News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by qgin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:36AM (#43229405)
At some point we have to consider the possibility that these aren’t just cuts to the budget, but an intentional plan to visit each government department and giving it a stab wound to let it bleed out and die over the course of the next year or two.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throw0101c on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:10AM (#43229640)
> At some point we have to consider the possibility that these aren’t just cuts to the budget

"At some point"? That point was a few weeks, like when they blindly purged the folks that did maintenance on nuclear weapons:

* https://time.com/7225798/doge-fires-national-nuclear-securit...

Or when they purged people dealing with bird flu:

* https://apnews.com/article/usda-firings-doge-bird-flu-trump-...

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by csomar on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:11AM (#43230176)
Given that they Kennedy retracted on the vaccine mandate suggests gross incompetence might be at play here.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by kennysoona on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:48AM (#43230439)
I normally defer to Hanlon's Razor, but with this administration it's 50/50 if their actions are due to incompetence or malice.

The only thing we know is their intent is never to benefit the majority of the people they are meant to be serving.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by tedivm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:31AM (#43230838)
I don't think we need to pick between incompetence and malice here. I think both apply to most of their actions.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Jtsummers on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:04AM (#43231099)
Select non-malicious but incompetent people to head departments, gives you plausible deniability when people claim that what's happening is malicious. "No, look, RFK Jr is sincere in his desire to help the American people." He's just really bad at it. Of course, that doesn't speak well to the judgment of the people at the top. They'll try and claim that RFK Jr did a fine job and it was the Deep State that caused the problems.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by brookst on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:27AM (#43231353)
Probably exactly what will happen. “Oh, with the dramatic reduction in vaccinations the American people would have been so much healthier, but the Deep State sprayed measles from chemtrails just to make us look bad”
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throw0101c on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:18AM (#43231237)
> I normally defer to Hanlon's Razor, but with this administration it's 50/50 if their actions are due to incompetence or malice.

The incompetent people were hired / appointed[1] as a form of malice against the "Deep State" (read: civil service) specifically, and government and civil society in general.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoils_system

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by marcosdumay on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:14AM (#43231196)
At this point, I don't see why it should matter if it's criminal negligence or malice.

They know what they are doing is illegal. Or, if they don't, it's because they are actively insisting on not learning it, what shouldn't make any difference.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by jrflowers on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:57PM (#43234990)
Hanlon’s razor is funny because it assumes that malicious actors can’t be incompetent and incompetent people can’t act maliciously. It is a fun logical trick that functions by pretending that huge swathes of the population don’t exist, like a sort of inverted cognitive behavioral therapy exercise
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by kennysoona on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:01PM (#43235042)
I don't think it is assuming that malicious actors can’t be incompetent or that incompetent people can’t act maliciously, it's just asserting that incompetence is so, so much more widespread than actual malice.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by clumsysmurf on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:30AM (#43230314)
Indeed, as Gary Kasparov eluded to

"These are not the acts of people who expect to lose power any time soon, or ever."

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2025/02/pu...

or

https://archive.is/l4kLV

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by devin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:21AM (#43231276)
Not sure why you took a downvote. I think it is plain to see that we are unlikely to have free and fair elections in 2028, possibly even the next cycle.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by readthenotes1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:25AM (#43232031)
That's exactly the attitude a number of right-wing people had after Trump's 2020 election loss.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by oblio on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:25PM (#43234653)
The thing is, are these situations really comparable?

Biden has just transferred power peacefully and gracefully, his supporters didn't initiate any coups.

And after Trump's 2020 loss, Biden basically enacted a bunch of sensible policies, including continuing some reasonable Trump policies (some specific tariffs, for example). Trump in 2025 instead decided to ban paper straws (!!!!).

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:05AM (#43231105)
I think if your argument is that they're making hasty decisions, you've provided good evidence for that. But the remainder of the sentence you quoted was:

> but an intentional plan to visit each government department and giving it a stab wound to let it bleed out and die over the course of the next year or two.

If your argument is that they're trying to make agencies die, and you're using the above as evidence for this, then you'd have to convince me that they want the government to lose control of nuclear bombs or bird flu.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throw0101c on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:16AM (#43231213)
> If your argument is that they're trying to make agencies die, and you're using the above as evidence for this, then you'd have to convince me that they want the government to lose control of nuclear bombs or bird flu.

I'm saying they want to get rid of government:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starve_the_beast

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43218884

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:20AM (#43231265)
I don't necessarily disagree, but unless they're literally ready to jump to anarcho-capitalism in the next four years I don't think they're trying to let the nuclear bombs go unattended. I think the specific examples you gave aren't your best examples to this point. If anything it's a counter-argument.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:31AM (#43231403)
There are US citizens, former employees of USAID, who have been abandoned after trying to stop a cholera outbreak in the middle of a civil war in South Sudan.

With their families.

Their security detail: fired. Their logistics team: fired.

No water, no power, no fuel.

Look: sufficiently advanced incompetence and/or carelessness is equivalent to malice.

I don’t care if you WANT to attend to the nuclear weapons, if you are so unserious, or understaffed, or incompetent, or distracted, or whatever to fail to actually do the thing.

Intent is irrelevant. Outcomes are everything.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:35AM (#43231451)
That's fair, but the initial point I was replying to was about intent.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:21AM (#43231992)
Again, intent is irrelevant.

Sure, criminal negligence vs murder, but do you really care if it’s your kid?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:22PM (#43232680)
And again, I'm responding to another post (two, actually) about intent. If you have an issue with it, take it up with them. I acknowledge your point as fair, but a separate point.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by philistine on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:14PM (#43233888)
Do not worry about world-ending neglect towards the staff responsible for the maintenance and security of our nuclear arsenal, their intent was only for a smaller government!
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:48PM (#43234276)
I don't know what's going on with HN right now, there usually is a lot more reading comprehension and level headed conversation, even on controversial topics.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by philistine on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:06PM (#43235105)
It's not me minimizing a series of catastrophic events because in my great wisdom I have perfectly ascertained the intentions of an unpredictable administration, it's reading comprehension.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:55PM (#43236154)
The foundations of the American government and its ability to care for its citizens. People are loosing their livelihoods, people are dying, etc.

You have been desperately attempting to defend the “intent” of the perpetrators.

That might rub folks the wrong way, huh?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by _DeadFred_ on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:37PM (#43233491)
They have spoken their intent out loud, over and over.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:43PM (#43234217)
I think I did a poor job of articulating my point. My point is that they've spoken their intent to smash the bureaucratic state. Their intent is not to dismantle 100% of the government, including the military and the nuclear bombs. So I don't think the nuclear bombs incident is a great example of them enacting their intent. Unless you actually think they want to do that, but then that's a much different claim you're backing up.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by digdugdirk on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:33AM (#43232100)
"Yes, your honour, I did shoot him point blank in the chest. But you can't use that fact as evidence that I wanted to kill him, that's just evidence of how he died."

Murder, manslaughter, intent, accident, purpose, neglect. We have many words that try to put a degree of malice on the act of taking a life, but the life is still gone.

At some point, you need to draw a line in the sand and say "They're going where I can't follow.". Right now, it seems like you're drawing the line right after they come out and tell the world that they specifically intend to burn America to the ground and auction off the remains for their personal profit. Where you draw your line is your own personal choice, but it's worth thinking about ahead of time.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:51PM (#43232981)
What is your model of this group of people behind DOGE? If it's a group of radical right wingers with libertarian leaning who want to smash the bureaucratic state, that's probably accurate and most people (even supporters) can get behind that characterization. Do you think this group of people, ushered in by Donald John Trump, want to dismantle the military? If not, then why would they purposely try to lose control of the nukes? There probably exist some radical libertarians (or even left-wing anarchists) who would actually advocate for let's say decommissioning the nukes, but I think it's pretty clear that that's not who's in office.

What I see is a ham-fisted approach to slashing the Department of Energy. That's the actual goal. Plenty of anti-Trump outlets report it that way. The idea that they actually want the nuclear weapons to lapse is a pretty bold implication, assuming I'm not misunderstanding the argument.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:26AM (#43231346)
Sufficient active disregard for consequences is equivalent to actively seeking said consequences.

If someone consistently drives extremely recklessly, refuses to service their brakes, allows their tires to become completely tread worn, removes their mirrors, etc. etc.

What could one reasonably infer about their desire to get into a car crash?

Would loud and repeated claims of a desire to drive safely convince you? Moreover, would you consider such claims to be in good faith, especially if said reckless behavior continues?

Besides, the GOP has said time and time again: let’s make the government so small we can drown it in the bathtub.

What private sector entity would find it profitable, or even be able to, control the bird flu or manage the nuclear arsenal.

Much less, do you want there to be a profit motive in those places?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Centigonal on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:57AM (#43232374)
I don't think there is one unified plan to destroy the federal government; however, many influential people in the current administration are motivated to destroy particular parts of the federal government and will not get in each other's way. I believe the result of this is that the current administration will attempt to destroy the union (inclusive OR) of all the agencies that influential individuals within the administration want to destroy.

Here's a quote from the conservative political operative and self-described Christian Nationalist Russ Vought, who is both the current and former head of the Office of Management and Budget under Trump:

“We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected. When they wake up in the morning, we want them to not want to go to work because they are increasingly viewed as the villains. We want their funding to be shut down so that the EPA can't do all of the rules against our energy industry because they have no bandwidth financially to do so. We want to put them in trauma.” [1]

This is a visceral and radical statement which has gotten some airtime on the news recently. However, it's interesting to note that Project 2025, which Vought helped lead and authored key sections of, does not advocate for the dismantling of USAID, rather recommending that its mission be narrowly aligned to national security goals[2]. In 2025, however, Elon Musk wanted USAID shuttered, and Vought was happy to oblige in his position as "the nerve center of the federal budget."

However, Project 2025 advocates for eliminating or defunding the Department of Homeland Security, Department of Education, EPA, Corporation for Public Broadcasting, and other government agencies. It's likely that these will also come under fire.

Finally (and this is my opinion), I believe it is impossible to understand this current administration's policy agenda without at least a surface level understanding of the writing of Curtis Yarvin, a software developer and reactionary political blogger. One this topic, Yarvin says the following:

“What is government? A government is just a corporation which owns a country. Nothing more, nothing less. It so happens that our sovereign corporation is very poorly managed and there’s a very simple way to replace that, which is what we do to all corporations that have failed. We simply delete them.”

[1] https://www.propublica.org/article/video-donald-trump-russ-v...

[2] https://static.project2025.org/2025_MandateForLeadership_FUL... (pg 253-255)

[3] https://apnews.com/article/trump-doge-russell-vought-project...

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by 47282847 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:23PM (#43232691)
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:45PM (#43232926)
Could you imagine any Project 2025 type wanting the government to disband the military? I imagine not. So why would they want to lose control of the nukes? I think in the case of the nukes it was just a ham-fisted attempt to downsize the Department of Energy. To that point, last I heard they were scrambling to re-hire those people.

Curtis Yarvin isn't a libertarian (anymore), he's a monarchist. I also don't think he would advocate for the government to lose control of the nukes.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Centigonal on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:16PM (#43233264)
I think the DoE thing was a mistake. Kind of frightening that nobody in the chain of execution for that decision knew what the DoE actually does, but I don't think that was intentional.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:03PM (#43234440)
Yeah. Remember when Mitt Romney planned a speech promising to abolish the DoE, forgot which agency when giving the speech, and then got put in charge of the DoE? I imagine this is the sequel.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by chao- on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:53PM (#43234952)
You are misremembering Rick Perry as Mitt Romney.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:25PM (#43238288)
Thank you, but also: it feels appropriate.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by orblivion on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:28PM (#43233382)
Okay cool. Well maybe I misinterpreted, but it sounded like the person I was responding to in my initial post was implying that it was on purpose. Or at very least, they would have to imply that it was on purpose for their argument to make sense. That was my point. Perhaps I haven't been clear.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Centigonal on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:46PM (#43233596)
I think the person I responded to did insinuate that, and I think that the evidence they provided doesn't support their premise.

I am making the argument that the current administration is trying to make government agencies die, but that it isn't one centrally orchestrated conspiracy. I am using different evidence than the parent comment to make that argument.

More importantly, the purpose of my original comment is to inform readers of the thread on highly influential second-tier actors (Russ Vought is well-known, but he's not Elon Musk) and help foster a more nuanced discussion of the current administration, its motivations, and its actions.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ldoughty on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:47AM (#43229467)
There's a proven track record with the Republican plan and USPS that they like to sabotage the agency and then point to the dysfunction they created as a reason to get rid of it. I fully suspect that we're going to hear that several agencies have been non-productive since January 20th and should thus be cut... Despite the fact that they BLINDLYfired not only the new employees, but all the employees that have had promotions over the last year as well (And were probationary in their new role).
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by i80and on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:23AM (#43229745)
I don't know how to fix this ratchet of "Republicans shatter things for fun and self-profit; Democrats try to tape things back together but it's harder to fix things than break them; so voters punish them by electing Republicans" that's been going on my entire life
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:32AM (#43229835)
It's not that simple. Democrats are responsible for plenty of stupid ideas, and Republicans have pushed through some good ideas.

Being overly reductionist makes one easier to reject as partisan.

What is new is the MAGA/2025 hijacking of the Republican party to enact its goals. To the extent that the current Republican leadership is essentially a different party than it was 6 years ago.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by djeastm on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:55AM (#43230033)
How is it a hijack? He got and is still getting overwhelming support from the GOP rank and file.

It mightve been a hijack at one point, but MAGA owns the whole airline now.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethagnawl on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:13AM (#43230198)
It's an evolution, not a hijack. Even Mitt Romney accepts it as the new normal: https://www.cnn.com/2024/12/15/politics/video/mitt-romney-ma...
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by DevX101 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:07AM (#43230140)
Many Republicans don't realize this. The party you've voted for all your life is not the same party running America today. Today's Republican party has been co-opted by an Anarcho-capitalist wing. And step 1, which they're well on track to do is to dismantle the Federal government. Step 2, which will be coming within the next year or two is to sell off previous government services to private entities.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:45AM (#43230421)
When the Soviet Union collapsed the US sent over "economic consultants" to steer what happened next towards "free markets."

What happened next is that various chancers marched into state institutions, usually with private security details made of low-grade armed thugs promoted from street crime, and said "This is ours now."

The US aristocracy saw this and apparently thought "Perfect - let's make that happen here too."

The fact there's been no significant state or media push back against Musk's takeovers is all anyone needs to know. The aim is a kleptocratic imperium drowning in gold, drugs, delusion, and corruption - which is exactly what Russia turned into.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Muromec on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:20AM (#43231263)
The best part is where the plant is still state property on paper, but operates at loss because it exports everything to a shell company in Austria who resells it at profit paid to the actual benefociary controller.

And if report on this, the president orders you to be behaded

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by aswanson on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:51AM (#43229995)
10 year dominance of a political party by one man is not a hijacking. It's a revealed preference.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:55AM (#43230038)
I think they believe the hijacking happened 12 years ago.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by natebc on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:36AM (#43230359)
It started in 2008 and kicked into super high gear in 2010.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:39AM (#43230373)
Yeah, this might be correct. It's possible Trumpism is a natural extension of tea-party-ism.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:21AM (#43230762)
Especially ironic, given one of the tenets of tea partyism was paying down the national debt.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by i80and on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:45AM (#43230943)
The national debt is too abstract and wonk-ish to be an actual tenet of a populist movement. I remember people talked about it a lot, but only in trite ways and I really think it was just a fig leaf.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:45PM (#43234865)
The national debt is concrete, but no president likes having their ability to spend constrained.

It should be handled in the way all >4 year payback US problems are: by empowering a commission to do the neccessary unpopular things and give members longer-than-4-year terms.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by pclmulqdq on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:02PM (#43237851)
I actually believe that the hardline tea partiers did believe this until they actually saw where the money was going. Then, lots of people in the tea party started saying "get the government's hands off my social security" (the irony would be funny if it didn't hurt so much).
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by clumsysmurf on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:20AM (#43230251)
David Brooks, at the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship, had a session called "How the Elite rigged Society (and why it’s falling apart)"

I included a link just below to at the exact timestamp he talks about this:

How Brooks sees Trumpism: not conservative, they don't have a conservative or positive vision for society, they just want to destroy the institutions "dominated" by left. In his words, this means, they are astoundingly incompetent. "Elite Narcissicm" leads to the destruction of every thought system it encounters.

https://youtu.be/QSa52TR9tCA?si=Uckncgw-WbAfA5tZ&t=277

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by i80and on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:35AM (#43230351)
I attended GOP caucuses circa 2010-2014. I would like to believe there was once a healthy sensible conservative party, but I'm sorry to say that to my eyes nothing has been hijacked: MAGA is what the Republican party has been for my entire adult life. It's just loud about it in public now instead of behind the doors of political machinery.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by selimnairb on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:50AM (#43230452)
There is a through line from Goldwater to Nixon to Reagan to Gingrich to Trump. Connective tissue has been provided by the likes of Roger Stone. This has been a 60-plus year project to overturn the New Deal.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by aswanson on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:45AM (#43230420)
Facts. All Trump did was take the top talking points of AM radio & fox (birtherism/racism, illegal immigration, and no factory jobs) and parroted them to power.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:19AM (#43230741)
That's a fundamental shift in historical Republicanism though.

For most of its history, the Republican party was fairly anti-populist (defined by whatever populism was at the time).

The Republican southern strategy from 1980+ was predicated on attracting southern white votes by attacking civil rights (explicitly or implicitly), but ultimately focusing on business priorities (with some headline-catching red meat).

However, in the decades since, the explosion of hardline conservative talk radio then dragged the party to answer to its more egregious populist demands.

Hence Trump.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by brookst on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:29AM (#43231384)
I would argue that their opposition to civil rights was populist. It was amoral and intended only to get votes from racists, as an “ends justify the means” way to pursue deregulation and corporatism.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by aswanson on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:33AM (#43230854)
That bait-and-switch reveals the core, though. The R base wanted what Trump is doing all along but was tricked by the establishment business class. The reason they are so loyal to Trump is because he ripped away the fasaud and acts out their longstanding wishes.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by markhahn on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:23AM (#43230777)
Non-MAGA republicans gave up; they are now extinct.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by amanaplanacanal on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:01AM (#43231762)
There were two paths, the examples I would give are Cheney and Graham. Both thought Trump was terrible, one stuck to her convictions and is now out of government, the other rolled over and is now licking Trump's boots.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by hedora on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:55AM (#43231034)
Name a single good idea the Republican Party has proposed and implemented at the federal level since 2000.

The most recent thing I can think of was getting Clinton to balance the budget, and he was a democrat.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by neaden on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:25AM (#43231332)
PEPFAR started in 2003 under Bush and has saved millions of lives. Of course Trump is dismantling it now but I think it's inarguably the best thing Bush did as president.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:39AM (#43231497)
The GOP fought against AIDS interventions since its discovery.

Had they not, PEPFAR or something similar would have existed a decade or more earlier.

Lotsa people died because of that.

By 2003, it was no longer tenable to refuse to fight AIDS, plus, notable GOP family members got AIDS.

Just like Nancy Reagan’s 180 on gay people once her daughter came out.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by SauciestGNU on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:45PM (#43232935)
I totally agree with you, but as someone who has seen the impact on the ground in parts of Africa, and how HIV/AIDS is no longer the death sentence it once was, PEPFAR is an amazing program that came too late, but let's not discount the actual good that it has done.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:30PM (#43235949)
Of course not! Better late than never.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by freen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:35AM (#43231444)
What good ideas?

The entire platform of the GOP is that the government is the problem.

The ACA would have been much better had the GOP not tried to stop it any way possible. Suing to remove critical aspects of it, voting at every turn against it, arguing that there would be death panels for grandparents.

Even once it was law, no attempt to improve, or replace.

A good faith effort would include an alternative health care plan. Where is it?

Two options: either incapable of producing a plan or are at best indifferent to the suffering and death of hundreds of thousands of people, if not more.

The GOP has only tirelessly worked to ensure that the ACA would be less effective than it could have been.

Note: not repeal it. It’s entirely too popular and effective for that.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by soulofmischief on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:51AM (#43229996)
Takes like this only focus on domestic politics and ignore the harrowing neoliberal foreign politics both parties uphold in order to perpetuate class inequality and create consumer demand. Both parties are invested in selling this country out, even if some Democrats really do care about social services.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by i80and on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:42AM (#43230397)
I actually agree, but I'm not sure this is a relevant observation. It's not fawning over Democrats to say that they are, as a group, pro-institution.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by npteljes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:50AM (#43232287)
The two-party system in itself doesn't work well. So I'm not holding my breath.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:17PM (#43236811)
Two santas theory.

I worry that the solution is a race to the bottom. As long as this shit helps only one party it won't get fixed.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by exe34 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:44AM (#43230415)
> "probationary in their new role"

This is such a big tech "move fast and break things" thing to do. The cancer has now metastasized and reached the executive function.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by zaik on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:15AM (#43230694)
Don't worry, a privately owned monopoly will pick up the slack.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:43AM (#43229448)
If history is any indication, it won't even go towards fixing the debt. Capital Gains tax cut incoming in 3... 2... 1...
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by bloopernova on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:58AM (#43229557)
That's already planned. The republicans want to pass another 4.5 trillion of tax cuts for the richest 0.1%

They simply lie to their supporters, and are believed because republicans are indoctrinated throughout life to believe that "government bad, corporations good, taxes bad, money good, collective power bad, individual power good"

trump said before the election he didn't know what project 2025 was. He lied, pure and simple.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:15AM (#43230208)
The TCJA made $4.5T in cuts for the richest 0.1%? Can you explain more about that? Is that by income, wealth?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by cupcakecommons on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:18AM (#43229698)
Why do you want to pay a government more money when it obviously can't allocate what it already has? I really, truly, don't think the feeling that government is bad or that taxes are bad are simply reflexive responses by stupid republicans.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by shakna on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:48AM (#43229965)
Why did they kill 18F, then? A department that was net-zero in costs.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:28AM (#43229783)
> when it obviously can't allocate what it already has

No large government in the history of the world has ever perfectly spent its money.

We can at best aspire to good government spending, not perfect.

Therefore the current dog and pony show of 'look at these excesses and get mad' is just a distraction to functional cuts that would be less popular.

Elon Musk, Russell Vought, and Donald Trump are lying. They know exactly what they're trying to do: impair the operation of the US government.

Any claims about fiscal justification are ridiculous from a financial standpoint -- if they cared about US debt, they'd be making these spending cuts, and not passing tax cuts.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by cupcakecommons on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:40AM (#43229910)
We aren't even in the same dimension as perfection here. It's a historically obvious phenomenon. Basically all human organizations tend toward inefficiency and waste eventually. The US government is the largest employer in the world. The reasoning would be no different if it was a corporation.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by joshuahedlund on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:11AM (#43230174)
This is true. So now let’s look at the substance of what DOGE has actually done:

- indiscriminately fire people who have been in long term positions but recently got promoted and so were considered “probationary”

- dismantle the CPFB which was a net gain for revenue

- dismantle 18F which has a track record of improving government efficiency

- fire people who were involved in managing nuclear weapons and bird flu and then try to bring them back

- share spreadsheets on Twitter about really old people in the social security system making people think there’s tons of fraud without learning about the 2023 OIG report that already existed that explained this data

- make a bunch of noise about cutting a bunch of contracts including a third of which were already fully spent and will save nothing

Does this give you confidence that they are genuinely focused on reducing inefficiency and waste? It seems to me like they are rushing in, not bothering to learn what has already been done, arrogantly making assumptions, randomly breaking things and causing chaos, and all for what… a few billion in real savings which is not even a fraction of the proposed increase in spending by the current budget resolutions being worked on by the Republicans in the house?

Why should we have ever thought that an operation literally named after a dog meme was serious about anything?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by acdha on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:18AM (#43230239)
I’d also add that doing all of this by breaking laws/contracts makes it likely that the net cost will be greater than the advertised savings. Every one of the contractors they stiffed has pretty straight forward grounds for a breach of contract suit and every government employee they said was fired for poor performance has grounds and a strong incentive to sue to clear their name.

All of this makes everything more expensive in the future: new contracts are going to have higher overhead to account for new legal and accounting costs, and unless the government will never hire anyone again they’re going to struggle to get skilled employees at all, much less at the same salary, when it’s clear that they’d be signing up to be treated like this. The direct cost is bad but the productivity cost will be even greater and last for decades.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by jfengel on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:52AM (#43230483)
The government has a fair bit of flexibility to cancel contracts without penalty. They usually don't, and of course nobody has ever seen it as this scale.

You're probably correct about the employment law. That will take more legal finesse to keep them from having to pay a ton of money. Fortunately for them they also own the judiciary. It's not 100% reliable, but they've for 4 out of 5 needed votes locked in at the top level

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:25AM (#43230789)
Most contract or employment disputes aren't going to the Supreme Court.

And expecting lower federal courts packed with conservative judges to vote in favor of ignoring contracts?

We'll see, but I wouldn't take that bet...

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by jfengel on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:55AM (#43231681)
They aren't packed with conservatives. They are packed with Republicans.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by troupo on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:23AM (#43230266)
They also deleted the largest "fraud findings" from their site after a day or so after posting them because they were lies, and enough people called them out
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:53AM (#43230013)
The next step after identifying some waste isn't to cut well-performing functional parts of the government.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by cupcakecommons on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:10AM (#43230167)
ah jee wiz is that what they did? ah elon musk the man who started the company that moves 90% of everything that makes it into orbit currently while running a handful of other extremely successful businesses where he's done exactly this kind of cost cutting over and over again must really not be the right guy for the job, you should get in there and give him and his teams some pointers
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by consp on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:53AM (#43230012)
> The reasoning would be no different if it was a corporation.

The difference being the overflow after wastes gets spend on society instead of shareholders.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by squigz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:07AM (#43230139)
> It's a historically obvious phenomenon. Basically all human organizations tend toward inefficiency and waste eventually

It's not that obvious to me, and is such a broad assertion that I'd require more than an "Everyone knows it. Just look at history" explanation to accept it as fact.

It also implies 2 things that I would disagree with

1) That the inefficiency and waste increases over time. It's likelier to me the ratio of those things stays the same, but it's more apparent as it scales - a company "wasting" 2% of its budget is vastly different than the US government "wasting" 2% of its budget.

2) That it's inherent to "human organizations" themselves - this doesn't seem to explore any other possible explanations. Given the nature of the discussion, I would think it's worth discussing whether other factors (like capitalism) might have an effect

(We'll ignore the vagueness of terms like "inefficiency" and "waste" with regards to government spending; not everyone agrees on what things are efficient or not. There are also many ways of measuring efficiency for both long- and short-term outlooks.)

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by jfengel on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:55AM (#43230505)
Dilbert is about a corporation, not government. Everyone seems to know that every large organization has some inefficiency. They seem to think the government has it worse, because that's what Republicans have been telling them.

It's no worse for government than any other large organization. Better than expected, given it's size.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:29AM (#43230826)
A oft-missed point is what's required for redress of waste at scale: more spending.

It costs money to save wasted money.

Sometimes, that equation is net positive and other times net negative. But it's never financially efficient to reduce waste to zero.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:37AM (#43230883)
When ever anyone talks about government inefficiency, ask what perfect efficiency would look like.

Nail them down to specifics. Not just improvements, but perfect efficiency.

Guaranteed they will soon start to flounder, because "inefficient government" is a propaganda talking point, not a fact that can be established with any workable economic definition.

And "the deficit" is the difference between what government chooses to spend and chooses not to tax.

A huge proportion of government spending is either/both an investment and/or a direct driver of beneficial economic activity. That includes "unworthy" spending like welfare.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by gaadd33 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:13AM (#43231188)
I don't think the US government is the largest employer in the world unless we aren't counting other countries governments. China seems to have around 50M government employees, 10 million civil servants and 30-40 million in other government jobs.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throwaway894345 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:48AM (#43229971)
> Why do you want to pay a government more money when it obviously can't allocate what it already has?

I don't think they're reflexive responses by stupid republicans, I think billionaires don't like paying taxes (to pay back into the society that made them fantastically rich in the first place) so they purchase Republican politicians to both obstruct government and vote for tax cuts. They obstruct the government to make it inefficient and then they use the resulting inefficiency as evidence that the government needs to be "starved".

And that's just politics-as-usual stuff before the literal cabal of billionaires in the Trump admin began working expressly to create an oligarchy.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by elif on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:42AM (#43230406)
It's deeper than lying about P25. P25 was allegedly an intentionally public document, designed to grab the media spotlight. It is actually plausible that trump had never seen a single page of that document by design.

There is a secret runbook that goes much further than P25 which the same authors ensured was never printed or emailed anywhere which could be susceptible to FOIA. That is the runbook they have been using since day 1, which likely contained all 74 of his day 1 orders pre-written.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by greenie_beans on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:53AM (#43230486)
somebody needs to FOIA donald trump jr's etc chatgpt account
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ForTheKidz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:35AM (#43230871)
Trump is too reactionary to have an N-step plan. The man thrives in chaos and uncertainty. Furthermore project 25 is large enough I'd be a lot more surprised if whatever happens wasn't on that wishlist somewhere.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by amelius on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:01AM (#43230569)
Trump lied about a lot of things.

The concept of "electoral fraud" is enshrined in law, so I guess more lawsuits are coming.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:56AM (#43229533)
What capital gains? Everyone will be getting tax relief next year for market losses.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by exe34 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:47AM (#43230436)
The entire federal workforce is 4% of expenses. If they wanted to cut costs, they would halt all private contracts and audit those first.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by genter on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:42AM (#43229436)
This isn't a possibility. They've publicly stated it's their goal.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43225342

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throw0101c on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:12AM (#43229657)
>> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43225342

> Everyone should watch the director of the Office of Management and Budget, Russell Vought, speak on government workers:

Russell Vought is the architect of Project 2025:

* https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c977njnvq2do

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025

You know, the thing that Trump publicly said he wasn't part of.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:31AM (#43230327)
That was a master class in weasel words.

"I haven't read it, I don't know what's in it."

"I know nothing about it."

I absolutely believe he never read it during the campaign, probably hasn't done more than skim a summary to this day. He doesn't need to. None of that matters to him.

Keeping his distance gave him "plausible" deniability...kinda. Anyone who actually thought Trump wasn't going to let Heritage Foundation people take over substantial control of government should take a long hard look at their sources of information, internal biases, and critical thinking capability.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by amelius on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:49AM (#43229983)
Argentina style. We've seen Musk with a chainsaw, he's not trying to hide it.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by someothherguyy on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:58AM (#43229548)
It is well-known, but it seems like it is hip to be indifferent on this sinking ship.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by xg15 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:10AM (#43230172)
I wonder how long until they pull the "who needs public libraries when you have Jeff Bezos?" shtick again.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by agumonkey on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:56AM (#43229536)
And at some point it's time to take action to go around a rogue non government. We have the technology, we can rebuild it.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by lkrubner on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:08AM (#43229622)
We can rebuild the government. We will eventually rebuild the government. All of these agencies will eventually be rebuilt. It might take 20 years, but eventually the USA will get back to where it was in late 2024, in terms of state capacity. But the damage being done right now almost guarantees a "Lost Generation" that has to spend its life rebuilding what we had, rather than moving into the future.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by andyjohnson0 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:51AM (#43229999)
> We can rebuild the government. We will eventually rebuild the government. All of these agencies will eventually be rebuilt. It might take 20 years,

They're going to a lot of effort, and exposing themselves to a lot of risk, if this is all likely to be undone in a few years time. My worry is that they won't be able to resist trying to permanently lock-in these changes, even if the most obvious way to do that is to abandon democracy.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by agumonkey on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:48AM (#43229972)
I was hinting at building an alternative system that would be resilient to this kind of tampering. Decentralization fanatics might be of use right now.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by qgin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:01AM (#43230087)
Can you sketch out a bit more how this could work?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by agumonkey on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:06AM (#43230127)
With precision no, I'm a newb, but a distributed system ala DHT, or git so that there is no single path of access.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by i80and on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:05AM (#43230607)
I cannot emphasize enough that this is not a technology problem, nor is it one where solutions can be usefully informed by technology.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by agumonkey on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:11AM (#43230657)
Sorry if I misjudged the way to approach this, I still think that the 'method' (or technology) matters because it influence the social and political layer too. How would you approach it, genuinely curious.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ForTheKidz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:29AM (#43231372)
The only thing I can think of would be.... weakening the federal government and giving up on the idea of centralized control outside of the military and the dollar. Which is exactly what republicans are doing now.

On the bright side, this might also mean the end of rampaging around the globe in the name of democracy. I think that ship has fully sailed, alhamdulillah.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by edoceo on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:05PM (#43232474)
Every citizen of age is entered into a lottery. From this pool you will be selected, at random, to be assigned into a government management role (eg: president, law maker, justice) supported by staff. Any citizen, randomly in roles of power. No voting. Then you serve your role for 4 years and never get another one. Now the incentive is to do the least harm?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by lkrubner on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:50AM (#43242886)
Decentralization is not the answer. Centralization is the answer.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by danieldk on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:22AM (#43229731)
It is possible, but why do you believe this is a necessity? It's also possible that the US becomes an oligarchy dictatorship like Russia. All the assets are seized by a small group (crashing the economy, removing oversight, removing national park maintenance, etc. makes it possible). Then give people just enough money and fear not to revolt. Feed them propaganda all day, find some enemies to direct their hate towards. I mean, it's pretty much Vance and Thiel's playbook, rule by 'wise' tech CEOs.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Loughla on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:13AM (#43230197)
I'm genuinely afraid of what we're doing to our childrens' futures.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ForTheKidz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:09AM (#43231145)
We're already far too balkanized as a country for a central dictatorship to make much sense in the long run. Especially when the money tap starts running dry. I think we'll just have an extremely weak federal government (or perhaps we will finally split.)
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by whatshisface on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:31AM (#43231401)
A centralized dictatorship is what held the actual Balkans together...
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ForTheKidz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:32AM (#43231404)
How's that working in the long term?

What has bound us together as a people is the massive ocean of cash we collectively float on. Abundance that's actively being slashed and burned as we speak. Apologies for the mixed metaphor.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ForTheKidz on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:06AM (#43231110)
Our global influence and wealth will almost certainly never be this high again. I think that's probably a very good thing for the globe in itself, but we can wreak a lot of destruction on our way out of power.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by akudha on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:01AM (#43230089)
Eh? “At some point”? You must’ve been sleeping. This has nothing to do with efficiency or improving the budget. Bill Clinton laid off thousands of employees, but he did it in an orderly fashion, got congressional approval etc. This is the exact opposite. The goal here is to cause havoc, be cruel, cut regulations (by reducing budget and reducing personnel) etc. After the carnage, divvy up what’s left among the billionaires. So far, it seems going according to plan.

Did you hear what Russell Vought said? “We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected,”

Anyone genuinely interested in efficiency should start with why the Pentagon has failed audits and is unable to account for tens (hundreds?) of billions of dollars

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by FollowingTheDao on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:47AM (#43229959)
Keep in mind that this my be an internal revolt.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by MattGaiser on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:48AM (#43229482)
This is an explicit Project 2025 goal.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sigmoid10 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:58AM (#43229555)
It's surprising to see how many people still don't get this. None of what happened so far was in any way surprising. You can literally go right now and read up what else they have planned. We're in for a wild ride.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by andyjohnson0 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:54AM (#43230024)
Reminds me of how 9/11 turned into the GWoT and Iraq I etc. The Project for the New American Century posted their playbook for that on their website too. Most people downplayed it.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by mschuster91 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:18AM (#43229699)
I distinctly 'member people even right here on this site taking dumps on anyone who dared accuse the Republicans of being hellbent on implementing Project 2025. Called us "conspiracy nuts", said that this was just "enemy propaganda" or that there was no connection between Trump and Project 2025, downvoted and flagged our warnings... where the fuck are y'all now? Where the fuck are y'all with your guns and "don't tread on me" flags now that MAGA is tearing down the government and installing an autocracy in all but name? And where the fuck are the even more people who did just the same on Reddit?

The thing is, almost no one was used to politicians actually following through with their plans and promises. Trump is the first Western leader since I'm alive (other than the current Spanish government) to actually do what he has promised, and I fear this image of him being an "accomplisher" will send him for a wave of support in both the midterms and the next election (and yes, I also believe that there will be no one left to enforce the "two terms" regulation).

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by nubinetwork on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:56AM (#43230044)
Democrats don't believe in guns or storming the white house... they'll either wait 4 years or wishfully dream that orange man dies of a heart attack.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ben_w on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:58AM (#43230056)
> I also believe that there will be no one left to enforce the "two terms" regulation).

I don't want to suggest what Trump himself suggested: https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/trump-2nd-amendment-folks-st...

I think that's a bad option.

What I am saying is: Every single time I've seen a headline about school shootings, someone suggests gun control.

Someone reacts that guns keep the government from becoming despots.

I said then, no, the military are the ones who decide such things. Militia don't make a dent, despite their self image.

And yet, Trump, who just narrowly avoided being killed, signed more support of the 2nd amendment.

https://www.nraila.org/articles/20250207/nra-statement-on-pr...

Did he sign because he's afraid, or because he's not?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by mindslight on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:57AM (#43231705)
> Where the fuck are y'all with your guns and "don't tread on me" flags now that MAGA is tearing down the government and installing an autocracy in all but name?

The same place they were when Breonna Taylor was summarily executed by government agents in retaliation for Kenneth Walker exercising his second amendment right to home defense at night (the exact type of scenario they continually grandstand about!) - following the twisted logic and misdirection of their mainstream media so they can continue lazily attacking a strawman of their fellow citizens ("oWn tHe lIbS!1!") rather than reflect on what it would actually take to live their purported values.

At this point the only real question for so-called "conservatives" is when will they realize their leaders have betrayed us and given away our country's future to China?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by x86_64Ubuntu on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:07AM (#43230618)
They get it, they just know it looks bad so they act as if they are surprised.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by plagiarist on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:47AM (#43231587)
There are still some people (even in this thread) pretending it is not deliberately sabotaging the government in favor of billionaires.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by yapyap on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:52AM (#43230007)
Don’t wanna be that guy but if not really being about budget cuts seemed pretty obvious from the start, if Elon and Donald got a hand in it it’s pretty much always ego driven.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:42AM (#43229434)
IMO we don’t need to attribute malice to it, which will drag everyone into a debate about what’s going on inside the clearly broken minds of a few rich men.

The sheer incompetence of it all is disqualifying by itself.

In my experiences arguing with MAGA, the incompetence argument lands a lot more convincingly than the evil argument.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by lkrubner on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:10AM (#43229637)
What we are seeing is clearly an act of malice. We need to be honest about that. Trying to obfuscate what we are seeing helps no one. We should use plain English and talk in a straightforward way about what is happening.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by raphman on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:48AM (#43229968)
I disagree. The nameservers still respond to requests on 53/tcp. It seems like someone messed up a firewall configuration or rolled out a bad server configuration. Shit happens - maybe exacerbated by the DOGE insanity. But there is no indication that this was done on purpose.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by kube-system on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:56AM (#43230042)
The insanity that has/will lead to functions no longer being properly staffed is on purpose.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:11AM (#43229656)
“Helps no one” except probably winning elections, given the “he’s a fascist” messaging (while true) didn’t seem to resonate.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throwaway894345 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:59AM (#43230063)
Yeah, I think a big part of the problem is that fascism is somewhat abstract and for a good decade everyone to the right of Mao was called a fascist. I'm not sure that normies ever understood what fascism really meant, but at least they knew it was serious; however, after a decade of crying wolf, the term predictably lost its punch and became a garden variety insult. Now we don't have a word that triggers the same degree of alarm because we used it to bludgeon moderate liberals. And the most tragic part is that many were warning that something like this would happen for the last decade.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by lesuorac on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:07AM (#43230133)
I'm not sure the crying wolf is accurate.

It's like shouting that the bridge is going to collapse because you see a few supports buckle. Anybody with eyes can see the bridge is standing and heavy ass trucks are driving on top of it.

Trumps first term was relatively neutered because people just refused to do what he asked. Those supports are gone now though and like the bridge collapse the observable changes happened slowly and then suddenly all at once.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by throwaway894345 on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:38AM (#43242764)
I would agree with you if I had been talking about using "fascism" to describe first-term Trump and his hardcore supporters, but I was very specifically referring to the application of the term toward liberals and progressives who were deemed too moderate on identity politics. And to be clear, by "too moderate", I mean stuff like "advocating nonviolent protests" and "criticizing the weaponization of Title IX at universities".

I think warning about Trump fascism was appropriate and legitimate, but I think using the label as a lazy cudgel to get liberals and progressives to toe a poorly-conceived line did a tremendous amount to erode the term's significance and rhetorical power.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by croes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:46AM (#43229463)
Given the sheer amount of incompetence malice becomes a lot more probable
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by derbOac on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:53AM (#43230015)
To borrow a phrase, any sufficiently incompetent organization becomes indistinguishable from malice.

Although I agree with others' sentiment that focusing on incompetence can be more persuasive to certain segments of society.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:51AM (#43229500)
I’m not saying what’s true, I’m saying what is useful to argue.

The goal is to convince other people, not to rah-rah the already-believers.

Trivially: these websites go back up in a few days, is that more convincingly malice or just “these people don’t know how to operate a government?”

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by croes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:05AM (#43229600)
Then incompetence as as reason isn’t useful.

If it’s malice then it’s an attack. You have react differently to an attack than to incompetence.

The EU made the same mistake with Trump‘s appeasement to Putin. They hoped it’s some kind of clever negotiation tactic but they learned it’s not. It’s just two autocrats teaming up at the expense of Ukraine.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:10AM (#43229645)
That is not even close to analogous.

Meh, feel free to disagree. How many MAGA voters do you talk to on a daily basis?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by croes on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:18AM (#43229700)
In person? None.

Online? More than enough and they show the same kind of malice like our own type of MAGA: AfD voters

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @06:59AM (#43229559)
Democratic turnout was a problem in the 2024 election. Rah-rah is important, like it or not.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:10AM (#43229639)
And do you have evidence to suggest more people would’ve been activated by more “he’s a fascist” messaging?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by smallmancontrov on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:29AM (#43229793)
You open with "IMO" but want evidence from me? Lol.

There were many dems who remembered Trump as the funny orange man, didn't really care to turn out against him, and fell for the "both sides bad" messaging that was absolutely rampant on the left (esp with regard to Kamala and Palestine). So no, I don't think the most important rally-the-base rhetoric was to ratchet up "Trump is Fascist" so much as suppress "Both Sides Bad" while we had an election to win.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:38AM (#43229890)
Both sides were bad. Biden and Kamala were terrible candidates for the Democrats to run, and their campaign positioning lacked a unifying aspirational message.

What was Kamala's 2024 campaign slogan?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by someothherguyy on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:53AM (#43230017)
We're not going back?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ethbr1 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:10AM (#43230643)
Exactly.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by datavirtue on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:28AM (#43230812)
Which was a horrendously stupid tag line. All people saw was "prices not going back." Everyone in America remembers simpler, better times. 1990s race relations alone were far better than they are now.

I saw that slogan and cringed immediately.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by datavirtue on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:51PM (#43232984)
Sorry downvoters, I'm no MAGA cultist, it's just the worst slogan ever.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:37PM (#43233487)
"IMO" means "in my opinion." You made a statement as a fact, which is why I asked for evidence. Lol.

Agreed the "both sides bad" messaging was a huge factor here. But that's exactly why we should talk about these fuckups as questions of competence. They are unambiguous evidence of a difference in both sides' ability to actually operate a government!

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by johannes1234321 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:09AM (#43229635)
It is not incompetence to put people with no relevant experience into cabinet positions. It's purpose. Destruction with a huge amount of distraction is the purpose.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:56AM (#43230513)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Enlightenment

https://www.ft.com/content/02217acf-ac64-49c2-acd5-ef4f107f0...

https://www.newyorker.com/culture/infinite-scroll/techno-fas...

There can be incompetence and malice together in all this. The malicious often leverage the incompetent to further their goals.

One way to get more people on board with destroying government structures is to render the government structures as ineffectual and incompetent as possible.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:00AM (#43231738)
I didn’t say there isn’t malice.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sjsdaiuasgdia on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:32AM (#43232097)
You want to downplay the malice to avoid arguments about whether it's really malicious. I want to spotlight the malice because it's really fucking bad and a lot of people are going to get hurt, and that's not an accidental outcome.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:02PM (#43232429)
And when these websites are back up? What then?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by ck2 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:24AM (#43230274)
and it's not like private industry is going to do this work, there's no profit in such services, at least not short term

AND if they are doing this to NIH, imagine what they are doing to food and drug inspection for safety

just assume all regulation is gone or being ignored without penalty, now scale that out for four years

Forget "great depression" it's a dark ages of sorts with smartphones for distraction

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by DevX101 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:30AM (#43230310)
TurboTax makes a lot of profit. This a perfect example of what should be a government service being privatized. That model will be replicated.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by MPSimmons on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:50AM (#43230453)
It's really hard to have private companies charge for doing work that a functional government agency performs.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sneak on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:06AM (#43231113)
The US mismanaged the pandemic about as badly as anyone could; other than the ubiquitous surveillance of the population I don’t know many us federal agencies that I personally would describe as “quite functional”.

I certainly don’t know any that require they be run by the state.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by UncleMeat on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:51AM (#43230468)
Curtis Yarvin has been writing about this forever. JD Vance has spoken publicly about his agreement with ideas like RAGE (Retire All Government Employees). Musk has similarly spoken publicly about how CEOs are the best people to run the world. Although Thiel is not directly in power, he's also a Yarvin-ite and has been instrumental in both Vance's rise and also the pipeline for the various people working at DOGE to destroy the government.

Alongside these budget cuts, the GOP is proposing massive tax cuts and massive increases in funding for parts of the government related to law and immigration enforcement that will massively outweigh any savings from DOGE destroying entire programs overnight. DOGE is also demolishing organizations that are revenue positive and Trump has fired Inspector Generals, who are responsible for identifying waste and inefficiency in government operations.

It isn't a possibility. It is very very clear.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by hedora on Sunday March 02, 2025 @09:59AM (#43231070)
In blue states, the middle class taxes are going to be hiked to pay for all this, just like under Trump 1.

Also, half of the “law and immigration enforcement” budget increase is actually going towards deploying the military inside the US, which is illegal.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by Nuzzerino on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:52PM (#43238421)
Musk is still there to take the hit, and he will. He's spoken about it openly to a degree. Something about how he's only planning to be in that role temporarily and will get back to building rockets.

> DOGE is also demolishing organizations that are revenue positive

The revenue will be still be there when the re-org is completed. Are you worried about competitors?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by layer8 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:58AM (#43230541)
This article is giving some background on the planning and setup of the new DOGE: https://archive.ph/oJRrI
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by dcow on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:11AM (#43231169)
HN was in the same uproar after Musk reformed Twitter. Minor disruption? “The sky is falling!” Brief outage? “It’s malice!” “You see! Musk is obviously driving it into the ground.”

Could there be a world in the middle where maybe the government is bloated and irresponsibly spending money and republicans aren’t just myopic nitwits and do care for our country? And they’re executing on cleaning things up but in a way you disagree with?

Why is it always malice and ruin? It’s tiring. Twitter BTW pulled 1.25B in profit last year…

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:25AM (#43231335)
The government is bloated but rather than attacking the bloat (DoD budget that never shrank after ending two wars, subsidies for profitable businesses) they're going after the regulatory infrastructure that protects Americans from corporate greed.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by dcow on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:04AM (#43231790)
Extraneous regulation stifles innovation and is the definition of bloat. I certainly haven't been protected from corporate greed lately, have you? The main function if gov’t is to provide a military. That’s appropriate spend.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by hooverd on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:07AM (#43231825)
Because it's the explicit goal of the people doing it. Why go after the CFPB and 18F and IRS Direct File? They've been very outspoken about destroying administrative capacity and making the executive branch a king to punish the enemies of their national conservatism project. Red states are already trying to roll back women's and LGBT people's rights. How does trying to overturn Obergefull balance the budget?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by dcow on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:12AM (#43231894)
There is waste everywhere. I sincerely don’t understand how, when the stated plan is to look closely at all orgs and cut waste across the board, when the lens focuses on specific instances of orgs, the response is “not this one, cutting here will ruin everything”. I don’t buy it.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by hooverd on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:27AM (#43232047)
What is developing in-house capabilities with 18F waste? Why is protecting consumers from scams and even recouping that money by the CFPB waste? Why is allowing people to e-file without private middlemen waste?
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by dcow on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:56AM (#43232359)
Well, we don’t need two identity providers, for one. I’m sure the non wasteful things will be sustained under different management that isn’t insubordinate.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by hyoomen on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:40PM (#43234827)
You're sure... Based on what?

Non wasteful things... Such as? Says who?

"Different management" ffs the govt isn't supposed to pivot like a company every 4-8 yrs. That's an unthinking suggestion for a federal govt & heterogenous population.

"Insubordinate"... To a unitary executive?

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by _DeadFred_ on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:48PM (#43233610)
Ah yes, tech companies that provide zero personal support just scaling storage and delivery are the same as government which is MOSTLY providing support and person to person work, the OPPOSITE of scalable using tech.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by catlover76 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:37AM (#43231474)
It's already well-known that crippling the government and destroying things is the point. To have ever entertained anything else is to have been naive, morally defective, and stupid.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by jordanpg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @10:48AM (#43231600)
** WAKE UP FOLKS! ** THIS IS HAPPENING RIGHT NOW. NO ONE IS COMING TO SAVE US.

If you're in the US, it's time to start asking yourself what you are going to want to be able to say to your kids or grandkids when they ask what you did about it when the constitutional republic was falling.

Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre... by sizzle on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:04PM (#43234446)
What’s the end goal here though?