News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:57AM (#40367027)
Government agencies use the statistical value of a life to weigh the benefits of a regulation against the costs to the public - the same people who would benefit from the regulation. Would a new safety requirement for cars be worth it if it added $500 to the price of every new car? They might use the value of a life to help answer that question.

This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation. When government agencies make rules about product recalls, they do not try to balance the benefit to the public against the cost to the recalling company, that would be insane.

See the DoT's own guidance here: https://www.transportation.gov/sites/dot.gov/files/2021-03/D.... They do not at all use this figure in the same way that a profit-driven entity does.

> The benefit of preventing a fatality is measured by what is conventionally called the Value of a Statistical Life, defined as the additional cost that individuals would be willing to bear for improvements in safety (that is, reductions in risks) that, in the aggregate, reduce the expected number of fatalities by one.

The word "individuals" is very important in this definition.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gruez on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:07AM (#40367148)
>This is very different than the recall story, because in that scenario there is no cost to the public at all, only to the corporation.

...assuming they don't pass it on to the customers

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:29AM (#40367440)
That would be illegal, and "the public" is much larger than just the customers of a particular company. This is beside the point though. The government asks "would the average person be willing to pay $x to lower their chance of death by y%". The corporate executive asks "would I be willing to pay >$0 to lower their chance of death by y%". "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make."
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gruez on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:03PM (#40368735)
>That would be illegal

As the other commenter has mentioned, it's passed on via higher prices in the future.

>This is beside the point though. The government asks "would the average person be willing to pay $x to lower their chance of death by y%". The corporate executive asks "would I be willing to pay >$0 to lower their chance of death by y%". "Some of you may die, but it's a sacrifice I am willing to make."

Okay, but surely you don't agree that Boeing should spend infinite amounts of money making their planes safe? For instance we don't install backup engines on the off chance that all 2 engines fail. That's all I'm trying to argue, that the cold calculation/cost benefit analysis as mentioned in the OP isn't where Boeing went wrong, it's that they they undervalued the value of a human life. This was specifically mentioned in my original comment.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by burkaman on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:49PM (#40369355)
What I am trying to argue is that valuing a human life accurately doesn't matter if you're weighing it against your own profits. The correct comparison is against societal benefit, profit is completely morally irrelevant.

I agree that the ceiling for how much money you could spend trying to make an airplane perfectly safe is infinite, so by definition they have to stop somewhere. However, I disagree that finding that line of where to stop has anything to do with the statistical value of a human life.

For example, imagine the Boeing CEO says "we could spend $20 billion on R&D and manufacturing of a new safety system that would on average prevent 1 crash per year, but a 737 MAX carries 200 people, at $15M per life that's only $3 billion in value, so it's obviously better for us to skip it and pass that $20 billion on to shareholders". This would be criminal, and not because their value of a life is off and they got the math a little bit wrong. It's criminal because they are consciously choosing to kill people unnecessarily.

If it is physically and financially possible to make your product safer, you do it, without any thought to how much a life is worth. If it is not possible, because you can't figure out how to solve a problem or it would be so expensive to fix that your business couldn't survive, then you sit down and think about whether it's worth selling your product at all. Are there safer alternatives available? Could a better-funded company fix the flaws you've found? If you determine that your product is important, there are no alternatives out there, and it cannot be made safer, only then do you start weighing the benefits to society against the deaths you expect to occur. I don't really think this is a financial decision involving the value of a life - if you expect your product to kill people then the expected benefits need to be so overwhelming that doing the financial math is unnecessary.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by llm_trw on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:03PM (#40369562)
>For example, imagine the Boeing CEO says "we could spend $20 billion on R&D and manufacturing of a new safety system that would on average prevent 1 crash per year, but a 737 MAX carries 200 people, at $15M per life that's only $3 billion in value, so it's obviously better for us to skip it and pass that $20 billion on to shareholders". This would be criminal, and not because their value of a life is off and they got the math a little bit wrong. It's criminal because they are consciously choosing to kill people unnecessarily.

It is not criminal and I have no idea how anyone can think it is.

The crime is in the first paragraphs of the article:

>Boeing has violated a 2021 agreement that shielded it from criminal prosecution after two 737 Max disasters killed 346 people overseas, the Justice Department told a federal judge in a court filing Tuesday.

>According to the Justice Department, Boeing failed to "design, implement, and enforce a compliance and ethics program to prevent and detect violations of the U.S. fraud laws throughout its operations."

So to recap, they were agreed to implement internal rules that match US laws after killing a bunch of people to avoid criminal liability, _which they failed to do_.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gravescale on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @06:51PM (#40373332)
> If it is physically and financially possible to make your product safer, you do it, without any thought to how much a life is worth.

A cursory glance at how literally any product is designed will tell you that this is not true.

All engineering is fundamentally compromise between utility functions and cost functions (where cost is monetary, or weight, or size, or poor usability, ugliness etc). There's always a balance point somewhere. It may be the cost/benefit functions to the user differ from those of the manufacturer, and again to regulators, so the product appears out-of-balance to one or the other, but a meta-balance was struck somewhere.

If every light switch was a 2-foot, 200kg cube with a titanium shell filled with monitoring electronics running on lockstepped processors, fire suppression and potting compound, and was tested individually for a year before sale, it's still not as safe as one with six grounding points (in case the first 5 fail) and triple-thick gold plating on the contacts. You have to stop somewhere.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by verall on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:36AM (#40379003)
This isn't what the parent comment is saying. Functional safety is an entire discipline. It neither results in titanium light switches nor uses "value of a human life" calculations. The scenario described by the parent would be a civil and potentially criminal liability.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by gravescale on Thursday May 16, 2024 @07:02PM (#40384375)
I know what functional safety is. It's just not described by "you must always make all possible efforts to make things safer under all possible circumstances".

In the case of a normal light switch, for example, two cable screws rather than one per wire would be safer than one as the cables are less likely to come adrift. This would easily be affordable for the manufacturer and the buyer, and well within the abilities of the manufacturer. And yet no light switch has those.

And every aircraft manufacturer could think of something the costs $20 billion to develop and adds safety but they don't, unless the product is unsafe already The one crash a year is, to be fair, solidly in the unsafe end of the spectrum, but would they spend the same to avoid a once in 10,000 year crash and if not, what's the cut-off? There must be a cut-off or it would be impossible for any manufacturer of anything to make any profit, ever, as all spare cash must go into safety system research. And this is demonstratively not what they do.

Boeing has a slightly different problem in that they actively made something less safe and lied about it. They'd have gotten away with it but they flubbed the execution with a single point of failure, which made it easier to line up the Swiss cheese holes and the rest is history.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by verall on Friday May 17, 2024 @09:54AM (#40389912)
> It's just not described by...

Yes, I know - I think I read the parent comment as "If it is physically and financially [reasonable] to make your product safer, you do it"

This is basically what I was taught working in automotive safety.

> ... what's the cut-off? There must be a cut-off...

There's no hard $$ or other cutoff though, it's a soft cutoff that may come down to engineers and/or management arguing about what is really safer.

> Boeing has a slightly different problem in that they actively made something less safe and lied about it.

Yes I agree, for Boeing it is different, reading about their management's intention destruction of positive safety culture is sickening.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by beojan on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @06:10PM (#40373015)
> For instance we don't install backup engines on the off chance that all 2 engines fail.

We used to. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by krisoft on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:19AM (#40368109)
> That would be illegal

What do you mean it would be illegal? Obviously the corporation prices in all the expected future recalls into their prices. Yes they won't charge you for the recall, but the future costumers will pay higher prices if in the corporation's calculation the chance of recalls (or the cost of doing them) is increased.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by cycomanic on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @12:45PM (#40369312)
> > That would be illegal

> What do you mean it would be illegal? Obviously the corporation prices in all the expected future recalls into their prices. Yes they won't charge you for the recall, but the future costumers will pay higher prices if in the corporation's calculation the chance of recalls (or the cost of doing them) is increased.

Why oh why do I have to read this on HN again and again? The price of a good does not primarily depend on the cost to make it. So no Boeing can't easily raise their future prices to account for the cost of saving lifes, because there are competitors.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by Georgelemental on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @05:34PM (#40372672)
> because there are competitors

Unfortunately, in Boeing's case there aren't very many competitors.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by krisoft on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:03AM (#40378617)
Ok? Does that change the legality of what I described? I don't think so. And that is what I talked about. Raising their prices to cover the recall would not be illegal. Maybe it would be bad business for them, maybe not. I haven't said anything about that.

> Why oh why do I have to read this on HN again and again?

This is unnecessarily confrontational.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by enragedcacti on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:30AM (#40367455)
If they could have charged more for the car they already would have. A recall only affecting one make or model won't have a large effect on the profit-maximizing price of the car because the value proposition of the car hasn't changed (or got worse because of perceived unreliability). The cost would then be born by the company and not the consumer.
Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by close04 on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:07AM (#40367940)
They could make products or services more expensive but then manufacturers with many recalls would end up being prohibitively expensive.

Each person can just choose individually a different manufacturer from the many options, one being "none at all". But you only get one government, it takes a majority to choose, and once chosen you're bound to its directions. So not the same thing at all.

Re:Department of Justice says Boeing may be criminally liabl... by hatenberg on Thursday May 16, 2024 @10:28AM (#40378909)
Competition is the antidote to passing it on, which is why regulatory intervention against concentration is critical. Left to it's own devices, competition disappears in capitalism.