News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @02:41PM (#11433144)
Guesses as I don't know which specific models you're referring to:

The parent's lack of throttle response is most likely due to turbo lag. Modern cars are getting better with variable vein turbos.

If your Mom's Mercedes suffers from poor throttle response I'd guess it's because she purchased one with a small engine relative to the size of the vehicle. A C230, for example, isn't the sportiest of cars. A C63, however, does not suffer from poor throttle response.

Re:It's a Tesla by jd20 on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:02PM (#11433342)
Or the transmission settings. Most luxury cars default in a "comfort" mode which introduces some lag in the down shift until revs build up more, so that the shift is smoother. A C63 is usually left in the sport transmission setting, of which the whole purpose is to jolt you as hard as possible every time you mash the pedal, to remind you what you're paying for :) Also, 4 or 5 speed cars this lag is much more ponounced than say a 7 or 8 speed, especially the newer ones with double clutch.

Turbo lag is a real issue too, although newer cars deal much better with it. Many newer model Audi's for example, it's hard to even identify the lag (not so true 10 or even 5 years ago).

Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @03:12PM (#11433421)
C63's default to comfort mode. They don't introduce any lag in comfort modes, they simply select a higher gear than what would be ideal and up-shift at lower RPMs (1,800RPM in a C63).

Source: I own a C63 and my startup procedure includes completely turning off traction control and putting the transmission into S+ every time I get in the car.

Re:It's a Tesla by azth on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:09PM (#11436351)
You shouldn't disable traction control for safety purposes. Don't put your life and the lives of others on the road at risk.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @11:23PM (#11436400)
No one is at risk. Most people should not disable the nannies. ;)
Re:It's a Tesla by azth on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @08:47AM (#11438379)
Stability control is there for a reason. People over estimate their driving abilities. No need to put unnecessary risk for everyone.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @09:17AM (#11438521)
You're right.

I will not be changing my behavior. ;)

Re:It's a Tesla by azth on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @07:04PM (#11443046)
Wonder if you'd still think the same if someone who is doing the same as you ends up crashing into your car because they think they're too good and disable the stability control systems.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Wednesday April 06, 2016 @07:28PM (#11443222)
HN Is a lot more combative with posters making broad assumptions than I remember.

In that hypothetical situation I might wish that they had taken some high performance driving courses from me or my colleagues/friends. And spent time behind the wheel of cars at the limit, as I have, so that they had better skills to potentially avoid the accident they caused (with or without ESC).

ESC doesn't save people from bad driving, it masks some of their errors.

There is nothing wrong with disabling traction control. Please don't use the ESC in your car as a crutch. It won't save you.

Re:It's a Tesla by azth on Thursday April 07, 2016 @07:49AM (#11446476)
Even if you did take driving courses, the roads are for transportation, and are to be used with as many safety features as possible. Stability control is another thing to add to the list of safety behavior. Disabling it on public roads is even careless behavior. Yes, it does not save from bad driving, but it plays a very big role in mitigating or preventing certain accidents, which even the best human drivers are not able to react in time.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Thursday April 07, 2016 @10:39AM (#11447594)
Sorry, you're misinformed on what ESC and traction control do, it seems, and the rhetoric makes for a difficult conversation.

I didn't take them, I taught them.

We call the driver aids "nannies" in motorsports because they fix some driver errors. They limit control and input. They don't react for the driver. Interesting fact: A driver can out-brake ABS. The vast majority of motorsports competitors do regularly.

I'm not sure why I'm engaging in this, I should probably have more coffee... :)

Re:It's a Tesla by kbenson on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @02:45PM (#11433191)
No, it's a CLK430 convertible from ~2003. It's got plenty of power, it just feels like it purposefully retards the throttle when starting from stop for a short while to keep it from jerking off the line. In my trying to compensate for that, I give it more throttle, which seems to trigger it to stop the retarding action, and the it accelerates faster than expected. It feels like if I just let it do its thing it would be fine, but it feels slow to me when starting, which causes the whole problem. This isn't a developed problem, it was like this from the beginning, so I assume it's on purpose.
Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:18PM (#11434557)
The CLK430 has a 275 HP V8 and the car weighs nearly 4,000lbs. That's not a lot of power for a vehicle of that size and non-AMG models aren't geared for acceleration. The surge you experience is probably the transmission down-shifting. On typical city driving the Mercedes transmissions seem to select gears 2 higher than what would be optimal for acceleration. In the AMG models they don't even use 1st gear unless the transmission is in Sport mode.

Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...

Re:It's a Tesla by kbenson on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:28PM (#11434658)
> The CLK430 has a 275 HP V8 and the car weighs nearly 4,000lbs. That's not a lot of power for a vehicle of that size and non-AMG models aren't geared for acceleration.

I alternate driving a Honda Odyssey and a recent base level Hyundai Elantra as a commuter every day. I'll tell you flat out this is not a problem with too little horsepower or torque. I've also recently driven one of the AMG Mercedes variants for a few days, and seemed to notice the same issue in that vehicle, but much less pronounced.

> The surge you experience is probably the transmission down-shifting.

What I'm experiencing seems to be slightly different than what the original commentor started out with. I'm referring to starting moving forward from stop, such as a stoplight.

> Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...

Naw, I still have my 240z sitting out back. It was fairly tricked out prior to it becoming basically useless most the time when I had multiple children. I get most of my jonesing for fast cars satisfied by the fantasy that I'll one day fix it up again. I think it was way more fun to drive than most the modern fast cars, because it's not so much about how fast you go, but how fast if feels like you are going. Driving a small early 70's sports car serves that up pretty well even without actually going all that fast. :)

Re:It's a Tesla by kerryfalk on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @05:43PM (#11434771)
We're veering off topic a bit but I've come to learn Mercedes pretty well now. I'd put money on your feeling with the Mercedes being two-fold: 1) The gearing: They're long gears and it defaults to selecting a very tall gear. I have 500hp on tap and doing 50mph in 7th gear isn't fun, but that's what it selects as a default in comfort mode. 2) Traction control: It might not be as much of a problem in non-AMGs but the traction control is surprisingly intrusive and very good at hiding that it's engaging because there isn't a mechanical coupling to the drive wheels. It uses the brakes and I assume some throttle limiting. Even in the sport handling modes it's quite intrusive.

I never drive with traction control or in comfort mode - not even in winter. It's a completely different car with them off - if you get another chance to drive one I'd suggest turning it all off. Unfortunately the throttle isn't linear but any more than 20% will spin the tires.

I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.

Re:It's a Tesla by kbenson on Tuesday April 05, 2016 @06:20PM (#11435030)
I'll see if the traction control makes a difference next time I have reason to drive either of the cars. Thanks for the input.

> I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.

50% the horsepower but 74% the weight isn't that bad a trade-off. Less top speed, but likely better cornering, which is probably fun. :)