News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by JMTQp8lwXL on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:31PM (#24228550)
They want to stay independent, fine. Then actually treat them like independent contractors. Let them set rates. Let them decline rides without facing penalties by the platform. Make the changes necessary to fit the independent contractor model. And not just the rideshare company, but the state too: these workers need unemployment insurance, as Covid has shown, and somebody needs to pay for it: be it the workers or the ridesharing businesses.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:52PM (#24231151)
I worked for SuperShuttle developing their driver mobile app.

I can tell you for a fact that a big reason SuperShuttle failed is because the drivers were independent. They would consistently reject low cost trips and wait it out until they got one "mega" trip so that they only need to actually work for about 3 hours/day. Some days they wouldn't take any trips, just hang out in the van playing Flappy Bird.

This was a main issue for the SuperShuttle because they couldn't get their drivers to do adapt when Uber came around, including accepting work that more resembled Uber pool workloads.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by jeffbee on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:16PM (#24231290)
This is what we call "revealed preference". It doesn't really matter what ten thousand Uber drivers have told you (and some of the supposed first-hand field surveying claimed in this discussion stretches belief). The only thing that matters in the end is how the participants in the market actually behave.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Zak on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:15PM (#24238466)
I think what's happening here is the defined categories don't adequately model reality. An Uber driver is somewhere between the current legal categories of employee and independent contractor.

A fully independent contractor like a SuperShuttle driver can treat each fare as a separate contract, pick only the best offers, and generally not provide the company an adequate service level to ensure a reliable stream of customers. Each driver prioritizing their short-term interests keeps that model from being a viable profession in many cases.

On the other hand, an employer is required to provide certain benefits to employees, especially if they exceed certain thresholds of hours worked. To make the fixed cost of some of those benefits viable, the employer will usually want to require the employee to work specific hours, and often limits those hours to stay within legal thresholds.

It's the flexibility of scheduling I that I think attracts people to gig work. They'll take the ability to cherry-pick the most profitable gigs if given the chance, but it isn't a core requirement.

It's probably desirable to add a third category to provide gig workers some protections without shoehorning them into the employee classification, which many of them actively wish to avoid.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by toddmclaughlin on Sunday August 23, 2020 @12:03AM (#24249419)
Very well said. Gig workers are in that nebulous, legally undefined category between employees and contractors.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Nydhal on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:49AM (#24232954)
Actions > Words.

Such a simple concept yet many ignore it. Nowadays it's trendy to call such concepts "mental models".

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by SQueeeeeL on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:44PM (#24238206)
True! I use this concept a lot when arguing with people about minimum wage! I think those single Mom's should be happy to have a job, not complaining they can't pay rent! Like they can just learn to code if they don't want to make min wage
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by BoorishBears on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:31PM (#24239556)
I can't tell if this is a joke or someone incredibly out of touch with the reality of poverty (this being HN, there are enough people who fall in the latter group to make it unclear)
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by SQueeeeeL on Saturday August 22, 2020 @09:35AM (#24244025)
It's a joke, I'm glad taking "Actions > Words" to it's logical conclusion seemed like someone's real opinion, really tells you about the type of people that frequent this site
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by swc on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:51AM (#24233778)
This seems more nuanced than implied here. It sounds as though the 'main issue' wasn't that Super Shuttle couldn't work while letting their drivers be independent, but rather that they couldn't compete on price with a service that didn't.

If a business was paying their workers minimum wage and couldn't compete on price with another business that came in and didn't respect minimum wage laws, you wouldn't say the main issue was paying minimum wage. You would say it was the business that didn't respect minimum wage laws.

It seems like if all companies treat drivers as independent contractors, then the market will naturally work itself out. Drivers will compete amongst themselves and determine what they are willing to work for, and prices will adapt as needed to support that. However, if some companies don't, then obviously it isn't a level playing field. That will only be exacerbated if the company that doesn't then also further depresses ride prices to the point of operating at a loss.

Whether the current legislation actually achieves the goal remains to be seen, but the whole point is to level the playing field. I don't think anyone actually thinks that the way forward is to treat drivers as employees. Instead, I think having to treat drivers as employees is a deterrent to the current way contractor laws are being skirted, with the intent of pushing all companies to treat their drivers as independent contractors in order to level the playing field.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:26AM (#24234688)
No. It isn’t more nuanced than that. SuperShuttle couldn’t make changes because the drivers irrationally refused to work more for the same pay, even though they knew the company was failing. It really is that simple.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by nogabebop23 on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:51AM (#24234865)
>> because the drivers irrationally refused to work more for the same pay

How is this irrational? You offer me $X for Y hours of work. If X/Y gets too small I say "no" and do something with higher utility, even if that's playing flappy bird. I don't really care that my actions destroy the source of this opportunity because I've already rejected it.

You are right that this is simple, just not in the way you're interpreting it.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:44PM (#24237136)
Because if you don't take trips then you don't make any money. They felt entitled and refused to adapt when the market demanded it. That's irrational.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:34PM (#24238127)
In discussions like these I like to start from a basic premise: people aren't stupid.

It's obvious to the drivers that if they don't take trips, then they don't make money. Clearly then, they've decided that below a certain dollar amount, it make more sense to them to play computer games than take a fare. How they arrived at that conclusion, I don't know. But I have faith that it made sense to them.

I do very small software projects for people I find online. I have a minimum fee. If I take on projects below that minimum, I'd have more work, but I have determined that it's in my best interest to hold out for that minimum rate. If this means that I don't make money on that side gig a particular day or week, so be it. I have my reasons for doing that and they won't necessarily make sense to anyone looking in from the outside.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by BoorishBears on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:29PM (#24239546)
It's trivial to find out why looking at driver's posts online:

There's a minimum time cost to them for each ride or delivery. There's the time you spend finding out exactly where the person is, there can be a delay between jobs, there's delays when picking up an order.

Someone who drives 10 miles for one job will spend much less time than someone who drives 1 mile for 10 jobs. And since they have X units of time to spend in the app, they'll start making less and less per mile driven.

They also don't get paid for the time spent going to a pickup unless it exceeds a certain length: https://www.theverge.com/2017/10/24/16533940/uber-long-picku...

It's easy enough to see how, at some point, they start to get paid so little that it's in their best interest to just not drive and spend the gas and their effort

__

Here's a severe case showing someone go through that exact experience:

> I accepted the pick-up and app informed me that the customer was 13 miles away I drove there[...] pressed my App for the drop-off Destination [...] and saw that drop-off was 1 mile away

> Total time of trip, back and forth, 45 to 50 minutes and 29 miles , and I earned $8 dollars

> So, after thinking about it, I have decided to ‘decline’ all trips that are more than 10 miles away from me and do not say that it is gonna be a ‘long trip’

https://ride.guru/lounge/p/uber-drivers-how-far-will-you-dri...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:12PM (#24239882)
You can be smart and be irrational. You can be dumb and be irrational. So it’s sort of a moot point.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by barry-cotter on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:37AM (#24235242)
The drivers were not investors in the company; it failing was not a huge problem for them. Having a strong preference for leisure is totally ok. The drivers didn’t have enough stock and weren’t paid enough to motivate them to work the hours the company needed to be viable. The company failed. The investors lost all their money. The founders and employees got nothing. That’s capitalism. If they’d been right they’d have made massive bank and that too would have been capitalism. Workers get to play capitalism too. Everyone played. Everyone made their choices and the company failed.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:42PM (#24237123)
The drivers are franchisees so they have huge interest in keeping the company going, otherwise they wouldn't get any trips. It was their problem. They just didn't want to change.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ric2b on Saturday August 22, 2020 @12:12PM (#24245071)
They can just drive for another company, they don't suffer any significant loss the same way a McDonald's restaurant would if McD's folded and had to overhaul the entire restaurant. The drivers just install another app on their phone.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by lathiat on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:28PM (#24231365)
This is a problem with Taxi drivers as well. Have had friends too close to the airport miss flights because drivers keep rejecting the fare because it goes to drivers near the airport who want a long trip.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by xapata on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:02AM (#24232143)
I've had taxi drivers yell at me for how close I lived to the airport. Angrily banging the steering wheel. "I waited in line for 2 hours and I get this fucking fare!?" Then they drive maniacally fast, weaving through traffic hoping to catch the tail end of passengers disembarking my flight. Mildly terrifying. Uber and Lyft were so welcome.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by goostavos on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:44AM (#24232646)
Things I don't miss about cabs:

1. them complaining about short fair or straight up driving off before I could get in because I wasn't going far enough (lesson learned in Vegas: get in before answering questions) 2. The constant, relentless dance about their "credit card machine being broken" "you can pay cash!" "there's an ATM machine inside"

Uber and Lyft were god sends when I was traveling a lot for work. click button, get in car, arrive at place. None of the adversarial nonsense.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Scoundreller on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:06AM (#24234980)
In theory, the idea of regulated, but high, fares for taxis came with a legal obligation to accept all rides.

But that never stopped drivers from playing that game anyway.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by plussed_reader on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:22AM (#24234656)
>Uber and Lyft were god sends when I was traveling a lot for work. click button, get in car, arrive at place. None of the adversarial nonsense

At the expense of the security of the drivers serving you. You get convenience, they get a subsistence lifestyle.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by barry-cotter on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:40AM (#24235257)
If they don’t want to follow the terms of the taxi license fuck them. Universal service, take every fare, don’t discriminate by race. If Uber and Lyft destroy the entire taxi industry it can’t come soon enough.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by meowface on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:13AM (#24235541)
I don't want anyone working a job to live a subsistence lifestyle, but taxis have also always been a nightmare for me (in the US and every country I've ever been in) and I never want to go back. Uber and Lyft are vastly superior and less stressful experiences for the customer in every way. I'd like them to be good experiences for the drivers, too, but the answer isn't to scrap the whole thing and go back to taxis.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by xapata on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:39PM (#24239617)
In some countries, the meter is just for show and every ride is a negotiated fare. Also, sometimes it's hard to distinguish taxi from pirate. Heck, in some places, even the licensed drivers are notorious for robbing tourists. Yikes.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Bootvis on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:21AM (#24235092)
A living wage and convenient cabs don't need to be mutually exclusive. Also, the adversarial nonsense was more than just a lack of convenience. Some drivers are just not nice people and managed to get away with it.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by xapata on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:37PM (#24239606)
You think they'd have been that angry if they had a decent lifestyle?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ric2b on Saturday August 22, 2020 @12:17PM (#24245105)
Maybe the causality goes the other way, people like that might have difficulty finding other jobs.

Most low-paying jobs aren't known for having lots of angry/rude people working them. Probably because in most jobs you have to work with other people or interact with customers within view of your co-workers/manager.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by gwd on Friday August 21, 2020 @05:55AM (#24233523)
But that's partly because, in all likelihood, the taxi driver also couldn't set their own rates. If that taxi driver could have asked $20 instead of the $3.75 legally mandated by the meter, would you have paid it?

It seems like allowing a proper market, where both riders and drivers could bid on rides, would solve both this problem and the SuperShuttle problem.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by eloff on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:32PM (#24236345)
Taxis work like this in Panama. Prices vary wildly ( but are low by developed world standards) and trying to get across town in times of high traffic is nearly impossible, nobody will take you ( they ask you where you're going, snort and drive away) until you offer at least four times the standard fare.

They're also unsafe, my brother was robbed at gunpoint by a fake taxi. I've heard multiple women who had to jump from a moving taxi to escape a potential rape.

Uber is more expensive in Panama, but I use it nearly exclusively.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by londons_explore on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:56AM (#24234475)
It doesn't, because at 3am in a sparsely populated bit of town, there aren't enough participants for a market to work.

For me to have real choice as a rider, I need at least a few different offers from drivers on the table, at which point I can pick the cheapest/fastest/highest rated/whatever.

Likewise, for the driver to have a true choice, he has to have multiple ride offers in front of him to pick the best.

The reality is that in most local markets, most drivers spend the majority of their time sitting around because there are no riders (and therefore would never turn down any work), and riders are frequently so far from drivers that there is only one driver to choose from within 10 minutes waiting time, so they would be forced to accept the ride, whatever the price.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by xapata on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:47PM (#24239686)
It was a $20-something fare. It'd vary between $22 and $26 based on traffic. I'm not sure how much of that was airport fees. For pleasant drivers, I'd bump it to $30 with tip.

Yeah, $20 and about 1 in 3 were visibly angry and not shy about letting me know it.

Context: I took this route almost weekly for a few years.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by derivagral on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:47AM (#24235330)
As a tourist in Shanghai/Beijing last year, this (technically illegal) practice is quite common if you don't have the right apps set up. We did frequently pay the higher fare, though the difference in currency was like $1 vs $3 iirc.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by thesimon on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:22AM (#24232812)
> Uber and Lyft were so welcome

Then you are lucky. I can't count the times the drivers called me before picking me up, asking me where I want to go and then cancelling if it was nearby (or no answer at all).

I never cancel, but they do.

And when they don't do that, they are extremly annoyed when it's something close to the airport.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by chriskanan on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:16AM (#24233902)
I've used both hundreds of times in the US, and that has never happened to me. They would only call to sync our positions to find each other, which happened very rarely.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by beerandt on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:20AM (#24234239)
This is basically the same thing, except cancelling based on pick-up location instead of destination. The app apparently doesn't always tell the driver exactly where the pickup is- it only gives the direction to drive and the next turn or two. It only gives the exact location once they're close to it.

This is to keep drivers from cancelling based on an out of the way pick-up location.

When they call, it's almost always to get information that the app won't give them.

I've gotten burned by both.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sails on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:33AM (#24232595)
I had the same thing, but the driver dropped his phone off with a friend that was still "within the airport" as we drove out the airpot so that he didn't lose his virtual place. He was pretty upset with me.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Cthulhu_ on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:29AM (#24233123)
Sounds like taxi drivers should be paid by the hour instead of per fare.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mcguire on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:39AM (#24235767)
Strange. I've heard the same stories about Uber: drivers complaining about short, unprofitable rides, and then there was the study about Uber drivers who take more risks while driving making more money.[1]

I suppose the only thing preventing the adversarial behavior is that the driver needs your five-star review.

[1] in the context of why women Uber drivers make less.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by itsoktocry on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:13PM (#24236130)
>Uber and Lyft were so welcome.

Because these companies are VC and investor subsidized, and apparently breaking labour laws. It isn't a functioning market. If they had to cover the full costs they would face the same issues as taxis.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by fellowniusmonk on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:57AM (#24232408)
I have had this exact experience, Taxi's are the worst and there is 0 feedback loop to improve quality. I once had a taxi driver yell at me and ask me why I didn't just take an uber if I live so close to the airport. Good riddance to traditional taxis (in all but a few cities where they are still marginally more convenient in my experience).
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by bobloblaw45 on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:13AM (#24233047)
Did doordash for a few weeks and discovered that this is exactly how the dashers in the community that made "okay" money operated. They turn down deliveries that didn't pay a certain amount and would sit in their car doing nothing if they had to.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by chmod600 on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:30AM (#24232580)
So lower the price of big trips and raise the price of small trips until thing balance out?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:03AM (#24234528)
We tried. The drivers revolted when we changed fares because they didn’t want things to change. Remember humans are irrational beings.

Most were longtime drivers and knew historical fare. We just couldn’t get them to change their mindset.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mikeryan on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:35AM (#24232288)
Then the “fix” would be to make the shuttle drivers employees right?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:08AM (#24234557)
Each van is a separate business franchise. The franchise owner, owned the van and could hire drivers as employees under their franchise.

It was more profitable for everybody with this way.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by neumann on Friday August 21, 2020 @05:57AM (#24233534)
I remember seeing off a rental travel van a few miles from LAX. They were a tiny business and had no shuttle service. Next door was a EUROPCAR rental and outside it a bunch of taxis and Ubers. They ALL refused to take me, and EUROPCAR security didn't want me catching their shuttle bus because I want a customer. I had to conspicuously beg them to let me on the bus in front of customers in the service area to not miss my flight.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mancerayder on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:30AM (#24231982)
I'm curious what you mean by failed - do you mean in the model and they had to change? California?

I'm seeing Supershuttle availability right now (not in California but in the U.S.)

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kyle_martin1 on Friday August 21, 2020 @01:47PM (#24237174)
SuperShuttle was bleeding money from subsidizing fares to compete with ride sharing and shrunk 30% YoY for 3 years straight. The SuperShuttle that you see is now just a brand facade and the original business is on a feeding tube.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by strbean on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:07PM (#24228992)
Regarding the whole declining rides thing...

Wouldn't most companies keep performance stats for their contractors, and if one started refusing lots of jobs, stop giving them work? Seems like Uber is just automating what is a normal part of working with a contractor.

With regards to unemployment insurance, this is really a hole in our safety net. Regardless of whether Uber drivers should be considered independent contractors, we should have a solution for independent contractors being put out of work.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:32PM (#24229268)
> Wouldn't most companies keep performance stats for their contractors, and if one started refusing lots of jobs, stop giving them work? Seems like Uber is just automating what is a normal part of working with a contractor.

The easiest way to allow drivers to set rates, and I'm not sure if there is some reason they haven't already done this, is to just let the driver tell the app their rate, so that they wouldn't even be offered rides below it (which naturally might mean they don't get as many), and the service would just give the ride to the driver in the area with the best rate. Obviously that would mean that if you set a lower rate you'd get more rides.

> we should have a solution for independent contractors being put out of work.

It's kind of non-applicable to the situation though, because when you have market pricing like this, you never really get put out of work, it's just that the amount you get paid may vary (and fall below the point where you seek other employment). Does Uber even do layoffs of contractors?

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by bhupy on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:25PM (#24229739)
Uber now lets drivers set their own rates, with a multiplier: https://therideshareguy.com/set-your-own-rates-uber-feature/
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by perryizgr8 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:49PM (#24231470)
> we should have a solution for independent contractors being put out of work.

We have one age old solution for this problem. It's called savings.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ganafagol on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:21AM (#24232529)
Hard to do for people living paycheck to paycheck. Then they should refuse the job you say? Yeah right then they don't even have that little paycheck anymore.

There is a power imbalance here, and that's the root issue. The employee and the employer are not on the same level in terms of negotiating power. Hard for tech people like the HN crowd to realize, but in most areas outside overpaid overdemanded software engineering that's reality.

The first industrial revolution showed this pretty dramatically. The solution was workers rights, unions etc. Those things that others here call bureaucrats with a those-people-just-want-to-destroy-the-free-market negative subtone.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by gridlockd on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:13AM (#24233602)
It's called a buyer's market. It's normal that there's an oversupply of unskilled labor, so the buyers of that labor have more power.

However, don't forget that it's usually the same for a business and its customers: Ride-hailing itself is a buyer's market. Lyft and Uber are unprofitable. The only way for them to stay "in business" is to constantly burn money.

Supply and demand is not a free market ideal, it's a law of nature. Worker's rights or unions can't raise market prices above demand by fiat, all they can do is limit supply so that prices naturally rise. That means more people are out of a job, but those that are in the job might make a little bit more, if the overhead of running the union doesn't eat up the difference.

You can make the argument that limiting supply is justified, just like forcing people into pension or health care systems may be justified because people are fundamentally irrational. You just have to be able to phrase it that way and acknowledge the trade-off, otherwise you're just fooling yourself.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sagichmal on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:43AM (#24235805)
> Supply and demand is not a free market ideal, it's a law of nature.

In which nature? Not this one...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by icebraining on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:12AM (#24233597)
That makes sense when the fat cats are making huge profits and paying a pittance to their workers. But Uber is losing billions every year. Where is the money going to come from?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by icebraining on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:32AM (#24233697)
Well, I know where it's coming from: a massive number of unemployed drivers, as rates are raised, reducing trips to the few that are profitable enough to pay for that (therefore also excluding lower-income users).

Maybe that's an acceptable trade-off, but we should be clear about it, not pretend we can just pump money from an empty well.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by take_a_breath on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:00AM (#24235456)
== But Uber is losing billions every year. Where is the money going to come from?==

Maybe it’s not a viable business model.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by strbean on Thursday August 27, 2020 @05:04PM (#24298645)
So people without enough savings to tide them over to the next job (about 70% of the US [0]) should be destitute if they are laid off? And in cases of national disaster, we want vast numbers of destitute people?

Preventing people from becoming destitute is a public good. People not having money to provide for their basic needs leads to increases in crime, which is bad for everyone. It leads to increases in disease, which is bad for everyone. It leads to decreases in economic activity, which is bad for everyone.

Arguing against the basic social safety net is just plain foolish and short sighted.

[0]: https://www.fool.com/retirement/2019/12/18/the-percentage-of...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by EliRivers on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:40AM (#24233738)
Solution found not to work.

Cost of living found to render savings unrealistic for many. Single accident, equipment failure, medical emergency or other such unforseeable found to wipe out meagre savings without warning. Precarious nature of employment market and inadequacy of social protections found to eradicate savings at horrific rate upon losing job, such that they become a countdown to destitution rather than a bridge.

Solution rejected; cannot be broadly implemented without other changes to the system. What else you got?

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by apsec112 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:37PM (#24228633)
Uber and Lyft already did this in California after the passage of AB5 earlier this year. That's why they now have price estimates instead of giving exact values ahead of time.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by jkarneges on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:21PM (#24229146)
Indeed Uber allows drivers to set fares in California. I'm not sure if that's true of Lyft though?

https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Uber-to-Lyft-Yo...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by smsm42 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:06PM (#24228979)
So how that works in practice? One of the major advantages of Uber for me was fixed price upfront. So now I don't know the price until I order the ride? What if the driver sets an excessive price - can I decline the ride?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by grandmczeb on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:58PM (#24229500)
See https://www.uber.com/blog/california/set-your-fares/

My understanding is that the rider is presented with a range of possible fares before searching (e.g. $9-10). If they are matched with a driver asking for a higher fare than that range they have the option to decline.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by coding123 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:59PM (#24230810)
So basically they will keep declining until they get the best price. It sounds like the proposed strategy is hogwash.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by grandmczeb on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:28PM (#24231010)
Who will keep declining? Drivers set their prices up front (they don’t even get requests outside of their price) and riders auto accept if it’s in the range they were shown.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by admax88q on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:16PM (#24230934)
Isn't that just supply and demand finding the market price for something?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by chairmanwow1 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:25PM (#24230989)
I will use Uber and Lyft less because of this. I don’t really want to go through the process of negotiating the rate. This is much more tedious.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by grandmczeb on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:36PM (#24231060)
Do you live in CA? Because this has already been rolled out for a while. If you don’t, you don’t have to worry about it.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by jocker12 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:53PM (#24231159)
> you don’t have to worry about it.

...yet!

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mcguire on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:57AM (#24235937)
A market economy is indeed a pain.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by wwweston on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:47PM (#24230726)
Sounds like a positive impact of AB5?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by bsimpson on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:55PM (#24228832)
We expect eBay/Amazon/Etsy to enforce standards on their platforms, but no one would argue that their sellers are employees.

I'm not convinced that having price and ride quality standards invalidates the contractor relationship.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:12PM (#24229037)
Quality is debatable but none of eBay, Amazon, or Etsy enforce prices. Fundamentally choosing prices is what defines markets, trying to set them is the actions of an employer.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by bgorman on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:40PM (#24229345)
This is just fundamentally wrong.

As a kid I refereed soccer games. There was a set cost structure for each game depending on age group and whether I was assistant referee or center referee.

There was a system where I could sign up in advance if I wanted the work or not. Uber drivers know exactly what they are getting into and they are free to quit at any time.

I was not an employee of the soccer leagues, I was an independent contractor who was able to work for multiple leagues if I wanted to and who was able to quit at any time.

There is a fundamental role in society for temporary work.

The employer will always set the price in any kind of business relationship. If I hire a contractor to remodel my house for 4 weeks does this mean he is a full time employee of mine and I need to provide him benefits. If he doesn't want the work, he doesn't need to be there.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by paxys on Thursday August 20, 2020 @07:48PM (#24230351)
> I was not an employee of the soccer leagues, I was an independent contractor

Actually you were an employee, just misclassified. If you took them to court you would likely win.

Being able to set your own hours, working part time, working for other employers, quitting at any time - these are all possible in an employee relationship.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mattmcknight on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:40PM (#24231428)
Just because they are possible in an employee relationship, setting your own hours is typically not representative of an employee relationship. Doing the same job for multiple customers is typical of an independent contractor relationship. I see no evidence of misclassification where this person was employed by multiple employers. Which of the leagues do you believe was his employer?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:35AM (#24232005)
Working 2 to 3 part time jobs is extremely common in the US for low level staff and has been for decades. These people say when their available and then get scheduled in.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mattmcknight on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:25PM (#24237497)
Of course, but that is not what make them employees, but is actually the part of the criteria for being able to claim independent contractor status. If you work one game for a soccer league, it is highly inefficient to have to create an employment relationship.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:31PM (#24238581)
My point was having 100 clients is a strong sign that someone is a contractor having 3 is not. It’s also just one of ~20 factors.

Also, length of relationship is judged on how renewable it is not how long it lasted. You can fire anyone on their first day.

It’s really a question of how open ended the work is not how long someone spends doing it. A restaurant always needs people to cook food and a league always needs a referee as an inherent part of it’s business model. On the other hand a company might only need an architect when designing their new office, aka it’s inherently a finite business need. That architect can largely work at a location and time of their choosing, the referee needs to be where and when the games are taking place. Similarly, an Uber driver needs to be picking someone up at a specific location and specific time going somewhere else or waiting 1 hour doesn’t work.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by OliverGilan on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:47PM (#24230720)
Under current laws you are correct but I think he is trying to highlight the point that maybe the laws shouldn't have this dichotomy and we should recognize there are instances where not being a full employee yet not filling the exact current definition of a contractor should exist
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by URSpider94 on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:59AM (#24232131)
The reason these laws exist is because corporations will use them to reclassify the maximum number of employees possible as contractors, so they can avoid a whole host of legal constraints around employment.

In general, flexibility in classification of workers almost always plays out poorly for the majority of workers.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by fastball on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:52AM (#24234074)
Yeah, to me a contractor is just someone that does one-offs. All these other things (setting prices, hours, etc) never actually struck me as accurate.

A contractor is someone you hire to perform a particular piece of work. An employee is someone you hire for their skill who is then expected to do many (sometimes varied) pieces of work.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:15PM (#24229664)
Uber drivers know exactly what they are getting into and they are free to quit at any time.

New Uber drivers don’t know what their pay will be. They can eventually keep a running average to get some idea, but that’s only meaningful as part of an ongoing relationship.

Surge pricing seems like a benefit to the drivers, but as they can’t simply decline endless non surge prices that’s not an individual price negotiation. Essentially, their options are quit the platform or accept the vast majority of whatever is being handed to them.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by chrischen on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:32AM (#24233696)
If you let people set prices some will set absurdly high prices. For good user experience those get filtered out. What gets left is the system that we currently have which is in fact price that is set by drivers—just not explicitly. When there's more drivers in the area, prices drop, when there are few drivers, prices go up. That's how it works and it makes little sense to revise the UI to present nonsensical prices (we'd always pick the lowest price of a certain threshold of driver rating) for the user to choose from in a list just to fit some arbitrary definition of contractor drafted by some dumb politician or lawmaker.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by fastball on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:55AM (#24234104)
It's not really set by the drivers either, its set by the market. Uber is just a market maker. Prices too high and passengers won't use the service. Prices too low and drivers won't drive. The whole goal of Uber is to find the ideal price to maximize capacity.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mardifoufs on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:15PM (#24229665)
I'm not sure but I think amazon enforces some kind of forced price adjustment policy. IIRC they change the prices if their algo detect lower prices somewhere else on the internet or on similar listings. I'll try to find the WSJ article where I've read about this.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by grumple on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:56PM (#24229982)
Maybe for their own products. Definitely not for others.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mardifoufs on Thursday August 20, 2020 @07:08PM (#24230069)
You are right,but they've just recently stopped doing that.

https://www.axios.com/amazon-price-practice-antitrust-elizab...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sida on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:25PM (#24230988)
you know uber lets drivers set prices now right?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:11AM (#24231883)
Globally they can’t, there is a tiny program in some parts of California designed presumably for local regulars, where some drivers can influence rates. https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/uber-lets-some-cal...

Of note the way it’s implemented is actively designed not to be used. Effectively Uber lets those drivers multiply their existing calculation by some number but not for example simply set a minimum charge or actually negotiate individual trips. Further, regularly declining trips is not accepted.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sida on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:02AM (#24234522)
Well they can in California and that’s what matters. Because this law is being contested in California.

I get the design. And of course uber wants to encourage lowering prices. However, the point remains: driver set prices, even if the design makes it less obvious. Eventually, if a driver has a number in mind, the driver flips a button to get that number.

As for negotiate individual trips, I don’t understand the point here. You set the prices for dollars per mile / per minute. The trip price is reflective of what the driver set already.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Retric on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:40AM (#24234784)
Not even everyone in California, further it’s US and other countries law ride sharing companies are breaking not just California law.

Why negotiation is important is overhead. Dollars per mile / per minute doesn’t cover time to pick someone up. If someone wants to go 1 miles and it’s going to take you X minutes to pick them up that’s much worse than a trip that’s 10 miles long and takes the same X minutes to pick them up. Uber really doesn’t want drivers to be able to decide such trips or people left for hours end up going to other platforms. However, Uber is pushing these losses to their drivers.

Now, if Uber is pushing people to take such unprofitable trips that’s fine if drivers are employees. But, it clearly breaks the model of drivers as independent contractors with each trip being independent.

PS: in term of breaking the law that’s not an automatic prosecution. Enforcement tends to be extremely lax on such issues.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Dobbs on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:02PM (#24228920)
In all of your listed examples people set their own standards, list their own products, and set their own prices. I’m no way is it comparable.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by EpicEng on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:47PM (#24231122)
>Let them set rates. Let them decline rides without facing penalties by the platform...

As a contractor I can set my rate, but the company can also simply not hire me. As a contractor I can act as I wish, but the company can terminate my contract. As a contractor, I pay for my unemployment insurance if I want it.

So... What's the practical difference? How is this any different than someone who decides to make a living by selling goods on eBay?

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by URSpider94 on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:55AM (#24232114)
You’re making an error in your analogy.

When I sell you my Smurfs collection on EBay, I set the terms of sale and you bid. You and I come to agreement on the terms of the transaction, within some limits that EBay, as the platform, sets.

When I sell a ride to you on Uber, Uber sets the price, tells me where to pick you up, and even dictates the route I should take. I don’t even get to see where I’m taking you until after I accept the ride.

On EBay, you and I are negotiating with each other. On Uber, the driver has no say in what the offer to the passenger is.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sida on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:39AM (#24234773)
You know your statement is categorically untrue right.

"Uber sets the price"

In California, the driver sets their own price.

"tells me where to pick you up"

Given that this is a taxi service. The driver has to know where to pick up. In fact, how is this different from EBay? Does the seller become an employee because ebay tells the seller where to ship the goods?

"even dictates the route I should take"

No it doesn't. Most drivers use google maps.

"I don’t even get to see where I’m taking you until after I accept the ride"

That's also categorically untrue in California. The driver gets to see the trip before accepting.

Of course, all of these rolled out because of AB5. The question is: can you tell me why the driver is an employee?

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by jeffbee on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:22PM (#24231322)
If your contract can be terminated at any time without cause, that supports the notion that you're an employee, not a contractor. That's one of the aspects of the Borello test.

https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/faq_independentcontractor.htm

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by renewiltord on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:50PM (#24231472)
> If your contract can be terminated at any time without cause, that supports the notion that you're an employee, not a contractor.

How interesting. That inverts expectations: you need a reason to fire a contractor but no reason to fire an employee.

Ah, I see it:

> Whether the employer has a right to fire at will or whether a termination gives rise to an action for breach of contract; and...

You can't fire a contractor when you haven't written in end-of-contract terms in there. i.e. when you contract with someone and you say "I hire this person from time X to time Y for money Z for delivery of A" you can't just abort sometime in the middle and be like "welp! off you go then".

However, it is perfectly reasonable for you to have exit clauses in your contracts to say that you pay per ride and that either party can exit the contract at any time.

i.e. it determines whether the 'firing' is a breach-of-contract situation

Okay, that makes sense, but it's not a factor in this case. Only a naïve reading makes it work that way but that won't work if you have the exit stipulations.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by jeffbee on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:54PM (#24231483)
Point 5, "What is the Borello test?"
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by renewiltord on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:54PM (#24231488)
Whoops, managed to update just moments before you posted. Sorry!
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by zebnyc on Friday August 21, 2020 @03:51AM (#24232963)
Won't companies get around this rule by just having these contractors become employees of "staffing agencies". Happens all the time in the software world
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ng12 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:53PM (#24229463)
> Let them decline rides without facing penalties by the platform

The independent contractor model works both ways. Uber has the right to avoid working with contractors who continually refuse work. You can't be picky about your work but also demand the company keep contracting you like you weren't.

The independent contractor model doesn't map perfectly to gig work but it's much closer than traditional employees.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by gamblor956 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:46PM (#24229909)
The point of Uber's alleged model is that Uber is not employing the driver, but rather that it is simply matching up drivers to passengers as a marketplace.

If that's the case, then Uber has no right to avoid working with contractors simply because they continually refuse work. That indicates a non-independent agency arrangement between Uber and the driver (aka "employee") and that's what they're claiming they don't have.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by dahfizz on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:59PM (#24230811)
I disagree. Solely from the perspective of the person running the platform, it makes lots of sense to factor in "likelihood of accepting" into your driver selection algorithm.

If I know driver X rejects all rides from a certain area, I'm going to stop showing them rides in that area. That way the user gets their driver faster.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by gamblor956 on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:14PM (#24236141)
Right, but now they're no longer a marketplace, now the're the one assigning the driver...which makes the driver their agent.

And if the driver is their agent, it matters whether the driver is classified as an employee or independent contractor.

If Uber wants to be a transportation marketplace, they can be, but they actually have to act like one. (And in fact, in CA they've been run a small trial in the Bay Area to make that shift. The trial will supposedly be expanded to all of CA this year.)

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Supermancho on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:07PM (#24230872)
> That way the user gets their driver faster.

How is that relevant? If you are an agency, you are advertising availability both ways. If you filter on behavior, you are no longer acting as an independent agency but as an agent for one side.

Disclosing pattern behavior (has rejected 12 rides this hour) is the correct way to provide value-add, not silently making decisions for parties.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Negitivefrags on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:32AM (#24232591)
If you went to a recruitment agency, would you expect them to send you to interview at every single company regardless of if they think that the company would be interested in hiring you?

Clearly agencies do discriminate who they match with each other. I would say that is the entire point of agencies infact.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Supermancho on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:35AM (#24235735)
> you expect them to send you to interview at every single company regardless of if they think that the company would be interested in hiring you?

I expect to be matched with every available role and an attempt to be made to represent me to them (and they to me). The disclaimer that they are looking for X Y or not Z is part of that. There is a practical issue muddying the metaphor which does not apply to the rideshare matching technology.

> Clearly agencies do discriminate who they match with each other.

That needs to be explicitly outlined in your contract with an agency. An employment agency is legally prohibited from doing that. This is the heart of the legal matter, imo.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by gamblor956 on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:17PM (#24236186)
Crucial difference: recruitment agency matches based on criteria that customer and contractor provide, because they work for both as an agent.

Agencies don't match based on their own internal criteria. That would recharacterize the relationship between the agency and the contractor, flipping it around so that the contractor becomes their agent.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by dahfizz on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:16PM (#24230930)
> How is that relevant?

User experience is incredibly relevant. The entire purpose of the platform is to match drivers and riders. If it can do that more effectively, it has become better as an independent platform.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Supermancho on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:33AM (#24235718)
> The entire purpose of the platform is to match drivers and riders.

That's fine, but we're talking about legal relationships here, not the facilitating product. If you are going to assert you are legally acting in an impartial role, turning around and claiming partiality for one party (the riders) invalidates that position.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by saalweachter on Thursday August 20, 2020 @07:34PM (#24230275)
I think the one exception there is that you need to distinguish between people who don't take contracts and people who break contracts -- refusing to take a job is one thing, but if a driver frequently accepts a job then cancels it halfway through (eg, they are driving to the pickup and suddenly get offered a better job, on the competing platform), that is a horse of a different color.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by perryizgr8 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:54PM (#24231487)
> If that's the case, then Uber has no right to avoid working with contractors simply because they continually refuse work.

Why? Uber has a right to do whatever they want for whatever reason or without any reason. Just like the other party in the contract, the driver, can stop accepting any rides and drive for lyft if he so wants. No reason required.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sudosysgen on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:56PM (#24230787)
Uber is arguing that drivers are not their contractors, but contractors of the riders. Therefore, Uber denying some wouldn't be the right of Uber unless they were contractors to Uber, in which case they would be misclassified and actually employees as per AB5.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ng12 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:08PM (#24231562)
So Uber isn't allowed to delist drivers from their marketplace?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sudosysgen on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:24PM (#24231645)
In a vacuum, yes. But when the controls that Uber exercises over their marketplace inch closer and closer to the control exercised by an employer over and employee, it becomes dicey.

More so, not accepting to sell your item (labour) at the first price offered becoming a cause for delisting in a marketplace is very shady and stretches the definition of "marketplace" really hard.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sytelus on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:30PM (#24230627)
So what if rideshare companies puts you under water if you are not working 40hr week just like an employee? Given the almost duopoly, wouldn't there is no recourse for workers but to accept the same terms as employees.

The essence of contractor model is that your future offers are based on past work, not past declines. If you as a driver were giving quality ride and decided to take 6 months break, there shall be no impact on your rating.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by piptastic on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:37PM (#24228629)
I think they do allow them to set rates now in CA

https://www.uber.com/blog/california/set-your-fares/

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mehrdadn on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:38PM (#24228646)
> Let them decline rides without facing penalties by the platform.

Does the model of IC have to imply that every ride is a new, independent contract? Is there no other reasonable model in which multiple rides are part of one contract? Why?

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by wtallis on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:02PM (#24228922)
What would such a contract look like? How would Uber or Lyft hold up their end of a N-ride contract if they don't end up having enough riders that day?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mehrdadn on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:11PM (#24229034)
> What would such a contract look like?

The obvious answer: perhaps more similar to the way it looks like right now? I just don't see why IC implies "let them decline rides without facing penalties by the platform".

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kelnos on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:43PM (#24229379)
I don't think it directly implies that, but I think many of the policies in place chip away at things that should be a part of an IC's experience. Imposing penalties from declining rides means that their power to set rates is reduced.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ttymck on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:04PM (#24228945)
What does the alternative look like? A contract for 10 rides? A contract for one week at a time? What if the driver wants to serve one ride, and then never again: what contract models allow that single ride to fulfill a "contract"?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by Swizec on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:08PM (#24228994)
The alternative is traditionally called a retainer. You hire the contractor for “various tasks over a set period of time up to N tasks and at least M tasks”

This is the indie version of being salaried. Very common among software engineers, for example.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by fooker on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:19PM (#24229115)
Contracts can be pretty arbitrary. "Independent contractor -- except can't turn down a ride."
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ng12 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:44PM (#24229889)
Great, next time I take a consulting gig I'll be sure to turn down the jira tickets I don't want to do.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by CarbyAu on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:34PM (#24231695)
If you were to have a separate contract for every Jira ticket that would be your call to make. Unusual, but fine.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by prepend on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:42AM (#24234019)
First, Uber doesn’t have separate contracts for every ride.

If a contractor had a contract to accept or decline every jira ticket (although I don’t see anyone ever forming that contract), if they declines too many tickets they would no longer have the option to pick.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by SubuSS on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:43AM (#24234397)
Could this be simply solved by having their star rating influenced by % ride drops? Uber can provide its price estimate as just that - a kelly blue book value so that riders can compare and contrast?

Most customers will search for a range of rating + price - so the market can regulate itself. I mean we accept amazon displaying user ratings - so I don't know why this won't work.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by brian_cloutier on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:12PM (#24229631)
> these workers need unemployment insurance, as Covid has shown, and somebody needs to pay for it: be it the workers or the ridesharing businesses.

The state could also pay for it, through tax revenue. Unemployment insurance seems like a great fit for a government, since any kind of massive correlated unemployment, as we're experiencing now, would absolutely wipe out any private insurer.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by _jal on Thursday August 20, 2020 @07:33PM (#24230271)
And that is the way it works, in functional countries.

And I absolutely agree, divorcing healthcare from employment is the single best thing the US could do to help fix several different issues.

But "We could massively restructure the US economy" is only an answer to "how should rideshare employees be classified" if you want to ensure nothing changes.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by rayhendricks on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:27PM (#24231356)
More specifically we need to totally decouple health insurance from employment. This is not post-ww2 anymore. No more Cadillac plans from FAANG companies either unless your paying for it out of your own pocket.

This would immediately solve half of the problems with healthcare in this country if everyone had to use the health insurance exchanges to buy insurance.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by scarface74 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:43PM (#24231752)
My health care plan was better and cheaper when I was working for a 50 person company than it is at a FAANG. Then again, I work for the one that is all about “frugality”....

It’s not bad, but no better than my jobs before the last one.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by cbmuser on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:13AM (#24234587)
> And that is the way it works, in functional countries.

In Germany, neither health insurance nor unemployment insurance are paid through taxes. Both are deducted from your salary.

It is true, however, that the government subsidizes the public health insurance so that low-income households can afford an insurance.

Also, we have similar laws in Germany (and most European) countries like AB5 that prohibit misclassification of employees as independent contractors:

> https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scheinselbst%C3%A4ndigkeit

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by mcguire on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:07PM (#24236055)
How is Germany handling ride-sharing?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sudosysgen on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:58PM (#24230795)
Sure. Once the State nationalizes unemployment insurance and healthcare insurance then we can reclassify them as contractors.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by dahfizz on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:09PM (#24230891)
This perfectly lays bare why I disagree with the ruling: you don't actually think drivers are employees, you just want them classified as employees so they get X benefits. It's a legislative hack.

It's seems so obvious to me that we need to create a third kind of worker: not an employee, not a contractor, but a new category that has some of the extra freedom of contracting and some of the benefits of employment.

It's important that we maintain integrity in our legal system. Uber drivers are not employees, and saying "we need to classify them as employees so they get insurance" is fundamentally backwards.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sudosysgen on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:29PM (#24231014)
No, they pretty much are employees, sorry. Under the current framework, they fit the definition of employee well in the letter and perfectly in the spirit.

Employees can have literally every single freedom that Uber drivers have. Nothing is disqualifying.

I agree that once we reform Healthcare and Unemployment, we can create a third category if we want, but there are actually no inherent disadvantages in freedom of being an employee in this case. The classification as contractor only really benefits Uber and hurts the common man.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by DangitBobby on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:00AM (#24231838)
>once we reform Healthcare

Your optimism is inspiring, but there's been "bipartisan support" for meaningful healthcare reform going as far back as Nixon. Probably further. If the people who actually make the rules wanted it done, it would be done.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sudosysgen on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:03AM (#24231856)
I share your pessimism, it was a rhetorical device, hence the "Once we're done reforming", which will likely never happen. Since Biden is against any form of Universal Healthcare, it is literally impossible before 6 years into the future.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by cbmuser on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:29AM (#24234710)
That still doesn't still solve the problem that drivers for UBER and Lyft don't get paid time off and paid sick leave.

Also, neither unemployment insurance nor healthcare are paid through taxes here in Germany, for example, yet the system works very well.

If the business models of Uber and Lyft cannot be profitable without misclassifying workers as independent contractors, then the business model is broken.

I don't understand why so many people, in particular from the US, have such problems understanding the reasoning behind laws to prevent the misclassification of employees as independent contractors.

It's actually very simple:

- If you're employed, you don't get to choose how you do your job and when, that's done by management. In return, the company pays your healthcare, pays unemployment and various other benefits. You are also protected through your company's liability insurance in case of an accident.

Your company basically pays you compensation for stealing your time but they are responsible for your well-being and safety during that time.

- If you're contractor, on the other hand, you get to decide how you do your job and when. You are free to decline offers, set your own prices and work with multiple partners at once. You get the maximum business freedom and are your own boss. In return, that also means you are responsible for your health insurance, your unemployment insurance and the liability insurance. You usually also can make more money as compared to being employed for the same job.

Being an employer and a self-employed contractor are fundamentally different work models with both advantages and disadvantages on their own. What Uber, Lyft and similar companies do is that they want both the benefits of an employee (being able to tell workers what to work and when) without the associated disadvantages and costs for them, shifting the risks and costs towards the workers as if they were independent contractors without the workers having the usual benefits of being an independent contractor.

And that's simply neither fair nor ethical. It's just exploitation. And that's why German (and most European law) protects workers against this misclassification.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by manquer on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:38PM (#24229331)
I understand that there is significant power disparity , however this is true for most contract gigs .

If you turn down some projects and/or get back feedback most companies will give you less work .

Consultants have to be really niche and highly skilled , hard to replace to be able to meaningfully negotiate their own terms .

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by matthewowen on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:26AM (#24235670)
I am as skeptical about uber as anyone, but didn't they do this already in california?

Riders can choose their own rates, which leads to users being offered a "closer but more expensive" option. They also got rid of the decline penalty iirc.

https://www.uber.com/blog/california/set-your-fares/ https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/Uber-makes-majo...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by spsful on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:03AM (#24235469)
I'd just like to add here that Uber is now allowing drivers to set rates.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by meowface on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:15AM (#24235562)
This comment definitely shouldn't stay buried. I wasn't aware Uber was doing this anywhere. If they are, that changes the debate.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ezoe on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:11AM (#24233041)
In my country, it's illegal for the taxi driver to decline the customer unless it has valid reasons(the customer is violent or threatening, does not satisfy the hygiene standard, road is damaged etc).

I think it's a fair regulation for it will casually lead to the discrimination.

Also, in my country, being a taxi driver requires special license and certified car so Uber/Lyft doesn't offer the service. They don't want to pay the cost of checking if the contractor satisfy the requirements of license and car.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by icebraining on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:59AM (#24234143)
How is that regulation enforced?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ezoe on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:11AM (#24234198)
By the usual law system. Police find the suspects, send it to the prosecutor, the court, lawyer, judge and all.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by icebraining on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:34AM (#24234345)
You're missing the part of getting evidence. Seems downright impossible to prove.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by SubuSS on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:46AM (#24234410)
I believe it will go along the lines of a sting. Get enough complaints, send enough undercover cops on said bad rides (short routes / racial differences - whatever the drivers are being accused of) and get em.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by rrdharan on Friday August 21, 2020 @11:53AM (#24235896)
I was going to say there's no way there's police budget for this kind of enforcement in the US but I would've been wrong:

https://gothamist.com/news/undercover-taxi-fare-investigatio...

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by prepend on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:24AM (#24233932)
Independent contractors can’t set their own rates or decline jobs.

FedEx uses independent contractors with established rates and requirements to carry.

There are many independent contractors who can’t set rates or choose not to do parts of the job.

Even my local barber shop co-op makes independent contractors have price ranges and doesn’t let them refuse walk ins if they are on duty.

When I was an independent contractor I paid into unemployment insurance so all these Uber drivers should have unemployment insurance that they pay themselves.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ta455634 on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:40AM (#24234375)
I think the distinction is that Uber is claiming to facilitate a contract between the driver and the user. In your examples, not being allowed to refuse work (I would guess) was given as terms of the contract, whereas the argument against Uber is that Uber is setting the rates that drivers are allowed to use to enter into a contract and penalizing them for not entering into a contract. That said in the system where contracts are made between drivers and riders if a drivers accepts a ride and then cancels it that would be a breach of contract and I think Uber would be right to use that as a reason for delisting drivers from their marketplace.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by prepend on Friday August 21, 2020 @08:44AM (#24234402)
Uber is the market maker, so it’s a three part contract. Between driver and rider; between driver and uber; between rider and uber.

Part of the market making function is matching prices offered and taken. Theoretically Uber is chopping off all the drivers with too high a price and riders who want too low of a price and “forcing a rate” is really just matching all the compatible rates that fall into a close range (“the algorithm”).

Maybe Uber could do more to show all the incompatible rates. But I think they delist drivers who would ask too high.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by cbmuser on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:30AM (#24234715)
> Independent contractors can’t set their own rates or decline jobs.

Yes, they can. If not, they're not independent.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by kortilla on Friday August 21, 2020 @12:05PM (#24236035)
Independent contractors have the same pricing ability as drivers. They can’t force people to pay higher rates any more than a driver, they can just reject jobs that don’t pay enough.

If you’re a plumber and you’re charging $1,000/hr, you’ll certainly be punished for your high prices and for rejecting work after you’ve already accepted (your public reviews on Yelp, etc will take a hit).

“Real independent contractors” have much less power than you think in a competitive market.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by ArkVark on Friday August 21, 2020 @06:09AM (#24233583)
If politicians really want to improve things for the working class: then lower sales taxes, extend land taxes (remove loopholes), support and encourage higher-density housing (including rooming houses), ban sugar, stop legal and illegal immigration from low and moderate-HDI countries, legalise safe drugs, and decriminalise all other drugs.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by CryptoPunk on Friday August 21, 2020 @09:14AM (#24234591)
How about things stay how they are, and drivers are treated as the contract they agreed to stipulates.

Mandated employment benefits are a completely unjustifiable imposition on private contracts.

Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by smabie on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:20PM (#24230949)
We know how to solve this problem:just use an order book or auction.
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by sixothree on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:02PM (#24228917)
Also, doesn't Lyft require drivers to have an Lyft sign on their car?
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by pishpash on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:01PM (#24231201)
It's the government that requires a trade dress: https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/tncinfo/
Re:Uber and Lyft shutdown in California averted as judge gra... by theroo on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:35PM (#24228596)
This is a key point, well made.