Why should they be? It's likely that the restaurant still charged them for the full price of the plates that were removed from the belt, regardless of whether or not they ate everything that was on said plate.
If they're otherwise quiet, respectful and paying customers, what about picking apart their food warrants kicking them out? As another user suggested, what happens if you don't eat the crust at a pizza joint?
Edit: Since I'm getting a lot of similar replies here, I'll point out that OP has since clarified that the conveyor belt sushi joint that they went to, contrary to how they are usually run, did in fact charge a "flat fee" for access to the sushi train. Hence my confusion - this is a deviation from the norm.
Edit 2: Kinda interesting watching the up/downvote progression in this thread. My initial post, despite being incorrect, was decently upvoted. Now that I've clarified that I was wrong and tried to correct myself, I'm getting downvoted. Neat!
At all-you-can-eat buffets, customers are charged a flat rate, not per plate.
Obviously this breaks down if people are taking plates of food and chucking them in the trash.
Eg, if yellow plates are $1, blue plates are $2, and orange plates are $3, and you pulled two orange plates, a blue plate and a yellow plate, your total would come out to $9 even if you didn't clear your plates.
That a conveyor belt is involved doesn’t change the offer.
And if I am a part of this comment chain, and I am confused (admittedly so, I should remind you), is there not confusion in the comment chain? :)
Boy, you should probably step outside and touch some grass or, I dunno, maybe let stuff like this bother you a bit less. Yikes.
Edit: And no, contary to your suggestion, I'm pretty comfortable not deleting my comments - I don't mind publicly making a mistake and then owning it. Thanks for the thought, though! :)
Yes, flat-rate sushi conveys exist.
OP clarified, and I thanked them for clarifying and acknowledged I was wrong. I've further mentioned as much in additional comments[1, 2, 3], and I've edited my original post to clear things up. Care to continue being snarky despite my attempts to correct myself?
>Yes, flat-rate sushi conveys exist.
And are, by and large, less common than per-plate joints, hence the confusion.
[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38562397
But most all-you-can-eat sushi places use a conveyor belt.
The entire world is not just Japan or the USA, please be respectful of this.
Basically 100% a buffet except the table moves to you (which, to the point of the original article, waiting for your preferred sushi to come around probably slows down consumption and improves the economics)
Obviously if people want to buy food and waste it that's on them. But this was a pretty clear abuse of the restaurant's business model as well.
Because people didn't know you were wrong before, and it's usually good to make factually incorrect comments be gray.
Not 100% on-point, but check out Roadside MBA, [1] which was written by a trio of MBA professors. Instead of using the case study method with examples from huge companies, they do a deep dive on small businesses that they visited on cross-country roadtrips. Very entertaining and accessible.
1: https://www.amazon.com/Roadside-MBA-Entrepreneurs-Executives...
I don't plan to read the book about online dating with my daughter, but perhaps she'll read it on her own someday!
Edit: It's $5 for a used edition. Then my comment is now moo.
https://www.npr.org/2023/10/27/1197954459/all-you-can-eat-bu...
The exchange rate is usually better for grains than for e.g. chicken or even beef[0], though.
[0] https://animalvisuals.org/projects/1mc/ Note that I'm a little skeptical of the numbers here, particularly those for grass-fed beef. Not that it matters for the purpose of claiming rice has a cost in lives.
So any kind of waste that we can put a dollar value on, also has a value in human lives.
Make of that what you will.
> 33 field mice were fitted with radio collars and tracked before and after harvest. The researchers found that only 3 percent of them were actually killed by the combine harvester (amounting to one mouse). An additional 52 percent of them (17 mice) were killed following harvest by predators such as owls and weasels, possibly due to their loss of the crop cover. It is unknown how many of these mice would have been eaten by owls or weasels anyway.
That last sentence is key: without a control you can't draw much from this experiment.
Additionally, while they say "animals" many times they're not clear on which ones they're including. The decision on whether to consider insects would be especially important.
Carbohydrates are much cheaper than proteins and fat.
Proteins and fat of vegetable origin are cheaper than those of animal origin, but they come accompanied by excessive amounts of carbohydrates.
The most efficient way of getting food for human consumption for now is to dump as waste most of the carbohydrates from vegetables and retain only the valuable proteins and fat (this can be done at home for instance by making bread but washing the dough before baking in order to remove most of the starch, producing thus a protein-enriched bread, or by removing completely the starch by extra washing of the dough, converting in into gluten a.k.a. seitan).
The high proportion of carbohydrates from vegetable food can be used completely only by those who do hard physical work, but not by those who have a sedentary lifestyle, who must necessarily dump the carbohydrates as waste, either directly or indirectly (by buying food where the carbohydrates have already been wasted in various ways, including as energy sources for animals that have been raised for becoming food).
In the future it might be possible to develop better ways to use the carbohydrates that must be wasted now, by converting them with high efficiency into proteins or fat, by using bacterial or fungal cultures.
Are you arguing that everyone should be vegetarian? That's a topic I was not even remotely touching on.
For now, there exists no way of producing enough proteins and fats without also producing an excessive amount of carbohydrates, which must be wasted in some way or another.
One way of using the excess amount of carbohydrates from vegetable food is by feeding animals or mushrooms, to obtain food with a more favorable proportion of proteins or fat (and this is a form of food wasting, as less food is obtained as output than it is provided as input), but another way is just dumping the excess carbohydrates (i.e. starch or sugars), after using food processing methods that separate the protein-rich or fat-rich parts.
When humans eat the excess amount of carbohydrates instead of dumping them as waste, the result is obesity, which is a worse choice than wasting the undesirable food.
I've never had either.
Food in general is a significant part of our ecological footprint. Rice has a relatively high impact for a crop. Of course it's still in a different ballpark than beef.
I'm guessing it's very, very small.
But, when it comes to the real deal. Sushi from a tier one or two Japanese sushi chef then the rice is actually the most important factor in making good sushi.
Discarding the rice would be seen as comparatively barbarian as dunking a freshly made piece of sushi by a good chef into this mixture of soya sauce and ersatz "wasabi".
How is that not a completely useless waste of energy, time, money and resources?
I'm in the "every life is sacred" camp, but...even if you do kill one animal and leave it to rot, it's not a total waste, just a "cruel" one.
Other things feed off of the carcasses of animals the same as you or I do. We just consider all other organisms beneath us, so if we kill and discard something, we write it off as a total waste. Birds, dogs, rodents and microorganisms disagree.
Maybe I should do it!
(Pun intended)
In my opinion you could teach both economics and common spreadsheet usage. Just please do not make it Excel-specific, many people here use Linux desktops. I would suggest LO Calc as it runs everywhere, or maybe Google Sheets as a distant second.
I was planning Google Sheets, since I'm on Linux and don't have excel.
I am hoping for something I can embed in the actual article.
I didn't even know about LO Calc. I'll check it out.
The restaurant had a to-go by-weight option. For the dine in patrons, you would check boxes on a menu slip with your order, quantity, etc.
Their menu included a simple request that patrons reasonably finish each plate before submitting a new order, that being honest kept their prices reasonable, and that patrons wasting entire orders would be charged on a per-weight basis for the wasted order at their discretion.
Some people are allergic to rice. Some people are on medically prescribed diets. Maybe there's an obscure religion that forbids eating rice. Some people just don't like rice. Are they all jerks too?
That restaurant wouldn't be my preference, but if I did have to be there for an important reason, I certainly wouldn't be bullied into eating something I didn't want to eat. I'm generally strict about wasting food, but in that situation I wouldn't feel even slightly guilty about it.
I know, reading is hard.
You have identified an aspect of the person with yourself and even though you yourself presumably don't walk acting like a jerk feel like you need to justify their misbehavior as if you were defending yourself. You don't need to keep defending them.
If that makes some strangers on the Internet think I'm a "jerk", so be it.
If you're given a single serving without asking, then you have almost no resemblance to the people being criticized here.
Your earlier post said you "wouldn't feel even slightly guilty" about wasting food in a way that implied you would act similarly to the people being criticized here, taking a whole bunch of pieces. If you do that, you should feel guilty. If you weren't trying to imply a similarity, you communicated your point badly.
I'd rather see the restaurant try to solve a problem than arbitrarily punish people, especially when "people" might include myself under the wrong circumstances. But I guess no one likes to hear nuance.
If you were trying to suggest nuance, you didn't do a great job of it.
"in that situation I wouldn't feel even slightly guilty about it" is jumping to the opposite extreme.
> All I suggested
You definitely suggested more than that.
Then you're reading something I didn't say.
If you do that, you should feel guilty.
Guilty of what? It's a business, not a charity. If that's where I happen to be stuck having dinner, and if they're unwilling to accommodate my preferences even at additional cost, I'm not going to go hungry or cheat on my diet purely out of politeness.
They can either solve the problem and increase their revenue, or accept that they've created an edge case situation where some food will be wasted. Punishing their customers would accomplish nothing except loss of business and negative Yelp reviews.
It's not politeness.
If we distill "all you can eat" down to the basics, you take a small amount, you eat it, only then do you get more.
It's generally fine to reorder those actions, such as by getting more food upfront, but the outcome needs to be the same as the basic version. That's the business deal being made. If you make a deal with the intent to break it, you should feel guilty, outside of exceptional circumstances.
If they're not willing to serve something acceptable to you, that's bad of them, but it doesn't mean you get to break the rules. Even if you "had" to be there for some external reason.
Also ejecting someone, or cutting off their supply, is probably nicer than charging them for eight pounds of extra food.
And again, this only applies to all you can eat situations. Not other restaurants, not plane meals.
What they shouldn't do is arbitrarily add new terms to the deal after the fact. Customers should be allowed to make an informed decision. If I know that they'll kick me out for eating, I can decide whether to leave or stick around and eat later. If they just kick me out without warning in the middle of my meeting/event/whatever, no one is happy and they look like assholes.
In practice, these are questions I would ask before paying and sitting down, but that shouldn't be expected. The business should either state its terms up front, or provide an early warning when they notice the behavior and offer a full or partial refund. Waiting until someone has eight pounds of rice piled up and then suddenly kicking them out is a ridiculous escalation, and they'd only lose more money when the customer rightfully disputed the charge.
All of this isn't to say that the guys in the story weren't necessarily in the wrong. What I am saying is that we simply don't know. Demanding they be kicked out is making an awful lot of assumptions. We have no idea why they were there or what their interactions with the staff may have been. As other comments have pointed out, there's a good chance that they were in fact charged for the leftovers.
The commonality is willingness to flagrantly violate social norms, entitlement, and lack of empathy.
What I've learned from such situations is that subtlety is wasted and tolerating misbehavior leads to encouraging more from that party and others. Conversely there is near zero cost or even a benefit to be had from squelching it. Such customers are on average worth less than nothing. They will consume half your support trying to screw you and all of your profit if you let them.
Saying no is even surprisingly trouble free when you have been consistent and only becomes a struggle when you have a policy of sometimes given in.
The hardest behaviors to extinguish are those which sometimes pay off. See arcades, lottery, and slot machines.
The worst polict to adopt is forcing front line employees to be the enforcers while managers make exceptions. This leads to the strategy of constant escalation.
The best counter is you can speak to a manager but he'll give you the same answer then do it when need be.
And the word "guilt" is being tied to the hypothetical version where we do have the information.
You're a jerk, because you're trying to defend someone who probably behaves worse than you, by equating yourself with that person.
If they had permission and were okay with spending all that extra money on leftovers, it's between them and the restaurant. I don't like wasting food on principle, but now we're getting into fuzzy issues around the relationship between supply and demand. At the end of the day, if someone wants to spend their money on food and throw it in the garbage/compost, that's essentially their business.
I'd have more of a problem with it if it were meat, because there's no reasoning around the fact that an animal was killed for it. Rice is in more abundant supply with with less severe negative externalities to its production. We also don't know how much rice it was; "eight pounds" was an eyeball guesstimate that could be completely wrong or exaggerated for narrative effect.
And it's not character assassination when it's such a vague anonymous anecdote.
Your wording strongly suggests that you took it personally and were defending yourself and them together. If that's not what happened you need to work on how you phrase these things.
The top response at the time I commented implied that the individuals in question were "deliberate food wasters" and "despicable".
The reaction is mostly to your second comment, not the first one.
> The top response at the time I commented implied that the individuals in question were "deliberate food wasters" and "despicable".
Okay? It's still a vague anonymous anecdote.
If they can accommodate your request, and they typically will, you’re golden. If not, you may need to patronize a different business. It is, after all, a reciprocal relationship. If your basic needs aren’t met, and they have a stiff policy on substitution - then yes, you are a jerk for ignoring them.
The actual controversy here is that the folks in the story clearly thought they were cheating the system, and people are responding without questioning that, and some people are questioning that.
Unless you're going to call the entire story fake, then yes we have enough information.
It's up to the market (ie patrons and restraunts) to decide which mix of policies they prefer.
Though it wouldn't come as too much of a surprise to reasonable customers when you kick out unreasonable customers.
You are right that (bad) surprises are bad for commercial transactions. Most restaurants, especially all-you-can-eat joints, have some rules written down somewhere about these kind of situations.
Can't really fault her for this weirdness, she has it rough enough.
At least, I've never had a hankering for a water and a half pound of tiny slivers of sashimi.
The prank of taking the same amount of sushi and leaving it in a neat stack would be closer to enlightenment.
Like when do operators decide to invest in a new ride and what’s the payback cycle like?
They have a really interesting blog overall.
Of course, elasticity goes in both directions. Demand that can be cut quickly, can also expand quickly.
Toilet paper is almost the opposite. And the extremely inelastic (and thus stable) demand means that competition is sharp and everything needs to be hyperoptimized for your business to stand a chance. There's almost no slack in the system, because that would be a needless expense.
I believe I once read a quip in The Economist about golf courses being a good investment for the second owner (the first usually going bankrupt).
And no, this isn't going anywhere. I'm not going to contact anybody for an interview or write a blog. This is everyday life in the real world. So much stuff going on that no one ever thinks about...
https://freakonomics.com/series/everyday-things/
Available as a podcast
Over here, all-you-can-eat Asian shops generally operate on one of two principles (sometimes combined):
1. You can only order 5 things per person per 10 minutes
2. For every X amount of weight left over you pay a penalty
Also, I can’t help but recount an anecdote from the last time I was at an all-you-can-eat place… conveyor-belt sushi with my kids.
A pair of guys came in and sat at the table next to us. They said a loud ironic prayer begging indulgence for “the sins we are about to commit” as they sat down… then proceeded to unwrap all the fish rolls, eating the contents as sashimi and discarding the rice and veggies on a tray on their table. By the time we left there was probably 8 lbs of rice on the tray… can’t believe they weren’t kicked out.