News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by fsflover on Saturday April 22, 2023 @04:01AM (#35664349)
Monopoly on violence is fine, but in return the government should be 100% transparent, in order not to abuse this monopoly.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by trinsic2 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @01:02PM (#35668610)
_should_ is the main problem I have with this argument. A Monopoly on violence is _never_ fine because there is never a time where we can trust a person or an organization to be completely transparent.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by fsflover on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @12:48PM (#35703107)
We have to demand the transparency and fight for it, not just expect it. Also nothing is perfect, which doesn't mean that everything is "never fine".
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by clnq on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:25PM (#35671060)
We give up our right to violence and in exchange, we expect a say in how it's used and transparency. It becomes unjust when there isn't a like-for-like trade of entitlements or rights. If the government monopolizes violence but has no accountability to its people or offers nothing else of value in exchange, then we consider it unjust.

There are also many ethical questions around monopolization of violence, but I want to focus on the aspect of exchanging rights for societal benefits.

The same applies to surveillance. And it is often said that in exchange for our privacy, we will get protection from criminal boogeymen. But this value proposition becomes unfair or unjust as soon as anyone looks at it with a critical eye. The map is not the territory here and we might be giving away our privacy for ineffective measures against crime.