Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by dotnet00 on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:04PM
(#38325701)
In terms of objectives, the stated primary objective was to get through staging without blowing up. That was a success. The secondary objective was getting to reentry for the Ship - testing the heat shield, which was a failure.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by cratermoon on Saturday November 18, 2023 @06:44PM
(#38326219)
> the stated primary objective was to get through staging without blowing up.
So I was more or less correct at the top of the thread when I said, "if the launch works through staging, SpaceX fans would declare it a success", and I consider that a low bar.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by Aeolun on Saturday November 18, 2023 @07:11PM
(#38326576)
I think you might build a rocket that was less prone to blowing up, but it might not be as efficient.
You might also not be able to build it with a room full of idealistic youths running on inspiration.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by cratermoon on Saturday November 18, 2023 @11:31PM
(#38328987)
I guess if you're a Longtermist, killing a 100 people on a flight to Mars is nothing if you save the human race.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by Aeolun on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:58PM
(#38340678)
They don’t have people on the rocket now right? It’s just a bunch of money being vaporized.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by cratermoon on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:48PM
(#38367123)
There were no crew on the first two Saturn V flights, yet the engineers considered it worthwhile to build them with sufficient care that they didn't vaporize anything except fuel and oxidizer.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by wheelerof4te on Sunday November 19, 2023 @09:12AM
(#38332784)
In the span of ~50 years, we've gone from "sending men to the Moon" to "barely sending an empty rocket to the orbit".
Isn't science great?
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by kbenson on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:32PM
(#38336821)
I'm confused by your stance here, because it's like you aren't aware that the Falcon 9 rocket by SpaceX has launched 80 times this year so far, and 60 times last year, and those are all commercial launches with payloads.
Thats hardly what I would barely sending an empty rocket to orbit. Just because some new version is being tested using different technologies and methodologies of building and isn't fully functional doesn't indicate that we can't or don't regularly exceed what you say we're barely accomplishing as a people.
Re:Starship Integrated Flight Test 2 at 7 Am Central Time
by wheelerof4te on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:46PM
(#38339946)
Yeah, I guess you're right. This is a thread about SpaceX, and I'm just hijacking it for my selfish reasons.
SpaceX is cool, I really hope they get to the Moon one day.
> the fuel was much easier to work with
This is a technical detail where I hard disagree. The oxidizer was liquid oxygen, so that's the same. The fuels were either RP-1 or hydrogen. Methane is somewhere in between those two in difficulty. kept at -180 °C, compared to -253 °C for hydrogen, and LOX is LOX. In the Saturn V, sloshing of the RP-1 led to the Pogo Effect, but that was solved[1]. Granted it didn't involve the maneuvers of the Starship first stage, but in some ways it was worse, because it happened during full thrust at the end of the boost stage, not after separation. You can read a lot more about NASA's experience with pogo at [2], but it's worth noting that it continued to crop up as late as Apollo 13, when the 2nd stage center engine shut down early as a result.
Yes, SpaceX is doing some things new, but the engineering experience is definitely something from the 50s and 60s.
1. https://www.nasa.gov/history/50-years-ago-solving-the-pogo-e...