Re:Microsoft quietly supported legislation to make it easier...
by coder543 on Saturday April 29, 2023 @11:36PM
(#35759486)
> Any responses to the other things I listed? Like how DCH driver packaging is a hardware security mitigation?
No, someone else responded to that. I was just here to look at a dubious claim and see what the evidence showed. If it had been supported by the evidence, it would have been scandalous, but it wasn’t. I’m not an expert in the Windows security model, so I don’t know anything about DCH drivers.
Regardless, I encourage you to re-read my comment, which I edited awhile ago, apparently while you were typing that out. I have made my points more directly.
No, your perspective is not supported by the evidence. There’s really nothing more for me to say here. I looked at your claims, and that doesn’t appear to be what happened. Dell being supported directly contradicts what you were claiming in the comment I responded to.
> Depending on BIOS settings, it is entirely possible
"Entirely possible" is quite a big umbrella that covers planned obsolescence quite well, too. It's not like using software to make hardware obsolete is lacking in historical precedent.
> There isn't some grand conspiracy here, as far as I can tell.
Well, it's "entirely possible", as far as I can tell. Though I'm not even claiming there is one - there isn't a particular need for a conspiracy here.
> I also found an entire forum thread[1] of people struggling to update a Surface Studio 2 to Windows 11, so even that hardly seems cut and dry.
All of those comments were posted in the span of the first 4 days Windows 11 was officially released. If you dig a bit more you see people have succeeded afterward. [1] So that was most likely just a bug on their side, which isn't surprising given their own device was an edge case they were trying to make an exception for.
[1] https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/windows-11/windows-11...