News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:12PM (#35759139)
> just to make existing CPUs obsolete and keep Intel in business.

Bizarre take. It's not random, it's specifically CPUs that support modern hardware security mitigations.

There's a pretty great talk from Bluehat a few days ago that goes into why Microsoft is doing this:

https://youtu.be/8T6ClX-y2AE

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:16PM (#35759162)
See the last paragraph. At best it's half-plausible deniability. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/08/why-windows-11-has-s...
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:28PM (#35759213)
The last paragraph is a little strange as Microsoft explained its reasoning the day before:

https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2021/08/27/update-...

It only added 7th gen processors that have DCH driver support, which is the absolute minimum baseline for W11 support.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:38PM (#35759254)
I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs. [1] Surely there's no conflict of interest here.

Could you explain in what way "DCH driver support" is a "hardware security mitigation" as you wrote?

Moreover, doesn't basing this on "DCH driver support" basically let the hardware vendors decide which otherwise-capable CPUs they'd like to make obsolete through software updates?

And furthermore, note that the OS isn't even turning on the CPU features they require by default, as the article also mentions.

[1] https://forums.lenovo.com/t5/ThinkPad-T400-T500-and-newer-T-...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by coder543 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:14PM (#35759395)
> I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs. [1] Surely there's no conflict of interest here.

That statement seems misleading at best. According to Microsoft's page[0] on that processor, the Dell Precision 5520 is supported as well, which means this support is clearly not limited to Microsoft's own hardware.

Depending on how Lenovo configured the BIOS, it is entirely possible that they disabled certain features that Microsoft deemed critical later on with Windows 11. Vendors do plenty of weird things with BIOSes, which can have far reaching impacts on what an operating system is able to do with the hardware. Or Lenovo didn't provide a necessary driver, or whatever the actual problem was here. Dell managed to meet the requirements just fine, apparently.

Yes, obsoleting a bunch of hardware sucks, but your claim that this was to help Intel sell more chips is extremely dubious. Your claim that Microsoft isn't doing this for security reasons because they're exempting only their own hardware doesn't mesh with the reality of that Dell laptop. None of the evidence here supports some grand conspiracy here, as far as I can tell.

I also found a forum thread[1] where at least one person was struggling to update their Surface Studio 2 to Windows 11, so even that hardly seems cut and dry.

[0]: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/design/mi...

[1]: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/surface/forum/all/window...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#35759476)
Any responses to the other things I listed? Like how DCH driver packaging is a hardware security mitigation?

> Depending on BIOS settings, it is entirely possible

"Entirely possible" is quite a big umbrella that covers planned obsolescence quite well, too. It's not like using software to make hardware obsolete is lacking in historical precedent.

> There isn't some grand conspiracy here, as far as I can tell.

Well, it's "entirely possible", as far as I can tell. Though I'm not even claiming there is one - there isn't a particular need for a conspiracy here.

> I also found an entire forum thread[1] of people struggling to update a Surface Studio 2 to Windows 11, so even that hardly seems cut and dry.

All of those comments were posted in the span of the first 4 days Windows 11 was officially released. If you dig a bit more you see people have succeeded afterward. [1] So that was most likely just a bug on their side, which isn't surprising given their own device was an edge case they were trying to make an exception for.

[1] https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-11/windows-11...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by coder543 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:36PM (#35759486)
> Any responses to the other things I listed? Like how DCH driver packaging is a hardware security mitigation?

No, someone else responded to that. I was just here to look at a dubious claim and see what the evidence showed. If it had been supported by the evidence, it would have been scandalous, but it wasn’t. I’m not an expert in the Windows security model, so I don’t know anything about DCH drivers.

Regardless, I encourage you to re-read my comment, which I edited awhile ago, apparently while you were typing that out. I have made my points more directly.

No, your perspective is not supported by the evidence. There’s really nothing more for me to say here. I looked at your claims, and that doesn’t appear to be what happened. Dell being supported directly contradicts what you were claiming in the comment I responded to.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:24PM (#35759434)
> I find it quite interesting how they whitelisted their own Surface devices but not, say, Thinkpads, despite them having the same CPUs

Because Lenovo did not bother writing DCH drivers, given DCH drivers are the baseline requirement.

> Could you explain in what way "DCH driver support" is a "hardware security mitigation" as you wrote?

I was recalling a 2 year old blog post in my head, but the point is still that much of the requirement is around baseline security. If you watch the video I linked, the speaker does go over all of this.

> basically let hardware vendors decide which otherwise-capable CPUs they'd like to make obsolete through software updates?

I'm not sure what you're getting at. DCH drivers were already the default for current-gen hardware _before_ W11 even came out, W11 just made it a requirement. Vendors clearly aren't going to go write some greenfield drivers for a years-old 6th gen intel product just to support W11, as those devices will be 10 years old by the time W10 support ends.

> note that the OS isn't even turning on the CPU features they require by default

Note that you're still referencing a blog post from 2021. W11 22H2 enables core isolation by default for new installations, and HVCI is enabled by default when using the Windows Enterprise security baseline.

https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-security-ba...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:08AM (#35759618)
> If you watch the video I linked

I have in fact. It's a nice talk about security in Windows 11, but I haven't seen anything in it answering these issues. He says absolutely nothing about DCH and doesn't give any explanation for the minimum hardware requirements. The closest I recall was he was mentioned of integrating Pluton on chip and making its firmware directly updatable, but I don't believe for example that the 7820HQ and the 7700HQ are any different with regards to Pluton.

> I'm not sure what you're getting at. DCH drivers were already the default for current-gen hardware _before_ W11 even came out, W11 just made it a requirement.

No, they didn't even make DCH a requirement; Windows 11 runs with standard drivers too.[1] And, again, DCH doesn't imply anything about hardware security mitigations, which was purportedly their reason for this.

> Note that you're still referencing a blog post from 2021. W11 22H2 enables core isolation by default for new installations, and HVCI is enabled by default when using the Windows Enterprise security baseline.

Because the situation is fundamentally the same since 2021. Core isolation support is not a distinguishing feature between (say) the 7700HQ and 7820HQ, as far as I know. And the Windows Enterprise security baseline seems kind of irrelevant for the millions of average consumer devices out there. A company that cares about consumers or the environment is telling consumers across the planet to turn perfectly good devices into electronic trash now because they might add something that helps security years later?

I'm going to let my comments rest here; people draw their own conclusions.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Windows11/comments/pr4kmr/why_is_wi...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:01AM (#35759811)
> He says absolutely nothing about DCH and doesn't give any explanation for the minimum hardware requirements

The hardware security baseline is one of the first topics he covers as part of Windows 11 security strategy, with mention given to features that require hardware support and how they intend to enable these by default going forward as not doing so was a failure of the Windows 10 strategy. He even mentions "virtualization extensions" aka HVCI-related features which would be non-performant to enable by default in older hardware.

How exactly would a strategy of enabled-by-default work if the hardware wasn't there to support it? You seem to be looking for some hard "gotcha" statement to refute your argument instead of considering all of the information available in front of you.

> No, they didn't even make DCH a requirement;

By setting the minimium CPU requirement to systems that use DCH drivers, they effectively did.

> Core isolation support is not a distinguishing feature between (say) the 7700HQ and 7820HQ, as far as I know.

That's not the issue here. The 7700HQ lacks Trusted Execution support (aka TPM), whilst it's included in the 7820HQ, thus it does not meet the minimum requirements.

> electronic trash now because they might add something that helps security years later?

No, it's giving people the heads up that Windows 11 security strategy requires these features and gives people & companies time to adapt. For example, motherboards now ship with TPM 2.0 enabled by default, so as Windows 11 rolls out more features that require it (some aspects of Windows Hello already do), users aren't stuck with a system that needs a BIOS update or are unable to use the new features. Windows 12 will very likely make these requirements hard-enforced rather than soft-enforced and thus it'll make the 11-to-12 upgrade a smoother experience.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:06AM (#35760549)
Is it time to bring up the old "TPM is a good thing for you only if you're holding the keys - which almost nobody on the non-enterprise level is, so it's actually bad for you" discussion?

> How exactly would a strategy of enabled-by-default work if the hardware wasn't there to support it? You seem to be looking for some hard "gotcha" statement to refute your argument instead of considering all of the information available in front of you.

I'd say the core issue here is of priorities. Microsoft may be treating aggressive enabled-by-default approach to security as a good thing. A lot of other people don't. If you don't, then the high-level summary of the issue is, essentially, "By making some relatively recent hardware features a requirement for Win11 in the name of sekhurity, while also aggressively pushing users to upgrade and actively preventing them from continuing to use Win10, they're forcing people to destroy perfectly good machines for bullshit reasons".

I'm having hard time seeing fault in this view.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by ablob on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:17AM (#35760336)
DCH Drivers apparently consist of the following things [https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/drivers/d...]:

  Declarative: 
        Install the driver by using only declarative INF directives.
        Don't include co-installers or RegisterDll functions.
  Componentized:
        Edition-specific, OEM-specific, and optional customizations to the driver are separate from the base driver package. 
        As a result, the base driver, which provides only core device functionality, can be targeted, flighted, and serviced independently from the customizations.
  Hardware-support-app:
       Any user interface (UI) component associated with a Windows Driver must be packaged as a Hardware Support App (HSA) or preinstalled on the OEM device.
The D and C parts of the description appear to be what you're looking for here. No special hooks or modifications of the system paired with independent modules.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Hawxy on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:56AM (#35760499)
Just to follow up if anyone reads this far down, an interview with David Weston from Windows 11s release also validates what I've said in this comment chain:

https://www.techrepublic.com/article/windows-11-understandin...

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by WarOnPrivacy on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:40PM (#35759267)
> It only added 7th gen processors that have DCH driver support, which is the absolute minimum baseline for W11 support.

I'm typing this on a T430 with a i7-3632QM running Win 11. The stupid thing is I never wanted Win 11 on it. MS suckered me into a installing Windows 10 update version 22000 (just after ver 19043) which didn't mention anything about Win 11.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:10PM (#35759390)
>Windows 10 update ver 22000 (just after ver 19043) which didn't mention anything about Win 11.

That's because those are NT kernel version numbers, not Windows marketing version numbers.

Windows 10 and 11 both identify internally as NT10.0.X.Y where the X and Y are the specific build numbers.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Kwpolska on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:00AM (#35760520)
Windows updates aren't advertised by the build number, at least if you're using release versions (no idea about the insider program).
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by NayamAmarshe on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:15AM (#35760597)
No amount of reasoning is enough to justify that on consumer PCs, where the users don't know any better, TPM and other software side requirements were this necessary and not optional.

So suddenly, all the Windows 10 computers are insecure or what?

A normal person looking at "Windows 11 is not supported on your device" WILL think that their hardware is not good enough to run the authoritative OS.

This is less about security and more about planning a strategy to sell more devices. Anybody denying this possibility is just ignoring on purpose.

Here, I am not actually arguing against the addition of TPM or anything. I am arguing against them being a fixed requirement to run the OS that would otherwise run without any issues because it quite literally is a Windows 10 reskin, nothing more.

This is proven by the fact that they broke their own requirements on their own surface devices. Which tells me that this is less about them being serious about security and more about declaring most fairly recent hardware obsolete.

It's anti-consumer at best and deceitful attempt to sell more computers to non-tech folks at worst.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by MikusR on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:58AM (#35761120)
https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000...

"Intel® 6th Generation Core Processors or Newer Processors are supported by Windows DCH Drivers."

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dylan16807 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @10:20PM (#35759173)
It's a neat little mitigation but it's ridiculous to label it necessary for a consumer OS and obsolete hundreds of millions of computers.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by charcircuit on Sunday April 30, 2023 @12:25AM (#35759680)
It's pointless for a consumer OS unless most users support it. There will need to be a version that requires it sooner or later.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dylan16807 on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:25AM (#35759885)
Having most users support it is largely just a matter of time. Screwing over a ton of people people because you want to make "most" happen a year sooner is not a good thing. Tens of millions of people are going to be forced out of perfectly good hardware years before they would have normally switched. Or left without necessary patches.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:51AM (#35759989)
Intel Coffee Lake and AMD Zen+ came out around 2017/2018, that's 5 to 6 years ago. I'm not even getting into processors that precede them.

I'm well aware computing power for practical use cases has plateaued since around 2011, but those Coffee Lake and Zen+ systems (let alone older) are coming due for replacement/upgrade soon for anyone inside of a lifecycle cadence whether Windows 11 demanded it or not.

For anyone who isn't who cares about hanging on to old hardware, it's perfectly fine to just keep running Windows 10. All those guys saying "yOuR sYStEM iS iNSeCurE!!1!1!1" are snake oil merchants wanting to sell you something.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Sunday April 30, 2023 @03:48AM (#35760456)
> For anyone who isn't who cares about hanging on to old hardware, it's perfectly fine to just keep running Windows 10.

Increasingly hard to get this days, especially through official channels. Currently, Microsoft actively prevents you from getting a Win10 installer/image, by redirecting all the relevant links to Windows 11 pages.

> All those guys saying "yOuR sYStEM iS iNSeCurE!!1!1!1" are snake oil merchants wanting to sell you something.

You mean like Microsoft? Saying that the new system is more secure is equivalent to saying your old system is insecure, given everyone's insistence that you either are fully secured or not at all.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by herbstein on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:54AM (#35760808)
> Increasingly hard to get this days, especially through official channels. Currently, Microsoft actively prevents you from getting a Win10 installer/image, by redirecting all the relevant links to Windows 11 pages.

Really? I used this just a few weeks ago and definitely got a Windows 10 ISO.

https://www.microsoft.com/software-download/windows10ISO

For reference, I searched the following on Google

> windows 10 iso

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by TeMPOraL on Monday May 01, 2023 @02:38PM (#35777200)
For context then, some two-three weeks ago, I wanted to upgrade my wife's perfectly good Windows 7 to a Windows 10 (mostly because Chrome has been whining for the past half a year, but also because Spotify plain old denied to start playing music until we upgrade the OS). I went for the in-place upgrade path, which involves downloading a Win10 media creator tool from Microsoft. Links to various Windows 10-related information all redirect to Windows 11 landing pages now.

Additionally, I suspected I'll need a new product key. I couldn't get that from Microsoft - every link I've managed to Google also had a redirect to Windows 11.

(In the end, I purchased an electronic license from some local software shop. Then it turned out that somehow, Microsoft considers my wife's Win7 license still valid for Win10 Pro, which is nice. I used the key to upgrade another machine, which I thought was on Pro, but actually was on Home.)

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:33AM (#35760691)
> Intel Coffee Lake and AMD Zen+ came out around 2017/2018, that's 5 to 6 years ago.

You're (probably unintentionally) exaggerating, but that's not how it works. When a new CPU comes out, all the machines on the market don't magically replace their CPUs with that one on day 1. The machine I'm typing this comment on right now was a pretty high-end one I got after those CPUs came out, and its CPU is from an older generation. In fact, I don't even recall having seen machines with newer CPUs on the market (at least not with the minimum specs I was looking at) until quite a few months later, though my memory might be hazy here. Sometimes the price points are also a factor here too.

> those Coffee Lake and Zen+ systems (let alone older) are coming due for replacement/upgrade soon for anyone inside of a lifecycle cadence whether Windows 11 demanded it or not.

That's by no means universally true; there are plenty of good machines out there that work just fine and that people want to keep using. Again, speaking from personal experience, I know my machine is perfectly good and I hope to keep using it for several more years. An older one I had from several years before that, which I gave away for unrelated reasons, was also great, and I would still use it if I had it and my current one somehow broke. There's been literally no reason for me to throw these away anytime soon other than Microsoft forcing me to. Lots of people are being forced to throw away perfectly good hardware because Microsoft/Google/Apple/etc. force them to, often via software.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @04:50AM (#35760785)
I have a Sandy Bridge machine still serving me dutifully as a sub computer to my main computer, so I know all about old hardware never really dying from impracticality especially since 2011 onwards. Hell, I still have a Pentium 4 machine running XP for the stuff that needs/wants that too.

As I already said, if you want to keep running Windows 10 (or 7, or XP) it's perfectly fine. Tell everyone who screams "SECURITY!" at you to screw off, they all want to sell you something.

Even if you do upgrade to a new machine, why does someone have to throw away their old one? Keep it as a sub computer, or give it a new role in your life. Windows 11 mandates TPM2 and SecureBoot, but it doesn't mandate throwing your old machine in the trash.

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by dataflow on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:00AM (#35760835)
I think we're mostly in agreement (?) but (1) XP isn't really practical nowadays, and (2) as to "why does someone have to throw away their old one" - well you don't have to, but having your files haphazardly spread/duplicated across N machines is quite a pain for most people.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by Dalewyn on Sunday April 30, 2023 @05:12AM (#35760904)
>I think we're mostly in agreement

We are indeed!

Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by JamisonM on Sunday April 30, 2023 @01:42AM (#35759949)
Does making all those computers still run Windows 10 make them obsolete?
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by ryukafalz on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:43AM (#35762465)
When Windows 10 stops getting security patches in a few years, yes.
Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier... by JamisonM on Sunday April 30, 2023 @09:29PM (#35768220)
End of 2025 doesn't seem like too big an issue.