Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by HarHarVeryFunny on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:05AM
(#38320988)
Well, whether you want to call it 8/9 years ('61-'69) or 14 ('55-'69), I don't think NASA looks too shabby landing men on the moon in that time frame without the decades of experience we have to draw on today, and with 1950's/60's technology, and so far no-one else has done it.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by ben_w on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:07PM
(#38321721)
The Apollo missions were certainly an achievement worthy of getting memorialised.
I also think that, given the size of the Apollo landers, if SpaceX had actually wanted to they could've redone those missions years ago with a Falcon Heavy and a variant of the Crew Dragon design.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by electriclove on Saturday November 18, 2023 @12:59PM
(#38322344)
The NASA of that time has been long gone for decades
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by panick21_ on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:11PM
(#38324496)
Nobody said it was 'shabby'.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by chrisco255 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:32PM
(#38328465)
Yeah they did less than 20 launches, had 6 successful missions, and then had to kill the program because the costs were too high at a $500B equivalent annual budget. Apollo 1 also burnt up and killed 3 astronauts on the ground.
Modern day NASA could not redo the Saturn V missions again. They lost the talent that achieved those missions a long time ago.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by leoc on Saturday November 18, 2023 @04:29PM
(#38324681)
It also seems that Saturn V's performance wasn't flawless, even on crewed missions (though some of the problems were down to external factors like lightning or debris from Skylab): https://www.wired.com/2012/03/great-balls-of-fire-apollo-roc... .
SpaceX simply didn't have the resource to fully invest in Starship until much later. Even by the early presentations around 2016 it was a tiny part of SpaceX and was prototyping with limited resources. Real ramp up of spending happened significantly later.
Your understanding of Apollo is also flawed. The F-1 engine started development as early as 1955, not 1961. So if anything your 2012 date would be more like 1955.
Starship is also twice as powerful as Saturn V and designed to be reusable in both stages. That's a significantly harder task. Had SpaceX just wanted to match Saturn V, that would have been significantly easier.