I expect these things are only on test flights indeed.
Autonomous flight termination systems are not "AI". It uses an on-board GPS and INS to figure out where the rocket is. It applies a pre-defined set of rules to the state vector and if any one of the rules fail it terminates the flight. You can read more about them here: https://www.gps.gov/cgsic/meetings/2019/valencia.pdf
*old man shouts at The Cloud*
An other question if you don’t mind: Did you ever used software which was not AI in your view?
Worth mentioning that the previous state of the art solution relied on a radio link too. Not sure if it was an implementation where jamming could led to flight termination, or where jamming could lead to failure to terminate a flight. But jamming, and resistance to it, was a concern even before autonomous flight termination.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_Dragon_In-Flight_Abort_Te...
No. The shuttle broke up when the overall stack became unstable due to the right hand SRB separating because a strut that attached it to the external tank failed (due to a blowtorch effect from a failed O-ring). The Challenger orbiter ended up 'on top' and broke into several chunks because of the aerodynamic stress (one of these chunks was the crew compartment). The SRBs were destroyed by their FTS systems, but this was more than 30 seconds after Challenger broke up. The ET simply disintegrated.
The point is that rockets carrying crew do indeed have FTS systems - presence of a crew doesn't negate that need.
That doesn't sound very automatic.
To be pedantic, the early flights had ejector seats for the pilot and commander, and the post-Challenger orbiters had a 'fire-pole' bail-out system. These systems could only be used in a very limited set of circumstances.
Shuttle death rate was about 1 in 75, which is insanely high.
Crew dragon hasn’t had anywhere near enough launches to compare. F9 itself though has and its a great system.
Going to be a long time before it’s a trusty as a 737 max though.
To compare with other launch methods, you'd need to use the same metric.
IIRC, Soyuz is actually more deadly, but it's been some time since I've seen the stats. Both Soyuz and the Space Shuttle are by far the most deadly form of transportation.
Worryingly for the shuttle the second failure was well into its lifespan. 5 failures in 50 launches then no failures for 200 more launches is better than 1 failure every 60 launches despite the second being theoretically better from the numbers.
Source: https://www.space.com/12376-nasa-space-shuttle-program-facts...
I don't see how this would work for Starship, since it won't have an abort system.
Maybe something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_crew_capsule for launch abort.
We'll see how the commercial spacecraft industry deals with this, but I do think that we are at far too early of a stage to start expecting progress in this area. The first few decades of commercial spaceflight will be dangerous just like the first few decades of commercial aviation, or for that matter the first few centuries of commercial shipping. The answers, varied or uniform, will be interesting and I hope that I'll be around to see them.
Whether the same idea could be adapted to a whole plane I don't know, but I would be skeptical of just on the basis that you probably wouldn't trigger such a thing unless the plane has had a substantial failure such that it could overpower any drogue chute.
one could envisage a '747-like' sized plane with many passenger escape-pods similar to the pod from an B-58 Hustler -- but who would pay the astronomic cost for such a ticket?
and similar to what the other person in this thread mentioned : those escape pods won't help during takeoff/landing phases.
http://www.chuckyeager.org/news/sr-71-disintegrated-pilot-fr...
I love the serendipitous detail of what happened on his next flight, though I'm sure it was not so amusing when it happened.
For those out of the loop on the nerd-flex, "Habu" was an unofficial, insidery nickname for the SR-71. It's the name of a venomous snake from somewhere with an SR-71 base (was it Okinawa? I think it was Okinawa), that the locals applied to the plane, because it (like the snake) was black and dangerous-looking.
https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/crew-escape-sy...
I'd take my chances and stay with the orbiter
That's a lot of energy to bleed off.
But we were in a hurry, so it was just part of the project.
In the very first missions with only two astronauts, the shuttle had ejection seats. They were removed when more than two people flew at a time, because a) it is not possible to add more, and b) crew ride on two decks, not one.
After the loss of Challenger serious consideration was given to designing some sort of escape capsule for the entire crew, but it was decided that the weight and practicality considerations were not worth it.
The bottom line is that it is impossible to design any practical means of high-speed travel that can cover all eventualities. A century of extensive experience has led to air travel being the safest way to travel on average, but there are still fatalities. Maybe once we have a century of experience with Starship and its descendants we'll be able to say the same about space travel.
Either way, it looks like the start of boostback was not quite norminal, and AFTS decided that wasn't close enough to the flight envelope and decided to exit status 1.
Some are speculating that the flip maneuver sloshed the fuel too much and resulted in vapor ingestion and/or complete fuel starvation. The fact the failures are clustered on the side the fuel would slosh away from adds weight to this idea.
Scott Manley also has the theory that the maneuver caused a sloshing motion of the fuel and the water hammer ruptured piping on the engines, causing a cascading failure.
The primary purpose of the water here is not to dampen the sound/energy, but to cool the metal plate below the rocket.
Careful what you wish for. The Saturn test program peaked at 3 tests / year (unless you want to count the separately tested launch escape system for the crew capsule), and the fully stacked Saturn V was only tested twice (in 1967 and 1968) before crewed missions.
For all its speed, Apollo was not a SpaceX-style rapid iteration program.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Apollo_missions#Uncrew...
Starship development started in 2012, and now 11 years later has had 2nd launch and failure to reach orbit.
Apollo program started in 1961 and had a men on the moon in 1969 - with 60's tech.
NASA's slow but meticulous approach has had a few failures, but also incredible successes such as the sky crane martian rover landing - got to get it right first time, tough to move fast and break things when the test environment is 100 million miles away!
When the government decided to build Kennedy Space Center in Florida wilderness, they just did. No lengthy environmental impact assesment process in the way.
For example, the F-1 engines that powered Saturn V first stage actually began development in the late 50s, with the first static firing happening in 1959. The (in)famous combustion instability challenges of the engine were solved by 1961.
Apollo had a tremendous running start in many areas - to say nothing of having the resources and know-how of the entire US military-aerospace-industrial complex at it's disposal. This isn't to minimize what an accomplishment Apollo was. I just don't think you can meaningfully compare the timelines of what SpaceX is trying to do with Starship, and what Apollo accomplished.
"A wiki" is a type of software. But when you use "Wiki" as a proper noun, referring to one specific instance, that's the name of Ward's Wiki, the original wiki, also known as wikiwikiweb, available at wiki.c2.com .
I'm guessing that you were not citing Ward's Wiki, but were rather citing some other site, in particular the site that contains this advice on citing it:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Don%27t_abbreviate_%...!
(Yes, I think Wikipedia's Don't Abbreviate... page is just wrong about this.)
> This is a humorous essay. It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Wikipedia contributors and is made to be humorous. This page is not one of Wikipedia's policies or guidelines, as it has not been thoroughly vetted by the community. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints. This essay isn't meant to be taken seriously.
SpaceX simply didn't have the resource to fully invest in Starship until much later. Even by the early presentations around 2016 it was a tiny part of SpaceX and was prototyping with limited resources. Real ramp up of spending happened significantly later.
Your understanding of Apollo is also flawed. The F-1 engine started development as early as 1955, not 1961. So if anything your 2012 date would be more like 1955.
Starship is also twice as powerful as Saturn V and designed to be reusable in both stages. That's a significantly harder task. Had SpaceX just wanted to match Saturn V, that would have been significantly easier.
I also think that, given the size of the Apollo landers, if SpaceX had actually wanted to they could've redone those missions years ago with a Falcon Heavy and a variant of the Crew Dragon design.
Modern day NASA could not redo the Saturn V missions again. They lost the talent that achieved those missions a long time ago.
This is all to say, Apollo was an extremely risky program.
This is a common misconception but mixes up at least three things.
1) Yes, Eagle was long, but not because of a software bug. The exact reason is unclear and there may have been multiple factors.
2) Yes, there were unexpected computer alarms but these were caused by a hardware bug that manifested because a switch was in an unexpected position. The software handled this appropriately.
Margaret Hamilton said: “To blame the computer for the Apollo 11 problems is like blaming the person who spots a fire and calls the fire department. Actually, the computer was programmed to do more than recognize error conditions. A complete set of recovery programs was incorporated into the software. The software's action, in this case, was to eliminate lower priority tasks and re-establish the more important ones. The computer, rather than almost forcing an abort, prevented an abort. If the computer hadn't recognized this problem and taken recovery action, I doubt if Apollo 11 would have been the successful Moon landing it was.”
3) Neil Armstrong did adjust the landing point late in the descent after noticing rough terrain. He utilized semi-automatic control to do this. Essentially adjusting the target point for the autopilot. Eagle wasn’t directly flown like an aircraft.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_11
A great video on the AGC and Apollo 11 landing: https://youtu.be/B1J2RMorJXM?si=Ypn6Gtp16_DEkpK9
The goal was something just under orbital speed.
Not that this wasn't totally amazing. Hopefully the launch pad wasn't damaged and they can crunch the data and have another test that gets further soon.
You might be looking at the first stage’s data.
Edit: 24,124 km/hr when telemetry stopped on the stream; 15k mph.
When I think I've gotten pretty far in a program I'm writing and there's even a small chance of it partially functioning, I'll often fire it up to get feedback on the errors I wasn't aware of as early as possible. Some of those may indicate larger structural changes that are required in the worst case, and the earlier I can learn about those the better.
Yes. My point is that the bar seems pretty low for Starship, and it's not clear why. Yes, some of the ways they are doing things are new, but overall, building large multi-stage rockets is 50s tech.
On top of that the fuel was much easier to work with and did not involve needing to be able to handle pressurization and sloshing during flips.
It's 50's tech only in the same way that a Ryzen CPU is 70's tech.
> the fuel was much easier to work with
This is a technical detail where I hard disagree. The oxidizer was liquid oxygen, so that's the same. The fuels were either RP-1 or hydrogen. Methane is somewhere in between those two in difficulty. kept at -180 °C, compared to -253 °C for hydrogen, and LOX is LOX. In the Saturn V, sloshing of the RP-1 led to the Pogo Effect, but that was solved[1]. Granted it didn't involve the maneuvers of the Starship first stage, but in some ways it was worse, because it happened during full thrust at the end of the boost stage, not after separation. You can read a lot more about NASA's experience with pogo at [2], but it's worth noting that it continued to crop up as late as Apollo 13, when the 2nd stage center engine shut down early as a result.
Yes, SpaceX is doing some things new, but the engineering experience is definitely something from the 50s and 60s.
1. https://www.nasa.gov/history/50-years-ago-solving-the-pogo-e...
So I was more or less correct at the top of the thread when I said, "if the launch works through staging, SpaceX fans would declare it a success", and I consider that a low bar.
You might also not be able to build it with a room full of idealistic youths running on inspiration.
Isn't science great?
Thats hardly what I would barely sending an empty rocket to orbit. Just because some new version is being tested using different technologies and methodologies of building and isn't fully functional doesn't indicate that we can't or don't regularly exceed what you say we're barely accomplishing as a people.
SpaceX is cool, I really hope they get to the Moon one day.
It successfully builds Golf 2, one of the most versatile cars ever made. That car can do everything and go anywhere.
Now, say that NASA wanted to upgrade that car after 50+ years. And now, that car can't even go 50 miles before requiring a refill.
Are we supposed to believe how the new car is better? Are we even supposed to believe that Golf 2 worked as well as NASA said it did?
Hell no.
Nearly every comment I leave about it gets a (rather poorly constructed) reply.
Parroting how "conspiracy makes no sense" is dellusional at best: https://centerforaninformedamerica.com/moondoggie-1/
Just explain to me how the USA managed to fund two large foreign wars and a bunch of expensive Moon landing missions at the same time, but now it's too expensive? You can't.
There were hundreds of thousands of people involved in the Apollo program. Yet, once again, not one person has actual physical evidence of any conspiracy to fake the landing.
The fact that the country which literally had thousands of nukes pointed at the US (and vice versa), and has never shied away from propaganda, did not and has not credibly denied the Moon landing, is the standard you need to beat. Not piss poor analogies and comparisons like the ones you keep giving.
> After leaving a recent reply and getting negative karma on several other unrelated comments in like 5 minutes, I can confirm with high probability that my assertion above is correct. Thank you NASA!
News at 11, person takes society's consistent interpretation of their crackpot conspiracy theories as ridiculius as further evidence of a conspiracy.
> Just explain to me how the USA managed to fund two large foreign wars and a bunch of expensive Moon landing missions at the same time, but now it's too expensive? You can't.
Sure I can. It's not too expensive as in "can't", it's too expensive as in "won't" because most the public doesn't care about it and it's not deemed a national security issues (which the space race was) which would cause the govt to push it anyways and also try to convince people with a concerted effort that it matters.
To me it feels like you don't understand how the social dynamics of representative governance works, but it's really fairly sinoke. Things people want are easy to fund or do, and things they don't are hard, but the government has various levers it can press to change that to larger or smaller degrees over time.
Consider a more substantial contribution the next time, this reeks of some sort of internalized battle the rest of us don't know about, and projection of it onto others.
So they achieved the primary goal, which is a good result.
It could even be argued that they got pretty close to one of the secondary goals. Starship was fairly close to shutting off its engines. If it would have completed that part of the flight, the next hour or so it would just be coasting. Physics alone would guarantee they'd end up near Hawaii.
But how can you explain to the current generation that 50 years ago people flew to the Moon multiple times over a span of a decade, but now we can barely go to Earth's orbit and stay there?
I could accept it if we're talking 15-20 years. But over 50 years and no visible progress? That just sounds fishy to me.
EDIT: The downvotes are expected and are just proof how many people in the world are still drinking NASA's koolaid. I hope Musk's failures dispell every lie that you have ever been told.
Hell, aside from SpaceX and a few similar efforts, we're still pouring most of our launch funding into the Space Shuttle Program, via it's SLS successor - currently over $11 billion spent on a program that has had, to date, one launch.
Which is why all subsequent Apollo launches were filmed on a set. Because in no way you would risk further political and national disaster to a one man's delusion that we, as human beings, can land on the Moon in the near future.
Like, we seriously lost the Moon rocks so we can't verify that they indeed are from the Moon.
I'll be waiting. Really, I want to know.
EDIT: They "have" them, but they're storing them in nitrogen, so good luck on those rocks every seeing light of day: https://www.nasa.gov/general/where-are-the-moon-rocks-we-ask...
"And the Moon rocks are stored in these cabinets that are filled with nitrogen. And we do that because we want to keep them safe from Earth water and Earth atmosphere and of course germs and all sorts of other weird things."
The real trick would have been sending the astronauts on a rocket into Earth orbit for over a week without being detected by Soviet radar operators, who would have been more than eager to share the coordinates with the world, and then somehow sending radio signals back to Earth always from the direction of the moon. https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/objects-and-stories...
Still, most of these (except for the retroreflectors) are not 100% foolproof evidence. For example, China is refusing to share the photographs taken by the Chang'e 2's mission.
Then for another 40 odd years people randomly spout off did you hear Putin posts as wheelerof4te on Hacker News.
The reason they don't get a strong refutation with evidence is that merely by opening their mouth metaphorically they have proved they have very little interest in reasonable argument. For the record you being literally Putin, crazy as it is, is actually a more reasonable theory than the moon landing being faked.
On a related note Russia due to its anti western propoganda is one of the few places this isn't a massively fringe theory.
You are unlikely to buy any of this I'm aware but have you ever found yourself arguing with a young earth creationist? It's the same feeling.
Instead of admitting that logical conclusion, you are pulling a strawman on me. Our discussion is over.
You yourself mentioned an experiment that can be repeated, bouncing light off those reflectors, its been done we went to the moon. A better question than "Did we go to the moon?" would be why do you want to believe we didn't?
Is it anti western propaganda that you've swallowed uncritically?
What other conspiracy theories do you believe?
No, just common sense after looking at the pictures from NASA's archive. And also, looking at all the hard evidence presented by this guy convinced me that there is ZERO chance any human ever went to the Moon: https://centerforaninformedamerica.com/moondoggie-1/
As for the other "conspiracies", 9/11 being an inside job by the AIPAC lobby, and JFK being murdered for going after the FED and Isreali nuclear programme.
Any other questions?
We’ve had humans in orbit on the ISS continuously for decades, sent probes to the edge of the solar system, landed multiple robots on Mars, and revolutionized our understanding of space and physics with space telescopes.
The biggest obstacle to space exploration was a contracting that didn’t bring down costs, and the thing that makes space so exciting now is high cadence low cost launches
The SpaceX flights are way more efficient and reproducible than the Apollo missions ever were. The only reason they aren't regularly going to the moon is that there isn't a strong incentive to do so.
Orrrr, it's just that people don't really like dying in a horrible explosion 10-15 miles above the surface?
Do you have any idea how many completely uneventful flights Falcon 9 vehicles have flown? The most recent version (the FT which had its first flight in 2015) has had precisely zero failures across 254 launches.
They have a better safety record than any other launch vehicle in history, including the Saturn V and the Shuttle.
The deaths stemming from those programs have held back interest in manned space exploration more than any failed test flight ever will.
I remember him doing this routine in another thread earlier this week:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38261198
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38260917
Don't waste your time with him.
Pretty sure we can land things on the moon if we needed to. We just placed the James Webb Telescope there. We just don't have the political will or necessity. Ho long was it between the first trip to the South Pole and the first permanent base? 1911 to 1944. And that was on Earth, where supplying that base is much easier than the humongous expenditure it was to go to the Moon or supply a lunar base there.
Things are not the issue, we agree.
But people are. We couldn't/can't land the human beings on the Moon.
Another thing: we are trying to do things a lot better than we did 60 years ago - fully reusable craft that, I assume, practically flies itself.
You need a reason and money to fund it. Which Musk supplied.
This generation has the Internet, social media, and mass communication devices that can fit in your pocket.
Thus, it is very hard to convince them that something fake and filmed on the film set is real.
Neat phrase for the booster explosion in the mesosphere.
- Booster destroyed during hot staging
- SpaceX reporting that destruct system fired on upper stage towards end of burn
all in all a pretty good result: clean launch and separation, good performance on the booster during ascent (no engine mishaps this time)