News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @09:54PM (#35759042)
Hard to believe they really care about right to repair when they added random CPU requirements to Windows 11 just to make existing CPUs obsolete and keep Intel in business.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:12PM (#35759139)
> just to make existing CPUs obsolete and keep Intel in business.

Bizarre take. It's not random, it's specifically CPUs that support modern hardware security mitigations.

There's a pretty great talk from Bluehat a few days ago that goes into why Microsoft is doing this:

https://youtu.be/8T6ClX-y2AE

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:16PM (#35759162)
See the last paragraph. At best it's half-plausible deniability. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/why-windows-11-has-s...
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:28PM (#35759213)
The last paragraph is a little strange as Microsoft explained its reasoning the day before:

https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2021/08/27/update-...

It only added 7th gen processors that have DCH driver support, which is the absolute minimum baseline for W11 support.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:38PM (#35759254)
I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs. [1] Surely there's no conflict of interest here.

Could you explain in what way "DCH driver support" is a "hardware security mitigation" as you wrote?

Moreover, doesn't basing this on "DCH driver support" basically let the hardware vendors decide which otherwise-capable CPUs they'd like to make obsolete through software updates?

And furthermore, note that the OS isn't even turning on the CPU features they require by default, as the article also mentions.

[1] https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/ThinkPad-T400-T500-and-newer-T-...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by coder543 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:14PM (#35759395)
> I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs. [1] Surely there's no conflict of interest here.

That statement seems misleading at best. According to Microsoft's page[0] on that processor, the Dell Precision 5520 is supported as well, which means this support is clearly not limited to Microsoft's own hardware.

Depending on how Lenovo configured the BIOS, it is entirely possible that they disabled certain features that Microsoft deemed critical later on with Windows 11. Vendors do plenty of weird things with BIOSes, which can have far reaching impacts on what an operating system is able to do with the hardware. Or Lenovo didn't provide a necessary driver, or whatever the actual problem was here. Dell managed to meet the requirements just fine, apparently.

Yes, obsoleting a bunch of hardware sucks, but your claim that this was to help Intel sell more chips is extremely dubious. Your claim that Microsoft isn't doing this for security reasons because they're exempting only their own hardware doesn't mesh with the reality of that Dell laptop. None of the evidence here supports some grand conspiracy here, as far as I can tell.

I also found a forum thread[1] where at least one person was struggling to update their Surface Studio 2 to Windows 11, so even that hardly seems cut and dry.

[0]: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/design/mi...

[1]: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/surface/forum/all/window...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#35759476)
Any responses to the other things I listed? Like how DCH driver packaging is a hardware security mitigation?

> Depending on BIOS settings, it is entirely possible

"Entirely possible" is quite a big umbrella that covers planned obsolescence quite well, too. It's not like using software to make hardware obsolete is lacking in historical precedent.

> There isn't some grand conspiracy here, as far as I can tell.

Well, it's "entirely possible", as far as I can tell. Though I'm not even claiming there is one - there isn't a particular need for a conspiracy here.

> I also found an entire forum thread[1] of people struggling to update a Surface Studio 2 to Windows 11, so even that hardly seems cut and dry.

All of those comments were posted in the span of the first 4 days Windows 11 was officially released. If you dig a bit more you see people have succeeded afterward. [1] So that was most likely just a bug on their side, which isn't surprising given their own device was an edge case they were trying to make an exception for.

[1] https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-11/windows-11...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by coder543 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:36PM (#35759486)
> Any responses to the other things I listed? Like how DCH driver packaging is a hardware security mitigation?

No, someone else responded to that. I was just here to look at a dubious claim and see what the evidence showed. If it had been supported by the evidence, it would have been scandalous, but it wasn’t. I’m not an expert in the Windows security model, so I don’t know anything about DCH drivers.

Regardless, I encourage you to re-read my comment, which I edited awhile ago, apparently while you were typing that out. I have made my points more directly.

No, your perspective is not supported by the evidence. There’s really nothing more for me to say here. I looked at your claims, and that doesn’t appear to be what happened. Dell being supported directly contradicts what you were claiming in the comment I responded to.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:24PM (#35759434)
> I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs

Because Lenovo did not bother writing DCH drivers, given DCH drivers are the baseline requirement.

> Could you explain in what way "DCH driver support" is a "hardware security mitigation" as you wrote?

I was recalling a 2 year old blog post in my head, but the point is still that much of the requirement is around baseline security. If you watch the video I linked, the speaker does go over all of this.

> basically let hardware vendors decide which otherwise-capable CPUs they'd like to make obsolete through software updates?

I'm not sure what you're getting at. DCH drivers were already the default for current-gen hardware _before_ W11 even came out, W11 just made it a requirement. Vendors clearly aren't going to go write some greenfield drivers for a years-old 6th gen intel product just to support W11, as those devices will be 10 years old by the time W10 support ends.

> note that the OS isn't even turning on the CPU features they require by default

Note that you're still referencing a blog post from 2021. W11 22H2 enables core isolation by default for new installations, and HVCI is enabled by default when using the Windows Enterprise security baseline.

https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-security-ba...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:08AM (#35759618)
> If you watch the video I linked

I have in fact. It's a nice talk about security in Windows 11, but I haven't seen anything in it answering these issues. He says absolutely nothing about DCH and doesn't give any explanation for the minimum hardware requirements. The closest I recall was he was mentioned of integrating Pluton on chip and making its firmware directly updatable, but I don't believe for example that the 7820HQ and the 7700HQ are any different with regards to Pluton.

> I'm not sure what you're getting at. DCH drivers were already the default for current-gen hardware _before_ W11 even came out, W11 just made it a requirement.

No, they didn't even make DCH a requirement; Windows 11 runs with standard drivers too.[1] And, again, DCH doesn't imply anything about hardware security mitigations, which was purportedly their reason for this.

> Note that you're still referencing a blog post from 2021. W11 22H2 enables core isolation by default for new installations, and HVCI is enabled by default when using the Windows Enterprise security baseline.

Because the situation is fundamentally the same since 2021. Core isolation support is not a distinguishing feature between (say) the 7700HQ and 7820HQ, as far as I know. And the Windows Enterprise security baseline seems kind of irrelevant for the millions of average consumer devices out there. A company that cares about consumers or the environment is telling consumers across the planet to turn perfectly good devices into electronic trash now because they might add something that helps security years later?

I'm going to let my comments rest here; people draw their own conclusions.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Windows11/comments/pr4kmr/why_is_wi...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:01AM (#35759811)
> He says absolutely nothing about DCH and doesn't give any explanation for the minimum hardware requirements

The hardware security baseline is one of the first topics he covers as part of Windows 11 security strategy, with mention given to features that require hardware support and how they intend to enable these by default going forward as not doing so was a failure of the Windows 10 strategy. He even mentions "virtualization extensions" aka HVCI-related features which would be non-performant to enable by default in older hardware.

How exactly would a strategy of enabled-by-default work if the hardware wasn't there to support it? You seem to be looking for some hard "gotcha" statement to refute your argument instead of considering all of the information available in front of you.

> No, they didn't even make DCH a requirement;

By setting the minimium CPU requirement to systems that use DCH drivers, they effectively did.

> Core isolation support is not a distinguishing feature between (say) the 7700HQ and 7820HQ, as far as I know.

That's not the issue here. The 7700HQ lacks Trusted Execution support (aka TPM), whilst it's included in the 7820HQ, thus it does not meet the minimum requirements.

> electronic trash now because they might add something that helps security years later?

No, it's giving people the heads up that Windows 11 security strategy requires these features and gives people & companies time to adapt. For example, motherboards now ship with TPM 2.0 enabled by default, so as Windows 11 rolls out more features that require it (some aspects of Windows Hello already do), users aren't stuck with a system that needs a BIOS update or are unable to use the new features. Windows 12 will very likely make these requirements hard-enforced rather than soft-enforced and thus it'll make the 11-to-12 upgrade a smoother experience.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:06AM (#35760549)
Is it time to bring up the old "TPM is a good thing for you only if you're holding the keys - which almost nobody on the non-enterprise level is, so it's actually bad for you" discussion?

> How exactly would a strategy of enabled-by-default work if the hardware wasn't there to support it? You seem to be looking for some hard "gotcha" statement to refute your argument instead of considering all of the information available in front of you.

I'd say the core issue here is of priorities. Microsoft may be treating aggressive enabled-by-default approach to security as a good thing. A lot of other people don't. If you don't, then the high-level summary of the issue is, essentially, "By making some relatively recent hardware features a requirement for Win11 in the name of sekhurity, while also aggressively pushing users to upgrade and actively preventing them from continuing to use Win10, they're forcing people to destroy perfectly good machines for bullshit reasons".

I'm having hard time seeing fault in this view.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by ablob on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:17AM (#35760336)
DCH Drivers apparently consist of the following things [https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/d...]:

  Declarative: 
        Install the driver by using only declarative INF directives.
        Don't include co-installers or RegisterDll functions.
  Componentized:
        Edition-specific, OEM-specific, and optional customizations to the driver are separate from the base driver package. 
        As a result, the base driver, which provides only core device functionality, can be targeted, flighted, and serviced independently from the customizations.
  Hardware-support-app:
       Any user interface (UI) component associated with a Windows Driver must be packaged as a Hardware Support App (HSA) or preinstalled on the OEM device.
The D and C parts of the description appear to be what you're looking for here. No special hooks or modifications of the system paired with independent modules.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:56AM (#35760499)
Just to follow up if anyone reads this far down, an interview with David Weston from Windows 11s release also validates what I've said in this comment chain:

https://www.techrepublic.com/article/windows-11-understandin...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:40PM (#35759267)
> It only added 7th gen processors that have DCH driver support, which is the absolute minimum baseline for W11 support.

I'm typing this on a T430 with a i7-3632QM running Win 11. The stupid thing is I never wanted Win 11 on it. MS suckered me into a installing Windows 10 update version 22000 (just after ver 19043) which didn't mention anything about Win 11.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:10PM (#35759390)
>Windows 10 update ver 22000 (just after ver 19043) which didn't mention anything about Win 11.

That's because those are NT kernel version numbers, not Windows marketing version numbers.

Windows 10 and 11 both identify internally as NT10.0.X.Y where the X and Y are the specific build numbers.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Kwpolska on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:00AM (#35760520)
Windows updates aren't advertised by the build number, at least if you're using release versions (no idea about the insider program).
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by NayamAmarshe on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:15AM (#35760597)
No amount of reasoning is enough to justify that on consumer PCs, where the users don't know any better, TPM and other software side requirements were this necessary and not optional.

So suddenly, all the Windows 10 computers are insecure or what?

A normal person looking at "Windows 11 is not supported on your device" WILL think that their hardware is not good enough to run the authoritative OS.

This is less about security and more about planning a strategy to sell more devices. Anybody denying this possibility is just ignoring on purpose.

Here, I am not actually arguing against the addition of TPM or anything. I am arguing against them being a fixed requirement to run the OS that would otherwise run without any issues because it quite literally is a Windows 10 reskin, nothing more.

This is proven by the fact that they broke their own requirements on their own surface devices. Which tells me that this is less about them being serious about security and more about declaring most fairly recent hardware obsolete.

It's anti-consumer at best and deceitful attempt to sell more computers to non-tech folks at worst.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by MikusR on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:58AM (#35761120)
https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000...

"Intel® 6th Generation Core Processors or Newer Processors are supported by Windows DCH Drivers."

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:20PM (#35759173)
It's a neat little mitigation but it's ridiculous to label it necessary for a consumer OS and obsolete hundreds of millions of computers.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by charcircuit on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:25AM (#35759680)
It's pointless for a consumer OS unless most users support it. There will need to be a version that requires it sooner or later.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dylan16807 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:25AM (#35759885)
Having most users support it is largely just a matter of time. Screwing over a ton of people people because you want to make "most" happen a year sooner is not a good thing. Tens of millions of people are going to be forced out of perfectly good hardware years before they would have normally switched. Or left without necessary patches.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:51AM (#35759989)
Intel Coffee Lake and AMD Zen+ came out around 2017/2018, that's 5 to 6 years ago. I'm not even getting into processors that precede them.

I'm well aware computing power for practical use cases has plateaued since around 2011, but those Coffee Lake and Zen+ systems (let alone older) are coming due for replacement/upgrade soon for anyone inside of a lifecycle cadence whether Windows 11 demanded it or not.

For anyone who isn't who cares about hanging on to old hardware, it's perfectly fine to just keep running Windows 10. All those guys saying "yOuR sYStEM iS iNSeCurE!!1!1!1" are snake oil merchants wanting to sell you something.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:48AM (#35760456)
> For anyone who isn't who cares about hanging on to old hardware, it's perfectly fine to just keep running Windows 10.

Increasingly hard to get this days, especially through official channels. Currently, Microsoft actively prevents you from getting a Win10 installer/image, by redirecting all the relevant links to Windows 11 pages.

> All those guys saying "yOuR sYStEM iS iNSeCurE!!1!1!1" are snake oil merchants wanting to sell you something.

You mean like Microsoft? Saying that the new system is more secure is equivalent to saying your old system is insecure, given everyone's insistence that you either are fully secured or not at all.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by herbstein on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:54AM (#35760808)
> Increasingly hard to get this days, especially through official channels. Currently, Microsoft actively prevents you from getting a Win10 installer/image, by redirecting all the relevant links to Windows 11 pages.

Really? I used this just a few weeks ago and definitely got a Windows 10 ISO.

https://www.microsoft.com/software-download/windows10ISO

For reference, I searched the following on Google

> windows 10 iso

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:38PM (#35777200)
For context then, some two-three weeks ago, I wanted to upgrade my wife's perfectly good Windows 7 to a Windows 10 (mostly because Chrome has been whining for the past half a year, but also because Spotify plain old denied to start playing music until we upgrade the OS). I went for the in-place upgrade path, which involves downloading a Win10 media creator tool from Microsoft. Links to various Windows 10-related information all redirect to Windows 11 landing pages now.

Additionally, I suspected I'll need a new product key. I couldn't get that from Microsoft - every link I've managed to Google also had a redirect to Windows 11.

(In the end, I purchased an electronic license from some local software shop. Then it turned out that somehow, Microsoft considers my wife's Win7 license still valid for Win10 Pro, which is nice. I used the key to upgrade another machine, which I thought was on Pro, but actually was on Home.)

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:33AM (#35760691)
> Intel Coffee Lake and AMD Zen+ came out around 2017/2018, that's 5 to 6 years ago.

You're (probably unintentionally) exaggerating, but that's not how it works. When a new CPU comes out, all the machines on the market don't magically replace their CPUs with that one on day 1. The machine I'm typing this comment on right now was a pretty high-end one I got after those CPUs came out, and its CPU is from an older generation. In fact, I don't even recall having seen machines with newer CPUs on the market (at least not with the minimum specs I was looking at) until quite a few months later, though my memory might be hazy here. Sometimes the price points are also a factor here too.

> those Coffee Lake and Zen+ systems (let alone older) are coming due for replacement/upgrade soon for anyone inside of a lifecycle cadence whether Windows 11 demanded it or not.

That's by no means universally true; there are plenty of good machines out there that work just fine and that people want to keep using. Again, speaking from personal experience, I know my machine is perfectly good and I hope to keep using it for several more years. An older one I had from several years before that, which I gave away for unrelated reasons, was also great, and I would still use it if I had it and my current one somehow broke. There's been literally no reason for me to throw these away anytime soon other than Microsoft forcing me to. Lots of people are being forced to throw away perfectly good hardware because Microsoft/Google/Apple/etc. force them to, often via software.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:50AM (#35760785)
I have a Sandy Bridge machine still serving me dutifully as a sub computer to my main computer, so I know all about old hardware never really dying from impracticality especially since 2011 onwards. Hell, I still have a Pentium 4 machine running XP for the stuff that needs/wants that too.

As I already said, if you want to keep running Windows 10 (or 7, or XP) it's perfectly fine. Tell everyone who screams "SECURITY!" at you to screw off, they all want to sell you something.

Even if you do upgrade to a new machine, why does someone have to throw away their old one? Keep it as a sub computer, or give it a new role in your life. Windows 11 mandates TPM2 and SecureBoot, but it doesn't mandate throwing your old machine in the trash.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:00AM (#35760835)
I think we're mostly in agreement (?) but (1) XP isn't really practical nowadays, and (2) as to "why does someone have to throw away their old one" - well you don't have to, but having your files haphazardly spread/duplicated across N machines is quite a pain for most people.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:12AM (#35760904)
>I think we're mostly in agreement

We are indeed!

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by JamisonM on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:42AM (#35759949)
Does making all those computers still run Windows 10 make them obsolete?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by ryukafalz on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:43AM (#35762465)
When Windows 10 stops getting security patches in a few years, yes.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by JamisonM on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:29PM (#35768220)
End of 2025 doesn't seem like too big an issue.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by cosmojg on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:03PM (#35759091)
For anyone else in this predicament, I was able to get around this by editing some registry keys and installing from a lightly modified ISO on the one Windows machine in my fleet.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:08PM (#35759126)
For anyone else in this predicament (or not), I recommend not getting around this and just sticking with Windows 10.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by ipaddr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:07PM (#35759377)
What is your plan for when Windows 10 becomes not supported
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by tourmalinetaco on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:41PM (#35759510)
Linux, as should be most sensible people’s solution. Especially since 80% of PC users just use their operating system as bootloaders into a browser. 80% of that remaining 20% use PCs for gaming, and that is only getting better on Linux. Not to mention more adoption = better native ports. The final 4% of users are people who understand enough to choose their OS with a purpose in mind and/or use a specific OS for work purposes.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by katbyte on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:14PM (#35759394)
Hope there’s windows 12 and it’s better?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:09PM (#35759385)
Cry, probably. (Only half joking.)
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dawidpotocki on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:34PM (#35759236)
Or you can use Rufus for flashing the ISO to the USB stick which will do it for you.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by throwaway70701 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:09PM (#35759130)
Yeah well I was like "if I have to buy a computer anyways it's going to be a Mac". Thanks Windows 11 for finally pushing me!
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nirvdrum on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:32PM (#35759228)
If you want a Mac, go for it. But if your opposition is to Microsoft requiring newer model CPUs, that seems like a weird turn to take. You can't even upgrade RAM or storage on any of the Mac laptops; you're supposed to just go buy a new machine.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by oblio on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:45PM (#35759295)
Don't try to reason with people in these circumstances.

"I hate big cars and they increased the size of my favorite midrange SUV. I wanted to buy the latest generation but because it's too big I instead bought a Ford F150".

You wouldn't believe how often an equivalent scenario happens with laptops, phones, Linux distributions.

It's largely emotional aka spite. Plus an excuse of sorts for a guilty pleasure.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by rvba on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:29PM (#35759455)
Rather: I have a perfrctly gine computer but cannot upgrade it to Windows 11 for free, because Microsoft came up with random requirements. They want me to buy a new computer and pay for Windows again.

Also "security" is not a real excuse. If someone can physically grab my computer they will be able to break into it few days after Windows 11 is life since there will be some exploit like there always are.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by crossroadsguy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:28AM (#35759693)
So I will move to a platform that's literally more restrictive in every other way (in)humanely possible? Right!
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by throwaway70701 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:00AM (#35760276)
Is it? I haven't seen any ads or a requirement to sign in with Microsoft/Apple account in macOS, there's no Pre-installed TikTok nor Angry Birds returning on every update and I haven't seen Apple discontinuing support for 6 years old computers.

It might be restrictive in all the ways I don't care about, but oh well.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by retrobox on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:41AM (#35760730)
> and I haven't seen Apple discontinuing support for 6 years old computers.

You mean the way macOS Ventura is only for their hardware released in the last six years? [1]

Apple’s absolutely do discontinue support for older hardware all the time.

1. https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT213264

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by throwaway70701 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:43AM (#35760194)
It is spite! I hate Microsoft putting ads into the OS, and pushing me to throw away a perfectly fine i7/32GB RAM computer. So a Mac it is. My first one btw. But it's not really a guilty pleasure - it's the best money/performance you can get now, especially if you do ML (thanks to Unified RAM).
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by oblio on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:25AM (#35761559)
While I think the Apple performance part is probably valid, you're still proving my point.

You absolutely did not have to throw anything away now, you wanted a new toy.

Windows 10 is still supported until November 2025, 2 and a half years from now.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by katbyte on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:15PM (#35759399)
For most users getting 24/32gb is all they will ever need.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nirvdrum on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:46PM (#35759531)
Neither 24 GB nor 32 GB are base model specs; they're fairly expensive upgrades that you have to decide in advance because you can't modify the machine afterwards. You really need to know what your usage is going to be, otherwise you overpay for hardware you don't need or have to replace a machine because it's insufficient. If you have the money and inclination, max out the specs and be done with it. But, doing that because you're upset you're going to have to buy a new CPU doesn't make sense to me.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by rwalle on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:39PM (#35759501)
No point with arguing with these people.

I have noticed that people love their operating systems, especially in the Mac camp, even if switching to a different operating system would make almost no actual day-to-day difference in experience to them because they would be using the same applications/visiting the same websites anyway. And they like to make false claims about the other operating systems that they don't use.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by crossroadsguy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:31AM (#35759704)
There is a section of Apple users/fanbase that, if one day Cook instructs someone at Apple to run a remote command and wipe every single piece of data on their devices and nuke backups in iCloud as well, they will find a way to feel grateful about that and advocate and defend Apple in hordes even before Apple had the time to speak about it.

From the top of my mind it seems they would start with "I was struggling to get into the zen mode, disconnect, and seeing Apple failed to do with with ScreenTime their latest effort helped me perfectly. It just works!".

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by mickelsen on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:46AM (#35759755)
You can still find those people right in the Apple community forums. When I switched to Mac many years ago I was so surprised at the attitude longtime users there had with technical questions, just turning them over to the user asking why would they even need that change. Anything that deviated from the standard "expected" experience, even if it was an evident bug, was just treated with hubris by them. Many of those answers are still voted as best answer.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by crossroadsguy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:53AM (#35759781)
Yes. Whenever someone says 4chan is a bad forum etc, and 4chan is bad in many ways imho, then I remember https://discussions.apple.com - the Mariana Trench of intellectual decadence. So much that it seems a necessary requirement to be a member and user there is to dislodge your brain and store safely in the fridge before going there.

I mean that forum is hard to believe to be real - in short and politer terms.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by quickthrower2 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:04PM (#35759098)
Yeah I am forced to do a real upgrade now to GNU/Linux
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by pierat on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:11PM (#35759136)
The bright side is that Linux is NOT a roach motel. And your data is your own.

And being a 'pierat' I've already seen Sony institute 'dont play torrented content on PlayStations'. And that was the PS3.

I completely expect similar with Windows and Mac. We already see keygens and patches marked as "malware" when the only mal- is for the publishers.

It may end up that the best play-anything-anywhere will be Linux.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by quickthrower2 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:41PM (#35759514)
The only thing keeping me on Windows is the sharing a PC with family kind of thing but now we have enough devices I might just reformat my laptop.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by krelian on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:03PM (#35759092)
By all accounts windows 11 is a hot pile of excrement so they really did us a favor.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by aardvarkr on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:36PM (#35759248)
The only people who say this are the ones who HAVEN’T tried it. Tbh it’s just like every other boring windows OS. Slapping a new coat of paint on it barely qualifies as “hot pile of excrement”.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by bitwize on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:45PM (#35759296)
Windows 11 is like Ghostbusters (2016 film). It wasn't as bad as I was expecting it to be, not by a long shot, but that doesn't make it good or something I want to subject myself to again.

But my perspective is unusual. The friction increase for Windows 11 over its predecessor is, for me, slight; but I've used so many WMs and DEs that adjusting to a new one is hardly noticeable. To a normie, Windows 11's pebble-in-shoe UI changes -- the start menu location change, the right-click menu change, the emphasis on connecting you to Microsoft and third-party apps and services rather than getting things done -- would be sources of profound aggravation.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:56PM (#35759339)
Anyone's first experience with Windows 11 is clicking on the start menu and discovering their virgin install is fully leaden with crapware - ala 1999 Packard Bell.

That sells you on Windows the same way stepping in cat barf sells you on your new pet.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by firecall on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:14AM (#35759637)
That really is a big issue, for me, with Windows 11 and Edge.

The entire experience is cheapened.

MS Edge, for instance, actually has an excellent base UI. But the UX is destroyed by plastering horrible tabloid news and ads all over the first launch experience.

The engineers are MS are obviously very good at what they do. But it feels like the rest of the product and marketing departments get ahold of things and jam in trashware and ruin it.

Windows 11 is fine. It's fine. The graphical changes to the UI are in improvement to my eyes, and they are slowly adding back utility. Such as right-clicking on the task bar and being able to launch the activity monitor!

They even have tabbed explorer windows now!

Still, MS did such a bad job of launching W11 that my two gamer teenager kids and their friends have sworn off it for as long as they can!

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by windowsrookie on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#35759474)
I have tried it. And it feels like windows 10 with more advertisements. I really dislike ads and avoid them by paying for ad-free services and/or using Adblock applications. In windows 11 it is seemingly impossible to remove the advertisements, so I will be choosing not to use it.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by hakfoo on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:08AM (#35759622)
They've already lost the conversation though.

There were Windows products people were genuinely excited for. 95 being the obvious one, but WinXP did really deliver the promise of modern, NT-based windows for the home desktop, and Win7 felt like we finally broke free of the stagnation of XP (worsened by the bad press Vista got).

I willingly went out and acquired a legit copy of Windows Vista (at the time, the pre-pre-predecessor to Bing Rewards let you grind some crummy games for a few weekends to earn enough tokens for a copy) but even being told Win11 is free and will be delivered directly to my desktop, I just go in and slide the TPM option to "off" in the BIOS to make sure it doesn't prompt it.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Semaphor on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:57AM (#35760258)
While I don’t agree at all with "hot pile of excrement", W11 requires more 3rd party tools to make it usable than before. One to remove the telemetry and ads (OO Shutup), one to put the taskbar in a sane position (StartAllBack).
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nibbleshifter on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:23AM (#35760642)
Been using it at work, "hot pile of excrement" applies.

Using fucking Corp licenced Win11 Pro and still getting ads/spamcontent in my OS?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by GordonS on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:25AM (#35760649)
I have tried it, and while it's not "shit", it's not good, and certainly worse than Windows 10. It basically is Windows 10, but with more ads and a much worse UI. And it's full of stupid, niggling things, like burrying context menu options in Explorer.

I'm staying on Windows 10 until EoL in 2025. If Windows 12 is out by then, I may switch, otherwise, I'm moving to the long-term support version of Windows 10.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:14PM (#35759396)
Windows 11 brings support for Intel Thread Director (perhaps not relevant/important to the AMD fanbois here), better support for variable refresh rate and high refresh rates in general, and tons of other kernel and system improvements in the backend that Windows 10 will not get.

The frontend UI still sucks, but it's overall better than the nonsense known as Metro and regardless it's all nothing that can't be addressed with sufficient will.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by the__alchemist on Saturday April 29, 2023 @09:55PM (#35759046)
You don't need this if doing a clean install; only reqs it from upgrade.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:04PM (#35759101)
I assume you do realize more people would be interested in upgrading from older CPUs than new ones?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by anaganisk on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:50PM (#35759550)
I assume you do realize you can still do a clean install (on old CPUs, instead of hitting upgrade, because that's what OP meant.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:57AM (#35760819)
Somehow both of you are strongly validating my point without realizing it, and it's rather perplexing why you're making it sound like a rebuttal.

When you deny ordinary people the easy path of an upgrade and force them to do a clean install (because "security"), you induce the vast majority of them to avoid the migration pain and just buy new hardware, with the new OS preinstalled. If this isn't a way to force people to buy new hardware via software, I don't know what is.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by anaganisk on Wednesday May 03, 2023 @02:25PM (#35805881)
Forced is a strong word here because, do we absolutely know a straight up upgrade might not corrupt something hence they're expecting a clean install? Else you are right.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by anarchy79 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:04PM (#35759100)
I am thinking this does more damage to their competitors than to themselves.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:20PM (#35759176)
CPU requirements hurt their competitors? How?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:24PM (#35759438)
>just to make existing CPUs obsolete and keep Intel in business.

AMD also "benefits" with their minimum being Zen+ (aka Ryzen 2000 series and certain 1000 series processors) to Intel's Coffee Lake (8th gen) and certain Kaby Lake (7th gen) processors.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by flangola7 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:26PM (#35759444)
>just to make existing CPUs obsolete and keep Intel in business.

This isn't the main reason, I'm not even sure why they would do that, Microsoft will cheerfully build for whatever hardware is available. They're not indebted to Intel.

The real reason is to finally close the circle of every mainstream OS supporting hardware-backed remote attestation. Once that is in place digital controls ala DRM become extremely reliable and virtually impossible to crack. Pirating locally-ran software will be as difficult as extracting the private key from a Trezor or YubiKey.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by rvba on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#35759473)
They want us to buy new computers. With a new computer you cannot upgrade for free - you need to pay for windows again.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by matrix_overload on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:17AM (#35759650)
IIRC, it was due to spectre/meltdown [0], where a rather obscure design flaw in Intel CPUs of the time made it possible to slowly read the kernel memory space from an arbitrary process.

Microsoft added software mitigations for it to Windows 10, but they came with a price of a ~20% slowdown.

By the time of Windows 11, Intel fixed the issue in the newer processors, so instead of supporting both old CPUs (with slowdown) and new CPUs, Microsoft just scrapped the mitigations altogether and limited Windows 11 to new CPUs only.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meltdown_(security_vulnerabili...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by pgeorgi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:37AM (#35759726)
Would have been a fun exercise to get Intel and AMD to replace (or properly fix) their defective product, instead of just shrugging their shoulders and telling people to buy new cruft.

Especially with win11 claiming to be eco-friendly in various places ("reduce CO2 footprint") it's somewhat annoying to force a hardware refresh cycle like that.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:51AM (#35759773)
> Would have been a fun exercise to get Intel and AMD to replace (or properly fix) their defective product, instead of just shrugging their shoulders and telling people to buy new cruft.

If people want extensive warranties like that on their electronics, they can already buy extensive warranties on their electronics.

Why force everyone to pay for these things?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dislikedtom2 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:37AM (#35759932)
Because this planned obsolete stuff is slowly killing us and yielding would probably only make it worse?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:50AM (#35759985)
If you don't like it, don't buy it.

Or do you just want to control what other people are doing?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by rablackburn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:29AM (#35760137)
Not put words in OPs mouth, but saying they “just want to control people” is perhaps not what they’re going for.

Since you raised the valid point of “why make everyone pay”, it seems they (OP) are concerned that currently _everyone_ is paying for the externalities of shitty electronics and the associated ewaste.

Of course these kinds of externalities are impossible (or just really hard?) to rectify at the individual-action level, its a collective action problem.

So they raised the interesting point why not target the specific companies who manufactured this faulty product and require them to clean-up the problem they’ve created.

If nothing else, it’s a useful conversation to have?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:54AM (#35760246)
Sure, it can be a useful conversation.

Assume for the sake of argument, that I agree that there are externalities and that we should do something about them.

The economics textbook tells you the simple solution: tax the externalities. In our case, you might want to tax e-waste (or directly tax whatever is bad about e-waste, like heavy metals or so.)

Then let the market figure out how to deal with it. Perhaps offering extended warranties is the way to go? Perhaps developing compostable computers is the way to go? Perhaps using fewer computers is the way to go? Perhaps just sucking it up, doing nothing and paying for the externalities is the way to go?

It's not at all obvious to me which of these (if any) is the best solution. And I don't have high hopes than any government would figure out the best solution either.

Different people might even have different answers, and suppliers can provide for this diversity.

This simple tax avoids a lot of regulatory complexity. Remember, that regulatory complexity leads to loopholes and regulatory capture and endless lobbying.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by aziaziazi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:02AM (#35761137)
The tax you propose is not as simple as you suggest :

Do you tax on material weight ? But bigger sized systems tends to be easier to repair/recycle than nano electronics. They also often last longer.

Do you tax on raw materials ? That would exclude all the junk made abroad. Or on components ? That would make a gigantic and perpetually changing list to maintain, creating an incentive to always create alternatives only needed to game this tax.

Hope does that address the externality “not infinite material rarefaction” ? Making thinks more expensive just make them less affordable for a part of the population while the other part can not care much especially for cheap disposable(!) small devices.

I don’t have the perfect solution but IMHO we need regulations, not tax. Creating an obligatory (long) warranty would push the society in the sustainability direction. I don’t need 2$ led lamp, an even slimmer keyboard or a 120hz screen, just want it to last way more (or being able to make repair) that 2/3 product cycle time frame defined by the corp business team. Who want to say to their children “enjoy this tech while there’s still some rare earth left” ?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:03AM (#35761439)
> Do you tax on raw materials ? That would exclude all the junk made abroad.

You can adapt the tax to fix that problem. See how VAT systems handle imports and exports. If your stuff needs eg lead, you either prove that you dispose of it properly, or you pay the tax.

> I don’t have the perfect solution but IMHO we need regulations, not tax.

Why? Wouldn't your argument also work for a 'good enough' tax?

I agree that a tax also needs some careful thinking about what the exactly the externalities are that you want to tax. But it still leaves more flexibility to consumers and suppliers than a blanket regulation like 'mandatory long warranty, whether you want it or not'.

> Making thinks more expensive just make them less affordable for a part of the population while the other part can not care much especially for cheap disposable(!) small devices.

I don't understand this objection. Could you please explain?

Obligatory long warranties also raise the price of goods.

> Who want to say to their children “enjoy this tech while there’s still some rare earth left” ?

Are you suggesting we are going to run out of rare earth elements? Fat chance. We are sitting on a giant ball of matter, we are not going to run out of any elements. We might be running out of easily mine-able deposits of something, but either the price will go up a bit or someone will invent a new technique. (The former often leads to the latter.)

> I don’t need 2$ led lamp, an even slimmer keyboard or a 120hz screen, just want it to last way more (or being able to make repair) that 2/3 product cycle time frame defined by the corp business team.

That's a valid preference, and I suggest you put your money where your mouth is.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by aziaziazi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:04AM (#35762169)
> See how VAT systems handle imports and exports. If your stuff needs eg lead, […]

It is way harder for a customs officier to distinguish if a package contains some trace of lead, gold, bore, cobalt, disprosium, neodyme… in some micro chip than classifying in “raw material, “alcool”, “processed food”, “weapon” etc.

Making thinks more expensive to prevent usage is pointless and that’s why countries put speed limits in place. Speed is dangerous (see ek=1/2mv2) and a “speed tax” would only reduce a road accidents to the proportional inverse of its users wallets. As the e-waste and elements rarefaction have impacts that last way longer than a road accidents, we need to absolute regulations to avoid those externalities. Relatives regulations (taxes) are good to balance some parts of the economy, not to prevent problems.

Of course I would stand for tax it can do a “good enough” job.

> We might be running out of easily mine-able deposits of something, but either the price will go up a bit or someone will invent a new technique.

What makes you suppose the price will go up only a bit ? What makes you expect a material price will stay bellow the economical threshold of its extraction ? I dream too of new clean techniques but the history showed us those inventions relies on way more energy and/or also have externalities on resources and environnement. I’m sure you’ll find plenty in battery material alternatives and oil replacement/new extraction techniques. Fracking [0] is my Favorite one.

0 https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/interactive/us/D...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:40AM (#35762967)
Many countries effectively have a speed tax at least for small amounts of going over the speed limit.

I'm not sure why you keep harping on about people's wallets? Yes, rich people can afford more stuff. What else is new?

The economic theory of taxing externalities does not rely on all people having the same size wallet.

Have a look at eg London's congestion charge: it's not a problem for that system, that some people are richer than others.

You can also look at Singapore's congestion charge or Singapore's Certificate of Entitlement system. Or look at the very successful US sulphur dioxide cap and trade programme: it's not a problem that rich people can in theory just pay to emit more sulphur dioxide, the system still works.

> What makes you suppose the price will go up only a bit?

In the long run, the same reasoning that made Simon win his wager: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simon%E2%80%93Ehrlich_wager

> What makes you expect a material price will stay bellow the economical threshold of its extraction ?

Sorry, I don't understand. The price will generally be above that threshold, otherwise why would anyone bother extracting the stuff?

> Fracking [0] is my Favorite one.

Fracking is great, yes, I agree. One my favourites as well:

The extra natural gas that the US got from fracking allowed them to reduce their carbon emissions in the 2010s, despite lack of political support for such a goal! Holier than thou Europe meanwhile increased their carbon emissions, because fracking is verboten over there, so they burned more coal and oil instead.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by atoav on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:48AM (#35760211)
Gotcha, so you are also against electrical regulations like requirements to use tested insulators etc?

Because some regulation is actually useful in a world where consumers cannot be expected to know everything and be able to test everything.

And some assumptions about a product should hold true as well. E.g. the assumption should be that if I buy a desktop CPU today I should be able to use it for at least n years. Because how would you know this beforehand?

If Intel made an optimization that turns out to be a security flaw, that is totally their fault and they should cover it. This is nothing any consumer could have known (and rherefore avoided buying) beforehand. This is the cost of taking risks in business.

It seems to be a popular stance these days to shill for corporations and protect them from ever having their risks realized. But that makes the products and the world we live in worse for everybody and gives you nothing at all.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:20AM (#35760946)
> And some assumptions about a product should hold true as well. E.g. the assumption should be that if I buy a desktop CPU today I should be able to use it for at least n years. Because how would you know this beforehand?

You ask the manufacturer, duh? If they lie, that's fraud. If you don't like the answer, you don't buy.

> If Intel made an optimization that turns out to be a security flaw, that is totally their fault and they should cover it. This is nothing any consumer could have known (and therefore avoided buying) beforehand. This is the cost of taking risks in business.

Customers and suppliers should be able to allocate such risks between themselves however they like.

You can fiddle with what the default should be, in case they haven't negotiated anything.

But if both customer and supplier agree, the customer should be allowed to bear such a risk.

> It seems to be a popular stance these days to shill for corporations and protect them from ever having their risks realized.

Why? I have nothing against any particular allocation of the risks, as long as all involved parties agree. (Otherwise, they just don't make a deal.)

> Gotcha, so you are also against electrical regulations like requirements to use tested insulators etc?

If you claim they are tested, you better not lie. Otherwise it's fraud and you should be held liable.

If a customer wants to buy untested insulators, who am I to keep them?

I mean, in the most extreme case, a customer can buy bread and try to use it as an insulator, if they really want to. There's nothing the supplier can do about that.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dannyw on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:42AM (#35761332)
There is a huge difference between electrical safety regulations, and a side channel attack that has never been seen to be exploited in the wild.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by atoav on Sunday April 30, 2023 @08:43AM (#35762028)
If that sidechannel attack that has not been seen in the wild leads to me having to throw my CPU/computer into the bin because it is unsopported on a up to date OS for that reason, there isn't.

How should I, as a consumer, have voted against this with my wallet, before it happened?

We can argue whether this is the fault of the hardware manufacturer or the software company that sells the OS, but I am 100% sure that no consumer should take the blame for "not doing their research".

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:31AM (#35762892)
> How should I, as a consumer, have voted against this with my wallet, before it happened?

That's what long term reputation is for.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by atoav on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:40PM (#35765356)
* * *
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:31PM (#35768814)
Me!

I happily resell you Intel processors at a 10x markup but you get a ten year warranty that I'll replace your processor with a new one of no worse specs, if similar vulnerabilities get discovered.

Details to be negotiated.

(More seriously: you don't need a new manufacturer. Someone else can do the warranty at a price.

That's actually what eg Apple Care: if a part inside your device catches on fire, Apple will replace it, even though they did not necessarily manufacture that part.

I have no clue whether their particular policy covers the vulnerabilities we are talking about. But you can easily imagine a variant of such an insurance policy that does.)

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Gigachad on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:48AM (#35761364)
Having a warranty on CPUs wouldn't have saved the environment. It probably would have made things worse as every user returned their computers for a new one.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by contravariant on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:37AM (#35761638)
Protection against being sold a defective product is considered 'extensive warranty' now? You're free to argue that this isn't a big enough defect to make the transaction fraudulent, but don't try to argue you need to pay more money to get the most basic protection. I mean, if you're not even getting the most basic protection than what on earth are you paying taxes for?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by eru on Sunday April 30, 2023 @11:02AM (#35763164)
What do taxes have to do with anything here?

If someone promises you that the product will do something or eg 'not be defective', they should stick to that promise or face prosecution for fraud or false advertising or similar.

I pay my taxes to eg fund national defense or make sure that poor people get some welfare. I don't pay my taxes so that the government can decide how much warranty I need. (They do some of that anyway. But I'd rather they don't.)

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nearbuy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:42AM (#35760186)
"Defective" seems harsh here in that every product will always have issues of this degree no matter how hard one tries to make a perfect product. We're talking about a very subtle side channel attack. I promise you every computer system today still has some undiscovered side channel vulnerabilities. Meltdown-like vulnerabilities most likely existed since speculative execution was invented, likely decades before researchers discovered it. To my knowledge, Meltdown has never been exploited in the wild.

Lawmakers could make chip designers replace all the chips but,

1) that's not very environmental either

2) it would be pretty disastrous for everyone when Intel and AMD go under because they can't actually afford to replace every chip they had in existence at the time

3) assuming this was somehow done in a way they could afford, the costs for these replacements ultimately get passed on to customers. For replacements that were never necessary to begin with. It's just kind of wasteful.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by pgeorgi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:59AM (#35760268)
It seems defective and in need of replacement enough that Microsoft decided to not support these products in their operating system that would otherwise be well-enough supported by those chips.

Right now, that argument seems to be simultaneously "It's critical enough for Microsoft to explicitly deny running Windows 11 on it" and "It's not critical enough that Intel and AMD should do something about it, except to sell more stuff."

What kind of incentives does that create?

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Drakim on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:15AM (#35761507)
It's the "too big to fail" scenario all over again.

Just like with too big to fail companies and banks, only half of the equation is being applied:

CPU industry wants to start using risky design techniques to get an edge on the competition? Who are we to tell them no? it's a free market.

CPU industry can't afford to replace the defects that came about from their risky choices? They are too big and important to be held accountable.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nearbuy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:12PM (#35765089)
You're going to have to go back to the 1990s if you want to undo the "risky design technique" of speculative execution.

You're ignoring half the equation too here. There are benefits to having faster and more efficient computers for the past couple decades that could execute more instructions per clock cycle.

These vulnerabilities are subtle, hard to predict, and can take years or decades to discover. Anything that makes computers faster is a risky design technique. If you want safe chips, you'd better say goodbye to caches, multithreading, and hyperthreading as well. You'll be left with a slow, inefficient chip. Non-American companies that aren't forced to take zero risks would take over the market and be miles ahead.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nearbuy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:22PM (#35765200)
> Right now, that argument seems to be simultaneously "It's critical enough for Microsoft to explicitly deny running Windows 11 on it" and "It's not critical enough that Intel and AMD should do something about it, except to sell more stuff."

The first part of that isn't right. Microsoft decided it wasn't worth it for them to support 6 year old chips on their new OS. People with older hardware can continue to run Windows 10. The two operating systems are almost the same anyway.

Microsoft's decision is not an indicator that you're in much danger from Meltdown.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by RobotToaster on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:41AM (#35762976)
When the intel FDIV bug happened they were forced to recall the processors. I don't see why this should be any different.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nearbuy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:06PM (#35768402)
Intel voluntarily recalled the processors. The cost was about equivalent of $800M today, which is quite large, but nowhere near the cost of replacing every Meltdown-susceptible CPU. The FDIV recall probably didn't have any benefit for the majority of customers who used it.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by tinus_hn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:28AM (#35760664)
Specter and meltdown are part of a class of problems that exists in all processors Intel and AMD have in their lineup and the fixes are just papering over the published exploits.

These problems can’t be fixed without large sacrifices in performance, perhaps it’ll happen in specialized products but it hasn’t happened yet.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by pgeorgi on Monday May 01, 2023 @04:35AM (#35770349)
Intel/AMD Model N is affected and therefore banned for use with Windows 11.

As per your assertion (that I agree with, btw) Intel/AMD Model N+1 is affected (just slightly less so) and can be used with Windows 11.

So, either this is fixable, then it's on Intel/AMD to replace defective hardware (or offer a fix that is worth unlocking Windows 11 over, e.g. through microcode) or it's not fixable in which case, why prevent the older chips from running Windows 11 if they're in exactly the same situation?

Either way, Microsoft's decision seems arbitrary, and puts the onus on their customers instead of the culprits, the chip vendors, who even get rewarded by encouraging new sales!

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by tinus_hn on Monday May 01, 2023 @05:46AM (#35770751)
It’s the third option, the publicized issues have been solved.

The claim that this class of issues is the reason for Microsoft’s hardware requirements for Windows 11 is not mine.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by andai on Sunday April 30, 2023 @02:20AM (#35760109)
>they came with a price of a ~20% slowdown.

Would be nice if upgrading to a new version of Windows came with such a mild penalty!

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:53AM (#35760477)
It's a whole list of reasons, not just this. I was finally able to find the interview with David Weston that goes over all of the requirements:

https://www.techrepublic.com/article/windows-11-understandin...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by alerighi on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:51AM (#35761079)
Spectre and Meltdown are two vulnerabilities unlikely to affect the normal home usage of a computer. Are surely a concern for computers that are employed in companies or where you have to manage sensitive data, but surely for the desktop user is not a concern. We are talking of very elaborate attacks that are not something you find everyday. It's something to the level that a government agency could do, not the random attaccker that only wants to encrypt your data and ask you for a payment.

Beside that in most desktop settings is even useless, you don't even care about elevating privileges with a vulnerability, since most users work with the administrator account anyway (yes there is UAC to ask for privileges but let's face it, 99% of users always click yes because they are used like this).

I usually disable mitigations on my personal computers and I'm not concerned about it.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Gigachad on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:47AM (#35761355)
>Spectre and Meltdown are two vulnerabilities unlikely to affect the normal home usage of a computer.

It was found to be exploitable via a website in your browser. This would have been dire for any kind of user unless they literally only used the computer for gaming and did no web browsing.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by andylynch on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:20AM (#35761531)
I saw some big fights about Infra guys insisting on enabling their mitigations for every device, including the most latency sensitive ones running only in-house software.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by MikusR on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:57AM (#35761111)
Whiskey lake (8th gen) is affected by spectre/meltdown, but is is fully supported by Windows 11. There are also a couple 7th gen cpus supported, that by pure coincidence are the ones used, in at that time latest, surface studio. There are also many unsupported cpus that even with ~20% slowdown are twice as fast as the supported ones.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by temac on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:47AM (#35761357)
That was absolutely not the rational they provided. Which was more a meaningless thing like: we got telemetry measures that show that modern computers are faster and crash less, so we are randomly requiring them.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nstart on Sunday April 30, 2023 @07:30AM (#35761588)
Speculation: Windows 10 end of life's in 2025. It's entirely possible that by the time that year rolls around, they throw in some backwards compatibility with some asterisks around performance.

Right now, Microsoft is not officially supporting the older processors but Windows 11 runs on 7th gen intel processors without any real issues except that it's a little slower than how it would run with Windows 10. But no work stopping issues at all if you were to run it yourself. I believe Microsoft even has a published way to do it if I'm not mistaken. It's manual and a little messy for now, with some asterisks around risks for automated updates, but it works.

Given all of this and MS's outlook towards backward compatibility I can see them eventually allowing older generations to upgrade after agreeing to some risks/performance degradation.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by BirAdam on Sunday April 30, 2023 @10:08AM (#35762683)
Thank you for this info. I had no idea. Makes sense.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by usernew on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:54AM (#35759784)
They do not. What they do care about is making it less profitable for their competitors, by attacking in spaces they no longer compete.

They lost the phone business, they've just now pulled out of making mice and keyboards. Their MS Surface line is not something people buy - it's something companies buy, with a support contract. Since their consumer hardware business is gone, they now can at least use that to hurt companies that still have a consumer hardware business.

But for selfish reasons and anti-competitive self-interest, they are doing something good for us against a greater evil. It's pretty much the DePanties/Disney thing where we cheer for a large evil corporation.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by kenjackson on Sunday April 30, 2023 @08:20AM (#35761890)
This is the case for almost all companies. When something is in their best interest, but that interest aligned with yours then the company is good.

See Google. Do no evil was easy for them when their business model made that look easy. Once privacy became a big deal then they became evil. But really its just interests we’re no longer aligned.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by usernew on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:54PM (#35766538)
Oh of course, and there's nothing wrong with that. What is wrong is articles spinning anti-competitive scammy behavior, as "Microsoft is good now."
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by 1letterunixname on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:27AM (#35759898)
Not entirely surprising. It harms their frenemies and doesn't really hurt them because it's not a large fraction of their business (Xbox and Surface notwithstanding). If one can make things more expensive for other companies and win points with customers, it adds to brand goodwill. I don't believe it's entirely realpolitik and there were likely legitimately interested Microsoft personnel who wanted to push some sensible change.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nubinetwork on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:20AM (#35760344)
Strange that you complain about that, but not the massive hell that is repairing the Microsoft Surface.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:23AM (#35760352)
Strange? There are orders of magnitude more people with non-Surface machines than Surfaces.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by nubinetwork on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:31AM (#35761004)
So what? Surface is what Microsoft manufactures and sells...

If they were just an OS company, they can support whatever hardware legislation they want... but to sell a locked down turd on one hand while crying about openness with the other really takes the cake.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by isodev on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:45AM (#35760442)
Wouldn’t it be nice if a somewhat “positive” thing “leaks” just to give the people something to talk about? All that chatter about antitrust, sucking personal data without permission etc doesn’t give a very positive image. Right to repair on the other hand... oh that fixes everything.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by temac on Sunday April 30, 2023 @06:44AM (#35761341)
I doubt it was more about Intel than about themselves. Of course, the environment being the huge collateral damage.

They also make unreparable devices, so their pretend support has no weight.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by bwat48 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @08:10AM (#35761836)
The CPU requirements are because they wanted to enable virtualization based security by default and have it be performant.