The fact that it was this big and this hard to get and with this many compromises against consumer interest, speaks more of the disfunction of the USA government at the time then it does about the value of that legislation.
This fight not about the dysfunction of the USA government at the time, it's about a fight over the structure of the USA as it was founded. There have always been strong political forces trying to dismantle all "common sense" features of the welfare state, who have convinced the masses to vote against their own interests out of the American Dream of rugged individualism.
This is in contrast to the unique decentralized communitarian history of America with community activism, charities, NGOs and nonprofits filling the social holes between the government and private enterprise. The current healthcare system evolved out of this with both private and government involvement which is in part why it's an expensive mess. Most European countries post WW2 had a chance to design something more efficient.
Which recent administration cut federal spending?
(and I don't have anything against cutting spending. In fact, actually think Reagan did the right thing in using this tool as well as deregulation to end stagflation. But cutting & spending should be based on the situation and for 2008, spending seemed the right course of action).
Rubinomics under Clinton was lower interest rates and spending cuts/deficit reduction).
And agreed, we known now that we should have gone bigger, but this was the first time stimulus like this was tried, and they weren't sure what they were doing. Also, have heard that at the time, there was a lot of opposition by many politicians to stimulus, so there was only so much they could do.
yeah, at least for me, it was one of the biggest risks the Obama administration took, bucking convention, but resulted in changing how we deal with many finacial crises.