Totally logical for the CEO of the company to be vocal supporter of the man who wants to kill those credits.
It is one of those terms were if you were to actually find people that are truly 'woke' and respresent everything it stands for, it would be a very difficult task indeed. It is like taking the 'No true Scottsman' fallacy and tipping it on its head.
That is not a luxury CEOs get. They do not have a free hand to run companies, they are hired by boards of directors who represent the shareholders. His job is to work for the benefit of shareholders, and if he can't do that then it's simply a case of firing him.
I cancelled my Cybertruck res, and after buying four Teslas, I will not spend another dime on one until Elon is gone. Tesla is, hopefully, forced into self preservation by market fundamentals.
The smart move is to wait for general production, but then I see posts like these and I can’t help but want to give you the middle finger.
I’m sure this comment will be removed, but HN has been write only for years now so I won’t even notice.
I also upvoted your comment and will vouch for it as well, shared perspective is important, even if contrarian or deviating materially from a consensus.
Not sure why that makes you more inclined to buy a Tesla or flip someone the bird?
I was under the impression that the fiduciary duty was to the company/corporation. At least that's the case in Canada (2008 SCC 69):
* https://www.fasken.com/en/knowledge/doing-business-in-canada...
(Further, legally speaking, the shareholders are not legally the owners of a company, just another type of stakeholder.)
While institutional shareholders generally mean your boss is an excel sheet seeking profit, the only "duty" to shareholders is still "do not defraud them". They can, of course, seek to change the board though...
I mean, can Musk argue that he legitimately believes battling the woke mind virus is for the benefit of Tesla shareholders and their returns on investment and thus fulfilling his fiduciary duty?
Breach of fiduciary duty however would be if CEO intentionally defrauded then of their value (essentially, through intentional bad care for the company)
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burwell_v._Hobby_Lobby_Stores,....
I think your expectations of loyalty might be a bit exaggerated. A job is a job. Whether as a CEO or as a warehouse picker, it's not one's life.
But no, _employees_ of a company do not have the same fiduciary duties towards a company that its officers do.
I mean, nothing stops you from making it into job requirements in your company, but, apparently, this is not a requirement at Tesla...
What, nothing stops you making director-style fiduciary responsibility a job requirement for normal employees in your company? I'd, er, check with a lawyer before you try that one.
I'm not sure that's always or even often true, despite the 'O' in the name. You're generally mostly talking about the CEO plus directors.
So he can’t be inconsistent.
I’m not saying what he (or anyone else) says today is consistent with anything else he says or has said. Just that that one statement is _internally_ consistent.
It would be immoral for Trump to offer a quid pro quo to Musk, so that couldn't be the what's happening at the moment
"When Elon Musk came to the White House asking me for help on all his many
subsidized projects, whether its electric cars that don't drive long enough,
driverless cars that crash, or rocket ships to nowhere, without which
subsidies he'd be worthless, and telling me how he was a big Trump fan and
Republican, I could have said, 'drop to your knees and beg,' and he would
have done it..."
-Trump, who Elon is currently giving $45 million / month for his campaign.
But hey, that's pocket change compared to the brand value he has incinerated on Twitter.To most people, those two things are completely separate despite actually being two sides of the same coin.
I know it makes Musk an easy target and easier to attack when a report comes out saying he's donating $45m to Trump but seriously people need to stop believing blindly what the media says about anyone (and Musk especially) without fact-checking first. When I first saw the article about it in WSJ I was skeptical. There were 0 sources and it was sus.
"Oh WSJ said it so it must be true!"
WSJ's source: "according to people familiar with the matter." [2]
[1] https://time.com/6999003/elon-musk-donate-millions-trump-cam...
[2] https://www.wsj.com/politics/elections/elon-musk-has-said-he...
Yes the PAC may support Trump but I don't think he's pumping 45 mil a month into it. WSJ put that article about it without any sources and Musk denied it.
https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/1086367432957...
Of course if Tesla didn't make those car and batteries they wouldn't have regulatory credits to sell. Also the credits were 3.5% of total revenue ($890M of $25,500M).
What is Tesla's edge in energy infrastructure?
[1] https://carboncredits.com/bp-grabs-the-opportunity-to-take-o...
Tesla isn't a top-ten battery producer [1]. The batteries it does use (and make) are optimised for EVs.
[1] https://cleantechnica.com/2024/01/19/top-10-battery-producer...
Megapack (a giant battery pack for grid energy storage) has much more in it than just battery cells.
Tesla's Megapack sales are growing rapidly, they just ramped one U.S. factory from 10 GWh to 40 GWh and are building another 40 GWh factory in China.
Every few weeks there's another big project announced that will use Megapacks.
As far as I know Tesla is a decisive leader in that field but hard to tell because while there is competition, they don't disclose the sales.
Relative to a utility? Or any deep-pocketed investor who can buy Panasonic cells?
Tesla is a terrific EV company. They shouldn’t be pivoting away from their roots but reclaiming them.
Megapack is a product they've been perfecting for many years and it's already at least a v3 product.
Not only they are not using Panasonic cells in Megapack (those go exclusively to their higher-end cars), if you think all it takes to create a competing product is to have money to buy battery cells then you exemplify "a little knowledge is a dangerous thing".
Megapack is a product with lots of sophisticated electronics that takes serious engineering to develop, it's at least v3 product with years of improvements. You need high-powered voltage conversion, battery management hardware and software so that it doesn't explode etc.
Tesla is a clear leader in the field: every major energy project announced, from Australia to California, uses Tesla megapack. I don't hear much about any of the competition.
Tesla is leading in scale and expanding rapidly (just finished ramping up first U.S. factory and building another factory in China).
Even for Tesla to build another 40 GWh factory which is mostly copy & paste of their existing megapack factor, it's a year long process.
If you start with battery cells, you're looking into a multi-year design & testing & initial production for the first megapack-like product and then at least another year to scale your first factory to 40 GWh yearly production.
By which time Tesla will have few more factories and v5 of Megapack.
I was nodding along to most of your comment but this part is a clear exaggeration. Many of the California BESS projects are using LG systems. For example Morro Bay, Edwards Sanborn, and Moss Landing, which are among the largest on the planet, all used LG, at least for some phases.
> their car business is really showing signs of strain at the moment.
Their car business aka "their entire business"? :-)
Tesla acquired SolarCity which became their Tesla Energy division so it's not just cars, they also do residential solar, batteries, and supercharger infrastructure (which more and more manufacturers are using).
And what if another company (tesla) makes its own batteries.
Are they judged in a similar fashion?
> all predicated on getting government money.
Ostensibly the government spends its money and things that benefit the population, no?In an ideal world, what you're saying makes sense, but at least to give an example, for an Android phone, you have to persuade 500 million people to buy it. For SpaceX to get a multi billion dollar contract with the government you only have to persuade 10 people.
I took my Y to the Bay Area this last week and with the crappy roads, it was a rough, rough ride.
That being said, like others have said.. I won't spend money on another Tesla while Elon's there, even if they ship magic on a stick.
Service and Energy Generation are <10% LOBs. They are a car business.
Really they aren't doing poorly when you consider the awful interest rates out there.
Until you've lived at a time when 13% was considered a great mortgage rate, you have no idea what an "awful" interest rate is.
That it would largely be about Musk winning, rather than doing all that he can to support global EV adoption, would absolutely track for him.
Either way, looked it up out of curiosity: Audi's parent company, Volkswagen, currently has a market cap of ~58B EUR with revenue over 300B EUR in 2023. Tesla has a market cap of $772B with revenue just under $100B in 2023.
Tesla's stock is trading (and has) at a staggering multiple for the automotive industry. It's fair to call out that their competitors may have their own struggles, but negative growth in Tesla's primary product line is going to make it increasingly tough for investors to stomach that premium.
Elon has a gift for selling a vision, so I certainly wouldn't bet against Tesla on any short-term horizon, but I struggle to imagine that alone will be able to carry their stock price in perpetuity.
I'll explain for you what my comment means. Operating income is a measure we use to see how profitable a company is at its core business after you subtract the costs of running that business.
Yes the credits are a small portion of Tesla's income but after account for the costs of building cars what's' left is the operating income. Those credits are about half o that income, without them the operating income( a measure of if the core business works) would be cut in half.
That is a significant measure.
It's very clear on the diagram I linked above. You can't attribute 100% of 'operating income' to one thing. If anything you need to attribute things proportional to their inputs. Otherwise it's misleading.
I mean if that's what you want, here you go - https://imgur.com/a/dWrGKuN
Then you create a strawman scenario of 'without tax credits...'. Well no, without tax credits the spending policies and prices of other revenue streams change in order to hit net income targets.
Hasn't this always been the case? Haven't they always been dependent on credits and subsidies to make a profit?
Tesla's received almost $3 billion in state and federal subsidies and half a billion in bailouts[0] (and has more violations[1] than most other companies of its size). Additionally, they regularly engage in probably illegal accounting practices like categorizing automobile warranty expenses as part of the "Goodwill" category rather than the cost of making the vehicle leading to a huge inflation of Tesla's claimed gross margin
[0] https://subsidytracker.goodjobsfirst.org/?parent=tesla-inc
[1] https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/parent/tesla-inc
They had a few decent misses on operating income and earnings per share.
And their operating margin is in the low 6%ish which would make it one of the worst performing auto manufacturers around at the moment.
Man things have turned quickly on Tesla.
They are still in a good cash position but their car business is really showing signs of strain at the moment.
they did announce that they'll release a more affordable model by the end of H125 so that will help, but with that timeframe its likely to be a model 3 refresh and not a new car.