Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by ErroneousBosh on Thursday November 12, 2026 @09:16AM
(#50467556)
If you have satellite TV you already have a solar radiotelescope.
Measure the voltage on the AGC line in the tuner and you'll see a peak as the sun passes the azimuth of the dish. That's it picking up 10GHz solar radiation, and turning its gain down to compensate for the background noise.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by rtkwe on Thursday November 12, 2026 @09:20AM
(#50467651)
Yes but repeated evenly spaced pulses are special and limited to a special subset of stars caller pulsars. The sun is mostly wideband radio noise where the article is talking about distinct regular pulses which are rarer.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by metalman on Thursday November 12, 2026 @09:09AM
(#50467373)
I didn't know that there was a whole slew of these red and white dwarfs orbiting other stars, which I think must make it extra unlikely for there to be habitable planets in the same system, the process of one star capturing another is going to realy wreck havock with any original planets,
and any surviving lifeform to get past the am radio phase of technological development
thats! GPM J071507−114153, "the pulse on your dial" brought to by astrophyisal phenominon, every 8 min, for eterinty
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by combobyte on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50469858)
The same general reasons that allow planets to form instead of all the mass going into a single star: mass/momentum/charge asymmetries in the original stellar nebula, complex interactions in the accretion disk, gravitational perturbations from other stars in the same stellar nursery, etc
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by dekhn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @09:29AM
(#50467853)
I don't think the title is really accurate- it doesn't emit radio signals every 8 minutes, it emits constantly, but emits along an axis that periodically aligns with our viewing cone.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by sandworm101 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:01AM
(#50469565)
There is an underlying tension in astronomical language. For over a thousand years "star" was a thing in the sky, a bit of light one could point a telescope at. We today understand stars not as lights but as giant objects billions of miles away. Which definition is used changes according to context. A steady beam that intermittently points towards earth can be described using either definition: It is a light in the sky that pulses, or it is aspherical star emitting a beam as it rotates. Both are correct.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by dekhn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:13AM
(#50469764)
I've never heard any astronomer I've worked with say that. What people said for a thousand years (incorrectly) is mostly irrelevant to modern science.
What I'm saying is that it's tecnically incorrect to say " emits radio signals every 8 minutes " because it emits constantly. Emission is different from detection.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by sandworm101 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:30AM
(#50470016)
"Sirius is the brightest star in the night sky"
I have heard that phrase from many. But Sirius is nowhere near the brightest star. Sirius is only brightest if one uses the "light in the night sky" definition of a star. Under the "ball of plasma" definition. Betelgeuse is visible to the eye and is many times brighter than Sirius... just not from our perspective of looking up at lights in the sky.
The brightness from our perspective might not be interesting to stellar astronomers, but to someone like a ship's navigator or NASA engineer building a satellite's navigation system, apparent brightness of a "star" is everything.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by sandworm101 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:56AM
(#50470394)
Lol, are you a linguist?
I have taken enough stellar astronomy undergrads to understand that "star" is a nuanced term, that "Which is brightest?" is a loaded question on an exam. Read any astronomical journal and you will see splits between the physics/math types who discuss stars as balls of gas, and the observer/telescope types who talk of them as lights to be seen. And anyone reading history can witness how often the definition of "star" has changed over time, and continues to change to this day.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by unrented7977 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50470464)
People also said the earth was flat for thousands of years. Stop intentionally conflating incorrect casual vernacular with actual scientific language. You are, quite simply, plain wrong.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by sandworm101 on Thursday November 12, 2026 @01:07PM
(#50471508)
"Pulsar" = Scientific term. They do not pulse, except from our perspective (the light-in-the-sky definition). Pulsars have kept the name and are regularly described as pulsing objects when discussed the context of observations.
"Neutron Star" = Scientific term. But is not a star by accepted scientific definition.
Science is full of ancient terminology. Being imperfect does not make a term "casual vernacular".
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by vhantz on Thursday November 12, 2026 @02:25PM
(#50472799)
Yeah words have an history. Google etymology.
Should every phenomenon be renamed as soon as our knowledge of it depens? Or should we wait until we have reached an understanding of the thing in itself until we dare name a phenomenon? Both of these are obviously impractical, useless and harmful options for science and society at large.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by philipov on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:07PM
(#50470585)
Your semantic argument is comparing apples and oranges, and therefore fails. The semantics of the word "emit" are not like the semantics of "brightest in the night sky." The first describes an objective action, while the second describes a subjective detection. You sneakily drop the "in the night sky" to try to turn a subjective statement into an objective one, but this is deception. Why yes, I am a linguist.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by adolph on Thursday November 12, 2026 @02:30PM
(#50472890)
Yes, it is incorrect and yes it is how language works. Even a "co-author on the paper" calls them "pulses" which maybe straddles the definition of periodic emission and detection.
Associate Professor Natasha Hurley-Walker, co-author on the paper, said that the pulses emitted by the white dwarf allowed the team to detect stellar flares on the Sun-like star, similar to those that create aurorae here on Earth.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by 1d22a on Thursday November 12, 2026 @09:02PM
(#50477138)
I don't know, we often talk about lighthouses "flashing", for example, when really they are constantly emitting but their rotation means the constant emission only periodically aligns with our viewing cone. This feels consistent with that.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by dekhn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @10:56AM
(#50469475)
Take a look also at quasars, which are supermassive black holes at the center of galaxies, fed by enormous amounts of matter falling into the gravity well.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by itintheory on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:28AM
(#50469972)
Sounds like the OnOff star from A Deepness in the Sky by Vernor Vinge. It started with very quick oscillation and eventually settled toward 200 years off, 60 years on (or so). Interesting speculation about what this would do to a developing species/society.
Re:Researchers discover rare star system that emits radio si...
by phailhaus on Thursday November 12, 2026 @11:34AM
(#50470065)
Unfortunately the headline is misleading. It's constantly emitting radio signals, it's just spinning in a way that points at us every 8 minutes. Great book though!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_radio_emission
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_telescope
Measure the voltage on the AGC line in the tuner and you'll see a peak as the sun passes the azimuth of the dish. That's it picking up 10GHz solar radiation, and turning its gain down to compensate for the background noise.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pulsar
thats! GPM J071507−114153, "the pulse on your dial" brought to by astrophyisal phenominon, every 8 min, for eterinty
What I'm saying is that it's tecnically incorrect to say " emits radio signals every 8 minutes " because it emits constantly. Emission is different from detection.
I have heard that phrase from many. But Sirius is nowhere near the brightest star. Sirius is only brightest if one uses the "light in the night sky" definition of a star. Under the "ball of plasma" definition. Betelgeuse is visible to the eye and is many times brighter than Sirius... just not from our perspective of looking up at lights in the sky.
The brightness from our perspective might not be interesting to stellar astronomers, but to someone like a ship's navigator or NASA engineer building a satellite's navigation system, apparent brightness of a "star" is everything.
I have taken enough stellar astronomy undergrads to understand that "star" is a nuanced term, that "Which is brightest?" is a loaded question on an exam. Read any astronomical journal and you will see splits between the physics/math types who discuss stars as balls of gas, and the observer/telescope types who talk of them as lights to be seen. And anyone reading history can witness how often the definition of "star" has changed over time, and continues to change to this day.
"Neutron Star" = Scientific term. But is not a star by accepted scientific definition.
Science is full of ancient terminology. Being imperfect does not make a term "casual vernacular".
Should every phenomenon be renamed as soon as our knowledge of it depens? Or should we wait until we have reached an understanding of the thing in itself until we dare name a phenomenon? Both of these are obviously impractical, useless and harmful options for science and society at large.
Such pedantry isn't very useful for communication, though.
"Well it's probably a whole hippo, it's just the rest of him is under the water."
What wait, 8mn is a long period?
I checked the fastest pulsar observed rotates and “emits” at 716Hz! :shock:
That’s ~70.000km/s on the equator given its ~30km diameter :shock: :shock:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_J1748%E2%88%922446ad
Wasn't there a subreddit dedicated to terrifying two or so sentences stories?
> All alone in his light cone.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_bomb
Make it random, at least receivers would have a harder time identifying intentions
Objects with a period this long are much rarer, according to this wp article there are only 12 we know of. I thought it was fewer!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_period_radio_transient
Seriously, if data doesn't fit the classical definition, you need to update the classical definition.
And I still find it mindboggling that the radio pulses from the star that we're receiving were emitted 5000 years ago.