It's true the interior of the Tesla is spare, but you could also call it clean. The Mercedes S550 has higher quality materials, but the interior is pretty busy/glitzy I think. BMW is also quite high quality materials, and cleaner design than the Mercedes. Tesla materials are not as nice, I have to say.
However:
1. Both the BMW and Mercedes infotainment systems are _profoundly_ clunky compared to the Tesla. Tesla is far, far ahead - not only with the 17" screen, but also UI. Cannot overemphasize this. The Tesla is a pleasure to use & they are clearly working to minimize # of clicks to get a task done - when will BMW get a clue about this??
2. When you press the pedal, the Model S accelerates _right now_. It is like piloting a UFO: car was there; now car is here. This makes the driving experience totally different in traffic. You see an opening in traffic, and pow, you can take it. It's frustrating to drive a gas car after getting used to this. Likewise handling is excellent - the weight of the battery placed so low in the car makes it stick to the road like a go cart. I used to have a BMW M3... so much noise and fuss to accelerate! In the Tesla, it's silent, you just pull away from people effortlessly. I think Tesla is actually under-marketing the driveability. It is not even the 0-60 time that matters: it's the very low latency.
During university there were always these huge talks about the engineering excellence needed for all the fancy embedded systems, but once you get in touch with these systems it leaves a bad taste.
For example with current Audi, if you put it into reverse, the camera pops up and then picture freezes for ~2 seconds.
In every talk with salesmen from the three large German brands I ask about the software issues, but they don't even notice it.
I really feel a lack of focus on UX.
(You could replace "embedded systems" with "human-computer interaction" - car industry was always the big example but once you get more experienced you see they are all hustling, and badly..)
I've owned a bunch of mercedeses over the year and they've generally been pretty good, though expensive to fix when something does go wrong.
My mini, by contrast, has a "sport" button. The documentation says "makes the car more sporty". The current "S" models have a turbocharger not a supercharger. 40% of the manual is on the entertainment system. I think these are all great.
(Of course at the end of the day that mini is a BMW so has all the fit and finish problems I experienced with BMWs before I gave up on them. Fun to drive but never again!)
I did some IT forensics on Mercedes models a couple of years ago, and you could retrace the bad guys' routes by looking at the exception log of their Windows CE navigation software. It had an exception ~5 minutes, and always dumping the stack including the filename of the currently played audio file that told the current road to the driver.
The horrible thing I have learned from car shopping during the past year is that all manufaturers are just repackaging the components delivered by continental. If you buy the premium options at Audi or Volvo, you basically get the same component from a third party. There is no secret sauce in the car apart from the engine and the navigation software, and they screwed up both big time.
The good news is this increases commoditization of the car business.
It's getting a little OT but I'm generally curious about what those problems might be in Mini's case. A close friend wants to buy a second-hand Mini One, I've heard they've got issues, I was curious what those issues might be. I've also heard they're very entertaining to drive, too.
"fit and finish" -- the interior trim on one side pillars didn't match (on the other it butted cleanly). Button finish wore off after a short time. And the brakes, timing belt, high pressure fuel pump all wore out rapidly. You could argue that the brakes could be user failure (riding the brakes) except no other car I had had the same problem, and my clutch didn't show the same problem (which is a correlated "naive driver" failure). Rear inside trim (from the back doors -- I have a clubman) keeps falling off.
I only owned two BMWs, though they both had similar problems. Then I picked my dad up at the airport -- turned out he had the same car with all the identical problems. That was the end of it for me.
I assume you can just turn the navigation off in a BMW so that it doesn't prevent using the rest of the functionality.
Motor Trend's Chevy Camaro SS vs. BMW M4 review is pretty telling. They rated the $46,000 Camaro better than the $81,000 M4 in almost every category, including interior features.
Really? Even though it was still missing features that a Chevrolet had? Like satellite radio, a heated steering wheel, and ventilated seats?
You can easily get an M4 up to $90k ($100k+ if you make it a convertible).
The M4 is basically an M3 - they've been around that price range for quite a while. What else can you obtain with similar performance numbers and fit and finish for "way less money spent"?
I drove an A4 for a while and the gas response was absolutely terrible. You had to press it gently if you wanted it to respond immediately. If you gunned it or even just pressed a little quick to get across oncoming lanes -- expect about a half second delay. One of the worst cars I have driven. Taking it to the dealer the response was -- "that's normal". My boring ass accord responds to the gas pedal better than the A4. Maybe their higher end cars are better, but I wouldn't get another audi.
I'll take a few less horsepower with better responsiveness any day. I'm not trying to beat anyone in a 1/4 mile -- i'd much rather the car be enjoyable and responsive. Half a second can easily mean the difference between getting out of the way of someone coming up on you not paying attention and getting rear ended. Hopefully they got their shit together.
TL;DR: .,-' is better than ___/
There is no way to "solve" turbo lag. The compressor needs torque before it can produce boost. At the high end you can do a twin turbo. Not in an a4. And you could say something similar about having necessary power on the highway to avoid a collision.
Tldr: It's all subjective.
How so? I would perceive no difference between a turbo'd engine and a Naturally Aspirated one while driving on the highway at a constant speed. Engine responsiveness as per the parent poster would be the same within the city vs. on the highway.
There is no way to "solve" turbo lag.
I'd suggest researching variable vein turbos. BMW has done it very successfully in their e92 335s. Even resulting in a flat torque curve at very low RPM. It's impressive engineering.
I'm not familiar with what BMW did for a 335, but I do know that the 335 is quite a bit more expensive than an A4.
Variable vein enables turbos to match engine speeds more quickly. Greatly reducing turbo lag.
And I call bs. You're being argumentative. The debate wasn't highway vs "city speeds" it was highway vs cold stop.
A more advanced turbo solves the problem in a car that is $15k+ more, and I believe you that it can reduce turbo lag. For that price range a twin turbo can as well. But there is still physics that cannot be overcome.
(It has a compressor afaik)
I love my 2014 Mazda 3's Sport Mode. When I hit that button, the engine goes from being more than adequate to chomping at the bit. It just flies. Love that thing. Paddle shifters so I can downshift without even moving my hands.
Test drive one someday, Mazda isn't kidding around with the "zoom zoom".
Whenever I drive it I end up jerking forward trying to manually compensate. I imagine if I just accepted it everything would be much smoother .
The parent's lack of throttle response is most likely due to turbo lag. Modern cars are getting better with variable vein turbos.
If your Mom's Mercedes suffers from poor throttle response I'd guess it's because she purchased one with a small engine relative to the size of the vehicle. A C230, for example, isn't the sportiest of cars. A C63, however, does not suffer from poor throttle response.
Turbo lag is a real issue too, although newer cars deal much better with it. Many newer model Audi's for example, it's hard to even identify the lag (not so true 10 or even 5 years ago).
Source: I own a C63 and my startup procedure includes completely turning off traction control and putting the transmission into S+ every time I get in the car.
I will not be changing my behavior. ;)
In that hypothetical situation I might wish that they had taken some high performance driving courses from me or my colleagues/friends. And spent time behind the wheel of cars at the limit, as I have, so that they had better skills to potentially avoid the accident they caused (with or without ESC).
ESC doesn't save people from bad driving, it masks some of their errors.
There is nothing wrong with disabling traction control. Please don't use the ESC in your car as a crutch. It won't save you.
I didn't take them, I taught them.
We call the driver aids "nannies" in motorsports because they fix some driver errors. They limit control and input. They don't react for the driver. Interesting fact: A driver can out-brake ABS. The vast majority of motorsports competitors do regularly.
I'm not sure why I'm engaging in this, I should probably have more coffee... :)
Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...
I alternate driving a Honda Odyssey and a recent base level Hyundai Elantra as a commuter every day. I'll tell you flat out this is not a problem with too little horsepower or torque. I've also recently driven one of the AMG Mercedes variants for a few days, and seemed to notice the same issue in that vehicle, but much less pronounced.
> The surge you experience is probably the transmission down-shifting.
What I'm experiencing seems to be slightly different than what the original commentor started out with. I'm referring to starting moving forward from stop, such as a stoplight.
> Glib solution: Buy an AMG and smile when you put your right foot down, but cry when you go to the bank...
Naw, I still have my 240z sitting out back. It was fairly tricked out prior to it becoming basically useless most the time when I had multiple children. I get most of my jonesing for fast cars satisfied by the fantasy that I'll one day fix it up again. I think it was way more fun to drive than most the modern fast cars, because it's not so much about how fast you go, but how fast if feels like you are going. Driving a small early 70's sports car serves that up pretty well even without actually going all that fast. :)
I never drive with traction control or in comfort mode - not even in winter. It's a completely different car with them off - if you get another chance to drive one I'd suggest turning it all off. Unfortunately the throttle isn't linear but any more than 20% will spin the tires.
I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.
> I also have an S2000. It has half the horsepower and weights 1,000lbs less but it's a blast.
50% the horsepower but 74% the weight isn't that bad a trade-off. Less top speed, but likely better cornering, which is probably fun. :)
I'm not challenging that, in general, Tesla attracts "non-car people" but the suggestion that people that buy AMGs, RSs and 911s are "car people" is nonsense. I'll give you M though.
Regardless of who buys what, because who cares.. let's compare the acceleration performance of a few (0-60 and 1/4 mi):
Tesla Model S P90D - 2.8s / 10.9s Audi RS - 3.3s / 11.5s 2016 Mercedes AMG GT S - 3.1 / 11.2 2017 Porsche 911 Turbo S - 2.8 / 11.1
These cars aren't even in the same retail category and Tesla is outperforming those that cost a lot more.
Very few 4-door cars offer what the Tesla Model S offers. It's a new brand and seen as anti-establishment, there's not many of them yet, they sell direct and they seem to communicate very well with their customers. Their software and in-car technology is great. People are reacting to many things that Tesla is doing right.
It will be interesting to see how they do as they move downward. It hasn't seemed to hurt Mercedes.
the more things change, the more things stay the same.
One aspect that is interesting to me is how Tesla will change the performance category.
The Model S is a nice looking car but it's a rather pedestrian looking car if you compare it to other cars that cost the same or more.
Yet it can beat way more expensive cars and absolutely destroy all the much less expensive tuner cars that fanboys love.
So when soccer moms and boomers everywhere can (and do) smoke these other performance cars, it becomes a rather sad reality for them. Until Tesla makes one they can afford. :)
That's why I'm kinda hoping Apple ups their game and makes car navigation work. No reason why they couldn't use smartphone hardware and just keep it in low power standby.
It's such a huge shift in mindset and operations for the incumbents they won't be able to make it. Recent models still come with a sim car slot so you can get real-time updates on the map.
I've been saying a while Tesla's competitive advantage isn't batteries or electric motors(these are pretty well understood) but in software. They can aggregate statistics across 100k+ cars and determine how people really use cars as opposed to guesses or surveys which are not nearly as accurate. Combine that with monthly/bi-monthly OTAs and you've got a good chance for disruption.
Have tried out a full-option Audi A8 or an S-Class or 7 series? During my time in the US I was shocked by the bad interior quality of GM.
Apart from the actual software running on the cars, I think German manufacturers still have very high quality interior in their flagship models.
RE: Software: Current Audis take ~15 secs to boot up the navigation, and during that period you cannot input anything / the screen just hangs.