This is really it. The Google/Android team have already made the "Zebra" library that actually reads barcodes; why on earth do they not include this as a standard app. Instead we get this myriad of different barcode scanner apps with all sorts of harmful features. All the heavy lifting is done by the Android team anyway (the actual barcode scanning).
To make matters worse, scanning a barcode when you enter a store/cafe (to register your location), is now begin done everywhere in order to track potential covid19 spreaders. This forces anyone without an iPhone to install at least one of these potentially harmful apps.
I heard from a friend that iOS has TOTP and indeed a barcode scanner build in, same goes for cal/carddav. To be fair, my wife's Pocophone also comes up with a QR-code icon when the cam detects a QR code. And, FireFox for mobile has a QC code scanner build in (although since I now have to open a new tab for each new page and I end up with many many tabs of the same 4 websites I find myself using FF less and less).
Maybe the experience on Pixel Phones is better? GCam makes a lot of difference in many aspects.
Both a QR-capable camera and a flashlight in the notification bar are in all my Android phones, and they've been for a very long time. I know the Nexus One didn't include it, but those will have problems with modern TLS anyway.
The problem is likely elsewhere. It wouldn't surprise me if many of these users are tricked into installing these apps. It is quite popular for malware to disguise itself as a legitimate app as to not raise suspicion.
I'm using Google Camera version 8.1 on a fully updated Pixel 4a and it works for me.
I don't like that example of utilitarian because it fights the youtube platform which does not want you downloading videos. Anything that sidesteps some sort of security fence or functionality is shady to begin with; even if you think it's fair use. Plus there's the whole copyright minefield.
Why are Google afraid to release a free non-harmful version of those popular apps. Is it to keep the illusion the app-store is a vibrant market place where tons of developers get rich? It just seems nuts to allow all those harmful apps (that does virtually nothing) to float among the top downloads.
QR scanning seems a little more complicated. FF for Android integrates a QR scanner, but chrome does not. Google's default camera also opens links, if you allow Google Lens.
I remember the play store being scary but I think there was something in fdroid.
I am not so sure on this, but I do not recall my nexus 5 having flashlight in the OS.
They already did; these have both been built-in for years. The flashlight was added in Android 5.0 (https://www.androidauthority.com/android-5-0-lollipop-offici... I'm having a harder time figuring out when the barcode scanner was added, but my phone does it automatically in the camera app now.
(Disclosure: I work for Google, speaking only for myself)
If Android has a built-in QR scanner now, that must be something that came with Android 11, but September 8 2020 cannot qualify as "for years". It takes a while for OEM's to catch up as well.
There are certainly Android phones that ships with this feature (QR-scanner), but stock Android 10 does not. (Google lens != Standard Photo app).
If you know about it, you can start "Google lens" app, but that app does not even come up as a suggestion when you type QR scanner into the play store. I.e. even when you have a QR scanner available on your phone, you wouldn't know unless you somehow knew about "Google lens".
[1] https://medium.com/turunen/built-in-qr-reader-on-android-696...
Fear of anti-competition lawsuits and complaints. They're seeing what happens when Apple integrates stuff into iOS / OS X core that previously were third party provided, or the flak that Amazon gets for pushing AmazonBasics products.
They could just create an open source variant that suddenly shows up top when people search for QR or barcode scanner. It would be in their best interest, and it would not violate any anti-competition laws, nobody can demand to see how these apps are ranked I guess?
It’s better to bake it into the OS and push an update. But then you’d have to get an OS update to heaps of phones.
From the people who make those crummy apps; criticism surely cannot hurt Google all that much?
> But then you’d have to get an OS update to heaps of phones.
That's not a viable option, this requires tons of work from OEM's that Google would have to pay for. I've rarely ever gotten any OS updates at all on Android - apart from my latest phone. But I think the only reason I get OS updates now is due to the fact that Nokia just ships stock Android under the "android_one" brand.
Those QR code scanner apps are basically taking advantage of people not knowing they don't need one.
Platform providers are also criticized when natively offering features that apps offer. You sort of can't win.
They have done more drastic things in the past. They have even removed apps entirely from Android phones due to very harmful features, and nobody cared when they heard about the horrid things these apps did in the background.
People doing low effort apps can only just whinge when the floor shifts under them. i have no sympathy - they just need to adapt and improve, and create new value to sell.
Our (New Zealand) Covid tracing app scans QR codes itself. What jurisdictions are requiring to scan an arbitrary QR code using random apps?
https://www.health.govt.nz/our-work/diseases-and-conditions/...
For most Kiwis this means a bunch of QR code data is stored on their phone and, months or years from now when the emergency is over (depending on how incompetent other countries are) that data is deleted. There is no NZ department of health MySQL database full of geo data of every New Zealand citizen and never will be.
If you're a case (remembering that New Zealand has elimination, so rather than cases being millions of people as in the US for example, they're very rare) then you can choose to help the contact tracers by giving them your data and in that case they do get all the data because you gave it to them. Because New Zealand has elimination contact tracing is something done by a handful of experts.
I would guess that like most countries New Zealand's contact tracing experts worked previously with sexually transmitted infections - so they already understand the sensitivity of this work. COVID-19 is actually less awkward, because at least you don't have to admit to fucking somebody you claim you're not sexually attracted to, just that you were in the same room as them for a period of time.
But of course none of what I wrote above matters much because those are merely facts, and for so many Americans mere facts can't oppose a Truth they have become certain of despite all evidence to the contrary. Not that Mother Nature gives a damn whether you believe her.
I literally can not believe you are arguing it's not better.
But privacy is clearly one of the victims of this pandemic. At least some countries are now opening up the source-code of the front and back-end of their apps. They had to do that here in Norway (they had to replace the whole app actually) when the original closed source version was demonstrated to contain harmful features...
Unfortunately very low cases doesn’t mean the virus is gone. Occasionally there is a case and if you want to clamp that down as fast as possible, you need contact tracing. Which means we need to know where you are.
For most people, no extra information is being leaked. Facebook and google already know where they are and they are far more malicious than the AU or NZ government. The tin foil hatters like you can take extra measures I’m sure.
The US has over 25million cases and over 400k dead. That’s literally the entire population of Australia infected. So I’d argue that NZ and AU are objectively better and we shouldn’t worry about “overreach” just yet.
Imagine you are an app developer of a really simple app that takes a number and tells you if that number is in a valid phone format or not. You have a textbox, the user enters it, you do the checking and display the result. Easy. Now imagine you want to allow scanning a qr which contains a number, to do the checking afterwards. You need to either ask your users to use an external app to scan and then open yours, include all the qr related library inside yours, or use a special intent from a third party app (that the users need to have already installed).
First solution is slow and inconvenience for users, the second is what almost all apps do, but then the code logic is duplicated on all of them (with the increment in app size). The third option is the best, both for the developer and for the user, however there is no official qr service so in the end this is basically option 1.
I mean, you already have a service to get a picture, a file and a contact, among others (you don't need to include all the code, simply do a call to the respective intent and wait for the result) so why don't extend this with the qr too?
When we sit down they just say, "use your camera app to scan the barcode". It seemed to work for everyone at the table. Samsung, Pixel, and iPhone.
Also FM Radio, screen recorder and IR remote control.
what do you recon would be included?
- barcode scanner, - auth app, - calculator of some kind, - wifi management, dns/network/firewall management.
Android is like Forrest Gump's box of chocolates: you never quite know what you're going to get. And sometimes it's stale.
I downloaded an app for it because it never crossed my mind it would be built into the camera app. After all I don't want to take pictures of the QR code, I want to decode it...
No idea when it was introduced. I've had an S3, S5 and now an S8 where I discovered it by accident last year. Pretty sure the S3 didn't have it.
I think Apple have the right idea with app review on browser extensions for Safari.
/s
Chrome used to. You used to be able to just download the source code of an extension, point Chrome at it, and done you are.
Well, you still can. But Chrome will CONSTANTLY nag you about it and try to forget you added that extension using source, like it's some vile crime.
They removed it because of "security", which is a hilarious reason because it just made everything so much worse.
Would be a real shame if some software would block your ads because you didn't want to pay, wouldn't it?
You'd think if they were serious about privacy their privacy policy would just say "we spy on nothing and collect nothing and share with no one". 1password effectively has that privacy policy, lastpass does not.
That's to say:
(a) The time for a given barcode to be accurately detected varies considerably from app to app.
(b) And various apps have different detection capabilities with respect to one another (i.e.: the detection performance varies from app to app depending on the contrast across the barcode image, camera focus or lack thereof, etc.).
(c) For a given app, the detection capability for different types of barcode scans can vary considerably.
For that reason, I have five different QR scanners installed including SecScanQR that you've mentioned and the one with the same namesake as mentioned in this Malwarebytes article.
It seems there's a great deal of variability in the detection algorithms between apps. Unfortunately, from my experience I've found that some of the commercial apps have better detection performance than those on F-Droid—but granted that's only from my limited testing. Which app I use sometimes depends on other features, for instance, the fact that it has a better database or export ability, etc. is more important than the fact that it's insensitive in the detection department.
I wish someone with more knowledge and experience could give others and me the good oil on this. Reckon it'd save us considerable time experimenting.
I'm very happy with it
This right here is a big reason, apart from actual restorable backups, why I root my Android device. Sure it is not required nowadays but it does give a sense of control if thats the right word.
So many times I had to restore older copies of apps like Chess or even Yoga app. The older apps allowed a functionality (downloadable content for offline view) which was straightup removed in newer versions.
Same for Authenticator or any other app which does things locally.
Recently Google Authenticator app added the ability to move all codes to next phone by displaying multiple sequence of QR codes, but I coded a simple no internet just local storage & javascript app to to utilize otpauth:// protocol to eadily readd the codes on new phone https://spa.bydav.in/otp.html
Wouldn't that be anti-competitive? Similar situation when Microsoft was including IE on their system that made them a quasi monopolist with subpar product. I'd rather have Google having stricter rules when it comes to malware.
And why stop here? We should open the market for TCP implementations. The status quo is anti-competitive and stifles innovation!
_Re-open_. There were, indeed, commercial TCP/IP stacks available for various operating systems until the operating systems started including them.
If we do a comparison with the browser situation, then it would be quite sufficient to allow people to install 3rd party TCP/IP stacks. Does Microsoft prevent that? I honestly don't know myself since I don't really use Windows. :D
The key to understanding the browser case is that, as MS wanted it, it would have tied client and server and rich application development together, all of which would have necessitated Windows. IE was a threat because of ActiveX.
I used various competing systems before that in Windows/DOS
In the early days Wordpress sold use of their domain to black hat seo / spammers.
I wouldn't accept it to sneak the change in, but I'd probably be perfectly willing to take their hand off and sell rights to the product. Assuming of course I didn't just delete the message assuming it was some sort of phishing scam or other rather than a genuine offer.
I'd feel obligated to make it known that I'd done this, perhaps via a notification in the app prior to hand-over and in its README. Something along the lines of a normal change of ownership message (copyright has been transferred to X, contact them for further information, future official releases will come from their fork, of course existing open source releases remain open source even if they change licencing arrangements for future releases, yadda yadda). Though we all know how often people just click through notifications, so I'm not sure how much difference that would really make - so if I were a robot I might be considered culpable under the second half of the first law...
If the buyer would walk away if I didn't agree to a more silent sale then I wouldn't touch it. It is a thin line that I won't cross, but still a line I like to think wouldn't cross. Then again I have the luxury of being relatively comfortable at this point in my life (decent day job at a company which is weathering the current collection of world crises pretty well, the little flat's mortgage near paid), for many others out there the financial incentive would be much harder to ignore. I'm not sure that I like that I wouldn't draw my line in a different place, but I'd be dishonest if I tried to claim that I would.
Bundling can be seen as bad in terms of competition [0], but it can also be good for the user experience. I wonder if these apps go unimplemented for fear of regulation. It might be silly to think of a barcode scanner (or other small utility) in that way, but, if the app is so silly, then is it really worth the risk (not just from regulation, but from having to deal with bugs)?
0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor....
The questions are: how do you decide is necessary and how do you present it to the user? Different people have different needs and making every should have been feature visible ends up making every other feature less visible. That may be fine if you're developing software for a specialist who will take the time to learn a particular application which is relevant to them, but it's a drawback when you're creating software for a general audience since only a handful of enthusiasts will take the time to learn the software.
I wouldn't be surprised if there are app developers that actually do accept these kinds of offers though.
Just one, together with alternative forms of 2 factor auth, such as a Yubikey (U2F token) or printed backup codes.
Or it suddenly gone from app / play store
Breaking OS changes are a problem, it's true. Thankfully they basically never happen on phones (certainly if you have a phone that stopped updates ~4-5 years ago it will still work).
"Thankfully they basically never happen on phones"
There has probably never been a phone OS update that didn't break things. And not in a "technically something broke so haha gotcha! way"
Broken in a "half the apps out there need to be rebuilt with a new SDK version and/or deprecated or there'll be obvious bugs" way
I wouldn't accept it to sneak the change in, but I'd probably be
imagine android version of Google Authenticator having no way to export data to the iphone version..
oh wait..
I will imagine that anyone who creates an authenticator is half-decent enough to NOT take that bribe and serve the greater good.
I will also imagine that when people install authenticators, they would NOT trust one from HenryBemis but only from sources that they recognize (Google, Microsoft, Yubikey, etc.)
It always amazes me how come all smartphone OS creators switch every connectivity option to ON by default on every new app installation. It would take a use another 3-4 seconds per app installation to prompt the user whether they want this app to access Wifi/Data/Background/Roaming. In the same sense than the OS asks you whether you allow access to Calendar, Contacts, Camera, etc. At least half my apps on my Android do NOT need access to the internet to function. They may 'want', but definitely not need.
Dear HenryBemis,
As a CEO of TRC, I would like to extend you an offer to purchase source and distribution rights to your app, SummerChildAuthenticator, to the form of $500,000 (five hundred thousand US dollars). We are a fast growing SV startup that wants to make it easier for people to secure their papers and money on-line. We have developed a streamlined, easy-to-use, user interface for authenticator applications and are looking for a way to quickly put it in front of a wide audience. We believe that your SummerChildAuthenticator, with its established base of over 50 000 users, is the gateway we are looking for.
If you are interested in this offer, please reply to this e-mail.
Sincerely yours,
TeMPOraL, CEO, TRC
<smallfont>Temporal's Rackets and Cons is a startup registered in Southern Vescillo, Arstotzka.</smallfont>
--
You think to yourself: "this is a good deal! The app is unlikely to grow more, it isn't making you any money anyway. Here is this hot new startup with great ideas, what's the worst that could happen? They'll just inject an ad here and there. Meanwhile, I have medical expenses, and..."
So you agree, and I take your app, and run a "growth hacking" campaign on Reddit to blow its userbase up to 500 000 people, and then proceed with my main business plan, which is selling access to OTP codes to the mob running phishing scams.
(Oh, dear reader, you've noticed Arstotzka and thought I'll be selling data to evil government? Nope, we registered there only because it'll make it mighty hard for anyone to sue us.)
Any developer knows/understands if the offer comes from a legit source or scumbag. I cannot make other people's choices for them. My answer would be 'no' even for 100k, BUT I am in HN and I suggest people get off facebook and google because they are privacy nightmares (also certified in a couple of audit/security areas - so there's that). Btw I did have an app on Apple store, target audience was children (3-6 years old), it did OK, I just didn't have the time to keep it around (for the little revenue it was bringing). It worked 100% offline, no tracking, no ads, no nothing. I have a free version as a sample and the full version at $0.99. I chose to sell than help the ad beast grow bigger and track children more.
But that is just me. $50k is a serious amount but it won't make me or break me. For some other parts of the world, where a monthly salary may be $200.....
And while I don't think you personally will sell out like this, I wanted to highlight that a) it's easy to make such an offer sounding legit enough (particularly to developers with little experience with the world at large), and b) an Authenticator app is a perfectly valid target for such offer. I'd even say it's more lucrative target than most.
And a lot of reputable software companies have sold out to peddling adware. Adobe is one, and there are a lot of others. Abandoned shareware or open source often resurface with adware installers.
> When inserted into a computer, the CDs installed one of two pieces of software which provided a form of digital rights management (DRM) by modifying the operating system to interfere with CD copying. Neither program could easily be uninstalled, and they created vulnerabilities that were exploited by unrelated malware. One of the programs would install and "phone home" with reports on the user's private listening habits - even if the user refused its end-user license agreement (EULA), while the other was not mentioned in the EULA at all. Both programs contained code from several pieces of copylefted free software in an apparent infringement of copyright, and configured the operating system to hide the software's existence, leading to both programs being classified as rootkits.
> on about 22 million CDs
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfish
> The installation included a universal self-signed certificate authority; the certificate authority allows a man-in-the-middle attack to introduce ads even on encrypted pages. The certificate authority had the same private key across laptops; this allows third-party eavesdroppers to intercept or modify HTTPS secure communications without triggering browser warnings by either extracting the private key or using a self-signed certificate.
I yes, I too rememeber the FirefoxOS. Good times.
I suppose I should be grateful that I can turn off a lot of permissions for apps at all these days, unlike the malware built into recent versions of the major desktop operating systems. :-(
Don’t be naive, the majority will accept the money and gladly.
I believe that particularly makeshift applications such as e.g. barcode scanners are susceptible to this kind of overtake. Apps that offer what should have been offered by the OS vendor in the first place. Why should the app developer refuse the money if what their app offers will be incorporated in a next OS update by anyways? Why defend your mini-adapter-app in an ocean of mini-adapter-apps, with yours becoming so large just because of a random seed and path dependency?
This can have a big impact for end users. Imagine an authenticator app ending service to all their users in such a scheme and how you will be cut out from all your accounts by this. How many authenticator apps do you have to use in parallel to mitigate this risk of a single point of failure?