News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by matthewdgreen on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:21AM (#50414572)
Being in the EV business means having to accept predictable revenues that then tie to more predictable stock prices. Being in the business of "some future technology" doesn't.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:44AM (#50414810)
The big problem for Tesla is that they cannot sustain their valuation from the car manufacturing business. There's a perpetual need to justify why Tesla should be valued an order of magnitude more than other automakers. Selling the dream of future profit is Tesla's main business.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by ares623 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:51AM (#50414881)
SpaceX and Tesla are just another form of the Star Citizen phenomenon.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:03PM (#50415001)
That's an awesome analogy, I'm stealing it right away.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by santoshalper on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:07PM (#50415049)
"Irrational exuberance" is, I believe, the most concise description.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by hparadiz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:02PM (#50414996)
They are a battery company. The cars are just a way to sell batteries.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by petcat on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:05PM (#50415037)
The cars are actually a way to drive yourself around town. Yes they also contain batteries.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by hdgvhicv on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:11PM (#50415095)
Very expensive batteries compared to the competition
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:12PM (#50415098)
The comparison is actually even worse if you compare it to other companies on the battery sector. How is Tesla supposed to be five times more than CATL ffs?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by Reason077 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49PM (#50415417)
> "They are a battery company."

Not really. Tesla, like most automakers, purchases most of its battery cells from other companies. In recent years they have started to manufacture their own cells as well, with their 4680 cell manufacturing line at "Giga Texas". But this is still a small portion of the cells they use globally.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by hparadiz on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:49PM (#50416465)
That's interesting cause FY2025 had them do about 14 billion in battery/energy products (revenue). With auto being a little over 60 billion. The energy products seem to be growing in volume though
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by orwin on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:08PM (#50416631)
Didn't tesla got a bunch of US government money to install superchargers everywhere? Wouldn't that be under 'energy product'?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by Reason077 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @03:22PM (#50416754)
Yes, "Energy Products" refers to Tesla's energy storage products (home Powerwalls and industrial-scale "Megapacks"). Tesla manufactures these packs using battery cells they buy from 3rd parties. Tesla's value is added in the pack design, software, inverter electronics, branding, etc.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by fifilura on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:16PM (#50415146)
You can laugh at it, and most likely it will crash and burn.

But at the same time, maybe they are doing the correct analysis.

"If we stay here and grow fat the others will eat us. To infinity and beyond!".

100 years ago your business was your warehouse or your locomotive. These days, maybe your business is defined by your rate of change?

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by ethbr1 on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:06AM (#50425056)
> These days, maybe your business is defined by your rate of change?

This is the most absurd and also true observation I've read on HN in a while.

As the rate of technological process accelerates, maybe it becomes possible to justify a company's valuation on a never-ending succession of "And then..."s.

Granted, that ended poorly in terms of stock prices for the .com bubble, but mostly for companies that weren't financially solvent enough to withstand higher interest rates + a public market downturn.

And it took a conflation of multiple events to pop that bubble (Asian instability, moderate US interest rate hikes, 9/11/2001).

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:18PM (#50415160)
Tesla and Space-X.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:22PM (#50415182)
Until the merger with xAI, spaceX was actually a decent company with a very solid business, a clear technological edge and clear growth perspective. It shouldn't be a trillion dollar company of course, but it should have been a cash cow capturing all the value from its niche market.

Not anymore, I guess.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by origini on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49PM (#50415421)
But not with the valuation it currently has.

The only reason why Payload into space increased from 1000t to 3000t is Starlink.

And there they have also massive problems for scaling. Base Station is expensive and they have to replace the Satelites every 5 years. Withouth the v3 and rocket big enough to send it up, they can't scale properly.

If they then scale, the rate of atmosphere poisening through STarlink will increase.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by ethbr1 on Monday November 09, 2026 @08:13AM (#50425146)
SpaceX's central flywheel is: (1) find unserved, profitable need for mass-produced space launch, (2) design, iterate, and scale production of a rocket that can do that, & (3) GOTO 1 at the next mass scale.

Starlink was the seed customer for unused gen1 launch capacity.

Space datacenters are probably intended to be the gen2 seed.

Because SpaceX needs to frequently toss rockets up to be able to iterate on them and scale manufacturing, and they'd rather use the (high-risk) payload capacity for something profitable while doing that.

But as a net result, SpaceX can afford to launch mass that others can't, because it wins two ways: whatever profits that launched mass produces + iterating rocket design and manufacturing.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by tarsinge on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:39PM (#50415340)
I don’t know, I think at this point the Tesla stock doesn’t have a link with the company anymore and behaves like any meme coin or collectible token. Like in crypto there is some vague narrative about a crazy future but ultimately the point is only to drive further speculation ("buy it before you’re priced out/join the elite crowd that’ll own the future/etc."). The genius of Elon is having realized (I’d say around the time he tested the ground with pumping dogecoin) that in a stock market where investors don’t buy for dividends but only price speculation the underlying business doesn’t really matter, only the narrative does (since dividends are the only link with the real business).
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:11PM (#50416070)
The parallel with crypto is very strong indeed.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by Reason077 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:43PM (#50415373)
> "Edit: Tesla is 3 times Toyota in valuation, not 5 as I said earlier, not that it changes the argument much."

Per Google finance, Tesla's market cap today is $1.42T. Toyota's is ¥48.72T, or $307B USD. So that would make Tesla's market cap about 4.6X Toyota's.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by lesuorac on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:49PM (#50415425)
Sure and Toyota [1] has significantly more outstanding bonds than Tesla [2] which should depress it's market cap.

[1]: https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/TSE-7203/bonds/

[2]: https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/NASDAQ-TSLA/bonds/

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by stymaar on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:16PM (#50417361)
Of course thank you, Idk how my brain farted when I did the double check…
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:48PM (#50415412)
You should probably compare revenue instead of profit because Tesla and Toyota are at very different places in their development.

But Toyota still makes 3x Teslas revenue.

I'm guessing some of the 9x difference is speculative and some is because Tesla is all in on EVs/etc, which are doing well, and Toyota is still very much in ICEs, which aren't doing as well.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by amelius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:52AM (#50414889)
Being in the EV business means having to compete with China. This market is dictated by manufacturing costs and so it is not where you want to be.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by ajay-b on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:58AM (#50414953)
Which begs a question: Is it really possible to compete with China on consumer products? The price and cost of labor advantage, indeed state sponsorship and support, would suggest that it's not.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by StilesCrisis on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:04PM (#50415024)
For electronics, sure. iPhone and Android are American products. Playstation and Switch are Japanese. If you mean "can we compete on cost of manufacturing," no. They all build in China.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by kraken_cult on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:05PM (#50415032)
That seems like a major issue national security wise. I wonder why no one has brought that up?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by detourdog on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:07PM (#50415050)
Veblen goods can compete. China is unique in cheap high tech products. As production scales down and shipping costs go smaller markets open.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by neves on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:14PM (#50415116)
Musk's companies are some with the most state sponsorship on the planet. Remove the tax credits, government buying, and commercial barriers, and there's nothing.

Even then, he is losing to Chinese competition. It's pure incompetence.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by proxyscore on Sunday November 08, 2026 @01:02PM (#50415530)
Well the usa always shouts free market from every rooftop in all the invaded countries, so I wonder where the struggle is?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by gumby on Sunday November 08, 2026 @11:59AM (#50414959)
Chinese cars are effectively excluded from the US market mainly to keep Tesla afloat.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by maxdo on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:17PM (#50415153)
no, they mostly not allowed to keep fords, gm, and other inefficient manufacturing afloat.

Proofs? tesla exists in China and cable to compete there. There is no ford or GM in it's US shape, only sub brands that loosing ground.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by bradknowles on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:10PM (#50416063)
So, the irony here is that, according to the latest JD Powers reports, Tesla scores 113 defects per thousand here in the US. That makes them the worst vehicle manufacturer in the country, with regards to quality. In China, Tesla also scores 113 defects per thousand. But there, that makes them the number one vehicle manufacturer in the country, with regards to quality.

If Chinese vehicles were allowed into the US, they would certainly eat all the other vehicle manufacturers, except for customers who care about quality. And that’s where Toyota would be able to continue to survive.

But even Toyota would lose a ton of sales, because prices here in the US are so, so much higher than they should be. You can just look at prices in Europe and Canada to see that.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by shawnb576 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @04:07PM (#50417259)
I think you're implying that based on these JD Powers numbers Chinese make low quality cars and will therefore not be successful.

I don't know what to make of these numbers. Are all defects the same? (I can't be bothered to look).

What I can tell you is we owned a Model Y in the US for 3+ years. It was great, we had one small seat problem (which mobile service promptly fixed). The news is full of customer horror stories from Tesla, and not only did we like ours, our wide network of friends had many with similar experience.

I now live in Australia and have a Zeekr 7x (Chinese EV). My in-laws have an MG. The place is swimming with BYDs, Geely's, GWMs, etc. The idea that Chinese cars are low quality and people won't like them is laughable. No - they are cars people like at a price they are willing to pay.

We've only had our Zeekr 4 months but so far its been great and the build quality seems MUCH higher than the MY. It's quieter, the trim is much nicer, its generally great.

Letting Chinese cars into the US will decimate the US auto industry. No question about it, they will be reduced to light trucks for a time but even that probably isn't defensible.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by bradknowles on Sunday November 08, 2026 @07:23PM (#50419339)
It is important to know that JD Powers makes a point of not distinguishing between different types of complaint. Not liking the color of the seat belt is treated the same as the motor blowing up when you turn it on. They’re looking at big picture numbers here.

And on that criteria, at the time that survey was done, I do think that Tesla probably may well have been the best car manufacturer in China. But perhaps things have changed quickly there?

I also think that Tesla quality has significantly declined overall as time has progressed. They’ve been more about trying to be the new thing, whatever that is.

I am also convinced that if Chinese car manufacturers are let into this country, that will kill the low to midrange market for any of the traditional car manufacturers. People are willing to put up with a lot of crap, if they can get it at a lower price — witness the rise of Amazon, Walmart, and Temu. And China can guarantee that they will always have the lowest prices, with lower labor costs, lower government environmental scrutiny, and active government subsidization. Tariffs on Chinese cars will need to be super high — maybe 100% or more? And even that isn’t going to save the car manufacturers in this country.

China can attack the high-end luxury market, but they’re going to have a lot more friction there, simply because people buying cars in that bracket won’t want to be seen as being cheap. China is going to have a long road ahead of them, but when they can deliver Lexus and Mercedes quality at bargain basement prices, there will be some people that they can peel away from the more well-established brands.

Meanwhile, companies like Polstar will do well, because many people don’t realize (or care) that brand is largely owned by Geely and another Chinese company. It will really be about the branding and how transparent the Chinese parent companies are about their ownership of other brands that people are more open to exploring.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by neves on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:00PM (#50414977)
Musk basically lost to China competitition, but can't assume it.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by re4r567t8z9u0k9 on Sunday November 08, 2026 @02:28PM (#50416264)
You mean "admit". I know your native language. :-)
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by peri-cl on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:14PM (#50415122)
It's sort of Tesla's core thesis that want to to attain the world's lowest manufacturing costs, by doing novel things with robotics and AI that automate away humans.

Everyone keeps getting this backwards. Tesla isn't abandoning their low-margin auto manufacturing in order to switch to high-margin robotics tech; they want to capture the margin of robotics for themselves first. If their manufacturing half fails, that means their robotics half also failed at its sole purpose.

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by amelius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:25PM (#50415213)
But is a low margin business really the one where you want to bootstrap your robotics industry?
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by peri-cl on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:35PM (#50415306)
It stops being low-margin if suddenly you can build things much cheaper than your competitors can, and they can't replicate what you're doing.
Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by amelius on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:40PM (#50415342)
Yes, but a lot of experience is required in robotics to reach that stage.

Maybe the insight is that it is better to first sell the robots (the "shovels") and only later go into the gold business yourself (if ever).

Re:Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB... by proxyscore on Sunday November 08, 2026 @12:17PM (#50415150)
Well fsd and robotaxi are still mere futuristic concepts and semi vaporware but I get it, that doesn't sell shares anymore