News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by MikeDelta on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:18PM (#35658665)
Many seem to not realize that privacy is not about having something to hide (I guess that would be secrecy), but about the right to keep things to yourself. Those are two different concepts.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by StingyJelly on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:30PM (#35658836)
Exactly! The best way someone put it - right to choose what to share and who to share it with.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by sixstringtheory on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:09PM (#35660210)
The best analogy for this I've seen is this: it's no secret that everybody poops. But that doesn't mean everyone likes having other people watch while they do it (privacy).
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by sporkl on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:46PM (#35660646)
I've tried using this in an argument and gotten a response along the lines of "I don't mind if people watch me poop."
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by sixstringtheory on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:39PM (#35661212)
Well I'd say their full of shit, haha. Most people have something they care about; them refuting a specific case doesn't refute the general concept. They're either arguing in bad faith or are not very good at thinking logically.

If they truly have no ethical or moral boundaries, then they are probably deviant enough that they won't be able to get into a position to set much policy, anyways, by definition of their lack of fitness to represent the majority of any population.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by boneitis on Friday April 21, 2023 @08:27PM (#35662042)
Right. I don't "mind" being seen pooping, per se.

You go ahead and zen out and, in turn, take those things with grace by going along with it when someone raises a fuss ("oh, I am soooo humiliated! :)"). Or if you're of another archetype, you'll find witty ways to playfully snap back and turn it around on people trying to clown on you (alas, I'm not of this type/talent). Moreover, there are the countless, other not-uncommon approaches that often lead to escalation/hostility/violence.

Then it becomes a drag (and where the issue lies) when it really catches on in wildfire manner, to where it will have practically problematic effects on you personally or professionally, not unlike the lie that makes it halfway 'round the world before the truth can put its pants on.

As far as I see it, all of that is what is trying to be highlighted with the pooping witness analogy. Of course, that should probably be underscored when presenting it.

You'll probably still get a "yeah, that's fine" or "I don't care what anyone else thinks" after you elaborate. And tons of other cans of worms can reasonably be opened as topical offshoots; I'm just trying to concur that the "I don't mind" response doesn't really feel like a response.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by autoexec on Friday April 21, 2023 @10:26PM (#35662797)
Assuming they're adults, offer to set up a camera feed in their bathroom and stream it. They don't mind, and you'd do the work, so it'd be no problem for them and a very specific type of audience would love it. They could likely even earn a bit of money doing it so it's win/win!

Maybe some people even think they believe it when they say it, but I've yet to see anyone who is willing to demonstrate it when pressed, and I've even met a few people who have claimed that they have no concerns at all about their privacy, but who then ended up feeling violated when even small things they assumed were private ended up being exposed.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by coldtea on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:23PM (#35670081)
At that point you can either call them a pervert and weirdo, or you can ask to film then while they poop and upload it to YouTube with their name attached.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by trinsic2 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:55PM (#35668517)
I like this. I added my own parts to clarify and solidify my stance. "Unless I have created a harm, I have a right to choose what to share and who to share it with. I have no interest in the "suspected guilty until proven innocent" mantra.""
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by sroussey on Friday April 21, 2023 @03:45PM (#35658998)
If you have nothing to hide, then publish it all for the world to see.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by louloulou on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:57PM (#35660006)
"Privacy is necessary for an open society in the electronic age. Privacy is not secrecy. A private matter is something one doesn't want the whole world to know, but a secret matter is something one doesn't want anybody to know. Privacy is the power to selectively reveal oneself to the world."

-- excerpt from A Cypherpunk's Manifesto, Eric Hughes, March 9, 1993

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by imoverclocked on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:49PM (#35660694)
> March 9, 1993

It's funny (not haha-funny) how political policy in 2023 is still trying to catch up to morality understood 30 years ago. I remember being annoyed at newscasters abusing the term "hackers" in the late 90s and extremely broad definitions of "hacking" being applied in court-rulings. It must still be really difficult to comprehend tech and the consequences of these kinds of policies for policy makers. Either that or policy makers really are maleficent towards life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by DocTomoe on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:09PM (#35660918)
Oh, politics understands that alright, don't you worry about that. Politicians are the enemies of privacy for the masses, because a transparent population is a population that is easier controlled and manipulated.

That's also why terms are being used deliberately incorrectly, to move legitimate positions nearer to criminal activity. Just ask anyone interested in hobbyist chemistry.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by whydoyoucare on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:35PM (#35661656)
Or how legal immigrants (on visas) are conveniently clubbed together with illegal aliens (who have no valid papers to be in the US) into a single term called "immigrants". That way build sympathy for the law-breakers, then legitimize them via immigration reforms that only benefit the illegals, and continue to remain in power for life.

Politicians are deliberately obtuse especially if it has significant long-term gains for them (read "remain in power indefinitely").

1984.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by andrekandre on Friday April 21, 2023 @09:10PM (#35662305)

  > That way build sympathy for the law-breakers
how do you build sympathy for law-breakers...? i'm having a hard time understating...
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by eigen on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:35AM (#35663370)
> 1984.

I think it was 1986, as in the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. [1]

> That way build sympathy for the law-breakers, then legitimize them via immigration reforms that only benefit the illegals

it was noted "The legalization provisions in this act will go far to improve the lives of a class of individuals who now must hide in the shadows, without access to many of the benefits of a free and open society. Very soon many of these men and women will be able to step into the sunlight and, ultimately, if they choose, they may become Americans"

1. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/99/s1200

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by tastyfreeze on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:18PM (#35668083)
I don't really care if somebody entered the country legally or not. Eventually, everybody assimilates. However, I am not ok extending benefits paid for by taxes to non-citizens. As long as there are politicians trying to give tax paid benefits to "illegal" immigrants I will be against illegal immigration.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by kelnos on Saturday April 22, 2023 @07:58AM (#35665682)
The term "illegal aliens" is an invention. "Immigrant" doesn't care about legality; it is literally just someone who has moved from another locale. Labeling one variant "legal" and another "illegal" is perfectly reasonable.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by quickthrower2 on Friday April 21, 2023 @06:54PM (#35661339)
By that definition I would say secrecy is also necessary for an open society. For example my bank password is something I don’t want anyone to know.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by louloulou on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:13PM (#35661502)
I agree, but I don't think that's a good example. The only reason for the existence of a bank password is to enable private interactions between yourself and the bank (and the government through their financial surveillance).

A better example would be encryption keys.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by quickthrower2 on Friday April 21, 2023 @07:32PM (#35661630)
I agree with that. And using your example automated encryption keys schemes, for example https.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by tialaramex on Friday April 21, 2023 @08:25PM (#35662027)
In practice your bank password is indeed a secret, and that's a bad thing, because that above definition is wrong, which is why I prefer to think about the U2 lyric (from "The Fly"):

"They say a Secret is something you tell one other person, so I'm telling you, child".

The bank knows your password. Which means they (or more precisely their agents, employees, etc.) can lose it yet they'll probably try to blame you.

It is possible to not have this happen via what's called an Augmented PAKE - the bank wouldn't know your password, but they'd be able to check you still remembered it - however almost certainly none of the systems you use today do this.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by joebob42 on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:11AM (#35663261)
Don't they usually store a hash of it? And doesn't it therefore for the most part work exactly the way you say it ideally should?

Of course leaking the hash of my password might make it easier to crack, to some extent, but if they've done a good job then this is much better than it being something the bank can trivially lose.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by u801e on Saturday April 22, 2023 @01:48AM (#35663731)
> Don't they usually store a hash of it?

Any bank that restricts which characters one can include in a password probably doesn't store a hash of it.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by shkkmo on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:14AM (#35663879)
This is completely false. You validate any password requirements before salting and hashing the password and then store the salt and hash. Even if you restrict usage of previous passwords, you are just comparing hashes.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by jimmydorry on Saturday April 22, 2023 @10:52AM (#35667133)
Except you are giving them the password and trusting them to discard it after validating it. If it's purely client side, then the bank is trusting you to follow the password requirements which is also out of the question.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by shkkmo on Saturday April 22, 2023 @12:13PM (#35668038)
Whether hashing is happening client side does tell you a little, though in most cases most users are still trusting the client side software to not exfiltrate the password before hashing it.

Even with Client side hashing, the software can still validate password requirements on the client side, you may be able to bypass those requirements by modifying the client side software.

So still no, having password requirements tells you nothing about whether the password is being stored in the clear or not. The statement that I disagreed with is still completely false.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by u801e on Sunday April 23, 2023 @03:47AM (#35674222)
If the bank is indeed salting and hashing the password, then what's the rationale of allowing certain special characters like '!', but not '+'? Hashing and salting should be character agnostic.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by Xorakios on Sunday April 23, 2023 @09:54AM (#35676252)
Some special characters are not processed as one might expect, particularly by implementations of languages such as COBOL, which is still used on the server side by many banks, insurance companies and government agencies where consistency is paramount.

"#" can mean phone number "+" or "&" can mean concatenate variables

It is vastly easier to screen out possible problems at the user/browser level than rewrite zillions of lines of legacy code.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by tialaramex on Saturday April 22, 2023 @05:39AM (#35664826)
> Don't they usually store a hash of it? And doesn't it therefore for the most part work exactly the way you say it ideally should?

Putting aside the banks who literally do store the password because they have security procedures like "Please enter the first and fifth characters of your password" even those that do store a password hash still need you to submit your password to authenticate.

So, like the lyric says, you tell the bank your password. You hope they just use it to authenticate you and immediately discard it, but if bank security lapses are anything to go by they're probably logging it "for security" and there are definitely employees able to snoop the decrypted plaintext passwords from customers on some internal teams.

That is what Augmented PAKEs fix, it's really hard to do well, and of course banks see themselves as infinitely trustworthy so why would they bother.

This mistaken sense of self-worth applies to your credit card PIN by the way also, of course banks and thus bank employees can know your PIN, which means when a purchase is "secured" by the PIN that rules out some local pickpocket having made the purchase, but as well as you it leaves open the possibility that it was a bank employee or their co-conspirator.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by coldtea on Saturday April 22, 2023 @03:21PM (#35670068)
>The bank knows your password. Which means they (or more precisely their agents, employees, etc.) can lose it yet they'll probably try to blame you.

Normally banks can't and shouldn't know the password in most jurisdictions. It does pass to their server, but they're supposed to only store a hash of it, so not be able to know what it is.

But if anybody makes this BS argument, just ask them for the credit card number and the 3 digits on the back of the card, telling them you will post it online.

Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by teaearlgraycold on Friday April 21, 2023 @04:57PM (#35660013)
There’s a reason we don’t mandate government cameras inside our homes. No one wants that. But in a world where everyone needs a computer, we shouldn’t take advantage of that obligation by turning our computers into surveillance devices.
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by hanniabu on Friday April 21, 2023 @05:05PM (#35660145)
Reminder that the same applies to use of crypto. Just because it's use for some illegal activity (it's actually less % than fiat), doesn't mean it should be made illegal as I've seen some comments here advocating for in the past.
[dead]
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by hanniabu on Saturday April 22, 2023 @02:42PM (#35669660)
You're taking the term cryptocurrency too literally
Re:The Earn IT Bill Is Back, Seeking to Scan Our Messages an... by BLKNSLVR on Saturday April 22, 2023 @01:22AM (#35663616)
Privacy is wearing clothes.

You should almost never be forced to nude up.