News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by vinniepukh on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:37AM (#38802302)
I like the term “emissions-free”.

It keeps our eyes on the target - not emitting CO2 and other gasses to the atmosphere.

Other qualities like “renewablility” or “greenness” are cherries in the top. Nice to haves!

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by globalnode on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:30AM (#38802522)
i agree, but i also dislike the term "natural gas" sure its natural just like everything in the universe is -- just a bit of greenwashing to go with our CO2 emissions
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:15AM (#38802741)
Saying that it is “greenwashing” is ridiculous. The gas is called natural because when it was discovered it came from nature, not from manufacturing by heating coal. This name is older than marketing or green politics and it is quite natural way to call this gas.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by shkkmo on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:27AM (#38802803)
The origin of the term doesn't mean that the term isn't an effective form of greenwashing that creates false perceptions around its harmful effects.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:24AM (#38803120)
The obvious fix for this is better education and a good understanding of the meaning of words ind different contexts. It is a way better than broadly applying various labels to the point when they become completely void of any special meaning.

Greenwashing is an intentional effort to portray greenhouse gas emissions as safe by relativizing their contribution to the climate change. Calling natural gas natural according to an old tradition is not the same.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by SlightlyLeftPad on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:09AM (#38803422)
Would it be wrong of me to coin the terms Natural Organic Oil and Natural Coal? They are both, in fact, natural and organic after all. Adding a prefix like Natural or Organic definitely resonates with a lot of people and builds a perception that it’s “clean.” It’s not ridiculous to point out this fact, it was clearly chosen with intent to mislead. The problem with Oil and Coal is that it’s hard to sell it this way because they’re already widely known to be disastrous for the environment.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:43AM (#38805453)
If you could do that in a letter exchange with Humphry Davy, Lavoisier or other scientist in 1750-1850, that would be fine, though they would probably ask why. There were scientific reasons for giving the name to natural gas (to differentiate from manufacturing process). Can you suggest any reason for your terms?

Anyway, if you would do it today, it is really hard to justify, not least because there exist new meanings of the words now and there exist already sufficiently good classifications. Context does matter.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by shkkmo on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:26PM (#38807609)
If you think that the emphasis of the name "natural gas" over other just "gas" or other common terms for it isn't intentional, then you are quite naive.

Education does not change how these sorts of tricks affect our brains. Research has shown that using the term "Natural Gas" creates false impressions of the its environmental impact.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:53PM (#38807949)
>If you think that the emphasis of the name "natural gas" over other just "gas" or other common terms for it isn't intentional, then you are quite naive.

Assumption about my personality doesn’t make your statement right or make sense. Of course it was intentional, just not the way you suggest here. The name “natural gas” exists in many languages, literally means “coming from nature” and is being used for centuries. Major suppliers outside USA use this name in contracts etc. Nobody is going to rename it just because American education system is so bad that people are getting confused.

>Education does not change how these sorts of tricks affect our brains. Research has shown that using the term "Natural Gas" creates false impressions of the its environmental impact.

Proof link? What factors were controlled in that research?

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by shkkmo on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:27PM (#38809151)
While the name was not coined as a form of greenwashing, the industry has a long history of greenwashing and outright lies. It is naive to think this industry hasn't considered what label to use for this product and how that affects public perception. It absolutely effects their efforts to dismiss for accurate alternative labels.

Not exactly hard to find, but here you go. https://climatecommunication.yale.edu/publications/should-it...

Do you have proof that this association or this type of association is correlated with education?

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:09PM (#38809604)
>It is naive to think this industry hasn't considered what label to use for this product

It is not a label, it is scientifically established and accurate name that nobody except some woke and poorly educated Americans wants to change.

The associations of the name with other terms are not correlated with education, they are caused by it, ergo the only proof needed is logical. If you know what it is, you describe it exactly as it really is — clean when burning if compared to coal, producing even stronger greenhouse effect when directly released to atmosphere.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by shkkmo on Saturday December 30, 2023 @01:18PM (#38817382)
> It is not a label, it is scientifically established and accurate name

Not all all. To someone who only understands the meanings of the individual words, the term is extremely ambigous. "Natural gas" could simply mean "air" or could refer to any gas that is naturally occuring in our atmosphere.

The reason why "natural gas" has the meaning that it does is purely convention and has no scientific basis or justification.

> The associations of the name with other terms are not correlated with education, they are caused by it

Education is not how we learn language. We learn language primarily contextually based on experience. While learning additional languages can be assisted by education, contextual experiencea are required for mastery.

> ergo the only proof needed is logical.

That's not how logic works...at all

> nobody except some woke and poorly educated Americans wants to change.

Scientists at Yale are "poorly educated"...? Throwing that accusation out pair with the word 'woke' exposes you as a partisan who has no intrest in learning or constructive discussion

That's not how logic works. Go learn about how logic and science are used together.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Monday January 01, 2024 @05:21AM (#38830891)
> someone who only understands the meanings of the individual words…

This person probably has a communication disability if they are not able to use language properly. We are not speaking in individual words, we use sentences and grammar, metaphors and homonyms, we have a lot of context even in low-context cultures. All of this can be learned and this is what education is for.

> Scientists at Yale are "poorly educated"...?

Maybe. Ivy League university or scientific degree is not a seal of quality. When you design such research only to control for political affiliation, that’s a bad science.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by globalnode on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:58PM (#38811620)
its greenwashing in the sense that its a convenient historical term used to mislead the average (contemporary) punter that its ok for the environment. so it has less emissions than coal, doesnt make it safe... just call it gas and drop the natural.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Teever on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:47AM (#38802930)
So what do you think we should rename it to?
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by OrwellianChild on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:26AM (#38803136)
"Natural Gas" is 97% methane, so it's probably most direct to just refer to it by it's primary component...
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Faaak on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:00AM (#38803002)
In some countries it is also called "city gas"
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Al-Khwarizmi on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:30AM (#38803157)
City gas was obtained from distilling hard coal or, later, from gasoline. So not the same thing as natural gas.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by adrianN on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:16AM (#38803078)
City gas is actually something else, it's coal gas.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Faaak on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:23PM (#38807576)
Yes, but it's still called that way
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by badpun on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:52AM (#38802954)
In Poland, it's called "Earth gas" or "ground gas".
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by dskloet on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:10AM (#38803045)
Also in Dutch: aardgas
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by namibj on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:36AM (#38803185)
And German: Erdgas.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by scotty79 on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:13AM (#38803058)
oil gas? carbon gas? fuel gas? fossil gas?
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by VintageCool on Friday December 29, 2023 @01:48PM (#38808696)
It has become popular to refer to it as "fossil gas".
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by nicoburns on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:24AM (#38802782)
"natural gas" is a historical term, to contrast with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_gas
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by zyl1n on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:41AM (#38802570)
What does natural gas have to do with greenwashing? It is naturally occurring gas; different from other hydrocarbon gas that is man-made.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by efnx on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:00AM (#38802677)
The argument is that humans are part of nature and therefore anything made by humans is still natural.

I tend to agree with this - there is a dichotomy here, but it is "natural" vs. "supernatural" - not "natural" vs "synthetic". I think it would be fine if for most cases we simply said "man-made" vs "not man-made" as it succinctly describes the dichotomy we're aiming for.

The "greenwashing" here is that you _could_ call anything that's not a ghost or a god "natural" by a certain definition...

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by tw04 on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:25AM (#38802791)
> The argument is that humans are part of nature and therefore anything made by humans is still natural.

Sure, if you completely disregard the context. “Natural” when talking in the context of humans is “nature vs man”.

A beaver dam is nature. The Hoover dam is man-made. If you want to red herring you could say “but man is part of nature” - there’s no point to doing so other than to argue semantics, but you could.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by tadfisher on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:09AM (#38802712)
That's true, but the term itself is archaic; at the time (early 19th century) the most widespread gaseous fuel was coal gas, also known as "town gas" because we piped it to urban homes for lighting. There's not much need for the distinction anymore, plus "methane" aligns with the other trade names for other fossil gases (propane, butane).
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:18AM (#38802751)
Natural gas is not pure methane, it’s a mix.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by _the_inflator on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:42AM (#38802893)
There is a grain of truth in the previous speaker's comments.

"Naturally occurring gas" does not magically transform itself into energy. The process along the way from being a resource to being usable as energy is usually anything other than "natural" and "green."

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by SapporoChris on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:56AM (#38802654)
"Natural gas (also called fossil gas, methane gas or simply gas) is a naturally occurring mixture of gaseous hydrocarbons consisting primarily of methane in addition to various smaller amounts of other higher alkanes." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas

Alright, so it goes by several names but it's sold to consumers as "Natural Gas". I'm not sure if it was green washing, but obviously the marketers were going for the most palatable name for consumers.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by bbarnett on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:13AM (#38802735)
but obviously

Predicated upon what?

Natural gas was merely a name to differentiate between 'gasoline', short form 'gas' for many english speaking countries. And the name is valid, it's mostly in its natural form, compared to 'gasoline aka gas', which required loads of processing to create it from oil.

And the name comes from a time before most of the population had even heard of global warming, at a time before people cared about using fossil fuels. There was in no way any attempt to greenwash, because absolutely no one cared one iota back then!

And the same is true for being palatable. It was just fuel. There was no reason to make it sound better. This was the age when most homes were heated by heating oil, or wood, or coal even!

People didn't get "triggered" back then, not in the 1950s or whatever. No one really cared except in the most extreme of cases. The earliest marketing concern over a name I know of, is "canola" oil, created by Canadian research programs, first on market I believe in the 70s, which is rapeseed oil.

(Rapeseed oil was added to cattle feed before this, but was considered too bitter for people until processing improvements were developed.)

It was thought that women would associate rapeseed with rape, and not buy it. This was in North America, the rest of the world generally, at the time, just called it rapeseed oil.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by scotty79 on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:17AM (#38803083)
> but was considered too bitter for people

also toxic

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ivan_gammel on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:49AM (#38805525)
> Natural gas was merely a name to differentiate between 'gasoline', short form 'gas' for many english speaking countries.

No, it has absolutely nothing to do with gasoline. Other languages, e.g. Russian, which don’t use the word gasoline also call it natural gas (coming from nature). This extra confusion is a late American thing.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by bbarnett on Friday December 29, 2023 @12:13PM (#38807440)
It most certaily does. It was often just called "gas", before cars, and gasoline became popular.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_gas

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by hanniabu on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:00AM (#38802676)
It's often dubbed as "clean energy"
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ekianjo on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:29AM (#38802813)
> "natural gas"

Gas can be created by many other means (combustion, chemistry, etc). Natural gas means it's gas that is found "as is" without any kind of synthesis.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:26AM (#38803135)
electric cars are greenwashing. not that CO2 is actually a problem, but if it were and it was even mildly urgent you would be rightly yelling for more natural gas. because that actually kills coal plants while electric cars are responsible for increased coal usage
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by reducesuffering on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:34AM (#38803174)
Try to look beyond 10 years. Calling for more nat gas over anything else will just lead to 60% Nat gas and 0% coal in a decade. Ok, now what? Still 60% high emissions and ICE cars according to you. No, we should be yelling for solar, electric cars, wind, batteries, and nuclear. Our priority is not a half measure that helps a bit now but makes nat gas stick around even longer.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:58AM (#38803342)
Yeah, I forgot that natural gas will necessarily bankrupt Tesla and kill the electric car (for the second time but at least this time we'll know whodunnit) because reasons.

Try to look beyond 10 years. Solar and batteries will have gotten cheaper due in no small part due to inexpensive, incidentally coal-killing natural gas.

Also I hate to tell you that NASA prioritizes planets 5C warmer than Earth in the search for extraterrestrial life, lol.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by UncleMeat on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:50AM (#38805528)
Policies like generation shifting encourage movement from coal to gas. They have been implemented in the US but were then undone by Trump and later declared unconstitutional by conservative supreme court justices.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by skrebbel on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:37AM (#38803192)
If only you folks would stop using the word “gas” for car fuel, which isn't a gas at all, then you could drop the prefix “natural” without confusion like in the rest of the world.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by SllX on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:29AM (#38803551)
People’s perceptions around the word “natural” has always been a bit unnatural to me. Plenty of things, good, bad, and every gradation in-between are “natural”, but the word itself got greenwashed somewhere along the way.

Having a few terms like “natural gas” as a way to counteract people’s perceptions of the niceness of “natural” isn’t so bad.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by weebull on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:43PM (#38809325)
It's because Americans use the term "gas" to mean the liquid fuel they put in their cars. In the UK it's just "gas".

It would be far better if we called it methane, but that's not really accurate either. It might contain ethane, propane, butane pentane and hexane. A lot of that stuff is condensed out before use, but not all.

[dead]
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by unglaublich on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:30AM (#38802526)
It's completely fine to be uninformed, still learning, or even uninterested. But writing bold, naïve statements instead of asking questions does not contribute anything.

You could have written: "Why do we need to reduce CO2 if plants thrive on it?". Then, someone might have invested a bit of time and effort in you and the audience to share their knowledge.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by stephen_g on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:14AM (#38802452)
That is disingenuous and misleading - some species of plants can use more available CO2 but not all can (there are other limiting factors in many cases as I understand it), but for sure most plants will be far, far more affected by the extremely significant negative effects of climate change than the small positive contribution of extra CO2 for photosynthesis.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Alpha3031 on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:41AM (#38802571)
Additionally, increased photosynthetic yield on some staple crops may not necessarily be the win that some people suggest it might be. While this is an area not yet very well studied, a number of papers have raised concerns regarding the nutritional quality of the resulting crops. Humans, after all, do not survive on a diet of exclusively carbohydrates.

See for example, Ebi, Kristie L., and Irakli Loladze. "[Elevated atmospheric CO2 concentrations and climate change will affect our food's quality and quantity.](https://doi.org/10.1016/S2542-5196(19)30108-1)" The Lancet Planetary Health 3, no. 7 (2019): e283-e284.

[dead]
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by stephen_g on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:10AM (#38802440)
Volcanoes would average out over the long term with the earth’s natural carbon sinks if we didn’t create gigatonnes of extra emissions from burning fossil fuels, etc. every year…
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Scarblac on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:23AM (#38802499)
Much smaller effect than humanity's.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by palemoonale on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:42AM (#38803221)
So many experts here... laptop experts!
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Dalewyn on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:51AM (#38802628)
Assuming this includes solar panels, windmills, dams, et al. their ecological negatives are very conveniently evaded with such terminology.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by rocqua on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:17AM (#38803087)
Good. We need to solve global warming a lot more than we need to reduce the kind of ecological damage done by dams, panels, and windmills.

If we refuse to choose the lesser of two evils, we will be fucked.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by dotancohen on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:07AM (#38803775)
The ecological impact of windmills and dams do not present a threat to the existence of human civilization as we know it.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by uxp8u61q on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:47AM (#38802601)
CO2 and methane ("emissions") is one target. A very important one, but let's not forget the other concerns altogether - plastic pollution, contamination of the environment through mineral extraction, etc.

The only path forward is a drastic reduction in overall consumption. Even if we reach 100% emissions-free electricity, we'll end up with an unlivable planet anyway if we don't focus on the other issues too. If we limit warming to 1,5°C — which isn't even realistic anymore — what good will it do to us if our water and arable land are contaminated beyond repair?

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by rocqua on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:15AM (#38803075)
If that is the case, we are fucked anyway.

There is no way 80% of the planet is willing to give up any comfort to stave off future ecological problems they cannot feel yet. We saw how much effort it took with global warming, and I doubt that will have made subsequent changes for the better easier. In fact, I suspect a lot of 'what, there is another thing wrong according to the scientific bozo's even though I can't see it' that will make people more resistant.

Actually reducing consumption globally won't happen. Not until it is too late. The best we can do is slow down consumption, and make consumption better. We have seen decent improvements in plastic free packaging. And power draw of devices is also getting much more attention. One big point here is pricing in externalities. That will push people into the less damaging choices.

Not to say that we should give up, nor to say that we should be quiet about other issues, nor even to say that people shouldn't reduce their consumption. My point is that a global reduction of consumption isn't going to happen voluntarily, and therefore shouldn't be the solution we pursue.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by anovikov on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:07AM (#38802707)
But well, the goal is about increasing consumption. No matter if we like it or not, it will increase massively - probably more than an order of magnitude overall - this century, simply because countries that are now poor, will no longer be so once massive amounts of renewable energy become the norm. We have to decrease pollution while also quickly increasing consumption - probably at same rate as in the "main" fossil fuel era - in 1870..1970, between oil becoming a thing, and Arab embargo.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by uxp8u61q on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:54AM (#38802968)
If you take as an axiom that the core cause of the current destruction of our planet is inevitable, then there's isn't much we can discuss.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by Faaak on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:02AM (#38803015)
I agree. Also, our planet is limited. Thinking that we can increase production infinitely ( good economist point of view), is just physically impossible
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:36AM (#38803186)
0.9 + 0.09 + 0.009 + 0.0009 +...

Seems physically possible to me.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by badpun on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:16AM (#38803464)
That's rather "infinitesimally", not "infinitely".
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by iraqmtpizza on Saturday December 30, 2023 @05:06PM (#38819718)
We're talking about infinite time, not infinite space.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by itishappy on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:47AM (#38806147)
With 10^27 g of Earth (without utilizing extra-planetary resources) each of which can be broken down into around 10^23 mol/g of stuff (without significantly altering the material composition) your infinite string of numbers will only be about 50 digits long.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by anovikov on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:09AM (#38803783)
But well this is the whole reason of existence of humankind and civilisation, the meaning of life: consumption. I struggle to understand how this can be doubted.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by itishappy on Friday December 29, 2023 @11:10AM (#38806457)
I must say, that's quite a depressing outlook. Sure, we consume a lot, but "the meaning of life?" Damn! I sleep a lot too, arguably even more than I consume, but I wouldn't argue that's my whole reason for existing...

Maybe you mean "we need to consume to live," which I agree with a whole lot more. Even then, there's no reason we need to maximize consumption. Food is definitely critical to our existence, but pre-peeled oranges in individual plastic packaging are not.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by vincvinc on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:52AM (#38803296)
upvoted you not because I 100% agree but your (completely reasonable) comment looks to have been downvoted very heavily.

I do feel there needs to be space to discuss what kinds of reductions of consumption make sense, esp for rich countries.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by influx on Friday December 29, 2023 @09:40AM (#38805407)
Great, when are you giving up your computer and internet connection?
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by uxp8u61q on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:03AM (#38805667)
I know this comment was made in bad faith. "You're not living as an ermite so you're a hypocrite and you have no business suggesting that consumption should be reduced" is an obvious fallacy that gets old quick. But let me entertain you a little. My computer and internet access is essential to my job and to a large part of my personal life. But I do cut down my consumption there (reduce power usage through several different methods, e.g., no power-hungry video games, low resolution videos, low-powered laptop) and in other areas of my life (eating, travel, clothing, and so on).

Now, your turn: what are you doing to help avoid global ecological catastrophe, even a little bit?

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by foolfoolz on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:17AM (#38802466)
it downplays the negative impacts of dams. dams prevent sediment from flowing to the ocean which leads to sand loss and erosion
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by rocqua on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:20AM (#38803102)
We can do without beaches. We can give up some land, and some spawning grounds for fish. If it means we can help against global warming, it is clearly the lesser of two evils.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by kgabis on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:00PM (#38810750)
New water reservoirs initially emit a lot of GHGs due to decaying organic matter, it takes decades for them to become carbon neutral.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ehnto on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:27AM (#38802512)
Which isn't trivial but there is no perfect solution, even wind and solar have externalities. We will always have some impact on the planet, but I will take erosion over a totally broken ecosystem. Erosion is inevitable over time, and if we don't reduce emissions and the seas rise, erosion will be abit of a moot point.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by polotics on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:42AM (#38802892)
Also btw about dams: they kill! a great deal of a lot more death and also lost land because of dams than all deaths and land loss issues with nuclear.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by rocqua on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:25AM (#38803130)
As a counter point, the danger of damns stops when the damn is empty. The danger of nuclear waste is on a longer time-scale. Hence it might be that there are future deaths due to current nuclear power that are not being counted.

I say might, because there is no way of knowing how many deaths will occur (or even statistically should be expected to occur) simply because we don't know what will happen to the nuclear waste.

I favor nuclear, but I'd love to see hard numbers on the 'headroom' nuclear has on deaths/GWH compared to dams, with some argument about whether long-term nuclear waste storage is likely to be less deadly than that headroom.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by redundantly on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:31AM (#38802828)
I wonder what is worse: the consumption of sand for manufacturing, construction, and man-made islands & beaches or the loss of sand generation that dams cause.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by mmazing on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:45AM (#38802590)
Every choice we make has compromises, but I think coal pollution is magnitudes worse than soil erosion.

One affects the entire environment with air pollution, and the other affects a localized area by modifying terrain.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by ekianjo on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:28AM (#38802808)
> I like the term “emissions-free”.

Because it's false? Nothing is emissions-free: making solar panels and wind turbines create emissions, and since they are all made in China, just transporting them around the world where they are used cause emissions as well. And when they become garbage they are shipped once more around the world to be disposed (and not recycled). So it's only "emissions-free" if you ignore the whole supply chain.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by andsoitis on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:31AM (#38803163)
> So it's only "emissions-free" if you ignore the whole supply chain.

Actually, burning natural gas does result in emissions of nearly all types of air pollutants and carbon dioxide (CO2).

About 117 pounds of CO2 are produced per million British thermal units (MMBtu) equivalent of natural gas compared with more than 200 pounds of CO2 per MMBtu of coal and more than 160 pounds per MMBtu of distillate fuel oil.

Source: https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/natural-gas/natural-gas-...

The article also specifically says that natural gas is not emissions-free: "The explosive growth of natural gas in the US has been a big environmental win, since it creates the least particulate pollution of all the fossil fuels, as well as the lowest carbon emissions per unit of electricity. But its use is going to need to start dropping soon if the US is to meet its climate goals, so it will be critical to see whether its growth flat lines over the next few years."

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by adrianN on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:27AM (#38803142)
Most wind turbines are made in China, because China is installing most wind turbines. Nobody ships 120m long blades around the world, it's hard enough to ship them within one country.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by bamboozled on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:52AM (#38802955)
Well everything that burns fossil fuels also needs to be built, therefore also is part of the problem, the difference is they have ongoing emissions where as something like a wind turbine doesn’t.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by sedatk on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:43AM (#38802899)
I think the term's used for "emissions-free when running", not "emissions free during manufacturing".
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by vinniepukh on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:24PM (#38809119)
it's pretty obvious that that's exactly what it means. i'm not sure why thy parent commenter posted what they did.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by fsh on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:04AM (#38803026)
I think this concern is often vastly exaggerated. Even with current "dirty" production and transport, renewables have orders of magnitude lower lifetime emissions than fossil fuels. And this will only get better once production and transport increasingly use renewable energy.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by YPPH on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:50AM (#38802943)
This argument lacks substance. Are you suggesting the benefits of emissions-free operation are set-off, wholly or to a substantial degree, by the emissions produced in the manufacture of those products? The answer is clearly "no". There is a net benefit. That is all that is needed, and it's not a marginal benefit, it's significant.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by jacquesm on Friday December 29, 2023 @04:16AM (#38803080)
> since they are all made in China

High grade bullshit stated with confidence.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by anileated on Friday December 29, 2023 @05:37AM (#38803617)
China produces about 80% of all solar panels in the world. Coindicentally or not, it is also the #1 country by coal production; it has the largest number of coal plants of any country (in absolute terms), and the government has recently been ramping up the rate of new coal plant construction after a few years of trying to keep it more or less in check. Most of electricity in China comes from coal (>60%, compared to US’s <20%).

Based on cursory checks of https://ourworldindata.org/energy, https://www.statista.com/statistics/668749/regional-distribu..., whatever sources they use.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by adrianN on Friday December 29, 2023 @06:18AM (#38803833)
For most metrics the country with most people in it will occupy one of the leading spots.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by anileated on Friday December 29, 2023 @10:32PM (#38812612)
So, India?
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by jacquesm on Friday December 29, 2023 @03:34PM (#38809894)
Note that the comment was about more than just solar panels.
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by vinniepukh on Friday December 29, 2023 @02:22PM (#38809099)
it's referring to "marginal emissions" per unit energy produced
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by abenga on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:06AM (#38813571)
I don't understand the arguments that "solar panels and wind turbines use mined resources and are transported around the world". And coal, oil, and gas waft down into our arms from trees in the backyard?
Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by defrost on Saturday December 30, 2023 @03:17AM (#38813637)
The argument being made is that solar and wind aren't "emissions free" .. that they don't waft into our neighbourhood from trees in our backyard.

Everybody (one would hope) understands that about coal, oil, and natural gas.

Many people (it seems) overlooks that for wind, solar, and battery technology.

It's akin to ignoring | being wilfully ignorant of what happens to material in the recycle bin.

Think of it more as a plea to remember that all this clean energy comes with a boatload of waste that needs addressing, that is often in other people's backyards, and the you don't get $64 billion US worth of copper without the digging up of what some consider to be sacred ground.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by abenga on Saturday December 30, 2023 @05:16AM (#38814092)
All good points.

What is the action this realization is supposed to help us come to though? Should we stop the transition to cleaner energy until we find a 100% clean energy source throughout its life cycle before we begin the transition? It is simple really. Wind, solar, and so on are cleaner than fossil fuel sources of energy, so we should gradually transition to them. Cleaner mining and responsible recycling and reuse of the infra we build can be worked on over time.

Re:40% of US electricity is now emissions-free by defrost on Saturday December 30, 2023 @06:35AM (#38814444)
We are where we are because the 1970s kicked a can down the road rather than take action on C02 when it was clear there was a problem.

In another 50 years we will have a pile of toxic waste as a direct result of scaling solar and wind up from the sliver it is now to enough to replace fossil fuels in world electricty production and replace fossil fuels in transport and build out enough batteries to ride out at least 10 hours of global demand.

> Cleaner mining and responsible recycling and reuse of the infra we build can be worked on over time.

How's that going so far - I can point to a few examples of mine reclaimation .. these are dwarfed by the majority that are left as problems for later on.

It's simple really, high consumers should consume less and as resources are used there should be focus on remediation and harm reduction from the outset.

Typically the worst offenders greenwash the nasty away and tut-tut about waste piling up in third world | southernn economies.