News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by andrewstuart on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:49AM (#35419948)
So it just happens that hippy values and western greed kowtowing to authoritarian regime values purely for the sake of money happen to be exactly the same thing. A story too convenient for my taste but everyone is free to believe whatever they want.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by skrebbel on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:08AM (#35421009)
What would you do?

Remember, there’s really only two options: run a service in a country and abide by the law and norms of that country, or don’t run a service in that country (ie IP geoblock the entire place).

I mean, sure, you can run a service that abides by the law but not the norms (eg Onlyfans is available in the US despite the US being a country founded by prudes), but it’s hard and you need your full focus to get it just right. And, worse yet, in China the border between law and norms is notoriously blurred.

I’m for freedom of speech and against Chairman Xi, but I can’t really fault the Midjourney team for choosing to operate in China regardless. It’s a hard choice and there are no right answers.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by prepend on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:18AM (#35421084)
I could have a set of values I believe in and not run my service in countries that violate my values. Seems pretty simple.

Not simple if you want to make money from a huge percentage of people in China.

Also, it seems like the principle of giving into bullies isn’t just an immediate decision but a precedent for future decisions where the rule is to capitulate to authoritarian regime demands.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by FpUser on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:55AM (#35421958)
>"the rule is to capitulate to authoritarian regime demands"

Western countries impose a crapload not so freedom loving laws / rulse / behavior / etc as well. Do you propose shutting down business in the West as well? Or you have a rule that says kill no more people than X or do not kill people in country Y and you're ethical?

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by prepend on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:25AM (#35422337)
Certainly if a western country demanded I kill people with my product, I would refuse.

I don’t propose limiting use in China because they are jerks. I just propose not accepting their bullying demands to change my product.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by madeofpalk on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:47AM (#35421338)
> drunk driving may kill a lot of people, but it also helps a lot of people get to work on time, so, it;s impossible to say if its bad or not,

https://twitter.com/dril/status/464802196060917762

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by Aunche on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:51AM (#35423547)
The difference is that drunk driving objectively kills over ten thousand people every year. Meanwhile, the negative effects of 10 person company refusing to generate low-effort satire is less clear.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by whythre on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:03PM (#35426152)
Bending the knee to a brutal ethnic cleansing regime is never a positive, regardless of the size of the entity capitulating.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by Aunche on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:59PM (#35427329)
At the end of the day, it's his company, so he can choose what services to supply. Freedom of speech means that he is allowed to have is own worldview that you disagree with, and you're free to use any other AI tools to make as much satire as you wish. If you're worried about China, worry about our incompetent Congress who is more interested in collecting sound bites than actually learn enough about technology to write meaningful regulation that protects us from China's influence on corporations.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by madeofpalk on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:24PM (#35431488)
Yes. No one doubts who's company it is. That does not make their actions free from criticism.

They're free to do what they want, others are free to say what they want to say (well, except when using Midjourney), the company can listen or not, and people can use Midjourney or not.

Saying "if you don't like it, shut up and find something else" doesn't seem particularly productive.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by collegeburner on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:51AM (#35423539)
i mean no there's obviously a 3rd option. run the service anyway and don't geoblock. like the banning country might block your service but that's on them.

if i'm running something not illegal and some other country bans it i see no moral case for me doing work to enforce some foreign government's laws for them. i'm not magically "operating" in every country around the world just because someone from there pings my server.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by voicedYoda on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:53AM (#35423563)
Just to clarify, puritans were involved in the founding of the USA, but much of the country was not based on prudish norms
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by tjpnz on Monday April 03, 2023 @10:43AM (#35424444)
If you want to operate in that country and accept all of the downsides there's nothing preventing you from offering China an inferior version of your product, as many companies already do. That they're going to force feed the rest of the world this authoritarian, fascist, shit is downright deplorable and worthy of condemnation.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by singleshot_ on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:34AM (#35425520)
The right answer is not to operate your business in totalitarian states no matter how much you want to be rich.
Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by seanmcdirmid on Monday April 03, 2023 @07:06PM (#35432613)
China's legal system doesn't run on rule of law, it runs on threat of rule by law. In this case, it means anyone who wants to function in china must predict what the government will dislike, since there is no actual Chinese law against making fun of Xi Jinping (but they will shut you down anyways if you allow it).

Sure, if they want to operate in China they are taking the best course of action, but it will hardly be enough since it is an user produced content system.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by mainframed on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:42PM (#35433483)
There is a third and a fourth option.

3. Split the platform/user-base. Allow freedom of expression in western countries and censor it in China.

4. Censor prompts and images only in China, which still allows sharing non-political artwork between Chinese and western user.

All other platforms operating in China (of Chinese or western origin) have to do the same.

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by satao on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:03AM (#35422810)
An authoritarian regime which takes people out of poverty instead of killing them or putting them in jails, what a joke!

Oh wait, is this the propaganda talking?

Re:Midjourney CEO Silencing Satire About Xi Jinping by smrtinsert on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:42AM (#35423417)
Yep. Midjourney is the exact reason why projects like Stable Diffusion are so important, anime distractions or not.