Polyfills fix most of the things and we are running automated end to end test on Linux, which catches most of the issues.
IMO the most difficult thing is figuring out how far the users are behind with their webview version, mostly on Linux and macOS. Windows has done thinga right with their WebView2 implementation
And the performances of webkitgtk are horrible on Linux.
The main drawback, of course, is that it ships a browser with every app.
On the contrary if it's a large app that the user spends lots of time in, then the performance overhead might well be worth it for the user.
Imagine in the first case that it requires a base load of 10 units of energy to run and gives 2 units of output, while in the second it still costs 10 units of base load energy, but now it gives 100 units of output. The base load becomes relatively irrelevant.
TBH, a lite weight polyfill for most system webview would be refreshing change to all the spa frameworks out there.
Edit: It looks like Tauri uses the following platform webview features.
https://github.com/tauri-apps/wry?tab=readme-ov-file#platfor...
More on the stack and our initial issues can be read here: https://kreya.app/blog/how-we-built-kreya/#cross-platform-gu... (from 2021)
With the Electron version of the app, we had issues running our bundled binaries on Macs with Intel chip. That caused us so many headaches that we decided for the rebuild on Tauri that we wanted to focus on one platform first (Macs with Apple chip) before supporting other platforms.
We went with Tauri 1.4 and no issues so far. Will have to check out the docs for 2.0 migration and see what that looks like.
In particular, rendering and crashing issues specific to Linux have been blockers, but Tauri 1.x also has other rendering issues on Linux that 2.0 fixed. There's little to no guidance on what's causing the stability and new rendering problems or how to fix them.
The app I worked on was a launcher that installed and managed content for an app, and the launcher invoked the app through command-line flags. Those flags arbitrarily fail to be passed in Tauri 1.x but work as expected in Tauri 2.x, but nobody we asked about it knows why.
My app needs wysiwyg editors, and JS is full of them.
Would you have any webpage or product info, possibly with screenshots?
We're building an in-house DCC with egui so I'm curious.
This is our #1 frustration with Tauri. The OS-provided system webviews are not stable, repeatable, consistent platforms to build upon.
Tauri decided that a key selling point of their platform was that Tauri builds won't bundle a browser runtime with your application. Instead, you wind up with whatever your operating system's browser runtime is. Each OS gets a different runtime.
Sounds nice on paper, but that has turned into a massive headache for us.
Safari and Edge have super finicky non-standard behavior, and it sucks. Different browser features break frequently. You're already operating in such a weird way between the tight system sandboxing and CORS behaviors (different between each browser), the subtle differences are death by a thousand cuts. And it never seems to stop stacking up. These aren't small CSS padding issues, but rather full-blown application behavior breakages. Even "caniuse.com" is wrong about the compatibility matrix with built-in web views.
To be fair, we're using advanced browser features. Animation, 2D contexts, trying to do things like pointer lock. But these are all examples of things that are extremely different between each web view.
All of this has doubled (quadrupled - with dev and prod builds behaving so differently! - but that's another story) the amount of physical testing we have to do. It takes so much time to manually test and ship. When we were building for the web, this wasn't an issue even if people used different browsers. The webviews have incredibly different behavior than web browsers.
Their rationale for using OS-provided system webviews instead of a bundled runtime baked into the installer at build time is that it would save space. But in reality all it has done is created developer frustration. And wasted so much freaking time. It's the single biggest time sink we have to deal with right now.
We were sold on Tauri because of Rust, but the system browser runtime is just such a bad decision. A self-imposed shotgun wound to the chest.
The Tauri folks have heard these complaints, and unfortunately their approach to solving it is to put Servo support on the roadmap. That's 1000% not the right fix. Servo is not even a production-ready platform. We just want Chrome.
Please just let us bundle a modern chrome with our apps. It's not saving anyone any headache with smaller programs and installer sizes. Games are already huge and people tolerate them. Lots of software is large. It's accepted, it's okay, it's normal. We have a lot of space, but we don't have a lot of time. That's the real trade off.
I want to use Rust. I want to use Chrome.
I hope the Tauri devs are reading this. It's not just from me. This is the general community consensus.
Built-in webviews are not the selling point for Tauri. Rust is.
So use Electron and FFI, it's not that hard
I tried to use Bevy (since we also use 3D) and that wasn't ready for prime time.
I thought about Iced and Imgui and several other Rust frameworks, but given our experience with Bevy we shied away from it.
We figured we'd be able to move faster and rely on a lot of existing tooling. That's been true for the most part.
You were wise. That's the biggest issue plaguing the project right now.
> curious about Rust integration though
Tauri is written in 100% native Rust, so you write Rust for the entire application backend. It's like a framework. You write eventing and handlers and whatever other logic you want in Rust and cross-talk to your JavaScript/TypeScript frontend.
It feels great working in Rust, but the webviews kill it. They're inferior browsers and super unlike one another.
If Tauri swapped OS webviews for Chromium, they'd have a proper Electron competitor on their hands.
I don’t quite understand why you have that issue in the first place. The fact they use the system webview is front, left and center on their website. It’s like you decided to use a fork because of the decorations on the back, and now complain that it’s pointy and the developers should just make it a spoon instead.
My read on it is that they didn’t understand the implications of using system webviews.
And possibly they expected Tauri would insulate them from cross-system differences without a lot of exploration.
Tauri needs a big fat warning label.
please, no.
I wish software companies had to pay the hardware they require for their users, then we would have devs using Rust instead of JS and optimizing using ASM just to save parts of cents per instance. And we wouldn't see companies like MS kill well designed and performed native apps for a electron app
I can't remember why I wanted to migrate to 2.0 now, but there was a nice-to-have that I couldn't do in 1.4. I ended up abandoning the 2.0 migration after a slew of cryptic errors, took a step back, and decided I'd be better off using Electron for my project. My app is at heart a rich UI text editor and none of the computation is that expensive. With all the value add coming from the interface, optimizing for consistency there feels right.
With Electron's UI powered by the same browser across platforms, you end up with a much more consistent experience. Makes sense to optimize for that.
> This year we've got a lot of exciting innovations in store for you, like CEF and SERVO based webviews...
From their discord.
HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43518462
No only were there UI inconsistencies, but Safari lags behind chrome with things like the Popover API and the build/codesign/CD ecosystem for Tauri is incredibly scattered.
When I was using it, IAPs were still not really an option for Tauri or at least I could not find any docs or resources about it.
I've worked on large consumer-facing web-apps where we had a dedicated QA team (and/or contracting firm) that runs visual regression testing on multiple platforms and browser versions. As a solo developer, I have no interest in being that team for my hobby project. So the tradeoff with Tauri for me was "accept that I will ship obvious UI bugs" vs "accept that I will ship a bloated binary."
Reading anecdata on forums, it seems like the only people who get up in arms over an extra 200MB are HN readers, and my app isn't really targeted at them.
It bas always been a fallacy though, as with CSS the end result can depend on the DPI scaling and the size of the display (unless you make sure it doesn't, but then you need to test different setups to be sure).
I never managed to find a set of CSS properties which made it look good in Chrome tho. And if it was a more serious project I'd probably have used SVGs instead of Unicode characters.
I think it's good to be wary of overly sensitive advice that regular users don't care about. But would a regular user realize they have 10 electron apps running and their ram is maxed out all the time?
The argument against Electron isn't just a single bloated binary, but everyone shipping an app that uses way more RAM than necessary.
In other circumstances too though, it's not great UX to demand your users quit your app once they're done with it because it eats too many resources just being idle in the background. It's an issue I have with both Electron, where idle apps waste tonnes or RAM, and with many Rust UI frameworks, where an immediate-mode architecture means they'll be consuming CPU on the background.
NSApplicationDelegate's -(BOOL)applicationShouldTerminateAfterLastWindowClosed:(NSApplication *)sender; method exists so an application can, uhh, automatically terminate after the last window closes.
https://developer.apple.com/documentation/appkit/nsapplicati...
It's not 100% consistent but if you look at Apple's applications based on single window (calculator, system preferences, etc), closing the window quits the app.
I can’t find obvious reference or when Apple started changing this, but it seems related to background app killing that is done now as well. I’m still not sure how I feel about it, but historically that wasn’t common for Mac apps.
Nowadays, apps closing themselves or being closed by the OS automatically is reasonable in a lot of cases, but Electron apps tend to hit the cases where it still is valuable to operate with the classic NeXT/OS X document-based app paradigm.
app.on('window-all-closed', () => {
if (process.platform !== 'darwin') app.quit()
})
Most Electron apps probably do exactly that. It would feel extremely out of place for a macOS app to quit just because you closed a window.Take pride in your work and respect the people using it.
I think the person you're responding to didn't actually measure if their claim is true.
Tauri however, is.
I also feel like I will have to, yet again, trot out the comment from a Slack dev that explains why they moved _from_ per-platform webviews to Chromium. This isn't new ground being charted, plenty of companies and teams have been down this path and Electron exists for a reason.
(I am not saying Electron is _good_, I am saying that Tauri isn't the holy grail people make it out to be)
It took me 2 seconds to find in Google, and you're splitting hairs if you think it being macOS-only was the point of my comment. Their second bullet point is just as true today as it was back then.
Regardless, your point stands: it's a bundled Chromium on all platforms
It's like developing sophisticated websites for IE6-era web, with ActiveX and Java applets and this new "ajax" thing on the horizon that sure sounds nice but it'll be a decade before you can actually use it for most of your users.
The very core basics are essentially the same because yea - it's just a web browser. An <h1> will be bigger than a <p>. But they are regularly multiple years out of date, have WILDLY different security and native-access models, version specific bugs, initialization and threading requirements, performance tradeoffs, styling quirks, and you might have hundreds or thousands of versions to test against which you cannot reasonably test against because they are frequently tied to specific operating system versions that you can no longer download and install, or require hardware you do not have.
So yea. IE6-era stuff. Not an exaggeration at all.
For simple stuff they work just fine, performance is generally more than good enough, and they start up faster, use fewer resources, and lead to a much smaller install. They're entirely reasonable choices. But once you push the edges of the envelope they're an absolute nightmare, and that is the entire reason Electron exists. That is what caused Electron to become the giga-powerhouse that it is now. It solved that problem, at relatively high cost, but it is incredibly obviously worth it to anyone who has dealt with native webviews in complicated ways.
Modern browsers are a completely different game, in comparison - far more consistent and up to date in aggregate. They're utterly incomparable.
What a waste of time it was fighting for Web freedom.
Additionally, the issues people find with WebkitGTK/Tauri aren't always web related, usually moreso Linux related (weird blank screens, issues with rendering certain stacked items, etc).
Good luck "testing" your video conferencing app on webkitgtk - it doesn't support webrtc! It is still useful to test your error page I suppose.
Note that this is one example among many of missing features, bugs and/or horrible performance.
Here's a preview: no notifications, no :has, no TLA.
(Not blaming the epiphany devs for the situation here to be clear)
It proves what everyone knows: that there's no reason WebRTC can't work in Tauri/Linux environments.
It also proves the point here: there are legitimate issues with the system-provided webview approach that are not always apparent.
I have one such device and Firefox and Chrome also run on it. They're slow but still usable.
Monocultures are great, as long they are the one we bet on.
Likewise I guess there is no problem that game developers mainly care about Windows, Proton is open source, so no big deal, why bother.
The browser is the actual product. An open source browser engine lowers the barrier of entry of creating new browsers.
>Likewise I guess there is no problem that game developers mainly care about Windows, Proton is open source, so no big deal
Which is why Valve recommends game developers to target Windows and use Proton for compatibility. Having one platform to target simplifies developers lives. Before developers were making bad ports to Linux because they did not have the resources to properly support another tech stacks. The value of developers being able to target a single platform can not be understated.
Though this is fundamentally a different situation as the leading implementation is closed source and is more capable.
>pretending to be "native".
The code is native. Just because something uses a library to call platform code it doesn't mean it isn't native. By that logic programs that use qt are not native because they use a cross platform api.
The Linux kernel is an implementation detail on Android, there is nothing about Linux exposed as official userspace API.
Any use of Linuxisms on Android apps is done at user's own peril and possible kick out of PlayStore.
>The Linux kernel is an implementation detail on Android
The kernel is such an important part of an operating system, you can't really ignore it as a developer even if technically it may be an implementation detail.
>Any use of Linuxisms on Android apps is done at user's own peril and possible kick out of PlayStore.
Sure, but Linux's ABI is stable and even in a world where things are moved to Zircom starnix was made to support that same ABI.
This applies to every open source project. The owners control what will be merged upstream and the direction the project will go in.
I am wondering why rendering differences between different platforms are such an issue? When building web apps, you face the same challenges, so I would assume it wouldn't be much different.
They build in Chrome and test with Chrome and then the test of the week they whine about Firefox and Safari.
Tauri does not bundle chrome with your app. This makes the bundle size much smaller. But the tradeoff is you end up rendering in whatever the default web view browser is. On Mac this will be some version of Safari (depending on MacOS version), and on Windows it will be some recent-ish Edge thing. Tauri actually has a nice page breaking this down: https://v2.tauri.app/reference/webview-versions/
This also means that a new OS release can change how your app is rendering, so a user can conceivably have a UI bug appear without updating your app.
Electron apps often fully share codebase with the Web apps, so on the app backend you implement native functionality and communicate with your app via IPC.
The question is not if Electron feels better for developers because it renders consistently.
The question is if that matters. Is it a big issue? Does any user actually care?
“We moved from X to Y and were so in love.” posts are often postcards from the honeymoon.
Of course not, it's only for Mac. If they were to support Windows and Linux, they probably would not have published this post.
Cross-platform UI is hard, even harder if you want to keep almost the exact same UI, same feature set across platforms, and potentially an online version. People moved from native applications to Qt to web stack for a reason.
Saying this as someone who works at a company that develops cross-platform desktop application that has millions of users. I can't imagine what my job would be like if we were using any other solution.
Chromium is superior to the native web view unless you have latest version of Windows or Mac.
It looks like your UI needs are pretty simple while computation is complex so the extra QA tradeoff would still be worth it for you. I'm just wondering if my experience was unusual or if rendering differences are as common as they felt to me.
Also, did you go Tauri 2.0 or 1.0? 2.0 released its first stable release while I was mid-stream on v1, and migration was a nightmare/documentation was woefully inadequate. Did they get the docs sorted out?