News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by mrb on Monday July 17, 2023 @06:47PM (#36765130)
Note this chart shows nominal dollars, not PPP-adjusted. The EU has certainly kept up with the US when looking at PPP GDP from 2008 to 2022:

US grew from $14.8T to $25.5T

EU grew from $14.3T to $24.3T

What that means in that the prices of goods are inflated in the US compared to similar goods in the EU. That's all.

Want something interesting? Look at China who grew from $10.0T to $30.3T over the same period (!)

Sources: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?locat... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?locat... https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?locat...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:15PM (#36765408)
No one uses PPP for measuring growth, GDP PPP can increase whilst your economy contracts.

PPP isn’t a good measure for population’s wealth or quality of life especially for developed economies either.

The economy of the US is still twice that of the EU and its global purchasing power has also pretty much doubled.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by mrb on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:32PM (#36765586)
"GDP PPP can increase whilst your economy contracts."

Still, if PPP GDP increases, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing.

That is why PPP GDP captures a more accurate measure of the real world.

Said another way, what truly matters isn't "GDP growth", but changes in purchasing power/quality of life.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:44PM (#36765729)
No it does not, PPP is calculated based on a basket of 3000 fungible goods and services as well as other costs such as major infrastructure construction projects.

It has zero account for quality or outcomes.

It doesn’t care if you have access to healthy foods, it just cares how much would X calories costs, it doesn’t care what is the quality of the housing stock or the outcomes of your healthcare system.

You can very much have a situation where your economy shrinks, the quality of life tanks and your GDP PPP stays the same or grows, communism is rather good example of just how a situation can be where things are on paper very cheap from food to infrastructure mega projects and where housing is free but no one would claim that life in 1970’s Soviet Union was particularly great.

In 1990 the USSR had the 2nd highest GDP PPP in the world, if you honestly think that it was a good place to live I’ll build you a time machine myself.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by kranke155 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:12PM (#36765990)
I know people who lived in the USSR in the 1970s and missed it.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:19PM (#36766065)
Good for them, I know plenty others who didn’t including my entire family.

That still isn’t the point, the quality of life in the USSR wasn’t a close 2nd to the US in fact when the USSR economy started to fall apart in the late 70’s and 80’s it too switched to PPP because hey our bread is cheap even if you need to stand in line to get it.

And Guyana today isn’t a better place to live in than France or Canada, and Bulgaria is definitely a 1000 times better place to live in than Russia.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by weard_beard on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:05PM (#36766885)
Don't you dare besmirch the name of Doctor Sausage!

https://tasteofartisan.com/doctors-sausage/

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by beebeepka on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:01AM (#36768434)
With climate change, today's Russia will end up the best prime estate in the world. Unless we flood them and turn it all to shit once we're driven up there due to draught, famine, war
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by midoridensha on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:19AM (#36768564)
>Good for them, I know plenty others who didn’t including my entire family.

There's a YouTube channel where an interviewer talks to people in various Russian cities today about the war and other topics. Loads of middle-aged and older women and men (esp. women it seems) say they want the Soviet Union back.

Your family was one of the malcontents that left. The people still there really do miss the authoritarian Soviet Union and want it back, and they fully support any warmongering necessary to achieve that goal.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FirmwareBurner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:50AM (#36769985)
>Loads of middle-aged and older women and men (esp. women it seems) say they want the Soviet Union back.

Because they have no marketable skills in the current economy. During soviet times they were basically state parasites, paid to sit around and do nothing, or pretend to work in some unproductive factory, and got free housing from the state without worrying about paying for electricity or heating as the state took care fo that too.

Now that they actually need to work to support themselves they find out capitalism works for those with actual productive skills not for those who are good at pretending to work or used to work as informants to the secret police for a living.

The sudden switch from communism to capitalism without a proper long term plan to reintegrate those people into the workforce really shocked them.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jhgfjhgfjhfgjhg on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:13AM (#36770142)
What percentage want the old Soviet Union back? I don't think you know what you're talking about.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by kranke155 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:43PM (#36775402)
A decent percentage of people from former communist countries liked it. You had full employment; full housing; low crime and 21 days of paid vacation.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by thomasz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:56AM (#36768395)
Despite all its shortcomings, the USSR did pretty well in areas they really cared about, like tank production. And it’s very difficult to compare the value of a t80 with the value of a m1, especially when there was little trade between both blocks. The USSR sold energy to Western Europe in order to get dollars which were then used to buy grain from the US. And that was just about it.

Your problem isn’t with PPP but with the Soviet societal tendency to falsify reports on absolutely every level and with the inherent incomparability between planned and market economies.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by landemva on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:05PM (#36765932)
>> it would imply the standard of living is increasing.

In USA, GDP includes the explosion of numbers of hospital admin staffers, energy prices doubled, and production of munitions which are given to Europe. That GDP does not increase my quality of life.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by mrb on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:32PM (#36766184)
"That GDP does not increase my quality of life."

I agree. As I said in my first post: "prices of goods [eg. healthcare] are inflated in the US compared to similar goods in the EU". So concretely, if healthcare prices increase in the US, but remain constant in the EU, this would increase the PPP GDP of the EU.

What I meant to write is: if the PPP GDP increases in the EU faster than in the US, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing faster in the EU than in the US.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:27PM (#36767051)
GDP PPP in the US is identical to the nominal GDP in the US since the purchasing currency in the US is the US dollar.

> What I meant to write is: if the PPP GDP increases in the EU faster than in the US, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing faster in the EU than in the US.

No it doesn’t mean anything of the sort in fact high nominal GDP to GDP PPP ratio usually indicates a low standard of living and a developing economy the Eurozone is an anomaly in this regard mainly due to its developed infrastructure and social institutions.

And don’t forget that your GDP PPP can be twice that another county whilst your median income is can be 10 times lower.

Median income per capita adjusted for PPP would be a better albeit an imperfect measurement of it since the standard of living is dependent on so many other things.

In which case there are only 4 countries which have higher median income PPP than the US, UAE, Luxembourg, Switzerland and Norway.

AIC/household final consumption expenditure is another good indicator for standard of living and wealth in which case the US is #1.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FredPret on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:05PM (#36767319)
US economic performance is all the more OP if you take into account that it's a huge country of 350m people and has a diversified economic base.

For a tiny banking nation or petrostate to be rich is unsurprising.

But when it's half a continent, the world really ought to take out their notebooks and go into full copycat mode - at least as far as economic policy and attitudes are concerned.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by beebeepka on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:56AM (#36768391)
Are you suggesting the EU should start pillaging countries? What petrostate should we liberate to becone self-sufficient? As luck would have it, the US achieved that right after conquering Iraq
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:21AM (#36769000)
Are you saying that the war in Iraq was in anyway profitable for the US?

> As luck would have it, the US achieved that right after conquering Iraq

Yes? A whole of of things happened back. I’m really not sure what are you implying here? Did they secretly ship Iraqi oil to the US and pretend it was extracted there?

> What petrostate should we liberate to becone self-sufficient

Uhm.. Libya? Or did everyone already forget that?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by rootw0rm on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:24AM (#36769430)
I'd personally recommend liberating Venezuela
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nvm0n1 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:33AM (#36770684)
The US is self-sufficient in oil because it developed the tech to do fracking of the oil sands, it's nothing to do with Iraq.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:41AM (#36770743)
Europe could be self sufficient in oil and gas (we're constantly finding new reserves in EU/EU associated territory), it just doesn't want to dig those up because it's hugely destructive for the environment.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by cman1444 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:19AM (#36771043)
Isn't Norway a massive producer of oil? And I think they're quite environmentally conscious. Also isn't Germany burning coal at record rates right now? I'm not totally buying the argument that Europe is just abstaining from easy production for environmental reasons.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:13AM (#36771605)
> Isn't Norway a massive producer of oil?

Yes, of oil and gas, and they're not producing as much as they could, for environmental reasons. They're holding off on production.

> And I think they're quite environmentally conscious.

They are, they could produce more.

Similar story for the UK and the Netherlands with North Sea gas.

> Also isn't Germany burning coal at record rates right now?

Not record rates, standard rates and declining very slowly (2023 is actually better than 2022, shown here):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_Germany#...

They did mess up the transition with the early decommissioning of nuclear power plants, corruption is probably to blame.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by thomasz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:03AM (#36768440)
Unfortunately, we are not allowed to print the world reserve currency like there is no tomorrow, and we do not possess the qualities of the US that make them the natural haven for capital in times of global turbulence.

That being said, the policy of austerity implemented during the Euro crisis was pretty catastrophic and arrested growth prospects for a whole generation.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by logicchains on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:46AM (#36769140)
>That being said, the policy of austerity implemented during the Euro crisis was pretty catastrophic and arrested growth prospects for a whole generation.

It was an austerity policy in name only given government debts have only continued to increase since then. There's a demonstrated correlation between high government debt and lower growth.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by bubbleRefuge on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:22AM (#36769419)
Not in the US
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by thomasz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:59AM (#36769670)
Nah, that’s demonstratively wrong dogmatism. Obviously it’s not a good idea to take three times your national GDP in debt to build three oversized airports next to each other because your family owns your nations construction business. But letting education and infrastructure collapse and watch a whole generation grow old without any chance meaningful workforce participation and without a chance at having a family is pretty devastating too.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by soco on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:33AM (#36770249)
This tendency didn't start at all with the Euro crisis. Remember Thatcher? She put this economic model firmly in place and everybody started to copy it, fiddle with it, without ever questioning its basis anymore. So it's not "a whole generation" but at least "two whole generations" - and it doesn't look like it's gonna stop the trend any time soon, public service keep getting defunded and big companies keep getting tax cuts.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by moomin on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:57AM (#36768815)
Call me back when this translates into regular working people’s salaries and health care outcomes and we’ll talk.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by fransje26 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:07AM (#36769716)
I, too, would prefer monthly shoot-outs to help regulate my population. And low-paid wages below the poverty line. And fentanyl as a substitute to affordable healthcare.

Folks, please leave your notebook in your bag and search elsewhere for a role model.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nocoiner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:31AM (#36770667)
Against my better judgment, I’m going to make a statement that sounds incredibly crass, but is directionally true: those are all travesties that no decent society should accept, but at the end of the day, they’re rounding errors.

There’s plenty that’s wrong with America, but there’s no other country within the same order of magnitude of scale (or, hell, expand that to either a population of 50+ million or an order of magnitude greater, even) that has long term prospects as promising as the United States.

China’s on the verge of demographic collapse. Europe, as much as I love to visit and would probably enjoy living there, is more or less the definition of sclerotic. Every other country that excels at both human and economic development is too small to move the needle. Yet the United States remains, overall, a pretty darn good place to live and a magnet for talent and capital all over the world (to say nothing of its own beyond-bountiful resources).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by happyraul on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:18AM (#36771034)
By what criteria do you judge the US to be "a pretty darn good place to live" compared to the EU?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nocoiner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:30AM (#36771855)
Edit: the formatting on this is just atrocious, and I don’t have time to do more than take a quick shot at hopefully fixing it, but suspect it isn’t gonna work. Apologies in advance.

Just off the top of my head, I guess my short list would look something like this. I grant some, maybe all, of these have drawbacks, but these are the factors that I personally value and what I would miss by moving to any of the other places I’ve visited or of which I’m aware that seem like delightful places to live. 1. The sheer number of incredibly unique large cities (and the correlating lack of a single city that dominates national culture)

2. The ethos of individualism

3. The national park system

4. The sheer amount of diversity (racial, ethnic, national origin, religious, regional, etc.)

5. My personal access to, and quality of, healthcare (I grant that this is highly, highly subjective)

6. Other Americans (believe it or not lol)

7. Higher educational system

8. Economic dynamism and opportunity

9. Our foundational documents and subsequent amendments/improvements thereto

10. Our national tendency to do the right thing (after, of course, exhausting all other courses of action)

11. Approximately 10 trillion different regional cuisines (have you seen the number of strongly held opinions about different ways to smoke and serve meat?)

12. Every type of natural beauty imaginable

Not saying we have a monopoly on any of these! But I like where I live and think it’s a pretty cool place.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nerdponx on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:26PM (#36766593)
Interestingly it probably does not increase the quality of life for most of those hospital employees either by all that much, except the very upper management.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:22AM (#36769005)
The gap between American doctors and those in some European countries is even higher than the one between software engineers.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FirmwareBurner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:48AM (#36769973)
Because public healthcare systems dictate how much a doctor is to be paid and how much each procedure should cost, in the public system, which is why the public system keeps getting more bogged down as the sums the state allocates aren't keeping up with the increased inflation and demand, so more and more people need to rely on the private system.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by lostlogin on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:06AM (#36770105)
And despite this, those socialised systems still have better outcomes per dollar spent.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FirmwareBurner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:10AM (#36770131)
Maybe if you can stomach the waiting times but then the private medical sector wouldn't be growling so rapidly for procedure the state also does.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:42AM (#36770750)
Anecdotally many people in Europe find waiting times comparable in the US and EU.

Unless you have studies to back this up, I'd drop the waiting time argument.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FirmwareBurner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:51AM (#36771364)
Who are those people in Europe who find waiting times comparable to the US?

Anecdotally I have to await much longer than my colleagues in the US (same field, same company) to see a specialist (months vs weeks). Also, the my public insurance doesn't cover my physiotherapy for my back pain, while the insurance my US colleagues get through their employer does.

>Unless you have studies to back this up, I'd drop the waiting time argument.

Maybe you should drop it until you can provide any kind of argument or evidence, because you wrote some words but said nothing of value.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:10AM (#36771568)
> Maybe you should drop it until you can provide any kind of argument or evidence, because you wrote some words but said nothing of value.

Neither have you.

My anecdotes contradict yours.

I'll just drop this since I've seen your other comment about inequality where I literally provided numbers and you disagreed without providing any counter-data.

Let's call this a day and move on.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FirmwareBurner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:21AM (#36771725)
>My anecdotes contradict yours.

Which anecdotes? You haven't even provided anecdote just baseless disagreement statements lol.

Might as well just plug your ears with your fingers and yell "lalalala I can't hear you lalalala" or just fart and call that an argument.

BTW, i did provide a source in the inequality comment. Check again.

Also how else do you want to measure waiting times in my country vs the US except comparing my experiences with the people I know living there on similar jobs? It's not like my government made statistics against the US health system to compare so comparing with my work colleagues from the US is the best I can do. You're just being contrarian for the sake of trolling.

Please provide some information if you disagree ,even anecdotes, because otherwise you're wasting everyone's time or you enjoy trolling.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by lostlogin on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @10:51AM (#36773335)
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nerdponx on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:43AM (#36772050)
I was talking about administrators and other "non-medical" staff. Nurses and doctors are in short supply as the working conditions are absolutely brutal, offset only by the possibility (not a promise) of fabulous wealth later in your career for doctors, and offset by nothing in particular for nurses. And hospital bureaucracy and poorly designed EMR systems makes it worse, not better.

Let's not glamorize the American system just because the European system is struggling in its own way.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by 0xcde4c3db on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:47PM (#36767205)
This reminds me of an old "ad" (not sure it was ever placed anywhere) questioning a similar tendency [1]:

> For years, economists have defined the economic health of a country by its gross domestic product. Trouble is, every time a forest falls, the GDP goes up. With every oil spill, the GDP goes up. Every time a cancer patient is diagnosed, the GDP goes up. Is this how we measure economic progress? Economists must learn to subtract.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0q-lEATP-9Y

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dmurray on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:35AM (#36768673)
This is usually called the broken window fallacy, from an essay by Bastiat in 1850.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Qwertious on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:25AM (#36769832)
More specifically, some valuable types of activities are not even measured in GDP - if you build your own table out of roadside scrap, then you might be immensely satisfied by the table, but it will contribute $0 to GDP. If you follow free instructions online (and look various stuff up on Wikipedia), that will again improve your life but not GDP.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by sixstringtheory on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:21AM (#36770185)
I wonder how that kind of reclamation project could be valued in terms of avoidance of waste, avoidance of expenditure of new resources, and the skill development of the person doing the work (in terms of either/both faster pace of the same value created in future reclamations, and/or future marketability of the skills towards a saleable product).
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dmurray on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:11AM (#36770503)
You could start by valuing it at the price someone would pay for it, plus the price the worker would have paid for that many hours of hands-on education.

This isn't totally farfetched: in some countries if you own your house you pay tax on the rent you would have paid to yourself [0]. Taxing someone for feeding or educating himself seems like a small and natural next step.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ryathal on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:26AM (#36771790)
The big thing is childcare from stay at home parents. That counts as 0 GDP, but put them in daycare and give the parent a job that's a net loss financially to the family and GDP has grown considerably.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HPsquared on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:53AM (#36769634)
Eisenhower put it well.

"Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed. This world in arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children. The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities. It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population. It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals. It is some fifty miles of concrete pavement. We pay for a single fighter with a half-million bushels of wheat. We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people.... This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chance_for_Peace_speech#The_...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by karp773 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:51AM (#36770359)
With all due respect to Eisenhower, this is an example of incredible political myopia. A country does not exist in a political vacuum and has to be able to protect its freedom and the very right to exist. So freedom is not free but comes at a price. How high the price is depends on the situation. Sometimes it's very high, unfortunately.

Complaining about this fact is as productive as complainig about gravity: if only we could float around effortlessly, imagine how much we would save on bridges and roads and fuel!

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by geysersam on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:18AM (#36770570)
It's not a fact that the US needs to spend 50% of the global military budget. If anything is myopic, that is.

It can still be argued that it's worth the expenditure. But the cost should be weighted against the alternatives. Neither Russia or China can be said to threaten the US with their military, except with nuclear weapons, but no defence budget protects against those.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:38AM (#36770720)
It's myopic to thing that having a large conventional army that deters rivals from attacking smaller trade partners is not beneficial.

Also, the US Navy protects vital global sea lanes that benefit US trade.

Also:

> Neither Russia or China can be said to threaten the US with their military

China is arming up at a huge pace, even outside of nukes.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by geysersam on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @11:31AM (#36774114)
> It's also myopic to think that having a large conventional army that deters rivals from attacking smaller trade partners is not beneficial.

No one suggested that it isn't beneficial.

What I said is that the benefit has to be weighted against the alternative benefits.

> China is arming up at a huge pace, even outside of nukes.

I'd argue that one large reason they're doing so is the threat they perceive themselves to be under from the large US military.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:59PM (#36779649)
That's not a valid reason since the US has had a large military since 80 years ago.

Don't fall into that trap.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by geysersam on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:51PM (#36781264)
Are you saying that China doesn't have a valid reason for having a large military, but the US does?

That sounds like a difficult position to maintain...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tekknik on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:27AM (#36782762)
China threatening to invade Taiwan, what’s your opinion now? What exactly are they building up for?

Are you from China?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @07:15AM (#36784594)
I'm saying that China was extremely prosperous and growing from 1980 to the present day, without increasing the size of its army 10x-20x-or-however-much-they're-increasing-it right now.

They don't have a real need for a bigger army, they could for sure defend themselves against any neighbor, even India and Russia, with "just" the military from 20 years ago.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by chrisco255 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:04AM (#36771507)
If there was a total war scenario with Russia and China, all bets would be off regarding U.S. military budget, as they would most certainly be a dire threat to numerous allies of the U.S.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tekknik on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:24AM (#36782748)
> but no defence budget protects against those.

what?!? what do missile defense systems do then? nothing?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by versteegen on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:51AM (#36782892)
In practice, nothing (against multiple multi-warhead ICBMs). If your foe only has one or two ICBMs maybe you have even odds. Against any nuclear-armed nation other than present-day North Korea, nothing. Even if you could intercept 90% of missiles/warheads if the opponent fires 20 (or 2000), you're screwed. There are multiple stages of flight in which one can attempt interception, but only the final stage after separation of warheads is realistic (which multiples the number of projectiles to intercept greatly): you can't intercept at accent unless you're very close to the launch site, hitting stuff in space with directed energy is defeated by a simple mirror, and hitting it with an inceptor is not feasible.

An article I picked at random:

https://breakingdefense.com/2022/02/no-us-missile-defense-sy...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tekknik on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:52PM (#36796405)
My next question is how did this organization get the security clearances required to know what missile defenses we have?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pastage on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:20AM (#36770591)
Tools created will be used, the cost of the US and Russian war arsenal is far greater than just the monetary cost to build them. One could argue that a weapons destructive force should be counted against it.

To strive for peace is not near sighted, it is the only way forward.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by codyb on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:42AM (#36788256)
The world’s more peaceful during the era of American Hegemony than it’s ever been. Odd how having a gigantic military with hundreds of millions of people under it’s umbrella seems to have stemmed regional conflicts from erupting.

You can’t prove that regional conflicts would erupt should the US become more isolationist but any history book should quickly show you human’s propensity for war.

It also turns out that human’s tend not to outright attack foes that will immediately decimate them.

The USAF is the greatest stabilizer this world has as far as I can tell, missteps and outright awful moves like Iraq taken into account in this calculation.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pastage on Friday July 21, 2023 @03:44PM (#36818631)
It really does not matter, because my point is that weapons cost is a lot more than the fiscal cost of the weapon, it does not matter who bought the guns.

Both the US and Russia have used their weapons to decimate other economies. It is very hard for us to prove or disprove your point.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HPsquared on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:43AM (#36770756)
Some budget is needed but it comes at a cost. It's a balancing act, like all economic decisions.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pphysch on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @11:06AM (#36773657)
This is true, but it is also true that USA is perhaps the most geopolitically-secure state in world history and should be spending among the least on national security (per capita).

Americans don't even know what genuine "national defense" feels like. Instead, we have a world-class propaganda complex dedicated to rationalizing our unnecessary overseas military adventures and proxy wars.

The idea that blowing up a government or tribe in Africa or Asia to open up resource extraction (natural or financial) for a Western MNC will benefit the "freedom" of the average American is totally absurd.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by xp84 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:32PM (#36776274)
> USA is perhaps the most geopolitically-secure state in world history and should be spending among the least on national security (per capita).

I think it glosses over too much complexity to simply state that, because part (not all! Geography is the other part) of the reason why we are so secure is that people know that we have that strong military. If the US were known as a soft target, who had neither the will nor the means to defend itself, we would probably see other actors much more willing to do things to us, such as piracy, etc.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by geysersam on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:29PM (#36779346)
What developed countries are victims of piracy nowadays?

There's an in-between the US and Somalia when it comes to control of territory.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by inpdx on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:51PM (#36775533)
The way to look at it is these are the tradeoffs, so we understand the ramifications. Do we need defense? Sure. But every $ we spend on it should be spent wisely, understanding that tradeoff.

We spend far more than we need to, and Eisenhower is 100% correct in the things we are giving up when we overspend on military.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dctoedt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:06PM (#36775802)
> With all due respect to Eisenhower, this is an example of incredible political myopia.

I'm curious what you know about Eisenhower and his career — it's hard to imagine anyone in the past century whose background and experience made him less myopic than he.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oska on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @10:41PM (#36781519)
> A country does not exist in a political vacuum and has to be able to protect its freedom and the very right to exist

Do you think that Eisenhower, a military professional and 5 star general, doesn't understand that? You're not understanding / misrepresenting what he is saying in that quote. It's about the cost of a military and how it has to be balanced against the productive and social needs of a country. A country that is grossly over-spending on the military, as Eisenhower perceived it already back then, and particularly in the case of the US, when that military is used for force and power projection, not defence, is strangling the society that it pretends to protect. This has been the history of the US over at least the last 50 years (when Eisenhower made this fore-warning speech).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by karp773 on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @07:40PM (#36795071)
One can be a good general but a bad politician and vice versa. I don't see any contradiction here.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FooBarBizBazz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:24PM (#36777912)
(Aside: I have mixed feelings about this antiwar line of argument in 2023, because while it seems generally good to be antiwar, it also seems like these arguments come mostly from Russian-aligned forces. To whom my answer would have to be something like -- "yes, let us be anti-war. You first."

But that, while possibly more important than what I'm about to say, is not what I really did want to say. Which is --)

Eisenhower uses a phrase of considerable rhetorical power here --

> those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed.

-- because he is essentially quoting the Beatitudes, and anyone who is familiar with them will fill in the rest.

Slightly less powerful to me (because it seems to equally reference William Jennings Bryan), but still very strong is

> humanity hanging from a cross of iron.

which is again extremely Christian imagery.

I'm not sure these phrases resonate so strongly with people today, but in those days they went straight to the heart of the question: What is it that is good?

I also really like the sentence,

> This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense.

because it focuses on the dichotomy of life vs. death, which again I think is very important. One could go in very positive green directions also from here. Some adjacent words would be: flourishing, abundant, fertile, growing. Frankly pagan things.

And, things that our economic metrics again tend to discount.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nvm0n1 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:31AM (#36770656)
> cancer patient is diagnosed, the GDP goes up. Is this how we measure economic progress?

Yes, obviously so! Diagnosing cancer early is one of the best ways to save someone from it. The cancer is there anyway, it's a natural occurrence. The economic activity that leads to and follows a cancer diagnosis is what economists call wealth: the things we do for each other than make each side mutually better off.

All the examples are like that. Nobody wants oil to spill, but accidents are a fact of life. The GDP created by mopping it up on the other hand leads to a cleaner environment, which is another form of wealth.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HPsquared on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:48AM (#36770797)
I think it was more that the harm caused in these (presumably) avoidable examples is not counted negatively. Preventing cancer makes less GDP than curing it; smoothly transporting oil without incident makes less GDP than spilling it.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nvm0n1 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:31PM (#36775202)
Why does preventing cancer make less GDP than curing it? That would surely depend on how you're trying to prevent cancer. By prevent do you mean keeping a cancer somewhat under control?

> smoothly transporting oil without incident makes less GDP than spilling it.

Oil creates huge economic activity when used. It does no good spread over the ocean. The cleanup generates activity, but it's clearly far better for GDP to smoothly transport oil around than constantly lose it, if only because ships constantly sinking would cause people to transport things way less and so markets would be less efficient, yielding less wealth.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nostrademons on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:42AM (#36768719)
That's exactly what the PPP adjustment is supposed to capture. If a dollar buys half as much energy in the U.S. as the USD/EUR conversion does in Europe, that adjusts the EU PPP for the energy sector up by 2x. (Not exactly a great example, Europe has its own energy crisis.)

I'm surprised at the number of people who are confidently arguing against mrb - they're exactly correct here. The point of PPP adjustments is to factor out the effect of having a strong currency, and the USD's status as reserve currency is exactly why the US GDP has been overtaking the EU. Adjust for what a dollar actually buys you domestically and the picture is far more muddled.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:14AM (#36768943)
> status as reserve currency is exactly why the US GDP has been overtaking the EU

USD was the reserve currency in the 90s and mid 2000s. Back then the Euro was very strong and some large European countries were close to overtaking US in GDP per capita.

The last 10 years have more or less been a lost decade in most of Western Europe because (amongst other things) it almost entirely missed out on the tech boom.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Cymrukicks on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:53AM (#36770006)
You're right no one in Europe can code or uses technology. Hell we're still using dial up internet. Its strange that you equate having huge tech companies that don't paid any onshore tax with a tech boom. Beyond convenience the average US citizen probably hasn't benefited much from the tech boom certainly not economically.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:27AM (#36783106)
> boom certainly not economically.

I’m not that certain about this.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:06AM (#36769713)
> That GDP does not increase my quality of life

It sure as hell does for the millions employed thereby, as well as those who catch their spending.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by lostlogin on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @06:04AM (#36770089)
Most negative things have an upside for someone, that doesn’t mean you have to like it.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:21AM (#36771056)
That’s my point. It wasn’t a comment about economic merit. OP just listed things they don’t like.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by blagie on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:06AM (#36770472)
It's an interesting argument. My feeling, completely based on spending a lot of time in the EU and the US is, and visited a lot of other countries:

- In general, GDP PPP per capita correlates pretty well with quality-of-life.

- In the case of US versus EU, it doesn't for this precise reason.

The amount of GDP I need to be happy is decent food, housing, education, basic entertainment (e.g. a nice park with a free concert, or a pleasant beach), and medical.

I get all of those in the (lower-income) EU country I normally visit, cheaply, and without much stress. $10k / year provides an adequate quality-of-life. That's not hard to make there, so people pick the careers they want. In the (high cost-of-living) area I spend time in the US, one needs around $150-200k / year to be stress-free. People do work like programming, biotech, law, finance, etc. to make it here.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nocoiner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:18AM (#36770561)
The energy position of the United States is just …. tremendously, tremendously sound. We’re a net exporter of hydrocarbons, have terrific renewable facilities in place, under development and untapped future potential, and have poured how many hundreds of billions of public and private capital into energy infrastructure in the past decade?

Are you, like, talking about the cost of a gallon of gas or something? Because I can cherry pick whatever numbers you like to craft a reductive substance-free assertion about the state of the US energy production and distribution system.

No argument on the hospital admins, tho (although it’s nice to have at least one in your social circle, so they can get you in with the top tier actual practitioners).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nonethewiser on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:11PM (#36765980)
Despite a shrinking economy. If we’re measuring economy size we’re not measuring purchasing power. I cant tell if you recognize this and just think we shouldn’t care about economy size or if you are actually conflating PPP with economy size. Mainly because you keep presenting it as a rebuttal to claims about economy size.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by conjecTech on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:10PM (#36766483)
Size is denominated in terms of some measure. You don’t eat dollars, and you can’t build a house out of one. GDP has doubled, but so have US prices. Does that mean the economy is actually stronger? Using PPP simply chooses to denominate GDP in terms of things other that fiat currency.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by FredPret on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:42PM (#36767166)
PPP is usually meant to compare economies and control for differences in cost of living, not comparing time periods. Inflation is when you compare the same economy in two time periods.

Furthermore, economic growth is measured in "real" dollars, aka, excludig inflation. If US prices doubled as you say, then their economy is therefore now four times as large in the new, inflated dollars.

None of this has anything to do with fiat currency. The same would be true if you measured in kg's of gold, but you'd have to account for the gold-cost of living ratio instead of fiat dollar inflation.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by conjecTech on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:21PM (#36767417)
Inflation isn't a scalar value, and all of this complexity is just trying to account for that. This thread is about whether an increase in effective income from prices going down is the same as your notional income going up while prices stay the same. My point is they're not, but feel very similar in most cases. I used an example with inflation rather than deflation since people understand that more intuitively.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by yorwba on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:06AM (#36768461)
Economic growth is best measured excluding inflation, but the chart in the tweet uses "current prices" aka the 2008 values are in 2008-dollars and the 2023 values are in 2023-dollars, including all the inflation that happened in between. (I've seen actual economists get confused by this meaning of "current", mislabeling a "current dollars" chart from 2019 as being in 2019-dollars, even though it wasn't inflation-adjusted at all.)

Using the World Bank's figures in 2015-dollars https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD?location...

GDP 2008 US: 16.38T EU: 13.19T US/EU: 1.24

GDP 2022 US: 20.95T EU: 15.21T US/EU: 1.38 (2023 not yet available)

Ratio of ratios: 1.11, so the US has increased its lead by about 11%, which is not nothing, but also less dramatic than it looks to me in the "current prices" chart.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by hef19898 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:56AM (#36768809)
Especially when accounting for negative GDP growth in the EU in 2012 and 2013, and the huge hit the EU took in 2020. 11% isn't nothing, but the both economies grew, one a bit more than the other, and that is hardly the end of the world one could be made believe by looking at the chart nased on current USD.

Sometimes lying with numbers is way, way to easy...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by nonethewiser on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:19AM (#36767753)
You have not clarified whatsoever and at this point it doesnt seem like you want to or even know.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by codedokode on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:39PM (#36766237)
PPP is a misleading figure. If your PPP-adjusted income is 2 times higher than someone's else does it mean that you can buy 2 times more MacBooks or trips to Korea?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ivan_gammel on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:59PM (#36766384)
If I earn $100k somewhere in Eastern Europe, then deducting all taxes and recurring costs like health insurance, rent or mortgage, from what’s left I may be able to buy more MacBooks or trips to Korea than someone from San Francisco. It is misleading to compare just a few imported goods to make conclusions as well.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:17PM (#36766994)
You’ll be surprised at how much housing costs in Eastern Europe these days…
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oneTbrain23 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:30AM (#36767824)
Still cheaper and sturdier than the cardboard house in USA. European houses typivally made of brivks and mortar. Cant say that in USA. Even 5mil house in San Fra, a significant portions the house is made of wood and drywall. Pounching through American wall is hollywood pastime. Cant find a similar think in other countries hollywood.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jandrewrogers on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:54AM (#36767944)
I’d like to see a European brick and mortar house survive a Magnitude 8 earthquake, which is a requirement in San Francisco. The US used to have lots of brick and mortar construction, just like Europe. After those buildings were all destroyed by strong earthquakes, they switched to steel and wood, which can survive a strong earthquake. Europe style construction is not allowed in much of the US because it demonstrably isn’t safe.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by hibikir on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:36AM (#36768244)
And yet, most residential construction is basically the same, whether it's going to be built in Palo Alto, upstate NY, Kansas, south Florida or Portland. Most of those don't have anything that even resembles strong earthquake risk.

American housing is built the way it is not due to extra interest in safety, but because it's cheap to build under US prices. You can call it better or worse than Europe, but it sure isn't earthquakes.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by themitigating on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:58AM (#36768410)
What is the advantage of using stronger building materials? Say brick vs wood frames.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by scarby2 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:09AM (#36768484)
It's not necessarily about strength but brick buildings will survive both fire and water much better than wooden buildings, they don't burn or rot. Brick buildings generally last hundreds of years with minimal maintenance (assuming no earthquakes).

Wood buildings can last hundreds of years but require far more upkeep.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by cman1444 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @08:36AM (#36771215)
This argument kind of falls apart when you start trying to maintain or improve plumbing, HVAC, and electrical through the house. It's much easier to do that through the wood and drywall of a typical American house.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by scarby2 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:33PM (#36777223)
AFAIK Plumbing tends to run beneath the floors in either construction model. Electrical in brick buildings is a pain as it runs in conduit behind the plaster but this doesn't compromise the viability of your structure and has a fairly long service life.

HVAC also can generally also be run under floors (and outside of the USA forced air systems are pretty unusual so you're only dealing with pipes).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by scarby2 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:03AM (#36768444)
>And yet, most residential construction is basically the same, whether it's going to be built in Palo Alto, upstate NY, Kansas, south Florida or Portland

This was the case but it's not really true any more. Building codes have become more stringent and risk specific. This hasn't changed anything around earthquakes though as as building a single story wood building that stands up to an earthquake is easy, building one that withstands a hurricane is harder.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by paganel on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:21AM (#36768997)
> I’d like to see a European brick and mortar house survive a Magnitude 8 earthquake, which is a requirement in San Francisco.

Sorry to put it this way, but is this a joke? I do live in Bucharest, in Eastern Europe, on the 8th floor of an apartments building built in the early 1980s, and I sure do hope that this building can withstand a Magnitude 8 earthquake seeing that we've had a 7.5 earthquake back in 1977 and a 7.7 one back in 1940 (and a 7.1 earthquake back in 1986, which I do remember).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by OfSanguineFire on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:10AM (#36771576)
The Richter scale is logarithmic, so I wonder how well a structure built to withstand an earthquake the magnitude of Romania’s previous earthquakes could withstand a Magnitude 8 earthquake.

When the huge construction boom began in Cluj in the first decade of the new millennium, the common opinion seemed to be that the old, ugly socialist-era blocks would survive an earthquake just fine, but people were less confident about the new buildings that private developers were constructing.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by oblio on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:45AM (#36770775)
> I’d like to see a European brick and mortar house survive a Magnitude 8 earthquake, which is a requirement in San Francisco.

This is how modern European brick houses are built:

https://stock.adobe.com/de/images/unfinished-brick-house-sti...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pzo on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:11AM (#36769331)
Sure increased but do people spend like 3k USD/m to rent something? In Poland you can still rent something for 1k USD even in Warsaw. Go to Bulgaria and rent is dirty cheap in places like Bansko you pay $400 or less for 1 month rental even using AirBNB.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by chmod775 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:20PM (#36766554)
> PPP is a misleading figure. If your PPP-adjusted income is 2 times higher than someone's else does it mean that you can buy 2 times more MacBooks or trips to Korea?

You're looking for "discretionary income" minus groceries (not to be confused with disposable income), because GDP does not tell you that (PPP adjusted or not) and PPP adjusted income doesn't tell you that either. Also you kind of made a jump from (per capita) GDP to income, which is related, but not the same thing.

To answer your question: In your example it may either be more or less, because PPP really does not say much for anything but your chosen basket of goods.

Example: Person A earns $2000 and spends $750 to meet standard of living X, while another person B also earns $2000 but has to spend $1500 to meet that same standard.

Adjusted for PPP using that standard of living/basket of goods X, Person A earns twice as much.

Let's assume that MacBooks and trips to Korea generally cost the same for both people. Person B has $500 left over to pay for such things, while Person A has $1250 left - more than twice!

I easily could have chosen numbers such that it was less than twice. I could also have chosen them such that one person, while appearing richer purely based on non-adjusted income, can in fact afford less of everything. Obviously you can also make it so that one person can afford less luxuries than the other despite appearing richer adjusted for PPP.

You can try to fix this by making any luxuries you're interested in part of your basket of goods. While you're still comparing an entire basket, at least you'll know how often each person could purchase that entire basket.

The point I'm trying to make is that while you still have to be careful to understand what PPP adjusted numbers are telling you, non-adjusted numbers aren't any better and in fact are probably more misleading for what you appear to be interested in.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Turskarama on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:16AM (#36767738)
Every statistic is misleading if you read it wrong enough. Typically, I'd say GDP is _more_ misleading than PPP in almost all cases.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by paganel on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:17AM (#36768970)
Who needs MacBooks or trips to Korea if housing and groceries are (relatively) more affordable in places with higher PPP (vs. comparatively lower GDP)? I cannot live in a laptop.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:28AM (#36768191)
> Still, if PPP GDP increases, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing.

PPP is weird. Many of my costs were higher when living in China since imported things were more expensive, and there were lots of extra taxes to consider. It didn’t feel like I had more PPP except when eating out and consuming services. You definitely can’t use PPP to buy imports.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by thomasz on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:30AM (#36768641)
PPP is meant to account for things like a haircut in San Francisco creating way more economic output than a haircut in rural China, and therefore inflating the numbers. It doesn’t completely solve the problem of comparing the economic output of a 747 to the economic output of a haircut in rural China.

If you are used to the lifestyle of the western upper middle class and consume the associated products, the effects of the PPP adjustment will not be that meaningful to you. The same isn’t true for people who have to use most of their income to buy basic necessities like shelter, food, transportation and so forth.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:52AM (#36772238)
Average Chinese costs are lower, however, not because their PPP is higher, they just have lower LCOL. So that hair cut that is only 20 kuai is done by a guy outside in the alley who maintains one very long finger nail (and yes, I actually experienced that before). If we were to compare the average Chinese bought car with the average American bought car, you would see a similar effect.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:10AM (#36768910)
If you want to measure the standard of living there a much better indicators than GDP per capita for that.

PPP is also a deeply flawed concept because comparing the quality of goods and services in the context of different consumption patterns. However if you really want to use you should look at median income (with social transfers etc.) rather than GDP.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dereg on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:40AM (#36769112)
Median income is not a better measure to gauge wealth changes over time because it doesn't take into account changes in the composition of your population. Following a median income time series over time doesn't actually track anything.

For instance, a country that accepts more lower-skilled immigrants will see its median income figures grow less than those who accept fewer of those immigrants. Is the country with more immigrants poorer as a result?

The only way that median income would be a valid measure of wealth or quality of life would be if you isolated the cohort of those considered "median" in 2008 and tracked their wealth over time.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:29AM (#36783126)
Or you could look at inequality, Gini and/or the 20th, 80th etc. percentiles instead.

> Is the immigrant-accepting country poorer as a result?

Yes, in this specific case it would be poorer per capita.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Gareth321 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:11AM (#36768916)
> Still, if PPP GDP increases, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing.

With some important caveats:

1. Balance of trade. The goods and services in the poorer nation are worth less, comparatively. Any trade with the richer nation will lead to a wider balance of trade deficit. This causes all kinds of structural economic and budget problems in the long term.

2. Foreign purchasing power. Customers have to substitute goods and services away from the richer nation to poorer nations. If one’s preferred television, for example, is produced in the richer nation, these will become more expensive, and will force consumers to purchase other options. This is especially acute in cases where a nation has a de facto monopoly on certain industries.

In reality, both nominal and PPP GDP figures are important to monitor for different reasons.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by andrewjl on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:33PM (#36777222)
> Still, if PPP GDP increases, with all else being equal (eg. stable population) it would imply the standard of living is increasing.

That's not necessarily true, depending on how the PPP is calculated it may not reflect the cost of imported food or energy or other necessities.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by aaomidi on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:21PM (#36765470)
Completely depends on what you’re measuring.

To me, economy isn’t an abstract thing to be measured without taking people’s quality of life into perspective. That just feels too much like stats for the sake of stats.

The PPP based measurement is way more interesting.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:31PM (#36765577)
Again PPP cannot by definition used to measure growth.

It has limited applications for developed economies and measuring AIC which it was initially conceived.

Here is a good breakdown of what it is, how it’s constructed and more importantly what it can and cannot measure.

https://www.oecd.org/sdd/prices-ppp/purchasingpowerparities-...

Regardless of how you slice it the national purchasing power of the US has doubled since 2008 whilst the EU’s has stagnated.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by flangola7 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:25PM (#36765508)
We don't care about size of economy, we care about aspects of daily life of the average person.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by coeneedell on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:40PM (#36765691)
We care about both, so we use different measurements for both.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by aerio on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:47PM (#36766738)
>We care about both

[ X ] Doubt

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:37PM (#36765643)
PPP isn’t a good or any indicator of that either, Guyana has a higher GDP PPP per capita than France or Canada, Bulgaria is below Russia and Kazakhstan.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by fulafel on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:07AM (#36769717)
Both are flawed proxies for QoL but PPP less so.

Canada and France have better QoL than Guyana at similar PPP GDP because of more equal distribution. They also happen to have higher non-PPP GDP but it's unrelated - it's accidental that in this case PPP normalization modifies the PPP GDP comparison to correlate less with QoL difference.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by _Parfait_ on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:30PM (#36765568)
..Ok but we're talking about the size of the economy you do know that right? Did you read even the headline?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by flangola7 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:19AM (#36767756)
The title of a headline does not dictate what I get to think and talk about. I'm not twelve.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by vjjsejj on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:43AM (#36769131)
> I’m not twelve

Not yet, anyway.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by flangola7 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:14AM (#36769765)
What a useless comment.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by _Parfait_ on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:34PM (#36775253)
You seem emotional about these facts. I'll let you get on with your day.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by flangola7 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:25PM (#36776153)
I didn't say anything about emotions. Are you confused?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by htfu on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:08PM (#36765960)
In 2008 the dollar was historically cheap (70% of current), now it's pretty expensive. This swing is the main driver of this whole thing and means that yes, PPP is superior for looking at growth. Not ideal, but much better.

Cheap imports are great for consumers, but a currency losing 20% certainly doesn't mean its economy has magically contracted 20%. If anything a weakish currency stimulates internal economic activity as it's good for exports.

The US economy is also not nearly "twice that of the EU", in nominal terms either - it's about 50% bigger. The (silly) chart is for the eurozone.

Seriously, the US always had a somewhat bigger/stronger economy, but a cheap dollar at the time made nominal almost equal, which was misleading. Now, the US still has a slightly bigger economy, and has had better growth, while the price of the dollar makes it look like a massive difference, which is also misleading. The true output difference is high single digit. Why are you pretending otherwise?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:13PM (#36765999)
PPP cannot be used to measure growth at all on any level.

https://www.oecd.org/sdd/prices-ppp/purchasingpowerparities-...

Also GDP, GDP PPP and every other economic benchmark is calculated using CID - constant US dollar; specifically to avoid skewing results due to fluctuating exchange rates.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by htfu on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:24PM (#36766118)
*Real GDP, chart is nominal...
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:31PM (#36766176)
? I’m replying to your statement:

> This swing is the main driver of this whole thing and means that yes, PPP is superior for looking at growth.

It is technically incorrect on every level. As GDP PPP fundamentally is unsuitable for calculating growth.

The GDP of Greece pre crash was $355B today it’s $219B, it’s GDP PPP pre-crash was $341B today it’s $389B if you think the Greek economy grew over that period or that today it’s a better place to live in with 11% unemployment and youth unemployment approaching 40% with the entire population having its wealth cut by nearly half than pre-2008 Greece then I have an island in the Aegean to sell you…

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by htfu on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:44PM (#36766276)
I'm saying given the choices of "US economy doubled! Eurozone completely stagnant" (nominal) and "both grew, US somewhat more" (PPP), PPP is by far a more accurate model of what has actually transpired.

That is all.

What it may or may not say about Greece is utterly irrelevant because that's not what I was talking about.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:48PM (#36766302)
But the problem that it is not, you are using PPP for things that explicitly it shouldn’t be used for.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Dylan16807 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:55PM (#36767626)
If you're only saying it's better for this single ratio then that doesn't make it a more accurate model. Statistics can be closer on a single number by pure happenstance.

If you want to say it's a more accurate model then you need to defend it more broadly.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by cbsmith on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:54PM (#36767622)
I am shocked, shocked! that a headline comparing data from a seemingly arbitrary date with today might be cherry picking data.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HWR_14 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:35PM (#36766211)
Isn't PPP per capita a better measure of quality of life than nominal GDP per capita? I care about what I can buy.

Obviously, nominal GDP per capita matters for international vacations.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by unmole on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:45PM (#36766281)
> Isn't PPP per capita a better measure of quality of life than nominal GDP per capita?

No.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:47PM (#36766296)
No, GDP PPP doesn’t measure what you can buy it measure how much things cost.

It doesn’t know how much money you have, it doesn’t measure the purchasing power of individuals. It also is based on a basket of 3000 fungible goods and services without accounting for value of quality or outcomes; as explained already in this thread.

It doesn’t take into account median income, income and wealth inequality, unemployment rates or any other factor that probably matters more than how much a bag of potatoes or a new highway costs.

Bulgaria has a worse GDP PPP per capita than Russia and many other far worse places. Guyana has a better GDP PPP per capita than France or Canada.

Greece’s GDP PPP per capita and in general is now higher than its pre-2008 crash, its nominal GDP however is still nearly half of what it was.

Youth unemployment is nearly at 40% with overall unemployment at 10-11% which is still masked by the fact that many people were still able to retire early over the past decade as they were still eligible for the 60 year retirement age (and earlier for certain occupations).

None of these factors alone can be used to extrapolate how well people are doing it take far more in-depth and even somewhat subjective analysis.

For example Norways GDP PPP per capita is about 30% higher than that of Finland however the average Norwegian is probably not better off than the average Finn especially not by “30%”.

Using GDP PPP per capita or otherwise as a rebuttal for economic stagnation due to lack of GDP growth is disingenuous at best and dangerous at worse.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by scythe on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:03PM (#36766859)
>It doesn’t know how much money you have, it doesn’t measure the purchasing power of individuals.

No per-capita metric does this. You have to use things like the median wage to capture the purchasing power of individuals. For example, Equatorial Guinea's GDP/c is among the highest in Africa, but due to insanely high inequality and oppression, people are better off in Senegal or Rwanda. Guyana, which recently discovered large oil reserves, is a less extreme example of the same thing.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:20PM (#36767016)
Exactly, your GDP PPP can be double that of the US and it does you absolutely squat if the median wage is 10 times lower.

I swear I don’t remember the last time I’ve seen this low level of topical knowledge in a post on HN as this one.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by thanksbucko on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:08PM (#36767342)
Thanks for posting clarifications and disputations, seriously. I naively thought all the PPP business meant something that I’ve since learned it does not.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HWR_14 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:45PM (#36767565)
It's orthogonal. Nominal GDP (or income) is if you took it to the money exchange and turned it into the same global currency (say US Dollars or Euros). PPP GDP (or income) takes into account how much stuff you can buy.

Whether it's better to take the median income or the per capita GDP (which is closer to the mean income) to represent the "typical" person is a different question.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by refurb on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:40AM (#36769928)
You can see this by the top countries in GDP per capita.

Countries like Ireland and Singapore have per capita GDPs that are 10-30% higher than the US, yet median wages are lower.

Wikipedia even has section explaining why:

Many of the leading GDP-per-capita (nominal) jurisdictions are tax havens whose economic data is artificially inflated by tax-driven corporate accounting entries.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HWR_14 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:43PM (#36767552)
That's not really relevant. I didn't say it was the best measure, I said PPP GDP is better than nominal GDP. All you did was argue that there are better measures. Both which I agree with and is irrelevant. Sure, median income is better than mean income.

Given that, PPP is better than nominal, however you compute the average.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:03PM (#36766871)
Neither measure what you can buy.

GDP isn't distributed evenly. PPP doesn't effect the distribution. It's just an adjustment.

An oil state like Russia has a decent GDP, but the distribution is horrendous. It doesn't matter if you look at GDP or GDP PPP. Neither gives you a great picture "what you can buy" unless you're in the top 1%.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by HWR_14 on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:46PM (#36767576)
No one said GDP was distributed evenly. My point was PPP GDP is better than nominal GDP. IF you use median income, PPP median income is better than nominal median income.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by rayiner on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:49PM (#36766757)
I think Americans would disagree with the implication that the US has done particularly well over the last 15 years, even though going by nominal dollars that seems to be the case.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by JackFr on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:38PM (#36767133)
That’s true, and it’s the point.

The reality is that there American system sucks by some metrics, and yet by others which are real and not BS, the US economy crushes.

In the end human flourishing, and life satisfaction are more important than GDP, but at the same time GDP is real and it does matter.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by rayiner on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:24PM (#36775041)
I think the issue is more than the divergence between what nominal GDP suggests and what people feel demonstrates that nominal GDP is not a useful metric. It essentially measures your ability to buy things denominated in USD. Some of those things are important and others are peripheral. But the purchasing power of most of the important USD-denominated goods is already reflected in the PPP adjustment. So that leaves the peripheral stuff. So for example, the standard of living in South Korea is probably closer to the country's $45,000 PPP GDP per capita, than to its $35,000 nominal GDP per capita. It doesn't really make a difference that South Koreans can purchase fewer MacBooks and must instead buy Samsung products.

It's similar to people who insist that folks in New York or San Francisco are better off than folks in Texas because of higher incomes, without adjusting for cost of living. If that was true, domestic net migration patterns wouldn't look the way they do. Yes, folks in New York or San Francisco can buy more MacBooks, but that's not a useful metric.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jopsen on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @06:22AM (#36784218)
> at the same time GDP is real and it does matter.

At least such a huge difference will have practical effects.

Can we fund our welfare systems without growth? (Just imagine what we could do, if the budget was 2x)

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by vkou on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:16PM (#36767383)
Americans with wealth or property have done great for themselves. They currently feel that the economy is in the dumps, but that's just because talking heads on Fox are telling them that it is. They can't articulate why the economy is in the dumps.

Americans who are between the ages of 15 and 35 feel like the ladder has been pulled up out of their reach, and they've felt this way for the past decade. Mostly because property owners have reaped most of the benefits of the past two decades.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pseudo0 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:04AM (#36768010)
The top 10% of American households own 89% of US stocks, and the top 1% own 50% of US stocks. The benefits have almost entirely accrued to a small minority at the top. Some of the 35+ cohort are doing exceedingly well, but most just have a primary residence (with a mortgage), some limited retirement savings, and maybe a small investment account. Those people are still working for a living, and likely have experienced real wage stagnation or decline. So media pundits claiming "the economy is great!" really does not match up with the typical experience. The stock market is not the economy.

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/18/the-wealthiest-10percent-of-...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ddd00001 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:24AM (#36771772)
Since ~2012 disposable income for Americans has lapped that of Europeans. See for yourself.

https://dart.lisdatacenter.org/dart

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pseudo0 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @11:18AM (#36773903)
I don't think anyone is disputing that the US had a really good run from 2014 until 2020, but real wages still have not recovered to pre-COVID levels. See eg. the BLS Employment Cost Index.

https://www.bls.gov/blog/2023/more-ways-to-look-at-wages-and...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ddd00001 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:07PM (#36776831)
The point of the convo is that Americans are much richer than Europeans. Which is true.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by LudwigNagasena on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:56PM (#36766812)
> GDP PPP can increase whilst your economy contracts.

So can GDP.

> PPP isn’t a good measure for population’s wealth or quality of life especially for developed economies either.

Why isn't it a good measure? Why is it worse than pure GDP?

> The economy of the US is still twice that of the EU and its global purchasing power has also pretty much doubled.

The GDP of the US is twice of that of the EU. How does paying $2000 for a 50 sq. feet box makes your economy bigger?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:10PM (#36766931)
> So can GDP.

No, not really as exchange rate fluctuations are avoided using constant international dollar benchmarks.

> Why isn't it a good measure? Why is it worse than pure GDP?

This been explained multiple times in this thread already including a link to the OECD FAQ on GDP PPP.

Nominal GDP isn’t a measure of individual wealth either, it is however a very good indicator of national economic growth.

>The GDP of the US is twice of that of the EU. How does paying $2000 for a 50 sq. feet box makes your economy bigger?

GDP PPP doesn’t include housing costs, at least not directly it includes a component which is called imbued rent which tends to grossly underestimate the actual cost of housing in a given country.

Housing in the EU is generally more expensive than in the US both to rent and to buy nearly every country has a massive housing shortage and inflated prices.

My partner bought a flat in Poland as an investment in March this year for the equivalent sum of ~£160,000, it’s a 48 sq/m 2 bed flat.

The 2nd stage of the development on an adjacent plot is starting now with the prices around £180-190K for an equivalent property.

And this is in a village 50km from Krakow… (Bochnia).

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by LudwigNagasena on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:35PM (#36767112)
> No, not really as exchange rate fluctuations are avoided using constant international dollar benchmarks.

There are ways for GDP to increase while economy contracts. As the simplest example, an informal sector may become formalized and be partially reduced in the process due to new bureaucratic obstacles.

> This been explained multiple times in this thread already including a link to the OECD FAQ on GDP PPP.

I don't see OECD FAQ claiming anything close to what you imply. It actually claims that "The major use of *PPPs is as a first step in making inter-country comparisons* in real terms of gross domestic product (GDP) and its component expenditures."

> Nominal GDP isn’t a measure of individual wealth either, it is however a very good indicator of national economic growth.

A nitpick: if we talk about growth, we should talk about the change in GDP. Anyway, how is the change in nominal GDP any better than the change in GDP PPP?

> GDP PPP doesn’t include housing costs, at least not directly it includes a component which is called imbued rent which tends to grossly underestimate the actual cost of housing in a given country.

The rent is included directly. Imputed rent is fictitious income that exists to account for housing services homeowners provide to themselves to make comparisons easier between situations where the rate of homeownership is different. If it grossly underestimates the actual cost of housing, it simply means it is calculated incorrectly. As a sidenote, for lots of other services such adjustments are not made (eg eating out vs cooking at home, paying a housekeeper vs cleaning yourself).

> Housing in the EU is generally more expensive than in the US both to rent and to buy nearly every country has a massive housing shortage and inflated prices.

I don't think any EU city can compare to the US juggernauts such as NY and SF in terms of housing shortage and inflated prices.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:59PM (#36767283)
There is literarily a table in the FAQ flr what PPP can be used for and what it cannot be.

PPP cannot be used to measure growth, period.

Nominal GDP increase indicates an increased production, PPP increase indicate absolutely nothing. In fact PPP often increase or maintains its level in times of crisis when income level drops and unemployment rises.

The US is far bigger than NY and SF and even then many EU cities can more than compare… The housing stock is far cheaper in the US and you get far far more for your money.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by LudwigNagasena on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:42AM (#36767876)
> There is literarily a table in the FAQ flr what PPP can be used for and what it cannot be.

Yeah, and it says "Uses with limitations: To analyse changes over time in relative GDP per capita and relative prices".

> PPP cannot be used to measure growth, period.

> PPP increase indicate absolutely nothing.

No, refer to paragraphs 32-34 of the overview from the PPP Manual: https://www.oecd.org/sdd/prices-ppp/PPP%20manual%20revised%2...

> Nominal GDP increase indicates an increased production

No, it doesn't. Value = price x volume. If value has gone up, it means either price or volume had gone up, but you cannot say more than that; for that you need real GDP.

> In fact PPP often increase or maintains its level in times of crisis when income level drops and unemployment rises.

Yeah, GDP and GDP PPP are both imperfect metrics. They are just proxies and should be treated as such.

> The US is far bigger than NY and SF and even then many EU cities can more than compare… The housing stock is far cheaper in the US and you get far far more for your money.

So what? It doesn't change the fact that nominal GDP fails horribly as a metric for such cases.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:41AM (#36769117)
> I don't think any EU city can compare to the US juggernauts such as NY and SF in terms of housing shortage and inflated prices.

Zurich, London, Paris and Munich

Also median income in SF and NY is much higher (with the exception of Zurich) so it should be much easier for an average person to afford a home in NY than in Munich.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:37AM (#36769093)
> $2000 for a 50 sq. feet box makes your economy bigger?

Isn’t real estate generally cheaper in the US than in Western Europe in PPP terms?

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by soligern on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:49PM (#36767220)
Why isn’t it a good measure? It costs maybe $0.50 to get a reasonable full meal in India, you’re not going to get anything close to that in the US. In second tier cities in India, people can rent a reasonable studio for $50/month, you’re not getting that anywhere in the US. Why shouldn’t that be a relevant metric?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by rjzzleep on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:13PM (#36767369)
Because obviously then all the MBA's, business consultants and other useless services industries don't get the real value they deserve on paper.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by theonlybutlet on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @12:53AM (#36767933)
For this purpose you're not measuring growth but rather comparing it against someone else who uses a different currency.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by throwaway4good on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:12AM (#36768077)
Sorry mate - I think you got that one turned on its head.

The common (and relevant measure) is real gdp growth or growth minus inflation. (And per capita if that is your concern.)

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jhoechtl on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:29AM (#36768194)
GDP isn’t a good measure for population’s wealth or quality of life especially for developed economies either.

The GDP wa invented by a russian working for US bureau of statistics during the great depression. It was a helpful measure to compare performance of different US evonomic sectors. It favors deficit spending to saving.

It is a very inadequate measure for people wealth in any developed economy.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by hef19898 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:28AM (#36768625)
I am by no means an economic expert, but I shared this chart yesterday, GDP 2008-2022 in current international dollar:

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.PP.CD?locat...

Now, I have no idea what thebdifference between constant USD, current USD and the international versions are, and wpupd be happy if someone cpuod explain it since the differences are huge, but measured in curren international USD, the EU and US GDP charts move more or less in parallel with the EU one being a little bit lower. But of course, a chart that shows a huge delta developing makes for much better headlines, and more eyeballs on the article...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by solardev on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:39AM (#36768697)
Explain?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by paganel on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:16AM (#36768958)
> No one uses PPP for measuring growth,

I've just started to read Graham Allison's Graham Allison (supposedly based on this article [1]) and the exact opposite remark is made at the beginning of that book, i.e. that one should use PPP numbers instead of nominal GDP numbers when looking at the quality of life.

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/09/un...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by ffhhttt on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:35AM (#36769081)
Growth is not the same quality of life.

GDP per capita (PPP or not) is a bad (and very lazy) indicator to use if you’re trying to measure QOL.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by next_xibalba on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:36PM (#36765629)
The WSJ article [1] from which this chart is derived does account for both inflation and purchasing power when comparing incomes.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/europeans-poorer-inflation-econ...

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by selectodude on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:17PM (#36765436)
The EU is an export-based economy, so that's great that people in the EU can drink cheaper beer and pay less in rent, but if they want to buy imports, they're absolutely poorer.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by anonzzzies on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @02:14AM (#36768519)
Even though I can afford it, I mostly do not need new imported stuff and second hand you can get a lot of things (mostly everything besides Apple stuff) at bottom prices. Many people unfortunately dump stuff after new shiny comes out and some even give them to me for free. My iPhone was a gift from a friend who bought the latest. It’ll go for many years still. My nreal (xreal) now was a gift because another friend didn’t like it and couldn’t be bothered to sell it.

But obviously I can live without these things and for vital things, like laptops, washing machines, dish washers or tvs (not really vital), they cost peanuts second hand.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by networkchad on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:43AM (#36769127)
Referencing hand me down and donated goods in a conversation about economic growth. What level of cope is this?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by anonzzzies on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:39AM (#36769919)
Wasn't responding to the article, was responding to my commenting parent.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by yourusername on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:25AM (#36769439)
If the new stuff gets more expensive second hand stuff that has some useful life left will become more expensive. If a new washing machine is €5000 a second hand washing machine with a year of useful life left will be €500 instead of €50. These things are not unrelated. If iPhones cost multiple monthly salaries people will substitute with cheaper options and the supply of high quality second hand phones will dry up.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by freetime2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:11PM (#36765371)
Thank you. Twitter is terrible when it comes to cherry picking stats out of context.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tnel77 on Monday July 17, 2023 @07:26PM (#36765527)
Ironically posted as a reply to a comment cherry picking stats.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by freetime2 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:05PM (#36766883)
Fair enough - my comment complaining about the quality of content on Twitter was admittedly pretty low quality.

When I said "Twitter is terrible when it comes to cherry picking stats out of context", I was referring to the fact that the Tweet doesn't link to its source, and that it only shows 2 years (instead of a line chart which would show all the years in between). It also doesn't make any attempt to interpret the data (e.g. why or what it means).

I view the parent comment as adding context. They linked to the source of their data and also included their interpretation - which other people can then agree or disagree with instead of having to guess what they meant. So yes I think this is a much more constructive post than the original tweet.

Note: I now see that they linked to the source WSJ article beneath the original tweet, but that was not clear to me when I made my earlier comment (and I see other people on Twitter asking about the source so it's not just me who missed it). I still think that twitter in an inferior platform for discussing nuanced topics like economics than, say, HN.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by tnel77 on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @09:47AM (#36772142)
I agree with you. It just made me chuckle :).
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jcfrei on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:32PM (#36766180)
PPP is not a good measure for comparing the strength of different economies. The more appropriate comparison is looking at the growth in GDP with conversion to USD using the conversion rate at that time. Additionally starting in 2000 (ca. time of introduction of the euro) makes more sense than 2008. Using the data from https://stats.oecd.org/ gives you the following:

EUR/USD in 2000: $0.92

EUR/USD in 2022: $1.072

US GDP in 2000: $10.25T, 2022: $23.31T, growth of 227%

EU GDP in 2000: 7.86€ T, 2022: 15.81€ T(27 countries, excluding UK), converted to USD:

EU GDP in 2000: $7.23T, 2022: $16.94T, growth of 234%

Growth in the EU from 2000-2008 has probably (didnt crunch the numbers on this) been higher than in the US and then lower since around 2010.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by dogma1138 on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:50PM (#36766325)
GDP figures are calculated explicitly using CID, specifically in order to prevent exchange rates from indicating false growth or contraction like you’ve demonstrated.

What’s worse you’ve committed a double sin, you’ve used figures which were already normalized using the constant international dollar and applied exchange rates to them.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by danielheath on Monday July 17, 2023 @08:59PM (#36766381)
Compared on the measure of “ability to produce US dollars “, the US has vastly outstripped everyone else /s
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by pas on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @05:03AM (#36769691)
others' demand for those dollars also wildly exceeded expectations!
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Amiable5326 on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:19PM (#36766550)
PPP numbers should not be taken seriously as PPP was invented by an Indian communist who was upset that India, and particularly his Marxist state that he was part of, was underperforming and as a result, like all good communists, invented a new methodology to cook the books and hide the fact that his failed ideology never produced the prosperity that it proclaimed to create. To this day bureaucratic individuals love using PPP because helps hide mediocre economic growth that their policies helped create.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by esperent on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:10PM (#36766930)
Attack ideas, not people. I don't care who invented GDP or PPP, only if they are adequate proxies for economic strength and quality of life.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by selimthegrim on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:44PM (#36767180)
Wait until you hear about who invented HDI.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by consilient on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:20PM (#36767414)
Cassel was a Swedish liberal.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by peyton on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:43PM (#36766704)
> What that means is that the prices of goods are inflated in the US compared to similar goods in the EU. That's all.

Other way round. PPP is a consumptive measure.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by throwawayggg on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:43PM (#36767174)
America prints a lot of money and invests in cutting edge technology and USA imports high skilled labour while EU imports low skilled labour so I would say the gap is going to increase more and more
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by metacritic12 on Monday July 17, 2023 @10:47PM (#36767207)
Except your conclusion of US inflation being huge doesn't square out in the data:

Eurozone inflation 2008 to today has been 33%

US inflation 2008 to today has been 42%.

This doesn't square with your implication that the US inflation is double the EUs.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPHPTT01EZM661N

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CPIAUCSL

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by Rexxar on Monday July 17, 2023 @11:52PM (#36767611)
Indeed, another way to see this is that's just forex valuation change.

2008 was the peak of EUR value after subprime crises in USA. And the "nearly two times" is more like 1.60 which is explained by the value of the euro coming back from 1.6$ to the more sustainable long term value of 1$.

(usd/eur chart https://www.macrotrends.net/2548/euro-dollar-exchange-rate-h...)

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by cesarvarela on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @01:28AM (#36768190)
Technology is sold in US dollars, and prices are mostly the same globally, so yes, food has kept the same, but technology, which drives growth and innovation, is further away. i.e., the Apple Vision Pro will cost twice as much (in GDP terms for what it is worth) to Europeans, reducing the chances of the next big company building on it to be located in Europe.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by fhe on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @03:32AM (#36769060)
I have always wondered to what extent GDP (price-adjusted or not) reflects standard of living. By different sources, GDP per capita for Britain is only 60% that of the US, but visiting these two countries I don't see much of a difference in standard of living.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by jltsiren on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @04:00AM (#36769256)
If you make $50k/year and work for living, you are probably middle class. If you make $250k/year and work for living, you are probably still middle class. That's more or less the same thing.

Differences in income have a surprisingly small effect on quality of life. If you make more money, you can still afford the same luxuries. Just more of them and more often. You are likely buying bigger and better versions of fundamentally the same things. You probably spend your money less efficiently, buying all kinds of minor conveniences.

And if everyone around you makes more money, your expectations go up, and your spending will be even less efficient.

Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by woliveirajr on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:48AM (#36770800)
Why not use the price of BigMacs and how many an average worker can buy?
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by unstatusthequo on Tuesday July 18, 2023 @07:58AM (#36770869)
Nobody believes China’s numbers, anyway. Take whatever they say and halve it. Then multiply by 1/3 of pi. Or pick a random number you like from roulette. Any of those could be more accurate than China’s actual numbers.
Re:the US economy and the EU were the same size in 2008, the... by frankreyes on Friday July 21, 2023 @01:20PM (#36816627)
$1 is still $1 when for example you travel to another country or buy stuff online. Just like CPI, PPP is biased to an average and meanwhile the extremes are getting worse. The poor are getting poorer and the rich, richer. If you have zero bananas and I have two, on average we have 1 each.