That’s mostly gone now with Prop 19. It used to be that children could inherit apartment buildings, multiple houses, commercial buildings, with no new tax assessment. Now, children can only inherit a parent’s primary residence without a new tax assessment. Even then, they can only avoid a tax increase up to the first $1m in value and only if the children live in the property. If they keep it as a rental, they lose the benefit.
The change should result in more properties being sold after inheritance, which will increase market supply and lower prices.
If you believe that, then why ratchet them up just because the property is sold? If you're going to detach property taxes from the value of the property, then do it for new homeowners too.
If we are scaling property taxes with the property's value, we might as well do it for everyone and not treat people special just because they were living there longer. Other costs people deal with scale at least by local cost of living. Groceries, electricity, water service, etc. all increase year after year. Do we let people pay 1960s costs for everything else just because they happened to move to the area in 1960?
Prop 13 as it currently stands, is a wealth transfer from young, new homeowners to elderly, established homeowners.
An argument here is that it's about budgeting and predictability.
If I choose to buy a $1M property today, I need to consider and budget for the $10K+/yr in taxes on it because I know full well that's what I'll have to pay. If that doesn't work for me, I don't have to buy it.
But someone who bought a $50K property and responsibly budgeted for the $500 in taxes on it will be severely punished through no fault of their own if that $500 becomes $10K.
They did not "make a leveraged bet". They bought a home to live in and watch their child grow in it.
Not everyone looks at real estate as a investment vehicle to maximize profits. It's just a home. It's not healthy for society to view homes merely as if they were shares of stock to be traded for maximum value. If you want to make leveraged bets, better to play the options market.
Don't think of it as an investment to flip. Think of it as home. After the purchase, no need to ever look at the property value estimates again. Just live it.
Maybe your feel good spiel would make sense if price-to-rent ratios weren't the highest but that's not the case. Most of what you pay for here is a bet that values will go up. If it weren't for stupid laws like Prop 13 that only help land speculation this wouldn't be the case.
It's an insanely unfair system.
I agree that scaling property taxes with their values is bad. Not sure why government expenses magically double when housing value do.
Ideally living people will move out and make room for the next generation when they no longer have use for 4 bedrooms in a good school district close to jobs.
Beyond split roll, do you have ideas to 1) protect people that would be harmed by an immediate rollback of 13 and 2) build the political coalition to get it done?
2) no. As long as California is a direct democracy the law will stay. Even Prop 15 failed so any chance of reform through the existing process is doomed. Justice Stevens echos this point here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/90-1912.ZD.html I suppose that maybe with billions of lobbying and ad spend we could Prop 22 a repeal through but even then I doubt it.
The only way I see it happening is if the courts strike it down as unconstitutional. Equal protection is applied stronger on issues of race and Nordlinger v Hahn didn't address that. We now can see real data that Prop 13 systemically hurts minorities and I believe another challenge is warranted.
Edit: actually should have talked about "disparate impact" instead in that last part.
If want to cry unfair, then it would be better to aim at commercial real estate. That's a pure money business. Why should they get protection under prop 13? Make no sense at all.
Why should some whose house went from $200k to $2M be getting a tax break?
Because they bought a 200K house and budgeted for taxes on a 200K house.
The paper estimate of it being worth 2M right now doesn't change anything about the house they actually live in.
It is absurd and an anomaly. Let them stay, but when the reap a $1M+ profit on the house when they sell or die, they can pony up the tax, just like everyone else.
I did not say that so I don't mean that.
If a low/middle class person buy the house they can afford to pay and live in it, they don't become millionaires just because other people around them bought houses more expensively later. They're most likely still in the same career earning that same low/middle class income. They don't have any additional money to pay much higher property taxes, they are certainly not millionaires.
Tax them after sale, sure, if the property value is still high when they sell (it might not be).
If they budgeted for a 200k house, that turned into a 2M house, they should be ecstatic when they sell it, the government takes the property taxes and they still get to keep more than 200k.
This is satire. Please do not take it seriously.
Oh great I'll take one of those. Maybe two. Where do I sign up?
This is double true when the value went up without any change to the structure. Structures depreciate, and become less valuable over time. When property values go up in California, it's almost entire land value that goes up. The value increase isn't from the labor of the land owner, it's just simple rentierism.
Land gets more valuable because of what one can access close to it: jobs, relationships, people, universities. All this value is socially created. This sort of wealth hoarding is hugely damaging to the economy, and all sorts of thinkers revered by people in the US have nothing but the worst possible words for it, from Adam Smith to Thomas Paine.
It is quite strange for the wealthiest members of a community to depend upon the less wealthy to fund a community, but that's what Prop 13 is all about. This situation, where the wealthy could buy their way out of taxation, is a lot of what led to the French Revolution.
This is literally the opposite. If you buy (a property), you'll have the taxes based on what you bought. You can't buy your way to a lower tax rate.
I wouldn't phrase it that way because it's not what they did, even if decades down the road it turned out that way (it could well have gone the other way like it did for homeowners in Detroit years ago).
What they did was buy a home they could afford, based on monthly mortgage + taxes payments, which is the entirely reasonable and responsible thing to do.
Having the property tax balloon out of control and out of any conceivable affordable range due to actions of other people in the area, is hardly fair.
The older the wealth, the lower the taxes.
And, surprise surprise, that class is white people.
https://twitter.com/alfred_twu/status/1327821019931787264?s=...
Makes sense given that minorities were at large disadvantages to buy property in the past so mostly whites have been able to take advantage on the low tax rates. I'm surprised this isn't getting challenged in court. Nordlinger v Hahn didn't consider race.
Also, I know there are probably better ways to finance a city, but that's how we currently do it. It should be done fairly, ideally we should meet in the middle. It's fundamentally unfair that some folks pay up to 10x or more than others. I'm speaking personally, but it really bothers me that my neighbors are actually OK with this.
Also, there are lots of ways to ensure elderly/retired folks can stay in their homes. Taxes can be deferred.