizes are there for a reason. The explicit framework fell away because its principles became ubiquitous - nobody needs to hire Agile™ consultants to tell their SWEs and managers to do things the way they've been doing them for their whole career.
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by ElevenLathe on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:03PM (#50501428)
You say this like its universal, but my ostensibly Agile org is currently planning the work we will be delivering Q1 of 2028 because that is how long our [proposed work] -> [approved work] -> [finished work] pipeline runs.

The memo has NOT gotten around, though AI now makes it easier to make all the various slide decks and schedule all the 50+ person meetings that power this process.

Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by fcarraldo on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:09PM (#50513914)
Sounds like Scaled Agile Framework aka SAFe or something similar? A total consulting scam sold to clueless execs (I worked for some, these processes are a nightmare)
Re:Jonathan Blow – If AI Solved Coding, Why Is My Software S... by derefr on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:47AM (#50498446)
> Common among them is that they are often delay projects championing their pet idea, sometimes bringing negative value to the project.

Negative value to the project, perhaps; but if these "software architects" are kept around despite several rounds of this, it may be because they're providing positive value to the company, in terms of:

- being able to provide the executive team corroborating evidence to show to investors to convince them that they're acting strategically in the market; or

- where the existence of the project, no matter how failed, serves as collateral to get breathless puff-piece articles written about the company in places where dumb CTOs/CIOs who make IT buying decisions will read them (and not necessarily buy the product that came out of that project — hopefully not! — but remember the company itself the next time they're comparing vendors for something else.)