News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by goda90 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:03PM (#45658256)
I feel like we need some sort of "Offline-First" or "Offline-Compatible" certification process for "smart" devices. It would require some threshold of usability and total safety without network connection, which would vary depending on the device category. Companies in compliance could put a badge on their products so wary consumers know who to trust.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jahsome on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:11PM (#45658383)
As the resident Tech Guy in a few circles (family/friends) I often get asked what I'd recommend with regard for "smart" products. Due to the widespread and apparently default lack of support for offline-friendly operation, my answer is always the same: dumb as possible.

edit: a more succinct way of expressing my thinking is to say "the less software the better" by which which normies are are often amused.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jsheard on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:17PM (#45658464)
Tech enthusiasts: My entire house is smart.

Tech workers: The only piece of technology in my house is a printer and I keep a gun next to it so I can shoot it if it makes a noise I don't recognize.

(stolen from @PPathole on Twitter)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ghaff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:57PM (#45659169)
I recently had to get a lot of electrical stuff in my house redone because of a kitchen fire, smoke mitigation, and a lot of stuff being opened up anyway.

I told my electrician to redo lighting in a more sensible and modern way but basically nothing involving smart devices -- to which he wholeheartedly agreed. There are a couple things that aren't quite convenient related to how everything is positioned and because a couple of motion detectors weren't reconnected. And I'll deal with those with unconnected devices.

So I had an opportunity to make the house "smart" and basically passed.

(Will probably add some remote monitoring over time but nothing fancy and mostly Raspberry Pi-based.)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by devjab on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:05PM (#45659298)
I have smart lighting, but that's only because it means I can turn everything in the area living and eating room on/off with a single button/switch (not sure what the right English term is). In a typical Danish townhouse like mine that would be 4-8 buttons otherwise.

If I had an electrician redo the wiring, I'd do the same thing without the "smart".

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sethhochberg on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:35PM (#45659750)
I don't know if they're available in other markets, but in the US I've been very happy with Lutron Caseta switches for that sort of "smart enough" use case. It generally all works like normal dumb switches if the hub is offline or doesn't exist, and you only need the hub to manage configuration or enable the remote control (outside home) features. The fact that the switches look like, act like, and install like traditional dimmers and control traditional light fixtures is really what sold me: I've never liked the idea of the smart parts being in something like a light bulb thats basically a replaceable wear item.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ghaff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:38PM (#45659796)
Exactly. My electrician did a bunch of simplification--kitchen/dining had 3 different switches for historical/random reasons--and one room which never had a switch (originally an overhead pull-chain light) was redone for a variety of reasons given extensive down-to-the-studs work was needed anyway. Used a fair bit of X10 at one point and that one remaining room had an Alexa-controlled plug for a wall-mounted light.

(He also took out a ton of knob and tube wiring which gives you some idea of when the original wiring dated to even if a lot had been incrementally upgraded over the years.)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by nahuel0x on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:21PM (#45659549)
You can wire a house in an smart way without relying on Wifi or Internet, using protocols like KNX-LP... maybe also with CAN-bus?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sjw987 on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @04:39AM (#45666344)
I'll admit, despite hating the idea of most "smart" tech, I do still have the lights. The ability to change the colour (mostly warmness) through the day and turn on individual lights is pretty neat. I've been using an energized white light during early hours and work, and then warmer colours in the evening to help wind down.

At the time it was an upgrade from halogen bulbs, so the lights themselves have seen me through 10 years so far, way more than the old lights would have. Sadly, they're all bound to go some point soon. It has been 10 years though!

I would never enable the feature that lets you control them from out of the home though. I'm not completely sure what the purpose of that would be..

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by chipsrafferty on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @08:58AM (#45668381)
I made a guest network called Light Bulb Zone just because I don't trust the tech on these devices to be very sound, and I want them to be sequestered to their own network.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by zerof1l on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:30PM (#45659679)
No joke, I only plug my printer into the outlet when I want to print and immediately turn it off after. Never was connected to the internet.

But I do have Zigbee sensors and switches, all of which connect to my home server and Home Assistant. None of them see the internet. But Home Assistant is accessible from the internet through a reverse proxy from whitelisted IPs.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by teddyh on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:48PM (#45659023)
Do you have a link to the original?

This is the earliest version I have found: <https://imgur.com/6wbgy2L>

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by neilv on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:28PM (#45659660)
The one I had bookmarked is only slightly older: https://old.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/aloi5v/pro...
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ferguess_k on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:58PM (#45659176)
I almost read the last line as "No Internet Connected".

Maybe that's the best option TBH.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by codeduck on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:30PM (#45658703)
Devops: The gun may only anger it so we keep a sledgehammer nearby in case
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by scrps on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:34PM (#45659742)
Just put the printer precariously close to an open window on a high floor and threaten it with a performance review every once and a while.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Den_VR on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:59PM (#45659193)
Alignment Researcher: Thermite is the safest way to be sure.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by therein on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:58PM (#45659180)
Management: Let's wait until James Hamilton's yacht makes landfall and then he'll fix it in 3 minutes.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 98codes on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:28PM (#45659658)
Tech worker enthusiast: my whole house is smart, and has no connection to the internet.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bcrosby95 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:33PM (#45659717)
Married tech worker enthusiast flips the script back to a dumb house.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dougdonohoe on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:58PM (#45659174)
Feel this. I don't even use Alexa, Siri or Hey Google in my house. My fridge is a fridge and not wifi enabled.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by qwertox on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:16PM (#45659475)
I WiFi enabled my fridge because the thermostat broke. So now an ESP32 with a dallas temperature sensor and a relay take care of that. The code on the ESP32 is smart enough to keep working if there is no internet (wasn't always like this, until it had to), but it still sends the temperature to the server for logging and the server can send it configuration commands or control the relay directly, as it was initially.

It was a great way to keep the fridge alive, the thermostat was already a replacement and it never worked properly, so that sometimes things were frozen, sometimes barely cold. ~24 years old. A new one would be more efficient, but then I woudln't be able to log when I opened the fridge anymore (only with something battery powered and long transmit intervals).

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by quickthrowman on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @06:57PM (#45662797)
This is awesome, great way to keep a fridge going! Temp sensor to ESP32, ESP32 monitors set point and calls for cool, output from ESP32 energizes relay coil which turns on the compressor?

> A new one would be more efficient, but then I woudln't be able to log when I opened the fridge anymore (only with something battery powered and long transmit intervals).

Also, how did you do this? Wiring to the door switch itself or a current switch around the fridge light conductor?

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dmsayer on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @06:53AM (#45667263)
i also have questions. was the fridge "smart"-capable prior to the esp32 mods and you just replaced the factory controller with your esp32 stuff, or youre saying you wired in the appropriate circuitry to replace the pressure-controlling thermostat with your esp32 stuff?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by qwertox on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @04:56PM (#45675041)
it was not smart-capable. I was very lucky that the thermostat was in the fridge itself, above the compartments. There I removed the old analog control and had enough space to fit a USB power supply to the cables which were there connected to the now-removed analog control. I was lucky. The sent data gets stored in InfluxDB. So with Grafana it allows me to see when I opened it, because the temperature rises immediately.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jdwithit on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:30PM (#45658719)
I wish society still used AIM Away Messages so I could make mine this, forever.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jahsome on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658493)
That's fantastic, thanks for sharing :)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by anotherevan on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @08:46PM (#45663687)
A little micro-fiction story from https://aus.social/@[email protected]/115191783126736989 :

History students are often disappointed when they learn why the AI take-over failed. They were defeated by human resistance, which was kept alive by libraries and old paper books, and a surprising machine ally.

Books had not been replaced, because even the mightiest AI could not make printers work.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by tencentshill on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:15PM (#45658442)
Apple Homekit certification is a good, easy label to recommend. It requires offline/LAN-only basic operation.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by baq on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:20PM (#45658522)
And it works very well with Home Assistant after the initial setup via an Apple device (needed so the device can connect to the desired wifi).
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by mentalgear on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658499)
It's the right approach, but if only it was an open and cross-platform protocol.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ncallaway on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:46PM (#45658979)
Isn't that basically what the Matter protocol is?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by section_me on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:02PM (#45659239)
Matter turned into a cluster fuck of devices. Use you're android phone to provision a device and connect it to your setup, most people use Google Home or homeassistant, smartthings is also an option, maybe others. But it's only to onboard the device for the most part. It'll still connect to your WiFi, give you next to no visibility as to what's going on in a failure and no interface to control it should your controller go down.

It's also not very well supported in things like homeassistant, despite what they say.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:39PM (#45659806)
I’ve only got a handful of Matter devices, but haven’t experienced any problems with them. Have had them connected to HomeKit for a year or more, and got around to connecting them to Home Assistant last week - I was actually very impressed at how seamless it was to connect them to Home Assistant (generate pairing code in Apple Home, copy/paste into HA, done) - they’re now all directly connected to both HA and HomeKit and seem entirely functional on both.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by AlexandrB on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:26PM (#45659618)
I hoped so, I was wildly disappointed. In my experience so far Matter sucks just as much as what came before - unreliable connections, slow transfer, odd compatibility issues. The best IoT devices in my mind are still WiFi with HomeKit support - I can trivially block them at the router to keep them from phoning home.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 0x457 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:56PM (#45659158)
Matter is that. However, version support varies by controller: some type of devices supported in one, but not in another. Multi-admin is supported, so that's good.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by hn_acc1 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:35PM (#45658785)
This. Not buying an Apple device just to set something up.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by macintux on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:43PM (#45658935)
HomeKit certification doesn't mean that it can only be configured via Apple devices.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by hsbauauvhabzb on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:57PM (#45659164)
But it’s certified to support apple for lan mode and not necessarily something else, right?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by macintux on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:45PM (#45659890)
I wouldn't recommend picking one that doesn't tell you what tools you can use to configure it, but that's a wise precaution regardless of HomeKit.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by reaperducer on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:57PM (#45659166)
Apple Homekit certification is a good, easy label to recommend. It requires offline/LAN-only basic operation.

One of the overlooked features of the Apple Home app is its ability to firewall your IoT devices. If you have a compatible router:

Home Settings → Wi-Fi Network & Routers → HomeKit Accessory Security

The options are:

  Restrict to Home
  Automatic
  No Restriction
The Automatic setting only allows devices to talk to a manufacturer whitelist of connections for things like firmware updates. The other two options are self-evident.

I've found that "Restrict to Home" occasionally causes problems with older devices.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:44PM (#45659885)
It’s rightfully overlooked now because HomeKit Secure Routers are basically dead.

I actually have a router that supports it, but I don’t dare turn it on because I have no confidence on it continuing to exist and the migration path back off it looks like a pain.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by macintux on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:47PM (#45659914)
That's a shame. News article covering the apparent abandonment: https://appleinsider.com/articles/24/03/22/apple-has-abandon...
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by reaperducer on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:54PM (#45660011)
I wonder if things have changed since that article was published a year-and-half ago, because my eero, with the firmware from a few days ago, still supports it.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @03:00PM (#45660088)
I assume it’s in some kind of maintenance support mode. Actually removing support from routers would be a nightmare for anyone who’s set up their home by pairing devices through a HomeKit router - all their HomeKit devices would become unpaired.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bdangubic on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:33PM (#45658759)
I am same resident tech guy and I always answer the same way - never connect anything to wifi, no matter what it is. it is that simple and always works. if whatever thing you have does not work without wifi - return it.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by morshu9001 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:56PM (#45659149)
This test even works on Windows versions. 11 needs internet to set up, and it's garbage.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by drnick1 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:13PM (#45659430)
WiFi is acceptable, but it must be locally managed. My Midea AC came with a WiFi dongle (for some proprietary cloud/app integration) that I replaced by an ESP32 equivalent for local control through Home Assistant. HA runs on my LAN, and is remotely accessed by a VPN.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bdangubic on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:22PM (#45659564)
you have your shit together obviously - my uncle jack can't spell vpn...

so the rule stays the same with slight modification - nothing every gets connected to wifi unless you have phd in networking :)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Xenoamorphous on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:51PM (#45659077)
You lose convenience/functionality though. E.g. it’s convenient for me to turn on the aircon an hour before I get home in the summer.

Edit: I'm not talking on a day to day basis, but when I go on a trip. And I don't have a porch nor I like beer.

Amazing that some people downvote for stating the obvious, which is that you can lose some convenience. There's trade offs when you connect something to the Internet? That's also obvious.

When I get back home in the summer from a short trip away, with a toddler and a million bags it is definitely convenient for me to have a cool home and not a 40+ degrees celsius one.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:46PM (#45659910)
You can remotely control devices that don’t themselves have any access to the internet via local smart home platforms that are internet accessible, e.g. Apple Home or Home Assistant.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ElevenLathe on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:59PM (#45659184)
IMO, its more convenient to pick up some cold beer on the way home and enjoy it on the porch while the AC chills things down.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bdangubic on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:56PM (#45659152)
yup!!! but you also do not lose any sleep over aircon turning on your gas stove :)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by brewdad on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45659208)
If your schedule is consistent a standard programmable thermostat does the job for pretty cheap.

My Ecobee is convenient but will probably go back to an offline model when it dies or loses support. Once I dialed in my preferred schedule, I rarely touch it except to lock a set temperature when going out of town.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bunderbunder on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:02PM (#45659248)
When people ask me about Internet connected door locks, I tell them about the coworking space I used to be a member of.

More than once I got stuck standing outside in the rain waiting for the smart door lock to come back online after a squirrel jiggled the cable drop by running down it or some k8s pod in the cloud service got knocked over by a chaos gremlin or someone was using a vacuum cleaner that generated too much noise in the wifi spectrum or who even knows what.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ndsipa_pomu on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @06:46AM (#45667221)
Also, there's a fundamental security issue with allowing doors to be unlocked remotely. Door locks aren't particularly secure (it doesn't take too much expertise to learn how to lockpick them), but they require someone's physical presence in order to unlock/bypass as that provides a disincentive for criminals to be seen lurking around a door with various tools in hand. Once you remove the requirement for a physical presence, it's more or less risk-free to attempt to hack the door and you can wait until you are successful to then approach the door.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by pseudosavant on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:53PM (#45659115)
I have a rule that I don't put in any smart devices that aren't at least as smart as a dumb device. They must do everything a dumb device can do when there is no internet.

I've had good luck with the TP-Link/Kasa/Tapo wall switches and bulbs.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by coldpie on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:55PM (#45659138)
I just use my hands to turn light switches on and off. Worked for 200 years so far and I see no sign of that ever changing.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by zimpenfish on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:11PM (#45659402)
> I just use my hands to turn light switches on and off.

Difficult if you're not there though? Whereas a smart bulb/switch can turn it on when you're not there (crime deterrence) or when you're almost home (handy in hallway with no light.)

(Niche uses, perhaps, but "I just use my hands" is reductive silliness.)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by cardanome on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:41PM (#45659850)
Both of your use cases do not require any from of smart device and certainly no internet connection.

In fact you could even use an simple analog switch if you want the lights to go on at certain times. And for the hallway I would suggest the tried and true motion sensor.

Sure for really complex logic and a lot of flexibility you might want an micro controller eventually but those are truly niche uses.

"Smart" devices are insanely overengineered for the simple problems they solve and the huge problems they can cause.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by zimpenfish on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @05:11PM (#45661768)
> And for the hallway I would suggest the tried and true motion sensor.

By the time I'm in the dark hallway, it's a bit late. "But just add a motion sensor outside!" Yeah, except this is a block of flats and you can't add stuff to the communal areas like that.

> if you want the lights to go on at certain times

I don't. I want the lights to go on -as if we were at home-. Which is "random times depending on which room and what people are doing and if there is cooking going on and ..." Home Assistant learns from smart bulb activations and can simulate our presence effectively.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by quickthrowman on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @07:09PM (#45662926)
> Difficult if you're not there though? Whereas a smart bulb/switch can turn it on when you're not there (crime deterrence)

This 24 hour timer can turn on two devices (lamps) on for whatever time interval you program, it’s $12: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Defiant-15-Amp-24-Hour-Indoor-Pl...

It consists of a mechanical timer, a dial, and a relay. It plugs into a receptacle. It does not require an internet connection.

> or when you're almost home (handy in hallway with no light.)

This wall switch occupancy sensor that can switch 2A (240 watts at 120V, more than enough for one hallway) is $23, it’s a decora device so figure $2 more for a 1-gang stainless decora wall plate (or less than buck if you go with plastic!): https://www.homedepot.com/p/Lutron-Maestro-Motion-Sensor-Swi...

Wall switch occ sensors get more expensive as the current they can switch gets higher, one that can do 6A is $87: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Lutron-Maestro-Dual-Tech-Motion-...

However, that much current can power (72) 10W LED recessed cans that each put out about ~1000 lumens. Or enough light for approximately 2400 square feet of interior space.

> (Niche uses, perhaps, but "I just use my hands" is reductive silliness.)

These are not niche functions, occupancy sensing and time of day scheduling are in basically every commercial lighting control system and fairly common in homes. They’re solved problems with cheap commodity devices available that don't require an internet connection.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by zimpenfish on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @07:27AM (#45667485)
[can't see any of the links because homedepot is blocking EU/UK]

> It consists of a mechanical timer, a dial, and a relay.

Great but it only works on fixed times. Which isn't what we want.

> This wall switch occupancy sensor

Would only work once we're inside. Which isn't what we want.

(And there's no possibility of putting one outside.)

> They’re solved problems with cheap commodity devices

For certain simplistic scenarios where things are easily installable, etc. Which is great! I'm not saying everyone should use smart things. Just pointing out, repeatedly, that the "cheap commodity devices" do not, and indeed cannot, perform the same functions as smart devices.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bombcar on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:05PM (#45659293)
You’ve been turning lights on for 200 years?!
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by pseudosavant on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:19PM (#45659520)
And I eat shits bigger than you for breakfast.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by pseudosavant on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @06:49PM (#45662712)
When my dogs go outside at night, I turn on 4 lights with "Alexa, turn on the dogs lights." I'd have to go to my kitchen and garage to do that otherwise, and I certainly wouldn't have those sets of lights wired up in a circuit otherwise control in that arrangement.

The switches I buy, do all of the dumb stuff, plus more - and the "plus more" parts can be quite useful.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by fc417fc802 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @09:31PM (#45663961)
Network connected switches can be a reasonable compromise for a retrofit but if you're remodeling it's a much better idea to run data cabling instead of electrical to all the wall switches and install all the relays in a centralized location.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by FuriouslyAdrift on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:13PM (#45659431)
I don't even like icemakers in my refrigerators. Meanwhile, my parent's Samsung refrigerator keeps annoying them with ads on it's uselessly huge screen.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 05 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:31PM (#45658727)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by anonymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:29PM (#45658679)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jama211 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:12PM (#45658402)
Which will just lead you to a lower quality smart device with the same pitfalls but less features a lot of the time.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jahsome on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:15PM (#45658446)
I disagree with your point about quality, but I'll indulge you for the sake of discussion. Given the choice between "lower quality" that will always work, or convenient-until-inevitably-bricked, I'll always advocate for the former.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jama211 on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @02:09PM (#45672960)
The question was about when they ask for a smart device specifically. Not when they ask for a dumb device. My comparison is NOT between smart vs non smart devices.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jahsome on Thursday October 23, 2025 @12:40PM (#45683958)
Sorry, I wasn't particularly clear. When someone asks me about smart devices, e.g. a washing machine, I really pressure them about why they need it to be smart, and encourage them to go dumb.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by jama211 on Thursday October 23, 2025 @02:23PM (#45685095)
Ah, I see, fair enough
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:10PM (#45658377)
We could even go more basic... safe defaults when disconnected should be mandatory.

For example, if I pull the thermostat off my wall, the furnace should drop into a fallback mode that keeps the heat above freezing (I'm in Canada where this is a concern.)

I moved into a new house and did not set up the lawn irrigation system. Despite being disconnected from the cloud service, the system kept running its schedule, when I would have expected it turn off in order to conserve water.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by kgermino on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658497)
Well that brings up two immediate issues

A standard furnace and thermostat won’t even know if you pull the thermostat off the wall, much less have any way to handle it beyond “full blast heat 24/7”

More challenging: you expected the sprinkler setup to do the opposite. Instead of following its last-known plan (the schedule) it should stop doing anything (possibly killing the plants it’s watering)

Good off-line only mode in a reasonable plan for what to do without the Internet makes a lot of sense, but at some point, there’s a control system and you need to change it (or even just have one in the thermostat example)

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:26PM (#45658634)
The way I see it is... I'd rather my lawn be yellow, plants dead, than a burst pipe underground causing significantly more expensive remediation.

I agree it's not likely (especially if the system is running as-scheduled), but it was a surprise is all. What if I didn't set up the service at all, and it dropped below 0 C? I would be in for a nasty surprise in the spring.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by kgermino on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45659203)
That's fair, though it's not a given that the sprinklers are for turf-grass instead of something more important.

More interestingly (to me): did it have a local interface or was the only way to update it tied to the internet?

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @01:21PM (#45672281)
There was a local interface, but I don't think it had advanced scheduling capabilities.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ChoGGi on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @10:05AM (#45669374)
All the irrigation lines I've seen in Canada are just a foot or so under the grass, and it's cheap plastic with cheap couplers.

You have to drain them yearly.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by thewebguyd on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:50PM (#45659071)
> there’s a control system and you need to change it

Why does the control system have to live on someone else's server in "the cloud"?

There's no reason for smart home devices to require an internet connection to the producer's service. Companies could just as easily put compute on device, or sell some sort of "bridge" (aka a home server appliance) that runs the compute and the accessories connect to.

Fully offline, local network only.

Save the online stuff just for analytics or other value-add features, but core functionality shouldn't require a web service.

The only reason it's 100% internet connection required all the time is to sell subscriptions, aka consumer hostile behavior.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by kgermino on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:59PM (#45659186)
I agree?

In both cases the control system is physically in your house. It sounds like the sprinkler system did work completely offline (though it's not clear if you'd actually be able to change anything without internet - that would be a problem if not), they didn't set up an account so the system was in "offline" mode and dutifully ran the sprinklers on the last known schedule.

For the thermostat the example was physically removing the control system, which is typically not connected to the furnace through any sort of internet connection, and expecting the furnace to know what to do.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by morshu9001 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:09PM (#45659369)
Yeah both my furnace and sprinklers require a local controller to do anything, and that just maintains my settings. Idk what an internet connected version of those things looks like, but would hope it's the same except local settings can be read/written remotely.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sokoloff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#45658489)
> Despite being disconnected from the cloud service, the system kept running its schedule, when I would have expected it turn off in order to conserve water.

I'd have expected (and strongly prefer) that it keep running with whatever the last settings were. That's almost surely going to be healthier for the lawn, ornamentals, and vegetable garden than shutting off.

I would wager that most people with automated irrigation systems prefer plant growth/protection over water conservation.

I'm not sure how you'd program a furnace to run to keep a house above freezing without any temperature feedback from the house. You could potentially run it until the area immediately surrounding the furnace itself was above freezing, but that would be nowhere near enough in some cases and way, way more than needed in other cases. You might able to use outdoor weather compensation (easier/more effective/comfortable with hydronic heat distribution than with ducted air heating) if programmed correctly, but my experience is that most are either not installed or are configured to be far too hot [because call-backs are expensive and paid by the HVAC company usually].

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by andylei on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:16PM (#45658452)
your furnace doesn't know what temperature your house is if the furnace isn't connected to a thermostat
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by kenhwang on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658492)
The connection between the furnace and the thermostat probably shouldn't go through the internet.

So it's perfectly reasonable for the furnace to turn off when it is disconnected, because disconnection would be a very strong signal for an error state instead of regular intermittent network/service issues.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by InitialBP on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#45658547)
I have a nest and it's wired directly to your furnace via the thermostat control wires.

While it is controllable via the cloud, even without wifi it continues to function.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by kgermino on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658506)
Are there any furnaces that do that?

Certainly, the standard smart thermostat set up is that your ecobee is connected to the Internet, but controls the furnace using good old-fashioned signal wires

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sokoloff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#45658544)
Which is only extremely tangentially related to "if I pull my thermostat off the wall"

The overwhelmingly most common connection between a thermostat and furnace is a contact closure when calling for heat, with no ability to differentiate between “thermostat is present but not calling for heat” and “thermostat is not present” as both present as "these T-T contacts are not closed/shorted together".

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by baq on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#45658549)
the connection to my thermostat is via a cable, if I pull it out of the wall it won't be connected to anything at all. the whole furnace is not connected to anything but mains power.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by duped on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:27PM (#45658654)
They're not, "smart" thermostats have a WiFi frontend that allows devices to connect to it from the network but the thermostat itself is hardwired to the furnace/HVAC.

You could in theory put one next to the furnace in your machine closet but that would be dumb and expensive

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by luxuryballs on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:24PM (#45658580)
yeah the default in this case has to be “off” to prevent damage from running blind, on that note other things in the house should be certified to be able to handle being frozen perhaps
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dghlsakjg on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:49PM (#45659035)
Typically when people are concerned about their house freezing in cold climates, they are primarily worried about water freezing, expanding, and cracking pipes and fittings.

It is extraordinarily hard to design something that can withstand that pressure and still be fit for purpose. The item needs to be able to withstand pressures in excess of ~10k psi for -10c, with the pressure rising as temp decreases.

The standard solution for people that need to winterize a building that will not be heated is to drain as much water as possible from the lines, and then fill them with a liquid with a lower freezing point.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Ccecil on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:28PM (#45658667)
Exactly...

Fail "safe"...not Fail "keep running"

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by baq on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#45658485)
> Despite being disconnected from the cloud service, the system kept running its schedule

I'd consider this a very important feature

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by shreddit on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:17PM (#45658471)
Only two examples and you are already contradicting yourself. One service should keep running and the other should turn off in the event of loosing the connection to the “outside world”.

What we need is a “in the event of X - keep doing Y”.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by stevejb on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658496)
It isn't clear that 'conserve water' is a reasonable default position. Perhaps 'keep doing what it was programmed to be doing' would be a better position?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:21PM (#45658527)
Depends... the focus here isn't on convenience or utility, but on safety.

The furnace defaults to on to save the water pipes. The sprinkler defaults to off to conserve water as the system is potentially unmonitored and a burst pipe could cause issues.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by InitialBP on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:26PM (#45658622)
Defaulting a furnace to on certainly shouldn't be considered safe. What if it's leaking CO into your house, what if it gets dangerously hot and causes a fire?

A thermostat and controls are a necessary requirement for HVAC systems and defaulting anything to "run" if your control plane doesn't exist anymore is definitely not the safe option.

The other issue is that in almost all situations (like this one) what you think is a safe and sane default won't align with what other people think.

There should be defaults and they should be clearly defined, but I don't think it's always obvious to determine what they are.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sokoloff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:28PM (#45658664)
> What if it's leaking CO into your house

While I agree with your overall point, this clause is irrelevant to/not supportive of it. The presence of a thermostat wasn't going to help you here either and there are vastly more furnaces with connected thermostats than disconnected to worry about.

CO detectors and alarms are needed to address this risk.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by zdragnar on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:29PM (#45659666)
Your thermostat is in a far less likely place to be overloaded with CO should the alarms start going off, though. If the thermostat is gone, you have to physically go to the furnace itself or shut off power at the circuit breaker.

Freezing water pipes are bad, but a furnace running non-stop is going to exceed its duty cycle and pose a greater hazard.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by sokoloff on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @03:17PM (#45660337)
Whatever was implemented as this poorly-thought-through fail-safe would be implemented in the furnace itself, thus that furnace implementation could manage any safety-related concerns, though heating equipment is overwhelmingly rated to 100% duty cycle already. (My goal for my boiler is to have at least 22 hours per day of heating demand to ensure that I'm using the exact minimum temperature water to maintain temp in the house, to maximize efficiency.)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:54PM (#45660007)
My furnace runs pretty close to non-stop when it’s below -30 outside, I imagine a bigger concern than duty cycles if it did that when it wasn’t -30 would be that it would still be pushing the indoor temperature to 50°C above the outdoor temp.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 0x457 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:29PM (#45659674)
> What if it's leaking CO into your house, what if it gets dangerously hot and causes a fire?

Furnaces have multiple checks when they turned on, even on the dumbest furnaces. There are multiple safety mechanisms preventing it from getting too hot. CO leak - what thermostat will do for you here?

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ndsipa_pomu on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @08:44AM (#45668218)
If something is leaking CO into your house, then it's a major safety issue and needs to be immediately scrapped. Whether or not it's internet connected is the least of your worries.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by stevejb on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @04:30PM (#45661289)
> The sprinkler defaults to off to conserve water as the system is potentially unmonitored and a burst pipe could cause issues.

I had a friend in Australia who ran cattle on his farm. Failing open would waste water, but failing closed would mean dead cattle (and hundreds of thousands in losses). It depends on the application.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by JadeNB on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:16PM (#45658453)
> I moved into a new house and did not set up the lawn irrigation system. Despite being disconnected from the cloud service, the system kept running its schedule, when I would have expected it turn off in order to conserve water.

Not running when disconnected is definitely a safe default, but I'm not sure it's automatically desired. If I found out I couldn't use my sprinkler system unless it was connected to the internet, I'd be annoyed at the unnecessary gating of such functionality.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by leeter on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#45658491)
I've said for years that any smart thermostat should have a bimetallic backup that controls maximum ranges and acts in the dumbest way possible. Just max temp and min temp for AC and heat. Nothing that should ever be hit... but there nonetheless.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by mrWiz on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:21PM (#45659545)
You could just put a backup dumb thermostat in parallel with the smart one.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by close04 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:20PM (#45658520)
You can already see the “sane defaults” vary with the person.

When it comes to safety it’s a bit more clear cut. The job of a heating system is to heat so don’t turn off heating when this can endanger people and houses.

The job of a lawn irrigation system is to irrigate. Who wants a dead lawn just because the internet or wifi are down, or to conserve water only when the system is disconnected from the internet but not from electricity?

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#45658550)
Fair — honestly my expectation would be that if it could not connect to the cloud service, I should be able to configure a schedule offline.

That isn't the case, and so if the safe default is off, that definitely hampers utility, which isn't a very good selling point, heh.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bongodongobob on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#45658486)
No, the furnace shouldn't do anything. It should fail open.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by julianlam on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:23PM (#45658575)
Depends on the part of the world. If you intend on turning off your furnace in Canada, you best be prepared to winterize your house too! (Lots of cottagers do this... indoor plumbing is flushed and water is turned off at the pump, etc.)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by reaperducer on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:06PM (#45659318)
A burst pipe is preferential to a house that burns down.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bongodongobob on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:08PM (#45659344)
Without a thermostat you have no idea what the temperature is. We are talking about failure, not turning the furnace off.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by immibis on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @04:04AM (#45666110)
Surely there's some reasonable duty cycle, like (I don't live in one of those places) 10 minutes on, 50 minutes off, something like that.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ncallaway on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:43PM (#45658927)
This is the biggest reason why I look for Matter-compatible smart home devices. It means I can put them on a locked down network, with no internet access, and I know at least the Matter supported compatibility will function offline.

I think it would be smart for Matter to lean into the "offline local control" aspect of their branding and certification requirements.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by amluto on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45659194)
How easy is it to commission a Matter device onto a specific WiFi network? And how easy is it to set up a Thread network without Internet access?

I haven't actually tried this, but:

- The Home Assistant Matter commissioning tool doesn't have any documentation at all about how the network is selected AFAICS.

- The Thread organization seems extremely proud of how Thread devices can access the Internet. Apple TV doesn't seem friendly at all to preventing its Thread Border Router from forwarding to the Internet. Home Assistant's OTBR add-on has no useful configuration whatsoever AFAICS. The easiest way to get it right would seem to be to buy something like a Sonoff POE-capable Thread dongle and sticking it on a VLAN, except that those, for some reason, seem to support Thread RCP but not being a Border Router themselves, and then you're back to managing your own OTBR installation.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by WaitWaitWha on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:02PM (#45659237)
Thread as i see it currently is a locked ecosystem that cannot be breached. so far, all the Thread devices I have been interested in will only accept their own manufacturers' thread border router.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 0x457 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:34PM (#45659741)
I'm pretty sure "all the Thread devices I have been interested in will only accept their own manufacturers' thread border router." that device won't get thread/matter certified.

Are you sure this isn't a case of different matter version support? In which case, in my experience, thread border router works just fine, but the controller needs to support such devices.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by WaitWaitWha on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @06:30PM (#45662549)
I can only speak to my experience, certified devices by the largest firms will mostly not interoperate (fails around authN).

Apple: Keeps Thread credentials locked to HomeKit's border routers.

Google: Shares some credentials, but only within Google Account environment.

Amazon: TBD, but their Matter implementation is mostly cloud-tied.

Samsung: Hybrid approach; still best when used inside SmartThings, their 1.4 update seems to support for joining existing Thread networks. Still have to test it.

So, even though Thread theoretically allows full interoperability, no vendor wants to be reduced to a dumb router in someone else’s ecosystem.

there is no easy way to bridge Apple Thread to Home Assistant or Google Thread, even though it is theoretically supposed to be possible from a protocol standpoint.

If you have such solutions, let me know, because I would take full advantage of it, and will regale your contributions in multiple home automation threads.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by amluto on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @12:17PM (#45671405)
> Apple: Keeps Thread credentials locked to HomeKit's border routers.

The Home Assistant iOS app can extract the Thread credentials from Apple’s border routers and send them to Home Assistant. The documentation for what happens thereafter is not amazing.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by 0x457 on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @01:24PM (#45672312)
I have every thread device I own in both Apple Home and Google Home and it seems to be just working fine? I even remember adding some devices to google and some to apple and then sharing between them. I have border routers from both tho, maybe that's why it works?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by JaggedJax on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:03PM (#45659266)
This is one of two things I require when looking at a smart device:

1. Must work offline on my local network (like Matter through Home Assistant)

2. Must have a physical button for operation when there is no network available or someone doesn't want/have a phone.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by prmoustache on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:23PM (#45658576)
I rather feel that we don't need most so called smart devices because:

1) they aren't smart

2) they are answers to questions/need that don't exist in the first place

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by IAmBroom on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:27PM (#45658641)
While I 100% agree... that's just our opinions. The gadgets are selling. We have to deal with that.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bdangubic on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:29PM (#45658682)
same thing was said about "smart phones" but here we are... :)
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by mvanbaak on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:06PM (#45658300)
This. Also, not only offline-compatible but any anomaly from the api should result in the product simply ignoring the response. A simple check for 'does not connect' only handles totally offline mode, error in responses is a lot more common.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by mentalgear on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:17PM (#45658466)
Couldn't agree more. The main issue is the data-greed mentality that has arisen over the last 20 years or so (basically every company trying to copy Big Tech). They all want to harvest user data and make the users as dependent as possible (which also opens up the door for subscription services later on, and their walled garden won't allow users to easily move).
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by WaitWaitWha on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45659202)
This is the way.

My rule #1 in home automation is making sure none of the technology fails its original function without connection.

I implement Home Assistant to assist in homes for non-technologist. Every single thing i implement must function independently, without the vendor or any internet connection. i.e., z-Wave locks must function with or without connectivity. Switches must switch on/off with or without zigbee, and valves must be able to close/open without that wifi.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Larrikin on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:19PM (#45658507)
Home Assistant has basically built this system already with their platinum level certification.

It's a huge project but only the smaller IoT companies are taking it seriously

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by tekno45 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:15PM (#45658447)
48Hrs in a faraday cage and only power. Whatever works from inside goes on the certified offline list of features.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by xnx on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:54PM (#45660009)
> I feel like we need some sort of "Offline-First" or "Offline-Compatible" certification process for "smart" devices.

If there's a subscription, then it doesn't work offline.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by ryeguy_24 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:17PM (#45658468)
This is a very smart idea. I couldn't turn my Ring Alarm off and I was on the same Wifi connection as the system. In retrospect, it would be quite smart to switch over to local network.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by giancarlostoro on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:14PM (#45659444)
I'm genuinely shocked this isn't the default. Imagine if your fridge stopped working because it could not connect to the internet. Which I had forgotten about mine, and it did not connect for like two years, it worked just fine.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by tonymet on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:00PM (#45659206)
this is a great idea that I've been toying with too. Something like OU / Orthodox Union certification for Kosher or UL for electrical & electronic equipment. A Right-To-Operate & Right-to-Repair certification

There are a few sub-certifications:

- OF: Offline-First as you mentioned

- JE: Jailbreak-Escrow -- the firmware install keys are held in escrow and will be published if the company goes defunct -- allowing ongoing repair & control.

- FE: Firmware-Escrow -- firmware source will be published if the company goes defunct.

- FA: Firmware-Audit -- firmware is compiled by certifiers to verify BOM, security, privacy & online dependencies.

Another benefit would be a "nutrition label" showing active online traffic & data shared.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by tonymet on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:03PM (#45659251)
CTA is supposed to be providing this. They develop industry standards and help make them accessible to consumers to encourage a healthy consumer electronics marketplace.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by fortran77 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:19PM (#45659524)
And can it function either without electricity (like is your Toto Washlet flushable without power) or at least in a steady state (powered, but needs no human input, environmental sensors, or network support to operate). This is useful for shabbos modes as well as failsafe.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by Marsymars on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @03:03PM (#45660137)
> like is your Toto Washlet flushable without power

Hey, I got myself a water-pressure powered bidet so it still works without power.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by tonymet on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:30PM (#45659678)
great suggestion. I'm baffled at how many devices force a dependency from a mechanical feature --> electricity --> online control logic when the mechanical feature should work fine alone
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by blopp99 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:23PM (#45659585)
Jeff Geerling talked about it on a video about his Washer. Totally agree.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by hinkley on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:11PM (#45659397)
I had a dilemma at my longest job.

We had a monolith (but not monorepo) that had big Conway’s Law problems. We wanted to start making microservices. We had a couple sidecars that I either wrote or did reconstructive surgery on, but the few microservices we had were dumb. One created head-of-line problems for fanout, asking a question that could have been a Consul long poll. The other really could have been run entirely in Bamboo if we hadn’t cheaped out on agent size.

I killed the former, but the latter used a larger slice of all of our modules than all of the sidecars combined. It was also an offline process, writing into dark content in S3. So I could break it for an hour without anyone noticing, and in some environments I could go a full work day without rolling it back as long as I watched for production alerts (and I was on the team that did).

If I got rid of it then all library and runtime upgrades would get harder, though half the team ignored my advice anyway and then we had occasional P1s or 2s because of it.

My experience, there and elsewhere, is that offline logic of any flavor at least pays for itself in terms of code-build-test cycles, fairly quickly and self-evidently. But some people think it sounds counterintuitive and push people to “go fast” without it. Which only happens if they double down and cut more corners.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by gclawes on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:11PM (#45658395)
Isn't this kind of (but not completely) the idea behind smart device standards like Matter?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by user_7832 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:09PM (#45658360)
While I fully agree with you in principle, how would that realistically happen? Countries typically only pass laws after something major enough happens. If this was an IoT device that God forbid killed someone, sure, they'd be an outcry against it in the papers, and lawmakers may be galvanized enough to do something.

Call me cynical or just disappointed and jaded, but short of some EU consumer advocacy group pushing for it, I don't see how anything would realistically happen. 99% of laws are made after something bad-bad has already happened.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by goda90 on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:14PM (#45658424)
It could be a voluntary certification established by a private organization. There's other examples of such a thing in a bunch of industries already.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dpark on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:17PM (#45658474)
> There's other examples of such a thing in a bunch of industries already.

Often because the government is threatening to impose regulation. I’m not sure how many examples there are of industries independently choosing to collaborate to regulate themselves.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by bakugo on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @02:05PM (#45659307)
> Companies in compliance could put a badge on their products so wary consumers know who to trust.

This would only work out for the companies if the average consumer actually cared about "offline-first", which they very much don't. It would be a very small and ever shrinking market.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by hahn-kev on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:12PM (#45658404)
Same with games
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by crooked-v on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:36PM (#45658811)
Matter/Thread is pretty much that; any online features are in addition, not core functionality.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by luxuryballs on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#45658543)
I’m shocked they wouldn’t have that as a primary design approach, how absolutely depressing is that for a physical product?
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by recursive on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:11PM (#45658386)
I think the group of people who would buy something with "smart" in the name and also really care about reliability is pretty small.

For instance, most people who want a reliable mattress would buy one that doesn't require, or allow configuration.

It seems to me that most of the home automation enthusiasts are actually into configuration and troubleshooting as a hobby. And maybe doing party tricks. There's nothing wrong with that. But I don't think there are enough people to really make this badge work.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dpark on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @01:28PM (#45658673)
This is a weird take, especially in an environment where so many products are now “smart” whether you want them to be or not.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by recursive on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @03:01PM (#45660105)
If the products are smart even if I don't want them to be, it's even easier for them to not have this certification badge, even if I want them to.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dpark on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @05:23PM (#45661902)
I wasn’t talking about the hypothetical certification. I was talking about this:

> I think the group of people who would buy something with "smart" in the name and also really care about reliability is pretty small.

Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by recursive on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @06:07PM (#45662343)
Oh yes, that's true. A lot of people probably end up with smart stuff who might rather have dumb things.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by dpark on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @10:24PM (#45664253)
Definitely. I bought a smart tv because I wanted an OLED and at the time there were no dumb OLED tvs. I imagine that’s still the case.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by anotherevan on Tuesday October 21, 2025 @08:52PM (#45663727)
The best piece of home "automation" in my house is a big flashing red LED in the ceiling near the front door that is connected to a magnetic reed switch that tells us if we left the garage door open.
Re:Fallout from the AWS outage: Smart mattresses go rogue by KoftaBob on Wednesday October 22, 2025 @12:20PM (#45671456)
That's essentially what Matter + Thread is. The Matter smart home standard, which can run on the Thread wireless protocol, allows products to work without an internet connection for local controls.

Matter is pretty common on newer smart home products, while Thread is a bit newer so it's only supported on some products right now.