Remember, there’s really only two options: run a service in a country and abide by the law and norms of that country, or don’t run a service in that country (ie IP geoblock the entire place).
I mean, sure, you can run a service that abides by the law but not the norms (eg Onlyfans is available in the US despite the US being a country founded by prudes), but it’s hard and you need your full focus to get it just right. And, worse yet, in China the border between law and norms is notoriously blurred.
I’m for freedom of speech and against Chairman Xi, but I can’t really fault the Midjourney team for choosing to operate in China regardless. It’s a hard choice and there are no right answers.
Not simple if you want to make money from a huge percentage of people in China.
Also, it seems like the principle of giving into bullies isn’t just an immediate decision but a precedent for future decisions where the rule is to capitulate to authoritarian regime demands.
Western countries impose a crapload not so freedom loving laws / rulse / behavior / etc as well. Do you propose shutting down business in the West as well? Or you have a rule that says kill no more people than X or do not kill people in country Y and you're ethical?
I don’t propose limiting use in China because they are jerks. I just propose not accepting their bullying demands to change my product.
They're free to do what they want, others are free to say what they want to say (well, except when using Midjourney), the company can listen or not, and people can use Midjourney or not.
Saying "if you don't like it, shut up and find something else" doesn't seem particularly productive.
if i'm running something not illegal and some other country bans it i see no moral case for me doing work to enforce some foreign government's laws for them. i'm not magically "operating" in every country around the world just because someone from there pings my server.
Sure, if they want to operate in China they are taking the best course of action, but it will hardly be enough since it is an user produced content system.
3. Split the platform/user-base. Allow freedom of expression in western countries and censor it in China.
4. Censor prompts and images only in China, which still allows sharing non-political artwork between Chinese and western user.
All other platforms operating in China (of Chinese or western origin) have to do the same.
Oh wait, is this the propaganda talking?
https://twitter.com/gregory2650/status/1641964378563158016?s...
Stable Diffusion allows for just about everything, including pornographic images and parodies of Xi Jingping.
MidJourney is a more controlled platform that doesn't allow for those things. And, because it's so tightly controlled, it hasn't degenerated into a mere parade of sexualized anime characters -- and it minimizes the political risk to its platform. MidJourney actually seems competently managed, in all seriousness...
Although you say "slightly Manga-ish" women - I saw some quite realistic photos.
Your comment was posted 22 hours ago though. It's possible that the models (pun unintended) have gotten even better since you last looked.
It's taboo because a dictator forbids it. The people have nothing to do with it
Just because it's illegal doesn't mean it wouldn't also be culturally unacceptable and alienating.
There are are similar laws that involve depictions of The Buddha, monks etc here that would fall into the same category. I imagine this is less contentious for Western observers because religion is often a protected class in Western nations too.
The idea of the head of state being immune to criticism however hits a political sore spot however and triggers these sorts of standoff views.
I just feel this sort of nuance is lost on primarily American audiences. The world isn't homogenous and at least here in Thailand values are significantly different for better or worse.
I think this isn't quite the right word. "Off-putting", perhaps? It doesn't exclude anyone.
So why not reduce functionality in the foreign versions and allow the rest of the world to have this functionality?
In the case of MidJourney the output is in Discord for all to see. Setting community standards like no-porn is about creating a space where the most possible people will feel welcome. I would like to think a policy of "no disrespectful imagery" of legally-protected deities or figures wouldn't be that burdensome as a whole. It also helps to avoid drama. There is probably places that such drama would be a welcome addition but I get the feeling MidJourney is not one of those places.
I'm not saying we should bake such constraints into the models, that I think is in poor taste and unnecessary. If people can run the model on their own machine where the output is private to them they should be allowed to generate whatever they want and they can post that in venues where that sort of content is acceptable.
But when images are emitted into a public shared space I do think some rules on what is and isn't appropriate are fair game. At the end of the day it's meant to be an AI art community that is about the fusion of technology and creativity. It's not setup to be a place for political discourse.
Cultural my ass. It is as political as it gets. Just do a search on Lèse-majesté in Thailand. Here is one from wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A8se-majest%C3%A9_in_Thai...
Holy shit you weren't kidding.
I don't think that follows - boobs being allowed doesn't stop people from creating SFW works as well.
"...That’s all there is to it."
Regardless of motivation, bowing to authoritarian control is still bowing to authoritarian control.
I would claim it's worse to censor ridiculing political figures out of politeness than out of profit seeking.
Self censorship is one of the main methods by which authoritarian ideologies are maintained and spread. It's not secret police knocking on peoples doors. It's people thinking in their head "I want to remain polite...".
I respect the intent to create forums for global collaboration. But this really is one of the areas where this is helping to spread the authoritarian ideology.
Is the genocide in Xinjiang one of the impolite topics?
What if China invades Taiwan, and the Taiwan war becomes one of the "impolite" topics for Chinese?
But bowing to a dictator who says you can’t say Winnie the Pooh anymore seems like a one-sided, pro-dictator decision.
It has nothing to do with the CEO wanting to make people in China comfortable - surely he wants people in the US to feel comfortable too if that was the case?
I suppose you can’t have both. So siding with the dictator was the choice made? Bold move cotton.
God forbid y’all see a nipple in a non-sexual context though :D
If David is such a "big dreamer hippie dork," he should: 1. either open source the model or at least make it cheaper ($8/month for just 200 images is ridiculous) and 2. not bow down to dictators, or just stay out of political subjects completely.
Generating realistic images is a powerful tool, that is used for political reasons already, so politicians will get involved. So it is a hard question, but I hope if I am in such a position, I will not preemptively try to please the winni puhs.
One solution would probably be, to not allow generating pictures with real persons at all. Whether they are Trump or Xi.
It can be personal too, and I wouldn't blame him. Getting denied a Visa to China would be the the easiest problem. The worst would be getting arrested (Chinese friendly airport), possibly extradited because you ran a satire generation service?
If he just wants satire and his goals aren't to fight political battles, this stance makes perfect sense. I'd like to be able to visit China without fear, too. Even simply transiting would bring up anxiety.
As far as I can see it's the one area of DEI that gets a free pass.
It's really creepy.
There's no DEI initiative to help the disadvantaged weeaboos
I don't think in a professional DEI environment you'd get a pass for having a fetishy anime desktop background.
> [...]
> So, [ridiculing] Xi is blocked
These two points are not congruent.
> The goal of Midjourney is to bring creative power to as many people as possible.
AI is unarguably powerful, even if we're still struggling to quantify that in terms of how "intelligent" it is, to what extent it's plagiarism, or reliability, etc. The consequence of power is necessarily interacting with real-world political power structures. There is no "neutral" option; AI will empower some and disempower others, who are going to object to that. As we're seeing in this thread, if you empower or disempower one side of a political dispute (making Xi art or not), there's going to be one side that gets mad at you.
Make cultural products, get culture war.
I do wonder if this is going to be regarded as the "Thomas Midgely" era of AI, where scientists from the 2050s struggle with the legacy of widespread AI "contamination" of everything in the data record by people who didn't acknowledge downsides.
Under Xi's dictatorship hundreds of thousands of Uyghurs have been imprisoned. There's plenty of evidence of forced labor, mass internment and forced sterilization. I don't know how a "hippie" attitude would support this?
Blocking prompts of Xi seems like bowing down to a terrible dictatorship to ensure that this giant market stays open to them. I can easily create prompts for various other dictators that don't allow ridicule in their countries. Try everything from al-Sisi to Museveni to Putin. All of those work easily.
Plenty of companies are adjusting their businesses so they can operate in China. At least they openly admit why they do so.
The fact that the treatment is “special” leaves questions about the argument for inclusivity, at least in my book.
You mean the Chinese politicians that are in power right? Chinese propaganda ridicules constantly politicians from other countries.
Obviously this is just a well calculated move. It's acceptable to mock certain kind of people/groups. That's all there is to it. We don't need to go into Chinese psychology.
"She currently stands accused of "insulting the president of the republic" and will stand trial on 20 June in Saint Omer, the prosecutor said. She risks a prison sentence and a fine of €15,000 if convicted at the trial." - [0]
Looks like they are learning from the best.
[0] - https://www.euronews.com/culture/2023/03/30/heres-the-story-...
>"that one time so that makes it okay for us to do"
I am not "us". I live in Canada. And I am way more concerned with what we and the West in general are doing in human rights department then what China does. When I see the case dismissed and prosecutor loosing the job I'll be celebrating.
I'll live it to China to sort their own shit.
And very effectively.
Also restoring ability to make staff here rather than getting it from China will not hurt but I am afraid that we have pissed this away permanently.
Actively engaging in censorship is the opposite of staying out of politics. It's engaging with a political system actively.
There's no reason that Midjourney couldn't allow whatever content the user wants to be generated there, as other Midjourney users would not be able to see it.
But they insist on censoring Midjourney even in channels/servers inaccessible to the wider Midjourney audience. Why?
The team behind MJ are a bunch of overly-nice people. The work very hard night and day to help people bring art into the world. When they see their hard work resulting in porn, gore, gross-out or hate material, it is very discouraging. It’s not material they want to collaborate on. It’s not what they want to work so hard to help bring into the world. Someone else can work to create communities for that.
Limiting art is one of the worst things one could do, IMHO.
This seems like a fundamental failure to understand humans. One of my favorite Renaissance artists arguably produced gore/gross-out material for his time.
We get a lot of death metal fans, 80’s schlock movie fans and a few horror artists that I get to talk to regularly. Pretty much everyone is pretty chill and agrees the guidelines are a good thing for the community. And, the few that don’t agree with MJ’s terms of service are free to do whatever they want elsewhere using Stable Diffusion.
Xi Jinping at pride parade, by the way: https://twitter.com/hardmaru/status/1642326687751733251?s=20
Today the objection is with jokes about the Chairman. Tomorrow it'll be content about Tiananmen. The day after it'll be about the Cultural Revolution and the Great Leap Forward, etc. If it were that simple, perhaps Google would have done it long ago. The demands of the Party are never clear and never end.
Having people depicting women with uncovered hair could make it unwelcoming to people in some Muslim countries, or at least their governments. Should we ban that too ?
What about gay couples kissing ? Should we ban that if (for example) the Russian or Hungarian government ask for that ?
I guess we are lucky that Iran or Russia are not a market as big as China.
Your entire argument relies on this assumption that I have a hard time to believe. I know close to nothing of Chinese culture but the few Chinese people I know are not shy about criticizing their president or their political class in general. I mean, the "Winnie the pooh" meme comes from China!
There is no "staying out of" politics or just "remaining neutral" on topics. Not taking a stand for one side in a two sided topic means taking the other side. Either you are pro gay rights or against it. Or you are pro democracy or against it. Or you are openly against the Russian invasion of Ukraine or you are against it - whether you are silent or not. so long as you do business with or in dictatorships. This applies to any tech company as much as it applies to FIFA or anyone else.
Remember, there's no remaining neutral in politics, so I expect a well-reasoned answer on this fundamental territorial rights dispute.
I'm not arguing that everyone have an opinion on everything. I'm arguing that when you do business, you might be taking a side in something whether you would like to or not.
If Google came out and said "Dokdo is Korea territory" I absolutely guarantee there would be a complete shitstorm in Japan, probably ending with Google getting banned from Japan. You have absolutely no clue what a hot-button issue that is between those countries.
Your initial assertion is just wrong. Businesses stay out of politics all the time.
We were using Agile Client as our Common Operational Picture tool during a joint exercise with the ROK Marine Corps. The default map layer in Agile has labels on bodies of water in white text built into the imagery. The body of water between Korea and Japan was labeled "Sea of Japan". The Koreans were ADAMANT that we either remove the text or change it to "East Sea". I think we dropped a blue rectangle layer over the text and then another text layer with "East Sea" on top of that. But they repeatedly pestered us about this seemingly-small detail. We're about to get our asses chewed by flag officers for not executing the Commander's Update Brief in timely manner, while also struggling to manage the info flow about the battlespace, but the #1 issue to you is the damn text label on the map mentioning Japan?!?!
If you're from the USA, I'm sure that as a well-informed citizen, you know about how the relationship between tribal law and federal law were recently challenged at the Supreme Court (Haaland vs Brackeen), and can provide a reasoned position on the status of Native American tribes and how they should be addressed. After all, it was big news in Native American circles, and silence on that issue is violence towards Native Americans.
My statement wasn't about opinions in any way. It was basically about the fact that some times an action is already an opinion in itself. You can't e.g. do business in Russia and claim that "we like to remain neutral and stay out of politics/wars (and keep our income from the business in Russia)".
You can of course just not do business in/with Russia and few would wonder whether you have any strong opinions on the conflict. This isn't about forcing anyone to have strong public opinions. It's about that you can't meaningfully separate such opinions from business (or sports, or...)
How would one determine if this statement is true or not? If true, is the truth universal or contextual?
How would one determine if this statement is true or not "when doing business?"
I'm trying to figure out the functional difference between a "hippie CEO" and a "slick CEO".
The HBO show Silicon Valley has a satirical business owner who hires a "spiritual adviser" that tells him the most spiritual thing to do is whatever makes him the most money in every situation.
I don't know why some people wants to keep defending the indefensible, is being a contrarian some kind of addiction?
The rest is done by the desire for social acceptance.
Midjourney is playing directly into China's censorship.
If homosexuality makes people uncomfortable in the Middle East, should Midjourney ban non-sexual depictions of same-sex couples?
What's with the dreamer hippie dork façade, then?
Other than as a foil, of course.
AFAICT, Midjourney has no shareholders and David Holz is the farthest thing from a slick CEO. He’s a big dreamer hippie dork. He made all the money he cares to have from the sale of his previous company and now just wants to work on fun research projects. The goal of Midjourney is to bring creative power to as many people as possible.
Whenever politics or other controversial topics come up, the MJ teams tries to stay out of it. They just want a welcoming space for all sorts of people to collaborate and create. Lots of people complain that they don’t allow porn. But, as a result, a millions of people who are not just horny teenage boys enjoy hanging out on the server sharing and discussing art that is not just pics of sexy women all day every day. Looking at you, unending parade of unfathomly huge boobs on https://mobile.twitter.com/search?q=%23StableDiffusion
David seems to think that since ridiculing politicians in China is taboo, having people ridicule Xi on MJ would make it unwelcoming to people in China. He wants them to feel comfortable collaborating with people all over the world on MJ. So, prompting Xi is blocked. That’s all there is to it.