News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ByThyGrace on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:31AM (#38320023)
Surely the final Starship carrying passengers will not have auto flight termination?
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by t0mas88 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:45AM (#38320190)
Imagine explaining to the court that the passengers were blown up by your AI algorithm...

I expect these things are only on test flights indeed.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by krisoft on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:31AM (#38320628)
> Imagine explaining to the court that the passengers were blown up by your AI algorithm...

Autonomous flight termination systems are not "AI". It uses an on-board GPS and INS to figure out where the rocket is. It applies a pre-defined set of rules to the state vector and if any one of the rules fail it terminates the flight. You can read more about them here: https://www.gps.gov/cgsic/meetings/2019/valencia.pdf

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ben_w on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:56AM (#38321569)
GOFAI is still AI in my books.

*old man shouts at The Cloud*

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ikari_pl on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:36PM (#38323485)
Heuristics used to be AI. Now only chat gpt is ai
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by krisoft on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:17PM (#38324548)
Okay, but then I assume you also call AI the model predictive controller flying and landing the rocket too?

An other question if you don’t mind: Did you ever used software which was not AI in your view?

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by anovikov on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:16AM (#38347500)
It's not AI at all. It just has preset border conditions in terms of flight corridor and probably, predicted/calculated impact point if engines go out at that moment, and blows rocket up if they are violated. It's hard logic, comparison of some variables with set thresholds, not some "thinking".
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by sroussey on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:17PM (#38321850)
Hopefully no GPS jammers nearby.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by dotnet00 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:47PM (#38324219)
A bit hard to GPS jam a rocket on the way up.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by krisoft on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:50PM (#38324251)
Yes. I'm sure they apply all the mitigations possible.

Worth mentioning that the previous state of the art solution relied on a radio link too. Not sure if it was an implementation where jamming could led to flight termination, or where jamming could lead to failure to terminate a flight. But jamming, and resistance to it, was a concern even before autonomous flight termination.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by dave78 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:12AM (#38320446)
I'm pretty sure Falcon 9 carrying crew has an AFTS. Challenger was destroyed by an FTS system as well despite having crew on board. I think it's just a risk you have to take to go on a rocket ride.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ceejayoz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:48AM (#38320798)
The Crew Dragon capsule has escape rockets that will fire as part of the flight termination system to carry the crew safely away.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crew_Dragon_In-Flight_Abort_Te...

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by KineticLensman on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:27AM (#38321233)
> Challenger was destroyed by an FTS system

No. The shuttle broke up when the overall stack became unstable due to the right hand SRB separating because a strut that attached it to the external tank failed (due to a blowtorch effect from a failed O-ring). The Challenger orbiter ended up 'on top' and broke into several chunks because of the aerodynamic stress (one of these chunks was the crew compartment). The SRBs were destroyed by their FTS systems, but this was more than 30 seconds after Challenger broke up. The ET simply disintegrated.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by dave78 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:40AM (#38321355)
I'm very aware of why it initially broke up. But once that started, the range safety officer did activate the FTS system.

The point is that rockets carrying crew do indeed have FTS systems - presence of a crew doesn't negate that need.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ben_w on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#38321610)
The SRBs (and the EFTs) had FTS's, but the Orbiters didn't.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by BobaFloutist on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:29PM (#38322761)
>the range safety officer did activate the FTS system.

That doesn't sound very automatic.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by WJW on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:58AM (#38321591)
If I were writing such a system it would have very straightforward if-statements linked directly to FAA requirements. No faffy AI stuff is needed.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by thinkcontext on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:52AM (#38320271)
Not sure about that but indications are it won't have an escape system like other manned craft.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by inglor_cz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:00AM (#38320331)
Space Shuttle didn't have an escape system either; its total death toll was 14.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by KineticLensman on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:32AM (#38321278)
> Space Shuttle didn't have an escape system either

To be pedantic, the early flights had ejector seats for the pilot and commander, and the post-Challenger orbiters had a 'fire-pole' bail-out system. These systems could only be used in a very limited set of circumstances.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by midasuni on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:05PM (#38321686)
Absolute numbers don’t really mean much. More than 14 people have died since this test flight on American roads.

Shuttle death rate was about 1 in 75, which is insanely high.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by troupe on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:58PM (#38322333)
How does that compare with other rocket systems?
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by pantalaimon on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:04PM (#38322409)
Pretty poorly, Soyuz has 4 fatalities (Soyuz 1, Soyuz 11) during it's over 140 flights, Crew Dragon has none.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by throwawaymaths on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:35PM (#38324749)
That's a unnormalized metric: shuttle had two failures in 135 flights and generally carried up way more people per flight and also did way more stuff per flight.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by midasuni on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:18PM (#38325908)
And how many failures in the most recent 100 Soyuz flights?

Crew dragon hasn’t had anywhere near enough launches to compare. F9 itself though has and its a great system.

Going to be a long time before it’s a trusty as a 737 max though.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by queuebert on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:22PM (#38323961)
What are the units on 1 in 75? People? Missions?

To compare with other launch methods, you'd need to use the same metric.

IIRC, Soyuz is actually more deadly, but it's been some time since I've seen the stats. Both Soyuz and the Space Shuttle are by far the most deadly form of transportation.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by midasuni on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:15PM (#38325865)
Broadly the same - 7 seats a launch, about 2 failures in about 150 launches, or 14 seat failures in 1000 seat launches. The early launches didn’t have 7 people on but it’s not really relevant.

Worryingly for the shuttle the second failure was well into its lifespan. 5 failures in 50 launches then no failures for 200 more launches is better than 1 failure every 60 launches despite the second being theoretically better from the numbers.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by mathgeek on Sunday November 19, 2023 @04:21AM (#38330794)
You can either use 14/833 crew positions (individuals flew more than once), or 14/355 actual people who ever flew on the shuttle. You could also use 2/135 missions. I suppose an argument could be made for 2/269 as well if you want to count launch and reentry as separate risk events.

Source: https://www.space.com/12376-nasa-space-shuttle-program-facts...

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by sebzim4500 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:10AM (#38320421)
As I understand it, on crewed flights of the Falcon 9 the AFTS is somehow integrated with the abort system so that it is impossible for it to detonate without the capsule having a few seconds to get to safety first.

I don't see how this would work for Starship, since it won't have an abort system.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by api on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:20AM (#38320527)
Couldn’t Starship detach and fire its engines to get away from the booster? Of course I guess if they are not hypergolic there is startup time.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ceejayoz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:22AM (#38320550)
The real question here is what happens with a crewed second stage that has a problem with its engines/fuel. We’ve yet to see designs for the crewed interior beyond very conceptual stuff.

Maybe something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_crew_capsule for launch abort.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by Phenomenit on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:01AM (#38320936)
I believe that the crewed version is way in the future when operations are much better understood. There’s no chance in hell they’re catching that 2028 window to march.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by dotancohen on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:02AM (#38320950)
This same question was asked in the early years of commercial aviation. In the end, the industry (mostly) settled on aircraft designs that could passively glide reasonably well enough to land (sometimes). But some aircraft, e.g. military jets and Cirrus, came up with different answers (parachutes for the crew and for the whole aircraft, mostly).

We'll see how the commercial spacecraft industry deals with this, but I do think that we are at far too early of a stage to start expecting progress in this area. The first few decades of commercial spaceflight will be dangerous just like the first few decades of commercial aviation, or for that matter the first few centuries of commercial shipping. The answers, varied or uniform, will be interesting and I hope that I'll be around to see them.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by candiddevmike on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:08PM (#38322452)
Wonder if we'll ever have commercial aircrafts with whole aircraft parachutes.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by theolivenbaum on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:19PM (#38322622)
There's no parachuting from 900km/h
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by jasonwatkinspdx on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:04PM (#38323122)
There's been a number of successful supersonic ejections of military pilots over the years. It's extremely dangerous and very likely to fail, but it's better than the alternative. The basic idea is a drogue chute stabilizes and slows the pilot.

Whether the same idea could be adapted to a whole plane I don't know, but I would be skeptical of just on the basis that you probably wouldn't trigger such a thing unless the plane has had a substantial failure such that it could overpower any drogue chute.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by serf on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:20PM (#38323295)
i'd be willing to believe it's an economics thing more-so than a physics thing.

one could envisage a '747-like' sized plane with many passenger escape-pods similar to the pod from an B-58 Hustler -- but who would pay the astronomic cost for such a ticket?

and similar to what the other person in this thread mentioned : those escape pods won't help during takeoff/landing phases.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by endymi0n on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:53PM (#38323649)
There is at least one documented survival at the insane speed of Mach 3: https://theaviationgeekclub.com/bailing-out-at-mach-3-the-in...
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by eszed on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:00PM (#38325657)
Here's Weaver's own account:

http://www.chuckyeager.org/news/sr-71-disintegrated-pilot-fr...

I love the serendipitous detail of what happened on his next flight, though I'm sure it was not so amusing when it happened.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by dotancohen on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:38AM (#38331323)
Well, his _next_ flight was to see the body of Jim. But yes, the next Habu flight started off interesting.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by eszed on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:15PM (#38356349)
Lol! I up-voted you (seriously, I did) because this is close to the platonic ideal of a HN comment: egregious pedantry, plus a nerd-flex.

For those out of the loop on the nerd-flex, "Habu" was an unofficial, insidery nickname for the SR-71. It's the name of a venomous snake from somewhere with an SR-71 base (was it Okinawa? I think it was Okinawa), that the locals applied to the plane, because it (like the snake) was black and dangerous-looking.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by nradov on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:53PM (#38323022)
No. Those systems can't really scale up in size and speed. And it would be pointless anyway because the few commercial airliner crashes that do occur are mostly during take off or landing where parachutes aren't very effective.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by tomaskafka on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:17PM (#38324545)
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by pantalaimon on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:00PM (#38322364)
How did Space Shuttle approach this problem?
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by WillPostForFood on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:33PM (#38322806)
They added this system after Challenger, seems extremely limited.

https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/crew-escape-sy...

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by fnord77 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:17PM (#38323266)
"The crew escape system was intended for emergency bailout use only when the orbiter was in controlled gliding flight and unable to reach a runway. "

I'd take my chances and stay with the orbiter

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by base698 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:32PM (#38326796)
> The vehicle touches down at 214 to 226 miles per hour, back wheels first. The nose then touches down, the drag parachute is deployed, and the shuttle cruises to a stop.

That's a lot of energy to bleed off.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ceejayoz on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:15PM (#38322575)
Death.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by ben_bai on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:55PM (#38324320)
There was a estimated 1/16 failure possibility for the first couple flights. Lots of edge-cases where: If XYZ happens, you die.

But we were in a hurry, so it was just part of the project.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by TMWNN on Sunday November 19, 2023 @03:58AM (#38330646)
As ceejayoz said, "Death". The system WillPostForFood mentioned is indeed, as he said, extremely limited.

In the very first missions with only two astronauts, the shuttle had ejection seats. They were removed when more than two people flew at a time, because a) it is not possible to add more, and b) crew ride on two decks, not one.

After the loss of Challenger serious consideration was given to designing some sort of escape capsule for the entire crew, but it was decided that the weight and practicality considerations were not worth it.

The bottom line is that it is impossible to design any practical means of high-speed travel that can cover all eventualities. A century of extensive experience has led to air travel being the safest way to travel on average, but there are still fatalities. Maybe once we have a century of experience with Starship and its descendants we'll be able to say the same about space travel.

Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by adastra22 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @01:10PM (#38322499)
If the booster is still firing, then starship will have to have a greater acceleration than the super heavy booster in order to separate. On F9 Crew this is done by the abort system, which is able to accelerate the crew capsule away at a higher acceleration than the whole F9 stack is experiencing at the time.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by jccooper on Saturday November 18, 2023 @02:50PM (#38323611)
At certain phases. It will not have enough thrust to survive that at low speed/altitude.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by walrus01 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:39PM (#38327990)
For the first flights of the space shuttle it was fitted with ejection seats, though how useful they would have been in reality is questionable.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by sheepshear on Saturday November 18, 2023 @09:43PM (#38328035)
Probably the same. Even with an abort system, aborting isn't an option throughout the whole flight.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by BurningFrog on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:20PM (#38321886)
If you pay the Non AFT Fee, yes.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by wheelerof4te on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:09PM (#38323826)
No. If thing go south, they'd just suicide themselves manually.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time by wly_cdgr on Saturday November 18, 2023 @03:21PM (#38323958)
Surely it will, but prob only Elon and a couple others will know about it