News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's a Tesla by sremani on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:29PM (#11434095)
I own the highest customer satisfaction Auto GM makes Chevy Volt. The instant torque and a very practical AER, and they do it for 33K (without tax credit) for a car available right now.

I have 2014 Volt am extremely happy, and do recommend the 2017 Volt which is a much better version retaining its original identity.

But TSLA is the darling of the press, rightfully or other wise. But at a Pound for Pound level, Gen2 Volt is an excellent choice. Unfortunately now those 250K people who reserved a Model 3 could be driving a EV right now and making an impact instead of waiting for 3 more years.

One thing is sure, Cars are not like Phones, you see People with Phones but you see People in the Cars, so once there is a bit of saturation of Model 3 on west coast, people will look around and "discover" Bolt EV or who knows may be Volt.

Re:It's a Tesla by TheMakeA on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:20PM (#11434586)
> Unfortunately now those 250K people who reserved a Model 3 could be driving a EV right now and making an impact instead of waiting for 3 more years.

This is a false dichotomy. As an anecdote, I started a 3 year lease on an EV two weeks before the Model 3 was announced and still put in a reservation.

Who cares if I can get a Volt for 33k right now? It still burns dinosaurs and has a terrible electric range.

Tesla is the press "darling" because it's doing something that the other manufactures aren't: Good looking, All Electric, High Range, Affordable Price. These are things people clearly want.

Every other vehicle sacrifices at least one of those.

Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:51PM (#11435549)
Tesla sacrifices classic sustainability, the do-it-yourself attitude, and "openness" of their platform.

http://syonyk.blogspot.com/2016/03/is-tesla-building-throwaw...

I do realize that the Silicon Valley types don't care about this issue, with iPhones behind walled gardens and all that jazz (or at least, SV doesn't seem to care about it anymore... what ever happened to the vision of open source and true ownership?)... but I know plenty of people who are still interested in vehicle with open standards.

Or hell, just a vehicle that can be taken from a junkyard and then repaired in a garage. You're not allowed to take a Tesla from a junkyard and salvage it, not unless you take it to a dealership and have it "reactivated" by Tesla.

https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1305...

Re:It's a Tesla by pbreit on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:04PM (#11434434)
That's baloney. There's very little overlap between Tesla & Volt wannabe-owners.
Re:It's a Tesla by sremani on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:13PM (#11434518)
I have to disagree, I have evaluated the option of throwing my hat in the Model 3 ring, but its not in my DNA to buy a Car without test drive and given that I follow green car news pretty closely, I know too well that the market in 2019 and 2020 is going to be exciting with more choices both in PHEV and BEV world. Audi, BMW, Volvo, Mistu, Honda etc. many traditional automakers are racing to the market.
Re:It's a Tesla by pbreit on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @08:42PM (#11435786)
Like I said...
Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:59PM (#11434388)
The Volt isn't really an EV, it's a hybrid. The Volt battery's estimated range is less than my daily commute, so I'd end up using a mix of battery and gas, just like my Prius does.
Re:It's a Tesla by brightball on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:04PM (#11434436)
Not in the traditional hybrid sense though. It's electric until the battery runs out and then uses a gas generator to create electricity. The generator is really just a range extender which is why they generally call it an Extended Range Electric Vehicle.
Re:It's a Tesla by dublinben on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:43PM (#11434767)
We used to call those plug-in hybrids. An all-electric range of <40 miles is a joke, especially when an 80-mile Nissan Leaf costs 50% less.
Re:It's a Tesla by brightball on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:46PM (#11435524)
It's less than 40 miles because most people drive 35 or less in a day. Then its range at 37mpg is about 280 between fill ups. I probably put gas in every 3-4 months when I had mine.

At one point when I was driving the engine came on and ran simply for maintenance because it hadn't been used for so long.

The only time I ever used gas was if I needed to drive out of state or across the state for holidays with the family. I could have bought a Leaf to go 80 miles...and then stop for the day.

Re:It's a Tesla by dublinben on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @08:57PM (#11435846)
The difference in cost will more than pay for a rental car a couple times a year. You sound like an SUV owner who pays for more vehicle than they need 99% of the time, because they might need to drive on a dirt track some time.
Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @09:12PM (#11435901)
Where are you getting this difference in cost? The MSRP for the Leaf ($29k) is only 13% less than the Volt ($33k).
Re:It's a Tesla by brightball on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:08PM (#11434471)
I leased a Volt for 3 years and 100% agree. That car was EXCELLENT and I still miss it. My father in law bought one after driving mine and hasn't stopped grinning.

Flip it into "sport" mode and you'll get a speeding ticket. Such a great car.

Unless you can afford a dedicated "commute only with no need to take on long trips" vehicle, I do not understand the appeal of fully electrics aside from status symbols.

Re:It's a Tesla by NickM on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:25PM (#11435075)
> Unless you can afford a dedicated "commute only with no need to take on long trips" vehicle, I do not understand the appeal of fully electrics aside from status symbols.

Compared to a plug-in hybrid like the Volt, you have: more interior space, less maintenance, cheaper per-mile cost, convenience of not having to stop at gas stations, quieter, safer, etc. Sure, the Volt is a great car, and there are plenty of people I would recommend it to. But EVs are certainly not just "status symbols"; for some people they are legitimately better cars.

Speaking from experience, the Supercharger network really does make road trips a non-issue as well. I'd honestly rather stop at a Supercharger station and get a free charge while I relax and eat lunch for 20 minutes than find a smelly, expensive gas station and stand outside pumping fuel.

Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:40PM (#11435480)
Lets take a look: https://www.teslamotors.com/findus#/bounds/49.38,-66.94,25.8...

I count TWO Superchargers in all of South Carolina, and SEVEN Superchargers in all of North Carolina. That's... pretty awful selection.

Seriously? I'm not buying a vehicle to pretend to be an elitist and superior over my fellow citizens and neighbors.

The fact of the matter is, being forced to stop at extremely limited locations to act high-and-mighty over the "poor gas users" (who are really the typical American's who can't afford a $30k+ vehicle so get off your damn high horse) is the biggest brand of elitism I've seen this week.

There's nothing wrong with stopping at gas stations. They're common, they are convenient, they're cheap and they're close to where the action is.

If you're happy to sit on a high-horse and pretend that TWO locations in some states is sufficient for a good long-driving experience (or even if Tesla DOUBLES the amount to FOUR locations by 2020)... suit yourself. But this sounds like an utterly awful road-trip experience in my opinion.

Re:It's a Tesla by NDizzle on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:05PM (#11434928)
One interesting thing to watch will be the resale value of the Bolts.

If you haven't looked lately, look up the price of a 2014 Volt with up to 40,000 miles on it. You can get one for around $15,000 USD. If after 2 years you can get a Bolt for ~half MSRP, like you can a Volt, I'm not sure how I can resist a deal like that.

Re:It's a Tesla by ryanmarsh on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:50PM (#11434299)
When the S ships do you suppose you would still pay 33k for a Volt?
Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @04:57PM (#11434375)
Considering that you can fill up the Volt with gasoline for long-term trips, that's a major plus for me.

You get the battery for daily usage, and the electric generator for long trips. That's a lot more practical than waiting 30 minutes every ~200 miles on the supercharger network. GM has utterly solved the "range anxiety" problem entirely, with only a 40-mile electric battery.

Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:03PM (#11434417)
You could just as well say the Ford Mustang solves the range anxiety problem by relying on gas. Making a gas-powered vehicle isn't solving range anxiety, because the range anxiety problem relates to electric vehicles. The Volt is a hybrid, like the Prius. Hybrids never had range anxiety associated with them.
Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:38PM (#11434731)
The Volt is a hybrid that is in 100% electric mode for the vast, vast majority of the time.

There's a big difference between an electric-assist Prius and an electric-first plus Gasoline Generator Volt. The Prius is always burning gasoline, while the Volt only starts burning gas when it runs low on charge.

There's a newer model Prius (ie: Prius Prime) that has 20-miles of pure electric range, but that's not even enough to get me from home to work and back. In practice, I'd have to keep the Prius in gasoline / hybrid mode even for a daily commute.

In contrast, the Volt's 40-mile pure electric range is a big deal changer. Again, the Volt is a pure electric vehicle with a generator. The Prius is a hybrid engine (and the Prius Prime is a hybrid engine that can shut off the gasoline feed, but is still a hybrid engine nonetheless).

I'd say the standard Prius is closer to the Malibu Hybrid, or other hybrids. But the plug-in pure electric mode of the Volt (and the recent Prius Prime) almost demands a new category.

Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:07PM (#11434946)
It's pretty strange to go from casually dismissing Tesla's 280-mile range as being too short in your last post, to calling the Volt's 40-mile range "a big deal changer" here.

It's only in 100% electric mode the "vast, vast majority of the time" if you hardly drive at all. A 40-mile range is positively anemic, not even enough for my average commute. That's much closer to the Prius' 20-mile range than it is to the Nissan Leaf's 80-mile range, which in turn is drastically shorter than the Tesla Model S's 280-mile range.

Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:21PM (#11435042)
The Leaf doesn't have an alternative source of energy.

Run out of the 80-mile range on the Leaf, and you're stranded. Call up a tow-truck because you're stuck.

The Tesla Model S 280 miles requires a 30-minute stop when you go cross country. In contrast, the Volt has a 400-mile electric generator on top of a 40-mile pure electric battery.

Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:26PM (#11435077)
Sure, and my friend's Mustang can also go a pretty long distance on gas, as can every other gas-burning car. That's my point — the Volt should not be grouped in with cars like the Model S or the Bolt, because it is not the same thing — heck, that's why Chevy is making the Bolt when they already have the Volt, because they are different. If you like the Volt, that's fine, but you're burning gasoline just like an ICE car if you ever drive more than 40 miles.
Re:It's a Tesla by dragontamer on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @07:54PM (#11435571)
And is there anything wrong with a small battery that's enough (or nearly enough) for the daily commute, and a gas engine to take you where you can't go?

As stated: the other "electric-mode / gas assist" vehicle is the Prius Prime, which only has 20-mile range. So the Volt is the highest-capacity pure-electric mode vehicle with an on board generator.

From the "Compare with Model 3", these are both electric vehicles that cost somewhere between $30,000 and $40,000 that overall have more than 300-mile range. One uses the common gas station to get there (40-mile all-electric + 400 mile gas generator), the other uses much larger battery packs and is therefore stuck on the supercharger network.

I mean, at the end of the day, they're basically cars. So... yeah. Cars should be compared against each other. There's a ton of options, and the Model 3 is finally at a price range where it can be reasonably compared against these options.

So lets compare. Amirite?

Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @08:21PM (#11435701)
> And is there anything wrong with a small battery that's enough (or nearly enough) for the daily commute, and a gas engine to take you where you can't go?

Wrong? No. But it's not the same thing as a large battery that can do both. You could drive a Tesla from the Mexican border to Disneyland and back without needing to charge. That is not bad range. The Volt could do that too, but it would spend about 80% of the trip burning gas. If you care about that, it's worse. If you don't care, then I guess you could say they're equivalent, but I don't quite understand why you're bothering with EVs in that case.

Basically, I don't have anything against people driving Volts. I don't drive an EV either — I have an old Prius. I am just annoyed by the rhetorical games people are playing here to draw false equivalences that favor of their favorite car.

When it supports the Volt, you'll compare cars in hyper-specific categories like "highest-capacity pure-electric mode vehicle with an on board generator." But when I suggest that there's a substantive difference between a pure electric car and a car whose rated range comes 90% from gasoline and that somebody might care about that difference, that's unreasonable because "at the end of the day, they're basically cars."

Nowhere in this thread have I criticized anyone for owning a Volt. I've just said there's a difference between a car with a 16 kWh battery and a car with a 90 kWh battery, and equating them with each other makes about as much sense as equating them with a Mustang (which costs about the same and can also drive about the same distance between fill-ups).

Re:It's a Tesla by sremani on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:24PM (#11435066)
You are oversimplifying things, PHEVs are not for every one, but to say they are not different from serial hybrids and regular ICE is being dramatically dishonest.

There is a role for plugin hybrids for people who have structured needs. If your commute and daily chores are fixed and do not have much variations and they fit within the AER(all electric range), PHEVs give you the best bang for the buck.

None of us have to defend a Car with excellent track record and is available against a not ready for pre-prod vehicle with evolving specs and likely delivered 3 years from now.

You are missing the point and missing it intentionally.

Re:It's a Tesla by chc on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:32PM (#11435113)
No, I'm not. I just feel it's disingenuous to refer to a gas-burning car as an electric vehicle comparable a Tesla or a Leaf or a Bolt.

If we want to treat the Volt as an EV, we should talk about it as only being able to go 40 miles. On the other hand, if we want to talk about the Volt having a 400-mile range, we are talking about burning gas most of the time.

I'm not saying you need to defend your car. I'm glad you enjoy it. My friend with a Mustang also enjoys her car, but she doesn't try to tell people it's the same thing as a Tesla. That's all I'm saying — a gas-powered car that can go short distances on battery power might be the best bang for your buck, but it just isn't the same thing as a long-range EV.

Re:It's a Tesla by sremani on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:51PM (#11435230)
@chc, having rolled over 20,000 miles on Electric motor, I get to say it is Electric. It is classified PHEV. Splitting semantics is useless, I drive 30+ electric miles daily on it. It burns gas but rarely. If you have interest, go check voltstats.net, there is every kind of use case there.

More than 80% of my miles are Electric. EV enthusiasts from times unknown consider PHEV as a subcategory of EV, but different from BEV. But BEVs and PHEVs are compared against each other. This is not the first time and this will not be the last time.

Re:It's a Tesla by ryanmarsh on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:04PM (#11434427)
Great point. I hadn't considered the utility for road trips. This is a thorn in the side of EV's and will stay that way for a while.
Re:It's a Tesla by sremani on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:05PM (#11434443)
Bought my 2014 Volt for 25K with credits and rebate, and I would certainly buy a Volt in 2019 for comparable net payment, given than Volt improved its AER from 34 to 53.

I like comparing the Volt to A10-warthog and Model S to F-22. I have to see Model 3 and test drive before passing judgement, I hope it is not F-35.