Your social security number? Your bank account number? Your debit card PIN? Yeah, pretty sure you have something to hide.
This is what fascism looks like.
Before that you shared your consuming habits online.
Then it becomes illegal.
You are now a suspect and get a search warrant and if they find traces of marijuana you go to jail.
Locks are more for security than privacy, and it's important not to conflate the two. People can have nothing to hide, but also not want to be robbed.
And as for email, that's again a matter of security because then someone could impersonate you for one, and I can't name a service that allows you to omit having a password for your email account.
(I know, looking too deeply into it! Sorry.)
Where I live, there are no laws against public nudity (as long as the nudity isn't "salacious" in nature). And yet, very nearly 100% of the people are clothed at all times.
People also smoke cigarettes, eat junk food, and do things that are unnatural and otherwise detrimental due to what they're bombarded with.
I wear clothes, I'm not a nudist. I have zero shame about my body though, it's a body—we've all got one.
The point as per my other comments: different solutions for different problems, the appropriateness of each varies with demographics. E.g., if you're surviving in an oppressive regime as a dissenter, email is something to be avoided. If you're running a business, it's likely fine, provided that it's compliant for your industry, e.g., HIPAA.
Is that adequate security? Is that adequate privacy? This is what bills like EARN IT and its ilk are positing with backdoors et al. It depends on your threat model.
If a warrant opens a door or account one way or another, it can be argued that privacy-wise, locks and passwords are poor solutions. Are you protecting business data or trying to survive in an oppressive regime?
Different solutions for different problems, how appropriate they are varies with demographics too.
This is an interesting talking point about privacy and security: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35617773
First it's just one, then it becomes the other.
Ergo, if this is a consideration within your threat model, it's an inappropriate solution. However, I am highlighting that EARN IT is no more a threat than existing service providers abiding by a court order, ergo the existing solutions likely aren't fit-for-purpose for some folks, depending on threat model.
Yes. Privacy is a subset of security.
Off the cuff:
* Being an anonymous person walking through a city. This is a privacy concern and only becomes a security concern if I'm a public persona or some kind of person of interest.
* Moving to a new school/city/job and not having your social reputation follow you. This allows a lot of people a chance to redefine who they are and how they interact with people around them. This can't happen if everybody always knows somebody's pervious public persona.
* Breaking a law and being fined/punished/imprisoned for it. Without privacy, such a person has a much poorer chance of having a decent life even after they've done their time or paid their dues.
These all strike me as privacy concerns, but not necessarily concerns to security. I think they're all important enough to consider privacy as a good thing in it's own right and that such scenarios signal that it's possible to advocate privacy in the absence of (or opposition to) security concerns.
The most accurate lines I can draw around either are abstract enough that they end up in the same bucket, but perhaps we're defining them differently
So you need to protect the system to protect the information on it, but there are also sometimes trade offs between security and privacy when you offload some system protection by giving away some information to another party. For example SmartScreen with Microsoft, and Safe Browsing with Google Chrome.
> IMO these are all 'security' related, just personal security (which is what I define privacy as).
I think this level of reduction becomes problematic in scenarios where security>privacy advocates talk about security in the collective sense.
Playing devil's advocate to highlight where I believe this reduction of security->personal security->privacy breaks down: A man borrowed many books from a library on the topic of explosive chemistry. That man later was involved in terrorist acts.
This is a situation where one could argue that less privacy for people in relation to their library borrowing habits may have resulted in greater security.
This is an example of an event that has happened, and while I hate the cliche of terrorism in debates about privacy and feel this particular point can be argued, it's exactly these kinds of scenarios that security>privacy advocates use to push for fewer privacy protections across large groups of people.
The Sokovia Accords Debate [1] from the Captain America Civil War (2016) film says it best, imho.
You know information people ALWAYS blindly believe 100%? "Leaked" data. Imagine how much power one could have with manipulated, leaked, data.
I guess if we're nitpicking I'll point out that this is still privacy (how one keeps their password) for the sake of security. Information is kept private and passwords are information.
This seems like it's shifting the goalposts. Someone says something about "nothing to hide but they have locks on their doors" and you say "security isn't the same as privacy". It's accurate but it's moot. I keep the location of my hide-a-key private so I can continue to keep my house secure with the lock on the front door. I keep my email password private so I can secure the account against unauthorized access.
Some people do use their email for what they would consider sensitive communications, and it's less than helpful to suggest they need better opsec practices in response to someone else saying that they should be able to expect their email to be private. It's saying "just hide it better, lol" when that's literally exactly what many people are trying to do when speaking against this sort of legislation.
With what I had in mind, if you logged into my Gmail account, which provides both sending and receiving, you could impersonate me to my own mother, but I would have nothing to hide as I don't receive any sensitive information via email (privacy). However, accounts elsewhere could be recovered via my email, and thus be used to impersonate me elsewhere (security).
Which means they do have things to hide. There are lots of thieves in places of power, and that is a compelling reason not to let them have our data.
I guess he is a metaphor for the surveillance state. Or the other way around. Dunno.
He might have been a little younger, I don't remember precisely, I don't believe he was talking much at the age when this happened.
There is a difference between pooping in front of family and in front of strangers.
Would they be okay with the data being used to overcharge them whenever they're in a hurry because the organization knows when they don't have time to comparison shop?
How about maximizing their tax burden by using the data to calculate the highest tax rates each area would tolerate before moving or changing their vote?
Suppose the government falls under the control of the party they don't like. Should they have access to the data that allows them to most effectively target their propaganda?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LOVEINT
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEXINT
But I find the sort of people who believe in "nothing to hide" tend to believe in the efficacy of bureaucratic systems set up to prevent that sort of thing. A belief (ironically) bolstered by the privacy those organizations secure for themselves, so that those kinds of individual abuses are rarely discovered. Who watches the watchers?
Whereas it's easy to understand that if you don't have a high opinion of the opposing party's most recent President, you might very well not want their administration knowing everything about everyone.
When people say they have nothing to hide, in most cases what they're actually saying is that they're afraid of the confrontation implicit in the opposite response (I'm going to forcefully argue for a right to privacy). They're telling you that they're a coward.
If they truly have no ethical or moral boundaries, then they are probably deviant enough that they won't be able to get into a position to set much policy, anyways, by definition of their lack of fitness to represent the majority of any population.
You go ahead and zen out and, in turn, take those things with grace by going along with it when someone raises a fuss ("oh, I am soooo humiliated! :)"). Or if you're of another archetype, you'll find witty ways to playfully snap back and turn it around on people trying to clown on you (alas, I'm not of this type/talent). Moreover, there are the countless, other not-uncommon approaches that often lead to escalation/hostility/violence.
Then it becomes a drag (and where the issue lies) when it really catches on in wildfire manner, to where it will have practically problematic effects on you personally or professionally, not unlike the lie that makes it halfway 'round the world before the truth can put its pants on.
As far as I see it, all of that is what is trying to be highlighted with the pooping witness analogy. Of course, that should probably be underscored when presenting it.
You'll probably still get a "yeah, that's fine" or "I don't care what anyone else thinks" after you elaborate. And tons of other cans of worms can reasonably be opened as topical offshoots; I'm just trying to concur that the "I don't mind" response doesn't really feel like a response.
Maybe some people even think they believe it when they say it, but I've yet to see anyone who is willing to demonstrate it when pressed, and I've even met a few people who have claimed that they have no concerns at all about their privacy, but who then ended up feeling violated when even small things they assumed were private ended up being exposed.
-- excerpt from A Cypherpunk's Manifesto, Eric Hughes, March 9, 1993
It's funny (not haha-funny) how political policy in 2023 is still trying to catch up to morality understood 30 years ago. I remember being annoyed at newscasters abusing the term "hackers" in the late 90s and extremely broad definitions of "hacking" being applied in court-rulings. It must still be really difficult to comprehend tech and the consequences of these kinds of policies for policy makers. Either that or policy makers really are maleficent towards life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
That's also why terms are being used deliberately incorrectly, to move legitimate positions nearer to criminal activity. Just ask anyone interested in hobbyist chemistry.
Politicians are deliberately obtuse especially if it has significant long-term gains for them (read "remain in power indefinitely").
1984.
> That way build sympathy for the law-breakers
how do you build sympathy for law-breakers...? i'm having a hard time understating...I think it was 1986, as in the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. [1]
> That way build sympathy for the law-breakers, then legitimize them via immigration reforms that only benefit the illegals
it was noted "The legalization provisions in this act will go far to improve the lives of a class of individuals who now must hide in the shadows, without access to many of the benefits of a free and open society. Very soon many of these men and women will be able to step into the sunlight and, ultimately, if they choose, they may become Americans"
A better example would be encryption keys.
"They say a Secret is something you tell one other person, so I'm telling you, child".
The bank knows your password. Which means they (or more precisely their agents, employees, etc.) can lose it yet they'll probably try to blame you.
It is possible to not have this happen via what's called an Augmented PAKE - the bank wouldn't know your password, but they'd be able to check you still remembered it - however almost certainly none of the systems you use today do this.
Of course leaking the hash of my password might make it easier to crack, to some extent, but if they've done a good job then this is much better than it being something the bank can trivially lose.
Any bank that restricts which characters one can include in a password probably doesn't store a hash of it.
Even with Client side hashing, the software can still validate password requirements on the client side, you may be able to bypass those requirements by modifying the client side software.
So still no, having password requirements tells you nothing about whether the password is being stored in the clear or not. The statement that I disagreed with is still completely false.
"#" can mean phone number "+" or "&" can mean concatenate variables
It is vastly easier to screen out possible problems at the user/browser level than rewrite zillions of lines of legacy code.
Putting aside the banks who literally do store the password because they have security procedures like "Please enter the first and fifth characters of your password" even those that do store a password hash still need you to submit your password to authenticate.
So, like the lyric says, you tell the bank your password. You hope they just use it to authenticate you and immediately discard it, but if bank security lapses are anything to go by they're probably logging it "for security" and there are definitely employees able to snoop the decrypted plaintext passwords from customers on some internal teams.
That is what Augmented PAKEs fix, it's really hard to do well, and of course banks see themselves as infinitely trustworthy so why would they bother.
This mistaken sense of self-worth applies to your credit card PIN by the way also, of course banks and thus bank employees can know your PIN, which means when a purchase is "secured" by the PIN that rules out some local pickpocket having made the purchase, but as well as you it leaves open the possibility that it was a bank employee or their co-conspirator.
Normally banks can't and shouldn't know the password in most jurisdictions. It does pass to their server, but they're supposed to only store a hash of it, so not be able to know what it is.
But if anybody makes this BS argument, just ask them for the credit card number and the 3 digits on the back of the card, telling them you will post it online.
You should almost never be forced to nude up.
The right protection is for the power to not exist.
"What level of trust do you think you've earned?"
"What do you want to do with all this information?"
"How will this make things better?'
"Don't you have more important things to spend time and money on?"
"Is this really the best thing the government should be working on right now?"
"How does this help any of society's ills?"
"Will taxes need to be increased to manage, store, and analyse the mountains of information that will be created?"
"How long will you store messages between me and my daughter about her contemplating suicide, and will those messages prevent her from getting a government job later in life?"
"Does the storing of all this data come with a responsibility to make it accessible to defend people who have been accused of a crime?"
"My wife works in law enforcement, will she have access to this trove of data?"
"Will there be a process to remove data from this trove that may be libelous or cause undue harm to an individual or company?"
"Is the government responsible for the complete chain of access to this data, or are there private companies involved that have to be trusted not to sneak a peek?"
"What specific issue, currently facing today's society, does this solve?"
Surveillance isn't some harmless thing, because you can tell a million lies with a drop of the truth in them for any reason you want.
Imagine you get established in life and decide to run for local politics only to have the fact that you've gone to Vegas 4 times in your life somehow turned into a completely untrue "drug use and prostitution" scandal that destroys your credibility and political career before it even started.
Imagine having your grandkids' college scholarships revoked because you ran an incredibly unprofitable and short lived onlyfans for 3 months in your late teens.
Maybe the results won't be as overt as this. Maybe it will be worse.
Either way, it is invasive and gives complete strangers power over your future and your children's future that they simply should not have and have no reason to ever have.
It's morally repugnant and abhorrent to any person who takes the time to think not of what information will be collected but of what that information will be used for and by whom.
The children of the people who as of today are still talking about how great trump is and how he "brought peace to the middle east" and how "evil demoncrats are running a global cabal to turn humans into monkeys" are the people who at best will be the parents and friends and neighbors of the people who will have finely grained and exacting data of everything you have done from well before the day of the passing of a bill like this.
This bill would make America the equivalent of living in an overly nosy HOA city everywhere for everyone. The people who fit in and don't make waves will get the 1950's nuclear family treatment, and those that don't will get the April 26, 1986 Pripyat nuclear treatment.
The argument above could really only be used if a case came to court and evidence providence needed to be questioned.
This argument is a poor one in the face of politics or lawyers because the ambiguity is such that it becomes a case of "who do you believe is telling the truth" because a jury is a group of humans, and our nature appears to be to err on the side of guilt over innocence. Hence accusation=at least guilty of "something". It therefore works in favour of the power status quo.
I have some baggage relating to this.
> The children of the people who as of today are still talking about how great trump is and how he "brought peace to the middle east" and how "evil demoncrats are running a global cabal to turn humans into monkeys" are the people who at best will be the parents and friends and neighbors of the people who will have finely grained and exacting data of everything you have done from well before the day of the passing of a bill like this
Reminder that both sides love control over your life. Remember calls for unvaccinated to be shut out of society, based on "vaccine passports"? That was the Biden supporters, not Trump supporters.
Moral of the story is those in power will do anything to stay in power, and you mean nothing to them.
who made those statements? links?
I don't think you're wrong in predicting this, and I actually think you're proven correct by precedent already. The answer to this is many and varied, but one core concept that should always be kept in mind is, much like "with great power comes great responsibility":
With great claims comes great burden of proof
What statistics are you trying to improve, and have you got a baseline you can share with us that can be used in 1 year, 2 years, 5 years to prove the effectiveness of this legislation in "protecting the children"? What's your time frame after which, if no measurable improvement to these statistics has been made, then the legislation will be declared a failure and repealed?
(This is, of course living in some kind of utopian thought experiment, and society just doesn't have the memory to allow such holding the decisions of the powerful to account, but it was therapeutic to write, and it's a worthy goal for long term pursuit).
True change lies in policy and legislation, not in technical defence. The ability to change policy and legislation is a sign that 'power' is coming back into balance between the people and the government - and if we can't do that, then the power balance needs restorative work.
Technical defence should always exist, but rarely be necessary, especially against the government of one's own country.
(If one can argue in good faith in public, visibly, the bad faith of the opposition matters less than the ability to make aware as many of the public as possible. Bad faith, irrational, or malicious actors should be able to be backed into a corner with their own arguments)
Regular people (aka "voters") don't have the power to demand anything. They're driven around like cattle.
You see, just statistically speaking, they have pedophiles on staff, staff with potential data access. They have ex husbands that want to abduct their kid after the messy divorce where the wife had to get a new identity, but good luck fleeing from your husband who has DB access at the DoE.
The real world is messy and filled with bad actors in positions of power and access to data that enables their abuse.
The less data there is, the less they can abuse it.
Almost like… guns. The less guns are out there… oh. Oh…
You guys in the States are screwed. I’m sorry for you all.
This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Keep escalating until they balk. Once that happens: "oh, so you do value your privacy?"
If they actually do share this sort of info with you, give you copies of their keys, and let you put up cameras in their house, it's probably safe to say that they are part of a vanishingly small minority, and you really don't need to care about their views on privacy. (Hopefully this assertion ages well years from now.)
* Cameras on their front doors (Ring doorbells, etc.) * Mics all around their house (Alexa's and other digital assistants) * 3D accurate maps out the entirety of your house's floor plan (Roomba's etc.) * Digital door locks managed in the cloud * Real-time position tracking (airtags, Google Maps app & equivalents, etc.)
We already have concrete evidence of some of the above being used / abused against the interest of the owner.
Until you can make a compelling case about why this is bad, I would wager that the default stance of the public is that no privacy is required.
Those who are burnt by this trust, tend to change their mind quickly.
It's pretty blatant in my neighborhood already. Whenever something criminal happens and cops come around one of the first things they ask is if I have a Ring doorbell they could take a peek at.
Completely ignoring privacy as a concept for a moment, a fair trade should be like for like, value for value.
I wonder how it is that the NSA hasn't already enabled that. One of my early concerns with government spying is that we'd up with some kind of NeoMcCarthyism on crack where someone in power would be able to discredit any inconvenient person or even identify and eliminate the career of a potential opponent before they grew to become a real threat. It's astonishing to me that with the wealth of data being collected already it hasn't happened. We've certainly had some very petty and morally bankrupt people in high positions who I'm sure would not have hesitated to abuse that information.
The risk is certainly real, and laws like EARN IT would only make it easier. Even today it seems like it'd be trivial for someone in power to plant a forbidden sequence of zeros and ones on somebodies mobile device at anytime and ruin them.
On paper, at least, the NSA technically isn't allowed to act on US soil or against US persons. The FBI would be the most likely vector for such a political police action, imho.
It seems pretty weird to assume it's not already done and in use by select people or groups in the NSA already. They literally have the ability, they're smart enough to pick their targets carefully, and there's plenty of evidence of their oversight being useless.
Obama campaigned on the promise to end domestic surveillance, and while politicians lie all the time to get elected, listening to him speak back then I believed him. He was a strong orator and was saying what I wanted to hear which makes my judgement there a bit suspect, but he also had a long history of speaking out against things like the patriot act, the illegal wiretapping of Americans, and national security letters.
Once he got into office however, instead of reining in the NSA he greatly expanded the NSA's powers to spy on the American public and he started defending them in speeches. I've often wondered if he was shown something highly classified that convinced him that violating every American's rights was genuinely needed, or if he was just threatened into compliance by showing him what information they'd collected on him and his family.
"Why is someone privileged to arrest me but I can't keep them locked up in my house?"
There are also many ethical questions around monopolization of violence, but I want to focus on the aspect of exchanging rights for societal benefits.
The same applies to surveillance. And it is often said that in exchange for our privacy, we will get protection from criminal boogeymen. But this value proposition becomes unfair or unjust as soon as anyone looks at it with a critical eye. The map is not the territory here and we might be giving away our privacy for ineffective measures against crime.
Some clever answers: “If I'm not doing anything wrong, then you have no cause to watch me.” “Because the government gets to define what's wrong, and they keep changing the definition.” “Because you might do something wrong with my information.” My problem with quips like these – as right as they are – is that they accept the premise that privacy is about hiding a wrong. It's not. Privacy is an inherent human right, and a requirement for maintaining the human condition with dignity and respect.
— https://www.wired.com/2006/05/the-eternal-value-of-privacy/
The real argument being made isn't that we should give all our secrets to the government, but that we should trust that the government will comply with our 4th Amendment protections and avoid gathering this data without a valid warrant issued by an impartial judge. If you're reading this, I'm guessing that like me, you don't believe a word of that. But that's the argument that's being made, and that's what needs to be debunked loudly and publicly.
They didn't get much push back when they threw out net neutrality which most Americans supported and as far as I know nothing was ultimately done about the faked opposition either (https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/05/biggest-isps-pai...)
This would only be true if government were in fact answerable to people. It isn't, and hasn't been for a long time, if it ever was. Legislators decide what they want to vote for, and then decide how to brush off people who tell them anything they don't want to hear.
I'm very tired
This worked surprisingly well and without fail for the conservative side of my family. The instant I reminded them who was president at the time (Obama) all of them changed their mind
I don’t love this strategy. It leans into fear mongering a bit much, but if none of the other very helpful rhetorical techniques folks have shared here don’t work. This one has some staying power.
The balance between privacy and the authority is just that. We outsourced the rule of law to the state in order to have a fair and just society. Ipso facto the government should be fair and just to have the right to invade some amount of privacy in order to keep a society free, fair and just.
That’s why the judicial branch exist: to see if what the government (or anyone) did was playing by the rules. Which brings us back to politics being a danger to a society if people vote in unjust or unfair people.
"You are responsible for protecting the confidentiality of your username and password(s), if any. In addition, if you choose to be remembered on your device or browser, or link your use of the Visa Solution with a digital wallet, on one or more device(s), you are responsible for protecting the safety of and access to such device(s). It is important that you do so since we are not responsible for any losses you incur as a result of unauthorized use of your Eligible Card and, depending on the circumstances, your Issuer may hold you responsible for unauthorized use of your Eligible Card account."
Another example for mandatory secrecy are confidentiality requirements imposed by professional obligations, such as for lawyers and physicians, in order to ensure fair trials, and for the protection of human dignity.
No, the real answer here is to address the actual corruption to expose and remove it.
Not to mention, if you have nothing to hide, how can someone abuse their power to use it against you?
These bills are put in place because they save lives, especially vulnerable children.
Also because we have a lot to hide that we should be able to. Our intimate pictures with our partners, our chats with friends (and gossip), our business plans, our in-progress work and ideas, yet to be filled patents, password and account credentials, and lots more.
And as you mentioned, power will be abused. Unchecked power will be abused unchecked. This is ethically, morally and humanely wrong.
There's so much wrong with this bill and the thought behind it. It should never see the day of light.
Some first hits as reminders of places where their powers are abused
[1]: "NSA staff used spy tools on spouses, ex-lovers: watchdog" https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-surveillance-watchdog...
[2]: https://reason.com/2022/07/26/police-can-access-your-ring-ca...
[3]: https://reason.com/2021/04/26/warrantless-border-searches-dr...