News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by ajiang on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:23PM (#17148537)
Making mass consumer flagship smartphones and going up against Samsung, Huawei, and Apple is a really tough game, but I'm sure Andy and the team at Essential knew that. I like that there are people who, in the face of giants, pick up the stone.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:59PM (#17148852)
I'm all for audacity, but I think it's better to have at least a few stones. It surprises me that they only raised enough money for one throw.

I believe there's still a lot of room for innovation in smartphones. But if your whole company is riding on your first product, I think it produces a lot of weird design pressure. You simultaneously want to be low risk and super edgy. While trying integrate a lot of new people, new partners, and (hopefully) new tech. Getting an industry-beater in one go under those conditions seems like winning the lottery.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by sebleon on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:50PM (#17150032)
They spent $100M on the first phone, and $200M left over. They had capital for multiple throws, and even started working on them.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:07AM (#17153821)
What still puzzles me then is why they didn't keep throwing. Did they really only have one product hypothesis that they thought was worthwhile? What lesson did they learn about phones here that was enough to kill the business? And did they really have to spend $100m to learn whatever that was?
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by flashgordon on Saturday May 26, 2018 @03:30AM (#17160684)
Actually there were a couple of reasons for this:

1. Not falling behind the curve. It seemed they couldn't stick to a deadline because each time they tried to, they would identify a newer cooler hardware feature that "had to be in". Doesn't help to do this when you don't have an established brand.

2. Incestuous hiring practises where it was based on brand name of canditates' school and past companies instead of focussing on indicators of execution and expertise!

3. No sense of urgency. In Andy we Trust!

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Saturday May 26, 2018 @11:54AM (#17162675)
Ah, interesting. That's a good example of something I think about a lot. Startups mainly focus on testing product hypotheses, but they also test organizational hypotheses, like ones about who to hire, how to organize people, and how to approach the work. This is a good reminder that you need to have enough of your organizational stuff right just to usefully test your product hypotheses.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cma on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:12PM (#17148944)
Their one throw took a notch out of every major smartphone.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by daveguy on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:49PM (#17149209)
Except it didn't, and that's why they are selling the business:

https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/12/17004278/essential-phone-...

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jhall1468 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:52PM (#17149225)
It was a joke. Essential introduced the "notch" in the phone around the camera. And it was a well-designed implementation.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by mjfern on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:37PM (#17150229)
I don't understand how selling 88,000 phones isn't considered a success. That's $44M in revenue, assuming the phones sold for $499 each. For a startup, even one founded by a Google veteran, like Rubin, this seems like a home run for a first product offering.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by unfunco on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:24AM (#17151375)
The comment above says they spent $100M to make that $44M revenue.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by icc97 on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:18AM (#17152074)
Going up against major players typically starts with a massive cost, consider the losses that Tesla is taking on. As per my other comment [0] from the article it's more like $89M in revenue.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17152056

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by yitchelle on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:38AM (#17150895)
The phone selling business is not as clear cut as selling oranges at the market. There are deals with carriers and other infrastructure stake holders that cloud the view significantly.

What that means to Essential's bottom line is not clear. It would be difficult to even consider the assumption of the revenue of $44M for them.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by baybal2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:07AM (#17151806)
>The phone selling business is not as clear cut as selling oranges at the market. There are deals with carriers and other infrastructure stake holders that cloud the view significantly.

My personal experience is a polar opposite of this.

I myself worked with few companies doing private label handsets. It is a near foolproof business.

You go to an ODM, put money first for a respin of a successful product under your brand, then you dump the batch on TaoBao, Aliexpress, and trade companies. This will stably gain you profits in single digits, and at about %15 if you have some luck along with real insight into doing things like that.

Should Andy be more easy on pricing, and also "simply dump the product off an online marketplace," he would've been in black by now.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by icc97 on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:15AM (#17152056)
More proving your point, but from the article:

> The phone’s initial price was $699, the same as an iPhone viewed as a competitor. At that price, the company sold as few as 20,000 units across its website and third-party distribution partners, one of the people said. Last October, Essential lowered the price by $200, which boosted sales. The company has sold at least 150,000 to date, according to the person familiar with the company.

So that's 20,000 * $699 + 150,000 * $499 ~ $89M

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:24AM (#17153981)
That's total sales, but probably not total revenue, in that third-party distribution partners (that is, stores) will take a slice. Possibly a big one given Essential's relatively poor bargaining power.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by ksec on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:34AM (#17150632)
>assuming the phones sold for $499 each

Except it isn't. Many were sold at heavy discount.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by snaky on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:11AM (#17152416)
More than 100,000,000 units is a one quarter at Chinese market. How 88,000 is even something to talk about.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by ianai on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:49PM (#17149507)
It’s one thing to try to enter a difficult market. It’s a complete other to enter a market with an inferior product.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by RachelF on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:35PM (#17149727)
...and overpriced for what it was.

Perhaps if they hadn't hyped it up so much before release, there would have been less disappointment.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by _pmf_ on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:07AM (#17151553)
> It’s a complete other to enter a market with an inferior product.

It's completely natural and sensible to enter a market with a product that is inferior in some aspects, but has a huge USP, which this phone had.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by vvanders on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:30PM (#17149938)
It's not really his first product, Andy has a ton of experience with all the generations of Sidekicks + Android partnerships(one could argue the G1 was almost a spiritual Sidekick hardware wise).

I wonder if it might be time for him to branch out into a new domain, I feel like there may just be too much common ground that's already been covered before.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by discordance on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:48AM (#17150697)
Andy Rubin was tasked with heading up Boston Dynamics at Google, who desperately needed leadership and guidance. but he ditched them to go do Essential.

Soon after he left, Alphabet sold BD to Softbank.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by goatherders on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:11PM (#17148933)
You make good points for sure. I wonder how much it takes to bring one phone to market compared to 2 or 3. In other words, how possible/practical is it to try for 2 or 3 bites at the apple compared to simply focusing on getting the first one right enough to keep going.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by kyriakos on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:48PM (#17150466)
OnePlus started with one stone and it seems to be doing quite well. I guess the business model is different though.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shrikant on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:38AM (#17151695)
OnePlus is one of many many brands run by a Chinese electronics behemoth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBK_Electronics
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by telltruth on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:12AM (#17151832)
Key reason for success for OnePlus had been price point. It's enormously popular in 3rd world because you can get specs that used to be 2X expensive from other. If you can keep quality same while reducing price by half, chances are that you are going to be very successful. Chinese company can do that but US company cannot because if they can then there will a Chinese company directly competing with them. Essential understood this and so never wanted to compete on price. You cannot win price war with Chinese company.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by suckerburg on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:16AM (#17150563)
OnePlus wasn't an individual company working from scratch, they have immense support from Oppo for R&D.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by megy on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:25PM (#17149038)
Yes, because if a small company can't successfully make one product, they should instead make 3.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by nine_k on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:40PM (#17149462)
Translated to the standard startup-speak: they should have enough runway for two pivots.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jodrellblank on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:32PM (#17149079)
Yes, because they will learn from the failures of the first, and make the second better. Then learn from the failures of the second-system-syndrome and make the third genuinely better.

Which is more likely to succeed, 1 attempt or 3 attempts?

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by astrowilliam on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:47PM (#17149189)
We're talking about a small company here. Sometimes small companies don't have the resources to move forward with a 2nd product if the first one didn't pay off.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:24PM (#17150176)
Ah, this poor, tiny company that raised only $330m: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/essential-2#section-...
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by vm on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:48PM (#17148765)
Different [1] is one of my favorite books on how to find a unique niche in crowded markets. It is written by a (brilliant) marketing professor but is useful for product strategy. Also see Blue Ocean Strategy [2] on this topic.

Essential had neither of these approaches.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Different-Escaping-Competitive-Youngm... [2] https://www.amazon.com/Blue-Ocean-Strategy-Expanded-Uncontes...

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by sometimesijust on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:25AM (#17152890)
I disagree. They are pursuing a Blue Ocean strategy but failing in execution as well as suffering from fast followers.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by vm on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:18AM (#17154510)
"Essential Phone The most beautiful Android upgrade, ever." is the tagline on their homepage. That's hardly an uncontested product niche (aka Blue Ocean Strategy). Apple dominates "beautiful" phones. Even if you believe the Android carve out (I don't), this is literally what Samsung has been doing for years and Google is doing with Pixel.

Doomed strategy from the start.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jillesvangurp on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:14AM (#17150797)
Hmd/Nokia succeeded where Essential failed in roughly the same timeframe grabbing a lot of marketshare. So it can be done. Essential fought themselves into a corner with a product that was too expensive and not that remarkable or indeed essential. Wrong strategy and they failed to deliver something to differentiate their products. Nokia took a more simple approach by first covering the low end with attractively priced and relatively well received products. Crucially, by shipping stock android, they took software off the critical path and wowed consumers at the same time by not exposing them to the usual crapware and focusing on hardware quality instead. Then they started doing the same for the mid and high range. It turns out there's a market for well built phones that simply run the latest android.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by stingrae on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:23AM (#17150826)
It's not necessarily a fair comparison given the power of the Nokia brand in the mobile phone industry. Would Essential have gotten as much press as it did if it had gone to the low end? I doubt it.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cc439 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:26PM (#17149691)
It's not like it's hard to carve out a niche now that literally every flagship phone is functionally identical. There have been so many novel features that have been tried since the birth of the Android ecosystem that there are bound to be dozens of useful, now-unique features to choose from that only failed to be adopted because the phone they debuted on was fatally flawed in other ways.

In my opinion, there are 3 major features that are immediately obvious, yet always overlooked by OEMs that are such low hanging fruit that I'm constantly amazed that no manufacturer has put them all together. They aren't even all that interesting either, the only reason they haven't caught on is that all the also-ran's have tunnel vision about playing copycat with Samsung and Apple.

1. Battery life. Seriously, we could have phones with 4+ days of battery life if we'd only stopped making them thinner to the point where the rear camera sticks out, effectively ruining the aesthetic of thinness. We've also sacrificed the 3.5mm jack in the pursuit of the most anorexic phones imaginable and all for what? A feeling of awe when we open the box of a new phone which only lasts 10 seconds before we throw it in a case which makes it as thick as an OG Motorola Droid?

2. Stock Android. Stock Android. Stock Android. I will never buy anything but a phone running stock Android (or maybe a dumbphone once Big Brother Google pushes me over the edge). Even the most technically illiterate users recognize that stock Android (whether they know what that means) is vastly superior to the Samsung Galaxy Whatever they just traded in.

3. Durability/Ease of Repair. Modern phones have become less fragile in many ways (waterproofing) but the screens and batteries are still weak points. Glass can never be made shatter-proof and lithium ion batteries will always lose a significant amount of charge capacity after being cycled several hundred times (a fault made worse by fitting a phone with a battery that often requires 2+ charges a day). So how do you fix this? Easy, just make the screens and batteries easy to replace like those of older iPhones. This works directly in conjunction with point #1 as we've been forced to accept bonded screens and sealed back panels as a result of the thinness wars.

Extra Credit: You know how you can get my money as well as the money of everyone I know? Bring back the landscape QWERTY keyboard. There hasn't been a phone since the Droid 2 that could lay claim to being anything more than a lower midrange design. The first company to do all of the above will make waves, I promise you.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by stirlo on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:45PM (#17149771)
“Even the most technically illiterate users recognize that stock Android (whether they know what that means) is vastly superior to the Samsung Galaxy Whatever they just traded in.”

Not even close to reality. Tech savvy users recognise stock android occasionally however when I worked telco sales frequently the thing that got the sale across the line was some kind of gimmicky feature/addition the manufacturer had integrated. The average user couldn’t even tell iOS and Android apart as long as it had the Facebook app installed.

Manufacturers should of course recognise the massive saving to be had by developing only minimal customisation and being able to quickly roll out updates/new features in the latest Android releases.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cc439 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:03PM (#17156882)
I guess I should have phrased that as "even the most technologically illiterate users will come to recognize the superior user experience of a phone running stock Android after getting comfortable with it. This effect works regardless of their ability to understand exactly what the reason for the improved user experience is, it's just so immediately apparent they can't help but notice."

You're right in that gimmicks move phones in a retail environment. When a consumer will only give ~1 minute's worth of attention (at best) to each phone in the store, selective pressure rewards flashy gimmicks that leave the greatest immediate impression. The thing is, there is a huge portion of consumers who have moved to buying phones online based on research conducted entirely through online sources. The tech-savvy reviewers who these consumers are likely to come across are always vociferously supportive of any attempt to use stock/stockish Android. That bullet point always gets a favorable mention even if the total sum of the phone's features leads to a poor review. Build a following among those who make informed and objective decisions and eventually you'll get the attention of the retail/tech illiterate consumer.

That's how Samsung managed to become the king of the Android world, the Galaxy S was the first decent phone hardware-wise that could be flashed to stock or custom ROMs that fixed the issues with early versions of Android. The Galaxy S, S II, and Galaxy Nexus became the phones for the tech-savvy Android crowd and their objectively supported recommendations to less savvy friends and family created a sales tsunami that kept rolling long after Samsung abandoned the key feature (making flagship quality phones that were hacker friendly) that led to their success in the first place.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by pjmlp on Monday May 28, 2018 @07:28AM (#17171846)
Not really, Samsung was already winning out thanks to their UI and usability over stock Android.

I never knew anyone that would burn custom ROMs on their Samsungs.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by TheOtherHobbes on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:51AM (#17151228)
Unfortunately this.

Engineers make up a tiny percentage of phone buyers, and a feature list that will excite engineers has very little in common with a list that will make most consumers hand over money.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by s73v3r_ on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:01PM (#17149832)
"2. Stock Android. Stock Android. Stock Android."

How is that differentiating yourself?

"The first company to do all of the above will make waves, I promise you."

I highly doubt it. For one, hardware keyboards are expensive to do right, and they add to the repair costs and warranty costs of the phone. Doing it means either making your phone more expensive (read: Fewer people will buy it) or using cheaper parts elsewhere (read: Most people who claim to want hardware keyboards will complain about this, and then not buy it).

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by s17n on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:53PM (#17150038)
> How is that differentiating yourself?

Cause nobody else does it.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by dvh on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:15PM (#17150359)
I have two cheep Chinese Android phones and both have stock Android. I'm writing this reply from $49 100g 4GB "myPhone pocket". But I'm not gonna lie, I had to write my own browser to make it usable.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Jaruzel on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:36AM (#17151147)
Out of curiosity, what was wrong with the browser it came with ?
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by dvh on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:42PM (#17160073)
To slow, too much memory (when I returned from browser to previous app it was killed for OOM)
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by aembleton on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:43AM (#17152232)
Apart from Nokia
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by JacobJans on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:02PM (#17149836)
My Asus Zenfone 3 has a lot of flaws, but the battery life is awesome. After a day of very heavy usage, I'll still have over 50% battery life. Light usage usually leaves me with 80 to 85%. It makes up for the flawed custom android they put on it. If only it was stock android, as you say.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by retzkek on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:44PM (#17150254)
I've had a Moto x4 Android One (Project Fi) for six months and I am still very impressed with its battery life. Right now it's at 75% after 15 hours of admittedly light use, but even under heavy use it easily lasts a full day. Great phone, especially as a "mid-tier."
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cc439 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:06PM (#17156913)
I've developed a strong loyalty to Motorola because of this. I've owned several Verizon exclusive models (Droid Turbo, Turbo 2, Z Play Droid) and all have featured incredible real world battery life and stockish Android. I'd kill to have received another one for work even though they are decidedly "mid range" in terms of features and specs. Instead, I've been saddled with a Galaxy S7 which is a complete turd despite its supposed status as a "flagship".
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by sjellis on Saturday May 26, 2018 @03:21AM (#17160660)
"I've developed a strong loyalty to Motorola because of this. I've owned several Verizon exclusive models (Droid Turbo, Turbo 2, Z Play Droid) and all have featured incredible real world battery life and stockish Android."

Ny past three phones have also been Motorola, because they are basic, well-made devices with close to stock Android. I really hope that Motorola keep differentiating themselves by shipping phones that don't have gimmicks.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by goatherders on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:23PM (#17149907)
I have a Sam S8+ would gladly add a 1/2 inch of depth for a 2 day battery.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by paulie_a on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:16PM (#17150142)
I just dumped my s8 because of all the custom Samsung software. Great hardware crapped up with their bullshit. It's like they go out of their way to make an inferior product by adding their garbage software to it.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by dwighttk on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:33AM (#17152540)
Surely there’s a case that does this.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shp0ngle on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:37PM (#17149976)
If you want stock android, try Android One phones.

I have Xiaomi Mi A1, which is Android One, and it's amazing.

HTC is selling one too, I think. Motorola also maybe

Android One are stock Android phones, and I get updates once a month more or less. It actually delivers on its premise

Also, I think Elemental phone or whatever was the name had stock Android

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by joecool1029 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:39PM (#17150239)
> HTC is selling one too, I think. Motorola also maybe

The entire Nokia (HMD) line is Android One. With LTS commitments on every android phone they release.

I picked up a cheap Nokia 6 a couple months ago and was pleasantly surprised to see it actually OTA updates with no nonsense and actually works on voLTE.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by konraditurbe on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:35PM (#17155363)
Mi A1 owner here, very pleased with the phone, especially for the price I paid.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shinratdr on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:28PM (#17150189)
> Battery life.

Nobody but technically inclined users care that much about battery life anymore. For most people, you can throw a rock and hit a phone that has all day battery life. People are used to charging their phones nightly.

People will take a battery life improvement, but it's not a driver. Many manufacturers have slapped in giant batteries or included battery modules, removable back cases that allow for double life batteries. None have caught on, because really. If I have to charge it once a day or twice if I'm using it for games all day or something, then what is the difference? Have a charger at work, a charger at home and a decent phone, and you'll never have a battery life issue. I don't think I've depleted my iPhone X once and I've owned it since day one.

> Stock Android

Another thing nobody but techies care about, and even they are mixed. I know plenty of people who prefer modern TouchWiz, or more likely, simply don't care. Caring about stock Android really only applies to those who spend most of their time in the launcher or OS, which isn't most people. For most, their phone is a gateway to apps, and this goes double for Android phones.

If the primary use of your phone is launching Instagram, Snapchat, WhatsApp, Gmail & Facebook, then who the hell cares what the launcher interface is? Most younger and less technical users don't even use the dialer or contacts or other apps people typically leave stock.

> Durability/Ease of Repair

I can't believe people can actually say this with a straight face. Once again, the last thing on people's list. It's far and away a nice to have, not anything that actually influences a purchasing decision for a significant number of people. For those that it does matter to, they'll just slap it in a case anyways. It also requires a boatload of design compromises to make things easier to repair.

> Bring back the landscape QWERTY keyboard

The icing on the cake. I don't know who you know, but seriously, nobody wants a hardware keyboard. Most people under 30 (y'know, the people who buy new phones frequently and use them as primary computers) would actually be significantly slower on a hardware keyboard, regardless of layout.

What you've described is a giant phone, double or triple the size of any other normal between the massive battery, use of durable materials and durable slider mechanism. Nobody wants this. You might, and some of your friends might, but any company that took a run at actually making this phone would have abysmal sales.

You make a ton of assumptions here, all of which smack of someone who hasn't spoken to a normal consumer or someone under 30 in a long time. I suggest hanging around retail for a little bit, because you're in for a rude awakening.

Things people actually care about in a phone, in rough order:

1. OS - This is tied for the next two for number one. Nobody gives a shit about stock Android, but most are pretty set in one camp or the other in regards to iOS v Android at this point. People do switch though, so its not the highest priority for all.

2. Screen Size - Massive consideration. Many want a giant screen, many want a manageable screen, both are pretty set in their ways.

3. Camera - I can't count the number of times people have asked me for a phone recommendation and had this as their number one concern. I put the other two first because they tend to have those decided before speaking to me, so they are typically more important. Camera quality, as subjective as that can be, can really sell a phone.

4. Design - Gasp! Weight, thickness, materials. Actually really important. It may not show up on a spec list, but people do make decisions based on this even if they aren't acutely aware.

5. Price - For many this is the number one factor, but for many it's not even on the list so it's hard to know where to place this one in terms of order.

6. Cool new features - Hugely important, triggers upgrades. The giant OLED screen & FaceID sold plenty of people on the iPhone X. "What can this phone do that my phone can't" is a strong driver of upgrades that aren't required due to a failing/broken phone.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by fauigerzigerk on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:49AM (#17151967)
>Nobody but technically inclined users care that much about battery life anymore.

That is very far from the truth. Just look at the scramble around power outlets in all sorts of public places from cafes to trains. People are desperate to recharge their phones.

Stories of phones running out of battery are now as much part of folklore as not having coins for payphones was a few decades back.

Go to any Android or iOS support forum and you will find that battery draining questions are a major category. And it's plain to see that it isn't just techies asking these questions.

Battery is also _the_ limiting factor for the tasks phones are suitable for. CPUs, especially on iPhones, are capable of so much more than what the battery allows.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shinratdr on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:29AM (#17154630)
I never said people don't have issues with battery life. I said it's not a driver for most phone purchases, and I stand by that. Good battery life or better than average is a nice to have.

> Go to any Android or iOS support forum

The average consumer will never post to any support form in their entire lives. /r/iOSbeta was all battery life posts until they were banned because they cluttered up the subreddit, because of course that will be a common issue.

> Battery is also _the_ limiting factor for the tasks phones are suitable for.

But we don't have an answer for that. All GP is suggesting is slapping in a giant battery. That won't solve the problem at all. If someone has a breakthrough solution for multi-day battery life that isn't just "throw in a bigger battery and to hell with design" then that would be a game changer.

However, is it a major driver in purchases? No. Like I said, there have been plenty of "big ass battery" devices, none have been successful, because it's not a significant driver of sales.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Steltek on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:02AM (#17153227)
Badly written apps and forgetful users won't be solved by larger batteries. It'll just extend the time between incidents slightly.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Jaruzel on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:31AM (#17151134)
> The icing on the cake. I don't know who you know, but seriously, nobody wants a hardware keyboard.

Not true. If it were true the Blackberry KeyONE wouldn't have been the moderate success that it was. Clearly TCL believe that QWERTY phones are viable as they've just announced the Blackberry Key2.

My better-half has not one, but two, KeyONEs - one for work, and one for personal use. They are very nice, well built phones with a pretty good spec. If you type stuff all day, then they are a great option.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by distances on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:44AM (#17151186)
Your experience is anecdotal. So is mine, and I haven't seen a single hardware keyboard in use -- not a single one, from any manufacturer -- since Nokia N900 was a thing almost ten years ago.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Jaruzel on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:52AM (#17151232)
It's not actually. What I didn't say, is that my other half works for a large Law firm. Most of the Partners there (100+) have switched from iPhones to Blackberry KeyONEs as they can actually work on them because of the proper keyboards.

At the end of the day, keyboardless and keyboard phones CAN co-exist. I was just disagreeing that with the point that no-one wants a keyboard phone.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shinratdr on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:34AM (#17154678)
> I was just disagreeing that with the point that no-one wants a keyboard phone.

Perhaps glib. I could have clarified further but "a keyboard phone could carve out a small but somewhat lucrative niche amongst people who refuse to get used to software keyboards, people over 30-40, and people who owned devices that sport hardware keyboards in the past but they are ultimately doomed to irrelevancy in the long run" is less pithy.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by hbosch on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:19AM (#17153378)
I can’t find anything even close to “moderate success” for the KeyOne. Most of the articles I pulled up describe awful sales although Blackberry had an optimistic outlook. Most outlets citing sales numbers say that Blackberry only managed to outperform one company: the now-deceased Essential.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shinratdr on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:31AM (#17154646)
> the Blackberry KeyONE wouldn't have been the moderate success that it was.

Ok, well I come from the land of BlackBerry, and I have seen maybe one person with this phone in the wild. Keep in mind that BlackBerry was still a significant force here until years after it was dead everywhere else.

Just out of curiosity, how old is your better-half? Did they have a hardware keyboard device in the past?

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Jaruzel on Saturday May 26, 2018 @07:23AM (#17161445)
I don't think age has anything to do with it. People either prefer hard keyboards or not. Technology should be an enabler, and allow people to use the device formats they want. Just because 90% of people are now used to touch keyboards, doesn't make the remaining 10% wrong.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by axaxs on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:43AM (#17151184)
i would buy a phone with a good hw based keyboard immediately. I was just thinking tonight, after correcting my 400th mistake, how weird it is we as consumers put up with this inefficient on screen keyboard.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by konraditurbe on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:27PM (#17155284)
>Another thing nobody but techies care about, and even they are mixed. I know plenty of people who prefer modern TouchWiz, or more likely, simply don't care. Caring about stock Android really only applies to those who spend most of their time in the launcher or OS, which isn't most people. For most, their phone is a gateway to apps, and this goes double for Android phones.

Umm, I want a phone with the latest security updates, since it holds very personal information I don't want it to have unpatched access. Phones with Stock Android - on average - get more updates/faster updates [1] (if at all). Also Stock Android gets rid of manufacturer code which can affect apps, for instance some Huawei phones, on Nougat, have USB-OTG disabled in the skin, accessible otherwise with LOS.

[1] Phones like Pixel, Android One program, Sony, Nokia, OnePlus (https://www.computerworld.com/article/3257607/android/androi...)

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cc439 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:24PM (#17157032)
I actually based my recommendations off of the most common areas of complaint I come across and specifically the areas the younger set complain about most often.

Battery Life:

You can find someone tethered to a wall outlet in almost any public space these days. The apps which the younger set use most frequently (photo, video, and data heavy social media apps) are also enormous battery hogs. Facebook and Snapchat in particular are the source of more "my phone is on 2%, can I borrow your charger?" requests than anything else.

Durability/Ease of Repair:

Go to any high school or college campus and count the number of phones you see with cracked screens. I can't even count the number of people I know who have been stuck using a phone with a busted screen until they're eligible for an upgrade or able to afford a new one. Back in the days of the iPhone 4, a broken screen was a $50 fix. Now it is a mark of shame that lasts until you buy a new phone because replacing a screen is either not feasible at all or far too expensive to justify (this applies more to phones in the $250-300 range)

Bring back the landscape QWERTY keyboard:

I'll admit this is heavily biased by my curmudgeonliness because I loved my OG Droid and Droid 2, but there's something to be said about a feature that helped those 2 phones rack up huge sales figures but hasn't been seriously tried ever since. In relation to its appeal among the younger set, the amount of horrific typos and "oops, autocorrect screwed that up" I see across all forms of content generated on software keyboards is enormous. People may be "faster" with software keyboards but the speed means nothing when they either butcher their point or have to edit/send a second message to correct their mistakes. Also, the proportion of smartphone users who actually use swipe style predictive input and those who hunt and peck is skewed heavily toward the peckers.

You make good points in relation to camera quality and cost but I see those as inherently "solved" problems in today's smartphone market. There are dozens of phones with great cameras, copying what they're doing is both easy and not a real differentiator. Any feature I neglected to mention can be covered under the heading of "just don't screw it up", there's no excuse for fucking something up when you have dozens of examples of how to do things right. As far as cost is concerned, it's obviously factor #1 these days as the "mid range" is continually eaten away by pressure from unceasingly good budget phones and the "flagship" price point becomes unattainable to startups that can't create an entire supply chain to support the latest whizbang innovations. I still think there's room for a phone like I've described at the $400-500 price point, whether that's achievable with the landscape QWERTY is the real question.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by pjmlp on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:55AM (#17150964)
I can't stand the bland Stock Android UI, some of us do like using good looking UIs.

It is like using fvwm instead of Enlightenment.

Hence why many common users always install an Android theme when the phone comes with Stock UI.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by nixonpjoshua1 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:16PM (#17150361)
I think the closest thing to what you want is a Blackberry keyone, great battery life, nearly stock Android with unobtrusive changes and a great qwerty.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by cc439 on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:09PM (#17156935)
I would have bought/requested one of the Blackberry offerings a long time ago if I could manage landscape keyboards with my large hands. They're just too damned small.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by matwood on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:02PM (#17149838)
While I agree if you’re going Android make it stock Android comment, I know tech people who prefer Samsung’s software.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by PascLeRasc on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:47PM (#17149780)
Are there still phones being made with stock Android and a headphone jack? That's a big part of durability to me since the USB-C adapters seem to constantly break.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by namibj on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:08PM (#17150102)
Not sure if it's still made, and it's barely still a phone (it's 4mm total height away from not letting me sit down if I have it in the front pocket of a normal, male jeans), but the Lenovo Phab 2 Pro serves as a nice tall (3:4 [sic]) 80-col (exactly) terminal... In portrait mode, using JuiceSSH, but any reasonable terminal should do the trick. As far as I know they just skipped the budget for a custom firmware, at least for the most part. It doesn't feel branded. The ToF sensor is nice, but the tracking algorithm seems borked, as it often looses registration, leading to shifting artifacts in any scan, and I have not yet found any software that allows the user to only do a very rough recontruction live, and do high quality post processing offline.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by aembleton on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:37AM (#17152192)
Nokia 8, Nokia 6, probably all of the Nokia phones.

I use the Nokia 8. Works great.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by konraditurbe on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:35PM (#17155368)
Android One phones like Nokia phones and Xiaomi Mi A1
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by fjsolwmv on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:25PM (#17149915)
Moto/Lenovo
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by incompatible on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:14PM (#17150137)
Stock Android + quick updates to every new version, forever, + easy installation of alternative Android distributions.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by Steltek on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:44PM (#17150253)
So Essential then? They shipped updates faster than Google, was close to bone stock, and was project treble compatible for custom roms.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by incompatible on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:39AM (#17151435)
Thanks, Android seems to be getting somewhere with that. https://github.com/phhusson/treble_experimentations/wiki

The Blackview A20 that's listed there is a pretty cheap phone.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by arbitragy on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:22PM (#17169919)
They are for sale : )
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by rb808 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:55PM (#17149243)
You mean going up against Samsung, Huawei, and Apple, + Sony, Google, Motorola, LG, Xiaomi, HTC, Microsoft, Nokia, BlackBerry, BLU, ZTE, Kyocera, Alcatel & a bunch of generics. That's tough!
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by shams93 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:54PM (#17148804)
Yeah a genius isn't always motivated by the same success metrics are normal people sometimes they just want to make something amazing even if they know it's a one off because it's not just business it's art.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:04PM (#17148887)
I like art, and am all for it. But nobody should mistake it for a business.

Want to make a poignant, subtle art-house film? Go for it. Want to make a blockbuster sequel which will be predictably profitable? Go for it. But please don't raise money like you're doing the latter and then do the former. Steve Jobs said, "Real artist ship." And given his record at Apple, I suspect he'd agree that real artists ship things people want.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by staunch on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:37PM (#17149114)
No one has said it better than Steve Jobs himself:

"We did iTunes because we all love music. We made what we thought was the best jukebox in iTunes. Then we all wanted to carry our whole music libraries around with us. The team worked really hard. And the reason that they worked so hard is because we all wanted one. You know? I mean, the first few hundred customers were us."

"It's not about pop culture, and it's not about fooling people, and it's not about convincing people that they want something they don't. We figure out what we want. And I think we're pretty good at having the right discipline to think through whether a lot of other people are going to want it, too. That's what we get paid to do."

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by sho_hn on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:35PM (#17149446)
Classic Jobs indeed. In the sense that iTunes was originally called SoundJam MP and not done by Apple, but published through Casady & Greene and bought up. But he knew to tell and sell a narrative.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by majormajor on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:54PM (#17150042)
I remember SoundJam pre-acquisition being much more in the Winamp/Audion vein - playlist window + player window. I thought most of the library stuff came after they joined Apple. I would believe that Apple bought them and then suggested how they should build it out further.

Looking at old screenshots on Google seems to agree.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by staunch on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:25AM (#17151106)
Yup. SoundJam MP was basically a Winamp clone and it became iTunes. The above comment is also ignoring the entire iTunes store was arguably the only hard part about creating iTunes.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jacobush on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:19PM (#17149656)
In a way, it doesn't matter. "Real artists ship, even if it means stealing" - you could amend it probably.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by fjsolwmv on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:26PM (#17149922)
"Great artists steal." -Picasso
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by wpietri on Thursday May 24, 2018 @10:28PM (#17150188)
Interestingly, there is no evidence that Picasso said that, and Jobs is the first person on record claiming that he did: https://quoteinvestigator.com/2013/03/06/artists-steal/
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jacobush on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:00AM (#17150982)
Haha, figures - he probably felt he could use some moral support.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by WoodenChair on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:32PM (#17149949)
> Yeah a genius isn't always motivated by the same success metrics are normal people sometimes they just want to make something amazing even if they know it's a one off because it's not just business it's art.

Are you calling Andy Rubin a "genius?" I'm familiar with his career, but I'm not familiar with any evidence he is a genius. Care to elaborate? And this is not a dig at him, I just don't perceive him to be a genius.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 24, 2018 @09:16PM (#17149882)
Art is awesome, and people should definitely make art and take risks, but if you raise investment money on the promise of some sort of return, then what you have there is a business.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by realworldview on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:15PM (#17148973)
Keyboard without comma keys, perhaps?
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by LeoNatan25 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:41PM (#17149139)
Probably a MacBook Pro 2016-2017.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by jdietrich on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:57PM (#17149548)
I dn't knw what yu're talking abut. I have a MacBk Pr and the keybard wrks just fine.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by walrus01 on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:47AM (#17151727)
Not just going up against Samsung, but oppo/OnePlus are tough competition, as well as several other 2nd tier Android manufacturers.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by baybal2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:01AM (#17151785)
Making a hole in the screen was a bad idea.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by rdlecler1 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @11:54PM (#17150489)
In this case it looks like the investors picked up the stone.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by syedkarim on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:43PM (#17148717)
>>I like that there are people who, in the face of giants, pick up the stone.

Just upvoting this quote.

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by realworldview on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:45PM (#17148734)
David got there first, I believe.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by realworldview on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:51PM (#17148789)
Damn you, down-voting Philistines.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by joering2 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:18PM (#17148984)
I honestly dont get it. What kind of stone is Google listing?

Sorry just genuinely confused and search returned nothing on google stones ;(

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by praneshp on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:20PM (#17149001)
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by realworldview on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:25PM (#17149041)
You fell for the “Google knows everything” mantra…
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by icebraining on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:32PM (#17149077)
It does, though :) googling "people who, in the face of giants, pick up the stone" returns a bunch of results on David and Goliath.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by realworldview on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:47PM (#17149193)
Oh, I thought it was a search for a new product, the Google Stone. Now that is a product I would buy.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by IncRnd on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:05PM (#17159208)
Google Stone: No privacy worries. No recordings. Nothing evil. Just a rock made by Google.

https://googlelogorockpainting.wordpress.com/2009/01/13/goog...

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by darkkindness on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:21PM (#17149009)
I think it was a reference to David and Goliath.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by IncRnd on Thursday May 24, 2018 @06:34PM (#17149095)
It is a reference to the stone used to slay Goliath.
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by joering2 on Thursday May 24, 2018 @07:45PM (#17149488)
thanks!

PS. cant even ask a genuine question without being downvoted into oblivion; HN became just another reddit :(

Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by IncRnd on Thursday May 24, 2018 @08:06PM (#17149591)
No worries :)
Re:Andy Rubin Puts Essential Up for Sale, Cancels Next Phone by goatherders on Thursday May 24, 2018 @05:55PM (#17148819)
Great quote.