News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by observationist on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:29PM (#43382517)
Serbia had the LRAD systems on hand, after buying them in 2022, most likely from Genasys, but possibly from HyperSpike.

https://genasys.com/lrad-products/

It's a legal gray area in Serbia where the use against civilians isn't explicitly forbidden, so they're playing fast and loose and moving fast to crush opposition. It's better than troops just gunning people down, but for a modern, supposedly civilized country it's horrible to see.

The people in power are the type of people that use their power in these ways. The US shouldn't be supplying them. We're not the world police, we don't need to enforce global norms, and we shouldn't be selling hyperoffensive mass crowd control technology. They should be limited to Temu LRAD, or their LRAD at home; we shouldn't be providing them S-Tier dystopian authoritarian kits for DIY oppression.

The people that profited off of this are a special kind of evil. We shouldn't be outfitting dictators, gangsters, or warlords.

But, greed is good. The dollar is king. This is what happens when incentives and principles don't align.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by camilo2025 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:35PM (#43382580)
You are aware that these LRAD systems have been used against US citizens, aren't you?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:51PM (#43382781)
Police also regularly use tear gas against US citizens. These are weapons that would violate the Geneva convention, but we're okay with them to disperse a crowd.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by killjoywashere on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:38PM (#43383211)
Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) (a follow-on to the 1925 "Geneva Convention") allows for the use of riot control agents (like tear gas) for law enforcement purposes.

https://www.opcw.org/our-work/what-chemical-weapon

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ty6853 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:52PM (#43383340)
Suppressing protests in US isn't usually law enforcement, its purpose is to violate the law and suppress speech.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tptacek on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:08PM (#43383458)
The link you were just given offers clarity on that point; the definition does not hinge on the meaning of the word "riot".
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by cantrecallmypwd on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:14PM (#43383501)
In the case of the Bonus Army, it was Herbert Hoover's intent to deny a means of existence with bullets to deny existence of vets and their families even sooner. History really wants to rhyme again soon, which is unfortunate.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by labster on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:59PM (#43383800)
Don’t worry, that will never happen again, because America will never be willing to fight another war in Europe.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:48PM (#43383309)
I think that's inline with what the point the GP was trying to make. Tear gas would otherwise fall into the definition of a weapon that would violate the Geneva Convention if not for the specific earmark that its okay for law enforcement to use it.

Its a bit of a logical loop based only on definitions. Its not against the convention because the law includes the exception, but the exception otherwise goes against the principles of the convention.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lurk2 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:55PM (#43383366)
> As explained in the military manual of the Netherlands, the prohibition of the use of riot control agents as a method of warfare is inspired by the fact that use of tear gas, for example, in armed conflict “runs the danger of provoking the use of other more dangerous chemicals”. A party which is being attacked by riot control agents may think it is being attacked by deadly chemical weapons and resort to the use of chemical weapons. It is this danger of escalation that States sought to avert by agreeing to prohibit the use of riot control agents as a method of warfare in armed conflict. This motivation is equally valid in international and non-international armed conflicts.

https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/en/customary-ihl/v1/rule75

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by vpribish on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:48PM (#43384072)
finally someone bringing some reason and evidence to this stupid discussion. thank you
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:57PM (#43384129)
>This motivation is equally valid in international and non-international armed conflicts.

Okay but clearly protesters aren't going to escalate to mustard gas just because police used tear gas?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:03PM (#43384152)
I think the argument here is that its okay to use against a crowd because the risk of escalation is very low.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by soco on Monday March 17, 2025 @04:52AM (#43386377)
It's acceptable only because the authorities know the masses will accept it. And what could the masses do otherwise, gather signatures? So yes, it is how it is, until the masses somehow decide it's not - and then will get gassed again. Because the masses wishing for a change are rarely in a majority and authorities usually listen to majorities.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pas on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:46AM (#43387030)
Well, by definition yes. The job of the masses is to resist by any means available. If it starts using terrorist tactics it stops being the masses. Of course besides gathering signatures there's many other peaceful adjacent things that can be done (leftist types love the meme of a general strike, but of course civil disobedience, road blockades, and so on are all on the table), and somewhere between guerilla warfare and spray painting stencils in the night there's a fuzzy ethical line. On one side it's Taliban style "we will wait until they leave" and on the other side it's again Taliban style, but the bad things.

Mostly the masses ought to be proactive, educate itself, and so on to avoid signing conventions that have these exceptions.

Yes, I know. :/

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by killjoywashere on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:28AM (#43388979)
I think this discussion is missing a significant issue: why would a democratic government, of the people, by the people, and for the people, use tear gas? Why do British Bobbies carry batons?

The simplest answer, which is the basis of all police powers of the state: to prevent crimes against persons and crimes against property. Riotous mobs get people hurt, often killed. The businesses proximate to a protest, often small businesses, often under-insured due to cost constraints, are very likely to be severely affected by protests that turn violent. Major corporate storefronts can absorb the cost of damages, but the same damages to a mom-and-pop grocery could be the end of the business, no matter how much they sympathize with the community that is outraged. And let me reiterate what I started with: riotous mobs get people hurt, often killed.

Tear gas vs the baton is a lesser version of the observation by James B. Conant, president of Harvard University, in his autobiography: "To me the development of new and more effective gases seemed no more immoral than the manufacture of explosives and guns. . . I did not see in 1917, and do not see in 1968, why tearing a man's guts out by a high-explosive shell is to be preferred to maiming him by attacking his lungs or skin."

https://www.amazon.com/My-Several-Lives-Memoirs-Inventor/dp/...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:00PM (#43384137)
Can you elaborate on your point here? It seems that you're linking to documentation of where the exception was made, but I don't think the existence of that exception was in question here.

I don't have a dog in this fight as it were, but the GGP comment was taking issue with the exception allowing a tool that would violate the Geneva Convention in war being used against civilians in a context where law enforcement considers it crowd or riot control.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lurk2 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:54PM (#43384464)
> A party which is being attacked by riot control agents may think it is being attacked by deadly chemical weapons and resort to the use of chemical weapons. It is this danger of escalation that States sought to avert by agreeing to prohibit the use of riot control agents as a method of warfare in armed conflict.

The implication of the statement “These are weapons that would violate the Geneva convention, but we're okay with them to disperse a crowd.” is that riot agents are considered too barbaric to be deployed even in war, which is not the reason these agents are prohibited in wartime use. Instead, there was a worry that it would be too difficult to differentiate riot agents from chemical weapons (e.g. chlorine or mustard gas), which could lead the party attacked with riot agents to retaliate with chemical weapons.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Monday March 17, 2025 @07:53AM (#43387507)
Is your argument, or would you agree with governments making the argument, that the use of force should be acceptable as long as you/they know its asymmetric?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lurk2 on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:34PM (#43390830)
I made no such argument. My argument is that the claim

> These are weapons that would violate the Geneva convention, but we're okay with them to disperse a crowd.

is misleading because it implies that riot agents are comparable to chemical weapons. Riot agents are intended to disperse crowds while keeping casualties to a minimum. Chemical weapons are intended to kill people.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by sidewndr46 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:51PM (#43384740)
As opposed to citizens, who ought to just be thrilled their government is gassing them?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lazide on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:01AM (#43385079)
Nuking a non-nuclear country has less risk of MAD style escalation, yes? Same idea.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:26AM (#43385429)
Is your argument that the use of force should be acceptable as long as you know its asymmetric?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lazide on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:48AM (#43387976)
I’m not making an argument, rather an observation.

A saying I’ve heard from many folks I know who have been in the US military is ‘fair fights are for idiots’. I think it’s a common mindset in any (successful) military.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:10AM (#43388795)
For sure, I agree with that. How does that link back to having exceptions allowing law enforcement to use tear gas on civilians though?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lazide on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:12AM (#43388828)
Because civilians don’t have WMD style chemical weapons, generally? So are not an ‘MAD’ type risk. Unlike potential enemy combatants.

Morality has nothing to do with these scenarios (treaty/convention wise) near as I can tell.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _heimdall on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:36AM (#43395801)
It seems like you would agree then that the use of force should be acceptable as long as you know its asymmetric.

Am I misreading you there?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lazide on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:58AM (#43397493)
Clearly yes, you are misreading me.

If governments consider it acceptable or not has nothing to do with my opinion. Or yours.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ever1337 on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:20PM (#43393323)
This would be all well and good except that society is not actually constructed by neutral arbiters outside the world, as much as certain parties have their pretensions to that -- they are created by the interactions of interested parties. In other words: class struggle.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by sa46 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:27PM (#43383118)
The Geneva Convention bans all chemical weapons. Part of the rationale for a total ban is to avoid escalating to more dangerous chemical agents. Helpful r/AskHistorians thread:

https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/gwtj89/the_c...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:39PM (#43383226)
> Part of the rationale for a total ban is to avoid escalating to more dangerous chemical agents

Chemical weapons are tactically useless for modern militaries [1]. You’re pretty much always better off pounding with high explosives.

And there isn’t a known path to escalation potential. If there were, everyone would be developing it.

[1] https://acoup.blog/2020/03/20/collections-why-dont-we-use-ch...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:49PM (#43383318)
Chemical weapons are tactically useless to the American combat doctrine, as described in that article. As we have seen, the Russian doctrine (and Ukraine's doctrine) relies on much more brute force to push a meter at a time and much more indiscriminate damage. It's hard to imagine chemical weapons being useless.

He makes the mistake of looking at how the US military fights and thinking that is the only way to fight a war. Incidentally, if you looked at how the Roman army used short swords and concluded that "long swords are useless for fighting a war," I bet he would have something to say about it.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by jncfhnb on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:04PM (#43383421)
Russian tactics have been largely ineffective and characterized by horrendous losses despite immense advantages in manpower and material
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:16PM (#43383512)
Russian tactics have worked so far in Ukraine, as gruesome as that is.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by zozbot234 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:21PM (#43383552)
That very much depends on what you mean by "worked". And it's not like Western militaries are lacking the physical means to engage in heavier and more damaging attacks; they just have viable alternatives that they prefer.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by spwa4 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:01PM (#43384139)
1) Putin has conquered more population than he lost (even just counting fighting age men)

2) Putin has conquered more money/value/resources than he lost due to the conflict (by a factor of 10, maybe 100)

3) Even Ukraine's European allies seem to agree that Putin will get a ceasefire and sanctions relief where he gets to keep what he conquered

It's true that Russia did not achieve it's war goals (destruction or total control of Ukraine, and let's just not talk about the outright embarrassing "in 3 days" part), but they got quite a bit. Perhaps even more important, they got more than enough to make the conflict, at least potentially, a net positive for Putin.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by snozolli on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:08AM (#43385596)
Putin has conquered more population than he lost (even just counting fighting age men)

What a weird metric. More civilians subjugated than soldiers lost?

it's war goals (destruction or total control of Ukraine

Russia wants to destroy the Ukrainian cultural identity. It's cultural genocide, and it's been a goal of theirs for hundreds of years. This is why they steal Ukrainian children and ship them off to be adopted in Russia.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by spwa4 on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:30AM (#43388410)
I agree it's weird. But it's the metric, I think, that most determines if Putin can just start another war in 2 years, 5 years, 10 years. That's my reason for why it's important. It determines the next phase of the war.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by jncfhnb on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:15PM (#43425206)
They’ve worked, at great cost, against Ukraine. They wouldn’t work against a more powerful foe with air superiority.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by strken on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:21PM (#43383929)
Why would e.g. sarin be useful for indiscriminate damage when A) you could drop a conventional or thermobaric bomb instead, and B) you can circumvent sarin by wearing a $200 suit from AliExpress? I'm not seeing how it's meant to fit into Russian military doctrine other than in niche circumstances.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by dboreham on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:18PM (#43384584)
It's much cheaper. Read the book "The Dead Hand" for details.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by strken on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:32PM (#43384644)
If you give me a specific quote from the book I'll be able to understand what you mean a bit better.

I know there's a quote floating around which gives the figure of $2000/km^2 for conventional weapons, $800 for sarin etc., $600 for nuclear, and $1 for biological. I'll respond to that.

The problem is, those numbers are for attacking civilians. You can of course make the argument that Russian military doctrine includes massacring civilians, but I would respond that not only is sarin more expensive against modern military targets, it's outright ineffective against them if they're prepared.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:07PM (#43384534)
> He makes the mistake of looking at how the US military fights and thinking that is the only way to fight a war

Keep reading.

"And, so, where do we still see chemical weapons used? In static-system vs. static-system warfare. Thus, in Syria – where the Syrian Civil War has been waged as a series of starve-or-surrender urban sieges, a hallmark of static vs. static fighting – you see significant use of chemical weapons, especially as a terror tactic against besieged civilians. The limited manpower and capabilities of regime forces have caused the war to deteriorate into a series of sieges, sometimes stretching out years (fighting in Aleppo lasted for four years, for instance; the final siege itself ran from February 2014 to its conclusion in December 2016). Anti-regime forces are often poorly equipped (often completely unable, for instance, to engage regime air-assets) and the civilian populace was completely unprotected against chemical munitions, making them far more vulnerable targets.

But a major factor here is actually weakness, in the Syrian regime forces. Assad simply didn’t have a lot of modern air-to-ground munitions; chemical munitions weren’t being compared for cost- and mission-effectiveness against such modern weapons, but against barrels loaded with explosives, nails and scrap – weapons which would have been primitive by the standards of the 1940s, much less now. And – let’s be honest here – his ground forces lack manpower, but also perform quite poorly. Remember: the question for the effectiveness of chemical weapons is value-over-replacement – while the vulnerability of anti-regime forces increased the value, we also must note that Assad’s heavily weakened, static system forces also substantially reduced the value of the replacement. In a fight between what are, in the last analysis, two weak forces, the calculation on the effectiveness of chemical weapons changes."

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:17PM (#43384578)
I read the analysis. I think he's being far too dismissive of the doctrinal considerations in his analysis. Frankly, he is also not an expert on modern warfare in any way, too.

There is a good book called "eating soup with a knife" (and the author has given talks on this) that talks about the importance of doctrine and culture in constructing a fighting force (in this case, the book is mostly about counterinsurgency doctrine and how the American and British militaries are uniquely unsuited to it). An American-style doctrine simply does not work in Russia, even given unlimited resources, because of how the culture and the military work. The weapons are then built to fit the doctrine, not the other way around.

In other words, the "static system" actually is the way to get the Russian military (and the Ukrainian military) to work. That difference in doctrine, by the way, caused a lot of headaches because US weapons are not made for it.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:28PM (#43384625)
> the "static system" actually is the way to get the Russian military (and the Ukrainian military) to work

Well, yes. They've been unable to launch combined-arms maneouvres. They failed to establish even air supremacy against decades-old NATO air defence kit. Russia has to fight the way it does because it's unable to fight more effectively.

The author's core point stands: we didn't outlaw chemical weapons because of any moral reasons, we outlawed them because the world's leading militaries don't need them. In cases where they have tactical value, lo and behold, they get used.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:50PM (#43384736)
On that point we agree, that the world's leading militaries don't need them. However, they are a tool that increases the effectiveness of other militaries.

I disagree with him that the specific combined arms shock doctrine is what make those militaries the world's leading ones. Those militaries are leading because they have the best people, weapons, and training, and a combined arms shock doctrine fits with their culture.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:59PM (#43384776)
> they are a tool that increases the effectiveness of other militaries

Sure. Which is why the world's leading militaries banned them. OP said we banned chemical weapons "to avoid escalating to more dangerous chemical agents." There is simply no evidence we were that high minded.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by sidewndr46 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:53PM (#43384754)
Chemical weapons are useless because they're expensive and ineffective. It's not like they haven't been deployed on the battlefield before.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by D_Alex on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:03PM (#43384151)
>Chemical weapons are tactically useless for modern militaries

The defense of Azovstal steelworks and Gaza tunnels seems to show otherwise.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by oooyay on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:41PM (#43390349)
> Chemical weapons are tactically useless for modern militaries [1]. You’re pretty much always better off pounding with high explosives.

Maybe you know something I don't but in country we were always MOPP Ready:

    MOPP Ready – Protective mask is carried. First set of suit, gloves, and boots are available within two hours, second set within six hours.
My mask was usually in the truck or in my pack. We qualify with our masks on a yearly basis. It could be argued that the chance of chemical deterrents that require MOPP 0 and above is negligible due to the our current landscape but that can honestly change based on the opponent or geography.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by conception on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:37PM (#43383194)
Generally if you do it to your own people the world is fine with.. just about anything.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by s1artibartfast on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:50PM (#43383320)
Serbia is currently using it on its own people, and yet we here we are reading about it and discussing, with no small amount of outrage.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _carbyau_ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:47PM (#43384725)
I similarly condemn such actions. But unless we are in a position to enforce any change in behaviour on Serbia then being unhappy on a web forum doesn't count. It's as useful as "thoughts and prayers".

Take some meaningful action away from this forum and we'll see. I am not in a meaningful position to do so unfortunately.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by s1artibartfast on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:57PM (#43390480)
Action isnt the only measure of meaning or the only determinate of caring.

Caring exists on a spectrum, and isnt black and white.

Thoughts and prayers are a form of caring as well, and an important one. It isn't always what a utilitarian wants, but it is part of a package deal when working with real humans with emotional and social lives.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _carbyau_ on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:03PM (#43394176)
I think you and I are largely in agreement in that caring is good.

But as far as Serbia is concerned "no meaningful consequence = the world is fine with.. just about anything."

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tbrownaw on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:33PM (#43383164)
> These are weapons that would violate the Geneva convention, but we're okay with them to disperse a crowd.

Isn't that a category ban that came out of a couple specific members of that category that were used and had particularly nasty effects? And then countries' domestic law enforcement rules tend to be defined in different terms.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by EA-3167 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:42PM (#43383249)
It is. People think that the "Frangible bullets and teargas banned by the Genevan Conventions" means that they're seen as too cruel to use in war. Unfortunately the "wisdom of crowds" that we've created on social media has decided that it does.

The reality is that we're talking about the views of people in 1925, as informed by a previous group of people in the late 1800's. They were far more concerned with avoiding the use of gas as a weapon than in dealing with the LD50 of the various gasses.

Likewise with frangible/hollow-point ammunition, it isn't even banned by the Geneva Conventions, it was banned under the now-defunct Hague Convention. For better or worse they thought that these "tumbling" or "expanding" bullets were designed to inflict intentionally greater suffering. Who knows maybe the versions that existed in the late 1800's did too, the ones today aren't used because they're worthless against even modest body armor.

But again, people just see text on a picture in a meme and take it to heart.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:42PM (#43384030)
> Who knows maybe the versions that existed in the late 1800's did too

The ones now and back then aren't any different. They do inflict greater suffering when the injury isn't immediately lethal. They essentially maim the target.

There's a legitimate case to be made for home defense because they won't penetrate common building materials nearly as far. It makes them much safer to anyone in the surrounding area.

There are also cases where the additional stopping power is invaluable, for example against a pack of dogs.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by EA-3167 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:57PM (#43384126)
You can argue that any GSW that isn't immediately lethal inflicts suffering, I'm not sure how an expanding head changes that. In a handgun round mushrooming is absolutely about terminal ballistics rather than protection against over-penetration, but it is true that expanding .223 and frangible rounds are focused on over-penetration

But again the biggest reason you don't see expanding rounds in war is (especially modern) armor defeats them far more easily than standard .223.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:15AM (#43385395)
An argument that modern body armor has largely negated the incentive does not imply that the ethical concerns don't exist. They are entirely separate points of discussion.

> You can argue that any GSW that isn't immediately lethal inflicts suffering, I'm not sure how an expanding head changes that.

It's a matter of intent and degree. If we collectively threw up our hands every time we encountered a grey area we'd never be able to agree on anything.

The point is that in the event that a weapon fails to kill the target, there are ethical concerns if it does more damage, particularly long term damage, than absolutely necessary. There's no need to make warfare even worse than it already is.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by int_19h on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:04PM (#43384164)
Except they are used today. Russian 5.45 is famously highly prone to tumbling due to its design with bubble of air in the front of the bullet (even more so than rifle rounds in general). If we look at American 5.56mm, the original M193 was prone to fragmenting, which the original study reports on what would eventually become M16 noted as the reason why it's capable of creating more devastating wounds then the then-standard M80 ball. And modern M855A1 fragments even more reliably (at lower velocities) while still punching through armor.

Pretty much any OTM round is effectively expanding and/or fragmenting (depending on velocity) as well...

So for all practical purposes this convention hasn't been followed for literally decades now. The pretense is that we claim that all these bullet designs just happen to do what they do. Although IIRC the US military authorized use of 9mm JHP in some circumstances, as well, so I think even that veneer is mostly gone by now.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by laweijfmvo on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:15PM (#43383005)
are they against the Geneva convention because of the direct effects, or because in a war you’d then proceed to kill everyone while they’re coughing?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by seabass-labrax on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:31PM (#43383154)
It's because of the direct effects; chlorine gas for instance will almost instantly blind anyone exposed to it, and tear gas can also be fatal. My great-grandfather was gassed in the First World War and only narrowly survived. Chemical weapons were technically already banned by this point, but it was WW1 that prompted the modern Geneva Protocol (not the Geneva Conventions; these are slight different). Unfortunately, none of the Geneva treaties cover their use outside of wartime.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:01PM (#43384795)
Many people don't realize this but many of the banned weapons are ones with a decent chance of maiming people but leaving them alive. This is worse for everyone involved in a war (everyone here meaning politicians and generals, not soldiers) than killing them. Cluster munitions, flamethrowers, and anti-personnel mines all fit in this category, too.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by NewJazz on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:23PM (#43383077)
AIUI they are mainly banned because they could lead to escalations in chemical weapons usage. If your enemy uses tear gas vs cs gas, it could be hard to tell right away and you might feel pressure to use all the tools you have available (including lethal chemical weapons) vs. Play by the rules.

Of course if you are fighting a real war, there is probably going to be chem weapons used. It happened in Syria. It is happening in Ukraine. It will keep happening. Geneva convention is wishful thinking.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tehjoker on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:34PM (#43383169)
something to consider is that in the Gulf War (Operation Desert Storm) the military used a bunker buster on a Sarin gas storage facility and shot the sarin high into the atmosphere, where it then floated far downwind and landed on US troops. Ofc, reporting on it doesn't really consider Iraqi civilians and is only weepy about US soldiers.

https://www.utsouthwestern.edu/newsroom/articles/year-2022/s...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:46PM (#43384053)
> Geneva convention is wishful thinking.

It is a convention. It is useful for applying pressure. It certainly seems to reduce their use.

You could as well say that laws against murder or theft or whatever are wishful thinking.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by NewJazz on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:58PM (#43384486)
Murder is generally punished. Unless you spew pollutants with known biological harm leading to numerous cancerous deaths and cover it up and pay off enough politicians. Then it is generally rewarded or at least tolerated.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by jvanderbot on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:18PM (#43383034)
Both? Indiscriminate chemical weapons is the issue, not the intent. Otherwise wouldn't all weapons be illegal?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by seabass-labrax on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:39PM (#43383229)
Some weapons are intrinsically forbidden because of their effects on individuals: soft-point bullets for instance. These are as discriminate as you want them to be, but are nonetheless prohibited in conflicts. Thus it's not just indiscriminate weapons that are banned by international agreement!
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by jvanderbot on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:01PM (#43392701)
When asked why tear gas is banned, the answer I gave was "the weapon is indiscriminate and chemical" not "all banned weapons are indiscriminate and chemical".

For example lasers used to blind soldiers are generally banned as well and as you point out, lasers are basically arbitrarily discriminate.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by numpad0 on Monday March 17, 2025 @03:29AM (#43385997)
Most of Geneva Convention items are things that are huge liabilities to the own sides. e.g., there were such chemical gases that react with gas mask filters so to specifically bypass filtering. No one in Europe wants to pay welfare costs for factory leaks or downwind collateral damages in neighboring countries or army of veterans maimed with that thing, but they will have to if their enemies would use it to their advantages. Agreeing to a universal ban solves that problem.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by amelius on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:14PM (#43382997)
What would ICC think of it, I wonder.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:17PM (#43383014)
The ICC is fine with it. France is a particularly big fan of firing tear gas canisters at protestors. It's not just the US.
[dead]
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by matthewdgreen on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:32PM (#43383640)
Tear gas and more lethal gasses were extensively used in WWI. Afterwards the various belligerents came to an agreement on which weapons were acceptable, and they specifically decided to include tear gas in that ban. There were various reasons they did this (fear of escalation to lethal gasses was the biggest concern) but one specific reason was the indiscriminate nature of the gas as well as the fact that it can cause unnecessary suffering. It is true that the Geneva Convention only bans tear gas for warfare, and allowed it for military riot control. The CWC then banned it even for those military applications in the 1990s. Some of the arguments made against the use of tear gas in military applications (in the 1920s and 1990s) also make good arguments for minimizing or eliminating its use in law enforcement settings.

Rationalists like to reduce everything to a simple black and white argument, which tends to inject imprecision and bad understanding into the discourse.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:39PM (#43383688)
>one specific reason was the indiscriminate nature of the gas

What are you talking about? The canisters launched by police are probably as discriminate as you can be when firing into a crowd. Are you expecting some sort of weapon that can precisely target the rioters in a crowd but leave everyone alone?

>as well as the fact that it can cause unnecessary suffering.

In the sense that "tear gas is just mustard gas", or "protesters have every right to be there and therefore any sort of discomfort is 'unnecessary suffering'"? What amount of "suffering" would you find acceptable?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:27PM (#43383959)
I largely agree with what you wrote.

> Rationalists like to ...

But then you tacked this on to the end and it's entirely unnecessary. The linked article is actually a very good one about recognizing bad faith use of labels.

It just doesn't really apply in this case because the original point (at least by my reading) wasn't a gotcha relying on the definition of a label but rather was using a label that the author believes is legitimate to point out the seeming inconsistency.

Of course whether or not the label is legitimate is itself perfectly reasonable to discuss.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by matthewdgreen on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:14PM (#43390643)
My problem with the linked argument -- and specifically, with the idea of linking it and not so much the argument -- is that it takes a statement with validity and then tries to use a kind of rhetorical trick to argue that it's false. It is not false, which is the entire point of my post, and those rhetorical cookbook tricks harm understanding and lead us away from truth, because the world is full of nuance and complexity.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by axus on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:25PM (#43383585)
Or "murder is wrong, because God said so"
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:41PM (#43383701)
This isn't a case of a noncentral fallacy.

> "Tear gas is bad because it violates the Geneva convention" makes as much sense as "MLK is a bad person because he's a criminal".

Not really, no. The Geneva Convention has specific reasoning and rationale for making tear gas illegal during warfare, which does apply to tear gas and make perfect sense.

That's not the same thing as saying taxation is theft, or MLK is bad.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:46PM (#43383725)
>Not really, no. The Geneva Convention has specific reasoning and rationale for making tear gas illegal during warfare, which does apply to tear gas and make perfect sense.

Mind elaborating? The arguments in sibling comments seem to be some variant of "avoid escalating to more dangerous chemical agents". I don't see how that's relevant to protests. Are we seriously expecting the protesters to escalate to mustard gas because the police used tear gas?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:56PM (#43383780)
Even if mustard gas escalation is unlikely in protests, the reasoning behind banning the use of tear gas on protesters still matters:

1. The ban sends a clear message: chemical weapons of any kind are too dangerous to use on people. That's a good and important message to send.

2. If a government uses tear gas on its own citizens but condemns it in war, it creates a moral contradiction (even if the government don't see it that way).

3. Normalization - just as in war, allowing tear gas domestically could open the door to more severe measures over time. Maybe not mustard gas, but you know, that's not the only possible escalation.

4. When the government are describing peaceful protesters as "terrorists", and abducting them pending illegal deportation, arguing to give them carte blanche on using sonic and chemical weapons to suppress protest is... Well, it's kinda fascist. I don't know a nicer way to say it. Context matters.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:04PM (#43383834)
>1. The ban sends a clear message: chemical weapons of any kind are too dangerous to use on people. That's a good and important message to send.

This is begging the question. The topic being discussed is whether "all chemical weapons (including tear gas) are bad". You can't use "we should ban all chemical weapons because it sends a clear message that all chemical weapons are bad" as a reason to justify that, it's circular reasoning.

> 2. If a government uses tear gas on its own citizens but condemns it in war, it creates a moral contradiction (even if the government don't see it that way).

It's only a moral contradiction when people fall for the non-central fallacy that all chemical weapons are bad. Pepper spray is technically a "chemical weapon", but the average person isn't going to think that someone using a pepper spray is somehow comparable to Germans flooding the front lines with mustard gas.

>3. Normalization - just as in war, allowing tear gas domestically could open the door to more severe measures over time.

You can literally say that about any other bad thing that police does. It's not specific to tear gas, or the geneva convention.

>4. When the government are describing peaceful protesters as "terrorists", and abducting them pending illegal deportation, arguing to give them carte blanche on using sonic and chemical weapons to suppress protest is... Well, it's kinda fucking fascist. I don't know a nicer way to say it.

This is obvious a derail, and has nothing to do with the use of tear gas.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:23AM (#43386549)
> This is begging the question.

It's not. It's about setting a clear legal line.

> It's only a moral contradiction when people fall for the non-central fallacy that all chemical weapons are bad.

Who's begging the question here?

> You can literally say that about any other bad thing that police does.

Maybe police shouldn't be doing bad things? ... And maybe supporting them when they do bad things is also bad?

> This is obvious a derail, and has nothing to do with the use of tear gas, or the geneva convention.

Fascists and chemical weapons are not separate questions, because fascists are known to use extreme measures when suppressing dissent; systematically escalating past all previous reasonable lines.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:45AM (#43388554)
>It's not. It's about setting a clear legal line.

Which one is it? Are you sticking to the exact wording of the law (ie. that all chemical weapons are banned), or the principle (that we shouldn't use substances like mustard gas against combatants)? If you're going to stick to the exact wording, you should also note that the geneva convention only applies to conflicts between countries, so chemicals weapon use by police forces don't contravene it. There's no "legal line" being broken.

>Who's begging the question here?

It really isn't, given that I have plenty of other objections that don't depend on using the non-central fallacy, and the comment you replied to doesn't even mention the non-central fallacy.

>Maybe police shouldn't be doing bad things? ... And maybe supporting them when they do bad things is also bad?

I'm not sure how you got the impression, given that I specifically said otherwise in my previous comment:

"But that's fine, because you can still object to those things even if they're not banned by the geneva convention."

>Fascists and chemical weapons are not separate questions, because fascists are known to use extreme measures when suppressing dissent; systematically escalating past all previous reasonable lines.

None of this has anything to do with the geneva convention or the use of tear gas. Moreover this presumes that if it wasn't for tear gas, police would stand down, when realistically speaking they'll just escalate to more lethal weapons.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mandmandam on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:33AM (#43389017)
> this presumes that if it wasn't for tear gas, police would stand down, when realistically speaking they'll just escalate to more lethal weapons.

When cops use tear gas on peaceful protesters, a sizable segment of the population shrugs. That's nor the case when "more lethal weapons" are used.

Do you have stocks in tear gas manufacturers or something? This endless sea lioning is super weird. Every attempt to explain what the noncentral fallacy actually is and why it doesn't apply here just seems to leave you more confused, so I'mma stop trying. Good luck!

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by beepbooptheory on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:36PM (#43383667)
I believe you have misunderstood this (extremely dumb) article.

The idea and significance of the proper noun 'The Geneva Convention' is a much different class than just a noun like 'criminal' or 'murder'. The point of invoking it is not to hide behind an abstraction, but in fact to appeal to something specific.

Unless you just read that article as "how to be uncharitable," your point does not make any sense.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:42PM (#43383706)
>The idea and significance of the proper noun 'The Geneva Convention' is a much different class than just a noun like 'criminal' or 'murder'. The point of invoking it is not to hide behind an abstraction, but in fact to appeal to something specific.

What is it appealing to then? When you say "violates the Geneva convention", I'm thinking of things like genocide, killing of civilians, and soldiers in trenches choking to death because they couldn't put their gas mask in time. None of that applies to tear gas.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by beepbooptheory on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:29PM (#43383971)
Insofar as you want to continue to charge this fallacy here, it doesn't really matter because "the Geneva Convention" is not, per the cited article, a "category whose archetypal member gives us a certain emotional reaction." It is something specific that happened/exists, and in that it has no "archetypal member." Whether you specifically have an emotional reaction to it is beyond the point, and in fact beyond gp's point. If you take the argument minimally charitably its just pointing out an inconsistency between what was at once point judged to be bad by an international community, and the actions of one member of that community today.

But further, do you really, in good faith, think gp was trying to form some airtight logical argument against the use of tear gas? Do you think its possible they were maybe just pointing something interesting out? What actual motive could you have to try and create this very thin gotcha here? Can you maybe step back and see how sealioning like this just adds noise?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gruez on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:55PM (#43384110)
>Insofar as you want to continue to charge this fallacy here, it doesn't really matter because "the Geneva Convention" is not, per the cited article, a "category whose archetypal member gives us a certain emotional reaction." It is something specific that happened/exists, and in that it has no "archetypal member."

The exact phrasing used in the quoted post was "violate the Geneva convention". I don't know about you, but "violate the Geneva convention" does give me an emotional reaction.

>If you take the argument minimally charitably [...]

Like you're doing above by some clever rewording?

>its just pointing out an inconsistency between what was at once point judged to be bad by an international community, and the actions of one member of that community today.

I seriously doubt any member of "the international community" thinks that tear gas is somehow comparable to a war crime or using mustard gas, or that it's somehow extra bad because it's a chemical weapon. Moreover if you really want to cling onto what was written (ie. "no chemical weapons") vs what's intended (ie. "no mustard gas deployed in the trenches"), the geneva convention also has a specific carve-out for domestic use.

>BBut further, do you really, in good faith, think gp was trying to form some airtight logical argument against the use of tear gas? Do you think its possible they were maybe just pointing something interesting out? What actual motive could you have to try and create this very thin gotcha here?

Because I think it's interesting to point out how the non-central fallacy might apply here :^)

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:32PM (#43383981)
> this (extremely dumb) article

What's dumb about it? People often use labels in bad faith. I'd think that learning to recognize that is a good thing.

Of course the larger issue is that you are unlikely to be able to have a constructive dialogue with someone who is engaging in such tactics. Pointing out that someone is behaving poorly rarely solves the issue. I think it's still useful to be able to recognize the pattern though.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by BobaFloutist on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:45PM (#43384050)
How do you feel about the defensive use of pepper spray?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:36PM (#43384667)
You asked the wrong person. I would rather that people ditched pepper spray for defensive uses altogether and carried guns instead.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Y_Y on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:08PM (#43384195)
Ya, and what about high-velocity lead spray?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by kazinator on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:55AM (#43385540)
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mightyham on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:04PM (#43384160)
It is an obvious fallacy to conflate the usage of tear gas canisters with the usage of mustard gas in WWI. They differ drastically in amount/concentration, area of effect, and long term health risks, thus should be treated differently in considering their usage.

Tear gas clearly sits on a spectrum of non-lethal arms with various other options that are more or less harmful. While it's entirely fair to criticize its use on a case by case basis, insofar as disorderly public gatherings can have varying levels of violence/destruction, it would stand to reason that some instances warrant the use of tear gas.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by _DeadFred_ on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:56PM (#43391044)
24/7 lighting of prisoners so they can't sleep is torture, unless it's the American police and they need to keep the lights on for 'safety'.

Electro shock torture is illegal... unless it's the cops using a taser to get a desired behavior/compliance.

Police use > legally defined torture/war crimes.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by spacecadet on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:43PM (#43383256)
My American Citizen score card:

LRAD + Tear gas 2009

Tear gas 2017

Tear gas 2021

Still got the exhausted canister from 2009 as a souvenir. Carry a bottle of water, the tear gas rinses out quickly.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by observationist on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:49PM (#43382754)
Yes - we've got a long way to go with regards to these technologies.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by hammock on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:42PM (#43382659)
When?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by perching_aix on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:49PM (#43382755)
Here you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-range_acoustic_device#Uni...

Was an especially commonly discussed topic in 2020 during the George Floyd related protests. Some notable video resources on how to defend against these devices and what one can expect: [0] and [1]. To save you time, if i remember correctly, the most effective is one of those plastic riot shields held in reverse to direct the sound back at the sender (notably pretty difficult when you don't want to just hit other protesters, or don't know where the sound is coming from and/or are getting hit by reflections).

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXKTBQBugIA

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3sqIvak-4Ek

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by worldsayshi on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:48PM (#43382746)
Apparently used multiple times during Black Lives Matter protests: https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2020/06/04/204368...
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by alborzb on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:46PM (#43382714)
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ofcourseiwasone on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:40PM (#43383694)
I went hiking in Honolulu once with this woman who worked for the US gov I met on tinder. We went through this bamboo grove behind the city. All of sudden there was this overwhelming tiredness that took me over and I had to sleep. I needed to sit down by a rock and fell asleep very quickly. Then I woke up really quickly but it seemed like avea have passed. It was crazy. I was super healthy back then and don't have any issues or take any medicines. It was crazy, let me tell you, that woman was very precise but very strange.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by orochimaaru on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:51PM (#43384744)
They have been used against US citizens in the United States? That is news to me.

If they have been used in other countries against US diplomatic corps that is an act of war.

Now if a US citizen uses a visit to a foreign country to protest against a government they’re on their own. I’m sorry, but US citizens shouldn’t be engaging in that and the US state department has no obligation to protect that condition.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ruined on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:08PM (#43384820)
it's actually quite common. i have personally experienced use of LRAD by police as a weapon.

the first actual use of LRAD by police as a weapon in the united states was possibly in 2009

https://www.aclupa.org/news/2012/11/14/city-pittsburgh-settl...

though it is known to have been deployed but not used as a weapon earlier than that.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ruined on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:45AM (#43396116)
but to clarify, i don't think the video posted by OP shows use of an LRAD. that is something else
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by dole on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:26AM (#43385202)
Used in 2014 against protesters in Ferguson.

https://slate.com/technology/2014/08/lrad-long-range-acousti...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pjc50 on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:04AM (#43386755)
The US has also in some places explicitly legalized the use of cars as a lethal weapon against protestors: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/21/us/politics/republican-an...
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lazyeye on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:53AM (#43385325)
It doesn't matter what it is, or where it's happening in the world, the conversation always comes back to the US. Always.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by dewyatt on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:18PM (#43430923)
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tonyhart7 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:35PM (#43382570)
the only acceptable condition to use it maybe if there are riot or violence breakout in that area not for peaceful protest
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:05PM (#43382913)
If you were at a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy and somebody used one of these on you, what would you do? I'd either come back prepared for actual violence, or switch from protest to sabotage.

It just screams "escalation" to me.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:42PM (#43383245)
> If you were at a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy and somebody used one of these on you, what would you do?

Leave. The moment it turns into a riot you’re doing damage to your cause. (If you’re in a protest and see hooligans, restrain them.)

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:06PM (#43383435)
You might enjoy reading Rules for Radicals if you haven't already. If your riot can provoke a worse response from the authority, it can help your cause. The reaction is the action.

It may be that this protest in Serbia got a bit rowdy and riotous (see "diversity of tactics") and now the headline is about the government's use of a disproportionate weapon against protestors, not about a riot.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tptacek on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:10PM (#43383468)
Rules for Radicals is one of my favorite books and I don't think this an accurate summary of what Alinsky says, at all. It's a short book, you can get it for free online, people should just read it.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by krainboltgreene on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:12PM (#43383878)
This tracks so much with what you’ve said before.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:14PM (#43384562)
> You might enjoy reading Rules for Radicals if you haven't already. If your riot can provoke a worse response from the authority

One motif of Allinsky's message is the importance of organisation. Triggering tear gas against your peaceful protest is one thing. Losing control of it such that stores start getting looted is not.

> It may be that this protest in Serbia got a bit rowdy and riotous (see "diversity of tactics") and now the headline is about the government's use of a disproportionate weapon against protestors

This is the first-order effect. They got a tweet. (Not a headline.)

I'm sceptical they'll get a second because this isn't a clear case of a nonlethal weapon being used against a peaceful crowd, it's something more muddled, and as a result there are zero comments in this thread discussing what the protesters are protesting.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:06AM (#43385107)
> They got a tweet. (Not a headline.)

They got a headline https://apnews.com/article/serbia-protest-sonic-weapon-85025...

> Serbian officials deny illegal sonic weapon attack on peaceful protesters

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:27PM (#43384619)
Just for the sake of the thread, these are "anti-corruption" protests. It is essentially a mass vote of no confidence in the government. The immediate inciting incident was the collapse of a railway station in Novi Sad that killed a bunch of people, but it has turned into much more.

It's been going since November. I wouldn't be surprised if this is the prelude to a civil war.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Kostic on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:09AM (#43386781)
This happened during 15 minutes of silence for 15 persons that died in the collapse. Everyone was silent and mourning.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by hellotomyrars on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:55PM (#43383776)
Who defines what counts as a riot?

The people who have the state-sanctioned monopoly on violence are the ones who get to decide when a protest becomes a riot or unlawful assembly.

I’m not saying they’re always wrong but when only one group gets to pull the card that allows them to shut down protest it creates perverse incentives.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:10PM (#43384542)
> Who defines what counts as a riot?

Practically, the media and the public at large. I forgot the source, but you can pretty much directly see the negative effect of e.g. bridge blocking on public sympathy for a cause.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by hippari2 on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:23AM (#43385417)
I think it's pretty much a useless protest if everyone leaves the moment it become "a bit rowdy". Not to mention that if you meditate for long enough of time ( which is like the most peaceful kind of protest ) the Police will Spray / LDAR you anyway.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by consteval on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:46AM (#43388563)
I don’t think this is true. In order for the media to consider something a riot there has to be some violence. Gone are the days of print media, we expect videos now.

But it’s trivial for police to incite violence. We saw it all the time in the US during BLM protests. A protest starts peacefully, then the protesters are pushed by riot control, then rubber bullets are fired into the peaceful protest, and now it’s not peaceful. Sometimes the protesters would even get surrounded and flanked so they can’t escape the descent into a riot.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ty6853 on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:02AM (#43388718)
Yep, if you are depending on perception by media you have already lost. They will manipulate it to look however they like, trivially and convincingly.

If change does occur, what will happen is they will repaint history to make it seem as if the most cowish placid of the protests brought the change, to fool the public. And people actually believe it.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:31PM (#43383633)
That's good advice, but I mean what do you do when you get home? Now that your right to assemble has been effectively revoked, what's your next step?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by s1artibartfast on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:40PM (#43383697)
Plan a legal assembly, an economic protest, and write your legislator.

Right to assemble is not a blank check for violent action, or even to assemble wherever and whenever your want.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by int_19h on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:07PM (#43384181)
The reason why these are legal is precisely because they are so ineffective.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by BobaFloutist on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:46PM (#43384054)
Come back the next day?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:09PM (#43384540)
> what do you do when you get home? Now that your right to assemble has been effectively revoked

Your right to assembly remains. You just made a risk-adjustment decision about not participating in a riot. The correct thing to do is go home, regroup and join the protest leadership to help plan another protest where the hooliganism is kept in check.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:16AM (#43385166)
When deciding whether to pull the trigger on such a thing, what matters is whether it will make things worse, regardless of whether that worsening counts as correct behavior or not.

Also, not being in Serbia myself I'm reluctant to make judgements from afar about what degree of hooliganism is justified in this case.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:44AM (#43385279)
> what matters is whether it will make things worse, regardless of whether that worsening counts as correct behavior or not

Correct. Escalating from peaceful to violent protest shouldn't (I'd argue cannot) be responsibly decided in the moment.

If you went to a peaceful protest "that was starting to get a bit rowdy," the situation clearly changed from underneath you. Go home. Take stock. Decide if what you saw was random rioting or targeted violence. If the latter, decide if and how you can help and if it will make things better or worse.

I'm struggling to imagine non-Hollywood scenarios where someone showing up to peacefully protest is useful when it effectively escalates to civil war.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by int_19h on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:06PM (#43384176)
Ukrainians didn't leave, and they ended up taking their country back. Twice.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:57PM (#43384767)
> Ukrainians didn't leave, and they ended up taking their country back

I'm struggling to remember any rioting in the Maidan.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by int_19h on Sunday March 16, 2025 @11:26PM (#43384899)
I mean, they have literally built a catapult on Maidan to throw molotov cocktails at the police. And used said molotovs to set fire to an APC.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:00AM (#43385071)
> they have literally built a catapult on Maidan to throw molotov cocktails at the police. And used said molotovs to set fire to an APC

I guess I wouldn't characterise such focussed use of violence as "starting to get a bit rowdy." Rowdiness specifically implies unruliness, a lack of discipline. I'd also say that escalating from peaceful to violent protest is not a decision one should take in the moment--catapults and molotov cocktails imply preparation.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by martin-t on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:57PM (#43384484)
This thinking is dangerous and wrong.

You cannot fight against violence without violence. Violence is most effective when it's implied/threatened, before it is materialized.

The goal of protests are:

1) To serve as a show of force (they are literally called demonstrations in some languages because you demonstrate your ability to organize and act - large numbers of people are capable of large amounts of violence).

2) To paint your side as the victim by provoking an overreaction.

Westerners often think that 2 is sufficient because they live in democracies where a large part of the government is also unwilling to use violence and become the aggressor. But against a dictator who is willing to use as much violence against the people as is available to him, 2 alone is worthless.

Goal 2 only serves to maximize the number of people willing to rise up but the real goal is to break the enemy's will to fight. Either to make the dictator lose his nerve and flee or to kill him because corpses don't have a will.

The point is it's a delicate balancing act to paint yourself as victim/weak to get more support and angry/strong to make the dictator back down. Westerners focus on the first part because it works against their governments but against greater oppression, you will not get anywhere without actual will to fight and kill.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tonyhart7 on Monday March 17, 2025 @04:12AM (#43386194)
"You cannot fight against violence without violence."

well you wrong, in fact you can. latest news is US Navy bomb houthi as we talk right now

You cant do violence if you well die, it is effective

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by immibis on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:49AM (#43387986)
Is it a nonviolent bombing?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by vkou on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:02PM (#43384503)
So, the moment a single cop lobs a tear gas can at a peaceful protest, is the moment when the protest starts doing damage to its cause?

That would explain why they seem to be so eager to employ violence against peaceful protestors.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:05PM (#43384519)
> the moment a single cop lobs a tear gas can at a peaceful protest, is the moment when the protest starts doing damage to its cause?

No. The trigger was "a protest that was starting to get a bit rowdy." Not a peaceful protest that gets gassed. The latter is extremely effective at generating public sympathy.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by immibis on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:51AM (#43388004)
So all the cops have to do is send one of them undercover to throw a couple of bricks, and then they have casus belli to gas the whole protest.

Ever wondered why protests always turn violent very shortly after the government decides it's time to disperse them?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by NewJazz on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:24PM (#43383086)
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by propagandist on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:23PM (#43383083)
And that is possibly the aim. When the protests turn into violence or sabotage, the state uses that to justify its own violent repression.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tonyhart7 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:54PM (#43383358)
so you saying if there are violence or sabotage, you let these people do it??? how can that be better
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:30PM (#43383624)
They're suggesting that the point of an authority using this weapon on a mass of people may be to cause those people to become violent so that the authority can use the subsequent fear to justify further abuses.

Which I think is likely, but also a bad decision. Generally speaking, the job of a legitimate government is to make violent protest unnecessary. So depending on the situation, the best action may indeed be to back down and rethink how things got there in the first place, rather than continuing to provoke more violence. Continuing to escalate is not a sustainable strategy for anyone that intends to maintain power for long, as the numbers are not generally on their side.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tonyhart7 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:29PM (#43383974)
Yeah but the problem is with mass movement people like this, there are good chance people that can take advantage of these protest (looting,rob etc)

the point of these weapon is not "defeat" but mostly to crowd control right because you cant rule out if there is no crime even in peaceful protest, both things can be true at the same time

also if such weapon is not permanently injure or harm people, I can see why this weapon is in need like pepper spray

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by propagandist on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:35PM (#43391446)
That's very charitable to those in power. Believe me when I tell you most don't give two hoots about looting and vandalism.

You don't break up a gathering because there's the possibility of crimes occurring unless you live in an authoritarian society.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tonyhart7 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:02AM (#43396751)
"most don't give two hoots about looting and vandalism."

of course who give a shit is the owner, its all sunshine until it happen on your neighbourhood

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by propagandist on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:10AM (#43398019)
I think it's pretty clear the owners of the corner store are not deploying those tactics for they are not the state.

Thank you for engaging in good faith.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by propagandist on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:32PM (#43391424)
That's exactly it. Thank you.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by s1artibartfast on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:57PM (#43383377)
yes, it is an escalation.

Governance is maintaining public support for the government having a monopoly on violent escalation.

If the government does not have this power, then any person has an individual veto over the rest of the country.

Laws are used to describe how and when individuals can protest.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by zozbot234 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:29PM (#43383611)
As it turns out, part of maintaining that "public support" is not taking advantage of it. The very idea of a stable monopoly on violent escalation is obviously meant to deter violence. When it instead makes violence more likely (because the monopolist is suddenly planning to abuse its monopoly) that's quite a big change and people can be expected to react accordingly.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by s1artibartfast on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:48PM (#43383738)
That is correct. It really depends on the temperature of public sentiment .

Many protests get a charitable assumption in the US as a legacy of civil rights and the Vietnam anti-war movements. However, I think a lot of that good will is eroding.

Each country has different perceptions, and ultimately, each protest is different (e.g. who shot first, is it abuse, ect)

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Philorandroid on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:24PM (#43383090)
Are chemical irritants preferable, then? Or just LEOs in riot gear with rubber batons? There's no amount of pushback or repercussion that a rioter will feel is fair or humane, and the mindset of "I'll turn violent and/or destructive if my participation in civil unrest is punished" is a perfect justification for these systems to exist.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mrob on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:19PM (#43383539)
>Are chemical irritants preferable

Absolutely. You can heal from those. LRADs are maiming weapons designed to cause permanent damage. Under any reasonable legal system their use would be considered a war crime.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by kortilla on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:40PM (#43383695)
LRADs are not designed to cause permanent damage. They are explicitly designed under the intention of being a way to disperse a crowd without long term harm.

There hasn’t been much research on long term health impacts, but it’s not a tool to maim people.

https://phr.org/our-work/resources/health-impacts-of-crowd-c...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mrob on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:44PM (#43383715)
They are designed to produce sound pressure levels that cause permanent hearing damage from short exposure, which makes them maiming weapons. There is no safe way to use an LRAD. Anybody who uses an LRAD is evil. Stop making excuses for despicable behavior. Deliberately causing hearing damage is no better than smashing people's fingers with hammers.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by kortilla on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:55PM (#43391033)
They are not designed to cause hearing damage and the link I posted saying as much is a from a physicians org for human rights.

Speaking in hyperbole is counter productive to thoughtful discussion

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mrob on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:28PM (#43391373)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_pressure#Examples

Threshold of pain: 120-140 dB(SPL)

Risk of instantaneous noise-induced hearing loss: 120dB(SPL)

A sonic weapon must cause pain to be effective. Any sound that reliably causes pain is capable of causing instant hearing damage. Therefore any sonic weapon is necessarily a maiming weapon and is designed as such. There is no hyperbole.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by int_19h on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:08PM (#43384193)
160 dB way over hearing safe. Most rifle rounds are in >140 dB territory, and that is quite sufficient to give you permanent hearing damage.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Aloisius on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:38PM (#43384679)
That's peak power at 1 meter for a large LRAD, not what someone 75 or 100 meters away experiences.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mrob on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:21AM (#43386839)
There will be some attenuation, but the output is focused into a beam, so you don't get the usual inverse square falloff with distance.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ty6853 on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:37AM (#43389655)
You do, there is just a greater gain factor constant.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by numpad0 on Monday March 17, 2025 @03:13AM (#43385910)
The point is that LRADs are supposed to be an ethical alternative to guns and gases, as far as the original design intent is considered...
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mrob on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:44AM (#43386659)
As LRADs are less ethical than CS gas, the true design intent is likely to produce something that looks insignificant on video recordings so it can be used as extrajudicial punishment of undesirables with less risk of public outcry.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fazeirony on Monday March 17, 2025 @07:52AM (#43387502)
this. and let's not forget that these....officers always receive the best, most top notch training to use these things safely. (/s)

yet another reason to ensure footage looks like 'nothing terrible happened to these people' as expertly trained cop uses a weapon of war against civilians.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by consteval on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:49AM (#43388598)
I don’t think you need to be a rocket scientist to realize loud noise = hearing loss.

Just intuitively, I know many people with degraded hearing from concerts. And that hearing is gone, that’s how hearing loss works.

I think the people who designed these weapons aren’t anywhere close to stupid enough to think these won’t cause long term damage. Which means that the only explanation is they INTEND for them to cause long term damage.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by kortilla on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:57PM (#43391052)
Check out the link I posted. It’s from a physicians group focused on human rights.

> I don’t think you need to be a rocket scientist to realize loud noise = hearing loss.

Being a doctor and understanding that the levels people are exposed are not maiming if the thing is used “by design” should carry some significant weight in how you think about this.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by tehjoker on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:35PM (#43383178)
maybe the government should consider protestor demands and reform in many cases
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by giraffe_lady on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:32PM (#43383162)
> There's no amount of pushback or repercussion that a rioter will feel is fair or humane

I mean you're talking about using violence against people to stop or prevent property damage. Most options are off the table in the moment, in the same way you can't execute someone if you catch them vandalizing your car. Smashing their fingers with a hammer wouldn't probably kill them but you can't do that either.

After-the-fact repercussions like criminal charges or civil liabilities, well, it doesn't matter how they feel about it? That's not how court works.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Philorandroid on Sunday March 16, 2025 @08:06PM (#43383840)
This reads like you suppose the only thing to do is let rioters vent their outrage against whatever objects happen to be in their way at the time, and hope that there exists some legal comeuppance after the fact.

Why can't some reasonable degree of force be used to prevent property damage? What moral dilemma exists that makes protecting property deserve a comparison to executing someone?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:20PM (#43384266)
> Why can't some reasonable degree of force be used

No one said that. It was suggested that physically injuring someone in direct retaliation for property damage wasn't appropriate. Add to that the fact that riot control measures are hardly targeted.

There are many non-violent options available. Sometimes rioters will escalate violently against the officers carrying those out. It's far less likely anyone objects to proportionate and necessary use of force in such cases.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Philorandroid on Monday March 17, 2025 @07:01AM (#43387147)
If threat of injury is what stops someone from destroying your car, then it's appropriately leveraged.

I'm also curious, what kind of effective, 'non-violent' means are there to control the initial mob-martyrs, and ensure level-handed justice is served? Those looking to escalate will use any police activity against them or their group as justification to do so.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:21AM (#43387717)
Your disagreement essentially amounts to "it's appropriate because it accomplishes my goal", or do I misunderstand? In a discussion of ethics that seems specious to me.

> Those looking to escalate will use any police activity against them or their group as justification to do so.

As I previously pointed out, once rioters escalate against the officers themselves most people are unlikely to raise objections to targeted use of force. That's quite different than a paramilitary force lashing out violently at anyone perceived to be up to no good.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by consteval on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:53AM (#43388628)
Also important to note, most of the riots I have seen don’t start with the protesters escalating. It depends on the country, but based off of what I have seen, it is almost always the authority who escalates. Often, there is preemptive and disproportionate riot control.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Philorandroid on Monday March 17, 2025 @07:07PM (#43393677)
> Your disagreement essentially amounts to "it's appropriate because it accomplishes my goal", or do I misunderstand? In a discussion of ethics that seems specious to me.

My disagreement is that the ongoing or imminent unlawful destruction of property should be allowed to be met with _appropriate_ deterring force, whether by law enforcement or by the property owners. I argue that because in a system of individual rights that include property ownership, the position that an impassioned crowd has more right to that property than the owner (by damaging or destroying it in this case) is morally indefensible.

> once rioters escalate against the officers themselves most people are unlikely to raise objections to targeted use of force.

That is untrue for at least the last decade or so. After the 2015 Baltimore riots, President Obama couldn't even popularly get away with referring to rioters as "thugs"[1] after ~300 businesses were damaged, 60 buildings set on fire, 113 police officers injured and 27 drugstores looted. Since then, there have been plentiful riots and mass demonstrations that either turned violent or otherwise sheltered violent activity, including the moment in 2020 that spawned the "mostly peaceful protests" meme of the reporter with a building burning down behind him because of the rose-tinted glasses public analysts used in their coverage. Mayors and governors gave lip service to violent demonstrations like CHAZ/CHOP [2] while violence was taking place, and only tepidly supported law enforcement's presence to curtail it after the fact.

_To this day_ those actions are routinely and popularly dismissed as racial outrage, justified, etc. largely along political boundaries, all to the detriment of the thousands of individuals whose livelihoods were damaged or destroyed as result. The idea that good consciences will win the day and protestors will distance themselves from n'er-do-wells among them is, as a standard, irreconcilable with the countless recorded hours of protest footage that exist.

Rights aren't trumped by implicit public vote to destroy your property, any more than two thieves can vote that they need their victim's wallet more than them, or a gang of rapists can hold a 5-1 vote for consent. QED, immediate and active threats against property should, morally and legally, warrant an appropriate amount of force to defend it.

[1] https://www.cnn.com/2015/04/29/us/baltimore-riots-thug-n-wor... [2] https://www.fox13seattle.com/news/chop-seattle-mayor-walks-b...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by fc417fc802 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:35AM (#43395795)
> the position that an impassioned crowd has more right to that property than the owner

That is a blatant straw man. The original position is more or less that nonviolent enforcement action must precede use of force. You are arguing to start off with violence, and even to apply that to perceived precrime ("ongoing or imminent" in your words).

To be fair regarding your wording, depending on your definition of "imminent" and the crime in question I might be able to agree. But that doesn't appear to be the case here.

To the rest of your comment, you seem very politicized. Most of what you wrote is non sequitur to the point that it doesn't seem feasible or worthwhile to respond. An outraged minority on social media is not the "most people" I was referring to (indeed they are a clear minority). The mainstream media exhibiting an agenda about a particular event has approximately nothing to do with the general principles we were supposedly discussing here.

Why should your interest in asserting property rights be permitted to trump human rights and due process?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ImPostingOnHN on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:06AM (#43385588)
> Why can't some reasonable degree of force be used to prevent property damage?

It can, of course. If a police officer sees an individual engaging in property damage, that officer may walk over to that person and arrest them. If that person resists arrest, the officer can use appropriate force.

If you're talking about using force against innocent individuals who happen to be nearby, of course that is both outrageous and out of the question.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by immibis on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:53AM (#43388025)
Outrageous, out of the question, and practiced at 99.9% of protests that disagree with the government's foreign policy.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by KennyBlanken on Monday March 17, 2025 @12:09AM (#43385121)
At protests cops purposefully escalate things by having a cop undercover in the crowd to do something violent enough to justify police attacking the crowd.

They lob a rock in the general direction of their buddies and Bob's your uncle.

Years ago someone caught some campus cops tossing some bricks into the bed of one of their pickups behind their station.

They claimed they'd removed them from a section of sidewalk where they'd come loose and become a hazard. First time I've ever heard of a cop doing something like that...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by AngryData on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:11PM (#43382971)
I don't find it acceptable for any reason whatsoever.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by timewizard on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:42PM (#43382662)
It's a weapon meant to deny the use of an area by threatening non-selective permanent physical damage. There are very few legitimate civil use cases for something like that.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Aeolun on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:50PM (#43382763)
Something like protecting the capitol from being stormed by a mob?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by __MatrixMan__ on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:06PM (#43382920)
Only if you want to justify the mob's presence there.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by alabastervlog on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:45PM (#43383277)
You could outfit the front steps with crewed machine guns, but apparently they only do that if they expect people protesting in favor of liberal values.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Aeolun on Sunday March 16, 2025 @07:54PM (#43383768)
I thought they made these sound cannons so they didn’t have to mow down their own populace?

I also feel like that’d have a counterproductive effect.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by timewizard on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:18PM (#43383032)
I might have tried just closing and locking the doors first.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ta1243 on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:24PM (#43383095)
Yes because Trump's lot are too stupid to break down windows and doors

https://edition.cnn.com/videos/politics/2021/01/06/jim-himes...

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by timewizard on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:01PM (#43384141)
You really believe the security of those windows in the Capitol comes down to the glass? That you're even willing to accept this proposition says something.

Anyways, to my point, clearly observable in that picture are security shutters, on the sides of the window, left open and unlocked. I might have closed and locked those.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by shadowgovt on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:27AM (#43389564)
Egg on the faces of the Capitol security team for not drilling on a mob riled up by the sitting President storming the US Capitol I guess.
[dead]
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 16, 2025 @05:45PM (#43382701)
Everything short of the worst we've ever done is totally OK? What even is this argument?
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by shermantanktop on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:05PM (#43382916)
This attempted deflection is as old as the hills. The Soviet Union spent a great deal of propaganda time talking about American slavery and Jim Crow, and it wasn’t because they cared about the issues. We call it “whatabout” now but it’s been the first defensive move when defending the indefensible for ages.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by g-b-r on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:48PM (#43489614)
No, the argument was that thousands of innocents have been killed just in the last year, with US weapons, for no reason.

While *I agree* to what was written in the post I replied to (I'm no supporter of Vucic or his buddy Putin), many other things would deserve words a thousand times heavier; and are instead not even condemned by many people here.

I only meant to point out that, in the only hope that even other things get condemned at least similarly.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by heraldgeezer on Sunday March 16, 2025 @06:44PM (#43383266)
Ah "but the USA!!". Cant tell if you are a suburb leftie who lives there or a russian troll.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by g-b-r on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @09:51PM (#43489632)
None, just someone who didn't notice the downvotes, flagging (why?) and replies before
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by KennyBlanken on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:03PM (#43384510)
> It's better than troops just gunning people down

Except you're far more likely to use it.

This is why cops don't shoot to "injure" instead of kill (also, it's hard enough for them to hit center of mass in a tense situation; there's no way they hit a leg.) It's lethal force. Which means that for its use to be legal, that person has to die because they are an imminent lethal threat to others. If injury is sufficient to resolve a situation, they weren't an imminent lethal threat.

Tasers started out as a way to temporarily incapacitate someone so you didn't have to shoot them. Now they're being used as compliance and corporal punishment devices.

Lots of videos out there of cops ordering people to do something while shocking them with something that makes their entire body lock up and is extremely painful.

They know the person can't do what they want them to. "Stop resisting!" while tasering someone is the cop version of "stop hitting yourself!"

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by kazinator on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:06AM (#43385590)
> If injury is sufficient to resolve a situation, they weren't an imminent lethal threat.

That requires more explanation.

An injury could render someone with lethal intent and capability unable to perform.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by pjc50 on Monday March 17, 2025 @06:23AM (#43386863)
During the BLM protests US police realized that they could do serious injury with "nonlethal" rubber bullets. Several people lost eyes including a journalist.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ashoeafoot on Sunday March 16, 2025 @10:16PM (#43384576)
The opposition protesting here is 1/5 of the population of the country . Its basically all people. Like 1 million protesting in a country of 5 million , is all voters between 18- 59. Russia is loosing , the rot of oligarchy is dissolving.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ein0p on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:34AM (#43385461)
It is impossible for Russia to "lose" in Serbia. The vast majority of Serbs support Russia, and are pissed at their government for not supporting it enough.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by gloosx on Monday March 17, 2025 @02:29AM (#43385684)
It is very possible to juggle around with the opinions of "vast majority" like apples. Vast majority will always support the thing which a delicate minority will push into their throats via media.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by milutinovici on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:06AM (#43386473)
This is pure nonsense. These protests have nothing to do with Russia, and everything to do with corruption
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ein0p on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:18PM (#43392822)
Did I say otherwise? I think you meant to respond to the OP who implied that Russia is somehow "losing" because of these protests. My Russian wife is telling me that they don't like Vucic either and if he were to vacate the premises no one in Moscow would shed a single tear.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by Kostic on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:48AM (#43386685)
That's a blatant lie. We are protesting because 15 people died in Novi Sad because of corruption, 4 months ago. We want justice.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by ein0p on Monday March 17, 2025 @04:53PM (#43392628)
That's exactly what I'm saying. These protests aren't what the OP makes them out to be, completely orthogonal to Russia.
Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by observationist on Monday March 17, 2025 @01:54AM (#43385535)
Assuming average age distribution between 16 to 60 in the protesters, that leaves about 3 million non protesters in the same age distribution for serbia, with children and elderly making up the remaining population, which is around 6.7 million, give or take.

That's 1 out of 4 working age citizens hitting the streets - not all people, but a huge chunk. It's safe to say there are going to be a lot of sympathizers in the non-protesters, a lot of people who wanted to protest but couldn't. There are definitely those who support the government, but I'd wager they're less than 15% of the total population, with the rest in opposition, or at least not in support of the government.

The usual tipping point for revolution is lower - if 10-12% hits the streets, it's a strong signal that the movement behind that activity is taking power.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by mariusor on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:39AM (#43398230)
Age distribution is rarely "average", whatever you mean by that. See here a quick googled source for Serbia: https://www.populationpyramid.net/serbia/2022/

According to that graph the cohorts with age less than 15 and more than 69 form only 27.7% of the total. Parent was broadly correct.

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by lijok on Monday March 17, 2025 @04:49AM (#43386359)
> We're not the world police, we don't need to enforce global norms

How do you reconcile this statement with the rest of your comment in which you are advocating for enforcing global norms?

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by preisschild on Monday March 17, 2025 @05:35AM (#43386616)
Disagree with "We're not the world police, we don't need to enforce global norms"

Someone should definitely enforce international laws and norms and the US was in the best place to do it

Re:Military grade sonic weapon is used against protesters in... by K0balt on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:56AM (#43388048)
FWIW there was some nice MILsurp LRAD kit on eBay a few years back. Looked like there was some corrosion but repairable, possibly functional in its current state. Wasn’t the truck sized one, but big enough (about 1m emitter) to do what is seen in the video. Sold for around 3000 iirc lol. I don’t think anyone knew what it was or it would have sold for a lot more. The seller had no idea, or at least wasn’t letting on if he did.

So, it’s not like LRAD is controlled like SAMs or something. Also, pretty trivial to build. Idk what the IP looks like on it , but back of the napkin you can build a 1kw unit for around $7000 buying the parts at retail. The expensive bits are the transducers. Everything else is a few mosfets and MCU/software.