Re:Berkeley may get rid of single-family zoning
by caturopath on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:04PM
(#26253282)
Equity is not the only concern, though Prop 13 is certainly a transfer of wealth too established, richer people from poorer, less-established ones.
Prop 13 also incentivizes people _not to move_. This adds friction to an already high-friction market: people are disincentivized to upsize/downsize, move closer to work, etc., which harms the market beyond just the fact that it's an inequitable wealth transfer.
Prop 13 is promoted as helping people of modest means (lower income, or retired) who see the value of their property go way up, thus imposing an unaffordable tax burden and forcing them to sell and move.
The cost of this benefit is currently (AIUI), higher income taxes generally, and particularly on high earners, as well as higher sales tax. If you look at state and local revenue over time you will see a shift away from property tax and towards these other taxes.
The thing to focus on is that the total amount of state revenue is going to end up about the same, laws like this just shift who pays it.