Re:Berkeley may get rid of single-family zoning
by dragonwriter on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:24AM
(#26294413)
> Without Prop 13, home owners tax rates rise just because nearby businesses are successful, which is absurdly regressive.
No, they don't.
The tax bill rises, the tax rate does not.
> Prop 13 appeals to and benefits people who don’t own real-estate yet, because it means that when they can do so, they know that their costs will be predictable
It doesn't, though. First of all, because it makes it less likely that they will be able to (not just because of what it does to buy v. rent pricing, but also because it pushes needs that would be paid out of real estate taxes into other taxes, which means people who don't own property are less likely to be able to say to buy property, since they are paying extra other taxes to subsidized ultralow property taxes for property owners (Prop. 13, in addition to it's restrictions on assessed value increases, also limits California’s nominal maximum property tax rate to well below the national average property tax rate.)
But even if they manage to get to own real estate, it doesn't do anything to guarantee greater predictability overall, just greater predictability of the taxes associated with ownership. The financing gap it creates is closed through factors which change over time and to which homeowners are exposed.
No, they don't.
The tax bill rises, the tax rate does not.
> Prop 13 appeals to and benefits people who don’t own real-estate yet, because it means that when they can do so, they know that their costs will be predictable
It doesn't, though. First of all, because it makes it less likely that they will be able to (not just because of what it does to buy v. rent pricing, but also because it pushes needs that would be paid out of real estate taxes into other taxes, which means people who don't own property are less likely to be able to say to buy property, since they are paying extra other taxes to subsidized ultralow property taxes for property owners (Prop. 13, in addition to it's restrictions on assessed value increases, also limits California’s nominal maximum property tax rate to well below the national average property tax rate.)
But even if they manage to get to own real estate, it doesn't do anything to guarantee greater predictability overall, just greater predictability of the taxes associated with ownership. The financing gap it creates is closed through factors which change over time and to which homeowners are exposed.