Also, I know there are probably better ways to finance a city, but that's how we currently do it. It should be done fairly, ideally we should meet in the middle. It's fundamentally unfair that some folks pay up to 10x or more than others. I'm speaking personally, but it really bothers me that my neighbors are actually OK with this.
Also, there are lots of ways to ensure elderly/retired folks can stay in their homes. Taxes can be deferred.
That’s mostly gone now with Prop 19. It used to be that children could inherit apartment buildings, multiple houses, commercial buildings, with no new tax assessment. Now, children can only inherit a parent’s primary residence without a new tax assessment. Even then, they can only avoid a tax increase up to the first $1m in value and only if the children live in the property. If they keep it as a rental, they lose the benefit.
The change should result in more properties being sold after inheritance, which will increase market supply and lower prices.
If you believe that, then why ratchet them up just because the property is sold? If you're going to detach property taxes from the value of the property, then do it for new homeowners too.
If we are scaling property taxes with the property's value, we might as well do it for everyone and not treat people special just because they were living there longer. Other costs people deal with scale at least by local cost of living. Groceries, electricity, water service, etc. all increase year after year. Do we let people pay 1960s costs for everything else just because they happened to move to the area in 1960?
Prop 13 as it currently stands, is a wealth transfer from young, new homeowners to elderly, established homeowners.
An argument here is that it's about budgeting and predictability.
If I choose to buy a $1M property today, I need to consider and budget for the $10K+/yr in taxes on it because I know full well that's what I'll have to pay. If that doesn't work for me, I don't have to buy it.
But someone who bought a $50K property and responsibly budgeted for the $500 in taxes on it will be severely punished through no fault of their own if that $500 becomes $10K.
They did not "make a leveraged bet". They bought a home to live in and watch their child grow in it.
Not everyone looks at real estate as a investment vehicle to maximize profits. It's just a home. It's not healthy for society to view homes merely as if they were shares of stock to be traded for maximum value. If you want to make leveraged bets, better to play the options market.
Don't think of it as an investment to flip. Think of it as home. After the purchase, no need to ever look at the property value estimates again. Just live it.
Maybe your feel good spiel would make sense if price-to-rent ratios weren't the highest but that's not the case. Most of what you pay for here is a bet that values will go up. If it weren't for stupid laws like Prop 13 that only help land speculation this wouldn't be the case.
It's an insanely unfair system.
I agree that scaling property taxes with their values is bad. Not sure why government expenses magically double when housing value do.
Ideally living people will move out and make room for the next generation when they no longer have use for 4 bedrooms in a good school district close to jobs.
Beyond split roll, do you have ideas to 1) protect people that would be harmed by an immediate rollback of 13 and 2) build the political coalition to get it done?
2) no. As long as California is a direct democracy the law will stay. Even Prop 15 failed so any chance of reform through the existing process is doomed. Justice Stevens echos this point here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/90-1912.ZD.html I suppose that maybe with billions of lobbying and ad spend we could Prop 22 a repeal through but even then I doubt it.
The only way I see it happening is if the courts strike it down as unconstitutional. Equal protection is applied stronger on issues of race and Nordlinger v Hahn didn't address that. We now can see real data that Prop 13 systemically hurts minorities and I believe another challenge is warranted.
Edit: actually should have talked about "disparate impact" instead in that last part.
If want to cry unfair, then it would be better to aim at commercial real estate. That's a pure money business. Why should they get protection under prop 13? Make no sense at all.
Why should some whose house went from $200k to $2M be getting a tax break?
Because they bought a 200K house and budgeted for taxes on a 200K house.
The paper estimate of it being worth 2M right now doesn't change anything about the house they actually live in.
It is absurd and an anomaly. Let them stay, but when the reap a $1M+ profit on the house when they sell or die, they can pony up the tax, just like everyone else.
I did not say that so I don't mean that.
If a low/middle class person buy the house they can afford to pay and live in it, they don't become millionaires just because other people around them bought houses more expensively later. They're most likely still in the same career earning that same low/middle class income. They don't have any additional money to pay much higher property taxes, they are certainly not millionaires.
Tax them after sale, sure, if the property value is still high when they sell (it might not be).
If they budgeted for a 200k house, that turned into a 2M house, they should be ecstatic when they sell it, the government takes the property taxes and they still get to keep more than 200k.
This is satire. Please do not take it seriously.
Oh great I'll take one of those. Maybe two. Where do I sign up?
This is double true when the value went up without any change to the structure. Structures depreciate, and become less valuable over time. When property values go up in California, it's almost entire land value that goes up. The value increase isn't from the labor of the land owner, it's just simple rentierism.
Land gets more valuable because of what one can access close to it: jobs, relationships, people, universities. All this value is socially created. This sort of wealth hoarding is hugely damaging to the economy, and all sorts of thinkers revered by people in the US have nothing but the worst possible words for it, from Adam Smith to Thomas Paine.
It is quite strange for the wealthiest members of a community to depend upon the less wealthy to fund a community, but that's what Prop 13 is all about. This situation, where the wealthy could buy their way out of taxation, is a lot of what led to the French Revolution.
This is literally the opposite. If you buy (a property), you'll have the taxes based on what you bought. You can't buy your way to a lower tax rate.
I wouldn't phrase it that way because it's not what they did, even if decades down the road it turned out that way (it could well have gone the other way like it did for homeowners in Detroit years ago).
What they did was buy a home they could afford, based on monthly mortgage + taxes payments, which is the entirely reasonable and responsible thing to do.
Having the property tax balloon out of control and out of any conceivable affordable range due to actions of other people in the area, is hardly fair.
The older the wealth, the lower the taxes.
And, surprise surprise, that class is white people.
https://twitter.com/alfred_twu/status/1327821019931787264?s=...
Makes sense given that minorities were at large disadvantages to buy property in the past so mostly whites have been able to take advantage on the low tax rates. I'm surprised this isn't getting challenged in court. Nordlinger v Hahn didn't consider race.
It's bizarre how much Prop 13 appeals to folks, even those who don't benefit from it. When you explain it to people, their initial reaction is to express worry about the millionaires who own the houses that have quintupled in value, as though they are in need of protection.
I hope someone eventually finds the right sales pitch to get rid of it: the policy distorts not only price but liquidity.
It should appeals to anyone who buys a house at any age.
Without Prop 13, home owners tax rates rise just because nearby businesses are successful, which is absurdly regressive.
Prop 13 appeals to and benefits people who don’t own real-estate yet, because it means that when they can do so, they know that their costs will be predictable, and they won’t be forced out of their homes by the next wave of IPOs or whatever else beyond their control (such as government money printing) pushes prices up.
Prop 13 definitely doesn't benefit people who don't own real estate because property owners have an incentive not to sell: they can keep their lower tax rate and their expensive home! This restricts supply and raises property prices.
Property owners should be able to keep an affordable tax and their home, regardless of what their home cost.
Raising property taxes based on market values, is taxing people based on how much other people want their homes.
I agree that property taxes should be reformed.
Let’s not make houses even more risky and expensive to own.
Instead, let’s fund public services in other ways, so school quality isn’t dependent on the average income bracket of the neighborhood, for example.
Property tax - especially on the land value rather than the improvements - is good. It can provide a feedback of the cost of what someone is using.
Funding schools based on tiny districts is of course a poor policy, and local taxes -- be it property taxes, income taxes, corporate taxes, sales tax, fees, whatever -- shouldn't be what dictates the funding of local schools. That's really a separate question.
> That's really a separate question.
Schools are just one example of a service funded by property taxes.
It’s not a separate question at all.
> Property tax - especially on the land value rather than the improvements - is good. It can provide a feedback of the cost of what someone is using.
What you are calling ‘value’ in this case is just a measure of how much other people want the property. It has nothing whatsoever to do with cost.
This just makes it easier for even richer people to take existing property rather than invest in developing other places.
Allocating resources to the people who want it most (and presumably make the most of it) seems like a good goal to have. Wouldn't that be the most effective use of resources?
Estimated property price doesn’t measure how much the existing owner wants the property.
If they don’t want to sell it, we can safely assume that they want it more than the other people do.
If that wasn't the case, developers wouldn't want to build denser buildings.
Consider how much would it cost to get a standalone house with a sizable yard on Manhattan?
More density usually doesn’t come close to satisfying actual demand, but it does make the existing real estate more valuable.
> but it does make the existing real estate more valuable.
No it doesn't. Existing real estate is valuable because there is a mismatch between commercial and residential real estate. By building more residential real estate you are reducing the mismatch.
But sure - Prop 13 and new building are separate issues.
[1] page 4: https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/rr07-14_obr...
My guess is that other downsides, real and imagined, make people overestimate the impact on prices.
People who bought may feel more entitled to a stake than renters, but in either case it's necessary to have some kind of incentive (high property tax) to drive out people who don't want to pay the market rate for living somewhere, so that available housing slots end up being given to those people who are willing to pay the most for them.
What makes you think it was luck?
How about people who saw the potential in a place before other people did, and contributed to its success?
How about ordinary working class families who have lived there for generations?
> should entitle you to enjoy living there forever when others are willing to pay more for the same home.
I don’t see why people with money should have the right to force people out of their homes.
> that available housing slots end up being given to those people who are willing to pay the most for them
I see, so this is about people with lots of money being able to force people out of their homes.
Why are there limited slots? Why not just invest in other places? There are many underdeveloped towns even in California, where prices are cheaper.
The market signal is that people should go and invest in those places.
Why don't they move to a more equitable tax scheme based on, say, what the district requires rather than what the home was bought for? I already know the answer, because nobody would vote for it.
It is the same in Berlin, where I live. People voted for the Mietendeckel but the only group of people that benefitted from it are the long-term renters who already have all the house they need. Among the screwed: small-time landlords, new renters and new families who need bigger apartments.
Contributed to its success by following a tax policy that encourages commercial real estate at the expense of residential real estate? Are you sure those people aren't just taking the jobs that the commercial real estate is providing hostage and are now extorting people for the privilege of living near the job?
>The market signal is that people should go and invest in those places.
No, the market literally screams into your face that you should build more housing and fix the commercial vs residential mismatch.
Agreed. Opposition to prop13 essentially is a statement saying that whoever has more money because they hit it rich on an IPO deserves the right to kick out established residents just because they have more money.
What should buying a home mean if not that? Sure, if someone else is willing to pay a lot more, they're welcome to bid on it, but it's still up to you if you want to give that up and stay put where you have roots, friends, family, kids in school, etc.
If others are willing to pay more for the same home, then they should make the current owner of the home an offer.
(This is somewhat ameliorated by the fact we let people take the tax subsidy with them under many circumstances now, so people can move to a different part of the state and already pay less tax.)
A home is a home. Where your children are born and grow up. Where you get to know the neighbors and become part of the community.
It's not an investment and should not be taxed based on the highest bidder.
They have risen because nobody resists commercial development, only residential development. The reason? Commercial real estate still brings in taxes and it increases home values which also increases property taxes on homes. The insistence to only reap the benefits of commercial development without further residential development is what is causing problems in the first place.
Most other states regularly reassess the property of your home for taxation purposes and many have mechanisms to reduce tax liability of people living in their homes(vs renting them out) or seniors.
In california however due to prop 13, both the state and the city are forced to find different ways to pay for their costs, such as raising sales tax(which went up significantly since passing of prop 13 in 1978) or passing local bond measures to pay for schools, sewage etc.
The only people who win are those who won a lottery of being able to afford a home in CA 10/20/30 years ago.
Not as much as you seem to think. California’s nominal property tax rates are low (also due to Prop 13), so property taxes start low when you buy and get lower over time. The things that most people pay property taxes for in other places are paid for out of other local taxes, or redistribution of state taxes (e.g., sales tax) revenue to local governments.
> Most other states regularly reassess the property of your home for taxation purposes
So does California, annually; it just limits the annual increase of the assessed value.
At first yes, but over time you become one of the people who pays relatively less compared to new buyers.
Nobody won a lottery 10 , 20 or 30 years ago.
If you buy a home today, then in 10, 20, 30 years time people will be saying you won the lottery.
No one is saying that if someone makes a bunch of money, they don't get the money. Your assets go up, that's yours. We're just saying that they shouldn't also have the government reducing their taxes so other people can pay them.
Can you explain how?
I’m not turning anything into a virtue.
I’m just stating the fact that the deal has been the same for everyone.
You seem to be trying to change the deal to make it even more onerous to own property.
> government reducing their taxes so other people can pay them
That just isn’t what you are saying. Prop 13 doesn’t reduce people’s taxes.
It only limits the rate at which they can be increased.
You want taxes on existing property owners to be increased so they can no longer afford to live there, and can be replaced by people who have more money.
Yes, people who want to build more housing and lower prices in the long term.
Wow, if this is intended then this is a literal ponzi scheme. I always assumed that it was an unintended side effect but people are actually banking on this? That's crazy.
So we should all be looking forward to the Utopia where dumpy old single family homes are selling for checks notes $15M.
You’ll get no argument for me on that one.
Property taxes are an absolutely terrible way to fund local government.
Other countries don’t do it that way, and there is no reason we should.
England for example just has a flat tax per person living in a given county or borough, with some exemptions for people who don’t have enough income.
Income taxes, sales taxes and business taxes are of course other possibilities.
Taxing economic activity on the basis that a well serviced community supports that activity is very reasonable.
Yes - why don’t we invest in places where house prices are lower?
Stockton keeps being mentioned.
The incentives are for people to live there and for businesses to set up offices there, and amenities to be created for the people who live and work there.
Why would you be against developing areas that are not as nice right now?
There is an old quote. "Why do people rob banks? Because that is where the money is." Whatever benefits of the area are why people were willing to pay higher prices. It is good for not as nice areas to develop but trying to bootstrapping a less developed area is also expensive with fewer guarantees of demand in the area. It is like trying to go max density zoning from the start in Sim City and having massive bills and no demand. "Retirement communities" are the main demand for those cheaper niches and even then they have other demands to fulfill like medical care.
Nobody is talking about bootstrapping demand in less developed areas.
Elsewhere people were talking about how people were being forced to buy houses in places like Stockton because they couldn’t afford to buy them in Cupertino.
So the demand is already there.
One complaint was that those people have to travel a long way to get to work.
One dystopian solution to this is to use taxes to confiscate property from people who live near employees, so that workers can live there temporarily.
Another way is for companies to open offices in places where their workers can afford to live, contributing to the creation of more attractive communities as they do so.
Clearly not, otherwise people would move there. As it turns out, network effects exist, causing jobs to be near each other and for some reason people like to be close to their jobs rather than commuting 90 minutes from Stockton.
>Why would you be against developing areas that are not as nice right now?
These aren't mutually exclusive and you know that.
Comments elsewhere claim people are moving there since housing is cheaper there.
> As it turns out, network effects exist, causing jobs to be near each other and for some reason people like to be close to their jobs rather than commuting 90 minutes from Stockton.
That can be solved by building offices in Stockton.
Businesses expanding out of areas that are too expensive is a good thing.
Forcing people out of their homes so that businesses have access to a bigger pool of workers without needing to open more offices just seems like corporate welfare, forcing yet another externality onto both employees and the nearby community.
>Why would you be against developing areas that are not as nice right now?
> These aren't mutually exclusive and you know that.
The choice to live on one place versus another is mutually exclusive.
The argument seems to be that older people should be taxed out of homes near successful businesses so that current workers can live nearer to workplaces. (And they in turn should be taxed more so that they too move out as soon as they can).
That seems to be very much about businesses not needing to expand to areas in need of development.
The revenue is very stable and dependable. Even in the depths of the 2009 dowturn, almost all California counties still had slightly increasing tax rolls. Assuming most municipal business is pretty stable, this would seem to be a good match.
Other states solve this in other ways. In Washington state, the overall assessment for a municipality can only go up slightly each year, but individual property assessments are not limited, so you can still have your share of the tax go up a lot if your neighborhood is assessed higher and other neighborhoods in the municipality are assessed lower.
No, it's not.
Which is why California local government relies on special districts funded by Mello-Roos charges (essentially property taxes that are flat per unit rather than value based, and are outside of the Prop 13 limits) and large transfers of state revenue for funding ever since Prop 13 restricted the top nominal property tax rate in California to much lower than effective property tax rates in the US as a whole rolled back valuations on existing property so that people weren't then paying full rate, and restricted the rate of increase of assessed value.
> The revenue is very stable and dependable
And very low, forcing reliance on taxes that are less stable and reliable than property taxes would be without the Prop 13 assessment increase limit, which is a net loss of stability.
Stability might be a decent argument for something like the assessment increase limit (if you ignore the distributional inequities) without the ultralow nominal rate limit, but to avoid reliance on other means you'd have to raise the nominal rate to target the desired effective rate given age and value distribution observed.
I'd like my city to have a stable source of funding, so we don't have problems issuing bonds and don't have to cut school funding during a recession.
As pointed out by another commenter - this is exactly what Prop 13 provides.
Taxes are predictable for owners, which by definition makes them predicable for local governments too.
It is exactly a compromise - property is still taxed, but in a stable and predictable way.
> Property taxes are an absolutely terrible way to fund local government. Other countries don’t do it that way, and there is no reason we should.
What did you mean? I was replying to that assertion by pointing out the benefits of taxing property as a means to fund local government.
We're talking about millionaires, not vulnerable victims.
Millions of them are also retired or on SS and if they had to pay market value property taxes they would be not be able to. Take a huge profit and leave, for where? You've lived somewhere most of your life and should be kicked to Stockton?
For some reason I hear Tom Selleck's voice talking about reverse mortgages. There's a winner for public policy.
As it is today, young families are the ones buying in far out places like Tracy, Stockton, etc., and they still might pay higher property taxes than a retiree in the heart of the Bay Area. It seems backwards to me to have an incentive structure that keeps the labor force farther from work than retirees.
That is a problem that we don’t have to solve by destroying communities through eviction.
We can build workplaces where property is affordable, and those communities can develop into attractive places to live, and their property prices will rise too.
It seems like a weird non-goal to try to create a society where there are only a few places where there is work and amenities.
The natural response to one place becoming too expensive is to invest in making more places where people can live and work.
There are multiple ways to destroy a community. Apparently, one way is to artificially cap tax on long-time residents until only old people are left.
[1] https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/09/14/cupertino-district-pl...
I am convinced that California is hell on earth. It's designed to maximize human suffering and when you tell Californians how to get rid of the heat they tell you that they like it this way and actually would like it even more if it was hotter.
That is due to wage stagnation, not prop 13.
> Median household income (in 2019 dollars), 2015-2019
> Cupertino: $171,917 [1]
> USA: $62,843 [2]
[1] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/cupertinocityca...
[2] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/INC110219#IN...
It’s because wages haven’t grown in line with investment returns over time.
This is not controversial, and is nothing to do with Prop 13 or whether Cupertino has a higher average income than other US cities.
Trying to tax people out of homes because someone else wants them just means underinvestment in other communities.
"Beat it grandpa; young people want to live here now..."
1. Move
2. Take out a loan
3. Take in a boarder
4. Refuse to pay and know they will not be evicted for their lien (this could be codified statewide if this were the real problem)
I don't know why anyone would think that poorer, less-established people should be paying for these millionaires to stay there.
She will die soon enough. You can wait.
Better yet, you can do what she did many decades ago. Get a house built on undesirable land, then be part of a community that makes the value go up. The home you now covet is only valuable because of people like her. Nothing stops you from doing likewise. Pick some crummy land out in Mississippi or West Virginia and create a community.
We can roll-back prop 13 going forward for properties purchased some buffer of time after the new law goes into effect, without harming your grandma.
Why don’t you go somewhere where prices are cheaper and make a nice community there?
If her property taxes aren't artificially constrained by prop 13, she'll see her taxes go up over time, and decide how much she values staying in the house and paying the increasing taxes, versus retiring sooner or investing her resources in other areas of her life. The market at work.
Also, ideally we wouldn't simply remove prop 13, but replace it with a better, progressive-not-regressive tax code, eg. allowing homeowners of limited means to defer portions of their property taxes until the sale of their property. This would make it easy for grandma to stay put, and be vastly more fair and healthy for society than the status quo.
> Why don’t you go somewhere where prices are cheaper and make a nice community there?
Would you rephrase this in a kinder way please?
Incentivize usually means offering something to someone to make something attractive.
That is not what you are proposing. You are proposing to take away her money by force until she can’t afford to live there.
> If her property taxes aren't artificially constrained by prop 13
Taxes that rise based on a tax inspector estimating the value of an unsold property are at least as artificial as taxing based on transactions. There is nothing ‘natural’ about property taxes. It’s a system constructed and imposed by the local government.
> she'll see her taxes go up over time
Yes, through no fault of her own, if and only if other people continue to drive up prices.
> and decide how much she values staying in the house and paying the increasing taxes
Agreed. If other people drive up the price, they’ll be able to force her out of her home.
> Society benefits from incentivizing her to move, so that more humans can occupy the space she is currently occupying, which will improve regional productivity, reduce highway and transit overcrowding, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, all sorts of good stuff.
A kinder way would be - why force grandma to move, when not doing so would bring all of these benefits to areas which need them more, and frankly, have better incentives in the form of currently lower costs?
I don't see why (2) or (4) would affect her lifestyle much.
> Better yet, you can do what she did many decades ago. Get a house built on undesirable land, then be part of a community that makes the value go up. The home you now covet is only valuable because of people like her. Nothing stops you from doing likewise. Pick some crummy land out in Mississippi or West Virginia and create a community.
I don't follow any of this. I don't understand why this viewpoint would mean it makes sense that people who have made tons of money should contribute less of it to their societies.
Winning by taking from others ain't the goal. When new people arrive, they should be getting the same deal from the government you are, not getting hosed because they're less established.
(Obviously your prescience is rewarded: you made tons of money on your house.)
But that’s just it - they do get the same deal.
Everyone pays the same percentage of what their house cost when they buy it.
Grandma got the same deal you do.
If you buy a house now, it too will be worth more if you wait 30 years.
You just have to wait as long as grandma did. That is literally the same deal.
> If you buy a house now, it too will be worth more if you wait 30 years.
It might be. Or I might have bought it in Redding or Vicksburg and pay tax on the market value, same as my neighbors who buy today. Prop 13 only kicks in meaningfully for people who basically won the lottery, in proportion to their gains.
To do that, it distorts the market, adding friction to what is already a market with unhealthily-high friction.
Grandma already paid her taxes and now you want to force her out of her home.
Have properties in Redding or Vicksburg not appreciated in the last 30 years?
> Prop 13 only kicks in meaningfully for people who basically won the lottery
You keep saying ‘won the lottery’, when what you mean is they bought a property in a place where properties appreciated in value.
That just sounds like a good investment decision.
I guess they can all move to trailer parks in the Mojave and make way for the real millionaires.
Basically, for residential properties, keep the existing Prop 13 tax increase logic, but apply the difference in taxes between the Prop 13 rate and the real rate as a lien against the property, to be paid when it changes hands.
That preserves the (utterly unfounded) objection of "throwing out grandma on the street", while still recouping unpaid tax. There are some complexities with the lien happening for a very long time, like that happens when the lien matches the property value, but as long the lien is strictly called in, they should be minor.
I don’t know why anyone would think that they are.
Just allow a homeowner to defer taxes until sale or death. When the house is eventually sold the city can get back their $800,000 in back taxes, with interest.
That’s what my Canadian province does.
And the govt already provides healthcare for retirees. It’s called Medicare.
And how can the govt afford to provide healthcare and such when people sitting on assets with million dollar appreciation don’t pay any tax on it?
Also, no, they wouldn't have to move to Stockton, they wouldn't have to leave their home town. Sell your house for $2M, buy two condos, for $1M million each, move into one of them, rent out the other, and you're set for life, and you will still have your original $2M to pass to your grandchildren after you die. Or you can invest your $2M in ETF, and live in the rented condo, cashing $100k of capital gains profits every year.
For someone with $2M (or 1.5M, or even 1M) net worth possibilities are endless and living off of taxpayers money shouldn't be one of them.
Does this apply to all people who have $2M regardless of whether it’s invested in a house?
> For someone with $2M (or 1.5M, or even 1M) net worth possibilities are endless and living off of taxpayers money shouldn't be one of them.
It isn’t one of them.
Is supposed to be some joke? You know, if people knew they were going to get knocked out by property taxes they would have a strong incentive to prevent that from happening by simply building enough housing for themselves.
Like rent control, this is indiscriminate welfare. Qualified welfare reaches the people who need it the most.
Taking a loan against an inflated asset and using it to pay cash, is a good way to risk bankruptcy if prices go down.
Not to mention exposing them to leverage if rates rise.
It is not aimed at people who have made lots of money.
The people who are actually receiving the value of the benefit for prop 13 are those who have made lots of money on their house -- the more money they've made, the more benefit they get.
All property taxes are always a transfer from property owners to everyone else. Prop 13 or no Prop 13 this is true.
So then when we’re talking about Prop 13, we are talking about a putative transfer only between property owners - long-standing vs recent.
When I say that it’s also not a transfer, what I mean is that anyone who holds property will end up with the same relative gain over time.
This of course assumes that prices continue to rise.
If they don’t then these schemes to tax people on unrealized gains fail too.
That’s not how property taxes work. You pay them whether you make money on the house or not.
You only make money on a house when you sell it.
> We're talking about millionaires, not vulnerable victims.
This makes no sense.
Buying or owning a house doesn’t make you a millionaire. Most people take out large loans to do so, and generally their net worth goes down at the point when they do so because of the costs.
Purchase prices may go up, but they also go down when the economy weakens.
> That’s not how property taxes work. You pay them whether you make money on the house or not.
> You only make money on a house when you sell it.
You are correct in that you do not (yet) have cash in hand from the value increase of the property. So if one defines "make money" as "have cash in hand", no money is made until one sells the property.
But, what one does have in this situation is an unrealized capital gain. And if one defines "make money" to include unrealized capital gains, then the homeowner has "made money" -- they just do not yet have cash in hand.
Unrealized is the operative word here. It means not achieved or created.
An unrealized capital gain can become an unrealized loss. That’s because it’s not a real gain.
Leveraging unrealized gains through loans is universally recognized as a risky investment strategy.
This policy would force people to take on this risk.
Which is exactly the point I’m making.
Homeowners shouldn’t be forced to take on risky financial instruments that are tied to the performance of local businesses.
They're actually welcome to stay and have a lien on their house: if you're living there you aren't going to have it taken away for a property tax lien. (If they will where you are, they can fix that in the same bill that repeals property tax distortions.)
> Buying or owning a house doesn’t make you a millionaire.
I'm focusing on the millions of houses in California that have went up in value by huge amounts since the last market snapshot for the tax basis whose owners are millionaires.
Value is determined by what the market actually pays, not by someone’s model of what it would pay. That isn’t the value - that is an estimate of what someone would receive if and only if they sell at that moment. Contesting an estimate doesn’t change that.
Whenever prices fall, do you propose paying cash to homeowners to reimburse them for all of the overpaid taxes?
Forcing someone to take a loan on a volatile asset that they can’t sell without losing their home is a brutal policy.
> I'm focusing on the millions of houses in California that have went up in value by huge amounts since the last market snapshot for the tax basis whose owners are millionaires.
Ok - so you just don’t care how many other people get hurt or displaced as long as you get to take money from some millionaires?
I don't know if that is true for CA, but in some localities, you most certainly will, eventually, be evicted from your own property for a property tax lien. It will take quite some time for the court case to wind its way to completion, but eventually the Sheriff will show up one day with an eviction notice and forcibly remove you from the property.
That's not true. You have only made money on the house when you sell it. Should we force people to sell their own houses because other people have more money than them?
I don't think "if you have enough money you can push others out" is great policy.
Because the value of the asset they own has increased.
Prop 13 discourages people from moving and unfairly shifts the tax burden on new residents
Ok, so do you propose giving cash payments to home owners whenever there is a dip in their property price?
Also, what’s wrong with being able to call a place home and be able to live there without being driven out?
Seems like a human right since we first moved into caves.
It sounds like you are saying tax rates should have nothing to do with home values and should just be arbitrarily adjusted to make property owners pay for whatever the local government wants.
Property tax rates should be fair to all property owners, not favor those that got in first which is what prop13 does.
>Also, what’s wrong with being able to call a place home and be able to live there without being driven out?
Nothing, just don't make others pay for it. Prop13 has created a distorted housing market that hurts many more people than it helps
Because they paid tax on a gain that wasn’t real.
> just don't make others pay for it. Prop13 has created a distorted housing market that hurts many more people than it helps
People who don’t pay property taxes aren’t paying anything at all.
As soon as you buy property, you are benefiting from prop 13 yourself.
Exactly. Imagine one bought GME at $10. It rose to $350+ because the market went nuts. You never sold so none of that is real to you.
And the IRS comes back saying you now must pay taxes on your GME shares based on the $350 valuation because someone else paid that much for it.
Fortunately stocks don't work that way. A home shouldn't either.
So no more yearly property tax?
It allows for yearly property tax based on what the person could afford when they bought the property.
That’s a reasonable compromise.
People still get to own and live in homes and not be driven out by the actions of others over which they have no control.
And the community gets a reliable long term revenue stream, that is relatively stable even though boom and bust cycles.
That's the entire discussion. This is entirely your opinion. The previous poster was cherrypicking a comparison to stocks which is what I was trying to clarify.
You pay property tax on the assessed value of a piece of property.
>As soon as you buy property, you are benefiting from prop 13 yourself.
Based on what? Newer homeowners are carrying more of the tax burden than they would have without prop 13.
Yes, but as soon as they buy they start to benefit from their own taxes not rising.
No, they don't.
The tax bill rises, the tax rate does not.
> Prop 13 appeals to and benefits people who don’t own real-estate yet, because it means that when they can do so, they know that their costs will be predictable
It doesn't, though. First of all, because it makes it less likely that they will be able to (not just because of what it does to buy v. rent pricing, but also because it pushes needs that would be paid out of real estate taxes into other taxes, which means people who don't own property are less likely to be able to say to buy property, since they are paying extra other taxes to subsidized ultralow property taxes for property owners (Prop. 13, in addition to it's restrictions on assessed value increases, also limits California’s nominal maximum property tax rate to well below the national average property tax rate.)
But even if they manage to get to own real estate, it doesn't do anything to guarantee greater predictability overall, just greater predictability of the taxes associated with ownership. The financing gap it creates is closed through factors which change over time and to which homeowners are exposed.
Prop 13 is promoted as helping people of modest means (lower income, or retired) who see the value of their property go way up, thus imposing an unaffordable tax burden and forcing them to sell and move.
The cost of this benefit is currently (AIUI), higher income taxes generally, and particularly on high earners, as well as higher sales tax. If you look at state and local revenue over time you will see a shift away from property tax and towards these other taxes.
The thing to focus on is that the total amount of state revenue is going to end up about the same, laws like this just shift who pays it.
Prop 13 also incentivizes people _not to move_. This adds friction to an already high-friction market: people are disincentivized to upsize/downsize, move closer to work, etc., which harms the market beyond just the fact that it's an inequitable wealth transfer.
It’s not an inequitable wealth transfer. Only people who own property pay these taxes, and all property owners benefit from Prop 13.
You don't become a millionaire just because the paper value estimate of your house becomes larger.
A low-income person who scraped by to buy a modest home in a cheap area doesn't become any less low-income just because suddenly the demographics change and rich people move in. Forcing them out of their home where they have built their life just so one more rich newcomer can get in, is not fair. For example, East Palo Alto.
It's racist. Prop 13 enshrines discrimination of the past into today's tax law.
White families have lower tax rates: https://twitter.com/alfred_twu/status/1327821019931787264?s=...
Wait, you have a problem with a city government trying to serve the people who actually live in a neighborhood rather than potential new residents?
That's the whole point of a city government. To serve the people living in the city.
A lot of zoning code is based on similar ideas, even if most people are not dumb enough to say the quiet part out loud these days.
You do still hear it on occasion: Bend, Oregon, where I live, passed a similar change a few years back, which was then superseded by Oregon's HB 2001, which effectively eliminates exclusionary zoning in our cities. At the local hearing for the Bend rule, there was a woman who was really upset that "renters" might be able to live in her neighborhood. They're dirty, messy, and "don't care about where they live", according to her testimony.
It's economic segregation, plain and simple.
That's the way it's always been. Here's an '80s example I ran across just the other day, and I'm actually grimly impressed by the clever video editing that puts up a WW2-era photo of mostly-white schoolkids to anchor a viewer's thinking away from "is this racist?" just as he says the worst part about "them" lol https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=973&v=jCMvOiupDLo
Now, younger less settled people also need places to live, and the Bay Area’s solution is to send them to Stockton or something, but not everything is about race.
This can be generalized - beyond the housing debate - as "having skin in the game".
As someone who has been (at various times) a short and long term renter, a landlord, and a homeowner ... it rings true to me that, generally speaking, renters invest less in their homes and their neighborhoods and have less at stake in the outcomes of those neighborhoods/communities.
That was certainly the case with me as a renter.
I don't think it's morally negative to segregate neighborhoods on the basis of renting vs. owning. The attempts to link this kind of segregation to past periods of literal racial segregation is, in my opinion, going to find less and less traction - especially as non-white stakeholders (homeowners) aspire to the same kind of skin-in-the-game cooperation with their neighbors.
What about the rampant housing discrimination in home-buying (without any enforcement) [0]? What about massive racial wealth disparates?
I think it is pretty naïve to suggest that the current backlash against having "renters" has nothing to do with race. Not more naïve than suggesting it only has to do with race, but close.
[0]: https://projects.newsday.com/long-island/real-estate-agents-...
Or, we could take a shortcut and ask those very people what they think and what they would like.
Which is to say, let's find some non-white stakeholders (homeowners) with skin in the game in their neighborhoods and communities and ask them what they think.
I drive through some very nice, very well ordered, single family zoned nieghborhoods in Fremont - the owners of which are predominantly non-white. The same exists in many other bay area communities.
Are those people vehemently advocating for upzoning and loss of local control ? Do those people have a strong preference for owners over renters ?
Genuinely curious ...
In some cities in California, houses are "earning" more on an hourly - yes, hourly - basis than many people do:
https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article208678414.html
That's a bit dated, pre-pandemic, but it's likely still happening in places.
Source on real estate prices in SF falling?
Note that this isn't true in locations with actual renter's rights, like Switzerland.
Plenty of people who rent might buy if there were more opportunities to do so, which there would be if housing weren't such an artificially scarce good in the US.
And when you describe 'those neighborhoods', keep in mind that that's probably a policy. If all neighborhoods had a mix of people, you wouldn't have quite so much of a concentration of people who aren't as wealthy.
I don't think this is possible, or even desirable.
A huge part of a home's value is the neighborhood. How much crime is there? How good are the schools? How are the neighbors?
A "fancy" house and an "affordable" house in the same neighborhood are not going to have a large price difference. If you revert every neighborhood to the mean, then you more or less revert all property prices to the mean. Which means you have erased all the "affordable" housing options, and also reduced the QOL of the top 50% of people.
Also, even to the extent that values are dominated by other factors, the intention is to increase housing availability through higher supply and lower prices. All housing becoming as expensive as upper middle class housing would be a problem, but all housing becoming as affordable as existing low income housing would be great.
Your expectation is that a 1000 sq ft "house" on a quarter acre of land would cost on the order of the same amount as a 4000 sq ft "house" on a full acre of land?
Its the same exact reason why houses cost more in Boston than in Wyoming, but on a different scale. The value of a home is heavily influenced by its location.
I think its reasonable to expect this to be more true of houses than apartments. Someone who is buying a house and putting down roots is going to care more about "the neighborhood" than someone who plans to move on in a year or two.
This is unambiguously as a result of zoning. It's rare to divide a one acre plot into four quarter acre plots because it's prohibited.
> Its the same exact reason why houses cost more in Boston than in Wyoming, but on a different scale. The value of a home is heavily influenced by its location.
Nobody is disputing that. But all that means is that a quarter acre plot in Boston costs the same as a full acre plot in Wyoming. It still costs a lot less than a full acre plot in Boston, which is often the only option the existing zoning makes possible.
Where I lived in Italy, you actually had very different homes very close by - big expensive single family units right next to 10 plexes that are far more affordable.
Frankly, I think it was healthier for my kids to go to school there with both some kids from wealthy families as well as Nigerian immigrants. Their schools here are much more homogeneous.
America has the cheapest housing in the Developed world. SF is not cheap, but its still cheaper than big cities in Europe.
Land is mostly cheaper in the US, but Italy and most of Europe provide far more housing options, in large part because they do not impose things like single family zoning.
Padova has twice the population of the town where I live here in the US, in about the same area, and housing is cheaper.
The economy isn't great there, but that's a separate story from housing. If it were hotter, it's a place where you can simply build homes in many shapes and sizes, from small apartments to nice villas.
https://www.accountingbolla.com/blog/property-tax-in-italy-g...
When people of different classes ( not races ) have different opinions on what 'good' means, there is only going to be confusion.
even a good neighborhood, once it is deemed as undesirable, will lose its values, its taxes, and soon, its schools.
While it is true the renter does not have "skin in the game" it is also true that many landlord put in only the absolute bare minimum of resources to maintain the rental property.
For example my grandmother before she passed lived in a aging neighborhood, as the original residents passed the homes where sold off as investment properties. She generally had a good relationship with most of the renters however the owners of homes routinely refused to repair things, refused to have proper tree maintenance done, and other such problems that would not be the responsibility of the renter.
The owners of the properties were not waiting out the poor people hoping to strike it rich like you seem to be implying
Sure, but we're not talking about "everything", we're talking about housing trends in American cities.
Also contributes massively to sprawl and thus carbon emissions because you can't have a more traditional sort of neighborhood where people might walk to the park and corner store.
Nothing against people owning a 1 acre lot if they want - that's fine! Imposing it on everyone is economic segregation.
Uhhh not in the very least. Many of us want to live in areas that have 3-acre minimum lots because of a little thing called nature. Those who want to live crammed into micro-apartments with 1 tree for every 30 people can, but those of us who want a whole town that is more grass that pavement should NOT be accused of classism or racism.
If you really want to help poor people, figure out a system that doesn't box them into ever-decreasing concrete apartments further and further from clean air.
If everyone lived on 3 acres, you know how much truly wild land would be paved over?
Now, I strongly agree that people ought to have the right to purchase and live on a large lot if they want. Great, you earned it, have fun!
Requiring that? That's using the government to perpetuate a sprawly, carbon-intensive lifestyle that very much does exclude those who are not wealthy enough to purchase that much land. That's part of the point in many places with that kind of regulation.
The majority of residents of an area using the government to control that area is the pinnacle of democracy.
>> If everyone lived on 3 acres, you know how much truly wild land would be paved over?
Actually, no there's plenty of land in America. Nothing would be paved, it would just be moved to yards (hint yards aren't paved). And if the population doesn't grow, then there's no reason America can't live like that forever.
When excluding illegal immigration, the US population is actually shrinking. There's no need to artificially box ourselves in.
15.77b acres of habitable land. http://www.zo.utexas.edu/courses/THOC/land.html
15.77 / 7.7 = 2.04
Every human could have about 2 acres. At this level of distribution humans would essentially live in wilderness and integrate with nature. Oftentimes humans live in family groups so the actual point distribution would be uneven.
Unfortunately arable land needed to feed the humans varies by locale but tops at about .6 hectacres [0] or 1.48 acres[1]. This means that effective wilderness could be slightly less than .5 acres per human after some nominal usage for housing and utility right of ways.
0. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/arable-land-use-per-perso...
1. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=.6+hectares+to+acres&atb=v83-1__&i...
That's false though. There are a lot of animals that do not want to be anywhere near humans, roads, houses or anything else. The presence of people wrecks it for them. Not to mention the jacked up carbon emissions if everyone had to drive around for everything because everyone is spread out.
Human-avoiding life already has a hard time. The habitable surface estimate did not include many areas where the remaining ones exist, such as tundra, ice pack, mountains and deserts. Additionally inter-human proximity preference distribution will allow for additional area outside the aforementioned surface classifications.
This is fine to have a town like this.
But a town like this has no business being in a major metropolitan area of the US such as the Bay Area. (I'm looking at you, Atherton.)
https://www.vox.com/22252625/america-racist-housing-rules-ho...
We can't. That's the problem.
Sounds like you do, you more or less accused anyone that desires a 1 acre plot of classism or wanting to "keep the poor people out", and of wanting to destroy the environment.
In reality most people that want that simply desire privacy, I for example desire that because i do not want to "walk to the corner store" or have a park at all in my neighborhood. I do not want to have "neighborhood" events, or be able to talk to my neighbor from my porch.
I want privacy, I want to be able to enjoy my hobbies which are solitary pursuits not group activities.
I agree but only in the sense that it should include 39 more acres. And a mule.
Central planning leads to a situation where market signals are ignored, and entrenches the status quo, rather than allowing cities (and economies in general) to change as needed. It seems highly unlikely that we've stumbled upon the "perfect" land use pattern. Why make it impossible to change from it then?
I'm referring to zoning as the central planning. It's central planning at a local scale, but still central planning.
Instead of letting each town set its own course, why not just let each property owner set their own course (within reasonable limits for market failures, like safety)?
My entire point is that restrictive zoning is the bureaucrats in the city governments deciding what the best use is for each plot of land, rather than letting the market decide based on demand.
Also, if we look at the Berkley case (which is what the OP is about!), there was no external force, the town made the change on its own.
I've seen this claim in this discussion but without hard evidence that this was the sole or even primary motivation at the time (who would you even measure/prove that?). Regardless, it isn't the motivation today behind zoning so I am not sure why it matters what the motivation was 100 years ago. I feel like that's a weak attempt by urban activists to associate a negative label (like "racist") with zoning to trivialize the legitimate reasons people like zoning restrictions.
People want zoning so that they can retain the kind of city or neighborhood character they want to live in. There's nothing wrong with incumbents resisting change that accommodates others at their own expense. The point of local government is to serve the incumbent residents first and foremost and I don't see why the desires of newcomers to live wherever they want at whatever price point they want supersedes the quality of life that existing residents have sought out and cultivated for themselves previously. Those newcomers are certainly free to move to a part of the country with less demand than the Bay Area and make a life there.
> It's economic segregation, plain and simple.
Not really. It's segregation by people who are invested in their community versus people who may move on because they haven't put down deep roots. And even if it was economic segregation in effect or directly, so what? I, and certainly most other parents, want a safe neighborhood for our families, and higher income neighborhoods typically experience less crime. I also want better educated and more successful people in my neighborhood, because their children form the environment and society my children are exposed to and influenced by. Leaving all that aside, an influx of renters changes a city's politics, culture, and other characteristics. I've seen this first-hand in Seattle where the dramatic changes of the last 10 years have really hurt the quality of life in this city and crowded out 'old Seattle' culturally. So I see many understandable and legitimate reasons for people to want to avoid renters.
I don't think you can make an argument that you're going to repair any past harms by doing this. I think the argument that you're going to continue them if you do this is much stronger.
Why do you put protecting in quotes? The residents of areas typically like to be protected from demographic disruption, especially if the disrupting demographic is known to bring problems.
> Not a great look.
People are more worried about the place that they have to live, work, and raise their children than they are about your patronizing condescension.
So racism, got it.
Cities have many stakeholders. Residents, sure. But also businesses, workers, the homeless, the environment.
And there are tons of tradeoffs. Maybe by rezoning and not mandating single family homes, the increased population density will improve access to transit and services. It's not necessarily as cut and dried as "Rezoning is negatively perceived by current residents, therefore don't do it".
I am not sure if you are asking this as a rhetorical question, but if not ...
This aspect of the housing (and democracy) debate in the bay area is now framed in terms which reject local decision making ("local control") if those local decisions reinforce existing, exclusionary housing policies.
Which is to say, we like local control when it delivers results we agree with - like non-federal legalization of marijuana or so-called "sanctuary cities" but we don't like local control when it delivers results we disagree with.
Or, more succinctly:
"Democracy for me, but not for thee".
Can you please educate me on this? What specifically is this issue? How can I educate myself on it?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1978_California_Proposition_13
Maybe Berkeley should also try to address the other unending issues that they keep up to prevent any meaningful change, if they really mean it:
-- Endless and convoluted environmental + city approvals processes that corrupt any transparent application for development and favor those who have money to navigate it
-- Picking and choosing special interest / special case neighborhoods or people to try to protect, to the detriment of everyone else wanting to live there
-- Rent control
-- The extremely backwards property tax policies that favor existing landowners over anyone new, young, poor (though this admittedly is California's problem, not just one city or county) and make everything else attempted bandaids -- and misguided bandaids, at that -- to fix the system.