What is that commonly-used aphorism? "One man's trash is another man's treasure"? Like, even if this is true, Musk didn't do (and subsequently waived) due diligence.
> No, really, this is the allegation
No further comment on it.
> Count 2 is that Twitter committed [Texas fraud statute] by lying when it offered its shares. It's shotgun-pled, so I don't know which specific statements are supposed to be wrong, but I'm imagining it's basically the previous count recast under a different statute.
If it's due to Texas laws, is the appropriate jurisdiction is the Texas courts or... oh, he's trying to claim that the case should be heard in a federal court (for diversity reasons). Good luck though Musk.
> Count 3 says that Twitter broke the contract by failing to provide information.
What information? The contract is already in the public, but okay you want to waste court time.
> Count 4 says that Twitter broke the contract by instituting a hiring freeze.
Twitter could just point to its peers like Google, Meta and Microsoft.
> Count 5 is pretty please declare that Twitter lying about mDAUs is a materially adverse event that is cause to break the contract.
Yeah, at this point I'm convinced that Musk wants to just waste everyone's time, especially after the chancery court denied his petition to schedule the hearing next year.
The contract stated that Twitter had to provide Musk with internal data as required to close the deal. His teams tokens were apparently rate-limited at some point and it took a while for Twitter to give him access to all data, a.k.a. 'the firehose'.
Just for completeness sake, Twitter seemed to still try (the token thing was probably a technical error) and whether giving him access to the firehose was actually necessary could even be contested, as he arguably wanted to use the data to not close the deal.
Here's the thing though:
None of that data was required to close the deal. Musk had no diligence rights, he explicitly gave them up, and the contract clearly says so. He doesn't get to do regular diligence through that clause, it's meant to cover the literal things necessary to close the deal (like financing info or whatever).
So Twitter didn't have to provide anything here, and certainly not access to the firehose.
His response is going to be smacked down pretty hard by a chancellor - it's 100% nonsense.
1. due diligence as a buyer (contract) to review additional information, ask questions etc
2. using public information to purchase as an investor (he was) for a public company regulated by SEC
I think the claim is not that he has the right to #1 (he didn’t) but that #2 was false and has been false.
No idea if contract laws let #2 get him off the hook though
Musk wanted to invent some means to count users in an effort to demonstrate fraud. But that's not fraud. Just because musk provides an alternate means to count users, doesn't demonstrate fraud.
Full stop. Unless he proves that they didn't count the way they claim, he has not claim. Waiving he due diligence clause is what makes his claims a non issue.
I see you’re point though. I guess he’d have to prove they used a formula that they knew was wrong for it to be fraud?
They could know the formula was wrong - inherently every measurement is wrong to some extent which is why you see a +/- error, that is not fraud.
For it to be fraud, they would need to measure it in the way they claim to, get a result they dont like, and report it as <5% anyway (with intent to defraud people). Which could happen in theory, but seems highly unlikely.
If I recall correctly, Twitter says they had no obligation to provide the firehose to Musk, but they did anyway. Musk had issues with rate limit, but twitter fixed it in reasonable time.
Wasn't him collecting all of this MAU stuff to analyze it part of the due diligence needed in order to close the deal?
You do your diligence BEFORE signing the merger agreement.
But, hey, we’re all here speculating anyway! My take is:
1) He’s a history of making impulsive decisions without thinking (or caring) about the consequences.
2) It forced Twitter’s hand because they couldn’t act like it was it a non-genuine offer.
3) He’s so rarely held accountable for the consequences of his decisions he knew it didn’t matter because he’s above the law.
Also, anybody who thinks accusing a rescue diver of pedophilia purely because he told them not to interfere with rescue efforts is pretty far from being a genius. Musk has been lucky his whole life, people just rarely see his failures.
Basically, his press is full of shit. The claim that he learned to program and wrote a video game at age 10 is quite ridiculous. Seriously, there are online websites where you can play his "game". It's Space Invaders, except theirs only one alien, you can't have multiple projectiles on the screen at the same time, the alien doesn't fire at you unless they get extremely close, if the alien fires at you it locks your controls making it virtually impossible to dodge and prevents you from firing back, and when you successfully hit the alien it immediately respawns at a random location which may be in range of you, resulting in you immediately dying. My own nephew programmed significantly more impressive games at age 10, will people start following him and assume he's never made any mistakes if someone who owns an emerald mine gives him hundreds of millions of dollars to invest into new technologies and the businesses don't ultimately fail?
That’s a pretty weighty fact on the scale of “Musk - canny businessperson, or remarkable streak of being in the right place at the right time.”
This next bit is mainly speculation, but the reason Musk is actually trying to back out is partly to do with the fact that signing the merger contract caused his other companies stock prices to drop and public speculation that his existing business would suffer if he needed to focus on running Twitter. The second and more widely believed version of events is that partly due in fact to his other stock prices dropping, Musk cannot afford Twitter without having to sell more of Tesla and SpaceX than he is willing to. Musk is already down to owning only 17% of Tesla and less than 50% of SpaceX, although that's complicated as some percentage of Tesla is owned by SpaceX and vice versa along with the Boring company in such a way that Musk effectively has majority control over SpaceX whenever he wants. If he has to sell additional stock to cover the purchase of Twitter he would very likely lose the ability to control everything except possibly the Boring Company.
What's more, the contract he signed effectively puts him in a position of buying Twitter at a substantial loss as the stock market has significantly fallen since Musk signed the deal. He would effectively be losing significant control of his two primary sources of wealth in exchange for something he has likely since discovered he cannot run the way he wants.
In short, this was a bad move financially when Musk first announced his intentions, it was extremely foolish of him to waive due diligence, and it became financially even worse shortly after he signed the deal, partly due to the facts that people lost trust in him for waiving due diligence while making a financially inadvisable move, partly due to the fact that he's actually pretty bad at math and doesn't understand the stock market, and partly because the stock market took a nose dive right after he foolishly waived due diligence and signed such a financially ruinous deal.
If you're thinking Musk is smarter than I'm making him out to be, please consider that Musk tried to insert himself into a cave rescue he had nothing to do with, was told not to interfere with the professionals that know what they're doing, and retaliated to being told to butt out by publicly accusing the rescue team lead of being a pedophile despite knowing nothing about the man.
Trying to offer to help without really understanding the situation isn't necessarily a bad thing, but randomly accusing someone of being a pedophile because they were critical of you is so far beyond acceptable behavior it's amazing Musk wasn't banned from Twitter as a result (it was where he made the accusation publicly). That level of harassment violates Twitter's ToS, plain and simple.
As someone who's unfamiliar with this, could you explain what's banana-pants insane about a company inflating their hard-to-discover numbers, for profit? I thought that was, unfortunately, banana-pants standard? For example, the fiction that is Twitter or Reddit's user count.
> Additionally, our calculation of mDAU is not based on any standardized industry methodology and is not necessarily calculated in the same manner or comparable to similarly titled measures presented by other companies. Similarly, our measures of mDAU growth and engagement may differ from estimates published by third parties or from similarly titled metrics of our competitors due to differences in methodology.
They covered themselves very clearly, and Musk has no standing here. He knew this, and decided to waive his due diligence and buy anyways.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1418091/000141809120...
"If our twitter bid succeeds, we will defeat the spam bots or die trying!"
*Tried to write “chumps,” but liked the typo better.
It's not "users who use our website or 1st party apps", it's "monetizable daily active users", which may be similar to the group of users you described, but most importantly Twitter can choose not to show any ads (or not to charge money for ads shown) to bot accounts.
So even if Twitter only had 1 single non-bot user, as long as that's the only user they are "monetizing" they would be at 0% of mDAUs being bots.
Therefore, as jcranmer commented elsewhere in this thread, the 5% is actually their estimate of their own false negative rate of detecting bots (i.e. deciding which accounts can be monetised vs not).
I am shocked, just shocked that a company with six billion dollars of cash on hand is able to afford good enough lawyers who make their SEC reports ironclad against shareholder lawsuits. Who would've thought.
If the methods were reasonable is of course possible, but up for debate and at least questionable.
If there's an actual industry standard then you could argue that Twitter is lying. However as everyone in the legal community knows there are two important concepts here: wilfulness and negligence. Did Twitter willfully do this or is this just because there isn't an actual standard methodology but tried to do their best-effort anyways? Is Twitter aware of problems in its methodology that can be solved but were left as-is? Conversely, did an external party intentionally misinterpreted those numbers so that that party can paint a different picture that what Twitter actually claims?
https://www.scienceabc.com/innovation/why-do-hard-drivesusb-...
If said I count GB as 512MB, the court would say “nobody else does that, you’re just trying to defraud people, your disclaimer is not in good faith”.
E.g. Can they 100% say that there are less than 5% bot accounts, or is that 5% number being pulled out of their ass - and saying "less than 20% of accounts are bots" would hold as much water? That is therefore then a misrepresentation, fraud IMHO - and stockholders should be suing not only Twitter but also the SEC.
Also, then there is the fact that Elon apparently even didn't believe this number. So even if he proves it's faked and the court agrees that this is actually a major dealbreaker (which is already near impossible), Twitter could still argue that he was completely aware of the bot situation when he made the offer.
Home inspectors follow well-established practices. Bot estimation for Twitter has no such analog. The closest might be the seller saying they've seen rats but never looked into it. You say fine, I'm buying to clean it up anyway; waive inspection rights; commit and then discover a rat's nest.
Unless you can show the seller knew about the problem and lied about it, you're going to get your case thrown out of court. Now add multimillion dollar teams of lawyers and bankers advising each side prior to entering into the transaction and we have an approximation of the stupidity of this case.
And that's acceptable there isn't well-established/widely accepted practices?
Certainly Twitter and SEC will argue that to protect themselves from scrutiny and legal issues they likely deserve.
All company figures involve some level of trust that they’re based on correct processes as signed off by audit firms. For areas of material interest you’re supposed to do due diligence before signing final offers, but Musk explicitly waived that for some bizarre reason.
So, what might really be going on is: Twitter's able to detect that less than 5% of users are unsophisticated bots, but they're unable to determine how much of the remaining 95% are sophisticated bots that accurately enough mimic human behaviour; and so it's not possible to genuinely say "less than 5% are bots."
For one, this is not about what percentage of Twitter users are bots.
Nor have you accurately or fairly described Twitter’s methodology for verifying their mDAU figures.
The allegation is saying not only that Twitter has been lying about that number--for years, on documents that land it in legal hot water if it's been lying--but that it was doing so specifically so that Musk would buy Twitter at an inflated price. The insane part is really that specific intent, not the lying about the numbers.
0: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/03/10/nearly-48-million-twitter-ac...
> our estimates suggest that between 9% and 15% of active Twitter accounts are bots
From Twitter: “roughly 5% of our monetizable daily users are bots”.
Both can be true at the same time, and it does not mean that Twitter lied.
5% of users is not a claim that Twitter made.
The insanity is people being perfectionistic in that it was specific intent to target him to buy it - even if it says "him" - it's absurd that people are taking that literally, and not simply to "make it seem valuable for someone to buy."
Actually, even logged-out users (until they forced everyone to log in to read timelines) are monetizable, so Musk is really trying to make something to get out.
Any businessman who gets into such a position, even by mistake, would have at least taken this opportunity to require Twitter’s methodology on counting bots an expose its flaws. The claim would be something tangible like “This account is a bot and your criteria falsely counts it as a user.”
Not “Really there are 5% bots? Everybody, look!” He looks more like an engineer who can’t stand the fact that ballpark numbers are a decent way to do business in a lot of cases.
It’s crazy because it would probably be BETTER if you had more bots. Then you could say that your revenue per user was higher and you could argue that you had more room for growth. So, if anything, lying and OVERestimating the bot count would help your valuation more.
So the fact that he's using his reason for buying to try and get out of buying seems... Insane.
As a human, it's annoying to get get a reply notification only to discover it was bot spam, but from the platform perspective that bot just created user activity and content for you for free.
I have a theory that the most embarrassing thing to come out of this might be that Twitter doesn't really care about bots much more than issuing platitudes that they care about bots to assuage the user base.
In the past I tried to write bots that do things like reply to people, but that is a violation of the TOS and twitter would immediately identify and ban the account.
I guess this is similar to the "reality distortion field" people claim Jobs had. Except the examples given there were more of him not believing people who said something couldn't be done.
Jobs did bullshit, but AFAIK more on the design and marketing side than on the business side (give or take the backdated stock option thing and his first stint at Apple, when he wasn’t in control). Certainly nothing like Musk’s shenanigans.
Don't forget Jobs' prime role in having companies collude together to depress wages by not recruiting each other's employees:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
"an interconnected web of express agreements, each with the active involvement and participation of a company under the control of Steve Jobs...and/or a company that shared at least one member of Apple's board of directors."
Yes, indeed! I forgot to mention that.
He offers to buy twitter on a whim, then changes his mind after signing a contract. That doesn't really seem like a good way of getting to the top.
Levine covered it well here:
https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-07-09/elon-s...
He could lose the entire amount he pledged.
There's nothing in the contract about a billion dollars fee for any other reason of the sale not going through.
Of course, a judge could choose to take that number as the amount to punish with, but it's not a price Musk can just choose to pay to get out of the deal.
Personally, I want the court to rule for specific performance (ie. Pay the $44 billion) He fucked up.
On one hand, venture-funded hockeystick-startups like Twitter definitely aim for a quick exit to make cash, so it's not totally out of the blue. On the other hand, Twitter is publicly traded and therefore already had its exit.
LOL, their SEC filings basically say “these are our numbers but they’re highly subjective and could be way off”. Musk is either a liar or an idiot.
TWTR is only down 1.6% YTD.
* SNAP is down 80%
* PINS is down 40%
* FB is down 50%
A good chunk of TWTR's current valuation is now being propped up by Elon's buyout offer. Elon could be looking at paying a 100-125% premium on what should be the fair market value for Twitter. Twitter's board should care deeply about getting as much value here as possible.
Why would Twitter want to negotiate on a new price? There's already the agreement at a high price - why would they go lower?
BUT, accusing Twitter of actual federal and state crimes is going to raise the awareness of several regulatory bodies, so this is going to get hairy.
You might get some red state DA eager for some publicity to make a song and dance about it for a bit, but that’s it.
If Musk’s team could produce actual data and evidence of criminal law breaches they’d be reporting them to authorities not adding them as minor points in a civil suit filing in Delaware.
I don’t think that’s the argument. Twitter is an ad supported business. As such, the incentive is to count the “monthly active users” rather higher than lower. Specifically, there us no incentive to make an effort to exclude automated accounts from that number at all.
This describes the entire business model of WeWork (minus the self-dealing), why should Twitter be different?
The choice for Twitter boils down to what level of price cut are they willing to make to remove that possibility.
As they should have been, as it’s a sound enough process given constraints and doesn’t need to be 100% accurate. They have nothing to worry about.
I agree with you that they seem confident, but the entire back and forth around mDAU originated with Musk and my belief is that choice of dispute was taken in the interest of setting things up so they won't actually go to court. The gambit of course may fail and it may go to court.
Musk is trying to pretend the mDAU = number of active bots. It’s dishonest, and likely designed to hurt the company and tank its share price and therefore bully it into conceding. Given the strength of their case I don’t see that happening.
Not a lawyer, so could you explain why this is banana-pants insanity? There's malicious fraud (unlikely) and then there's the more likely case of under-investing in bot-detection and expunging efforts, e.g. "in favor of other priorities", to keep DAUs and subsequently valuations high for a potential sale.
First, only Twitter knows which users are active (the population being analyzed are the DAUs). People doing bot analysis from publicly available define activity based on the account tweeting, which will probably skew heavily toward spam bots.
Second, the mDAU metric is the DAUs with known bots having been removed. Nobody outside of Twitter knows which active accounts were excluded by Twitter from the metric. Even if 50% of Twitter DAUs are bots, as long as Twitter detects 90% of them as bots and marks them as non-monetized, the 5% number stands.
Third, nobody outside of Twitter can actually do a proper job of evaluating whether an account is a bot, since they have orders of magnitude more signals than a simple tweet stream / public profile information.
Twitters methology is far better than any publicly available bot detection would be, but the flipside is that it's not a replicable methodology.
This is true of most material statements provided by companies in every industry:
- Revenue? Trust the company, I cannot independently verify from outside the company.
- Retail same-store sales comparable? Have to trust the company's numbers.
- Headcount? I have to trust their number again here.
- Expenses? I have no way to verify this unless I work at the company, in a very senior position.
Outside verification of data is not a concern relevant to corporate disclosures.
So it cannot be replicated by third parties, and Musk does not know what he’s talking about (shocker!), but it can be verified a posteriori. And I assume it will be at some point.
Maybe Musk hopes to find something in discovery to discredit the process, e.g. evidence of the process not being followed, or of the numbers being tampered with.
Indeed. But surely they have at least internal audits. They seem like they take this stuff seriously.
> I look forward to finding what kind of a kook Musk finds as his expert
Indeed! If he picks his experts like his lawyers, this could be spectacular.
> e.g. evidence of the process not being followed, or of the numbers being tampered with
Yeah, he sounds like he’s hoping to find a smoking gun where some Twitter higher-up admits fudging the numbers. To be fair, if that is true, then Twitter deserves to be raked over the coals, even though it would not be sufficient to get Musk out of this mess.
* Twitter committed fraud by lying to the SEC about the mDAU numbers with the intent of inducing Musk to buy Twitter at an inflated price. No, really, this is the allegation (see paragraphs 202-206).
* Count 2 is that Twitter committed [Texas fraud statute] by lying when it offered its shares. It's shotgun-pled, so I don't know which specific statements are supposed to be wrong, but I'm imagining it's basically the previous count recast under a different statute.
* Count 3 says that Twitter broke the contract by failing to provide information.
* Count 4 says that Twitter broke the contract by instituting a hiring freeze. [not gonna fly, especially when Musk admitted that Twitter gave him warning of what it was doing and Musk didn't respond. Did I mention that Musk's answer admits far more than I would have expected?]
* Count 5 is pretty please declare that Twitter lying about mDAUs is a materially adverse event that is cause to break the contract.
I still can't get over the banana-pants insanity of the first count... arguing that Twitter lied about its numbers for years specifically so that someone would buy it at an inflated price?