Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre...
by llamaimperative on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:11AM
(#43229656)
“Helps no one” except probably winning elections, given the “he’s a fascist” messaging (while true) didn’t seem to resonate.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre...
by throwaway894345 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:59AM
(#43230063)
Yeah, I think a big part of the problem is that fascism is somewhat abstract and for a good decade everyone to the right of Mao was called a fascist. I'm not sure that normies ever understood what fascism really meant, but at least they knew it was serious; however, after a decade of crying wolf, the term predictably lost its punch and became a garden variety insult. Now we don't have a word that triggers the same degree of alarm because we used it to bludgeon moderate liberals. And the most tragic part is that many were warning that something like this would happen for the last decade.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre...
by lesuorac on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:07AM
(#43230133)
I'm not sure the crying wolf is accurate.
It's like shouting that the bridge is going to collapse because you see a few supports buckle. Anybody with eyes can see the bridge is standing and heavy ass trucks are driving on top of it.
Trumps first term was relatively neutered because people just refused to do what he asked. Those supports are gone now though and like the bridge collapse the observable changes happened slowly and then suddenly all at once.
Re:NIH.gov DNS servers down, making PubMed, BLAST, etc. unre...
by throwaway894345 on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:38AM
(#43242764)
I would agree with you if I had been talking about using "fascism" to describe first-term Trump and his hardcore supporters, but I was very specifically referring to the application of the term toward liberals and progressives who were deemed too moderate on identity politics. And to be clear, by "too moderate", I mean stuff like "advocating nonviolent protests" and "criticizing the weaponization of Title IX at universities".
I think warning about Trump fascism was appropriate and legitimate, but I think using the label as a lazy cudgel to get liberals and progressives to toe a poorly-conceived line did a tremendous amount to erode the term's significance and rhetorical power.