News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Berkeley may get rid of single-family zoning by toast0 on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:31PM (#26253658)
Property taxes under Prop 13 are actually a pretty good way to fund local government.

The revenue is very stable and dependable. Even in the depths of the 2009 dowturn, almost all California counties still had slightly increasing tax rolls. Assuming most municipal business is pretty stable, this would seem to be a good match.

Other states solve this in other ways. In Washington state, the overall assessment for a municipality can only go up slightly each year, but individual property assessments are not limited, so you can still have your share of the tax go up a lot if your neighborhood is assessed higher and other neighborhoods in the municipality are assessed lower.

Re:Berkeley may get rid of single-family zoning by dragonwriter on Sunday February 28, 2021 @11:38AM (#26294531)
> Property taxes under Prop 13 are actually a pretty good way to fund local government.

No, it's not.

Which is why California local government relies on special districts funded by Mello-Roos charges (essentially property taxes that are flat per unit rather than value based, and are outside of the Prop 13 limits) and large transfers of state revenue for funding ever since Prop 13 restricted the top nominal property tax rate in California to much lower than effective property tax rates in the US as a whole rolled back valuations on existing property so that people weren't then paying full rate, and restricted the rate of increase of assessed value.

> The revenue is very stable and dependable

And very low, forcing reliance on taxes that are less stable and reliable than property taxes would be without the Prop 13 assessment increase limit, which is a net loss of stability.

Stability might be a decent argument for something like the assessment increase limit (if you ignore the distributional inequities) without the ultralow nominal rate limit, but to avoid reliance on other means you'd have to raise the nominal rate to target the desired effective rate given age and value distribution observed.

Re:Berkeley may get rid of single-family zoning by zepto on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @01:50PM (#26253939)
Good point - stability of taxes is important for the govt as well as homeowners.