Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Avicebron on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:15AM
(#50414501)
Isn't Tesla trying to be SpaceX's vertically integrated robotics division? My gut feeling says they are trying to move out of the EV business as crazy as that may seem to us normals.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by martythemaniak on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:18AM
(#50414538)
Not crazy at all. Tesla gave up being a car company a few years ago, but there's lot of inertia and the 3 and Y are still competitive products in the marketplace.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by buran77 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:27AM
(#50414634)
Their charging network and carbon credits revenue were probably the more valuable parts of the company. Tesla's current promise and foundation for that valuation is that they'll deliver fully autonomous driving.
But Musk has enough avenues to spin things left and right and bury any losses in the process his DOGE assault helped a lot bury some things already) so he'll do that.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by judge2020 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:43AM
(#50414803)
I think the market is mainly banking on Robotaxi being nationwide in 5 years, and Optimus being ready in 10.
For robotaxi, the last 2 years has shown us that FSD 14 has solved the really hard parts of autonomy, so the next logical step is some percentage of people deciding not to own their next car and instead only getting around by Robotaxi.
This is not a bad play by the market. They're poised to absorb some amount of the costs that people are currently paying to (A) own a car, (B) pay interest on the loan, and (C) pay for car insurance. And C does not carry meaningful risk as autonomous vehicles are de-facto safer drivers.
Then the market is kind of putting their faith in giving Tesla 10 years to apply the same playbook to humanoid robots and all of the jobs that that _could_ replace (remains to be seen how capable they can actually make it and what the economics will look like).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by close04 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:43PM
(#50415369)
Human drivers pay one insurance, for themselves. It’s easier to swallow because most drivers think they are above average skill. Not so easy when they need to cover someone else’s coding mistakes. And if the company has to pay for every car that self drives that can get ugly fast, one bug and half the fleet has a fender bender.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by judge2020 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:55PM
(#50415932)
Chances are they just self-insure (like they are now) and eventually will have some group insurance if they can actually prove it's safer over the next half decade.
>Our fleet of Model Y and Cybercab vehicles offers autonomous rides in cities across the U.S. You can already hail a car in Austin, Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, Miami, Orlando and Tampa with more rides arriving in more cities soon.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by santoshalper on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50415071)
If you want any kind of good faith information or analysis on Tesla, you're going to need to ignore tesla.com. They are primarily in the business of selling hope and bullshit.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by judge2020 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:25PM
(#50415214)
They have a xlsx download on https://www.tesla.com/robotaxi/safety that is somewhat transparent. For example it mentions the two following scenarios where hospitalization is alleged, although neither seem to be caused by the robotaxi car:
> The ADS was proceeding straight through a work zone on a street and drove over a pothole at approximately 29MPH. The ADS had two riders present in the vehicle. One customer alleged they sought medical care.
> Summary: The ADS was stopped at an intersection stop sign, waiting to turn left and yielding to crossing traffic. An SUV that was stopped behind traffic straight across at a stop sign drove into the oncoming lane passed traffic. The SUV then drove up to the intersection, stopped, and proceeded straight, crossing into the lane and path of a passenger vehicle from their right cross street. The front of the passenger vehicle collided with the right side of the SUV and the SUV's airbags were deployed. Post collision, the SUV's front was pushed into the ADS's lane and collided into the front of the ADS. The ADS was pushed backward, causing its rear to collide with the front of another SUV that was stopped behind it. The ADS had one rider present in the vehicle. The driver of the passenger vehicle from the original collision was transported to the hospital for unknown reason.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @09:36AM
(#50441005)
I have a bridge to sell you. Tesla doesn't operate 24/7. They can't monitor enough of their taxis they have registered to deploy even half of them. They don't release stats. Tesla has a fake business.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hvb2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:01PM
(#50414987)
> Then the market is kind of putting their faith in giving Tesla 10 years to apply the same playbook to humanoid robots and all of the jobs that that _could_ replace
So when I go for a coffee, I don't go to the place where it's a dollar less expensive because it has a robot...
I'm not convinced we wanted to be helped by a robot, even if it does the same thing.
So the economics might be there.... But that's not the whole story, this isn't automating a production line...
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hdgvhicv on Monday November 09, 2026 @03:02AM
(#50422517)
It won’t be a dollar less. The large companies that currently have the massive share even though they charge more will all go for robots and will simply increase their profits.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by close04 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:08PM
(#50415057)
The valuation would be realistic only if they were the only ones with a real shot at autonomy or at least a considerable head start, like they did in the EV market. But they don’t.
The real incentive is that Musk won’t let one of his companies “fail”. It will be absorbed into a larger more successful one and keep delivering “investor value”.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:24PM
(#50415197)
Its a story nothing more.
Tesla fan boys still say that NO ONE else can do self driving despite plenty of companies which do like waymo or Nvidia, Mercedes and BMW.
Then they tell you that no one will own a car anymore but we already have Taxi/Uber and the world hasn't changed much and they complelty ignore basics like traffic spikes for workers.
You don't get good utilization when you can handle everything and low utilization means a LOT of space for waiting cars.
Its the same spiel with Optimus but there people seem to be quite enough and do understand that china is ahead.
Lets ignore the fever dream of Space-Xs payload story...
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by judge2020 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:31PM
(#50415269)
> Tesla fan boys still say that NO ONE else can do self driving despite plenty of companies which do like waymo or Nvidia, Mercedes and BMW.
Absolutely no one is saying that. The bad faith is people saying that Robotaxi is doomed because it's vision-only. It may end up not being the best approach, but it's looking to be good enough to be performant and still be one of the larger players in the market.
> Then they tell you that no one will own a car anymore but we already have Taxi/Uber and the world hasn't changed much and they complelty ignore basics like traffic spikes for workers.
I'm not saying this either. This is like saying that busses and trains are vaporware because they can't serve 100% of transportation needs.
Some peoples' lifestyles will adapt to this change or already fit within it. A lot of people's won't. Over time, they will gradually close the gaps and/or people will change their own lives to fit it if they'd like to save money on transportation.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:46PM
(#50415391)
I'm reading this argument and had discussions with people plenty of times. I then remind them of all the other companies.
Does selfdriving work? yes. Is robotaxi a real business? Yes.
Thats not the point. The point here is the valuation of Tesla because of it and thats not justifiable. Despite the fact that Tesla originally sold FSD so that everyone can leverage this feature.
So either Tesla builds a cheap Robotaxi and floods the market as a car company OR Tesla becomes a competitor on a competitive market.
Why would people adjust their lifestyles based on a Robotaxi? We have already Taxis and Ubers.
The only chance for 'people changing their lifestyles' is if a Robotaxi is always available and A LOT cheaper which then again breaks the whole valuation of Tesla.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by judge2020 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:46PM
(#50415856)
My main issue with Uber/Lyft/Taxi is the human element (humans sometimes want to chat) and the tipping element. Plus how flakey drivers are - e.g. they might not immediately go to pick you up and could taking detours or pit stops, etc.
To actually switch to it myself, I'd need robotaxi to deliver:
- p99 5 minute wait for ride hailing, including at peak times
- 24/7 operation
Longer 200-500 mile trips would also be nice, although then you get into needing robotic and/or wireless charging pads at SCs for road trips to work.
Also, there are a lot of ways some sort of subscription service could be handled. Maybe included usage, maybe I pay to have it ready in my driveway between 6am and 9am (but still to where I don't own it / need to personally insure it). Either way, it won't be hard for it to undercut my current car expenses if I can cut out car insurance.
None of the above is de-facto impossible with automation in the space. In fact, more reliable ops would be easier because the company can predict and dynamically scale how many are running at any given time, purely limited by (non-human) capital, instead of needing to increase their bid for human drivers to accept rides when demand is high.
Although the question is indeed if they can do all of this economically in a crowded space; I don't disagree that $1T is an insane valuation in any respect. Elon's umbrella of companies is all funny money to me.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:45PM
(#50418287)
I checked the calculation which was a lot easier than i thought. The german automotive club actually has a table what a car costs per km and the range is between 50-100cents per km.
Tax and uber are at around 2.5 Euro per km so 250 cents per km.
Tbh I thought before already that this not an easy story to sell, but the price point is between 2.5-5 already and if you remove 16% of the driver, you only get down to 2.1-4.2
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by detourdog on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:37PM
(#50418201)
It could be similar to late 90’s market share slide of Macintosh. Apple was the largest pc manufacturer but had the smallest market segment overall. There were so many IBM clones that the overall market share of the PC market was higher volume than Macintosh.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by notatoad on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:19AM
(#50414547)
is this something that's actually happening, or just something elon told investors at his optimus event with the obviously fake robots a couple years ago?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by thinkingtoilet on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:19AM
(#50414549)
It's not crazy at all. Elon, in all his genius, built up an EV company and then alienated the core demographic for his product. They tried to salvage it with a wildly over-priced, virtue-signaling "truck" and that didn't work. There are literally millions and millions of Americans who would have other wise loved to buy a Tesla but will never buy one because of Elon. They have to pivot.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by alpha_squared on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50414552)
Pretending Tesla isn't a car company and SpaceX isn't a satellite services company (Internet, maybe mobile) is wild stuff. The only real profits are from those traditional industries. All the sci-fi hype is for investors and fanatics.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jordanb on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:22AM
(#50414589)
Value the company by the sizzle not the steak. And before it fails completely fold it into the next grift. Sounds far fetched but it's been working for Elon for years.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by FabHK on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:52PM
(#50415444)
> stacking his house of cards higher and higher
Indeed. What I find particularly grating is that Tesla seems rather overpriced, but if SpaceX acquires it, it'll provide the Tesla investors with a nice exit. (And SpaceX of course is a very long shot that's in any number of retirement portfolios by virtue of its rash index inclusion.)
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:25AM
(#50414619)
Those are just side projects. SpaceX is now an AI company. All their phony future revenue projections are dependent on magic numbers cooked up by a drug addict who convinces people to believe his stream of lies.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by derefr on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50414974)
FYI, Tesla makes a large fraction of its profits off the margins from selling grid-scale ("Megapack") batteries to utilities; renewable energy projects (buffering energy generated by e.g. private wind farms); and most recently, data centers (where they act either as giant battery-backed UPS systems, or as reservoirs between on-site power generation and fluctuating on-site demand.)
They probably also want to get into the military energy storage market (a.k.a. "tactical microgrids"), but they need more vertical integration for that. Right now they don't make their own cells, so the defense contractors that build ruggedized batteries skip them and go straight to sourcing from the cell manufacturers.
(Fun fact: Tesla's Gigafactories as physical spaces produce a ton of battery cells, but Tesla itself doesn't. Tesla leases space in its Gigafactories to cell manufacturers like Panasonic, who actually produce the cells, so that Tesla can then directly consume some of the cells produced into battery packs, without any intervening logistics costs.)
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by matthewdgreen on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:21AM
(#50414572)
Being in the EV business means having to accept predictable revenues that then tie to more predictable stock prices. Being in the business of "some future technology" doesn't.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:44AM
(#50414810)
The big problem for Tesla is that they cannot sustain their valuation from the car manufacturing business. There's a perpetual need to justify why Tesla should be valued an order of magnitude more than other automakers. Selling the dream of future profit is Tesla's main business.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:12PM
(#50415098)
The comparison is actually even worse if you compare it to other companies on the battery sector. How is Tesla supposed to be five times more than CATL ffs?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Reason077 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49PM
(#50415417)
> "They are a battery company."
Not really. Tesla, like most automakers, purchases most of its battery cells from other companies. In recent years they have started to manufacture their own cells as well, with their 4680 cell manufacturing line at "Giga Texas". But this is still a small portion of the cells they use globally.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hparadiz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:49PM
(#50416465)
That's interesting cause FY2025 had them do about 14 billion in battery/energy products (revenue). With auto being a little over 60 billion. The energy products seem to be growing in volume though
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Reason077 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:22PM
(#50416754)
Yes, "Energy Products" refers to Tesla's energy storage products (home Powerwalls and industrial-scale "Megapacks"). Tesla manufactures these packs using battery cells they buy from 3rd parties. Tesla's value is added in the pack design, software, inverter electronics, branding, etc.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ethbr1 on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:06AM
(#50425056)
> These days, maybe your business is defined by your rate of change?
This is the most absurd and also true observation I've read on HN in a while.
As the rate of technological process accelerates, maybe it becomes possible to justify a company's valuation on a never-ending succession of "And then..."s.
Granted, that ended poorly in terms of stock prices for the .com bubble, but mostly for companies that weren't financially solvent enough to withstand higher interest rates + a public market downturn.
And it took a conflation of multiple events to pop that bubble (Asian instability, moderate US interest rate hikes, 9/11/2001).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:22PM
(#50415182)
Until the merger with xAI, spaceX was actually a decent company with a very solid business, a clear technological edge and clear growth perspective. It shouldn't be a trillion dollar company of course, but it should have been a cash cow capturing all the value from its niche market.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49PM
(#50415421)
But not with the valuation it currently has.
The only reason why Payload into space increased from 1000t to 3000t is Starlink.
And there they have also massive problems for scaling. Base Station is expensive and they have to replace the Satelites every 5 years. Withouth the v3 and rocket big enough to send it up, they can't scale properly.
If they then scale, the rate of atmosphere poisening through STarlink will increase.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ethbr1 on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:13AM
(#50425146)
SpaceX's central flywheel is: (1) find unserved, profitable need for mass-produced space launch, (2) design, iterate, and scale production of a rocket that can do that, & (3) GOTO 1 at the next mass scale.
Starlink was the seed customer for unused gen1 launch capacity.
Space datacenters are probably intended to be the gen2 seed.
Because SpaceX needs to frequently toss rockets up to be able to iterate on them and scale manufacturing, and they'd rather use the (high-risk) payload capacity for something profitable while doing that.
But as a net result, SpaceX can afford to launch mass that others can't, because it wins two ways: whatever profits that launched mass produces + iterating rocket design and manufacturing.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by tarsinge on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:39PM
(#50415340)
I don’t know, I think at this point the Tesla stock doesn’t have a link with the company anymore and behaves like any meme coin or collectible token. Like in crypto there is some vague narrative about a crazy future but ultimately the point is only to drive further speculation ("buy it before you’re priced out/join the elite crowd that’ll own the future/etc."). The genius of Elon is having realized (I’d say around the time he tested the ground with pumping dogecoin) that in a stock market where investors don’t buy for dividends but only price speculation the underlying business doesn’t really matter, only the narrative does (since dividends are the only link with the real business).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:48PM
(#50415412)
You should probably compare revenue instead of profit because Tesla and Toyota are at very different places in their development.
But Toyota still makes 3x Teslas revenue.
I'm guessing some of the 9x difference is speculative and some is because Tesla is all in on EVs/etc, which are doing well, and Toyota is still very much in ICEs, which aren't doing as well.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ajay-b on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:58AM
(#50414953)
Which begs a question: Is it really possible to compete with China on consumer products? The price and cost of labor advantage, indeed state sponsorship and support, would suggest that it's not.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by StilesCrisis on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:04PM
(#50415024)
For electronics, sure. iPhone and Android are American products. Playstation and Switch are Japanese. If you mean "can we compete on cost of manufacturing," no. They all build in China.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by neves on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:14PM
(#50415116)
Musk's companies are some with the most state sponsorship on the planet. Remove the tax credits, government buying, and commercial barriers, and there's nothing.
Even then, he is losing to Chinese competition. It's pure incompetence.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by bradknowles on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:10PM
(#50416063)
So, the irony here is that, according to the latest JD Powers reports, Tesla scores 113 defects per thousand here in the US. That makes them the worst vehicle manufacturer in the country, with regards to quality. In China, Tesla also scores 113 defects per thousand. But there, that makes them the number one vehicle manufacturer in the country, with regards to quality.
If Chinese vehicles were allowed into the US, they would certainly eat all the other vehicle manufacturers, except for customers who care about quality. And that’s where Toyota would be able to continue to survive.
But even Toyota would lose a ton of sales, because prices here in the US are so, so much higher than they should be. You can just look at prices in Europe and Canada to see that.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by shawnb576 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:07PM
(#50417259)
I think you're implying that based on these JD Powers numbers Chinese make low quality cars and will therefore not be successful.
I don't know what to make of these numbers. Are all defects the same? (I can't be bothered to look).
What I can tell you is we owned a Model Y in the US for 3+ years. It was great, we had one small seat problem (which mobile service promptly fixed). The news is full of customer horror stories from Tesla, and not only did we like ours, our wide network of friends had many with similar experience.
I now live in Australia and have a Zeekr 7x (Chinese EV). My in-laws have an MG. The place is swimming with BYDs, Geely's, GWMs, etc. The idea that Chinese cars are low quality and people won't like them is laughable. No - they are cars people like at a price they are willing to pay.
We've only had our Zeekr 4 months but so far its been great and the build quality seems MUCH higher than the MY. It's quieter, the trim is much nicer, its generally great.
Letting Chinese cars into the US will decimate the US auto industry. No question about it, they will be reduced to light trucks for a time but even that probably isn't defensible.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by bradknowles on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:23PM
(#50419339)
It is important to know that JD Powers makes a point of not distinguishing between different types of complaint. Not liking the color of the seat belt is treated the same as the motor blowing up when you turn it on. They’re looking at big picture numbers here.
And on that criteria, at the time that survey was done, I do think that Tesla probably may well have been the best car manufacturer in China. But perhaps things have changed quickly there?
I also think that Tesla quality has significantly declined overall as time has progressed. They’ve been more about trying to be the new thing, whatever that is.
I am also convinced that if Chinese car manufacturers are let into this country, that will kill the low to midrange market for any of the traditional car manufacturers. People are willing to put up with a lot of crap, if they can get it at a lower price — witness the rise of Amazon, Walmart, and Temu. And China can guarantee that they will always have the lowest prices, with lower labor costs, lower government environmental scrutiny, and active government subsidization. Tariffs on Chinese cars will need to be super high — maybe 100% or more? And even that isn’t going to save the car manufacturers in this country.
China can attack the high-end luxury market, but they’re going to have a lot more friction there, simply because people buying cars in that bracket won’t want to be seen as being cheap. China is going to have a long road ahead of them, but when they can deliver Lexus and Mercedes quality at bargain basement prices, there will be some people that they can peel away from the more well-established brands.
Meanwhile, companies like Polstar will do well, because many people don’t realize (or care) that brand is largely owned by Geely and another Chinese company. It will really be about the branding and how transparent the Chinese parent companies are about their ownership of other brands that people are more open to exploring.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by peri-cl on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:14PM
(#50415122)
It's sort of Tesla's core thesis that want to to attain the world's lowest manufacturing costs, by doing novel things with robotics and AI that automate away humans.
Everyone keeps getting this backwards. Tesla isn't abandoning their low-margin auto manufacturing in order to switch to high-margin robotics tech; they want to capture the margin of robotics for themselves first. If their manufacturing half fails, that means their robotics half also failed at its sole purpose.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by slowin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:22AM
(#50414591)
It’s especially crazy since they sell cars and do not sell robots. Both of Musk’s public companies are little more than financial fraud. That the SEC allows any of this gives me zero confidence in the entire market.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by mschuster91 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:31AM
(#50414672)
> That the SEC allows any of this gives me zero confidence in the entire market.
It will be truly nasty for the next President. All of this shit is going to blow up hard, even worse than 2007 was. With any luck, it will blow up during Trump's final months, but in the truly worst case it will collapse during the early time of whoever the next President is, which means no matter who gets the job will get smoked in the 2030 midterms - in turn ending up like Obama who didn't have a majority of his own for six years.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by kraken_cult on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:33AM
(#50414704)
The cynic in me would say, "all according to plan", it will be right before the new house and senate are going to roll out universal healthcare or something equally good for the average person. Better to get head of it before that happens.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by runarberg on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50414973)
I would argue that the Affordable Care Act was nothing more then a common sense consumer protection legislation for a consumer market that should not exist in the first place.
The fact that it was this big and this hard to get and with this many compromises against consumer interest, speaks more of the disfunction of the USA government at the time then it does about the value of that legislation.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:11PM
(#50415088)
Maybe a bit of both sides in my opinion. It shows the dysfunction of the government and our healthcare system, but it was also practical and helpful to the those left out of the healthcare system.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by parasubvert on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:23PM
(#50415195)
This is a deep misunderstanding. Socialized healthcare has been a fight for almost 100 years. What you find "common sense" has been an intense, almost existential fight, up there with slavery, universal suffrage, civil rights, prohibition, and abortion.
This fight not about the dysfunction of the USA government at the time, it's about a fight over the structure of the USA as it was founded. There have always been strong political forces trying to dismantle all "common sense" features of the welfare state, who have convinced the masses to vote against their own interests out of the American Dream of rugged individualism.
This is in contrast to the unique decentralized communitarian history of America with community activism, charities, NGOs and nonprofits filling the social holes between the government and private enterprise. The current healthcare system evolved out of this with both private and government involvement which is in part why it's an expensive mess. Most European countries post WW2 had a chance to design something more efficient.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:08PM
(#50415060)
And to add to this, for also properly dealing with the 2008 financial crisis. Just as a reminder to those out there, the strategy of recent administrations for crises like this was to cut federal spending in order reduce deficits, and many of the politicians at the time were calling for cutting spending. Obama listened to his economic advisors who told him to stimulate the economy and get money into the hands of the people. There were some rough edges to their stimulus spending but it seems to have worked and our recovery was the envy of most of the world. In recessions, stimulus seems to have now become the norm.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Sunday November 08, 2026 @09:12PM
(#50420127)
Hmm, think I meant mainly Reagan and his deregulation of the US economy with Reagonomics, and how this type of thinking became the norm afterwards, not just for politicians but for the American people. This is of course my opinion, but think the way a lot of politicians in 2008 reacted when stimulus was proposed backs this up at least somewhat.
(and I don't have anything against cutting spending. In fact, actually think Reagan did the right thing in using this tool as well as deregulation to end stagflation. But cutting & spending should be based on the situation and for 2008, spending seemed the right course of action).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Monday November 09, 2026 @11:32AM
(#50427862)
Hmm, seems like the web partially agrees with you. Just did a search and yes, Reaganomics increased defense spending but tried to reduce all other government spending. The overall idea was small government (although in practice, this didn't happen).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by justin-reeves on Monday November 09, 2026 @07:59AM
(#50424990)
The stimulus was too small, and the recovery too slow. The economy didn’t reach full employment until 2016, with the last full employment period being the late ’90s.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Monday November 09, 2026 @05:00PM
(#50432869)
Agreed, but compared to most European and Asian countries, who chose austerity, our recovery was much better as most of themhad multi-year recessions or stagnation.
And agreed, we known now that we should have gone bigger, but this was the first time stimulus like this was tried, and they weren't sure what they were doing. Also, have heard that at the time, there was a lot of opposition by many politicians to stimulus, so there was only so much they could do.
yeah, at least for me, it was one of the biggest risks the Obama administration took, bucking convention, but resulted in changing how we deal with many finacial crises.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by khriss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50415068)
You mean other than Obamacare, Dodd Frank, GFC stimulus, Auto industry support, repeal of DADT?
Yeah, you're right. Much better to have Trump who just passed tax cuts for billionaires and corporations, imposed tariffs on Penguins and pardoned a bunch of people, some of whom he said he didn't even know.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by khriss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:54PM
(#50418402)
edit: spelling
> The world would've been very different with say, Bernie Sanders as president in 2016.
Undoubtedly, US and probably the world would likely have been a better place if that had happened.
Unfortunately, at present in the United States, the choices om offer(at least at a national level) are either neo liberalism with a woke 1.0 add on, or full on MAGA. The latter part is likely going to swing back to neocon territory by 2028 though.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by rsynnott on Monday November 09, 2026 @09:04AM
(#50425790)
> The latter part is likely going to swing back to neocon territory by 2028 though.
That will be an... interesting transition. They're kind of between a rock and a hard place; they clearly have to ditch the MAGA thing, because it's electoral poison, as we've just seen. But also the die-hard Trumpists are still a big part of their base, and won't like that.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:48AM
(#50414851)
Hyundai even bought the humanoid robot company that actually has a working humanoid robot. But it didn't make them any money or give them an absurd P/E ratio.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by mschuster91 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:26AM
(#50414625)
> My gut feeling says they are trying to move out of the EV business as crazy as that may seem to us normals.
It's not that crazy. The last new release of a truly mainstream car was the Model 3 a decade ago. Anything ever since has been facelifts and the ill-fated Cybercuck.
The major problem Tesla faces is that on the one side their brand image is in the gutters and has been for years and on the other side, "established" car companies finally have brought competitive cars to the market at relevant scale. They'll need to invest a lot of money to develop a new model from scratch with a high chance of not making back the money.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by lotsofpulp on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:46AM
(#50414821)
$100 per month in a $40k vehicle that allows it to drive sufficiently well 99% of the time such that it reduces driver stress and liability is worth something.
Other car manufacturers somehow can’t even provide dashcam recordings in a $40 vehicle.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by toast0 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:54AM
(#50414909)
> The last new release of a truly mainstream car was the Model 3 a decade ago.
I'm no Tesla fan, but having longevity in car models is a good thing. My fun car was built by VW in Germany for a decade and then by VW in South Africa for another decade; parts availability is great.
In today's marketplace of very samey cars, models that work should probably last a decade or more.
That said, Tesla could have built out a couple more styles, such as maybe a minivan/workvan/delivery van, although van sales can be pretty cyclical, and Tesla parts and service was (is?) notoriously poor in some cases, so I dunno if commercial users would be interested.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by wildzzz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:04PM
(#50415022)
I like what Rivian does, an EV skateboard where different bodies can be bolted on top with little design modification. I could see them moving into the crossover market just by shortening and lowering the frame.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by aNoob7000 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:28AM
(#50414646)
The problem I see is with focus. Elon/Tesla seems to go after the next big thing every couple of years without a real plan.
I'm surprised that the markets have given Elon the amount of slack he's gotten. Once you merge Tesla into SpaceX, what's the plan? Tesla can't seem to roll out new vehicles with different body styling. Is robotics or AI the next big thing? What will happen to their car business? Will it just be CyberCabs? Will they become a mobile phone carrier?
The list of questions goes on and on. All this feels like a YC company looking for a new line of business because they just figured out their current line of business isn't all that great.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sneak on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:50AM
(#50414862)
I think it’s pretty obvious: sell the machines that replace humans as AI improves, and be ready to run that AI at massive scale.
First off is robotaxis and semis (99% of highway driving and 80-90% of city driving driver jobs have been very effectively replaced right now by machine, look at Waymo if you don’t believe Elon), and then Optimus for stuff that needs hands, like warehouse workers or other low-skill “move heavy things from here to there” jobs.
My six year old Tesla 3 just drove me from Vegas to LA, door to door, without me having to give it any control inputs. Not a lot of people seem to be paying attention to how good it is now.
I imagine Optimus will be a really big deal once they get it working as well as Teslas drive.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by oivey on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50415076)
> First off is robotaxis and semis (99% of highway driving and 80-90% of city driving driver jobs have been very effectively replaced right now by machine, look at Waymo if you don’t believe Elon)
Waymo hasn’t achieved that, though, right? They’re deployed in minimal markets, and I would be surprised if they had even replaced a majority of taxi rides where they are deployed.
Your trip still requires you to be at the wheel and conscious because the technology can’t be guaranteed to not try to murder you. How many miles do you go between driving accidents? Really asking: how many miles do you go between intervening with self driving?
The lack of complete market takeover is a sign the technology just isn’t there yet.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by FabHK on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:17PM
(#50415637)
Worth noting that Mercedes and BMW were the first to offer real L3 under specific conditions (as in: you could legally do something else, and the company would be responsible in case of accident), but they dropped it this year due to low demand and high cost. Some Chinese manufacturers offer it still.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:32PM
(#50415272)
I'm quite aware that the self driving capabilities of a Tesla is good, has been for a while.
So were is the revolution now?
Even the internal Tesla paper determined that the self driving market is not that big. There are clear issues no one seems to really like to hear:
People don't mind driving; A lot of people have to drive at the same time (which is not economic to catch this spike and then have all these cars with low utilization the rest of the day); We know the taxi/uber market.
Either it is so good that i literlay can do whatever i want while its driving and not getting car sick and move around, OR i'm sitting in a car seat anyway. I hate being not the driver, its a lot more boring than driving.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sneak on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:05PM
(#50415555)
Once the Tesla semi is shipping in greater numbers, I expect a lot of trucker jobs to disappear. Not all, and not even most, but still, tens or hundreds of thousands. (IIRC there are 3 or 4 million truckers in the usa.)
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by wildzzz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:13PM
(#50416087)
Waymo has very little market penetration where I live. I've only seen a handful of them driving around. When I went to visit San Francisco last month, I never realized how prevalent they are.
I'd say that only some places have seen city drivers replaced by Waymo to such an extent. As for self-driving semis, the market penetration is near zero. Maybe the tech is good enough but no one is buying it.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sobellian on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:56AM
(#50414930)
The line of business is fine. Tesla & SpaceX both make things people want. Neither cars nor rockets are being disrupted by AI. They could achieve good-to-great growth under stable, full-time, drug-free management. But if you feel you need a large amount of capital and you want to retain control of SpaceX and Tesla, bolting these startups onto them is a way to double down. It's just a shame to see those existing things get torched.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by inglor_cz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:00PM
(#50415980)
"Elon/Tesla seems to go after the next big thing every couple of years without a real plan."
I wouldn't consider this to be a weakness, necessarily. No plan survives a contact with the enemy, and the market is sorta-kinda war with unclear sides and developments. Plans tend to bind people to their old decisions, and make them beholden to sunk costs even if the world drifts in another direction.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:40AM
(#50414776)
Musk's companies are good at entering a stagnated industry and proving that it can work better if radically changed. But once the new concept is proved, they seem kinda spent, a pivot makes sense to me.
It'll be interesting to see if they can do well in places where there aren't a bunch of stagnant incumbents to upset. I'm sure Musk would love to edgelord his way through a conversation where he offends a bunch of people by implying that they have been doing asteroid mining all wrong, those idiots, and then go prove himself right, but there's just nobody doing that.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:43AM
(#50414802)
It's not "crazy," it's flim flam. It's what Elizabeth Holmes would've look like had she bought a health tech firm before starting the Thernos scam so she could pump her stock to a P/E ratio over 300 instead of scamming naïve noob tech investors.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by yoyohello13 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:47AM
(#50414827)
That roadster demo proved to me they are not serious about making EVs anymore. Strapping rockets to a car makes an interesting spectacle, but is utterly impractical for a real consumer vehicle.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ajay-b on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:00PM
(#50414965)
To be fair, I did not believe for a moment that this was a serious idea. Instead it looks a stunt to be performed, not a serous consumer feature. Surely? Such a feature would never pass FMVSS muster.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jeffnappi on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:06PM
(#50415040)
Truth. However it's pretty great marketing, fairly certain every car enthusiast on the planet has seen that demonstration. Eyeballs that likely can't be bought otherwise. The flying version will never be made for a human occupant, but if they do make a few they will be collectors items.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by yoyohello13 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:25PM
(#50415211)
The only thing that demo proved to me is that I will never buy a Tesla. I’m even in the market for a new car and I’d be interested in getting an EV.
Imagine if they put all that engineering effort to building an affordable, reliable, EV? Man that would be something to behold. But America is in the meme economy now, nobody cares about real products for real people. Just hype generators that appeal to the 1%.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by grandpajoey on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:27PM
(#50415225)
Was it great marketing? Did it move the needle on sales? That’s what marketing is supposed to do. I see Musk do dumb stuff all the time and all it makes me think is “I will never buy a product from this scam artist”.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by dzhiurgis on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:00PM
(#50417809)
Probably not good - if you are buying Roadster you'll never get flying model as thats for friends and family, despite car absolutely mogging everything else in the market.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by fuzzythinker on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:14PM
(#50419249)
Maybe not the needle on sales, but the needle on stock valuation. The moment the company stops making dreams is the moment the stock start to fall down to a car company valuation.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Ekaros on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:54PM
(#50415460)
Jaguar also did extremely well spread marketing campaign. It is really questionable if it moves units. Same goes for this one. You might get notoriety but that doesn't always translate to sales. And I am pretty sure no one was unaware of Tesla at that point.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by londons_explore on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:53AM
(#50414897)
They have to move out of the EV business. Their shareholders have eyed up the big potential returns from optimus/cybercab/next-moonshot and valued the company sky high as a result.
When you have a sky high valuation, spending capital on something that just gives steady returns is a net negative for everyone. You have to put all the capital into the moonshots.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by grandpajoey on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:01PM
(#50414980)
It’s pretty absurd to base such a high valuation on things that don’t exist. Not only do they not exist, they’ve missed every deadline put out by Musk for over a decade. This is where you put the CEO in prison in a functioning society.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jknoepfler on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:16PM
(#50415142)
Why would Tesla pivoting seem strange? They've lost the global EV race, they've sabotaged their American market and they haven't done anything but weak publicity stunts in years. Their profits are tanking, their brand is toxic and their prospects are dim. That doesn't scream 'bright future' to me.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by gim89 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:25PM
(#50415212)
> My gut feeling says they are trying to move out of the EV business as crazy as that may seem to us normals.
Expect this trend to continue. I've started seeing it all over across different industries. Consumer based businesses are being abandoned to instead chase the bigger numbers from B2B sales and premium consumers.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by bilater on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:38PM
(#50415331)
It's no secret to anyone paying attention. The EV business is basically dead, and they're getting their asses kicked by Chinese competition.
Robotics is the new focus. Depending on who you ask (and how well they execute), this will either be another grift for bagholders or exactly the right move to capture a massive emerging industry.
I do think people are massively underestimating robotics. The convergence of LLMs and robotics will be the next great wave of AI, unlocking an enormous boom in productivity across the economy.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by troupo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:17AM
(#50414517)
Elon had an insane talent of finding the right people with wild moonshot ideas to run his companies while he was getting the credit and the limelight.
Then he got older, got into politics and fully bought into the marketing about himself. He thinks he's a genius and that everything he touches turns to gold.
Well... Turns out stuff works as long as he is out of the loop and doesn't make any direct decisions.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by swiftcoder on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:29AM
(#50414653)
> Turns out stuff works as long as he is out of the loop and doesn't make any direct decisions
This is not unique to Musk - many tech CEOs learn this the hard way when they start meddling in the day-to-day. Bezos built an empire, but the projects he took personal control of (like FirePhone) tended to be unmitigated disasters.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by swiftcoder on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:03PM
(#50415009)
My understanding (admittedly second-hand), is that he handed down the famous "malloc for the internet" requirement, and mostly left the team to their own devices past that point
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jm4 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:29PM
(#50415245)
So is at least half the US auto industry, if not all. Modern Chinese cars look great and you get a lot of bang for your buck. Even without CCP subsidies keeping prices low they would eat up other manufacturers if priced similarly.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by modeless on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:26PM
(#50415711)
The Model Y outsells every Chinese EV in China. It's every other US manufacturer who would be doomed if the China EV tariff went away. That's why the tariff was imposed by Biden, not Trump.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by modeless on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:40PM
(#50416953)
Of course BYD sells more cars overall. The point is that the Model Y and Model 3 are competitive with BYD models even in their home market and would continue to sell even if BYD came to America.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jdross on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:20AM
(#50414566)
FSD that actually works and the massively popular in live markets robotaxi service are the obvious answer to “big-deal things that came after this CTO left”
$2B cybertruck failure barely registers vs how impactful FSD has been on model Y / 3 sales. Tesla is supply constrained again, with multi-month waits for the model Y L edition
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by gre on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:02PM
(#50414994)
There are so many robotaxis in austin. Something like 300 waymos and 350 Teslas? I love waymo and wont step into a robotaxi, but people definitely are riding them.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:42PM
(#50415364)
FSD is old and the promises too. Its not new its not whatever its just very slowly progressing to what was promised and it still doesn't show up as the big deal.
Wasn't there even multiply lawsuits against Tesla because the payed for FSD didn't work? Didn't exist? Wasn't supported by the Hardware build in?
2016 did Tesla announce that every future car has the hardware for FSD. 2016!
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by l1tany11 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:02PM
(#50415994)
They update it all the time. It’s not old, it’s new. Yes it finally is starting to achieve the promise of 10 years ago… and the market is recognizing it and they are calling out the subscription growth on the earnings calls. 67% yoy growth this year.
Most people don’t care that some guy paid $10k for a feature on a $80k car 10 years ago that didn’t achieve its crazy promise. They care that they can pay $99 today for a feature that blows away their expectations, AND is good enough to not just be a surprising novelty but something they use long term.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by l1tany11 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:12PM
(#50417940)
I’m not saying I would. I’m saying that 1.7 million subscribers currently do, and that number is growing rapidly. It’s also a big reason why people buy the cars. People legitimately talk about and consider it from a safety perspective. Drive to the ER, that kind of thing, as well as a luxury feature.
People don’t like driving, and they hire(d) people to do it for them. There’s even a word for it: chauffeur. Now the car does it itself. Yes the chauffeur could do other things as well, but you can’t pay a chauffeur $99 a month.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by stasomatic on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @01:09PM
(#50443920)
Have you tried FSD?
I don't have a Tesla, my uncle has a Model S. I met up with him recently for lunch, I told the car to drive us to a seafood place, it did most of the work and parked itself. This is commuting. And, it didn't roll through stop signs.
I like myself a Cooper or a GTI for the twisties, but that's a different thing.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Levitating on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:23AM
(#50414601)
Isn't it completely overshadowed by Waymo? From what I've heard Waymo is more profitable and has substantially fewer accidents due to better technology.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:08PM
(#50415064)
Waymo's total is probably 5000 or fewer. But they operate 24/7. They are providing half a million commercial rides a week.
Tesla hasn't got the scale or operating consistency to even truly call itself a commercial service. Elon keeps claiming the Tesla will overwhelm everybody in the whole fleet will wake up one day and be a moneymaking taxi machine.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:58AM
(#50414954)
Tesla's taxi business isn't real. Waymo has been transparent about how their cars handle situations that require human intervention. Waymo's most important technology isn't superior sensors, it's the ability to be truly autonomous without continuous oversight, even when putting a human in the loop to make a decision. Humans never drive a Waymo remotely, because that's dangerous and stupid. Tesla won't say how their remote intervention works, but it's probably a sketchy as a Chinese Robo taxi but without the Chinese 5G network that actually is low latency.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by mbajkowski on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:39AM
(#50414763)
Tesla has had a massive surge in cybercabs in Austin over the last few weeks. I would venture to say they have surpassed the number of Waymos over here. Don't have any numbers to back this up though. As for being profitable, it seems the cost of a cybercab should be much less than a Waymo.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by schneems on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:06PM
(#50415048)
From the outside in this is how I see it (being in Austin which seems to be ground zero for a lot of the testing):
Waymo is betting that cutting zero corners and being rigorous will pay off down the line. They seem best in class.
Zoox seems to be betting that reducing time to get passengers in and out while providing a novel platform will be a differentiator. More sensors than Tesla but fewer cars than both the others.
Cybercab seems to be about cutting cost (and corners) wherever they thing they can get away from it and betting cheap will win the day (sort of like a discount airline). This assumes they're not doing something O(N) expensive behind the scenes, like having every ride monitored by a human operator in another country.
I remember some company dragging a person for awhile and the car not realizing. I'm worried tesla will find itself in a situation like that (or another edge case). I feel safer being around a Waymo as a pedestrian than a cybercab. I even had a Waymo stop for me at a pedestrian crossing when I was waiting for it to go by (I wasn't trying to cross).
In the long run Waymo will have to figure out how to have a cheaper platform and Tesla will have to toe the cheap/good-enough line. Zoox is still seemingly unlaunched so IDK about them. Time will tell.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:46PM
(#50415390)
Interesting overview. And on who will win, on one hand, as you said, Waymo's platform is better, and they just need to continue focusing on developing it cheaper. But on the other hand, Tesla has the volume in that you can already buy a car with FSD (although, we're talking about taxis, not consumer cars, but Tesla has assembly lines ready to produce 100k of taxis). Hmm, hard call...
... just looked it up, Waymo's 6th gen hardware is estimated to cost $20k per vehicle. That's getting down there. And if they ever do even higher volumes, will probably go down further:
https://x.com/fchollet/status/2023522267846815874
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by schneems on Sunday November 08, 2026 @10:21PM
(#50420638)
Honestly, it's hard to say.
> you can already buy a car with FSD
Which did things like drive off roads into parked cars and killed people. I feel like if Tesla hadn't been selling "full self driving" for years, the trust would be higher "no guys, we promise it's actually full self driving this time for real now" just doesn't have the same ring.
On the rollout:
It's notable that Tesla is building their own rideshare while Waymo is partnering with Uber. Tesla has the vertical integrated benefit of getting all profits but Waymo doesn't have to handle new user acquisition they just peel off existing requests and can roll out faster.
Tesla might "pivot" later to selling the 2 seater cybercab as a cheap base to competitors like waymo. It seems like Tesla has an identity crisis. They don't know how to be a consumer car platform (cybertruck halting production) they torched their PR with the green base that made them successful in the first place. Now sort of feels like a startup trying to "pivot" to find product market fit instead of a mature, well run company with solid strategic vision. There are a lot of jobs on the line so I hope they figure something out.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by computerdork on Monday November 09, 2026 @12:01AM
(#50421269)
Yeah, agreed about Tesla's identity crisis. Tesla (and Elon) are really making a lot of mistakes in the past couple of years and at least regarding creating a great EV, they feel like they have lost their edge. They don't look as good as they did compared to what's currently out there and they don't seem to be innovating as much. Think Elon isn't interested enough in the type of cars normal people buy anymore, or changing the world with a low cost EV.
And yeah, FSD has been misrepresented for a long time now, but yeah, what I've been hearing it is finally getting really good. It's not completely hands free, but it's supposed to be very usable, and keep reading in reviews that this is the one feature that sets Tesla's EV's apart.
... And actually, on Uber, only in Austin (where said you are) and Atlanta does Waymo use Uber. Yeah, I used to live in the SF Bay Area, and had used Waymo a couple of times directly from their own app. It was a very natural experience. And recently stumbled upon an article that even in Austin and Atlanta, Waymo is going to discontinue using Uber in 2028.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by underseacables on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:25AM
(#50414622)
It was very strange, in the beginning people celebrated Tesla, they raved about it, the sales were great, but then as soon as the politics got involved, suddenly it's all turned negative.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by lanstin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:36AM
(#50414741)
The early Tesla fans are politically engaged woke people. Having to settle for new Leaf now but in some ways it’s nicer than Model 3. And more friendly to my kids networks of ethnically diverse trans and queer friends and partners. And less scary for the many immigrant communities in my neighborhood.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by y0ssar1an on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:43AM
(#50414788)
Elon's cognitive decline from drug addiction affected both his business and political decision making. pre-ketamine Elon delivered the Falcon 9, Model 3/Y, and Starlink. post-ketamine Elon gave us Cybertruck, Starship (aka the SpaceX Cybertruck), and a bunch of fake products like the flying roadster, humanoid robots, and Cybercab.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by icegreentea2 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:55AM
(#50414915)
"Politics got involved" from the beginning. In the context of USA politics, being an EV company while your CEO talked about how important electrification was to stave off the effects of human caused climate change is 100% a politically coded act.
What happened wasn't "politics got involved", what happened was that CEO started talking other politics.
And to say that "politics got involved" is a ridiculously passive statement. Elon has full control over how he publicly acts. Politics "didn't get involved" from 2022 onwards, Elon's publicly articulated political views significantly shifted, AND THEN Elon personally led massive organizational changes in the federal government.
Regardless of if you support or oppose DOGE, it's completely dishonest to wall off his actions at DOGE into a separate category of acts that you can clearly separate from his business.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by pessimizer on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:34PM
(#50415292)
Musk has been consistently vile the entire time, it's just that liberals always think they were always right, even when they had the opposite opinion five minutes ago and were advocating that people who have their current opinion be fired and arrested for treason. He must have changed they say.
Even now, they have no idea how to criticize him because they adore the blindingly wealthy, opinionated, and willing to use that wealth to force that opinion on others (it's upper-middle-class sainthood.) His biggest crime somehow is that he allowed you to say what you wanted on twitter. Just like they turned on Assange, it's always telling that their consistent enemy is democracy. Democracy is directly offensive to the credentials that they dedicated their lives and compromised their personal integrity to get from wealthy people and institutions.
They're offended by Musk because they wanted to show their Teslas off, and to talk about the projects that their company partnered with Tesla on at parties, and to be proud of their kids getting named Tesla scholars and getting Tesla genius grants. They can't be because he's obviously a slimeball in a way that they can't overlook and ignore and mock the victims of (in return for money and status.) That's it. They, however, are currently overlooking the crimes of their favored billionaires and employers, so have no language to articulate their resentment of him that doesn't also incriminate themselves. So it's just this insane inarticulate id-explosion.
Reminds me of people being embarrassed about working at Arthur Anderson or Lehman Brothers at parties. "I worked in accounting; I worked in insurance," they would say. Their mothers used to gush about them, and now they don't even mention the names of the companies, like a father who died in prison. All Musk's properties are like that now, as well as Google, Facebook, Amazon, etc.. Musk's properties still actually even come out better than other tech slop because they all ostensibly have some material purpose other than extracting rents from normal people through deceit and by doing the least work possible.
I used to have a name for people who can't see this dynamic: "emoluments libs." They were the libs during Trump's first term who kept saying "The Democrats aren't going after Trump for profiting from his office because they're too afraid." No, dude. They're not going after him because they have the same deals with the same people, and everything that they would go after him for implicates them too. After you avoid the obvious, you're left with impeaching a totally corrupt guy for not arming Ukraine hard enough to threaten Russia hard enough because they wouldn't cooperate in uncovering the blatant corruption of his predecessor. If that's the best you've got, a thing that sabotages one of your own prominent politicians (who was destined to win the next presidency by a hair), and highlights an evil thing you're currently doing in Ukraine, the other alternatives must be really horrible i.e. would send you to jail with him. Their only bright spot is that they hoped it would take (a notoriously disobedient) Biden out so The Atlantic libs could push one of their soulless golems Harris or Buttigieg into the presidency.
I have to be honest. I'm part of the ancient left that is celebrating the imminent death of the middle class, because it's their weird psychology that is killing us. I encourage their replacement with AI wherever it is possible, my criticism of AI is that it is still not good enough to do it, and if the middle class have anything to say about it it will never be. They will ruin it by either coddling the owners of AI to total flaccid laziness or threatening the owners of AI to make them cripple it, but they will make sure that they will maintain a lawn by any means necessary. They will, however, never give a shit about the uninsured unless they get sick.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jazzypants on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:28AM
(#50414645)
There are millions of Americans like me who will never step foot in one because of their association with Elon Musk.
That's an insane negative attribute that Waymo doesn't have to worry about. I hate the Alphabet guys too, but not to the same extent of completely boycotting all their products (yet).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by parineum on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:42AM
(#50414783)
> There are millions of Americans like me who will never step foot in one because of their association with Elon Musk.
You guys have to realize at some point that you're not a significant part of the market. There are a lot of people who don't particularly like musk but the amount that would never use a cybercab isn't a significant part of a 300m person market.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jazzypants on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:43AM
(#50414801)
Yeah, sure. That's why Tesla sales have fallen for two consecutive years ever since he exposed himself as a fascist. You keep telling yourself that, buddy.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by losvedir on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:44AM
(#50414814)
Speaking as someone who follows the NFL, people will forgive all kinds of horrendous behavior if the player's team is winning. It's easy to say things in the abstract like "won't buy a Tesla" because most people aren't really shopping for a car all that often. But if the cybertaxi works and is cheap, then I would guess a lot of people won't be sticking to their proclaimed values. That said, I have my doubts that cybercab will really work all that well.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jazzypants on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:47AM
(#50414834)
I was a Cleveland Browns fans for literally my entire life until they signed Deshaun Watson. I watched every single game, but now I haven't watched a game in like four years. I was already concerned about the effects of CTE, but I couldn't go on cheering for a team that knowingly signed a rapist.
You should surround yourself with people who are willing to stand up for their convictions.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by losvedir on Monday November 09, 2026 @09:42AM
(#50426321)
Heh, easy to do when you're a Browns fan. But he was one of the examples I had in mind, actually, and I fully expect that if the Browns were going to the Superbowl with him a lot fewer people would take such a principled stand.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by pessimizer on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:48AM
(#50414847)
> Cybercab seems to have had a very promising start, metrics are good. This seems far more of a political hate piece than one based on any data.
What? This is just a political hate piece because of the potential of something that just started five minutes ago? You're damning Tesla with faint praise yourself and don't even know it.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Zigurd on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:12PM
(#50415102)
Lack of lidar isn't the biggest problem. Nor will adding it make Tesla's cabs suddenly reliable and useful. They don't have Google's geospatial data, they don't have the remote intervention infrastructure, they haven't expanded it across multiple cities and built out the service infrastructure to clean and repair their fleet. They don't have the financial history to go to Pimco for term loans paid out of cash flow.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ckdarby on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:25AM
(#50414623)
Is this a paid piece behind the scenes by JB Straubel? It reads exactly as someone who was paid or got exclusive access to write something to over highlight someone.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by martincsweiss on Sunday November 08, 2026 @06:57PM
(#50419101)
They aren't on par - but people are irrational and the world has a lot of detail. Therefore, it's hard to do credit assignment on why Tesla is making fewer hit products.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sowhat1 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:34AM
(#50414714)
Exceptional success is both timing and having an exceptional team. But yea, let's keep attributing it to great man theory, because that's more digestible and people like to mythologize a single person.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jdiff on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:15PM
(#50415132)
Your first link comes from Tesla themselves, and the second smells strongly AI generated. If I search for the "best selling car 2026" and don't lead the search engine by feeding it "tesla model y", I see none of those results.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by phyzix5761 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:28PM
(#50415237)
When I google "best selling car 2026" my results show Tesla Model Y. I suspect maybe google is playing a bit of the "confirmation bias results" game for the both of us based on our past search history.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by jdiff on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:45PM
(#50415845)
Maybe. One of the links was to a Tesla Reddit thread making the same claim you are, but with people in the comments pointing out that there was no sourcing provided. I don't think Google's algorithm is smart enough to notice the pro-Musk subreddit wasn't chugging the kool-aid for once.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by ajay-b on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:57AM
(#50414936)
You make an excellent point. So long as the stock of a company continues to rise, or at best stable, is the only thing that seems to matter. Regardless of customer service, quality, etc. it's the stock price. I think we have seen that enough across other companies to reach some conclusion on the assumption.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by kakacik on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:02PM
(#50415531)
Its more about lack of morals than IQ per se, seeing them only convenient when aligned. Plenty of smart folks with dubious morals when it actually counts out there
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by l1tany11 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:51PM
(#50415900)
You mean when sales were lower? Sales numbers are pretty clear. They are up every year, along with the price.
The slate is a joke. They said they need to sell 80k per year to break even. The maverick is currently only double that in its 6th year, after a major mid cycle refresh, basically without competition. Now the slate is going to appear with less utility, fewer features, 205 miles of range and sell in comparable volumes? What a joke.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by mkl95 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:03PM
(#50415011)
Elon Musk is the most successful man in modern history at privatizing profits and socializing losses. Tesla's decline has little to do with JB Straubel, Elon simply got bored and started toying with the business, leading to the disastrous Cybertruck and other failures.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hbarka on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:04PM
(#50415025)
MKBHD made a good observation about the Cybercab[1]. The way the doors are designed, you will get high incidents of “collision with an open door of a stationary vehicle” also known as a dooring accident. If it was intended to be a robotaxi, why didn’t they just make the door swing up in a vertical plane rather than butterfly out like that. Another impractical vanity door feature just like with the Model X doors. Most likely conjured up by none other than the boss himself, designer of the Cybertruck.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by Grombobulous on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:09PM
(#50415074)
If we are to be charitable to Tesla, new car development isn’t like new tech product development. The shortest possible period of time to develop a new car is probably about 4-7 years.
I’d also say that the YL is something of a new product and a very successful one, even though it’s more of a long wheelbase variant.
Still, I agree with the thesis of the article. Where are the smart decisions?
The Cybertruck could have been a home run product for the US market, but Tesla’s own hubris about that market really buried it. They focused on styling and marketed it as a cyberpunk lawless society survival vehicle where angry mobs of cyberpsychos can’t break your window.
Hello, Tesla, you needed to put the truck in NFL advertisements and show how it’s going to be amazing for your blue collar cosplay sessions and how it’s going to get 300 miles of range while towing a boat (which it was supposed to but it didn’t).
The Cybercab being a two-door coupe is insane. How did that pass the first design discussion? Look at how the Waymo Zeekr cab is designed, look at a how a London cab can fit like 5-6 people in a normal-sized car, look at the Nissan NV200 as NYC’s exclusive taxi from 2012-2018.
None of these are two seater low entry coupes.
Where is the full size 3-row family veggie? Where is the European city car?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sheepscreek on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:19PM
(#50415165)
This is an opinion piece - there’s no factual basis (nor any facts quoted) to support this narrative at all. Plus, key things missing from the calculus include:
- COVID, that put a strain on manufacturing during lockdowns and the eventual worldwide supply chain disruptions
- the new administration and its anti EV stance
- emergence of AI
- betting the company on Optimus (product) and Robotaxi (service)
How much could JB Staubel have influenced Tesla during these times is anybody’s guess.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by sheepscreek on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:03PM
(#50415534)
And like the author, are you suggesting that is because JB left the company?
Why would him being there have changed anything? What ‘hit product’ could JB have launched that you would have bought given everything that happened with Tesla.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:38PM
(#50415332)
Even EV Car makers are making now what the Tesla Roadster should have been.
This is the weirdest thing ever by far. Why would you not just build a Tesla supercar? Why 2028?
You know what I bet? They are so dependend on what Elon Musk does and says and decides, that stuff like Twitter, DOGE and alllll the other garbage he did on the side, just stalled everything.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by modeless on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:40PM
(#50415796)
Sure, if you don't count the redesigned Model Y as a new product, with the successful synchronized global factory changeover. Or the Y L, backordered until well into next year. And you don't count Semi which is being delivered to customers from its new factory right now. And you don't count the Cybercab even though hundreds are giving rides today. And you don't count the Robotaxi service even as it passes Waymo for number of cars and miles ridden per week in Austin.
Yeah, if you disqualify or assume imminent failure of all of those, then zero successful new products.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hn_submit on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:23PM
(#50416198)
The CyberCab won't work out since it has to be truly self driving, as opposed to Tesla's Full Self Driving (Supervised) which is merely a driving aid with the driver responsible if something goes wrong.
That means it will have to be more capable a driver than most human beings and that seems unlikely at the moment if you look at how well FSD works today. Yes, it works okay most of the time, but that's just not good enough for a self-driving taxi cab without a steering wheel or controls. And Tesla can't have thousands of remote taxi-drivers standing by all the time. That would make the service uneconomical and a loss leader.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by dubeye on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:36PM
(#50417568)
it only needs to be better than an average human. isn't the crash rate already better?
some say the bar is higher due to sentiment, but it's insurance companies who will decide, and they are more interested in the numbers than sentiment. Your view that it has to be better than 'most' humans doesn't make any kind of insurance sense
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by hn_submit on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:20PM
(#50419306)
Like I said: with FSD you're responsible. That will not be the case when a CyberCab kills an infant running across the road.
No doubt SpaceX will try to defer responsibility in its T&C's, but that won't fly IMHO. The manufacturer will be held responsible (or the cab company if they're lucky, but either way a fatal accident will mean the service will be curbed or halted).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by bakies on Sunday November 08, 2026 @05:37PM
(#50418202)
I don't really think it's about insurance at all but not letting killer robots on the streets. The insurance for a FLEET of killer robots isn't going to be cheap. They are all bad drivers if they're average.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by stasomatic on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @01:20PM
(#50444094)
One example. I am insured by Progressive in the States. Progressive (and others) have a rate for safe drivers, they monitor your driving behavior via their app or a device they provide you. So if you text and drive, exceed speed limits, your rate goes up. Tesla FSD obeys all traffic laws, the few times I have been in one. Gotta be in their "Chill" mode though.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by vlovich123 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @08:27PM
(#50419808)
Everyone else is getting the counter-argument wrong. The counter-argument is that the robots are better than humans in some cases, but the places they are worse they're worse in a non-human way and react in non-human ways. It's precisely that that will make the risk worse. Also, when an insurance company insures a driver, the lawsuit is against the driver and they're most out what a single bad driver can do. When the lawsuit is against CyberCabs, it's against all cabs and the most they're out is a class action lawsuit against all CyberCabs + negligence etc + Tesla has deeper pockets.
So on principle, you're probably right. In practice it's easy to see why a corporation running a fleet of self-driving vehicles would have a different insurance profile than randos driving around.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB...
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Monday November 09, 2026 @02:02PM
(#50430019)
From the HBO Documentary Films Musk documentary released 2026:
"Clearly, there was never any real effort to make battery swap actually work because the value to Tesla was not, you know, as an actual viable way to drive adoption. It was a way to earn ZEV credits. Once California changed its rules and insisted that Tesla prove that customers were swapping batteries, Tesla abandoned the program. But Tesla had already banked over 100 million dollars from its phantom battery swaps. Since its founding, Tesla padded its bottom line with more than 11 billion dollars in government carbon credits."
Perhaps Tesla's most successful product was carbon credits
"The electric automaker earned $10.7 billion from selling credits created by government climate programs, a total that accounted for a third of Tesla's profits over the last decade, according to an analysis of securities filings by POLITICO's E&E News. In the first nine months of 2024, some 43 percent of its net income came from those credits, which Tesla sold to rival carmakers after exceeding climate mandates in California and elsewhere."
But Musk has enough avenues to spin things left and right and bury any losses in the process his DOGE assault helped a lot bury some things already) so he'll do that.
For robotaxi, the last 2 years has shown us that FSD 14 has solved the really hard parts of autonomy, so the next logical step is some percentage of people deciding not to own their next car and instead only getting around by Robotaxi.
This is not a bad play by the market. They're poised to absorb some amount of the costs that people are currently paying to (A) own a car, (B) pay interest on the loan, and (C) pay for car insurance. And C does not carry meaningful risk as autonomous vehicles are de-facto safer drivers.
Then the market is kind of putting their faith in giving Tesla 10 years to apply the same playbook to humanoid robots and all of the jobs that that _could_ replace (remains to be seen how capable they can actually make it and what the economics will look like).
>Our fleet of Model Y and Cybercab vehicles offers autonomous rides in cities across the U.S. You can already hail a car in Austin, Dallas, Fort Worth, Houston, Miami, Orlando and Tampa with more rides arriving in more cities soon.
https://autonomixinvestor.com/robotaxi-tracker/
> The ADS was proceeding straight through a work zone on a street and drove over a pothole at approximately 29MPH. The ADS had two riders present in the vehicle. One customer alleged they sought medical care.
> Summary: The ADS was stopped at an intersection stop sign, waiting to turn left and yielding to crossing traffic. An SUV that was stopped behind traffic straight across at a stop sign drove into the oncoming lane passed traffic. The SUV then drove up to the intersection, stopped, and proceeded straight, crossing into the lane and path of a passenger vehicle from their right cross street. The front of the passenger vehicle collided with the right side of the SUV and the SUV's airbags were deployed. Post collision, the SUV's front was pushed into the ADS's lane and collided into the front of the ADS. The ADS was pushed backward, causing its rear to collide with the front of another SUV that was stopped behind it. The ADS had one rider present in the vehicle. The driver of the passenger vehicle from the original collision was transported to the hospital for unknown reason.
For total autonomous fleet miles driven Tesla is years away from Waymo.
Both stacks can succeed, but for Google it's not existential fight so I don't think they will.
So when I go for a coffee, I don't go to the place where it's a dollar less expensive because it has a robot...
I'm not convinced we wanted to be helped by a robot, even if it does the same thing.
So the economics might be there.... But that's not the whole story, this isn't automating a production line...
The real incentive is that Musk won’t let one of his companies “fail”. It will be absorbed into a larger more successful one and keep delivering “investor value”.
Tesla fan boys still say that NO ONE else can do self driving despite plenty of companies which do like waymo or Nvidia, Mercedes and BMW.
Then they tell you that no one will own a car anymore but we already have Taxi/Uber and the world hasn't changed much and they complelty ignore basics like traffic spikes for workers.
You don't get good utilization when you can handle everything and low utilization means a LOT of space for waiting cars.
Its the same spiel with Optimus but there people seem to be quite enough and do understand that china is ahead.
Lets ignore the fever dream of Space-Xs payload story...
Absolutely no one is saying that. The bad faith is people saying that Robotaxi is doomed because it's vision-only. It may end up not being the best approach, but it's looking to be good enough to be performant and still be one of the larger players in the market.
> Then they tell you that no one will own a car anymore but we already have Taxi/Uber and the world hasn't changed much and they complelty ignore basics like traffic spikes for workers.
I'm not saying this either. This is like saying that busses and trains are vaporware because they can't serve 100% of transportation needs.
Some peoples' lifestyles will adapt to this change or already fit within it. A lot of people's won't. Over time, they will gradually close the gaps and/or people will change their own lives to fit it if they'd like to save money on transportation.
Does selfdriving work? yes. Is robotaxi a real business? Yes.
Thats not the point. The point here is the valuation of Tesla because of it and thats not justifiable. Despite the fact that Tesla originally sold FSD so that everyone can leverage this feature.
So either Tesla builds a cheap Robotaxi and floods the market as a car company OR Tesla becomes a competitor on a competitive market.
Why would people adjust their lifestyles based on a Robotaxi? We have already Taxis and Ubers.
The only chance for 'people changing their lifestyles' is if a Robotaxi is always available and A LOT cheaper which then again breaks the whole valuation of Tesla.
To actually switch to it myself, I'd need robotaxi to deliver:
- p99 5 minute wait for ride hailing, including at peak times - 24/7 operation
Longer 200-500 mile trips would also be nice, although then you get into needing robotic and/or wireless charging pads at SCs for road trips to work.
Also, there are a lot of ways some sort of subscription service could be handled. Maybe included usage, maybe I pay to have it ready in my driveway between 6am and 9am (but still to where I don't own it / need to personally insure it). Either way, it won't be hard for it to undercut my current car expenses if I can cut out car insurance.
None of the above is de-facto impossible with automation in the space. In fact, more reliable ops would be easier because the company can predict and dynamically scale how many are running at any given time, purely limited by (non-human) capital, instead of needing to increase their bid for human drivers to accept rides when demand is high.
Although the question is indeed if they can do all of this economically in a crowded space; I don't disagree that $1T is an insane valuation in any respect. Elon's umbrella of companies is all funny money to me.
Tax and uber are at around 2.5 Euro per km so 250 cents per km.
Tbh I thought before already that this not an easy story to sell, but the price point is between 2.5-5 already and if you remove 16% of the driver, you only get down to 2.1-4.2
You can't tell me there's a rational reason there's a common headline of Tesla missing forecast and guidance but still going up after earning report
Indeed. What I find particularly grating is that Tesla seems rather overpriced, but if SpaceX acquires it, it'll provide the Tesla investors with a nice exit. (And SpaceX of course is a very long shot that's in any number of retirement portfolios by virtue of its rash index inclusion.)
They probably also want to get into the military energy storage market (a.k.a. "tactical microgrids"), but they need more vertical integration for that. Right now they don't make their own cells, so the defense contractors that build ruggedized batteries skip them and go straight to sourcing from the cell manufacturers.
(Fun fact: Tesla's Gigafactories as physical spaces produce a ton of battery cells, but Tesla itself doesn't. Tesla leases space in its Gigafactories to cell manufacturers like Panasonic, who actually produce the cells, so that Tesla can then directly consume some of the cells produced into battery packs, without any intervening logistics costs.)
Not really. Tesla, like most automakers, purchases most of its battery cells from other companies. In recent years they have started to manufacture their own cells as well, with their 4680 cell manufacturing line at "Giga Texas". But this is still a small portion of the cells they use globally.
But at the same time, maybe they are doing the correct analysis.
"If we stay here and grow fat the others will eat us. To infinity and beyond!".
100 years ago your business was your warehouse or your locomotive. These days, maybe your business is defined by your rate of change?
This is the most absurd and also true observation I've read on HN in a while.
As the rate of technological process accelerates, maybe it becomes possible to justify a company's valuation on a never-ending succession of "And then..."s.
Granted, that ended poorly in terms of stock prices for the .com bubble, but mostly for companies that weren't financially solvent enough to withstand higher interest rates + a public market downturn.
And it took a conflation of multiple events to pop that bubble (Asian instability, moderate US interest rate hikes, 9/11/2001).
Not anymore, I guess.
The only reason why Payload into space increased from 1000t to 3000t is Starlink.
And there they have also massive problems for scaling. Base Station is expensive and they have to replace the Satelites every 5 years. Withouth the v3 and rocket big enough to send it up, they can't scale properly.
If they then scale, the rate of atmosphere poisening through STarlink will increase.
Starlink was the seed customer for unused gen1 launch capacity.
Space datacenters are probably intended to be the gen2 seed.
Because SpaceX needs to frequently toss rockets up to be able to iterate on them and scale manufacturing, and they'd rather use the (high-risk) payload capacity for something profitable while doing that.
But as a net result, SpaceX can afford to launch mass that others can't, because it wins two ways: whatever profits that launched mass produces + iterating rocket design and manufacturing.
Per Google finance, Tesla's market cap today is $1.42T. Toyota's is ¥48.72T, or $307B USD. So that would make Tesla's market cap about 4.6X Toyota's.
[1]: https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/TSE-7203/bonds/
[2]: https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/NASDAQ-TSLA/bonds/
But Toyota still makes 3x Teslas revenue.
I'm guessing some of the 9x difference is speculative and some is because Tesla is all in on EVs/etc, which are doing well, and Toyota is still very much in ICEs, which aren't doing as well.
Even then, he is losing to Chinese competition. It's pure incompetence.
Proofs? tesla exists in China and cable to compete there. There is no ford or GM in it's US shape, only sub brands that loosing ground.
If Chinese vehicles were allowed into the US, they would certainly eat all the other vehicle manufacturers, except for customers who care about quality. And that’s where Toyota would be able to continue to survive.
But even Toyota would lose a ton of sales, because prices here in the US are so, so much higher than they should be. You can just look at prices in Europe and Canada to see that.
I don't know what to make of these numbers. Are all defects the same? (I can't be bothered to look).
What I can tell you is we owned a Model Y in the US for 3+ years. It was great, we had one small seat problem (which mobile service promptly fixed). The news is full of customer horror stories from Tesla, and not only did we like ours, our wide network of friends had many with similar experience.
I now live in Australia and have a Zeekr 7x (Chinese EV). My in-laws have an MG. The place is swimming with BYDs, Geely's, GWMs, etc. The idea that Chinese cars are low quality and people won't like them is laughable. No - they are cars people like at a price they are willing to pay.
We've only had our Zeekr 4 months but so far its been great and the build quality seems MUCH higher than the MY. It's quieter, the trim is much nicer, its generally great.
Letting Chinese cars into the US will decimate the US auto industry. No question about it, they will be reduced to light trucks for a time but even that probably isn't defensible.
And on that criteria, at the time that survey was done, I do think that Tesla probably may well have been the best car manufacturer in China. But perhaps things have changed quickly there?
I also think that Tesla quality has significantly declined overall as time has progressed. They’ve been more about trying to be the new thing, whatever that is.
I am also convinced that if Chinese car manufacturers are let into this country, that will kill the low to midrange market for any of the traditional car manufacturers. People are willing to put up with a lot of crap, if they can get it at a lower price — witness the rise of Amazon, Walmart, and Temu. And China can guarantee that they will always have the lowest prices, with lower labor costs, lower government environmental scrutiny, and active government subsidization. Tariffs on Chinese cars will need to be super high — maybe 100% or more? And even that isn’t going to save the car manufacturers in this country.
China can attack the high-end luxury market, but they’re going to have a lot more friction there, simply because people buying cars in that bracket won’t want to be seen as being cheap. China is going to have a long road ahead of them, but when they can deliver Lexus and Mercedes quality at bargain basement prices, there will be some people that they can peel away from the more well-established brands.
Meanwhile, companies like Polstar will do well, because many people don’t realize (or care) that brand is largely owned by Geely and another Chinese company. It will really be about the branding and how transparent the Chinese parent companies are about their ownership of other brands that people are more open to exploring.
Everyone keeps getting this backwards. Tesla isn't abandoning their low-margin auto manufacturing in order to switch to high-margin robotics tech; they want to capture the margin of robotics for themselves first. If their manufacturing half fails, that means their robotics half also failed at its sole purpose.
Maybe the insight is that it is better to first sell the robots (the "shovels") and only later go into the gold business yourself (if ever).
It will be truly nasty for the next President. All of this shit is going to blow up hard, even worse than 2007 was. With any luck, it will blow up during Trump's final months, but in the truly worst case it will collapse during the early time of whoever the next President is, which means no matter who gets the job will get smoked in the 2030 midterms - in turn ending up like Obama who didn't have a majority of his own for six years.
Plus, president's don't usually have more than two years of majority.
The fact that it was this big and this hard to get and with this many compromises against consumer interest, speaks more of the disfunction of the USA government at the time then it does about the value of that legislation.
This fight not about the dysfunction of the USA government at the time, it's about a fight over the structure of the USA as it was founded. There have always been strong political forces trying to dismantle all "common sense" features of the welfare state, who have convinced the masses to vote against their own interests out of the American Dream of rugged individualism.
This is in contrast to the unique decentralized communitarian history of America with community activism, charities, NGOs and nonprofits filling the social holes between the government and private enterprise. The current healthcare system evolved out of this with both private and government involvement which is in part why it's an expensive mess. Most European countries post WW2 had a chance to design something more efficient.
Which recent administration cut federal spending?
(and I don't have anything against cutting spending. In fact, actually think Reagan did the right thing in using this tool as well as deregulation to end stagflation. But cutting & spending should be based on the situation and for 2008, spending seemed the right course of action).
Rubinomics under Clinton was lower interest rates and spending cuts/deficit reduction).
And agreed, we known now that we should have gone bigger, but this was the first time stimulus like this was tried, and they weren't sure what they were doing. Also, have heard that at the time, there was a lot of opposition by many politicians to stimulus, so there was only so much they could do.
yeah, at least for me, it was one of the biggest risks the Obama administration took, bucking convention, but resulted in changing how we deal with many finacial crises.
Yeah, you're right. Much better to have Trump who just passed tax cuts for billionaires and corporations, imposed tariffs on Penguins and pardoned a bunch of people, some of whom he said he didn't even know.
> The world would've been very different with say, Bernie Sanders as president in 2016.
Undoubtedly, US and probably the world would likely have been a better place if that had happened.
Unfortunately, at present in the United States, the choices om offer(at least at a national level) are either neo liberalism with a woke 1.0 add on, or full on MAGA. The latter part is likely going to swing back to neocon territory by 2028 though.
That will be an... interesting transition. They're kind of between a rock and a hard place; they clearly have to ditch the MAGA thing, because it's electoral poison, as we've just seen. But also the die-hard Trumpists are still a big part of their base, and won't like that.
It's not that crazy. The last new release of a truly mainstream car was the Model 3 a decade ago. Anything ever since has been facelifts and the ill-fated Cybercuck.
The major problem Tesla faces is that on the one side their brand image is in the gutters and has been for years and on the other side, "established" car companies finally have brought competitive cars to the market at relevant scale. They'll need to invest a lot of money to develop a new model from scratch with a high chance of not making back the money.
Other car manufacturers somehow can’t even provide dashcam recordings in a $40 vehicle.
I'm no Tesla fan, but having longevity in car models is a good thing. My fun car was built by VW in Germany for a decade and then by VW in South Africa for another decade; parts availability is great.
In today's marketplace of very samey cars, models that work should probably last a decade or more.
That said, Tesla could have built out a couple more styles, such as maybe a minivan/workvan/delivery van, although van sales can be pretty cyclical, and Tesla parts and service was (is?) notoriously poor in some cases, so I dunno if commercial users would be interested.
You see one Tesla, you have seen every Tesla. Colors? The same too.
I'm surprised that the markets have given Elon the amount of slack he's gotten. Once you merge Tesla into SpaceX, what's the plan? Tesla can't seem to roll out new vehicles with different body styling. Is robotics or AI the next big thing? What will happen to their car business? Will it just be CyberCabs? Will they become a mobile phone carrier?
The list of questions goes on and on. All this feels like a YC company looking for a new line of business because they just figured out their current line of business isn't all that great.
First off is robotaxis and semis (99% of highway driving and 80-90% of city driving driver jobs have been very effectively replaced right now by machine, look at Waymo if you don’t believe Elon), and then Optimus for stuff that needs hands, like warehouse workers or other low-skill “move heavy things from here to there” jobs.
My six year old Tesla 3 just drove me from Vegas to LA, door to door, without me having to give it any control inputs. Not a lot of people seem to be paying attention to how good it is now.
I imagine Optimus will be a really big deal once they get it working as well as Teslas drive.
Waymo hasn’t achieved that, though, right? They’re deployed in minimal markets, and I would be surprised if they had even replaced a majority of taxi rides where they are deployed.
Your trip still requires you to be at the wheel and conscious because the technology can’t be guaranteed to not try to murder you. How many miles do you go between driving accidents? Really asking: how many miles do you go between intervening with self driving?
The lack of complete market takeover is a sign the technology just isn’t there yet.
So were is the revolution now?
Even the internal Tesla paper determined that the self driving market is not that big. There are clear issues no one seems to really like to hear:
People don't mind driving; A lot of people have to drive at the same time (which is not economic to catch this spike and then have all these cars with low utilization the rest of the day); We know the taxi/uber market.
Either it is so good that i literlay can do whatever i want while its driving and not getting car sick and move around, OR i'm sitting in a car seat anyway. I hate being not the driver, its a lot more boring than driving.
Your claim that robotaxis and semis have replaced humans is not credible. Show me all the truck driver job losses due to self driving trucks.
I'd say that only some places have seen city drivers replaced by Waymo to such an extent. As for self-driving semis, the market penetration is near zero. Maybe the tech is good enough but no one is buying it.
I wouldn't consider this to be a weakness, necessarily. No plan survives a contact with the enemy, and the market is sorta-kinda war with unclear sides and developments. Plans tend to bind people to their old decisions, and make them beholden to sunk costs even if the world drifts in another direction.
It'll be interesting to see if they can do well in places where there aren't a bunch of stagnant incumbents to upset. I'm sure Musk would love to edgelord his way through a conversation where he offends a bunch of people by implying that they have been doing asteroid mining all wrong, those idiots, and then go prove himself right, but there's just nobody doing that.
Imagine if they put all that engineering effort to building an affordable, reliable, EV? Man that would be something to behold. But America is in the meme economy now, nobody cares about real products for real people. Just hype generators that appeal to the 1%.
"Come work for us and you could get to design rocket cars!"
When you have a sky high valuation, spending capital on something that just gives steady returns is a net negative for everyone. You have to put all the capital into the moonshots.
Expect this trend to continue. I've started seeing it all over across different industries. Consumer based businesses are being abandoned to instead chase the bigger numbers from B2B sales and premium consumers.
Robotics is the new focus. Depending on who you ask (and how well they execute), this will either be another grift for bagholders or exactly the right move to capture a massive emerging industry.
I do think people are massively underestimating robotics. The convergence of LLMs and robotics will be the next great wave of AI, unlocking an enormous boom in productivity across the economy.
Then he got older, got into politics and fully bought into the marketing about himself. He thinks he's a genius and that everything he touches turns to gold.
Well... Turns out stuff works as long as he is out of the loop and doesn't make any direct decisions.
This is not unique to Musk - many tech CEOs learn this the hard way when they start meddling in the day-to-day. Bezos built an empire, but the projects he took personal control of (like FirePhone) tended to be unmitigated disasters.
Who sells more cars in China: Tesla or BYD?
$2B cybertruck failure barely registers vs how impactful FSD has been on model Y / 3 sales. Tesla is supply constrained again, with multi-month waits for the model Y L edition
Wasn't there even multiply lawsuits against Tesla because the payed for FSD didn't work? Didn't exist? Wasn't supported by the Hardware build in?
2016 did Tesla announce that every future car has the hardware for FSD. 2016!
Most people don’t care that some guy paid $10k for a feature on a $80k car 10 years ago that didn’t achieve its crazy promise. They care that they can pay $99 today for a feature that blows away their expectations, AND is good enough to not just be a surprising novelty but something they use long term.
What?
People don’t like driving, and they hire(d) people to do it for them. There’s even a word for it: chauffeur. Now the car does it itself. Yes the chauffeur could do other things as well, but you can’t pay a chauffeur $99 a month.
So 9% bought their Tesla with FSD.
A lot less bought FSD than I expected, a lot more people who pay for the subscription.
A lot of people btw. do like driving.
I don't have a Tesla, my uncle has a Model S. I met up with him recently for lunch, I told the car to drive us to a seafood place, it did most of the work and parked itself. This is commuting. And, it didn't roll through stop signs.
I like myself a Cooper or a GTI for the twisties, but that's a different thing.
Waymo’s entire fleet is estimated at about 6000 cars. Tesla produces this many cars in a little over a day.
The cybercab is also likely to end up costing 1/10th of a Waymo car
It’s not that Tesla is winning here. But the economics of their solution can totally tilt the entire market in the future.
If.
I've been reading the same thing each year since basically the first version of Tesla's car AI. I'm sure I've even written similar things.
Tesla hasn't got the scale or operating consistency to even truly call itself a commercial service. Elon keeps claiming the Tesla will overwhelm everybody in the whole fleet will wake up one day and be a moneymaking taxi machine.
No it won't. Here's the reality:: https://autonomixinvestor.com/robotaxi-tracker/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1Id2aas5wI (you can find more using Youtube search, or Chat)
Is it global, or US wide? Nope, Waymo isn't neither.
> Musk’s vaporware doesn’t actually exist in the market.
Unsupervised robotaxi has lower (at fault) accidents than unsupervised waymo.
All notable cybercab accidents have been done by remote driving.
The only thing waymo have are - large fleet thus large miles/week - many cities
In last week or so, Tesla went from tiny to equal/more than waymo in Austin seemingly in just a few days.
They'll do that in other cities too in due time.
Waymos exist and have for years. Whatever fabricated data Musk came up with here has no relation to reality.
Robotaxi has more hit a chain or barrier while trying to park. On the go, really really good, not perfect yet.
Waymo has more crossed lines while turning, very very wrong lane selection and blocking traffic. I don't know about their parking situation.
https://x.com/KHerriage/status/2114902145627504719
Waymo is betting that cutting zero corners and being rigorous will pay off down the line. They seem best in class.
Zoox seems to be betting that reducing time to get passengers in and out while providing a novel platform will be a differentiator. More sensors than Tesla but fewer cars than both the others.
Cybercab seems to be about cutting cost (and corners) wherever they thing they can get away from it and betting cheap will win the day (sort of like a discount airline). This assumes they're not doing something O(N) expensive behind the scenes, like having every ride monitored by a human operator in another country.
I remember some company dragging a person for awhile and the car not realizing. I'm worried tesla will find itself in a situation like that (or another edge case). I feel safer being around a Waymo as a pedestrian than a cybercab. I even had a Waymo stop for me at a pedestrian crossing when I was waiting for it to go by (I wasn't trying to cross).
In the long run Waymo will have to figure out how to have a cheaper platform and Tesla will have to toe the cheap/good-enough line. Zoox is still seemingly unlaunched so IDK about them. Time will tell.
... just looked it up, Waymo's 6th gen hardware is estimated to cost $20k per vehicle. That's getting down there. And if they ever do even higher volumes, will probably go down further: https://x.com/fchollet/status/2023522267846815874
Looked online, Waymo is really starting to ramp up it's services. They're now in 13 US cities (including Atlanta and Austin): https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/9059119#zippy=
And are planning on increasing the size of their fleet by a factor of 5: https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/waymo-...
They will have a huge advantage and seems to me like Waymo is going to win out, but can never tell.
> you can already buy a car with FSD
Which did things like drive off roads into parked cars and killed people. I feel like if Tesla hadn't been selling "full self driving" for years, the trust would be higher "no guys, we promise it's actually full self driving this time for real now" just doesn't have the same ring.
On the rollout:
It's notable that Tesla is building their own rideshare while Waymo is partnering with Uber. Tesla has the vertical integrated benefit of getting all profits but Waymo doesn't have to handle new user acquisition they just peel off existing requests and can roll out faster.
Tesla might "pivot" later to selling the 2 seater cybercab as a cheap base to competitors like waymo. It seems like Tesla has an identity crisis. They don't know how to be a consumer car platform (cybertruck halting production) they torched their PR with the green base that made them successful in the first place. Now sort of feels like a startup trying to "pivot" to find product market fit instead of a mature, well run company with solid strategic vision. There are a lot of jobs on the line so I hope they figure something out.
And yeah, FSD has been misrepresented for a long time now, but yeah, what I've been hearing it is finally getting really good. It's not completely hands free, but it's supposed to be very usable, and keep reading in reviews that this is the one feature that sets Tesla's EV's apart.
... And actually, on Uber, only in Austin (where said you are) and Atlanta does Waymo use Uber. Yeah, I used to live in the SF Bay Area, and had used Waymo a couple of times directly from their own app. It was a very natural experience. And recently stumbled upon an article that even in Austin and Atlanta, Waymo is going to discontinue using Uber in 2028.
What happened wasn't "politics got involved", what happened was that CEO started talking other politics.
And to say that "politics got involved" is a ridiculously passive statement. Elon has full control over how he publicly acts. Politics "didn't get involved" from 2022 onwards, Elon's publicly articulated political views significantly shifted, AND THEN Elon personally led massive organizational changes in the federal government.
Regardless of if you support or oppose DOGE, it's completely dishonest to wall off his actions at DOGE into a separate category of acts that you can clearly separate from his business.
Even now, they have no idea how to criticize him because they adore the blindingly wealthy, opinionated, and willing to use that wealth to force that opinion on others (it's upper-middle-class sainthood.) His biggest crime somehow is that he allowed you to say what you wanted on twitter. Just like they turned on Assange, it's always telling that their consistent enemy is democracy. Democracy is directly offensive to the credentials that they dedicated their lives and compromised their personal integrity to get from wealthy people and institutions.
They're offended by Musk because they wanted to show their Teslas off, and to talk about the projects that their company partnered with Tesla on at parties, and to be proud of their kids getting named Tesla scholars and getting Tesla genius grants. They can't be because he's obviously a slimeball in a way that they can't overlook and ignore and mock the victims of (in return for money and status.) That's it. They, however, are currently overlooking the crimes of their favored billionaires and employers, so have no language to articulate their resentment of him that doesn't also incriminate themselves. So it's just this insane inarticulate id-explosion.
Reminds me of people being embarrassed about working at Arthur Anderson or Lehman Brothers at parties. "I worked in accounting; I worked in insurance," they would say. Their mothers used to gush about them, and now they don't even mention the names of the companies, like a father who died in prison. All Musk's properties are like that now, as well as Google, Facebook, Amazon, etc.. Musk's properties still actually even come out better than other tech slop because they all ostensibly have some material purpose other than extracting rents from normal people through deceit and by doing the least work possible.
I used to have a name for people who can't see this dynamic: "emoluments libs." They were the libs during Trump's first term who kept saying "The Democrats aren't going after Trump for profiting from his office because they're too afraid." No, dude. They're not going after him because they have the same deals with the same people, and everything that they would go after him for implicates them too. After you avoid the obvious, you're left with impeaching a totally corrupt guy for not arming Ukraine hard enough to threaten Russia hard enough because they wouldn't cooperate in uncovering the blatant corruption of his predecessor. If that's the best you've got, a thing that sabotages one of your own prominent politicians (who was destined to win the next presidency by a hair), and highlights an evil thing you're currently doing in Ukraine, the other alternatives must be really horrible i.e. would send you to jail with him. Their only bright spot is that they hoped it would take (a notoriously disobedient) Biden out so The Atlantic libs could push one of their soulless golems Harris or Buttigieg into the presidency.
I have to be honest. I'm part of the ancient left that is celebrating the imminent death of the middle class, because it's their weird psychology that is killing us. I encourage their replacement with AI wherever it is possible, my criticism of AI is that it is still not good enough to do it, and if the middle class have anything to say about it it will never be. They will ruin it by either coddling the owners of AI to total flaccid laziness or threatening the owners of AI to make them cripple it, but they will make sure that they will maintain a lawn by any means necessary. They will, however, never give a shit about the uninsured unless they get sick.
That's an insane negative attribute that Waymo doesn't have to worry about. I hate the Alphabet guys too, but not to the same extent of completely boycotting all their products (yet).
You guys have to realize at some point that you're not a significant part of the market. There are a lot of people who don't particularly like musk but the amount that would never use a cybercab isn't a significant part of a 300m person market.
You should surround yourself with people who are willing to stand up for their convictions.
What? This is just a political hate piece because of the potential of something that just started five minutes ago? You're damning Tesla with faint praise yourself and don't even know it.
Examples: Covid controversies around musk in 2020, Twitter acquisition in 2022, Musk becoming the world richest person in 2021
2023: $15B
2024: $7B
2025: $3.8B
2025: $6.22 billion
2024: $3.581 billion
2023: $4.357 billion
https://www.goodcarbadcar.net/2026-us-auto-sales-figures-by-...
https://www.best-selling-cars.com/usa/2026-q3-usa-top-10-bes...
Look at the Maverick sales, when it was 20k. Slate Auto seems to have gotten it right.
The slate is a joke. They said they need to sell 80k per year to break even. The maverick is currently only double that in its 6th year, after a major mid cycle refresh, basically without competition. Now the slate is going to appear with less utility, fewer features, 205 miles of range and sell in comparable volumes? What a joke.
1: https://youtu.be/fo-uubnajWM?t=3m30s
I’d also say that the YL is something of a new product and a very successful one, even though it’s more of a long wheelbase variant.
Still, I agree with the thesis of the article. Where are the smart decisions?
The Cybertruck could have been a home run product for the US market, but Tesla’s own hubris about that market really buried it. They focused on styling and marketed it as a cyberpunk lawless society survival vehicle where angry mobs of cyberpsychos can’t break your window.
Hello, Tesla, you needed to put the truck in NFL advertisements and show how it’s going to be amazing for your blue collar cosplay sessions and how it’s going to get 300 miles of range while towing a boat (which it was supposed to but it didn’t).
The Cybercab being a two-door coupe is insane. How did that pass the first design discussion? Look at how the Waymo Zeekr cab is designed, look at a how a London cab can fit like 5-6 people in a normal-sized car, look at the Nissan NV200 as NYC’s exclusive taxi from 2012-2018.
None of these are two seater low entry coupes.
Where is the full size 3-row family veggie? Where is the European city car?
What is Tesla doing with their time?
- COVID, that put a strain on manufacturing during lockdowns and the eventual worldwide supply chain disruptions
- the new administration and its anti EV stance
- emergence of AI
- betting the company on Optimus (product) and Robotaxi (service)
How much could JB Staubel have influenced Tesla during these times is anybody’s guess.
Why would him being there have changed anything? What ‘hit product’ could JB have launched that you would have bought given everything that happened with Tesla.
This is the weirdest thing ever by far. Why would you not just build a Tesla supercar? Why 2028?
You know what I bet? They are so dependend on what Elon Musk does and says and decides, that stuff like Twitter, DOGE and alllll the other garbage he did on the side, just stalled everything.
Yeah, if you disqualify or assume imminent failure of all of those, then zero successful new products.
That means it will have to be more capable a driver than most human beings and that seems unlikely at the moment if you look at how well FSD works today. Yes, it works okay most of the time, but that's just not good enough for a self-driving taxi cab without a steering wheel or controls. And Tesla can't have thousands of remote taxi-drivers standing by all the time. That would make the service uneconomical and a loss leader.
some say the bar is higher due to sentiment, but it's insurance companies who will decide, and they are more interested in the numbers than sentiment. Your view that it has to be better than 'most' humans doesn't make any kind of insurance sense
accidental death is inconsolable, but it is also insurable
No doubt SpaceX will try to defer responsibility in its T&C's, but that won't fly IMHO. The manufacturer will be held responsible (or the cab company if they're lucky, but either way a fatal accident will mean the service will be curbed or halted).
So on principle, you're probably right. In practice it's easy to see why a corporation running a fleet of self-driving vehicles would have a different insurance profile than randos driving around.
"Clearly, there was never any real effort to make battery swap actually work because the value to Tesla was not, you know, as an actual viable way to drive adoption. It was a way to earn ZEV credits. Once California changed its rules and insisted that Tesla prove that customers were swapping batteries, Tesla abandoned the program. But Tesla had already banked over 100 million dollars from its phantom battery swaps. Since its founding, Tesla padded its bottom line with more than 11 billion dollars in government carbon credits."
Perhaps Tesla's most successful product was carbon credits
https://www.eenews.net/articles/musk-made-a-fortune-on-clima...
"The electric automaker earned $10.7 billion from selling credits created by government climate programs, a total that accounted for a third of Tesla's profits over the last decade, according to an analysis of securities filings by POLITICO's E&E News. In the first nine months of 2024, some 43 percent of its net income came from those credits, which Tesla sold to rival carmakers after exceeding climate mandates in California and elsewhere."