News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by purple-leafy on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:49AM (#40363512)
Narrator: A new car built by my company leaves somewhere traveling at 60 mph. The rear differential locks up. The car crashes and burns with everyone trapped inside. Now, should we initiate a recall? Take the number of vehicles in the field, A, multiply by the probable rate of failure, B, multiply by the average out-of-court settlement, C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one.

Business woman on plane: Are there a lot of these kinds of accidents?

Narrator: You wouldn't believe.

Business woman on plane: Which car company do you work for?

Narrator: A major one.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mcepl on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @02:53AM (#40363858)
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by ebri on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @02:21AM (#40363682)
great crossreference, I salute you
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by lukan on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @03:02AM (#40363920)
(The reference is "Fight Club" for the uninitiated btw.)
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Liquix on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @03:08AM (#40363949)
the third rule of fight club is that it's okay to explain references to fight club on pseudonymous discussion boards, provided the explanation is furnished in parentheses
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by whoknowsidont on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @02:53AM (#40363857)
There's a button for that.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by dralley on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @07:39AM (#40365548)
Don't turn this into Reddit
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by pif on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @07:19AM (#40365381)
> A new car built by my company ...

While I think I get your point, I also believe that the background is very important. If your company applied standard engineering procedures, that's critically different from building a new product and actively hiding the differences with respect to the last one.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:01AM (#40365759)
Like Toyota's car with a “simulated stick shift”? https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a45754176/toyota-manual-ev...

> The prototype was convincing even when we tried to fool it. De-clutching leaves the car coasting, and selecting lower gears increases the regenerative braking, simulating the feeling of engine braking. When downshifting, it's possible to rev match by blipping the accelerator in the brief moment when the clutch is fully depressed. The penalty for letting the clutch up too abruptly when selecting a low gear is a bump of shift shock—momentarily over-revving the electric motors—and a similar lack of finesse when trying to pull away without sufficient revs results in a virtual stall.

Sure, simulating the stall characteristics of an aeroplane is several orders of magnitude worse than simulating the stall characteristics of a car, but… still.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by maxerickson on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:09AM (#40365838)
It doesn't sound like Toyota is trying to hide anything, they are preparing to sell something they think people want.

(The feature sounds stupid to me)

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by tstrimple on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:58AM (#40366315)
I've been eyeing the Ioniq 5 N which has the paddle shifting rev-limiting simulation stuff as well. Most of the reviewers really enjoy those features on a track. When coming up to a turn, the simulated RPM gives you much more contextual information than a pure electric experience does. The main point that kept coming up is the RPM levels when approaching a corner. They could tell if their speed was right in the approach based on the sound the engine was faking which is how they would drive a manual ICE car through the same track. Of course you can turn all that off and soften the suspension right back up in order to get the comfortable daily driving most folks are after. I don't think it belongs on most EV, but it certainly seems to enhance some. At least while we're still more familiar with the trappings of ICE performance vehicles.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by maxerickson on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:26AM (#40366640)
I would guess that it will vanish when someone comes up with a similar feedback mechanism that is better aligned with the performance characteristics of the powertrain.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by newsclues on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:59AM (#40367826)
I think the technology will explode when you can download a tune from classic or cool cars and have the sound and performance map of a Ferrari or Aston Martin when you go out for a fun drive on weekends.

It’s not about max speed but enjoying the experience of driving.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mikestew on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @03:14PM (#40371103)
That's the most reasonable explanation I've heard for why the N model makes "unnecessary" noise. Because as an owner of a regular Ioniq 5, I feel it's an otherwise dumb idea. The reviews I've read all just say, "makes vroom-vroom noises, yeah!" But track-time feedback, okay, I can get along with that.

(And it makes those steering wheel flappy paddles at least somewhat useful. The paddles on mine just change the regenerative braking level...which could have been done with a steering wheel button.)

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by maximus-decimus on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:38AM (#40366119)
99.9% of cars with cvts pretend to switch gear instead of just acting like a CVT.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mrWiz on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:52PM (#40374112)
What's your source on this? My 2014 Outback does not pretend to shift gears, is it part of the 0.1%?
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by maximus-decimus on Thursday May 16, 2024 @09:00AM (#40377830)
I watch a lot of car reviews for fun and they all comment on cvt behavior. The only recent car I've heard of that actually acts like a cvt is the mitsubishi mirage (maybe all mitsus? I don't really see any reviews of them). Then there's the new impreza that sometimes acts like a cvt and sometimes fakes gear shifts.

Apparently they used to behave to cvts but people hated that so they switched to faking gears. Maybe your car predates that, I don't know what year they started doing that non-sense.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by hughesjj on Thursday May 16, 2024 @07:49PM (#40384752)
My 2021 Forrester absolutely pretends to shift gears, wonder what's different
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:37AM (#40366108)
It is a stretch to call the MAXes a new product, even though it turned out to require more extensive work than envisioned, but the bit about actively hiding the differences is right on point.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:39AM (#40366126)
There’s a bigger difference between the MAX family and other versions of the 737 than there is between all the different crossovers a car company pumps out.

Boeing 737 MAX 7 is 138,699 lbs vs 737 800 @ 90,710lb vs 737 100 @ 61.994 lbs. Hell the new 737 MAX 10 is ~203,000 lb.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by dylan604 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:12AM (#40367206)
Is the size the biggest difference or the fact that the center of gravity is totally different? So much so, they created an "hidden" software program to counter the CoG difference so the pilots feel like it is in the same place they are used to?
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by labcomputer on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:08PM (#40369625)
No, CoG has approximately nothing to do with it.

The problem with the Max is aerodynamics: Civil airplanes are designed with negative aerodynamic feedback, so the nose-down torque (“pitching moment”) increases as the AoA increases. But on the Max at very high AoA this feedback torque becomes somewhat smaller due to interaction of airflow around the engines and the wing. That by itself is not a problem because the nose-down torque still exists and airframe is still stable.

There is a regulatory requirement that the amount of pilot’s control force required to maintain a given AoA must be a non-decreasing function of AoA[1]. Due to the Max’s aerodynamics, this requirement is not met.

Boeing’s MCAS was a bandaid to make the plane meet regulations by applying nose-down trim while at high AoA. The trim results in a higher yoke force, so the plane meets the requirement. A better method would have been a “stick pusher” (which have been used as stall prevention devices for over 50 years, though not on the 737) or addition ventral fins (like on the Beech 1900). But either of those would have probably required recertification

[1] The purpose of this is to reduce pilot-induced oscillations: see what happened with AA flight 587, where the lack of a similar requirement for rudder pedals and yaw led to PIO which ultimately resulted in the tail falling off an Airbus.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:42AM (#40366148)
This is not the issue that is raising questions of criminal liability.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:52AM (#40366253)
It’s definitely part of the issue.

Boeing was trying to pretend scaling the aircraft again and again wasn’t significant due to regulations and physics eventually disagreed.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:09AM (#40366428)
Regardless of how one characterizes the magnitude of the changes, if the unanticipated difficulties had been handled openly, there would be no question of criminal liability. Furthermore (though it is also beside the point), physics has not ruled out the MAXes.

In addition, the door-plug issue is tied in here on account of the 2021 deferred prosecution agreement, which also followed from Boeing's duplicity over the MAX issue.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:33AM (#40366710)
> Regardless of how one characterizes the magnitude of the changes, if the unanticipated difficulties had been handled openly, there would be no question of criminal liability

You’re skipping over the first half of my statement. If the unexpected difficulties had been handled openly they would have needed to go through more regulatory hurdles. Physics didn’t put them into some kind of catch 22 situation the aircraft could have been safe, it just couldn’t be safe while playing games with regulators. That’s where criminal liability shows up.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:22AM (#40367339)
As far as I can tell, I'm just skipping over the issues which may be true, but are beside the point, but then, it is not clear to me which statement's first half you think I am skipping over.

The point I have been making all along is that, regardless of what led Boeing to the point of choosing to hide or misrepresent the situation, it is the choice to do so that turns this into a potentially criminal matter. With the same physical/technical problems but proper and timely disclosure of the issues during development, by far the most likely outcome would have been a delayed program delivering MAXes substantially similar (in both construction and operation) to the ones which are certified and flying today. After that, even in the unlikely event that the crashes had occurred, criminal prosecution would be unlikely, and certainly not on the basis of the facts for which it is currently being considered.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:30AM (#40367458)
> are besides the point

Except they aren’t beside the point.

> substantially similar (in both construction and operation)

The physical aircraft would have been similar, but airlines would have spent 10’s of millions more on training which makes a real difference to them and thus sales.

Boeing could have released the aircraft on exactly the same date while complying with the spirit of relevant relations though at higher costs, but the product would have been meaningfully worse from a sales perspective. Even today regulators have allowed Boeing and the airlines to treat the 737 MAX family as much more closely related to earlier 737’s than they actually are.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:52AM (#40368569)
All of these things are beside the point here because none of them form the basis on which criminal proceedings are being considered by the DOJ. Without the information hiding and misrepresentation, there is no basis, regardless of either the physics or the economics of the issue.

In addition, even if it is true that regulators have now allowed Boeing and the airlines to treat the 737 MAX family as much more closely related to earlier 737’s than they actually are, this is not the basis of the DOJ's investigation, either.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:04PM (#40368747)
Criminal proceedings in the US care about motives. It would be vastly harder to bring a case like this if there weren’t incentives to ack as they did.

Regulators aren’t at issue, but trying to avoid regulatory scrutiny is. Or as is often said it’s the coverup that they get you for.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:14PM (#40368916)
The motives were there regardless of how Boeing chose to act. It's the chosen act that is potentially criminal. The DOJ is not in any doubt as to whether or not Boeing had a motive, and it is not considering at all the question of whether regulators have now allowed Boeing and the airlines to treat the 737 MAX family as much more closely related to earlier 737’s than they actually are, regardless of any parties' motives in that regard.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:22PM (#40369810)
A and B is false if B is false, but that doesn’t make A irrelevant.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @07:28PM (#40373572)
It is not at all clear what (if anything) A and B are standing in for here, so instead of discussing them, let's go back and see what specific issue prompted our disagreement over whether it was to the point here. It was just this: "There’s a bigger difference between the MAX family and other versions of the 737 than there is between all the different crossovers a car company pumps out..." [1] (specific weight differences elided for brevity.)

I won't dispute the implicit claim that this was an important factor in Boeing running into development difficulties, but running into development difficulties is not a crime. Materially misrepresenting the state of the development process (specifically (IMHO) the magnitude of the high-AofA handling problem, rather than merely weight issues) to the FAA is a crime, and it is this, not the fact that Boeing ran into technical difficulties, that is the point of DOJ's investigation, the article, and the discussion here of it.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40366126

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Retric on Thursday May 16, 2024 @01:02AM (#40375348)
It wasn’t developed difficulties at issue here. They inserted a system and hid what it did and where it could fail from pilots and airlines. Quite literally removing it from the manual: “elected to not describe it in the flight manual or in training materials” https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maneuvering_Characteristics_Au...

So when it failed and pilots had no idea what the issue was people died. The crazy thing here is telling pilots about it could have prevented those crashes even with an absolutely identical aircraft being released.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mannykannot on Thursday May 16, 2024 @09:00AM (#40377835)
Perhaps the first thing to note about your latest response is that it makes no mention of the increase of weight of the MAXes over their predecessors, and yet it was specifically over the relevance of the weight change where we disagreed [1]. I have followed this story quite closely, and I haven't seen anyone citing the weight gain as being a factor in this tragedy, let alone claiming that the weight gain itself amounted to something criminal (or that Boeing was somehow hiding it, for that matter), and your summary here, by its omission of the weight issue, tacitly acknowledges its lack of relevance.

The second omission from this summary is any mention of Boeing's interaction with the FAA staff having the responsibility for certifying the MAXes as airworthy (together with the adequacy of the flight manuals and training materials), and yet, in all other accounts I have seen, Boeing misrepresented (to put it mildly) the extent to which MCAS was modifying the handling characteristics of the airplane and therefore the consequences of its failure and the need for pilots to know about it. No-one else, as far as I am aware, disputes the fact that the DOJ's investigation is centered on this dissembling (together with similar dissembling relating to the plug door incident, which is being included on account of the MAX issue being in a deferred prosecution status.) Once your account here is augmented with this missing information, it becomes clear that this pattern of dissembling is what the DOJ is investigating as a possible crime, as I have been saying all along.

Now you want to extend this disagreement by disputing my characterization of Boeing's difficulties in developing the MAXes as being, well, development difficulties! It is not clear to me what point you are trying to make by doing so, but to be clear, I am most certainly not dismissing the tragedy as merely a matter of development difficulties. On the contrary, I am saying that this became a criminal matter precisely when Boeing went beyond treating the matter as an above-the-board technical problem, and started misleading the FAA.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40366126

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by labcomputer on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:46PM (#40369318)
> Boeing 737 MAX 7 is 138,699 lbs vs 737 800 @ 90,710lb vs 737 100 @ 61.994 lbs. Hell the new 737 MAX 10 is ~203,000 lb.

No, you are confusing the empty weight of the 737-800 with the mass gross takeoff weight of the 737 max 7.

The correct comparison of MGTW is 174,200 (-800) vs 177,000 (max 7).

Similarly, the -100’s MGTW was 110,000, not 61,994. Also, the only source I can find for the max 10 is 197,900, not 203,000.

Edit: so the plane grew by 80%, not 320%

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by bmitc on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:07AM (#40365816)
Is this referencing a real event or interview?
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by ThrowawayTestr on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:09AM (#40365830)
It's referencing Fight Club
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by bmitc on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:10AM (#40365842)
Thank you.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by someonehere on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @08:59AM (#40366340)
It’s comical nobody gets this reference, sir.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gruez on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:04AM (#40366386)
This might seem calculating and cold, but that's basically how government agencies work. It doesn't make sense to spend unlimited amounts of money to save a life, so government agencies have some sort of a dollar value on a life[1], above which where they won't bother doing interventions. For instance if it takes $15M to save a life, and that's above the DoT's estimate of $12.5M, then they won't bother. That's not to say that Boeing is in the right here, but if they were in the wrong it's not because "If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one", it's because they grossly undervalued a life in their calculations.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#United_States

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:57AM (#40367027)
Government agencies use the statistical value of a life to weigh the benefits of a regulation against the costs to the public - the same people who would benefit from the regulation. Would a new safety requirement for cars be worth it if it added $500 to the price of every new car? They might use the value of a life to help answer that question.

This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation. When government agencies make rules about product recalls, they do not try to balance the benefit to the public against the cost to the recalling company, that would be insane.

See the DoT's own guidance here: https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2021-03/D.... They do not at all use this figure in the same way that a profit-driven entity does.

> The benefit of preventing a fatality is measured by what is conventionally called the Value of a Statistical Life, defined as the additional cost that individuals would be willing to bear for improvements in safety (that is, reductions in risks) that, in the aggregate, reduce the expected number of fatalities by one.

The word "individuals" is very important in this definition.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gruez on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:07AM (#40367148)
>This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation.

...assuming they don't pass it on to the customers

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:29AM (#40367440)
That would be illegal, and "the public" is much larger than just the customers of a particular company. This is beside the point though. The government asks "would the average person be willing to pay $x to lower their chance of death by y%". The corporate executive asks "would I be willing to pay >$0 to lower their chance of death by y%". "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make."
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gruez on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:03PM (#40368735)
>That would be illegal

As the other commenter has mentioned, it's passed on via higher prices in the future.

>This is beside the point though. The government asks "would the average person be willing to pay $x to lower their chance of death by y%". The corporate executive asks "would I be willing to pay >$0 to lower their chance of death by y%". "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make."

Okay, but surely you don't agree that Boeing should spend infinite amounts of money making their planes safe? For instance we don't install backup engines on the off chance that all 2 engines fail. That's all I'm trying to argue, that the cold calculation/cost benefit analysis as mentioned in the OP isn't where Boeing went wrong, it's that they they undervalued the value of a human life. This was specifically mentioned in my original comment.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:49PM (#40369355)
What I am trying to argue is that valuing a human life accurately doesn't matter if you're weighing it against your own profits. The correct comparison is against societal benefit, profit is completely morally irrelevant.

I agree that the ceiling for how much money you could spend trying to make an airplane perfectly safe is infinite, so by definition they have to stop somewhere. However, I disagree that finding that line of where to stop has anything to do with the statistical value of a human life.

For example, imagine the Boeing CEO says "we could spend $20 billion on R&D and manufacturing of a new safety system that would on average prevent 1 crash per year, but a 737 MAX carries 200 people, at $15M per life that's only $3 billion in value, so it's obviously better for us to skip it and pass that $20 billion on to shareholders". This would be criminal, and not because their value of a life is off and they got the math a little bit wrong. It's criminal because they are consciously choosing to kill people unnecessarily.

If it is physically and financially possible to make your product safer, you do it, without any thought to how much a life is worth. If it is not possible, because you can't figure out how to solve a problem or it would be so expensive to fix that your business couldn't survive, then you sit down and think about whether it's worth selling your product at all. Are there safer alternatives available? Could a better-funded company fix the flaws you've found? If you determine that your product is important, there are no alternatives out there, and it cannot be made safer, only then do you start weighing the benefits to society against the deaths you expect to occur. I don't really think this is a financial decision involving the value of a life - if you expect your product to kill people then the expected benefits need to be so overwhelming that doing the financial math is unnecessary.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by llm_trw on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:03PM (#40369562)
>For example, imagine the Boeing CEO says "we could spend $20 billion on R&D and manufacturing of a new safety system that would on average prevent 1 crash per year, but a 737 MAX carries 200 people, at $15M per life that's only $3 billion in value, so it's obviously better for us to skip it and pass that $20 billion on to shareholders". This would be criminal, and not because their value of a life is off and they got the math a little bit wrong. It's criminal because they are consciously choosing to kill people unnecessarily.

It is not criminal and I have no idea how anyone can think it is.

The crime is in the first paragraphs of the article:

>Boeing has violated a 2021 agreement that shielded it from criminal prosecution after two 737 Max disasters killed 346 people overseas, the Justice Department told a federal judge in a court filing Tuesday.

>According to the Justice Department, Boeing failed to "design, implement, and enforce a compliance and ethics program to prevent and detect violations of the U.S. fraud laws throughout its operations."

So to recap, they were agreed to implement internal rules that match US laws after killing a bunch of people to avoid criminal liability, _which they failed to do_.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gravescale on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @06:51PM (#40373332)
> If it is physically and financially possible to make your product safer, you do it, without any thought to how much a life is worth.

A cursory glance at how literally any product is designed will tell you that this is not true.

All engineering is fundamentally compromise between utility functions and cost functions (where cost is monetary, or weight, or size, or poor usability, ugliness etc). There's always a balance point somewhere. It may be the cost/benefit functions to the user differ from those of the manufacturer, and again to regulators, so the product appears out-of-balance to one or the other, but a meta-balance was struck somewhere.

If every light switch was a 2-foot, 200kg cube with a titanium shell filled with monitoring electronics running on lockstepped processors, fire suppression and potting compound, and was tested individually for a year before sale, it's still not as safe as one with six grounding points (in case the first 5 fail) and triple-thick gold plating on the contacts. You have to stop somewhere.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by verall on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:36AM (#40379003)
This isn't what the parent comment is saying. Functional safety is an entire discipline. It neither results in titanium light switches nor uses "value of a human life" calculations. The scenario described by the parent would be a civil and potentially criminal liability.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gravescale on Thursday May 16, 2024 @07:02PM (#40384375)
I know what functional safety is. It's just not described by "you must always make all possible efforts to make things safer under all possible circumstances".

In the case of a normal light switch, for example, two cable screws rather than one per wire would be safer than one as the cables are less likely to come adrift. This would easily be affordable for the manufacturer and the buyer, and well within the abilities of the manufacturer. And yet no light switch has those.

And every aircraft manufacturer could think of something the costs $20 billion to develop and adds safety but they don't, unless the product is unsafe already The one crash a year is, to be fair, solidly in the unsafe end of the spectrum, but would they spend the same to avoid a once in 10,000 year crash and if not, what's the cut-off? There must be a cut-off or it would be impossible for any manufacturer of anything to make any profit, ever, as all spare cash must go into safety system research. And this is demonstratively not what they do.

Boeing has a slightly different problem in that they actively made something less safe and lied about it. They'd have gotten away with it but they flubbed the execution with a single point of failure, which made it easier to line up the Swiss cheese holes and the rest is history.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by verall on Friday May 17, 2024 @09:54AM (#40389912)
> It's just not described by...

Yes, I know - I think I read the parent comment as "If it is physically and financially [reasonable] to make your product safer, you do it"

This is basically what I was taught working in automotive safety.

> ... what's the cut-off? There must be a cut-off...

There's no hard $$ or other cutoff though, it's a soft cutoff that may come down to engineers and/or management arguing about what is really safer.

> Boeing has a slightly different problem in that they actively made something less safe and lied about it.

Yes I agree, for Boeing it is different, reading about their management's intention destruction of positive safety culture is sickening.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by beojan on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @06:10PM (#40373015)
> For instance we don't install backup engines on the off chance that all 2 engines fail.

We used to. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by krisoft on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:19AM (#40368109)
> That would be illegal

What do you mean it would be illegal? Obviously the corporation prices in all the expected future recalls into their prices. Yes they won't charge you for the recall, but the future costumers will pay higher prices if in the corporation's calculation the chance of recalls (or the cost of doing them) is increased.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by cycomanic on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:45PM (#40369312)
> > That would be illegal

> What do you mean it would be illegal? Obviously the corporation prices in all the expected future recalls into their prices. Yes they won't charge you for the recall, but the future costumers will pay higher prices if in the corporation's calculation the chance of recalls (or the cost of doing them) is increased.

Why oh why do I have to read this on HN again and again? The price of a good does not primarily depend on the cost to make it. So no Boeing can't easily raise their future prices to account for the cost of saving lifes, because there are competitors.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Georgelemental on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @05:34PM (#40372672)
> because there are competitors

Unfortunately, in Boeing's case there aren't very many competitors.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by krisoft on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:03AM (#40378617)
Ok? Does that change the legality of what I described? I don't think so. And that is what I talked about. Raising their prices to cover the recall would not be illegal. Maybe it would be bad business for them, maybe not. I haven't said anything about that.

> Why oh why do I have to read this on HN again and again?

This is unnecessarily confrontational.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by enragedcacti on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:30AM (#40367455)
If they could have charged more for the car they already would have. A recall only affecting one make or model won't have a large effect on the profit-maximizing price of the car because the value proposition of the car hasn't changed (or got worse because of perceived unreliability). The cost would then be born by the company and not the consumer.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by close04 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:07AM (#40367940)
They could make products or services more expensive but then manufacturers with many recalls would end up being prohibitively expensive.

Each person can just choose individually a different manufacturer from the many options, one being "none at all". But you only get one government, it takes a majority to choose, and once chosen you're bound to its directions. So not the same thing at all.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by hatenberg on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:28AM (#40378909)
Competition is the antidote to passing it on, which is why regulatory intervention against concentration is critical. Left to it's own devices, competition disappears in capitalism.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by jollyllama on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:16AM (#40366510)
We were taught as part of our CS curriculum that "often, the refusal to assign a dollar value to a human life results in it being terribly undervalued."
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by mountainb on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:07AM (#40367159)
There is no such reluctance to do this in law. I think in philosophy classes, professors feel shy about acknowledging the humdrum reality of insurance, the tax code, and our regulatory bodies continuously assigning dollar values to human lives. It feels good and makes you look like a better person to say things like "the value of a single human life cannot be expressed in money terms." Perhaps this is the case, and what the companies and the governmental bodies are really valuing is the economically meaningful activity associated with a person and not the totality of their person.

Babies are worth a lot of money even at a low imputed earning potential just because they have so much life to live.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by skywal_l on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:49AM (#40366936)
Put some CEOs in jail and you won't need to do all those multiplications.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Spooky23 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:23AM (#40368159)
There’s always a risk calculus that seems cold to an outside observer.

The issue with Boeing and the MAX is that they sort of used the designation of the plane to for lack of a better term, avoid some of the risk calculations.

With the early issues, a pretty cut and dry type training program would have likely prevented catastrophic incidents. They shaved pennys and set many dollars (and hundreds of people) on fire.

If you run a company where low probability, high impact risks drive the operations of your products, setting trust on fire is going to have a real impact on your bottom line. You go from a trusted, admired company to target of memes about assassinated whistleblowers.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by everforward on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:49AM (#40368523)
My very amateur understanding is that the MAX would have been dead on arrival if it required recertification. It was a marginal bump in fuel efficiency that still lagged behind Aerobus, so their only real marketing strategy was not having to recertify.

Basically either it didn’t require recertification or it wasn’t worth making. I suspect somewhere along the line they realized that wasn’t practical and they either shipped a shoddy project and maybe burned a pile of money or they gave up and definitely burned a smaller but still sizable pile of money.

Probably also some worry that if they didn’t have a competitive smaller plane, they’d lose market share and there’d be even less interest in their next plane.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by salawat on Thursday May 16, 2024 @02:01AM (#40375634)
...Actually it doesn't matter how relatively uncompetitive it would have been in the face of Airbus. Their (Airbus's) waitlist is so bloody long, you'd still have looked longingly at Boeing anyway.

Despite that, they made a coscious decision to deceive airlines, pilots, and their regulators. All to "maximize shareholder value".

That's what's criminal.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Spooky23 on Friday May 17, 2024 @11:24AM (#40390919)
Exactly. End of the day, poor governance from product inception to execution to operation.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by HPsquared on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:25AM (#40366629)
In practice, there's a difference between a hypothetical probabilistic death rate, and real people / news stories.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:53AM (#40367747)
No it's because they grossly underestimated the importance of brand trust and reputation
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by crznp on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @02:38PM (#40370700)
Or: they had an accurate estimate for the importance of brand trust and reputation over the short term, and they've had that short term outlook for a long time. Perhaps since 1997.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by cced on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:08AM (#40367164)
The problem with this type of thinking is that it often assumes externalized costs, and even at that, what price do you put on “I don’t want to use car of brand X because the car maker is doing sus things and people speaking out about it are dying.” ?

Take for instance the recent train derailments. Are the costs of cleanup n>0 if the company can get their lawyers to successfully argue they don’t need to pay it? For the company it’s n=0 but for society it is n>0.

Doing the maths is simpler when you can disregard many factors and leave only the ones that affect your bottom line.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by stephenr on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:29PM (#40369897)
Government agencies in the form of rescue/emergency response organisations frequently spend huge sums of money to try to rescue indidivuals.

The US Coast Guard explicitly stated that they "do not associate cost with saving a life" following that fateful Billionaires game of chicken with extreme water pressure.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by badpun on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @04:19PM (#40371875)
The difference is that the government agency actions do not cause deaths (it merely prevents death from independent causes), whereas "major car manufacturer" kills people with their faulty rear differential.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by bastard_op on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @06:19PM (#40373093)
And what self-respecting congressman, senator, or president didn't have a pet CEO or three of any said major automotive cartel at the time sponsoring them? If they didn't, they're not doing it right.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by asah on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:25AM (#40366633)
Just C is set to a high enough value, including personal penalties and imprisonment for any executives who failed to stop this decision (including the failure to setup reporting to hear about such decisions).
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by brian_herman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:42AM (#40366851)
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by bottom999mottob on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:03AM (#40367877)
Honestly this quote is one of Chuck Palahniuk's best dialogues. Recommend checking out his other work like 'Rant.'
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by hengistbury on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:44PM (#40369283)
More accurately, this is a quote from the Fight Club movie
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by tanseydavid on Thursday May 16, 2024 @02:54PM (#40381826)
It is in the book. The book came first.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gosub100 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:03AM (#40367096)
What's the alternative? Never ship unless the risk is 0.00? (And yes I get the book reference)
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by MisterBastahrd on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:17AM (#40367269)
Reminds me of a business consultant who recently got roasted on TikTok recently because he described his $500k job as deciding whether or not companies should recall products or just weather the class action and liability suits.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by tangjurine on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:59AM (#40368663)
Source?
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by IG_Semmelweiss on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:50AM (#40367711)
This 5ypical MBA formula ignores the most important variable.

Z = brand trust

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by tflol on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:05AM (#40367900)
oh so this is what google facebook elon musk microsoft does to collect/share user data then get slammed with affordable fines later. I surprised this quote hasnt come to mind at reading those article
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by bongoman42 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:37AM (#40368344)
For airlines and many other things you also have to consider the case that people might switch to even worse alternatives if the cost is too high. If airlines have to raise the prices too high for added safety features, people will switch to cars which are several orders of magnitude worse in safety. So airplanes might become safer but society may be overall worse off.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by rawgabbit on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:57AM (#40368636)
This formula is for the statistically stupid. There is no such thing as average out-of-court settlement. One jury may find your company’s behavior as egregious and decide to drive you out of business by awarding a trillion dollar judgment. Next your business insurance drops you for being uninsurable.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by henry2023 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:05PM (#40369575)
1. There are long tail distributions which have a statistical mean

2. Boeign exists

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by rawgabbit on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @07:57PM (#40373762)
If a jury awards a trillion dollar judgment, that is not a long tail distribution. It blows up the distribution as it is an asymptote.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by henry2023 on Thursday May 16, 2024 @02:36AM (#40375786)
When was the last time you heard about a jury awarding a trillion dollar settlement ? If any, fines tend to be in the low spectrum (1% a 3%) of net revenue.

Get some data and graph it. It’s long tail

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by rawgabbit on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:42PM (#40411270)
You just made my point. Thank you. Good day.