News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Jenk on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:33AM (#35710911)
Netflix have really dissapointed me. I've been a subscriber since before streaming, and have even been content paying the subscription fee during the "breaks" of not using their service for up to months at a time because I so badly want(ed) them to succeed. I also understood the difficult situation they were facing when the producers of content were makkng ridiculous demands on their distribution, or worse, just pulling their content because they were opening their own service or some fuckhead like Murdoch threw money at them to keep an exclusive lock on it.

Their streaming model of watching on-demand (i.e., not a weekly release, here's the whole show to watch at your own pace) and their investment in shows that were not the usual low-brow trope-laden predictable shit meant I was actually excited when a new show was announced. My favourite TV-watching moments have been getting lost in shows like Narcos, The Ozarks, or even the seemingly polarising Orange Is The New Black.

Now I log in and see nothing but nostalgia tv, trash telly like Love Is Blind, or inexplicably 1/3 of my screen is listing mobile games that Netflix think I would be interested in.

.. and I'm genuinely concerned shows like The Diplomat are just going to leave us all hanging.

Meanwhile the other streaming services are at least as bad, but typically worse.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by rerx on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:31AM (#35711301)
Compared to competitors, Apple TV+ currently appear to put much more emphasis on quality over quantity in their original content. I really enjoyed some shows like Severance, For All Mankind, Trying, Acapulco, Foundation. It reminds me of the time when Netflix Originals stood for content to be excited about. What they don't have is a back catalog of licensed films and shows included with the flat rate offering (they all cost an extra fee).
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by circlefavshape on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:48AM (#35711398)
FWIW I thought Foundation was incredibly poor
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by MikusR on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:35AM (#35711647)
It's a weird example of the original material like Cleons being good while stuff from the books being incredibly bad.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by anotherhue on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @08:02AM (#35712339)
The acting talent is a factor here. Other than Harris, Pace is incredible. The rest of the cast? Disposable.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by rerx on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:53AM (#35711435)
The first season could have been better, but it has great production values and as far as I can tell they see it as an investment and they are not going to cancel it soon. So for now I'm optimistic about a second season.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by thaumasiotes on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:30PM (#35720877)
> The first season could have been better, but it has great production values

This thought process is how we got to the point where movies stopped having plots.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by rerx on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:18AM (#35727635)
Many shows have hit their strides in later seasons. IIRC I found Breaking Bad a bit boring in season one. (Granted, probably the writing was already better than season one of Foundation.)
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by polychrome28 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:51AM (#35711420)
It might not been great, but they didn't set out to produce a cheap and fast show.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by upon_drumhead on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:05AM (#35713835)
I really enjoyed foundation. I just had to let go of the book series and take it as a new universe and I’m really looking forward to what they do next.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jackmott42 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:25AM (#35715207)
I know some people are really irritated by how it differs from the book, but I really enjoyed it, especially "The Empire". I kinda want the bad guys to win, lol
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Gareth321 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:48PM (#35716615)
Lee Pace and his character arch carried that show. Everything else was terrible. I LOVED the books and felt personally affronted with how they butchered the content. These are some of the best science fiction books every written, and THIS was the best they could do with it? The only way they could have screwed up this badly is writing egos the size of Jupiter and zero oversight.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by regus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:14PM (#35716085)
I was not a fan of Foundation, however the Cleon story line was awesome, everything was really bad.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by lockhouse on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:55AM (#35711802)
Mythic Quest is hilarious as well.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by EvanKnowles on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:53AM (#35712239)
It improved suddenly in the third season, I was about to give up.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by lockhouse on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:23AM (#35714107)
My favorite were the quarantine episodes! Comedy gold.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by capableweb on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:20PM (#35717932)
I felt the opposite, two first seasons were great, last one not so great. Still a good show though.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by pjc50 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:15AM (#35713172)
I'm still amazed that a series sposored by Ubisoft can be such a sharp satire about the games industry.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by conradfr on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:10PM (#35716032)
First season is OK. Same for Ted Lasso.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by highwaylights on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:32PM (#35716346)
You can't please everybody.

Tried with Mythic Quest for two seasons and just couldn't stick with it.

Ted Lasso OTOH I'll watch as soon as a new episode pops up.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by philsnow on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:39PM (#35718880)
I skip most of the Ted Lasso scenes with Mr Gruff and lil' Ms SideBusiness. If you had told me back in season one that I'd prefer watching the scenes with Mr BoringHomeLife, I wouldn't have believed you.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by gandalfian on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:34AM (#35712067)
Severance, I turned the playback speed faster by 20% or something and it actually became much more pleasant to watch with wierdly no adverse effect?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by lotsofpulp on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:10AM (#35714907)
Severance’s story is good, but has a ton of garbage time, like many or most other streaming shows.

I just skip the middle few episodes and feel like I did not miss a beat.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by hinkley on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:11AM (#35714934)
I really wish YouTube allowed 1.10 playback speed. It’s just fast enough to save you some real time on long video series, but slow enough that you can still absorb difficult subjects. Even slow talkers become fast talkers on 1.25 speed.

1.10 is perfect for most audiobooks.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by alimbada on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:28AM (#35715280)
SmartTube (for Google/Android TV) used to allow this but a recent update has removed the other speed increments and it now only lets you use the usual increments you find on YouTube. :(
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by howinteresting on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:23AM (#35715172)
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by stronglikedan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:29AM (#35715302)
Only works with web based viewers, unfortunately.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by hombre_fatal on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:24AM (#35715195)
document.querySelector('video').playbackRate = 1.1
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by dsmmcken on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:54AM (#35715771)
I agree, I like 1.1 speed. The playback dropdown actually has a "custom" button in the top right of the dropdown on the desktop view of the site. You can set 1.05 and 1.1 playback speeds with it. It's a little annoying to use on mobile, as you have to switch to "desktop" view in the browser and can't use the app.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by hinkley on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:08PM (#35715996)
I watch a lot of YouTube from Apple TV so it’s a limiting factor.

Either on my real TV, or via input switching on one of my monitors when working on tedious tasks.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by LordDragonfang on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:49PM (#35716638)
Honest suggestion, try getting used to listening to things at faster speeds.

I started listening to podcasts at increasingly faster speeds, going from 1.1 to 1.2 and slowly increasing it. It only took a few days to a week of listening to slightly-too-fast-for-comfort content before it started sounding normal and I could bump it up again. Now the slowest I listen to is at 1.5 (going up to 1.6 or even 1.8 for my "filler" podcasts). Videos I can crank even higher, since the addition of visual content and/or subtitles can help process the audio information.

I now watch half my videos at 2x speed, and 1.25 or even 1.5 are how 1.1 used to seem for me.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by sleepytimetea on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:07PM (#35716916)
Do the ads also run at 2x ? ;-)
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by hinkley on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:27PM (#35721326)
So rather than using 1.10 - which doesn't exist - I should get to 1.25... by using 1.10 and ramping up?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:02PM (#35716859)
I watch most non action-focused YouTube videos and podcasts at 1.5-2x speed and I honestly don’t lose any comprehension at all with the speed bump
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by vikingerik on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:35PM (#35719593)
I use this Firefox extension to get 1.10 or 1.15 speed on Youtube: https://github.com/WaldiPL/playbackSpeed
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by yowzadave on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:53AM (#35713662)
Severance was great! I watched For All Mankind and Foundation, which both had great production values but were hurt by cheesy storytelling and sometimes iffy acting.

I'd love to see TV+ try something more experimental.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by upon_drumhead on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:06AM (#35713847)
They’re releasing their silo series from the dust books next week. I have relatively high hopes
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by indigodaddy on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:32AM (#35715355)
Really looking forward to this one..
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by greedo on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:13PM (#35717840)
Can you ELI5 this?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by upon_drumhead on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:39AM (#35724548)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silo_(series) (May have spoilers in the plot section) is being made into a tv series
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by tyingq on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:09AM (#35714885)
Interesting. I also like the Apple TV+ content, but my list is completely different. I liked BlackBird, Invasion, Slow Horses, Servant, and Tehran...and mostly didn't like the ones on your list.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by system16 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#35715030)
Apple TV+ has really surprised me. They've quickly become my favourite streaming platform, and somehow even got me interested in Major League Soccer (a sport I didn't even follow previously) enough to subscribe to their MLS Season Pass.

I really hope they don't fall into the Netflix habit of cancelling shows before they have time to find their groove (Mr. Corman was really creative and just getting good and got axed), and some of their dramas are starting to veer into the forgettable "Netflix Hallmark made for TV" territory.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by tonightstoast on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:23AM (#35715161)
Mr. Corman was tough to see cancelled but that show was hard to watch. It was scarily depressing and I while I think some people say they want a show like that, I don’t think it pulled the viewership numbers to keep it on air.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by system16 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:28AM (#35715270)
Very true. It also didn't help that the little promotion they did framed it as a comedy.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by dom96 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:17AM (#35715043)
Agreed. Apple TV in general has that feeling of quality. Another great one there that I'd highly recommend is Slow Horses.

I feel like I must mention though: as soon as For All Mankind decided to have a teenager seduce a grown married woman I lost interest. Then to top it off, they continued that plotline into the next season. What a shame.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by anonfunction on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:18AM (#35715050)
Watching on the Apple TV+ app on an Android TV it frequently replays the same episode I already watched or starts at some random time earlier in the episode than when I left off which is a pain to fix using their scrubbing feature which is itself a bad experience.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by 98codes on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:40AM (#35715497)
Same for Xbox & Windows -- the app is barely serviceable, and I figure that's by design from Apple.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by causi on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:42AM (#35715541)
Apple TV+ currently appear to put much more emphasis on quality over quantity in their original content.

Which is a win for literally everybody. The consumer wins because they get a very high amount of enjoyment for their invested time. The service wins because the less time each loyal subscriber spends actually using the service the less their bandwidth costs are.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by zerocrates on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:07PM (#35720018)
Apple has a few great shows but a pretty significant amount of junk too. I don't know that it's all that meaningfully different.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jerrydoughan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @10:36AM (#35714292)
Shameless plug: I’m the cofounder of SceneXtras, a Chrome extension that provides contextual info and answers common questions that arise while streaming like “Who is that character?”, “What song is playing?”, “What is the name of that place?”, “What is the backstory of that character?” and get instant answers from our GPT-powered chats with fictional characters directly.

When you're six episodes deep into that foreign political thriller and forgot who's screwing over who, we've got the character map to keep you in the loop.

We want to enhance our favourite stories, not compete with it. So SceneXtras works with whatever service you're streaming on, even if you're sharing accounts across Netflix, Hulu, and HBO. Think of us like a utility - makes your experience that much more immersive so you can get on with the important business of fandom!

We're working on adding new features like shoppable content from your favorite shows, voice interactions, and real-time notifications to help you keep up with complex storylines and not miss important details.

We're launching the beta and looking for a few good testers to put SceneXtras through its paces. We'd love feedback on the extension, if you are interested, join the waitlist while we scale: https://scenextras.com/

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by dpratt on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:10AM (#35714906)
This extension seems rather interesting, but I suspect you may have harmed your brand more than you helped it by making the above post.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jerrydoughan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:04PM (#35716881)
The opposite of love is not hate, it is indifference they say so I'll take that ha! Any suggestions on how to better approach these things? I'm like a fish out of water when it comes to branding, so would be happy to learn from anyone with constructive criticism. Thanks!
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by tyingq on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#35715033)
I see the plug doesn't seem to be going well, but it interesting to me that Amazon is the only service with something somewhat similar with Prime's X-ray. I know it's easier for them since they have IMDB, but I don't understand why I can't at least have a "Cast/Characters" popup in the other services. Even if it's just the whole cast and not contextual to the scene.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jerrydoughan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:31PM (#35719532)
You make a great point. X-ray is a prime example of the potential for extending and enhancing the viewing experience, even with something as simple as a persistent character/cast sidebar. Netflix has a version of this but as a separate site called tudum that feels more like a information dump. And Disney has disney extras which is primarily behind the scenes videos. I suspect it's harder for them to do in platform-agnostic way. Amazon has the benefit of IMDB as you noted, while Netflix, Hulu et al would have to build from scratch.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ciupicri on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:16AM (#35715026)
What nostalgia tv? A lot of 20 - 30 years old TV shows or movies aren't available on Netflix.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:05PM (#35716894)
Likely talking about shows like Fuller House that just feed off nostalgia and offer nothing new or entertaining
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by light_hue_1 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:22AM (#35715155)
> .. and I'm genuinely concerned shows like The Diplomat are just going to leave us all hanging.

This is why I don't pay for Netflix anymore. They cancel every show I enjoy. No other service treats their fans worse than Netflix.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by duxup on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:27AM (#35715250)
> trash telly

It's not just Netflix.

Disney+ has a bunch of National Geographic infotainment ... minus the info type shows.

HBO is going to end up with Discovery Channel ... stuff.

I want some way of telling them "I don't want to wade through crap..."

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by warent on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:31AM (#35715349)
> I want some way of telling them "I don't want to wade through crap..."

Yarr matey, one way do be not parting ways with coin for said services, instead making a more... equitable re-appropriation

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:47AM (#35715630)
I genuinely don't understand this sentiment in 2023. Maybe in 2003 it was reasonable, but if you have the money, just spend it to buy the content you want. I get that there's a lot of "crap" that you don't want to see, but I appreciate some of that, and I'm sure you appreciate some of what I call "crap". I don't see how you go from that situation to justifying not paying for it. There's a price for the content and it's not $0. You can either pay it, or enjoy free things. There's so much content out there.

Can you offer a full throated defense of why you feel it's okay to pirate media in 2023, with so many options for consuming media legally, on whatever device, at any time? That was the dream of pirates in 2003, but we've achieved that dream legally today and it's still not good enough for the pirates it seems.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by acuozzo on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:05PM (#35715961)
> Can you offer a full throated defense of why you feel it's okay to pirate media in 2023

-- NOT OP --

In the general case, no, but consider the cases of:

1. "Altered media" e.g. (1) Star Wars, (2) THX 1138.

2. "Remixed media" e.g. (1) Terminator 2 not having its theatrical CDS mix, (2) Earthquake not having its SENSURROUND mix

3. "Omitted media" e.g. (1) Halloween not having its original mono soundtrack, (2) The Exorcist not having its original mono soundtrack

4. "Missing media" e.g. (1) The Star Wars Holiday Special, (2) HBO's "Real Sex" documentary show

5. "Censored media" e.g. (1) Fantasia, (2) Song of the South

There are entire online communities dedicated to finding, restoring, and preserving items like the ones mentioned above.

So, is piracy OK in these cases? I emphatically believe it is.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by laserlight on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:33PM (#35716389)
6. Segregation. “Sorry, this content is not available in your region.”
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by themitigating on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:22PM (#35716210)
Why would it be ok in these cases?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by acuozzo on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:39PM (#35716469)
If art has value, then its form has value as well since art devoid of form is just communication which is no longer art.

If the form of art has value, then the original form of that art has at least as much value since it reflects the original intention of the artist which inherently has value by being part of the historical record.

If the original form of art has value, then there's value in preserving it for future generations to appreciate.

If there's value in preserving the original form of art, then there's value in distributing it widely since history has shown time and time again that copyright holders alone are not enough...

    1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1937_Fox_vault_fire

    2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1965_MGM_vault_fire

    3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Universal_Studios_fire

    4. https://www.bbc.co.uk/archive/bbc-archives--wiped-missing-and-lost/z4nkvk7

    5. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/the-steely-dan-songs-on-aja-that-cant-be-remixed/
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by laserlight on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:34PM (#35716403)
Why would it be not OK?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by toyg on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:31PM (#35716337)
For the same reason removing party figures from pictures with Stalin was Not OK. Historical preservation is important, if we care about truth.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:51PM (#35717541)
This is an argument for changing the law, not violating the law.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by sebzim4500 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:52PM (#35718322)
It's an argument for both
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @09:24PM (#35722113)
I think I'd need to see more to consider it an argument for violating the law. I'm all for civil disobedience if the cause it just enough. Preserving media seems like a good idea, but it doesn't seem like something we need to break the law to get passed. Also, the civil disobedience line is really undercut but posters (some in this thread) who broadcast their real reasons for pirating have nothing to do with ethics, but fulfilling individual wants and needs without remorse.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by acuozzo on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:37PM (#35720357)
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by doubled112 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:52AM (#35715719)
I don't pirate because I just can't be bothered. It's all too much work for a short temporary experience, but I do remember the promises.

Streaming was going to "save us" from the big cable companies. No ads, just pay that small subscription fee and watch what you want when you want it.

Now there are a dozen subscription fees, I'm getting ads anyway, and I'm not getting content I want to pay money for. Some are even streaming live TV now, with no way to watch what you just watched again.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:24PM (#35716253)
>I don't pirate because I just can't be bothered. It's all too much work for a short temporary experience, but I do remember the promises.

This is the opposite of my experience. It took next-to-no effort, maybe an hour or two one time, to set up my Synology NAS box with Plex, Sonarr and Radarr. The result isn't something temporary, it's a fully-working system that obtains all of the shows and movies I want to watch and drops them onto Plex almost immediately.

All I have to do is fire up Plex and the latest episodes of everything are right there, often within an hour of them airing on the east coast. I'm on the west coast, so this sometimes means I get to check them out before they air here.

The result is a carefully curated library that's far more tailored to my tastes than any algorithm has offered me on any service.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by doubled112 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:33PM (#35717309)
Easier than ever! And I have a home server to run it from.

It is just that I'm never going to consume it.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by wincy on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:20PM (#35716181)
I use Apple Shortcuts + VPN + seed box and the shortcut grabs the magnet link and hits my torrent boxes API. I shared the Shortcut with my wife and it has made pirating so dang convenient and easy we’ve filled up 20TB of space, whoops, time to delete some shows.

It’s also fantastic because I know -exactly- what my children are watching and if there’s some episode of Paw Patrol that’s particularly annoying it get deleted.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by oefrha on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:15PM (#35716109)
Pirating popular shows is actually pretty darn easy, and you get the benefit of watching it with your favorite player wherever you want to, not with the crap player they offer under scenarios they dictate. Want to watch an HBO show offline on a plane or train, no problem. I actually “pirate” some of stuff I pay for.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:22PM (#35717957)
> the benefit of watching it with your favorite player wherever you want to, not with the crap player they offer under scenarios they dictate

This is the part I don't get. Why do you feel you have this right?

FYIW, HBO Max allows you to download episodes for offline viewing, so it's not exactly true they are dictating the scenarios. I watch HBO all the time on plane rides.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:43PM (#35718206)
You seem to have missed the key line:

>I actually “pirate” some of stuff I pay for.

So, if someone pays for HBO Max and watches the latest episode of Barry at home via the app, but, as I do, feel that HBO's UI/UX is dogshit, and they then download a copy of it and slap it on their phone or laptop in a way that's more comfortable to them for their flight tomorrow, what's the difference? OP continues to pay HBO, but that next view is just on a local device.

Edit: HBO Max downloads "expire" after 30 days, and you have 48 hours to finish it once you've started[1]. You're also limited to 30 downloads at once. This is hardly 'convenient' for some people.

[1]https://help.hbomax.com/us/Answer/Detail/000001242

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by monetus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:02PM (#35721118)
I had a power outage recently, and everything I had downloaded but a children's movie had expired... This feature really got eaten by that policy.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Gareth321 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:51PM (#35716669)
I put far too much time into my server but now that it's up and running it requires zero input. I tell it what I want to watch and it serves it to me on a gold platter.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by geodel on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:03PM (#35715922)
Simplest answer is because one can. It is much safer to grab any digital content than physical goods. If it were easier like this to grab food from stores and restaurants, grab homes of other people, they would do that too. Its not even hypothetical, in many parts of the world this all happens very commonly.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by mynameisvlad on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:23PM (#35716227)
> Simplest answer is because one can

Sure.

> If it were easier like this to grab food from stores and restaurants, grab homes of other people, they would do that too.

You are implying that everyone pirating content would do these things if the chance of getting caught was low. I would posit that some people who pirate would, but it's a stretch to say that the entire group would.

Taking your simplest answer: just because one can does not mean one would.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by sebzim4500 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:54PM (#35718350)
For what it's worth, I am willing to pirate shows/software but would never steal physical goods even if there was a gurantee that I would get away with it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by gigel82 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:00PM (#35715876)
I bought and ripped the stuff we tend to rewatch a lot (The Office, Friends, Star Trek, Stargate, etc.) and am serving them from a local Plex instance.

I occasionally pirate episodes of TV shows that would require another subscription (already paying for Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, HBO and Prime). Honestly, I'd much rather cancel all that and just pay à la carte for content as long as it's something reasonable (like $0.50 - $1 / episode or ~ $10 / season and $2 - $15 / movie - that adds up to about the same cost based on my family's viewing patterns, plus I get flexibility).

It was nice when Netflix was the only game in town and it was worthwhile to pay it for the library, now it's too much to pay all these services for just a pile of 99% excrement.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:20PM (#35716176)
This, absolutely this, for my wife and I. Movies and shows that we love, we also download because it's often been inevitable that they get dropped from a streaming service at some point. Or, they're moved over to a new service (see: Peacock/Office) and we don't think that paying an additional monthly fee just to access that one show that we only occasionally watch is worth it.

Similarly, if the streaming service continues to play ads despite paying for the service, we will just pirate the content.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:26PM (#35718005)
> Similarly, if the streaming service continues to play ads despite paying for the service, we will just pirate the content.

Why though? Why don't you just watch some other content? There's so much out there, and you have so many choices, available without any ads, and also if you choose you can consume free content as well.

Given that you have these alternatives, why do you feel you have the right to nonetheless violate IP laws because you don't like that a subset of content carries ads or restrictions?

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:34PM (#35718095)
>Why though? Why don't you just watch some other content? There's so much out there, and you have so many choices, available without any ads, and also if you choose you can consume free content as well.

Because that content isn't this content, and I want to see this content.

>Given that you have these alternatives, why do you feel you have the right to nonetheless violate IP laws because you don't like that a subset of content carries ads or restrictions?

First, see above - that content isn't this content, so if there's not a suitable alternative, well, c'est la vie. I've demonstrated that I'm willing to pay for these things, albeit to a point. If the service goes beyond that point, and I still want the content, then I'll obtain it via other means. Besides, much of the specific content I'm referring to in this scenario rakes in massive profits every quarter and is doing quite well for itself regardless of whether or not I "violate IP laws" to obtain it. That's setting aside the fact that it's been shown that piracy doesn't harm sales[1]. Further, in spite of our pirating, we'll still often inject money back towards the IP via other means.

[1]https://gizmodo.com/the-eu-suppressed-a-300-page-study-that-...

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:54PM (#35719077)
> Because that content isn't this content, and I want to see this content.

I see. So is this your thought process?

1) I want it

2) I can't have it my way

3) So I take it, it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks

Is that fair, or no? I notice you offered some rationalizations for your behavior, but those doesn't really change the above calculus right? They are provided to justify it.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:20PM (#35719406)
2, fixed) We got to have it our way for a while, then more companies wanted a piece of the pie, and now we don't get to have it our way anymore.

They listened to consumers for a while. I stopped pirating for a good chunk of years because everything was glorious in the world of streaming. But after we finally got what we'd been asking for, they stopped giving that to us.

So, yeah, I'm going to go elsewhere to get it, your judgement be damned. I won't be losing sleep over it any time soon.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:05PM (#35720000)
I'm not really judging, you do you, but you are confirming my original thoughts as to the motivations behind pirating being rooted in selfishness. I'm very selfish myself so that's not a statement of judgement.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:17PM (#35722915)
Fair, dunno why I assumed as much. My bad!
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by gigel82 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:53PM (#35718339)
Good question; I can find gimmicks and talk about how I hate ads and whatnot, but really, it's because I don't assign the same value to an infinitely copy-able digital asset (which is confounding since I work in software).

I did a lot of pirating when I was a kid; I still do a little now (but a lot less), mostly out of frustration with the cost and availability of the content on streaming platforms. I wouldn't steal stuff from a store (because I know that causes actual material loss among other things), but making an additional copy of a TV show episode (which I wouldn't have bought anyway) - it's a philosophical question whether that causes a loss for someone.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:10PM (#35718534)
I'd also agree with this sentiment.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by FredPret on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:22PM (#35716209)
I do this. Buy DVD box set for ~one year of subscription fees, rip it all, store it in the cloud or on an external drive. Do this once for each show you like - probably less than a dozen. Legal, easy-ish, and I'm set for life.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by prepend on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:45PM (#35716572)
I use plex as an interface and it organizes my content in an easy to find and watch manner.

It’s the fewest clicks to see new content.

Comically I subscribe to many online services (Hulu, Netflix, apple+) and will end up discovering and watching new shows through plex and my rss feeds than the actual apps.

So pirating still gives me the best user interface. Especially with combining content from multiple services.

Also, it’s not just pirating. I ripped my couple hundred dvd collection years ago when kids kept breaking DVDs.

Comically, the cheapest way to watch most movies is to buy the dvd at Walmart for $4 and rip it to watch through Plex. The file never goes away and it skips the frustration of figuring out if Wolf of WalStreet is on Netflix, or Hulu, or HBO, some stupid one off streaming service that I’ll never use (peacock, paramount, whatever whatever).

So I think it’s the same reason in 2023 as it was in 2003.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:33PM (#35718080)
So piracy gives you the best UI. Sure. But why do you believe your need for the best UI is enough to clear the bar for ethics when it comes to violating other people's IP rights? Stealing food from the store is way more convenient than going through the line. Best UI there is for grocery shopping.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by prepend on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:21PM (#35718672)
Why do you think copyright it ethical?

I certainly wouldn’t steal food from a store as that deprives the store of food. That seems cut and dry.

If I could photograph food and turn it into food to feed myself, I would certainly do that, even if it was illegal. It doesn’t deprive the owner of anything.

There’s lots of injustice in the world. And I think IP leans more towards unjust than just. Do I think creators should be compensated? Yes. Do I think creators ancestors should be compensated for 90 years? Probably not.

I think copyright is designed and biased toward massive corporations to the detriment of society. So I don’t feel bad when I subscribe to HBONow and also “illegally” download torrents so it’s easier for loved ones to watch.

I also feel like there’s a giant PR effort from wealthy entities against a few individuals and the fact that you’d equate downloading a movie with stealing food is so weird to me that it shows how distorted the discussion is.

So we need some distinction between essential rights that seem real to me (bill of rights stuff) and “rights” that only exist because of successful lobbying on behalf of a very tiny industry (content industry is only like $100-200B globally where agriculture is $1.2T in the US alone).

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:31PM (#35723000)
> Why do you think copyright is ethical?

I think following the law is ethical, and copyright is not only the law, it follows directly from the Constitution.

> If I could photograph food and turn it into food to feed myself, I would certainly do that, even if it was illegal.

Context and perspective. We're talking about a media landscape that is flush with content, to the point where people complain that it's all just rehashed. There's plenty of media to go around.

> It doesn’t deprive the owner of anything.

It deprives someone of their rights, which is something I think pirates don't really care about at all, as it's never considered in the calculus. It's always "what's more convenient for me and my desires to consume particular media, rights be damned". I wish pirates would just be frank and admit this like the other poster who was replying to me.

> I think copyright is designed and biased toward massive corporations to the detriment of society.

Me too. But I also enjoy the rule of law and the hard work of people who make content that I consume.

> There’s lots of injustice in the world. And I think IP leans more towards unjust than just. Do I think creators should be compensated? Yes. Do I think creators’ descendents should be compensated for 90 years? Probably not.

I would feel more sympathetic to this argument if pirates had ever given an inch, or seriously attempted to organize to fix the law in the US over the past 20 years. Instead, they just kept pirating as hard as they could, even when the industry moved toward streaming services, and rationalized their behavior away.

> I also feel like there’s a giant PR effort from wealthy entities against a few individuals and the fact that you’d equate downloading a movie with stealing food is so weird to me that it shows how distorted the discussion is.

So you're saying my strong feelings about copyright infringement are due to a PR campaign, and not a carefully considered position I've come to on my own, through my own experiences as a content creator, artist, and owner of copyrighted works?

I understand that some people are so blasé about violating copyrights, they don't even think they could possibly be doing anything wrong. On the other end of the spectrum are people who have to spend money and resources to defend their rights from violations of law by others. I fully understand that digital media and physical goods are not the same. But I categorically reject that zero people are harmed when copyrights are violated.

> “rights” that only exist because of successful lobbying on behalf of a very tiny industry

As I said, copyright is a fundamental provision of the US Constitution. We can talk about the parameters of "securing for limited Times" but "exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." is not up for debate. The word "exclusive" is important here.

And as for the size of the industry interested in copyright... upending copyright would also upend trademarks and patents. There's a much larger industry (well... all of them) interested in those forms of IP.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by prepend on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:52AM (#35726141)
> I think following the law is ethical, and copyright is not only the law, it follows directly from the Constitution.

Copyright was 14 years at the time of the Constitution. If it was still that, I’d have no problem waiting it out and only watching material 14 years old.

Following laws isn’t always ethical. The constitution also allowed slavery. Do you think owning slaves was ethical? There’s lots of instances where laws are out of sync with ethics and morality, and, hopefully change over time.

In the past 20 years gay marriage became legal and I would argue it’s always ethical. Same for recreational drug use. And therapeutic mdma and ketamine. The list goes on and on.

Especially when the copyright laws aren’t the result of some specific debate and determination but by very targeted lobbying by Disney and others to extend copyright from 14 years to its current length of life+70 years or 95 years for corporate works.

Upending copyright would have nothing to do with trademarks (perpetual as long as in use) or patents (usually 20 years) and can be reformed completely independently. Although those other IP topics could also be improved.

I’m not making a judgement on your beliefs or how you formed them. I don’t know you. But there are PR campaigns to promote copyright targeted toward school kids (remember “don’t copy that floppy” [0] and “you wouldn’t steal a car” [1]) and I think they are in alignment with “copying a friend’s video is like stealing bread” so you just seem to be using simile analogies. It’s quite possible that you reached the analogy independently. It’s also possible that you aren’t aware of how you reached this analogy and are influenced by advertising and PR, just like everyone else.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_Copy_That_Floppy [1] https://youtu.be/ALZZx1xmAzg

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Thursday April 27, 2023 @09:18AM (#35727631)
Let's take a moment and recap this discussion. I put out a call for a "full throated" defense of pirating. In your reply, your full throated defense was that:

"pirating still gives me the best user interface"

To support this argument, you cited the various inconveniences you face when dealing with copyrighted works. Only after more prompting have you landed on a high-minded, ethical argument. Why didn't you argue this in the first place if you feel so strongly about these points? Why was your first foot forward an argument based on convenience?

Personally I pirated a ton back in the day due to convenience. Why did I stop? Because now I have money and it's all on my TV one click away. It's so convenient today compared to 2003, so that's why I don't understand why people who can afford it still pirate. I can understand why people without money would, but still... it's like $10 a month for all the music in the world, anytime, anywhere; whereas back then all you got was a CD for $10 that you could play in your crappy boom box or walkman. Spotify was my dream growing up, and now that it's a reality, the pirates still aren't satisfied.

> Do you think owning slaves was ethical?

I think you know the answer to this question.

> slavery... gay marriage.... medical drugs.... etc...

Everything you listed was changed due to robust and organized social movements to effect that change. Because the societal ills were so egregious, society mobilized to neutralize those.

If you want copyright to stand next to slavery, gay rights, and the drug wars as a worthy social cause, it's fine to make that argument. But you've got to back it up with a robust social movement centered around effecting change, not selfishly consuming.

When I look at the last 20 years of piracy, I don't see the same kind of movements. I see a lot of petulance disguised as civil disobedience (looking at the Pirate Bay), and a joke of a social movement (the Pirate Party), but other than that really nothing. Could it be because most of society doesn't really care about this issue the way they care about human rights? Maybe society recognizes piracy as the selfish act it is. I know that's not popular to say here on HN, but as a former pirate myself, I really can't justify my behavior any other way. I'm certainly not going to compare my actions to those of civil rights leaders and the movements they formed.

And if I did feel so strongly about the ethical nature of my actions, I wouldn't start by grounding my argument as "pirating still gives me the best user interface". Because if I did that, others would think that's what I really care about, and any ethical considerations would be secondary.

As I said to the other poster, I'm not judging you for this. It's okay to be unethical and selfish. I'm very unethical and selfish as a person (most people are), so it's okay if you are too. You can also be ethical and giving in other areas of our lives. Just be honest about your motivations like they were, and it's all good.

> Upending copyright would have nothing to do with trademarks (perpetual as long as in use) or patents (usually 20 years) and can be reformed completely independently. Although those other IP topics could also be improved.

My reply to you in this regard was in response to your assertion that copyright is not an "essential right", but instead a "right" only due to successful lobbying. My point was that this right is grounded in the Constitution itself, and no corporations today lobbied for that.

It's true that rights holders have broader protections today, and as a rights holder, I appreciate that. But as a citizen, I also recognize that the term should be much shorter, and we can indeed reform the whole system. But I wouldn't go back to the drawing board, because that requires a rewrite of the Constitution. As long as it's in the Constitution, rights holders will have representation to make sure our interests are protected.

> I think they are in alignment with “copying a friend’s video is like stealing bread” so you just seem to be using simile analogies.

I think what's actually happened here is that you've internalized these more than I have, and are jumping to conclusions. Because I didn't argue what you quote there, so let's go back and look at what I actually said instead of paraphrasing.

"Stealing food from the store is way more convenient than going through the line. Best UI there is for grocery shopping."

I was not saying that that copying data deprives someone of property; it was that convenience is not an excuse for violating the law. I made no argument regarding deprivation of property. Stealing food and violating copyright are both illegal. I'm not saying they are both stealing, as was the argument when I was growing up. It doesn't matter that one is physical and one is digital. You are free to make the argument that the acts are different and therefore one should not be illegal, or the punishment should be different, but that's not what I'm arguing. I'm arguing that both are de jure illegal, and the convenience argument doesn't make one better than the other.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by prepend on Thursday April 27, 2023 @03:13PM (#35733144)
> Everything you listed was changed due to robust and organized social movements to effect that change. Because the societal ills were so egregious, society mobilized to neutralize those.

People had illegal gay sex for centuries before society mobilized. So it was the groundswell of “unethical” activity that eventually led to social movement. Same for drugs and whatnot.

I think the societal change for legalizing what I think is ethical (and what billions of people think is ethical enough to do despite laws) will come about after many years of people just not caring and doing what’s convenient.

The convenient argument is just the most straightforward and I think why people continue to pirate. So that answers your question. All the other parts are going into additional detail that you requested.

It’s like if you asked someone why they illegally smoked pot 40 years ago they’d likely say “because I like to get high.” That doesn’t mean that there aren’t deep reasons why, just that that is the most important one.

Obviously legalizing pot cost corporations lots of lost revenue. And modernizing copyright will cost corporations lots of lost revenue as well.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Lio on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:24PM (#35720226)
The grand parent didn't say anything about selling or returning the DVD for a refund, so how is shifting formats to something more durable piracy?

If it's just a backup I can't see any ethical reason why you shouldn't be able to do this.

We went through all this in the courts when we got the rights to timeshift recorded TV programmes.

Comparing it to stealing food is ridiculous. No body has been deprived of anything, it's just copyright violation.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:09PM (#35722866)
> No body has been deprived of anything, it's just copyright violation.

The second part of your sentence doesn't follow from the first. If someone is violating a copyright, that someone else has been deprived of their rights to control their IP, and they're owed compensation. That's the system we set up, so that's the system we should follow.

If a rights holder wants to grant you the privilege of copying the data, that's great. Many of them actually do that. But that doesn't mean we're allowed to just violate the rights of those who choose otherwise. The response should be to consume media that is offered in favorable terms, not to pirate media just because you feel it's convenient.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Lio on Thursday April 27, 2023 @02:42AM (#35724144)
The system we set up includes fair use. Backing up media is fair use.

Again, no one has been deprived of their rights and the copyright holder’s rights are not unlimited.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ModernMech on Thursday April 27, 2023 @06:51AM (#35726128)
Granted fair use is a thing, and rights aren’t unlimited. I’m not arguing against fair use, but many here advocating piracy are not arguing from a fair use perspective. Or are you trying to argue that all piracy is fair use? That would be a more interesting argument than pointing at the existence of fair use, not that I would agree with it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by duxup on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:50AM (#35715682)
I'd rather encourage better options with my money than pirate.

Granted there aren't many / any.

I do donate to my local PBS station ... the content they provide is pretty dang good.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by dublinben on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:16PM (#35716123)
The Criterion Collection now offers a streaming service, which consists mostly of what would be considered "better options" than the typical mainstream chaff.

https://www.criterionchannel.com/

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by duxup on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#35716485)
TY, that's very interesting.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by nluken on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:00PM (#35717658)
Check out Mubi, or your local library's Kanopy account if they have one. Lots of great art films on both services.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by SoftTalker on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:01PM (#35715893)
I agree. I haven't watched anything on Netflix since 2019. Don't have D+, Hulu, HBO, or anything else. I have YouTube TV which I use pretty much only for sports.

Pretty much all the other video I watch is independent content on YouTube. Just people talking about and showing stuff they are interested in. I'm sort of amused that these people come up with more compelling stuff to watch than the big studios with their huge budgets, writers, celebrities, etc.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by themitigating on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:24PM (#35716246)
I'm not sure what the huge problem of wading through things you don't like. I don't like 90% of what Spotify has on it, so what? I just don't click it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by rchaud on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:56PM (#35716743)
> I want some way of telling them "I don't want to wade through crap..."

Welcome to the infinity pool. Spotify playlists, Youtube search results, your Twitter and Facebook feed....they're all bottomless for a reason.

Netflix isn't going to be any different.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by brucethemoose2 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:35AM (#35715425)
Use Reelgood or justwatch to search, and you can still find good stuff.

Netflix may have a quality problem, but another one (and a much easier one to fix) is their stupid recommendation algorithm. It shows me nothing but trash and genres (like Love is Blind) I absolutely dont want to see, while I have to use a 3rd party service to dig for gems.

I cant help but wonder if thats skewing their own metrics. People are going to watch trash if thats all they present.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by scantron4 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:42PM (#35716524)
Justwatch refuses to show me multi channel searches without amc+, for some reason. Either a really annoying advertising plot or a glitch with my account.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by christkv on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:39AM (#35715477)
Search for Korean made tv and movies. A ton of brilliant content coming out. Kingdom and D.P to name only two.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by mikeryan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:50AM (#35715694)
When Reed Hasting left and Ted Sarandos took over he had a bit of power shakeup and handed over the content reins to Bela Bajaria - who was brought in to head up international over Cindy Holland who was in charge of US content. Holland had brought in House of Cards, Orange Is the New Black, Stranger Things, The Crown, Ozark and Narcos.

Holland seemed to focus more on developing fewer shows of higher quality content while Bajaria was more focused on "get all the content, throw it all at the wall and see what sticks" (who saw "Squid Games" coming?). It also aligns, however, with a timeframe of the launch of the studios having their own top tier services such as Disney+, Peacock and even the new HBOMax (MAX now) all of whom are more tightly holding the streaming rights to the studios to which they're associated.

This for me aligned with when Netflix started going downhill. I have to say some of their newer content seems better but I'm not sure where its going to go. Right now HBOMax and Apple seem to be the most consistent for fewer, higher quality shows which also more closely aligns with my viewing habits. Netflix we keep mostly for my daughter these days and the few random hits that come through on Netflix.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by whinenot on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:11PM (#35716044)
“I wonder if, say, a bonobo throwing shit at a whiteboard full of titles as a method of deciding what projects to make would have more or less success than all of these other ‘deciders’ who think they know what people want or don’t want.”[0]

[0] https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/business/digital/netflixs-...

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:19PM (#35716169)
Why is Netflix not following short high quality 1-3 min videos model which is popular with young crowd? They already have Fast laughs tab which mimics that.

Youtube / Creative studios could pitch 1-3 min video ideas which Netflix could greenlight and provide just bare minimum capital to produce. If the final film is good, Netflix could buy the film and release on their platform.

Current Trends which are in favour of above idea:

1] Story generation will get cheaper thanks to ChatGPT.

2] Film generation will get cheaper thanks to Stable Diffusion.

3] Short video formats are already very good, engaging.

4] RunwayML and so on.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Miraste on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:32PM (#35716343)
The pitch/studio model does not work for short content, and it never will. It's too slow-moving and corporate. The videos that succeed in this format are zeitgeist, flash-in-the-pan trends that are faster to produce and more dynamic than even the laziest reality show. The production value doesn't really matter--if anything it's a downside past a point.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:38PM (#35716467)
Odd1sOut (Youtube Creator) has a animation series on Netflix. So in some sense, Netflix is already doing it. They just have to create a marketplace for this.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by nerpderp82 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:43PM (#35716542)
That is why you would need to fund creative teams and not specific projects. Those teams would make the zeitgeist shorts.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:06PM (#35716913)
If hackathons in software work and produce good product ideas, why can't the same be possible in creative fields? Cutaways in Family Guy are already short jokes which are shared without broader context on social media and they are popular. Netflix can always A/B test newly introduced content to determine engagement. Already built up cultural context (e.g. idea of multiverse, matrix and so on)need not be re-introduced from scratch, so no need to spend screen time on them.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by themitigating on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:21PM (#35716199)
Wasn't this what Quibi tried?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:36PM (#35716433)
Not sure why Quibi failed. Maybe trying to get distribution/tech and content right at the same time didn't work for them. Netflix doesn't have distribution problem, just content and it should try to iterate on what works.

Personally, there are so many short stories (e.g. by Greg Egan, Borges, others[0]) which I would like it to reach mass audience. Rights are tricky issue though.

https://qntm.org/responsibilit [0]

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by nerpderp82 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:42PM (#35716522)
Quibi failed because they over capitalized it and then pulled out when it didn't have the xxM DAUs. They basically launched and had an amazing journey in the same month.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Miraste on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:11PM (#35716989)
To be fair to the backers (such winning personalities as Jeffrey Katzenberg and Meg Whitman, ugh), it wasn't a case of 1M DAUs when they wanted 5M. It was more like 5k DAUs when they wanted 5M. The idea was dead on arrival, no amount of money and effort would've saved it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by mikeryan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:15PM (#35717030)
Quibi was interesting - the more I think about it (I work in this space) the more I think they actually might have had something.

The reason they failed is mostly because they went too big too fast. They spent almost a billion dollars in content at launch and expected to get a ton of people subscribed quickly at $8 a pop. Had a bit of a chicken and egg situation there. They needed enough quality content to justify that amount per month. But it was all new, untested content. When they didn't get the subscribers they had pretty much zero runway to ride it out and iterate.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by SoftTalker on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:08PM (#35716942)
Re. (1), not even slightly interested in spending time watching/reading a story written by ChatGPT.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:29PM (#35717243)
Here's a good first draft of the short story I generated.

https://pastebin.com/pDaJXHuC

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by erehweb on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:59PM (#35717642)
This is interesting, but mostly due to the prompt you gave.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by passion__desire on Friday April 28, 2023 @01:10PM (#35744171)
Here's another short story which GPT-4 churned out.

https://pastebin.com/vyThZkvR

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jorvi on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:32PM (#35716352)
Netflix it’s power is innovation. Think Bandersnatch.

I assume they’re going to be (one of) the first with an AI-assisted or even completely generated show that is completely tuned to your taste.

I expect the same to happen with games, with the wildcard of multiplayer. Music probably earlier than movies / series and games even.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:14PM (#35717022)
>Netflix it's power is innovation. Think Bandersnatch.

A one-off thing from 5 years ago that hasn't been replicated since and nobody really cares about now?

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jorvi on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:45PM (#35717458)
I mean, that is exactly my point.

I’m not saying HBO or Apple TV+ (what a name..) couldn’t do it, just that they seem much less poised to.

Funny how saying Bandersnatch was innovative gets HN absolutely livid.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jjulius on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:25PM (#35718000)
>Funny how saying Bandersnatch was innovative gets HN absolutely livid.

... huh? I didn't say Bandersnatch wasn't innovative and my feathers are far from ruffled. I just don't see how citing one thing from five years ago that no other streamer, nor Netflix themselves, have replicated since (correct me if I'm wrong) is a strong is example of Netflix being "innovative".

I'd argue that other streaming providers would've explored this sort of thing already if they felt there was enough interest. Anecdotally, I'm in multiple communities that involve the discussion of film and television and people just aren't asking for that sort of thing.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jorvi on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:34PM (#35718097)
Not you, the larger community.

My original comment was at -3 when I said that.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by silisili on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:07PM (#35717749)
Bandersnatch was a silly gimmick, not innovation. Sierra was doing stuff like that in the 90s.

Choose your own adventure TV may be for some, but I hate it. I want to be told a story, not just pick how I want things to go.

Besides, that or AI genned to taste would remove the social aspect. I love discussing shows, movies, etc with friends. That gets hard to impossible in this model...

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jerf on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:49PM (#35716628)
"Holland seemed to focus more on developing fewer shows of higher quality content while Bajaria was more focused on "get all the content, throw it all at the wall and see what sticks" (who saw "Squid Games" coming?)."

I think the root problem is that no studio anywhere is large enough to put out enough high-quality content to keep the people engaged continuously. Not even Disney.

All the studios were looking over at Netflix making all the money and wanted to disintermediate the middleman, but the combination of all of them doing that turn one fairly decent (not perfect, but decent) streaming service into an array of streaming services each individually not worth the subscription. That worked for a bit but it's wearing out.

The solution of just pumping out more is the obvious one to try, but it hasn't been going well.

I'm... actually not convinced that's impossible? The bottleneck on these seems to be quality writing. Generally the actors act, the editors edit, the directors direct, the effects crew broadly succeeds at the effects, etc. But Hollywood in 2023 seems to have negative respect for writing. Take any Writing 101 course, and if you want to write for Hollywood, completely throw it out the window because they do not care in the slightest about any of that. I recognize of course that any 101 course is only the intro and the basics, but current Hollywood writing is not taking the rules, deeply understanding them, and then transcending them by virtue of the deep mastery of their craft... they're just plain writing for crap. They've got a ton of other priorities and "good writing" is so far down the list that it might as well not be on there.

You can't get the best of the best to write for 100% of every season, but a lot of streaming stuff is several cuts below what middle-of-the-line episodic television shows were managing in the 90s in really, really basic stuff. Surely there's enough competent writers to at least get a solid C on the writing front to let all the other factors carry over to "at least worthwhile", if Hollywood would just raise the priority on that quite a bit more.

Tons of high quality content is probably not on the table for anyone, but surely with all these resources we could scrape together some medium quality content more consistently?

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by muffinman26 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:28PM (#35717216)
Bringing up episodic television shows in the 90s brings up an interesting point. For 90s episodic television, script submissions were open to the public. Each show still had a team of staff writers like they do today, but the staff writers would mostly write the really important episodes (like finales and two-parters). The bulk of the episodes would be freelance scripts, with the staff writers editing for consistency and adding an extra scene or two to hint at continuing plot threads. In today's binge-able format, almost every episode is written by the staff writers. (They might still let someone with connections, like an actor on the show looking to make a career change, submit an episode.)

Sure, 90+% of submitted episode pitches were probably terrible, but that was fine because show runners could choose the best episodes from the slush heap. Now each series only orders roughly as many episode scripts as a season has episodes. If a writer has a 75-80% hit rate, the show can't discard the bad episodes.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by MichaelDickens on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:44PM (#35717445)
> The bulk of the episodes would be freelance scripts, with the staff writers editing for consistency and adding an extra scene or two to hint at continuing plot threads

Can you name a few shows that were written that way? I'd never heard of this but I don't watch much TV from before the 2000's.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by muffinman26 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:31PM (#35718070)
I know that at least Star Trek: The Next Generation and the Golden Girls accepted freelance scripts. You can sometimes find the submission guidelines for Star Trek: The Next Generation on fan sites. You can also tell if this is the case for a show by looking at the writers. If there are lots of writers who only wrote one or two episodes, the show probably took submissions.

All the old books about television script writing I've read are about submitting in this way, but by the time I was actually considering it episodic television was rapidly dying out.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by CitrusFruits on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:11PM (#35717813)
I worked with a copy writer that had written an episode of "Star Trek: The Next Generation." By coincidence she had submitted an a script for an episode that coincided with a major plot point they were working to (a character leaving). I asked her about it, and it was really the only major writing credit she ever got.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by whartung on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:09PM (#35717782)
I know Star Trek: The Next Generation did this. They also did it with Deep Space 9. Not sure about Voyager.

I don't know what other shows might have done this.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by r00fus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:32PM (#35717291)
>but the combination of all of them doing that turn one fairly decent (not perfect, but decent) streaming service into an array of streaming services each individually not worth the subscription.

And thus we're back at "cable rates" but pick your poison.

The response should be "cancel services when you don't need them" but it's tougher if you have a family with young kids who you let watch.

I really liked paying CBS/Paramount for a single month so my kids could binge Korra (sequel to Avatar: the Last Airbender) back when Netflix released A:tLA first. We literally watched nothing else on the service.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by bmelton on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:06PM (#35717739)
A friend of mine just does one service at a time, and it's low-key fairly brilliant. There's a bit of headache with installing / uninstalling apps on televisions and having to log into things once a month or quarter or however long it takes him, but the kernel of the idea is that there are generally only a few new, good shows worth watching for any given network, but all the good shows are roughly equally distributed between networks.

So instead of paying $10 a month to Disney for Mandalorian, Wandavision, Loki, an additional $10 for Peacock for Mrs. Davis, Bel Air, and Poker Face, plus however much else for HBOMax, Netflix, Hulu, etc., he could just pay one network $10 a month, binge the couple of good shows that they had, and then instead of waiting months for the next thing to come out, unsubscribe and switch to another network. Lather, rinse, repeat.

He isn't as current, and sometimes it's hard to chat about whatever the current new thing is, but society has effectively already given up on the concept of the whole nation tuning in to any one thing and it being the topic of watercooler conversations for a myriad of reasons.

Note: He has children, and I have no idea how he handles this other than to note that he also has a digital antenna, so some shows are "always available" (or at least as much as is allowed for)

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:24PM (#35717988)
This is why all the streaming services are constantly trying to hype up their one "must watch" show. If you aren't watching it now, you're left out of the conversation, and nobody will want to talk about it in three months.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by bmelton on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:39PM (#35718153)
Are they though? Netflix in particular is famously bad at actually promoting their hot new stuff. I suppose they may do it more on-platform and just assume it's enough, but it seems like (and this is just from my memory, which is maybe wrong) that the ads for streaming services generally fall into the "look at all this stuff we have and maybe I won't even tell you what show I'm giving you a clip of right now" kinds of commercials.

I practically never see an ad for a particular new show -- tho in addition to memory faults there is also of course selection bias here.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by r00fus on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:40PM (#35720395)
I suspect what Amazon did with wheel of time and rings of power to be a less brutal method: weekly episode release. Disney does this too.

If they have enough “must-watch” shows that are staggered then you lose out unless you’re paying constantly.

It’s what they want: gets them som earned media/socialmedia hype, and prevents the binge+drop discount watching approach.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by bigger_cheese on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:53PM (#35721509)
I think the release cadence can be a double edged sword for viewer retention.

Certainly with Wheel of Time I felt that there was a few weak\boring episodes in a row and I hit the point where I dropped it, for me wasn't worth waiting a full week to see if quality of subsequent episodes improved.

If there had of been a buffer of episodes available I could probably power through the bad episodes until the show picked up again but with weekly release cadence it just caused me to give up on it.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by philsnow on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:15PM (#35718607)
I wonder whether some of the media streaming companies are going to try to use the sports streaming playbook, where you get penalized for canceling and then resubcribing within <12 months.

Those penalties could be "we just won't let you sign up" or "oh you don't get the promotional rate then, your rate for Netflix will be $44.95/mo for the next 11 months".

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by pierat on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:45PM (#35721448)
This is why I set up Jellyfin on my server.

I wanted a smattering from like 10 different services. No I'm not paying 120$ a month. So I pirated every last bit.

Turns out friends also wanted to watch them so I made my JF instance available via cloudflare. And now I get requests of shows, the arrs parses the request, downloads, and just shows up.

The services had their chance. They failed us. We came with alternatives. Until their offerings are better, we see no reason to change.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by justinclift on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:11PM (#35716981)
One of my friends is a writer, and his take on the problem is that the seasoned writers Netflix used to have (a few years ago) are now all getting fairly "old". Aka around their 50's.

So, they were let go, and a new generation of young, unseasoned writers has been doing the writing.

But unlike previous generations though (heh), many of them are not even slightly interested in learning from the previous (seasoned) writers, whom they view as inferior for some reason.

Thus, the extremely low quality (idiot level) of writing in recent years.

No idea how accurate that is, but it seems like a reasonable take at first glance.

Mind you, I don't really watch US origin tv/movies any more myself due to their crappiness. :)

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by FourHand451 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:40PM (#35717404)
Certainly I would agree that letting go a lot of experience folks would have an effect on the product.

However, I think this comment could use some more justification:

> But unlike previous generations though (heh), many of them are not even slightly interested in learning from the previous (seasoned) writers, whom they view as inferior for some reason.

Claiming that a particular generation is really different from another in this sort of way is something I'd need to see a lot of evidence to be convinced of. Kids trying to do their own thing and middle aged folks lamenting "kids these days" is a tale as old as time.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by justinclift on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:15PM (#35717870)
Thus the "(heh)" in my post. I recognise the same thing, and found it ironic.

> Kids trying to do their own thing and middle aged folks lamenting "kids these days" is a tale as old as time.

Yeah, agreed. From my point of view, it's not totally the new writers fault.

It's the fault of the management chain that got rid of the old writers and also didn't tell the new ones "Look, just humour the old fogies for a while, you might learn something...".

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jerf on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:24PM (#35720822)
The old have always considered the young vacuous and short on wisdom.

It has not always been the case that the young were raised on a steady diet of everyone older then them being stupid and evil.

For reasons that aren't all that hard to come up with if you think about them with a clear mind, this is not a long-term stable scenario for a society. You certainly can't have dozens of generations in a row in a high-tech society thinking that.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by hooverd on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:30PM (#35717256)
I wonder if some of that is TV writers growing up on ubiquitous TV writing, like how anime is increasingly made by people who just like anime and weren't as interested in a wide variety of media as the older generation.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by bmelton on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:00PM (#35717659)
Barely on-topic, but this is sort of the plot of Reboot, and I remember watching this show seeing the dynamic between the elder writer played by Paul Reiser) and the much younger writer played by Rachel Bloom.

The gist of the (relevant) bit of plot is that the younger writer wants to take an old classic series (ala Full House) but do a gritty reboot of it, but the studio brings in the original writers on to help, and there is unsurprisingly a culture clash.

I remember thinking (of the younger generation) how sad it was that they were so eager to dismiss all the experience of the elders, and how glad I was that this was just a TV show and probably not at all what was happening in the real world. I was safe in that ignorance right up until I read your comment.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by justinclift on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:19PM (#35717927)
> I was safe in that ignorance right up until I read your comment.

Oops, sorry. ;)

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by thewebcount on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:33PM (#35720300)
This was a great show I can't say enough about. It really mad me laugh out loud far more than any other show in recent memory. (And in the end, if I recall, both groups of writers learned that the other was actually pretty decent at their jobs and had a lot of good ideas.) Unfortunately, it didn't do spectacularly in the ratings and was immediately canceled. I seriously hope someone else picks it up, but I don't know how likely that is.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by autoexec on Friday April 28, 2023 @09:45PM (#35749199)
I've never seen the show but it sounds good and reviews were decent. Given that it was killed off after one season, is it still worth the watch? Does it end well?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by thewebcount on Monday May 01, 2023 @06:43PM (#35780293)
I think it's worth it, but I just like watching TV. It ends with a sort-of cliffhanger (a relationship cliffhanger), but it's not a surprising one.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @04:51PM (#35719826)
> No idea how accurate that is, but it seems like a reasonable take at first glance.

I mean that's what every generation of skilled workers has always said about the generation following them, so I'd take it with a grain of salt.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by svachalek on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:21PM (#35717137)
I really felt this when I was watching Andor. It's about a bunch of nobodies in the Star Wars universe, no Jedi at all. But there were so many moments when things just made so much sense, that it actually took me out of the moment in surprise. There's so little good writing anymore that it's shocking when you see it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ChuckMcM on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:02PM (#35716852)
A lot of wisdom in that rant. I too have noticed the big gap is writers (who are going on strike it seems). I think we're all going to have to suffer through "stuff written by LLMs" for a while, but I really think that a studio that restructured their revenue sharing to focus more of the proceeds towards writers would find quite a bit of success in today's market.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by teh_klev on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:37PM (#35717360)
> I too have noticed the big gap is writers

I started watching "The Night Agent" but the dialogue became too painful for me to carry on after about four or five episodes. That coupled with a script where two secret service agents bitch at each other like children eventually nailed the coffin.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by ChuckMcM on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:50PM (#35717528)
Exactly! I had the same reaction. First episode, "Okay, an interesting (if well worn) setup, a lead character that is somewhat interesting, some dynamics." to second episode "Well that really didn't feel particularly entertaining", to the third episode, "not getting better, time to get off this train."
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by chris_wot on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:37PM (#35718126)
I just watched “Ghosted”. It was somewhat entertaining, but hardly stellar. This is the sort of movie that is being released these days, and we can easily take it or leave it.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by teh_klev on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:57PM (#35720572)
Dexter Fletcher as director piqued my interest in Ghosted just a wee bit. I read The Rachel Papers as a youngster and quite enjoyed the film when it came out (in which he plays the main character in the book).

I'll probably watch it on holiday to hedge against the possibility of losing two hours of my life on a school night :)

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by teh_klev on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:59PM (#35720595)
I feel the same is also happening with Rabbit Hole, though I might persist with it. The Kiefer and Charles Dance in the same series, what's not to like?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jstarfish on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @03:00PM (#35718412)
The show got better by the end. The show itself-- not the dialogue.

On a similar note: for so much of Night Agent, it felt like they started with competent technical advisors that paid enough attention to detail to make terminals show TUIs/GUIs that actually relate to the current goal, but the writers came along and rewrote every technical explanation with "brb guys, gotta hack the mainframe" garbage.

The wine moms around me love the show though, so maybe it's just catering to the target demographic.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by TheCondor on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:25PM (#35717184)
> I think the root problem is that no studio anywhere is large enough to put out enough high-quality content to keep the people engaged continuously. Not even Disney.

This. There simply isn't that much really great content.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jstarfish on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:42PM (#35718184)
> Take any Writing 101 course, and if you want to write for Hollywood, completely throw it out the window because they do not care in the slightest about any of that.

I don't think it's that. Historically, you'd have a strong cast and crew on board for the first ~2-3 seasons.

Any show attracts its critical mass of viewers early on, so the first way to keep production of later seasons profitable is by eliminating expensive gimmicks (helicopters, SFX, on-location, etc.).

Firing the writers and replacing them with Writing 101 interns is usually the next step. It's not that nobody cares, but the replacement labor is new to the game; they're not writing award-winning scripts at that stage in their lives. It's a step above mining fanfiction.net for scripts.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by dahwolf on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:28PM (#35720855)
Well said, writing makes the difference. Quite a few great movies have an extremely simple setting. Even if we establish that writers can't write anymore, let's turn to books not yet televised?

One phenomenon of shitty writing and dialogue is that increasingly I hate the main character. Smug, cringe, sassy, sarcastic, lecturing. I'm not rooting for them, I hope the bad guys win.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by biztos on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:58PM (#35716789)
I'm starting to wonder if Netflix is maybe just trying harder in newer markets.

I cancelled my subscription out of frustration at the crappy content I saw all the time in the US app (and the terrible discovery too) -- but now I keep seeing ads for fairly compelling Asian shows and I might resubscribe "in" another country.

If you are throwing stuff at the wall to see what sticks, the stuff you get to throw might not be so good when you're competing with Apple, HBO, and all the rest. In a smaller market maybe the best people are still willing to be thrown at the Netflix Wall, so to speak.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by stiltzkin on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:15PM (#35717867)
For me it started going downhill with the high quantity of shows molded for ESG, now I download well-reviewed shows to my Plex even if I missed binge watching easily with Netflix.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by tmpz22 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @02:30PM (#35718051)
Do any of these executives deserve credit for the hits when Netflix earned a reputation for greenlighting just about anything?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by wnevets on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:52AM (#35715731)
> trash telly

The executives that ruined regular TV/cable with cheap and trashy TV are bringing that model to streaming.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by geodel on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:56AM (#35715792)
So Murdoch is fuckhead because he decided not to share content that his companies produce with other streaming providers?
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by maxboone on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @11:58AM (#35715824)
Not to forget the FOSS commitment from early Netflix.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by neals on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:16PM (#35716136)
Disappointment can only come from your own expectations. Good doesn't last. I like to have a mindset of using these kind of things while they work for me, until they don't, then leave and not look back. Don't get attached to commercial endeavours.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Jenk on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:37PM (#35716449)
> Disappointment can only come from your own expectations.

Reductionist victim blaming and, frankly, nonsense. Pessimism is not healthy.

I supported their business (by paying) because I liked their operating model, and their campaign (for lack of a better word) to keep adverts out of the platform and to support "better" content.

I am dissappointed that model has, apparently, failed and they are pivoting away into yet another low brow, low IQ, garbage distributor - even if it is an inevitability.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by itsoktocry on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:53PM (#35716700)
>Reductionist victim blaming

Victim-blaming? What exactly are you the victim of here? Netflix not having shows you like.

>Pessimism is not healthy.

Your entire post was to complain that Netflix is failing.

>I am dissappointed that model has, apparently, failed and they are pivoting away into yet another low brow, low IQ, garbage distributor

Can't get much more elitist than this, can it?

There is tons of good content on Netflix. And Orange is the New Black wasn't very good, imho.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by babypuncher on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:24PM (#35716239)
I think some people's expectations of Netflix were downright unrealistic.

When they started streaming, the platform was paying pennies to license shows that were already in syndication. Programs that had already made their money in first runs on network TV and cable.

As streaming became the de facto distribution method for new content, of course the cost of licensing that content ewas going to go up. Streaming licensing fees are no longer just gravy to the studios, they are their primary source of income.

The idea that Netflix could somehow afford to bankroll the entire entertainment industry on $15/mo subscriptions is ridiculous. There were three possible outcomes:

1. Netflix becomes the new cable and charges $100+/mo

2. The output of the entertainment industry shrinks until it is sustainable on $15/mo subscriptions

3. Competitors start popping up and fighting for market share

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Alupis on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:38PM (#35716464)
None of which says "Make a million garbage shows and movies that nobody asked for and few actually enjoy - then raise monthly rates to bankroll these pet projects".

Here's an idea - quality over quantity. Make fewer, but better shows and movies.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by babypuncher on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:41PM (#35716510)
That is Netflix trying to carve out their niche in timeline #3. They think they can compete with the other services by having a little of something for everyone.

The poor average quality of their content is why I cancelled Netflix and switched to a mix of HBO, Hulu, and Paramount.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by itsoktocry on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:55PM (#35716728)
>Here's an idea - quality over quantity. Make fewer, but better shows and movies.

What an insight.

But how do you determine what's "high quality" and what isn't? You don't think Netflix is trying to measure that?

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Alupis on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:33PM (#35717308)
> But how do you determine what's "high quality" and what isn't?

There's zero chance Netflix isn't aware they are peddling more junk than gold these days. It's a gamble to have more content than anyone else - and it seems to be slowly killing them.

Everyone has a story about spending 45 minutes surfing Netflix trying to find something interesting to watch while dinner gets cold. Everyone has stories about how awful the latest Netflix Original is, etc.

The amount of poorly dubbed foreign films is appalling, for instance. That's not a gripe against foreign films, it's a gripe about the utter lack of quality Netflix green-lit straight onto the front page of results. These things could be done well - but often are not.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by 542354234235 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:53PM (#35717569)
I thought about listing all the popular, critically acclaimed shows that Netflix has cancelled on a cliffhanger or without a “final season”, but that is a long list and there are plenty of BuzzFeed type articles about it. Not every show is going to be a hit, but Netflix consistently abandons great shows after 1-2 seasons because they aren’t Stranger Things level popular. So now they have a catalog of great shows no one wants to watch or recommend because why would you start a show that you know ends after 1 season on a cliffhanger? How many shows could have been tentpole shows, but people are hesitant to start them when they know how cancel happy Netflix is?

Netflix is shortsighted and myopically focused on tentpole shows that directly lead to “new subscribers” that join just to watch that show. All while ignoring having a strong catalog, since it is hard to measure how a cumulative collection of shows drives subscriptions.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by usrusr on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:30PM (#35717252)
Quality over quantity completely ignores differences in taste. One person's best show in the universe is another's torturous crap they'd avoid like the plague even if they were paid for watching.

It's perfectly possible to ignore that and still aim for some focused quality, but that's the path to becoming a niche operation. Might as well switch to pay per view.

The main challenge streaming networks are facing is that there is no attention on-ramp now that nobody is zapping through linear tv anymore who might get hooked on an earlier iteration of the franchise. When I know that I am multiple installments behind in $franchise, my willingness to pay for the latest one is zero. And if earlier ones are the same price as the latest, they will feel overpriced. That's why the focused "I subscribe x because of some specific production y" that would be implied by quality over quantity doesn't have much future, they need habitual subscription where discovery just happens.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by themitigating on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @12:20PM (#35716182)
"Meanwhile the other streaming services are at least as bad, but typically worse."

So then isn't it just good? Cable didn't have on demand and you couldn't share even in the same house. Beyond basic cable channels you needed a cable box for each tv for around $5 a month in the late 80s (around $11 today).

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by poisonarena on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:01PM (#35716832)
>been getting lost in shows like Narcos

A Brazilian man speaking mexican spanish as Pablo Escobar, with mexican actors using mexican slang in a show about the colombian drug trade, completely omitting Pablo regularly raped and afterwards executed 13-15 year old girls and other insane stuff.. this was not a popular show in Colombia

Netflix has always been unwatchable crap or woke garbage. Time to unsubscribe and pirate

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:05PM (#35716889)
Netflix should be a little ashamed that they revived the cult of Pablo Escobar. The amount of memes and “sigma male” videos featuring Escobar is embarrassing. They turned Escobar into a folk hero, not a scumbag criminal.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by tayo42 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @06:27PM (#35720847)
If you came away from narcos thinking Escobar was a good person, you only saw what you wanted to see in that show. Any amount of rape wouldn't change that. He blew up a plane full of innocent people...
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by DrBazza on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:18PM (#35717086)
To succeed they had to make streaming video easier than torrenting it, and cheap enough to attract the casual torrenter.

And like every company, v1 was run by the founders that understood their customer base.

Of course, we're at v2, with legions of sales, accounts and advertising execs, and layers of management whose performance and pay is based solely on company performance.

The other thing that Netflix dropped the ball on was the Spotify-esque "1 site to rule them all". There's now Disney+, Paramount+, Hulu, HBO, in the UK, BBC, ITV, E4, Sky, and so on. Movie + TV companies have always fought each other in a way that record companies never did, but both their products are just bits down a wire in 2023.

Competition is coming at them from all sides.

I know that they get precise viewing figures for their series, but cancelling some of them is just baffling. No more chance of "Growing The Beard" for shows given the crowded marketplace.

I cancelled a year or so ago after they cancelled some of the programmes I used to watch. The only thing left on Netflix for me is Stranger Things and that's not enough to keep me.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:16PM (#35720133)
> The other thing that Netflix dropped the ball on was the Spotify-esque "1 site to rule them all". There's now Disney+, Paramount+, Hulu, HBO, in the UK, BBC, ITV, E4, Sky, and so on. Movie + TV companies have always fought each other in a way that record companies never did, but both their products are just bits down a wire in 2023

Netflix didn't drop the ball; it was clearly never going to happen. When Netflix launched their streaming service, I thought it was a dumb idea because I figured it was 10 years tops before all the major studios could run their own streaming services, at which point Netflix would have no content to stream (unlike mailing DVDs, you need permission from studios to stream their content).

Most of the movie studios jealously guard the rights to their movies; Netflix got a lot of its early streaming content by sublicensing from Starz, which pissed of the studios (most notably Disney, but there was murmuring from Sony as well). At this point, Netflix invested both in TV back-content as well as creating original content.

We are now entering an era in which Studios can potentially have complete control over legal distribution of their content, and they look likely to do so. I'll pause for a moment while you try to buy a copy of the (now 3.5 year old) Mandalorian season 1 on DVD or Bluray...

I'm not sure why music ended in the "(almost) 1 site to rule them all" while video did not, but a couple possibly contributing factors:

1. MP3s had a one-two punch of coming practically out of nowhere, and portable players that significantly improved on the walkman/discman experience. Napster wasn't even around that long (2 years, 80M users at peak) but planted pirated MP3s as a big deal. Then the iPod came around and being on iTunes was important to stay relevant. If you're on iTunes, why not be on all streaming and purchasing services at the same time?

2. There is a long history in the US of compulsory licensing of music for various purposes. It doesn't cover on-demand streaming, but does cover satellite, terrestrial radio and "internet radio" services.

3. Retail media sales have long been the public metric of success for music; for film studios it's been retail ticket sales. The music charts even have formulae for translating streams into equivalent purchases of physical media.

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by Logans_Run on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:22PM (#35717148)
Indeed. I enjoyed 'The Mentalist' series (The Pilot and Series 1 in particular) which was also on Netflix if memory serves.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by MuffinFlavored on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:28PM (#35717219)
> Netflix have really dissapointed me.

I don't think your comment is exclusively about the password sharing policy, but I'll pretend it is at a high level:

Do they (as a business) deserve to do what is in their best interest (maximize profit)?

Why are users "owed" the ability to pay for 1 household and share it with 5 households?

Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by jayd16 on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @01:33PM (#35717303)
No one is owed but this question is flawed. Users were paying for 5 households. Now they can only use it for one. However you look at it, its a reduction in service or an increase in price.
Re:Netflix Loses 1M Users in Spain over Password Policing by naet on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @05:37PM (#35720361)
I stopped watching new Netflix shows after they left too many unfinished. I might consider it if it was a finished series, but it was too frustrating to start watching something, have it end a season on a cliffhanger, and then get cancelled before things got resolved.

I think they lost a lot of customer goodwill with those frequent cancellations. Even if they didn't want to finish the series, investing in a short special episode to wrap some things up might have kept more of that alive and made me more willing to invest my time in a newer series.

I'm not an expert but it really seems like Netflix is doing self inflicted damage with some recent decisions. Maybe an exec failed upwards and ended up in charge of some policies they shouldn't have been trusted with...