That is one anecdotal. A much more interesting one is that Tesla is so bad at QC that even the most die-hard Tesla fans are now building checklists to do the quality control that the factory skimped on [1].
It is also rather silly to compare Tesla interior/exterior design or reliability with the big three - it is well known that they are good at neither. Pick a Lexus or a Honda/Acura or an Audi or a Mercedes and see what you get for your money there...
[1] https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/model-x-delivery-che...
I'll save you some time ...
The interior of the lowest end BMW/Merc/Audi cars (3series/C-Class/A4) are so much nicer than the interior of a model S so as to be stupefying.
When it comes to the car hardware (besides the battery-thing) the Model S is a rather meager bang-for-buck deal.
I hope for Tesla that they can iterate on that hardware aspect as well as they do on the software part. The quality and looks as well as the manufacturing process are still the bread and butter of old giants.
What I'd like: Put a tesla engine in a car with quality interior (european/asian brands) and quality exterior (european brands/mazda), maybe their software too least for its "evergreen" update scheme - but keep the touchpad away from me unless it dims out in the dark and offers me haptic response.
Personally, I've always felt sports car companies---Porsche, Ferrari, and Mazda for a low-end comparison---all have interiors that feel far less luxurious than any luxury car available for 1/3rd the price, and many family cars of 1/2 the price.
Porsche didn't have cup holders until their 2001 editions, and as an unfortunate owner of one, I can attest those are the flimsiest cupholders ever to grace the face of the earth, and the entire interior is filled with so much fiddly plastic that's just waiting to break and often does. Any Mercedes, even one from 10 years previous, would have a nicer interior.
Did that prevent me from buying another Porsche? Well, no it didn't. I like the way the cars drive, and eschew luxury features if their weight is going to do anything to the handling or performance of the car.
You probably don't like how Model S handles (it's pretty heavy), but maybe you'll like the eventual 2-seater built on the Model 3 platform.
You can choose a drive train that has been more-or-less unchanged for many decades, with all the money spent on the interior, or you can choose a revolutionary drive train, with a basic interior.
It's simply your choice.
You can, for some models, but often not any more. Modern drivetrains include dual-clutch transmissions, which have only appeared in the last 10 years (despite actually being invented before WWII).
>with all the money spent on the interior,
Not really. A lot has been spent on combustion engine efficiency, for instance. I drive a twelve-year-old Renault Megane, not a wasteful car at all at its time, but new ones consume at least 30 % less gasoline.
Of course I'm biased. Owned six Volvos. Always thought you couldn't buy a better interior. Simple tactile controls. Best seats in the business. And I loved the waterfall console in the three that had it.
I think I'm over cars for the most part, but if anything could tempt me it'd be the new S90. Makes a Model S interior look like cheap junk at half the price.
Can you share more evidence to justify that claim? Not that I have any reason specifically to doubt it, but this seems like it warrants a lifetime analysis of the expected manufacturing and repair costs of Teslas.
If in the past years manufacturers had to cheat on emissions in order to present improvements to performance numbers, then there doesn't seem to be much innovation or the tech has stagnated.
On the other hand, there seems to be lots of room for improvement/innovation on the electric side.
The cheating is rather insignificant when compared to the actual decline in emissions over couple past decades.
Internal combustion engines have become more efficient all the time; there is a lot that has been developed there over the years.
Many of those things, such as the material technology, probably benefit also electric vehicles. Tesla as we know it wouldn't be possible without the pile of innovations done with combustion engine cars.
http://cleantechnica.com/2015/02/18/many-awards-tesla-won-in...
http://www.edmunds.com/tesla/model-s/2013/long-term-road-tes...
This article alone turns most Tesla enthusiasts into apologists immediately. Its a revolutionary drive train, no one has done this before, that's why its having issues. Or we can expect Tesla to fix the issues, or whatever.
Sure, but it doesn't change the fact that Tesla is performing awfully in practical long-term tests. IE: apologists, as opposed to enthusiasts.
What other long-term tests are you referring to?
edit: Apologies, I read the Edmunds blog wrong. You were right, they're on their 4th drive unit.
What does it have to do to count as not preemptive? Burst into flames at 70mph?
> If you're keeping score, our Model S is now on its third drive unit: the one that came with the car, the one that was replaced in November, and this latest one. And that wasn't the only thing that was replaced on this service visit.
This is when Edmunds replaced the drive unit twice. Look at the date, Feb 2014.
Later, in July 2014: http://www.edmunds.com/tesla/model-s/2013/long-term-road-tes...
Yet another drive unit replacement. Their Tesla S went through four drive trains (the first one came with the car, and then three replacements) in two years.
-----------
Consumer Reports also had an issue with their long-term test.
http://www.roadandtrack.com/new-cars/car-technology/news/a27...
Consumer Reports is a survey methodology, as opposed to a single data-point like Edmunds. But the fact that reliability concerns are hitting the major, reputable, reviewers is worrisome to me.
This isn't JUST an Edmunds issue. Everyone is reporting reliability concerns. In part, its somewhat okay because Tesla the company stands behind their warranty and fixed the problems without issue. So as a consumer, you get excellent service.
On the other hand, dying in the middle of a highway and being forced to call a tow-truck is not an experience that should be common on a high-end luxury vehicle. The question is if Tesla has solved these issues in time for the Model 3 / mass market.
I see you've never owned a German luxury vehicle.
Good one. +1.
Yet a staggering 98% of the Mode S owners said they would buy the car again [1]. Can you name a single product that has that kind of loyalty? I've never driven a tesla, but clearly something very different is happening in the automotive industry other than Fanboism.
1. http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/2012/12/owner-satisfactio...
[1] I don't know if there are others. But I count on others not knowing either.
I drive Model S. I don’t want to drive anything else ever, because the quality (of driving, of UI, the way service treats you) is superb. I’m damn motivated to earn enough to afford it, or at least Model 3, because my experience is that no other manufacturer gets it or is capable of making a decent driver UI — and yes, that includes Audis or BMWs.
I'll give Tesla a pass on door handles because I've replaced them on my Cadillac 3 times. Also body panels jiggle, buttons stick, fluids leak, electrical problems, should I keep going? Is there any equivalence here?
It amazes me that we can put an SUV sized robot on Mars but Cadillac can't make a car the bumper doesn't fall off of.
You realize that your Escalade would cost millions of dollars if it were produced to the same standard as Curiosity, right? It really is amazing that we can put an SUV sized robot on Mars, but aside from approximate volume, Mars rovers really have nothing at all to do with consumer vehicles.
(Not that it proves anything, ask Harrison Schmitt about the fenders)
That's abysmal. And from your story, it sounds like you could've done a lot worse than to pick up a subscription no?
Look, I'm not a CR fanboy. I only signed up to check out ratings on induction cooktops. Turns out, there doesn't appear to be any (they basically just rate the spec-sheet, no actual reviews AFAIK).
So this discussion is the first time I've used it it's been good for anything. While they may not be perfect, they buy a vehicle, test it, run surveys. I'm not aware of any recent scandals. You're going to have to try harder to discredit them since you're not actually offering an alternative.
No, you shouldn't. We get it, your current car is a lemon and you consider the Tesla, a car which you don't even own but drove for one day, to be of superior quality.
What exactly are you arguing?
Time will tell tell if they have long term reliability.
Everything from greatly diminished range (which is already well documented) to the drivers screen not working, or working intermittently and other weird stuff my friends attributed to cold weather.
Not sure which parts of MN and ND your friend lives in, but north-central MN like Bemidji or Grand Forks, ND are actually some of the coldest parts of the country.
Nothing about that weather is mildly anything.
ND and MN also sometimes reach -20F, but the problems may (or may not) require so much cold to reproduce.
He's basing that on his perception that Tesla is working out the quality control issues. I'm not in the market for a Chevy or a Tesla - key switch recalls come to mind for one and fit, finish versus price for the other.
Have tried out a full-option Audi A8 or an S-Class or 7 series? During my time in the US I was shocked by the bad interior quality of GM.
Apart from the actual software running on the cars, I think German manufacturers still have very high quality interior in their flagship models.
RE: Software: Current Audis take ~15 secs to boot up the navigation, and during that period you cannot input anything / the screen just hangs.
It's true the interior of the Tesla is spare, but you could also call it clean. The Mercedes S550 has higher quality materials, but the interior is pretty busy/glitzy I think. BMW is also quite high quality materials, and cleaner design than the Mercedes. Tesla materials are not as nice, I have to say.
However:
1. Both the BMW and Mercedes infotainment systems are _profoundly_ clunky compared to the Tesla. Tesla is far, far ahead - not only with the 17" screen, but also UI. Cannot overemphasize this. The Tesla is a pleasure to use & they are clearly working to minimize # of clicks to get a task done - when will BMW get a clue about this??
2. When you press the pedal, the Model S accelerates _right now_. It is like piloting a UFO: car was there; now car is here. This makes the driving experience totally different in traffic. You see an opening in traffic, and pow, you can take it. It's frustrating to drive a gas car after getting used to this. Likewise handling is excellent - the weight of the battery placed so low in the car makes it stick to the road like a go cart. I used to have a BMW M3... so much noise and fuss to accelerate! In the Tesla, it's silent, you just pull away from people effortlessly. I think Tesla is actually under-marketing the driveability. It is not even the 0-60 time that matters: it's the very low latency.
During university there were always these huge talks about the engineering excellence needed for all the fancy embedded systems, but once you get in touch with these systems it leaves a bad taste.
For example with current Audi, if you put it into reverse, the camera pops up and then picture freezes for ~2 seconds.
In every talk with salesmen from the three large German brands I ask about the software issues, but they don't even notice it.
I really feel a lack of focus on UX.
(You could replace "embedded systems" with "human-computer interaction" - car industry was always the big example but once you get more experienced you see they are all hustling, and badly..)
I've owned a bunch of mercedeses over the year and they've generally been pretty good, though expensive to fix when something does go wrong.
My mini, by contrast, has a "sport" button. The documentation says "makes the car more sporty". The current "S" models have a turbocharger not a supercharger. 40% of the manual is on the entertainment system. I think these are all great.
(Of course at the end of the day that mini is a BMW so has all the fit and finish problems I experienced with BMWs before I gave up on them. Fun to drive but never again!)
I did some IT forensics on Mercedes models a couple of years ago, and you could retrace the bad guys' routes by looking at the exception log of their Windows CE navigation software. It had an exception ~5 minutes, and always dumping the stack including the filename of the currently played audio file that told the current road to the driver.
The horrible thing I have learned from car shopping during the past year is that all manufaturers are just repackaging the components delivered by continental. If you buy the premium options at Audi or Volvo, you basically get the same component from a third party. There is no secret sauce in the car apart from the engine and the navigation software, and they screwed up both big time.
The good news is this increases commoditization of the car business.
It's getting a little OT but I'm generally curious about what those problems might be in Mini's case. A close friend wants to buy a second-hand Mini One, I've heard they've got issues, I was curious what those issues might be. I've also heard they're very entertaining to drive, too.
"fit and finish" -- the interior trim on one side pillars didn't match (on the other it butted cleanly). Button finish wore off after a short time. And the brakes, timing belt, high pressure fuel pump all wore out rapidly. You could argue that the brakes could be user failure (riding the brakes) except no other car I had had the same problem, and my clutch didn't show the same problem (which is a correlated "naive driver" failure). Rear inside trim (from the back doors -- I have a clubman) keeps falling off.
I only owned two BMWs, though they both had similar problems. Then I picked my dad up at the airport -- turned out he had the same car with all the identical problems. That was the end of it for me.
I assume you can just turn the navigation off in a BMW so that it doesn't prevent using the rest of the functionality.
Motor Trend's Chevy Camaro SS vs. BMW M4 review is pretty telling. They rated the $46,000 Camaro better than the $81,000 M4 in almost every category, including interior features.
Really? Even though it was still missing features that a Chevrolet had? Like satellite radio, a heated steering wheel, and ventilated seats?
You can easily get an M4 up to $90k ($100k+ if you make it a convertible).
The M4 is basically an M3 - they've been around that price range for quite a while. What else can you obtain with similar performance numbers and fit and finish for "way less money spent"?
I drove an A4 for a while and the gas response was absolutely terrible. You had to press it gently if you wanted it to respond immediately. If you gunned it or even just pressed a little quick to get across oncoming lanes -- expect about a half second delay. One of the worst cars I have driven. Taking it to the dealer the response was -- "that's normal". My boring ass accord responds to the gas pedal better than the A4. Maybe their higher end cars are better, but I wouldn't get another audi.
I'll take a few less horsepower with better responsiveness any day. I'm not trying to beat anyone in a 1/4 mile -- i'd much rather the car be enjoyable and responsive. Half a second can easily mean the difference between getting out of the way of someone coming up on you not paying attention and getting rear ended. Hopefully they got their shit together.
TL;DR: .,-' is better than ___/
There is no way to "solve" turbo lag. The compressor needs torque before it can produce boost. At the high end you can do a twin turbo. Not in an a4. And you could say something similar about having necessary power on the highway to avoid a collision.
Tldr: It's all subjective.
How so? I would perceive no difference between a turbo'd engine and a Naturally Aspirated one while driving on the highway at a constant speed. Engine responsiveness as per the parent poster would be the same within the city vs. on the highway.
There is no way to "solve" turbo lag.
I'd suggest researching variable vein turbos. BMW has done it very successfully in their e92 335s. Even resulting in a flat torque curve at very low RPM. It's impressive engineering.
I'm not familiar with what BMW did for a 335, but I do know that the 335 is quite a bit more expensive than an A4.
Variable vein enables turbos to match engine speeds more quickly. Greatly reducing turbo lag.
And I call bs. You're being argumentative. The debate wasn't highway vs "city speeds" it was highway vs cold stop.
A more advanced turbo solves the problem in a car that is $15k+ more, and I believe you that it can reduce turbo lag. For that price range a twin turbo can as well. But there is still physics that cannot be overcome.
(It has a compressor afaik)
I love my 2014 Mazda 3's Sport Mode. When I hit that button, the engine goes from being more than adequate to chomping at the bit. It just flies. Love that thing. Paddle shifters so I can downshift without even moving my hands.
Test drive one someday, Mazda isn't kidding around with the "zoom zoom".
Whenever I drive it I end up jerking forward trying to manually compensate. I imagine if I just accepted it everything would be much smoother .
The parent's lack of throttle response is most likely due to turbo lag. Modern cars are getting better with variable vein turbos.
If your Mom's Mercedes suffers from poor throttle response I'd guess it's because she purchased one with a small engine relative to the size of the vehicle. A C230, for example, isn't the sportiest of cars. A C63, however, does not suffer from poor throttle response.
Turbo lag is a real issue too, although newer cars deal much better with it. Many newer model Audi's for example, it's hard to even identify the lag (not so true 10 or even 5 years ago).
Source: I own a C63 and my startup procedure includes completely turning off traction control and putting the transmission into S+ every time I get in the car.
I will not be changing my behavior. ;)
In that hypothetical situation I might wish that they had taken some high performance driving courses from me or my colleagues/friends. And spent time behind the wheel of cars at the limit, as I have, so that they had better skills to potentially avoid the accident they caused (with or without ESC).
ESC doesn't save people from bad driving, it masks some of their errors.
There is nothing wrong with disabling traction control. Please don't use the ESC in your car as a crutch. It won't save you.
I didn't take them, I taught them.
We call the driver aids "nannies" in motorsports because they fix some driver errors. They limit control and input. They don't react for the driver. Interesting fact: A driver can out-brake ABS. The vast majority of motorsports competitors do regularly.
I'm not sure why I'm engaging in this, I should probably have more coffee... :)
Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...
I alternate driving a Honda Odyssey and a recent base level Hyundai Elantra as a commuter every day. I'll tell you flat out this is not a problem with too little horsepower or torque. I've also recently driven one of the AMG Mercedes variants for a few days, and seemed to notice the same issue in that vehicle, but much less pronounced.
> The surge you experience is probably the transmission down-shifting.
What I'm experiencing seems to be slightly different than what the original commentor started out with. I'm referring to starting moving forward from stop, such as a stoplight.
> Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...
Naw, I still have my 240z sitting out back. It was fairly tricked out prior to it becoming basically useless most the time when I had multiple children. I get most of my jonesing for fast cars satisfied by the fantasy that I'll one day fix it up again. I think it was way more fun to drive than most the modern fast cars, because it's not so much about how fast you go, but how fast if feels like you are going. Driving a small early 70's sports car serves that up pretty well even without actually going all that fast. :)
I never drive with traction control or in comfort mode - not even in winter. It's a completely different car with them off - if you get another chance to drive one I'd suggest turning it all off. Unfortunately the throttle isn't linear but any more than 20% will spin the tires.
I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.
> I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.
50% the horsepower but 74% the weight isn't that bad a trade-off. Less top speed, but likely better cornering, which is probably fun. :)
I'm not challenging that, in general, Tesla attracts "non-car people" but the suggestion that people that buy AMGs, RSs and 911s are "car people" is nonsense. I'll give you M though.
Regardless of who buys what, because who cares.. let's compare the acceleration performance of a few (0-60 and 1/4 mi):
Tesla Model S P90D - 2.8s / 10.9s Audi RS - 3.3s / 11.5s 2016 Mercedes AMG GT S - 3.1 / 11.2 2017 Porsche 911 Turbo S - 2.8 / 11.1
These cars aren't even in the same retail category and Tesla is outperforming those that cost a lot more.
Very few 4-door cars offer what the Tesla Model S offers. It's a new brand and seen as anti-establishment, there's not many of them yet, they sell direct and they seem to communicate very well with their customers. Their software and in-car technology is great. People are reacting to many things that Tesla is doing right.
It will be interesting to see how they do as they move downward. It hasn't seemed to hurt Mercedes.
the more things change, the more things stay the same.
One aspect that is interesting to me is how Tesla will change the performance category.
The Model S is a nice looking car but it's a rather pedestrian looking car if you compare it to other cars that cost the same or more.
Yet it can beat way more expensive cars and absolutely destroy all the much less expensive tuner cars that fanboys love.
So when soccer moms and boomers everywhere can (and do) smoke these other performance cars, it becomes a rather sad reality for them. Until Tesla makes one they can afford. :)
That's why I'm kinda hoping Apple ups their game and makes car navigation work. No reason why they couldn't use smartphone hardware and just keep it in low power standby.
It's such a huge shift in mindset and operations for the incumbents they won't be able to make it. Recent models still come with a sim car slot so you can get real-time updates on the map.
I've been saying a while Tesla's competitive advantage isn't batteries or electric motors(these are pretty well understood) but in software. They can aggregate statistics across 100k+ cars and determine how people really use cars as opposed to guesses or surveys which are not nearly as accurate. Combine that with monthly/bi-monthly OTAs and you've got a good chance for disruption.
I'm not sure I'd agree. The much of the interior and door handles felt very low quality to me. Theres just too much creaking/give on a light touch.
The central console is also pretty underwhelming. It's UI is gaudy and slow. The maps stutters and lags like a cheap ass Android phone from 2010 and the display isn't particularly bright or high contrast.
I think BMW is doing the best right now. Their UI is a bit gaudy too but at least it's responsive.
Even worse in the case of Tesla as they need to drive a 1920x1200 panel which is quite a strain on the Tegra3, I'm honestly surprised it's as fluid as it is.
It may be the most expensive and grant you the most prestige among a certain cohort, but it's not the "finest". Putting a Cadillac badge and some extra features on a truck doesn't change the fact that it's a shiny wrapper on a pickup truck chassis.
Edmunds long term Tesla Model S needed its drivetrain replaced twice[1].That doesn't seem very well made to me.
[1] http://www.edmunds.com/tesla/model-s/2013/long-term-road-tes...
Disclaimer: I think the Model S is a good car.
It's an unsubstantiated myth, just like the Tesla is the safest and fastest car on the road. The fact is, we don't know much about the maintenance record of these cars, because there aren't that many and they haven't been on the road long.
I wouldn't call the Model S the most well-manufactured ANYTHING. I love the car (and have money down on a 3), but, in particular, it was glaring how cheap the plastic panel on the floor between the front seats (with the rubber strips you can push out the bottom) and the flat hard plastic panel with USB sockets behind it were.
I have 2014 Volt am extremely happy, and do recommend the 2017 Volt which is a much better version retaining its original identity.
But TSLA is the darling of the press, rightfully or other wise. But at a Pound for Pound level, Gen2 Volt is an excellent choice. Unfortunately now those 250K people who reserved a Model 3 could be driving a EV right now and making an impact instead of waiting for 3 more years.
One thing is sure, Cars are not like Phones, you see People with Phones but you see People in the Cars, so once there is a bit of saturation of Model 3 on west coast, people will look around and "discover" Bolt EV or who knows may be Volt.
This is a false dichotomy. As an anecdote, I started a 3 year lease on an EV two weeks before the Model 3 was announced and still put in a reservation.
Who cares if I can get a Volt for 33k right now? It still burns dinosaurs and has a terrible electric range.
Tesla is the press "darling" because it's doing something that the other manufactures aren't: Good looking, All Electric, High Range, Affordable Price. These are things people clearly want.
Every other vehicle sacrifices at least one of those.
http://syonyk.blogspot.com/2016/03/is-tesla-building-throwaw...
I do realize that the Silicon Valley types don't care about this issue, with iPhones behind walled gardens and all that jazz (or at least, SV doesn't seem to care about it anymore... what ever happened to the vision of open source and true ownership?)... but I know plenty of people who are still interested in vehicle with open standards.
Or hell, just a vehicle that can be taken from a junkyard and then repaired in a garage. You're not allowed to take a Tesla from a junkyard and salvage it, not unless you take it to a dealership and have it "reactivated" by Tesla.
https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1305...
At one point when I was driving the engine came on and ran simply for maintenance because it hadn't been used for so long.
The only time I ever used gas was if I needed to drive out of state or across the state for holidays with the family. I could have bought a Leaf to go 80 miles...and then stop for the day.
Flip it into "sport" mode and you'll get a speeding ticket. Such a great car.
Unless you can afford a dedicated "commute only with no need to take on long trips" vehicle, I do not understand the appeal of fully electrics aside from status symbols.
Compared to a plug-in hybrid like the Volt, you have: more interior space, less maintenance, cheaper per-mile cost, convenience of not having to stop at gas stations, quieter, safer, etc. Sure, the Volt is a great car, and there are plenty of people I would recommend it to. But EVs are certainly not just "status symbols"; for some people they are legitimately better cars.
Speaking from experience, the Supercharger network really does make road trips a non-issue as well. I'd honestly rather stop at a Supercharger station and get a free charge while I relax and eat lunch for 20 minutes than find a smelly, expensive gas station and stand outside pumping fuel.
I count TWO Superchargers in all of South Carolina, and SEVEN Superchargers in all of North Carolina. That's... pretty awful selection.
Seriously? I'm not buying a vehicle to pretend to be an elitist and superior over my fellow citizens and neighbors.
The fact of the matter is, being forced to stop at extremely limited locations to act high-and-mighty over the "poor gas users" (who are really the typical American's who can't afford a $30k+ vehicle so get off your damn high horse) is the biggest brand of elitism I've seen this week.
There's nothing wrong with stopping at gas stations. They're common, they are convenient, they're cheap and they're close to where the action is.
If you're happy to sit on a high-horse and pretend that TWO locations in some states is sufficient for a good long-driving experience (or even if Tesla DOUBLES the amount to FOUR locations by 2020)... suit yourself. But this sounds like an utterly awful road-trip experience in my opinion.
If you haven't looked lately, look up the price of a 2014 Volt with up to 40,000 miles on it. You can get one for around $15,000 USD. If after 2 years you can get a Bolt for ~half MSRP, like you can a Volt, I'm not sure how I can resist a deal like that.
You get the battery for daily usage, and the electric generator for long trips. That's a lot more practical than waiting 30 minutes every ~200 miles on the supercharger network. GM has utterly solved the "range anxiety" problem entirely, with only a 40-mile electric battery.
There's a big difference between an electric-assist Prius and an electric-first plus Gasoline Generator Volt. The Prius is always burning gasoline, while the Volt only starts burning gas when it runs low on charge.
There's a newer model Prius (ie: Prius Prime) that has 20-miles of pure electric range, but that's not even enough to get me from home to work and back. In practice, I'd have to keep the Prius in gasoline / hybrid mode even for a daily commute.
In contrast, the Volt's 40-mile pure electric range is a big deal changer. Again, the Volt is a pure electric vehicle with a generator. The Prius is a hybrid engine (and the Prius Prime is a hybrid engine that can shut off the gasoline feed, but is still a hybrid engine nonetheless).
I'd say the standard Prius is closer to the Malibu Hybrid, or other hybrids. But the plug-in pure electric mode of the Volt (and the recent Prius Prime) almost demands a new category.
It's only in 100% electric mode the "vast, vast majority of the time" if you hardly drive at all. A 40-mile range is positively anemic, not even enough for my average commute. That's much closer to the Prius' 20-mile range than it is to the Nissan Leaf's 80-mile range, which in turn is drastically shorter than the Tesla Model S's 280-mile range.
Run out of the 80-mile range on the Leaf, and you're stranded. Call up a tow-truck because you're stuck.
The Tesla Model S 280 miles requires a 30-minute stop when you go cross country. In contrast, the Volt has a 400-mile electric generator on top of a 40-mile pure electric battery.
As stated: the other "electric-mode / gas assist" vehicle is the Prius Prime, which only has 20-mile range. So the Volt is the highest-capacity pure-electric mode vehicle with an on board generator.
From the "Compare with Model 3", these are both electric vehicles that cost somewhere between $30,000 and $40,000 that overall have more than 300-mile range. One uses the common gas station to get there (40-mile all-electric + 400 mile gas generator), the other uses much larger battery packs and is therefore stuck on the supercharger network.
I mean, at the end of the day, they're basically cars. So... yeah. Cars should be compared against each other. There's a ton of options, and the Model 3 is finally at a price range where it can be reasonably compared against these options.
So lets compare. Amirite?
Wrong? No. But it's not the same thing as a large battery that can do both. You could drive a Tesla from the Mexican border to Disneyland and back without needing to charge. That is not bad range. The Volt could do that too, but it would spend about 80% of the trip burning gas. If you care about that, it's worse. If you don't care, then I guess you could say they're equivalent, but I don't quite understand why you're bothering with EVs in that case.
Basically, I don't have anything against people driving Volts. I don't drive an EV either — I have an old Prius. I am just annoyed by the rhetorical games people are playing here to draw false equivalences that favor of their favorite car.
When it supports the Volt, you'll compare cars in hyper-specific categories like "highest-capacity pure-electric mode vehicle with an on board generator." But when I suggest that there's a substantive difference between a pure electric car and a car whose rated range comes 90% from gasoline and that somebody might care about that difference, that's unreasonable because "at the end of the day, they're basically cars."
Nowhere in this thread have I criticized anyone for owning a Volt. I've just said there's a difference between a car with a 16 kWh battery and a car with a 90 kWh battery, and equating them with each other makes about as much sense as equating them with a Mustang (which costs about the same and can also drive about the same distance between fill-ups).
There is a role for plugin hybrids for people who have structured needs. If your commute and daily chores are fixed and do not have much variations and they fit within the AER(all electric range), PHEVs give you the best bang for the buck.
None of us have to defend a Car with excellent track record and is available against a not ready for pre-prod vehicle with evolving specs and likely delivered 3 years from now.
You are missing the point and missing it intentionally.
If we want to treat the Volt as an EV, we should talk about it as only being able to go 40 miles. On the other hand, if we want to talk about the Volt having a 400-mile range, we are talking about burning gas most of the time.
I'm not saying you need to defend your car. I'm glad you enjoy it. My friend with a Mustang also enjoys her car, but she doesn't try to tell people it's the same thing as a Tesla. That's all I'm saying — a gas-powered car that can go short distances on battery power might be the best bang for your buck, but it just isn't the same thing as a long-range EV.
More than 80% of my miles are Electric. EV enthusiasts from times unknown consider PHEV as a subcategory of EV, but different from BEV. But BEVs and PHEVs are compared against each other. This is not the first time and this will not be the last time.
I like comparing the Volt to A10-warthog and Model S to F-22. I have to see Model 3 and test drive before passing judgement, I hope it is not F-35.
It's been a long time since Cadillac has been the Cadillac of cars …
I honestly don't think I'll ever buy an American car again, although I have heard from friends that Fords are pretty decent nowadays. I'm all about the Japanese cars for the foreseeable future.
Besides the whole electric car thing, there seemed to be a general opportunity in the auto industry for an upstart firm. It looks like a classic oligopoly where the incumbents got lazy.
Tesla is doing to everyone what the Japanese did to the Americans in the 70s and 80s. Outcompeting the complacent incumbents.
The Volt was excellent and really just needed some refinement on the interior consoles. Drove well. Had great pickup. Unlimited range via gas generator that gets 37 mpg if you need to take it more than the battery's 40 miles.
Love that car and still miss it.
The Tesla forums have quite a few people complaining about blown drive units, missing paint, stuck doors...this is for a low volume car.
From an outsiders view, I'm not sure your experience with 1 GM and 0 Teslas is relevant.
I feel the same way. Thought briefly about getting a new Corvette. Have had several 911's and other Porsches. Just can't wrap my head around buying a Chevy. When I was a kid it was all the rage (long long time ago). So was Porsche for that matter and Mercedes had just broken into the luxury market here (mid 70's).
(And just like every other car out there, the in-dash software sucks, but that's mitigated by it having Car Play.)
Car and Driver had a bit of a problem with their long-term Z51 (the one i would option out - no one needs 650hp) http://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/2014-chevrolet-corvette-...
I'm not sure I would get a used one, but hopefully they've got the bugs worked out by now.
(Full disclosure: I'd spend my 50k on a gently-used Evora S)
With that said, I personally chose to spend more for a very boisterous German muscle car...
No comment on how much other roads suck, after a day driving up and down the PCH? More seriously, do you think spending the day on the PCH colored your perception of the Tesla?
I did reserve a Model 3.
Of course, I don't know if that really counts as bias, since sitting in traffic is actually a representative task.
I drove a 2013 Nissan Leaf that I took into the shop because the main 12V fuse (seat heaters and dash lights, but not the instrument cluster) blew reliably every time I remotely warmed the car up with front and rear seat heaters enabled while plugged into my 240v charger. 4 times. It was obviously a short somewhere but they'd just replace the fuse and tell me they couldn't reproduce it. I did lemon that vehicle.
I had a 2015 Mazda 3 for a few months but meh. Nice car, but after the cavernous cargo space of the leaf I really grew to resent the sloped roofline and limited cargo of the Mazda 3. Reliable for the short time I had it though.
Now I drive a 2015 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali. The EGR valve disintegrated in the first month and left debris in the #1 cylinder. I made them replace the engine and extend the powertrain warranty. They also threw in an under-the-rear-seat organizer I didn't feel like paying $500 as a dealer installed option previously. "I bought a new truck with a new engine. Not a new truck with a rebuilt engine."
For the scope of that job I walked away impressed with how quickly they resolved it, (two weeks total; I think 4 days after ordering the engine, which had to be shipped by rail from Michigan) and with such little arguing/hassle compared to Chrysler or Nissan.
I think that mostly comes down to the dealership in that case.
Point is, all vehicles can have issues. I've been more unlucky than most. But I take comfort in the fact that the issues I've encountered are abnormal. My wife happily drives her Nissan Quest with no issues. My dad and my sister-in-law both had/have Chevy Cobalts with no issues that they paid very little for compared to a Corolla or Civic.
The Escalade has a reputation for having issues. I don't see why Tesla should get a pass on poor reliability (as someone who's had to replace door handles and power window motors and switches in used cars it's completely insane to me you'd want a motorized door handle) but an individual experience with a particular vehicle should sour you on an entire brand.
That's just not very rational.
Yes I was pissed at Chrysler (and with their ratings I'd probably be more justified than most). Yes I was pissed at Nissan.
If you're upset about your Escalade, I'd suggest it's probably more of a dealership issue than anything else. I'd be surprised if after one bad repair experience Sewell didn't make it right. They did for me. Which is a lot more than I can say for some of my experiences.
Which on the one hand might endear Tesla more (not having dealership franchises). Or not if you'd have to drive 150 miles each way just to drop off your vehicle to get a door handle motor replaced.
"All cars have issues, ho hum what's so great about Tesla"
The Model S has a lower than average reliability rating.
Just because I, individually, might buy a lemon MacBook doesn't make Apple an unreliable brand.
The Cadillac CTS for example has a much better reliability rating than Tesla (from Consumer Reports, which if you actually read the article on downgrading the Model S comes off as a bit fawning).
So should I judge Cadillac on a vehicle known to have way below average reliability? By that standard, sure, a Model S might look pretty good.
It's no Audi or Lexus though.
EDIT:
Also, this is what bothers me about fawning over Tesla. I pay what, a 20% maybe premium for Apple products MSRP? A decently equipped Model S costs 4X the price of a Leaf.
Be willing to spend $120K on a Leaf and I'm sure you'll see bigger motors and double or triple the range. You'll get LTE for free for life. You'll get free DC quick-charging for life (while there are a handful or NRG evGo stations in DFW, there are ZERO superchargers, unless you count the one in Denton 46 miles and right at an hour away from anywhere). You'll get a bigger central display, better ergonomics, much better reliability and more utility (unless you actually plan to load up a 5th adult I suppose).
Tesla isn't doing you some kind of a favor letting you spend over $100K on a vehicle with high depreciation. And there's no way you spent that much on your Escalade.
They're nice cars. Nice for the price? Your Escalade will have lost much less value. We've got a few years yet before battery warranties expire. How big of a hit are you going to take when the market is flooded with off-warranty Model S's selling in the mid 20's to mid 30's range?
> As Pam Fletcher, GM’s executive chief engineer for electric vehicles, recently put it to me with a confident grin: “Who wants to be second?”
Yah but... it's a GM.
I own the finest luxury automobile GM makes, the Cadillac Escalade. It is a chrome lined bucket of bolts. If they can't do this right how can they do a $25k car right? As I type this my GM is in the shop RN with a hard to reproduce transmission issue. Oh and it cost as much as a Model S. o_O
OTOH the Model S is the most well manufactured anything I've ever sat in. It boggles my mind why anyone would buy a second GM. They've had enough time to get it right. Instead they've a consistent track record of mediocrity with an epic failure about every decade.
Tesla tho...
All I can say is, the people baffled by Tesla's success can't have spent much time behind the wheel of a Model S. I didn't realize how much cars suck, even luxury cars, till I spent a day driving an S up and down the PCH.