News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starbase, LA by ianm218 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @01:56PM (#49437971)
It’s easy to be pessimistic about Musk timelines/ big tech but I am thrilled that ambitious, real world, hard projects are happening in the US again.
Re:Starbase, LA by adamtaylor_13 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:07PM (#49438119)
You're being down-voted (and so shall I) but I think you're right. Despite all the animosity towards him, Musk is doing things that are economically meaningful for our nation.

We'll need a few more of "him" to dig us out of this situation I reckon, but overall I still hope it's possible.

(Anyone asking antagonistic questions can go ahead and save their fingers, I won't respond to the petty comments.)

Re:Starbase, LA by sockaddr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:34PM (#49438534)
Elon-types won't "dig us out" of our mess.

Removing parasitic elements in government spending and policy will. This starts with politics. We first need a healthy, educated, engaged, and safe population. All else follows. These are all things Elon actively works against. You aren't part of his future.

Re:Starbase, LA by bko on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:45PM (#49439580)
I don't know, government waste and most policy sucks. But there's no reason we can't do stuff or even try.

For instance, take Tesla. It wasn't anything revolutionary. Any auto manufacturer could have invested in battery technology and building a compelling EV, but they didn't. Same with manufacturing in America. Every manufacturer took as given that they have to outsource manufacturing to oversees and components to third parties. But it didn't have to be that way. It takes someone naive and optimistic enough to try something different.

Re:Starbase, LA by boplicity on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:51PM (#49439664)
It's easy to forget that Tesla was made possible almost exclusively through government incentives. This is something that most people seem to have forgotten: Tesla exists because the government created incentive programs that paid in cold hard cash. Musk took advantage of those programs, and Tesla absolutely would not have been nearly as successful (and likely not existed) without it.
Re:Starbase, LA by fastball on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:45PM (#49440367)
As much incentive as the oil & gas industry receives?
Re:Starbase, LA by bko on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:12PM (#49440703)
This is incredibly overstated. There are "incentives" for all sorts of activities. These incentives were available to all manufacturers. We should have "incentives" to produce electric vehicles and manufacturing in America. Insane not to. And these incentives are often "you would normally have to pay us X million in taxes, but we'll let you pay less". When the alternative is something not being built and no tax revenue, it makes sense. And a lot of subsidies were to buyers of EVs
Re:Starbase, LA by throwawayqqq11 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:02PM (#49443725)
> In 2019, the loss was $862 million, but for 2020 there is a huge profit of $721 million.

> However: A closer look at the figures published last week shows that Tesla is still making losses with actual sales of electric cars - around $500,000 in 2020.

> In 2020, carbon certificates brought in $1.6 billion, without this revenue the numbers would still be below red.

https://www.electrichunter.com/ev-news/tesla-makes-money-co2...

With a "profit" margin that jumpy and a history of unrentability, i think it's fair to say that Tesla only exists today because of subsidies. It's not just tax benefits, as you frame it, but in this case EU-CO2 certificates, a direct "revenue" stream.

Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:30AM (#49463051)
Also available to other companies
Re:Starbase, LA by throwawayqqq11 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:30PM (#49468287)
Back then tesla was a unicorn.
Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Friday August 28, 2026 @07:28AM (#49477074)
Billionaires can claim child benefits too.

And Unicorns are about valuation, not money in the bank.

Re:Starbase, LA by Game_Ender on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:20PM (#49440812)
The government should find ways to strategically invest in developing major industries. The market for them is global and China has/will have a bigger internal market than the US, so without intentional development we'll get a continued industrial consolidation that is bad for the US and the world. I have robotic lawn mowers and vacuum cleaners made by Chinese companies partly because an intentional policy from China's government to grow these capabilities locally.
Re:Starbase, LA by dgellow on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:54PM (#49441218)
The current administration is literally cutting all those strategic investments
Re:Starbase, LA by sillyfluke on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:06AM (#49445075)
I think they're cutting strategic investments that they don't have personal investments in, as suggested in their banana republic handbook. They seem to be fine with fossil fuel investments for example.

I wouldn't be surprised if they start investing again once they destroy the competition and create rival companies in their stead.

Right now they seem to be swatting away wind and solar and propping up nuclear companies that are in their pocket.

The titles read like they're straight out of The Onion:

"Trump Media To Merge With Nuclear Fusion Startup"

https://oilprice.com/Alternative-Energy/Nuclear-Power/Trump-...

Re:Starbase, LA by dgellow on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:43AM (#49446278)
wtf, I missed that one. I’m really sorry for anyone living in the US but the country you knew is dead, whatever the new country is, the old rules don’t apply. It’s now closer to a 3rd world country where literally everything all the time is corruption, as a core fundamental value of the administration
Re:Starbase, LA by globalnode on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:13PM (#49443803)
the way the us govt has behaved internationally i wouldnt be surprised if countries/people actively boycott made in america.. the market for us goods and services would definitely have shrunk.
Re:Starbase, LA by YetAnotherNick on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:36PM (#49441000)
What was the incentive and was that specific to Tesla?
Re:Starbase, LA by Rover222 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:58PM (#49441824)
This is such a braindead take. Ford could have taken advantage of those same EV incentives. Any other new startup could have too. Tesla got nothing special.
Re:Starbase, LA by woah on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:43PM (#49443587)
The biggest miracle of Tesla is that they somehow got liberals to argue against government incentives for electric cars
Re:Starbase, LA by throwawayqqq11 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:04PM (#49443734)
... against Alon, not EVs.
Re:Starbase, LA by impulser_ on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:59AM (#49444595)
The government should give incentives to do things that benefit the future of the country. All auto manufactures had the same incentives but instead of building actual good vehicles they instead shipped more production to Mexico and continue to build the absolute most dog shit vehicles in the world.

Not a single US auto manufacturer, outside of Tesla, has a good EV, nor FSD. Waymo is buying thousands of Chinese cars because of how shit US car manufacturer are.

They are the worst of the worst. They shouldn't even be in business they are that bad at building cars which they literally invented.

Re:Starbase, LA by burnerRhodov3 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:36PM (#49457372)
Can you say point to any other industry that hasn't used subsidies/ selling to the gov? Oil and gas, semi conductors, compute... Everyone sells and gets loans from the gov... Tesla like the least.
Re:Starbase, LA by bigyabai on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:36PM (#49440248)
> Any auto manufacturer could have invested in battery technology and building a compelling EV, but they didn't

...because Tesla sold luxury vehicles at relatively low volume. By the time Elon reneged his "$25,000 EV" promise, China was ready to export vehicles that actually hit that price point. The only thing preventing Americans from driving affordable EVs is Elon's federal protectionism. Is that really progress?

Re:Starbase, LA by decimalenough on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:53PM (#49440469)
The Model Y has shifted over a million units every year since 2023 and sits at the top of many "world's best selling car" rankings.

Obviously it's not a cheap car, but it's still mass market, not luxury.

Re:Starbase, LA by bigyabai on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:57PM (#49440524)
It's only mass-market in the US because of subsidies and tariffs. Chinese EVs change the equation entirely.

Outside the US protectionist bubble, Tesla is seen as a luxury brand and their inability to deliver a $25,000 EV doesn't help.

Re:Starbase, LA by decimalenough on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:27PM (#49440908)
As of March 2026, the Model Y is the best selling car in China.

https://teslamagz.com/tesla/model-y/tesla-model-y-becomes-ch...

Also South Korea, Australia, the EU, etc.

Re:Starbase, LA by torginus on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:21PM (#49441487)
I guess it's to Tesla's advantage that unlike most manufacturers, they don't make a million different models which end up dividing sales.
Re:Starbase, LA by manytimesaway on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:58PM (#49441256)
No it's not. It was the most sold during March, but that's it.

Local sources (https://www.autohome.com.cn/hangye/showroom/) tend to show that it's Xiaomi / Geely that's leading the race in 2026.

Additionally, sales numbers doesn't correlate with the brand image of Tesla : it is a luxury brand, no matter how you put it.

Re:Starbase, LA by decimalenough on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:25PM (#49442100)
You're talking brands, I'm talking car models. And your own source lists the Model Y as the #2 best selling model cumulatively for 2026, behind only the Geely EX2 (星愿), which is a third of the price.

Also, you seem to be implying it's somehow a bad thing to have a luxury brand image with mass-market sales, but that's a pretty rare thing to pull off and it's also the key to huge margins. See also: Apple.

Look, Musk is a despicable human being, but the Model 3/Y has been a ginormous hit and it transformed the global EV market. Does he deserves all the credit for pulling this off? Of course not. But you need to stick your head pretty deep in the sand to pretend that a) it was not a success, and b) that Musk had nothing at all to do with it.

Re:Starbase, LA by dnautics on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:54PM (#49443661)
So you're technically correct, but IIUC Tesla is still the most delivered (customers taking delivery) EV brand in China. Draw what conclusions you will from that fun fact
Re:Starbase, LA by manytimesaway on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:10PM (#49455141)
Isn't that wholesale which does not always land to customer sales? Honestly I don't know much about all of this.
Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:32AM (#49463075)
It's not wholesale
Re:Starbase, LA by handle584 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:40AM (#49450052)
> It was the most sold during March, but that's it.

Also June, and a better link for monthly sales by model from your source is https://www.autohome.com.cn/rank/1.

Basically Model Y has been consistently in top 3 by monthly sales of EV in China so far in 2026. If you count by 3-month or 6-month periods, it is only next to Geely EX2 at 1/3 of its price as pointed out by another comment.

Part of the fluctuation is due to one month of every quarter the Tesla Shanghai factory is oriented at export, so domestic number drops dramatically.

HN is full of ppl claiming Chinese EV is superior in every way without realizing that Tesla is incredibly popular in Chinese domestic market.

Re:Starbase, LA by manytimesaway on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:09PM (#49455126)
Yeah that was a quick sumup based on the fact that the parent was not posting in good faith. Thanks for the precision.
Re:Starbase, LA by dgellow on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:53PM (#49441207)
> It takes someone naive and optimistic enough to try something different.

You mean Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning, right?

Re:Starbase, LA by jvwww on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:02PM (#49441872)
Tesla would be nothing without Musk. That doesn't take away from Eberhard and Tarpenning; they started the company after all and are great engineers. But it would be nothing without Musk.
Re:Starbase, LA by sockaddr on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:07AM (#49444126)
And it would be nothing without Eberhard and Tarpenning
Re:Starbase, LA by dgellow on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:35AM (#49446217)
The people who tried something different and did the work on batteries weren’t Musk. That’s the comment I was responding to. Musk has been a good showman though, and he seems to be a genius financial engineer with a cult following
Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:31AM (#49463068)
That's Straubel, sorry
Re:Starbase, LA by Rover222 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:58PM (#49441832)
You're a good sheep.
Re:Starbase, LA by ryandvm on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:38PM (#49438611)
We just need more leeches.
Re:Starbase, LA by throwaway894345 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:30PM (#49440184)
Yep, it's crazy that people can correctly recognize that corruption is responsible for the current situation but fail to recognize that adding more corruption will not deliver us from it.
Re:Starbase, LA by watwut on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:19PM (#49439200)
They will try to dig us out of the hole they created by their previoua digging.
[dead]
Re:Starbase, LA by teachrdan on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:01PM (#49439799)
> He was involved in DOGE, which did nothing but catch fraud and cut worthless spending.

Elon wasn't just involved with DOGE, he was responsible for it. And Elon said he would cut $2 TRILLION in federal spending before ultimately claiming just $110 billion in savings -- which the GAO found he lied about. Considering out budget deficit is about $2 trillion, even his inflated claims are a rounding error.

(To say nothing of the fact that a lot of it was NOT useless spending. For example, Elon ended a program to fund countries in Central America to stop the spread of screw worms. Now screw worms are projected to cost $1.8 billion in damage to Texas alone.)

> while Elon encourages reporting on X

Elon has a track record of banning journalists on Twitter / X, the everything app, when they criticize him. Literally the opposite of encouraging reporting on X.

> We need more "Elons", people like him are actually helping dig us out of this mess.

I would encourage you to start reading independent news sources and forming your own opinions, rather than uncritically believing everything people in power feed to you. Otherwise you end up saying things online that are trivially disprovable.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/08/09/gao-repor...

https://www.nbcnews.com/science/environment/flesh-eating-scr...

https://www.forbes.com/sites/markjoyella/2024/01/09/elon-mus...

Re:Starbase, LA by krapp on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:49PM (#49439628)
>Isn't that an Elon thing? He was involved in DOGE, which did nothing but catch fraud and cut worthless spending.

It did nothing of the sort.

Finding someone still pushing this line in 2026 is like seeing a thylacine in the wild. One can only stare in awe.

Re:Starbase, LA by platevoltage on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:04PM (#49439844)
Conservative media even barely talks about DOGE because of how bad the optics are, and how much of an utter failure it was.
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:46PM (#49441143)
> We first need a healthy, educated, engaged, and safe population. All else follows.

The requirement is economic freedom, from which everything follows.

Re:Starbase, LA by wyre on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:24PM (#49443435)
In what way? There is nothing inherent about economic freedom that leads to a healthy, educated, engaged, and safe population, in the same way there is nothing inherent about a healthy, smart, and safe population that leads to economic freedom.

The US is one of the most economically free places in the world, and always has been, yet obesity is at all time highs, gen Z is the first generation to score less on standardized tests than the generation before them, and civilians killed by law enforcement is at an all time high.

Economic freedom is a very important pillar to a healthy and thriving society, but acting like it is a panacea is wrong. Economic freedom at it's extreme will only lead to a weakening of the middle class and consolidation of wealth among those holding the most wealth.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:49PM (#49443623)
Free markets mean the only way to make money legally is to provide a product or service that other people want to buy. And people want to be healthy, educated, engaged and safe. In other words, it takes advantage of the inherently selfish nature of people to make others better off.

> obesity is at all time highs

Obesity is a choice. I know people won't like me writing that. I know it is very hard to lose weight. It's still a choice, though. I don't see how making people less free would change that.

> gen Z is the first generation to score less on standardized tests than the generation before them

The government is the primary institution that provides education, not the free market.

> civilians killed by law enforcement is at an all time high

I don't see how that is a result of economic freedom.

> Economic freedom at it's extreme will only lead to a weakening of the middle class

The US was much more economically free in the 1800s than now, and the middle class became the dominant class, by far.

> consolidation of wealth among those holding the most wealth.

Wealthy people get that way in a free market by creating products and services that other people want. In other words, they do not "consolidate" wealth, they create it.

Re:Starbase, LA by raptured-banal- on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:22PM (#49443862)
You psychopaths won't be happy until we've destroyed the entire planet in the name profit and the "economy" will you? I wish you felt empathy and had friends that you could care about and maybe you'd realize there is way more to life than making money. Put the ayn rand book down and work on connecting with people and trying to graduate from high school.
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:56PM (#49444055)
I've never read Ayn Rand's books.

More prosperity provides the surplus to afford being environmental. Unfree countries tend to be much more environmentally destructive, because the people are impoverished.

> there is way more to life than making money

I never wrote otherwise. You're making things up.

Re:Starbase, LA by wyre on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:30PM (#49443915)
What's a bummer is that Walter is a smart and talented engineer, yet has a very stubborn and out of touch economic perspective that is at least half a century expired.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Bright

Re:Starbase, LA by stackghost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:42PM (#49443978)
Just like Kyrie Irving is a talented basketball player but also a catastrophically-deluded flat-earther, it's just as possible for gifted software engineers to have flawed reasoning about the economy.
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:57PM (#49444062)
> it's just as possible for gifted software engineers to have flawed reasoning about the economy.

Are you sure your reasoning is flawless?

Free markets correspond with prosperity, in case after case.

Re:Starbase, LA by stackghost on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:05AM (#49444210)
A truly free market is also free of regulation and embraces predatory actions by monopolists. Think being paid in company scrip instead of dollars. Think a single food supply monopoly with patented seeds you can be prosecuted for propagating, and harmful additives in food because it's cheaper. Think better education inaccessible for those nincompoops who weren't born into wealth. Serves them right for choosing to be born poor, amirite?

Some amount of regulation is required if you want a just, healthy, society, with economic mobility.

People say they want 100% free markets but they don't really comprehend what that looks like.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:27AM (#49444368)
> company scrip

Did you know that paychecks are private money? They aren't legal tender. RSU's are company scrip, too. Besides, nobody can make you take a job you don't want.

> patented seeds

Patents are a government invention, and I'm on record opposing them.

> harmful additives

Harming and/or defrauding customers is against the law and is actionable.

> better education inaccessible

Government run schools are pretty much bottom of the barrel.

Re:Starbase, LA by stackghost on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:34AM (#49444861)
>Did you know that paychecks are private money? They aren't legal tender.

I did know this, actually. Thankfully your banks are not free market profiteers. They're subject to stringent regulations to ensure a more orderly and efficient market, and thus they'll dependably convert cheques to dollars. Another point against free market absolutism.

>Harming and/or defrauding customers is against the law and is actionable.

That's why Big Tobacco was dismantled and are no longer advertising and selling harmful, addictive products to teens, right?

Teenagers after all are well-known for their astute abilities to assess risk and make rational, informed decisions that are in their long-term best interests, right?

More regulation is needed here, not less.

>Government run schools are pretty much bottom of the barrel.

In the USA, certainly. That's not an indictment of public education as a whole, though, only of American society's "Fuck you, I got mine" values. If Americans were less selfish they could have the most highly-educated citizens on the planet, with global-elite schooling available to every American schoolchild.

In any case, free market absolutism is delusional for all but the billionaire class (for whom it's optimal) and I'm not interested in continuing this conversation further.

Re:Starbase, LA by slopinthebag on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:49AM (#49444517)
> A truly free market is also free of regulation and embraces predatory actions by monopolists.

This is a non sequitur and also makes no sense. A free market doesn’t “embrace” anything, it’s the sum of the decisions individuals make absent external coercion. That you might be unhappy with the decisions others make doesn’t necessarily make it a problem.

But every single economy is heavily controlled, regulated, and interfered with, and the so-called “free market” examples people use like healthcare in the States are examples of the most tightly controlled and regulated markets (if you can even call them that) on the planet. So when people complain about “free markets” they’re complaining about heavily controlled markets without even knowing it.

Re:Starbase, LA by stackghost on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:44AM (#49444920)
Sounds like we agree that the USA does not have a truly free market, and that some regulation is essential. I'm glad!
Re:Starbase, LA by slopinthebag on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:46AM (#49444927)
We agree on the first point yes, lol.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @05:08PM (#49455940)
> Are you sure your reasoning is flawless?

Oh, heavens no. I'm human, so I almost certainly make logic errors all the time, whether in terms of truth or validity.

However, one thing I am very careful about is that the definitions I use are falsifiable, which makes them minimally empirically testable. ("A hypothesis forbidding some observations means that hypothesis is testable.") In the best case, I can proceed a priori with my reasoning and entirely sidestep needing to approach a posteriori, but real life is very often not that nice.

I generally find capital-L Libertarian free markets less than useful for analysis because the syllogism tends to break down thus:

1. Free markets produce prosperity.

2. Prosperity indicates the presence of a free market.

3. Therefore, free markets are prosperous.

Like, that'd be a perfectly valid form of proving both directions of a biconditional if it were possible in this framework to show the presence of a free market that doesn't produce prosperity or that prosperity happens without a free market. Unfortunately, they're taken as axiomatic, so they don't admit the reasoning required for such a proof.

I want to be wrong though. Perhaps I'm missing something?

> Free markets correspond with prosperity, in case after case.

I'll caution that correspondence does not admit causal inferences.

Re:Starbase, LA by slopinthebag on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:53AM (#49444540)
If he is a libertarian that perspective is more modern than socialism, technocracy, or pretty much any other political ideology. Modern libertarianism is from the mid 20th century.

And if you share the view that societies gradually shift from materialist values (economic stability, physical safety, law and order, and maintaining traditional group norms) towards post-materialist values (individual autonomy, freedom of speech, gender equality, environmental protection, and self-expression) as societies develop, then freedom of exchange is something you would expect from a more advanced perspective, not one which is outdated. What is outdated is authoritarian, statist, and technocratic rule.

Re:Starbase, LA by imtringued on Thursday August 27, 2026 @06:08AM (#49462341)
>What is outdated is authoritarian, statist, and technocratic rule.

And yet the most popular model for freeing us from the horrors of capitalism is exactly that:

Authoritarian, static and technocratic rule. Yes, that's what communism and Marxist socialism are. You could even say that Marxism is basically this idea: The capitalists are rushing to the top, trying to own the entire world, why don't we accelerate this foregone conclusion with a violent revolution to institute a government that owns everything?

What was the original justification for this again? Oh, it's because capital that is scarce in relation to labor has power over labor, but there is no physical capital rule that says that the capital formation process has to stop right there. That's a monetary rule called the zero lower bound that actively prevents capital formation and guess who instated that rule? The very government that is supposed to save us by owning everything, including the workers.

It's like having the arsonist in charge of putting out the fire.

Re:Starbase, LA by wyre on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:25PM (#49443881)
Body weight is controllable, but is not the same thing as obesity, but scientific evidence does not suggest obesity is voluntary, but I'm not trying to talk about obesity. I was just merely using it as a proxy for societal health, because I hope you can agree that obesity is not healthy.

> The government is the primary institution that provides education

I thought there was a large section of free market libertarians that want to get rid of public schooling?

>I don't see how that is a result of economic freedom.

Again, i was using it as a proxy for safety, not economic freedom.

> The US was much more economically free in the 1800s than now

The middle class became the dominant class post-WWII. wtf are you talking about?

If I have one million people pay me $1000, I am creating value, but I not 'creating wealth' I would literally be consolidating the wealth of one million people into my bank account.

Owning desirable assets could be considered 'creating wealth' due to the price of those assets going up, but owning assets is not creating products and services that other people want.

I will go back to my original point, that economic freedom is not a panacea and does not solve for health, education, and safety, but rather creating things that people want to seperate them from their money. Health, education, and safety are all more effective when provided by the government.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:50AM (#49444159)
> The middle class became the dominant class post-WWII.

I've heard that before, and it's simply not true. Pre-revolutionary colonial America had a thriving middle class.

Consider this. A couple of decades ago, a sunken Missisouppi river steamboat was found in the mud. It had foundered before the Civil War, I don't recall the date. And so it was dug out, and researchers went over its cargo.

They were shocked to find out what the cargo was.

It was everything needed for a general store. Pots, pans, jars, knives, forks, shoes, clothing, preserved meats and candies, tools, etc. Nothing in it was for rich people, it was all meant for the middle class. And it was packed to the gills with that cargo.

If you like, look at paintings and photographs of towns in the 1800s. Do you see a couple mansions, and a bunch of shacks? Nope. You see middle class homes, general stores, all signs of a prosperous middle class.

> all more effective when provided by the government

Government providing that has a pretty sorry history.

> due to the price of those assets going up

The price of the asset is a function of its ability to create value.

Do me a favor and point to an American history book that informed your point of view. But fair is fair, I submit:

https://www.amazon.com/ALASTAIR-COOKES-AMERICA-Alastair-Cook...

Read it and tell me that the US consisted of overlords and serfs. Yes, I know about the slave South, which was an overlord/serf economy.

Re:Starbase, LA by bryik on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:09AM (#49444682)
> The US was much more economically free in the 1800s than now

Not much economic freedom for slaves or for Indians forced off their land (e.g. illegal seizure of the Black Hills by the US government [0], the Cherokee in Georgia, etc).

Prior to 1900s-era state laws and the federal Securities acts, you could sell fraudulent investments backed by nothing but the blue skies of Kansas. I suppose that's an economic freedom that was lost, can't say I miss it.

0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seizure_of_the_Black_Hills

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:36AM (#49444877)
Yes, we know a slave economy is not a free market.

> you could sell fraudulent investments

Fraud is against the law in a free market.

Re:Starbase, LA by bryik on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:00AM (#49445026)
Then I don't understand how you can say "The US was much more economically free in the 1800s than now".
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:30PM (#49452814)
The growth in endless regulations, taxes, permits, etc., are a serious impediment. For example, being unable to rebuild after the Palisades fire.
Re:Starbase, LA by Dig1t on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:56PM (#49442396)
I don't know, I'm sure you'd say Europe is a far more healthy, educated, engaged and safe place (by typical metrics), but they are not building anything like this and probably never will be able to approach anything close to it. In fact they have technologically stagnated in basically every way and are completely reliant on China and the US for technology.

SpaceX is 85% of all mass to orbit for the entire planet, then it's China, and Europe is <5%.

The next people to set foot on the moon will likely be Americans, and they will be put there by SpaceX rockets.

Re:Starbase, LA by tootie on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:04PM (#49442461)
This is almost certainly false. The vast majority of government spending goes directly to people that need it or debt service. There is very little outright fraud as DOGE quickly learned. The only meaningful target for cuts is military. And the only solution to debt is higher taxes.
Re:Starbase, LA by nradov on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:59PM (#49443705)
The only solution to debt is growth.
Re:Starbase, LA by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:27AM (#49444363)
Any day now all those tax cuts are going to pay off and trickle down. Any day.
Re:Starbase, LA by tootie on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:59PM (#49458062)
We cannot grow our way out of 6% deficits. Deficits need to be 2% max.
Re:Starbase, LA by 01100011 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:20PM (#49443841)
This is toxic logic. We need many things. There is no single fix for our diverse set of problems.
Re:Starbase, LA by remarkEon on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:00AM (#49444077)
All true but the kind of alignment problem you're talking about is only possible when the core of a society is directed at inspiring, bold, massive projects. There's not much on offer as an alternative to Muskism. It's worth remembering how insane everyone thought he was for claiming you could land the rocket upright and reuse it. And even more so, that you could catch one with chopsticks.
Re:Starbase, LA by dyauspitr on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:09AM (#49445100)
No these are two separate things.

You need big billionaires to pull off huge projects, no one else can take those risks. It’s basically how America was built.

What you’re talking about is improving people’s quality of life which we desperately need but it takes money and that comes from the first capitalist part.

Don’t get too sucked into any of the nonsense on the far right (obviously) but also don’t get too sucked into what the progressives are saying. They don’t have a plan for how to fund their socialism.

Re:Starbase, LA by rurp on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:47PM (#49439606)
Few Americans have done more than musk to destroy state capacity and to enable corruption on a massive scale, all while enriching himself to an unprecedented degree. That's great for him and his cronies that he has gotten so wealthy doing it, but he's been a huge net-negative to most humans.

I get that rockets are cool and a lot of people in the tech bubble think that starlink is the greatest thing ever, but most people don't care about that nearly as much as they care about seeing their children die from preventable diseases he cut the funding for or getting violently ill because he drove thousands of food inspectors and researchers out of a job.

Handling the enormous federal debt that he continues to play a part in worsening is going to very painful in the long run.

Re:Starbase, LA by throwaway894345 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:33PM (#49440217)
Lol why is this downvoted? There is no dispute that he spent hundreds of millions of dollars to elect Trump and seat himself in government while his companies are financially dependent on government programs and contracts. This is an obvious conflict of interest, and also completely on par with all of the other corruption we're seeing from this administration.
Re:Starbase, LA by ryandrake on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:12PM (#49441397)
Exactly. I actually laughed out loud at OP's comment. Elon Musk has never done anything to benefit the broader "us." The idea that "we" need people like Musk to "dig us out of this situation" --a situation that rich men like Musk put us into in the first place-- is absolutely ridiculous.

Billionaires don't "dig" anything except the foundations for things that are going to make them even more money.

Re:Starbase, LA by consensus1 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:17PM (#49441444)
So where is the guy who is respectful to the government and compliant with regulations that is out there building millions of EVs, rockets, and massive satellite constellations? If he existed I could respect your argument. But in reality the only guy who seems to be able to build a modern mass manufacturing company in the US is the trillionaire who runs roughshod over all forms of government oversight that gets in his way. That should tell you something about where the problem lies here.

Elon Musk isn't the problem, he is the symptom. The problem is that it is basically required to be ruthless and corrupt to get anything done in this country at the scale, price, and timeline needed to be commercially viable. The solution is less regulation and bureaucracy, not more.

Re:Starbase, LA by micromacrofoot on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:05PM (#49441894)
he's in china working on trains and renewable energy

rockets and wifi satellites are only solving problems because corporations have sucked public infrastructure dry for generations

Re:Starbase, LA by iknowstuff on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:55PM (#49443668)
ah yes the "wifi" satellites
Re:Starbase, LA by micromacrofoot on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:27AM (#49447802)
yeah yeah you're being reductive because you want to dismiss it, but that's essentially what they are... it's not like the dude is solving world hunger (which he is uniquely resourced to actually do), he wants to be space AT&T and is capitalizing on the degradation of public infrastructure using the funding that should be building it
Re:Starbase, LA by iknowstuff on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:42PM (#49468462)
It's a bit naive if you think lack of money is the cause of "world hunger". There is plenty of money, and governments have far more than he does. On the other hand, connecting previously unconnected (and some unconnectable) regions is a huge boon to their population. Starlink is great.
Re:Starbase, LA by api on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:48PM (#49441719)
I think the root of the problem is “vetocracy.” We’ve created a system where small minorities can hold everything up, sometimes for ideological reasons and sometimes for financial reasons. The classic case of the latter is homeowners opposing all home construction to raise their property values, but it happens in other areas too.

Vetocracy isn’t democracy. It’s a tiny minority having veto power.

So yes the only person who succeeds in such a system is a human battering ram who can just bash their way through it by being a manic asshole with insane force of will.

There should be tons of Elon Musks, including nicer ones, but nice people get vetoed.

Re:Starbase, LA by ineedaj0b on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:13PM (#49442538)
so insanely out of touch. go chat with any AI.

You don’t need AI to get psychosis!

Re:Starbase, LA by miltonlost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:17PM (#49440017)
A few more Nazi saluting eugenicists will help us out! Truly we are at the Weimar levels.
Re:Starbase, LA by nyc_data_geek1 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:52PM (#49438784)
We need to tax all of "him" out of geopolitical relevance to fund a new New Deal, like we did after the first Gilded Age.
Re:Starbase, LA by btmiller on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:53PM (#49439689)
Discounting challenges to your beliefs by burying your head in the sand is certainly a choice.
Re:Starbase, LA by watutalkinbout on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:33PM (#49439414)
Musk is a marketing genius.
Re:Starbase, LA by guywithahat on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:42PM (#49439543)
I don't think he's known for his marketing, he's known for his engineering
Re:Starbase, LA by fatal94 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:58PM (#49439765)
This sums up my and many others timeline of his understanding of engineering diciplines: https://mastodon.social/@rodhilton/109572674700288958
Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:12PM (#49439953)
Posts like this is why HN is made fun of now in circles where real engineering happens. In reality you would not be able to follow what he's talking about because it would be well over your head.
Re:Starbase, LA by jcranmer on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:47PM (#49440385)
In reality, you would not be able to follow what he's talking about because he's making stuff up and hoping your inability to understand him comes across as genius rather than bullshit.
Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:54PM (#49440492)
That's nice. Where's your rocket company?
Re:Starbase, LA by jcranmer on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:59PM (#49440560)
Sorry, I'm too busy trying to check an algorithm to convert floating-point numbers to strings for correctness to deal with people playing the "I'm a rocket scientist, therefore everything is easy to me" card. And yet somehow Elon isn't that (see his most recent SpaceX, where he quite literally uses that to justify his competence to build orbital data centers).
Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:06PM (#49440635)
Classic HN software eng. "I know everything about everything because I can cast a float to a string"
Re:Starbase, LA by jcranmer on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:12PM (#49440708)
Thank you for putting words into my mouth that I didn't say. Especially when they're quite literally the opposite of my message.

Although, given that I pointed out that Elon literally did the exact same thing, why do you trust him when he does it? Or is it simply that you're unaware that he does stuff like that?

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:59PM (#49441265)
> why do you trust him when he does it?

His companies have made many monumental engineering achievements at his direction.

Re:Starbase, LA by jcranmer on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:45PM (#49441698)
His companies making those achievements is not the same as he personally making those achievements. He does have some talent in being a CEO of a company and inspiring employees and investors.

But also don't oversell that: only Tesla and SpaceX have been successes, and he's had to have them bail out is other failed companies: SolarCity, Twitter, and xAI. The Boring Company also doesn't seem to be particularly successful either, and he never got around to building a company to build Hyperloop in the first place.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:21PM (#49442065)
The Boring Company is profitable.

> His companies making those achievements is not the same as he personally making those achievements.

Those achievements wouldn't have happened without him.

> He does have some talent in being a CEO of a company and inspiring employees and investors.

SpaceX employees are top shelf engineers and scientists. Being able to do that makes Musk a great CEO. Can you name any other CEO who has been able to do anything like what Musk's companies do?

Re:Starbase, LA by watutalkinbout on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:52PM (#49444026)
Steve jobs was not a great engineer.

He was ruthless, manipulative and lacking empathy - like Musk.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:39AM (#49444444)
And Apple never would have existed without Jobs.

Apple was 90 days from bankruptcy when the Second Coming of Jobs occurred. He took the same company, with the same engineers, from near bankruptcy to $347 billion.

Again, same engineers. 90 days from bankruptcy to $347 billion. Jobs was the magic ingredient - like Musk.

Re:Starbase, LA by watutalkinbout on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @07:00PM (#49457092)
And he wasn't an engineer.
Re:Starbase, LA by jedberg on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:43AM (#49444913)
> His companies have made many monumental engineering achievements at his direction.

If you know anyone who has worked at one his companies, especially at a high level, you would know that they made those achievements despite his directions. The SpaceX team was ecstatic when he bought Twitter, because it meant he would be around a lot less.

The policy at SpaceX was basically avoid Elon, and if you had to talk to him, just agree to whatever he said and then not do it. He almost always forgot by the next time he talked to you, and if he didn't, you just said it was really hard.

Since he doesn't understand rocket engineering, it was pretty easy to get away with that.

And the people who worked with him at PayPal would tell you that he knows nothing about software engineering and they basically threw away everything he wrote, but they had to be nice because he had a lot of stock after his company was acquired by PayPal but called a merger.

Elon's main skill is marketing himself. He next best skill is marketing his companies' jobs to talented people and getting them to agree to work there.

That is certainly a critical skill for a CEO, but he is not a great engineer.

Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:11AM (#49446466)
Why are you making shit up? Seriously. Everything you wrote is a lie.
Re:Starbase, LA by watutalkinbout on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:56PM (#49457056)
Dat u Elon?
Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:11AM (#49460998)
You know I'm posting with my real name right?
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:58PM (#49441257)
I implemented float-to-string for my compiler's printf back sometime before 1985. It's a medium difficult problem.

Once you understand engineering, transferring that skill to another engineering discipline is not that hard.

For example, the equations for Newtonian mechanics, electronics, beam design, rotating inertia, etc., are interchangeable.

> his competence to build orbital data centers

Since nobody has yet built an orbital data center, nobody is competent at it yet.

Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:40PM (#49441671)
> I implemented float-to-string for my compiler's printf back sometime before 1985. It's a medium difficult problem.

It might have been medium difficult back in 1985, but the state of the art has progressed in the intervening 40 years. The constraint of correctness makes things trickier because it further imposes three requirements: completeness, uniqueness, and determinism.

Unless the implementer has the skill to prove these properties about the algorithm they've implemented, such an implementation is likely not to achieve those requirements.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:16PM (#49442562)
There was no test suite for it available that I could use for correctness checks, so I did what I could.

I also implemented IEEE 754 floating point in asm. For that I did have an exhaustive test suite, and passed it 100%.

Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:33PM (#49443096)
We didn't have this definition of correctness until 1990 (due to Steele and White), and it wasn't until the past decade or so that we got a published algorithm (most recently, I think, Dragonbox, due to Jeon when he was still working on his PhD at UCSD), with mathematical proof[0], that satisfied all of the requirements of being complete, being unique, and being deterministic.

(Though, Steele-White expresses these slightly differently, as preserving information, having the shortest possible output, and rounding correctly. Completeness, uniqueness, and determinism seem to be equivalent and are easier to prove.)

--

0: Available at <https://fmt.dev/papers/Dragonbox.pdf>. It's pretty easy to understand either with a numerical analysis background or after having worked through volume 2 of Knuth's TAoCP.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:33PM (#49443508)
I didn't know that! Thanks for the link to the paper. I've saved it for later reading!
Re:Starbase, LA by BenzeneDream on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:24PM (#49440866)
What an odd comment. You think because he is the CEO of a rocket company that naturally he is beyond making stuff up and talking BS? Have you ever watched an interview of his?

And why are CEOs as smart as engineers now.

This isn't Twitter. You don't have to suck up to him. He won't ever see this.

Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @06:03AM (#49446418)
You are the odd comment. It's been like this my entire life. I was like 20 when Elon was near bankruptcy when Tesla was basically nothing. Then I watched him found SpaceX and again almost run out of money. I then watched him make electric cars a reality from nothing. I then watched him turn the space industry completely upside down. You think elons a bad guy? Whatever. You lost your moral high ground as soon as you started lying. I've watched him give hundreds of interviews with off the cuff engineering specifics. I don't care if he sees this or not. Tired of humoring morons. This isn't reddit. You don't have to suck up to the commies.
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:50PM (#49441180)
I bet that Russian rocket engineer who spit on Musk is regretting it now.
Re:Starbase, LA by elar_verole on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:50PM (#49440440)
Just watching him play POE should show you he's not the genius you think he is
Re:Starbase, LA by hparadiz on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:55PM (#49440505)
Just proving my point here. Trying to win an argument because vidya.
Re:Starbase, LA by doc_ick on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:51PM (#49441759)
At one point didn’t he say there was no sql in Twitter? I can follow that all the way to the dumpster that statement is.
Re:Starbase, LA by nyc_data_geek1 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:08PM (#49453365)
"Underground tunnels are immune to surface weather conditions (subways are a good example), so it wouldn’t matter to Hyperloop if a hurricane was raging on the surface. You wouldn’t even notice."

Musk, Twitter, 2022

This is, on its face, an utterly idiotic and untrue statement. Look at the subways in NYC anytime it rains

Re:Starbase, LA by ralfd on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:46PM (#49441133)
That link is from 2022 presumably about the twitter purchase. People like the guy in the link thought Twitter would go offline hard after firing almost all of the company, instead Elon was right and there was so much fat to cut.
Re:Starbase, LA by sixothree on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:27AM (#49444366)
Yeah, twitter is doing great. /s
Re:Starbase, LA by guywithahat on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:34AM (#49466535)
Since he bought it MAU are up 150 million people, and it seems to be more profitable (although that's not as clear in their most recent filings). Company valuation is down, but I think it's generally agreed he overpaid with the 44 billion takeover, current company market price is slightly above what it was before he publicized his intention to buy it.

It's doing a lot better since he bought it as far as I can tell.

Re:Starbase, LA by watutalkinbout on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:10PM (#49439933)
As I said, he's a marketing genius.

Or maybe "was" is more accurate.

Re:Starbase, LA by krsw on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:52PM (#49439674)
He doesn't build anything. Everything he's done has been acquisitions that he tries to astroturf as founding.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrmitchi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:50PM (#49439651)
*financial engineering
Re:Starbase, LA by potatototoo99 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:38PM (#49440266)
See? Great marketing, he is not an engineer.
Re:Starbase, LA by scubbo on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:52PM (#49441198)
He is (inaccurately) known for his engineering _because of_ his marketing.
Re:Starbase, LA by raptured-banal- on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:39PM (#49443961)
you must not be an engineer.
Re:Starbase, LA by preisschild on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @03:01AM (#49445031)
What engineering? Him doing mediocre PHP code work in the 90s?
Re:Starbase, LA by Gud on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:48PM (#49438725)
He was, until he took a chainsaw to things he didn’t understand.

I was a huge believer in Elon musk. I invested and made a lot of money in Tesla before Model S had even entered serial production. Now? Fuck you Elon, go Peter Beck…

Re:Starbase, LA by UltraSane on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:10PM (#49438160)
Musk has done a huge amount to put us INTO this situation.
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:04PM (#49438964)
Which situation did Elon Musk put us in to? Can you elaborate? When did this situation start? What happened? What did he personally do that put us in the situation?
Re:Starbase, LA by mbgerring on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:35PM (#49439449)
He personally ran the department that eviscerated funding for basic scientific research in the United States
Re:Starbase, LA by thegrim33 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:52PM (#49440463)
You could have just posted the numbers to easily make/prove your point, but you didn't, and everyone knows why you didn't. Because the numbers don't align with what you're saying. But if enough people like you say it's true, I guess that makes it true, data be damned.
Re:Starbase, LA by jryan49 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:31PM (#49440947)
Here ya go https://www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-026-00088-9/index.ht...

Something like 25% cut in new grants. 50% cuts to NSF... You could have just as easily found the data...

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:02PM (#49441305)
I did a word search on that article (it's impossible to read with its idiotic presentation), and "musk" is not mentioned.
Re:Starbase, LA by mbgerring on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:43PM (#49441692)
Are you being serious? Are you actually not aware that Elon Musk ran the federal government department tasked with cancelling federal grants and firing government employees in 2025? How is it possible that you are not aware of this?
Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:15PM (#49441994)
Present some evidence that he cut NSF spending.
Re:Starbase, LA by jryan49 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:27PM (#49442115)
A quick Google search will show you... https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/04/26/nati...

You're just willfully ignorant

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:09PM (#49442500)
Asking for evidence is not "willfully ignorant". People making claims have the onus of backing them up. Anyhow, the link to the canceled projects is:

https://airtable.com/appGKlSVeXniQZkFC/shrFxbl1YTqb3AyOO?jnt...

I looked at maybe a dozen at random, and only one seemed to have anything about scientific research. Of course, that is not a complete survey, but none of them looked important. I'm sure there are a few that are important.

Which one(s) do you think are most important?

Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @09:57PM (#49443247)
I might be biased, but everything under the Division of Mathematical Sciences in the MPS directorate is important. Math is one of those weird fields that tends to touch everything else even if not directly, and it's impossible to know prima facie which areas of research will be useful downstream to the sciences and engineering.
Re:Starbase, LA by remarkEon on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:06AM (#49444119)
Most of the important maths research is funded by the Department of War. NSF is a good chunk, I'd have to look it up, but I wouldn't be concerned about this at all. Math is important for the war planners, always has been always will be.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:41AM (#49444904)
Thanks for sharing. I don't work on weapons as a matter of deep conviction, so I'll continue to be concerned about this.
Re:Starbase, LA by remarkEon on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:53PM (#49452252)
My point is math is a weapon.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:32PM (#49455478)
Forgive me, but I don't exactly follow. This isn't obvious to me.
Re:Starbase, LA by remarkEon on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:12AM (#49461007)
No worries. Sufficient encryption, or encryption breaking, technology trends toward behavior as a weapon. As such, the military is highly, highly interested in mathematics generally, and cryptography specifically. There's a ton of really fun and riveting history there, if you're interested. For a long time, "encryption" to a certain degree was export controlled, but that's not really how it works today. The point is, you cannot have effective cyberweapons without extremely sophisticated ... math.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Thursday August 27, 2026 @05:33AM (#49462040)
Oh, I mean, I'm fully aware of the emphasis on codebreaking and on areas like operations research that provide optimization tools for tacticians, not to mention the ITAR restrictions on crypto export.

(I was there when only 40-bit SSL was unrestricted! I very much remember those days! They sucked!)

I guess the hangup I have is that my forays into areas like differential geometry and algebraic topology are extremely abstract, and I cannot control anyone who isn't me who misuses those tools in decidedly not-sober ways. I can only make sure that I don't have a direct hand in that kind of misuse.

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:30PM (#49443476)
I can go for that, as long as the research proposals are actually about math research.
Re:Starbase, LA by nrr on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:38PM (#49443554)
The stuff in Airtable seems to be. The lion's share of what's there is research that has applications to, like, sensors and robotics and AI, even if the abstracts themselves don't state that, likely because the PIs behind those proposals aren't aware of those applications of their work.

(Just to illustrate how mathematicians can sometimes embody the archetype of Hans Guck-in-die-Luft: I had someone tell me once that there were no applications of ODEs or PDEs to the sciences or engineering.)

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:06PM (#49443750)
> Hans Guck-in-die-Luft

I have to upvote you just for that reference!

My mom tore out Die Geschichte vom Daumenlutscher, thinking it would be disturbing to my young mind.

Re:Starbase, LA by keeda on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:32PM (#49443494)
Are we looking at the same link? I scrolled through a bunch of them and I could not find a single one that was NOT related to scientific research. The UI is horrible so I can't link anything on that page, but here's what I see when I click that link:

https://i.imgur.com/LzwDuKl.png

(Edited to add, these are the abstracts, because I can't fit both in one screen /facepalm: https://i.imgur.com/yQKHViO.png)

Maybe there's a different filter or ordering being applied somewhere?

Re:Starbase, LA by WalterBright on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:07PM (#49443762)
Maybe you and I have different views on what constitutes scientific research.
Re:Starbase, LA by keeda on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:27PM (#49452773)
Here is the list of projects I see (warning, text OCR'd from the screenshot) -- how many of these would you say are NOT scientific research?

Collaborative Research: Bounding global ice volumes over the last glacial cycle using reconstructions of Bering Strait flooding

Collaborative Research: Effects of government-insured mortgages

Basic Plasma Science Facility Renewal

Studies in the Climate Dynamics of Moist Process Variability and Change

NeTS: Medium: Provable Guarantees for Network Protocol Implementations

Collaborative Research: Ideas Lab: RNA-encoded Molecular Memory (REMM)

Research: Process and consequences of social partner choice revealed by multilayer network analysis

Collaborative Research: Towards the Foundation of Approximate Sampling-Based Exploration in Sequential Decision Making

Travel Grant: International School/Symposium for Space Simulations (ISSS) and Interrelationship between Plasma Experiments in the Laboratory and in Space (IPELS)

RAPID: Measuring Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC) Composition During and After the Los Angeles Wildland-Urban Interface Fires

GEM: Fundamental Properties of Dawnside Auroral Polarization Streams and Their Role in Magnetosphere-Ionosphere Instabilities and Dramatic Events

PFI-TT: A Rapid Multiplexed Diagnostic Tool for Serology of Tick-Borne Diseases

Re:Starbase, LA by chinathrow on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:05PM (#49438996)
Funding DJT while he was running for office?
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:07PM (#49439022)
I'm not sure what situation we're in (can someone describe it please?), but did that situation only start the day Trump took office again after being elected by the American people?
Re:Starbase, LA by sailfast on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:32PM (#49439403)
Yes.

Predictability is extremely important for markets and planning and general welfare. He doesn’t have to randomly declare things on a Thursday that haven’t changed for decades and create anxiety among (you name it community or industry) just to stay in the headlines.

Donald Trump has destroyed predictability, as well as any semblance of functioning, predictable government. Trump is an extremely influential and powerful unilateral executive - in all the wrong ways.

Evidence you say? I guess tariff policy and a completely arbitrary war with Iran that roiled markets, just to name a couple from this year.

Re:Starbase, LA by watwut on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:21PM (#49439235)
And Musks money and twitter takeover did a lot of work to convince Americans vote for Trump. Then Musk joined the administration and continued digging the hole
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:27PM (#49439335)
Ok.

The OP wrote:

> You're being down-voted (and so shall I) but I think you're right. Despite all the animosity towards him, Musk is doing things that are economically meaningful for our nation.

In the context of the US building big things, ramping up manufacturing, doing Space exploration, &c. and the person I replied to wrote:

> Musk has done a huge amount to put us INTO this situation

What situation did he put us in to in this context? Did he put us in to the situation where we are building bigger things now? Are you saying that there was a situation that we were put in to and that situation only started when Trump was elected and prior to that we were... what? Building big things and trying to restore manufacturing and now we're also doing that under Trump?

Someone here should be specific about what they're talking about instead of just "Musk bad Trump bad". Yea they're both morons or whatever but what exactly are we supposedly criticizing here? Just that Trump got elected? Ok that's a boring conversation let's switch back to talking about manufacturing and building big projects in America.

Re:Starbase, LA by njovin on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:20PM (#49440046)
I'll bite. Things we had in December 2024 that we no longer have today, all of which contribute to the success or failure of major initiatives:

- 2.9% inflation - Billions of dollars of grants for state-run energy projects - NATCAST - Healthy & stable funding for the sciences - Competent leaders at the federal and military levels to oversee large complex projects - Healthy partnerships with allies

Specific actions that have been taken by Trump (backed by Musk) that caused us to lose the above:

- Starting an unnecessary war with Iran - Cancelling grants for energy projects specifically in blue states - Imposing nonsensical tariffs on trade partners - Starting a full-blown trade war with Canada - Alienating other allies, ex. starting a middle-east conflict without any alliances (excl. Israel) - Specifically closing NATCAST because "illegal" - Gutting of science funding by DOGE & others - Removal of competent leaders & prioritization of loyalty over competence when choosing staff

I have a hard time taking anyone seriously when they bring up anything about Trump having a positive impact on manufacturing in America. For 4+ years he's been lying to the American public about how tariffs work and claiming that US consumers paying more taxes to the US gov't in the form of tariffs is going to 'return' manufacturing to the US. We have almost half a million unfilled manufacturing jobs in the US - explain to me again why this is a capacity problem?

Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:34PM (#49440227)
There's nothing to really bite on here - the OP said Elon Musk put us "in this situation" - I'm still looking for a definition or answer on what exactly this situation is. Is it a situation in which Trump is simply president? OK but Trump himself nor Musk are responsible for the previous decades of manufacturing capability destruction in the US, as an example.

If it's just complaining about Trump/Musk then yea sure let's complain about them in a different topic, but the OP was talking about Musk building big things and he undeniably has (or his companies have, rather).

Re:Starbase, LA by kijashdkujdfhas on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:59PM (#49439768)
It'd be nice if his companies paid the tax they owe.

https://itep.org/elon-musk-spacex-tax-breaks-doge/

Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:29AM (#49463729)
They certainly are
Re:Starbase, LA by watwut on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:47AM (#49444941)
It was reaction to

> We'll need a few more of "him" to dig us out of this situation I reckon, but overall I still hope it's possible.

There is no hope if people like Musk are unnacountable and increasingly powerful. The situation you need to dig out of was caused by people like Musk.

And large dream projects wont make the hole smaller. They will make it deeper.

Re:Starbase, LA by chinathrow on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:08PM (#49439048)
What are you talking about?
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:10PM (#49439062)
Please read the thread for context.
Re:Starbase, LA by yieldcrv on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:42PM (#49439545)
fun fact, voters cause election consensus, not spending

not spending ensures no voters know who you are, but the most spending doesn't result in the most votes

funny prisoner's dilemma for partisans, well, more amusing if you sell ad space

Re:Starbase, LA by nrmitchi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:51PM (#49439660)
> voters cause election consensus, not spending

This is potentially one of the most out of touch comments I've seen here in a while, and that's saying something.

Re:Starbase, LA by yieldcrv on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:03PM (#49441318)
that view doesn’t make it false
Re:Starbase, LA by nrmitchi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:08PM (#49441927)
You are claiming (or pretending) that spend (ie, marketing spend) isn't one of, if not _the_, biggest factors in which of a set of options ends up being the winner?

In this case you don't get to try the options first. You made a decision based on what you've seen and heard.

And you think the advertising budget isn't the key thing?

Re:Starbase, LA by yieldcrv on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:29PM (#49442131)
As I wrote

“not spending ensures no voters know who you are, but the most spending doesn't result in the most votes”

Did your eyes glaze over after the first line, it’s such a short comment

Re:Starbase, LA by SmirkingRevenge on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:21PM (#49439224)
One such example - he's using his massive wealth and influence to support fascist political movements that promise mass deportation and "remigration", and even supporting these policies explicitly himself.

In the US, his political beneficiaries have managed to "achieve" net negative migration to the US for the first time in 50 years, and the first decline in overall population in US history.

If this becomes the new trend (and if Musk gets his political desires fulfilled, it might), the hole is getting much, much deeper while our capacity to climb out is being severely impaired.

And oh yea, he killed hundreds of thousands of kids, mostly under 5.

Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @08:30AM (#49463737)
South Africa?
Re:Starbase, LA by UltraSane on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:50PM (#49441751)
The one with the intentionally broken federal government
Re:Starbase, LA by zoomaboom on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:10PM (#49438152)
Golden Dome might be "economically meaningful" but it will also lead to WWIII so, no thank you.
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:06PM (#49439002)
No it won't. Separately other countries don't get to dictate our internal policies or whether we decide to build any sort of missile defense system. If we're going to be nuked over it, then oh well they'll get nuked too. Never can we live as hostages to wanna-be dictators and tyrants (Xi Jingping, Vladimir Putin, IRGC, &c.) and if they want to blow the whole world up then so be it but acquiescing to their bullying is simply not an option. If you think it's an option, then we should issue our own nuclear threats and take them hostage instead.
Re:Starbase, LA by potatototoo99 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:44PM (#49440360)
Is your cognitive dissonance that strong that you don't see that if all major countries follow that line of thought all have to have their own golden domes and invite WW3?
Re:Starbase, LA by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:58PM (#49440538)
How does everyone having golden dome invite WWIII? We can't shoot missiles at them, so therefore let's go start a war with them? What sense does that make?

And if we do, how are we going to fight them? By shooting missiles at them?

Re:Starbase, LA by zoomaboom on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:23AM (#49445618)
It's an offensive first strike system
Re:Starbase, LA by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @08:25AM (#49447770)
A missile defense system is an offensive first strike system? How do you figure that?
Re:Starbase, LA by zoomaboom on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:01PM (#49451420)
That's literally what T*ump said about it. Also the heritage is the DARPA FALCON project.
Re:Starbase, LA by ericmay on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:59PM (#49442894)
I don’t think that’s an appropriate use of the term ‘cognitive dissonance’, but suffice to say, no, if the US develops the Golden Dome as currently described there is no danger of all major countries also developing the same technology and then starting World War III.
Re:Starbase, LA by throwaway894345 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:29PM (#49440162)
> economically meaningful for our nation

3,000 short term jobs doesn't put a dent in the thousands of jobs he has cut, not to mention the losses to our economy due to the tariffs, immigration policy, and deficit spending that he caused.

> We'll need a few more of "him" to dig us out of this situation I reckon

I'm of the impression that you can't corrupt your way out of corruption.

Re:Starbase, LA by Noaidi on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:04PM (#49441336)
There is a reason Musk is so rich. He got most of his funding from taxpayers:

https://www.moneytalksnews.com/slideshows/billion-and-counti...

It is not him, SpaceX is a government funded project yet he keeps all the money. You should be outraged.

Re:Starbase, LA by vlovich123 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:07PM (#49441922)
There's a lot to criticize, but this argument seems extremely misleading to me. The government wants to put things into space. SpaceX says "this is how much we're willing to take to do so" and bids on the government contract to do so. Notably, this is drastically cheaper launch pricing than the Space Shuttle and whatever other venues NASA had. These weren't R&D grants which are more arguable.
Re:Starbase, LA by Noaidi on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:15AM (#49450629)
We the people owned the space shuttle after we paid to have it built. Do "we the people" own any of those spacex rockets?
Re:Starbase, LA by vlovich123 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:56PM (#49453199)
The government spent drastically more money on the space shuttle (which is widely acknowledged as a mistake of a design) than what the private industry ended up delivering.

It’s rent vs build and I’m not so sure the government benefits so much from owning space shuttles. But arguing that the government purchasing launch volume is the same as them buying the R&D for the shuttles is not a logical coherent and consistent position.

For what it’s worth a common refrain I’ve heard from people who hold your position is that government patents are also the property of the people. So not only does the government spend a lot on R&D, in such a model it’s incapable of monetizing this R&D as a way to recoup those expenses.

Re:Starbase, LA by Rover222 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:56PM (#49441813)
Yes, hackernews has gone almost full reddit at this point and just wants to complain against any sort of industrial ambition.

Glad to see your sentiment though.

Re:Starbase, LA by archagon on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:41PM (#49442238)
Ironically, this is the most Reddit-brained kind of comment imaginable.
Re:Starbase, LA by ineedaj0b on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @08:22PM (#49442612)
Everyone who’s someone has moved to Twitter (or bluesky), even PG does not comment here like he used to.

Reddit is dead, the investors know this, their only income source is selling data to AI companies, and discord ate the “build your own community” lunch.

Talk with someone from a lab and they’ll tell you weighing Reddit data too highly results in more “hallucinations” so even their product is bad..

All the high signal commenters left Reddit, and they’re leaving here slowly too.

Re:Starbase, LA by Rover222 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @10:20AM (#49449716)
nope
Re:Starbase, LA by micromacrofoot on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:02PM (#49441871)
If it wasn't consolidated largely to a singular "him" we could be doing more of these, see: FDR's New Deal

By this method the money largely comes from the government and is captured into private interests, literally hollowing out the government tax base for corporate power

Re:Starbase, LA by archagon on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:38PM (#49442208)
Musk killed hundreds of thousands of impoverished people through the reckless and illegal wood-chippering of USAID and promotes and finances white supremacy and far-right politics around the world. This is who we should be celebrating? What a pathetic cult of personality this creep has built around him.

Personally, I can’t wait for the political pendulum to swing back hard so that he can be torn to shreds by the judicial system. (Where will he try to flee, I wonder? Back to South Africa? Will he try to pull a Carlos Ghosn? Man’s gotta dream…)

Re:Starbase, LA by stackghost on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:54PM (#49443662)
>We'll need a few more of "him" to dig us out of this situation I reckon, but overall I still hope it's possible.

Can you explain why you think the US needs more corrupt, authoritarian Nazi nepo babies and not less?

I'm honestly asking because I'm absolutely flabbergasted that people still think he's a force for good.

Re:Starbase, LA by cesarvarela on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:56PM (#49443676)
I wish he kept a lower profile. His public behavior risks overshadowing the work SpaceX is doing, work that could benefit humanity in ways we can’t yet fully anticipate. I wish we had more Elons pushing us toward a "future that looks like the future," as he said.
Re:Starbase, LA by sixothree on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:31AM (#49444384)
If we just don't talk about the blatant racism, the nazi salute, or that rampage about removing brown people from jobs they didn't deserve, it might stop being such a huge problem. Sure buddy.
Re:Starbase, LA by tasspeed on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:17AM (#49444288)
we need more nazis?
Re:Starbase, LA by tcmart14 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:25PM (#49439295)
But its also hard not to be. I'm not a fan of Musk and it doesn't even have to do with Musk himself as its a common theme I see among a lot of the big tech companies or really any company doing a big project in my neck of the woods. An hour north east of me, there has been big on going data center projects for 10+ years. Sounds good right? I got a lot of family and friends in the trades. But I can almost set my watch to it. When work ramps up, its always good pay and 15 years of guaranteed work until suddenly its not. 8 months go by, suddenly everything is paused and all those contractors are out of work for a year and a half until things start up again. Then its rinse and repeat.
Re:Starbase, LA by thegrim33 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:54PM (#49440497)
"I almost sold a car today, but if I did, sure it would have been some income, but who knows when the next time I would sell another car would be? Why bother? It's rinse and repeat"
Re:Starbase, LA by jrflowers on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:20PM (#49438316)
I love that people see a website about one of musk’s ideas and go “wow this is real and happening” in the year of our lord 2026
Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:06PM (#49439865)
These comments are so strange, because you’re demonstrating how far your head is in the sand, willfully.

Of course Musk talks big. He is almost always late. Lots of things have never happened, or have not yet worked (but they’re still trying)

At the same time he has monumental successes that nobody, ever, has achieved. Worlds safest car (multiple times) worlds highest selling car (model y), car of the year, massive factories building at a speed and quality that made Toyotas CEO say they’re in trouble and have a lot to improve.

The whole supercharger network that smashes every other one.

World’s first reusable rocket, done it 300 times now. Only two others have done it once. By far, by far more launches than every country and company in the world put together. Starship coming along.

To say that he never does anything is a very, very strange set of blinders to view the world through

Re:Starbase, LA by jjulius on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:19PM (#49440040)
>At the same time he has monumental successes that nobody, ever, has achieved.

"Nobody ever" doesn't really feel accurate here.

>Worlds safest car (multiple times)...

According to which body? Tesla's interpretation of NHTSA data? Some other organization? Did other cars prior to Tesla's inception obtain this title "multiple times"?

>... worlds highest selling car (model y)...

In 2023, the Y peaked at ~1.22 million. In 1923, the Model T sold ~2.09 million.

>... car of the year...

Numerous bodies label things "car of the year", and many cars were named that before and after Teslas were produced.

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:05AM (#49444113)
> ”Nobody ever" doesn't really feel accurate here

Please provide a list of all the companies that have reused a first stage booster many times.

And all the companies that have launched more to orbit in a year than everyone else combined.

> According to which body? Tesla's interpretation of NHTSA data? Some other organization? Did other cars prior to Tesla's inception obtain this title "multiple times"?

August 2013 (Model S): Tesla announced that the Model S achieved a 5.4-star rating from the NHTSA, noting it was the highest score ever recorded at the time.

February 2017 (Model X): The NHTSA gave the Model X a 5-star rating in every category, making it the first SUV with the lowest probability of injury.

August 2018 (Model 3): Tesla published data showing the Model 3 had the lowest probability of injury of any car tested by the NHTSA.

September 2022 (Model Y): The Model Y earned record-breaking safety scores during European testing, achieving the highest overall safety score recorded by Euro NCAP at that time.

December 2024 / 2025 (Model Y & Model 3): The IIHS awarded the Model Y a Top Safety Pick+ designation, while Euro NCAP named both the Model 3 and Model Y as "Best-in-Class" safety winners.

January 2026 (Global NCAP Wins): Euro NCAP and ANCAP crowned the Model 3 as the safest Large Family Car and the Model Y as the safest Small SUV under updated protocols.

> * In 2023, the Y peaked at ~1.22 million. In 1923, the Model T sold ~2.09 million.*

Safe to say the model T had a lot less competition in 1923 than the Y does now. Clearly it’s a bigger achievement now.

> Numerous bodies label things "car of the year", and many cars were named that before and after Teslas were produced.

Tesla were the first electric car to win coty and be highly praised as having a chance to make EVs mainstream. I don’t know how old you are and if you remember, the Model S was nothing like we had seen before (I’m an automotive journalist, FWIW)

Never owned a Tesla.

No horse in the race.

Re:Starbase, LA by jrflowers on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @04:30PM (#49440177)
Re:Starbase, LA by webdood90 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @05:33PM (#49440973)
> you’re demonstrating how far your head is in the sand

Interesting. Perhaps ironic?

If only society cared about genuinely good people like they seem to care about Musk. It's puzzling.

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:46PM (#49441706)
I want to be clear: I don’t care about Musk as a person. I care about facts. I care about achievements.

Just the same as saying Israel is committing genocide is not antisemitism, saying Musk has achieved incredible things is not caring about or supporting him.

Both cases are simply stating facts without any judgement or show of support/not support.

Re:Starbase, LA by jjulius on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @07:57PM (#49442402)
>I care about facts.

>Both cases are simply stating facts...

Sure, unless (as I pointed out in my other response) we're playing fast and loose with what actually constitutes "facts".

Re:Starbase, LA by jrflowers on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @10:59PM (#49443699)
It is factually true that Elon Musk has a reputation for saying things will happen that do not end up happening. Picking out some things that you like about him and posting them while excluding the dozens of publicly documented examples of him either lying or (very charitably) being so “hopeful” that he’s disconnected from reality is indistinguishable from volunteering support.

If your Tesla (made by a company he took private at $420/share) makes you passive income as a robotaxi while you sleep, which you spend paying off the loan you took out in 2020 for the ticket to Mars that you bought to avoid covid which ended up being pointless because nobody got it past April then I’d understand being confused about his reputation. If not, you kind of just posted a roundabout way of saying that you don’t care or notice when he makes stuff up.

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @11:57PM (#49444063)
As both you and I said, Elon talks big and has failed to deliver on a ton of things

That does not mean he has achieved nothing incredible.

The two are unrelated, in fact.

Re:Starbase, LA by jrflowers on Thursday August 27, 2026 @05:36AM (#49462068)
Why are you listing other people that you imagine you wouldn’t mind if they were habitual liars
Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:45AM (#49463220)
Because people have failures and successes and when the successes are bigger than the failure we consider that a success
Re:Starbase, LA by jrflowers on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:29PM (#49470015)
This is the thread where we’re all agreeing that Elon Musk has a reputation for making stuff up, I think you might mean to be posting in a thread where people are talking about how cool he is or something. You posted that the two things are unrelated so you might be mixing up a conversation that is happening with one that is not happening here

If I wanted to have a completely different conversation, unrelated to his reputation for making stuff up, with a fan about his creations I’d say something like “He created reusable rockets? Wow that Elon guy must have so many patents relating to aerospace and manufacturing” but that would be a totally different thread

Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Friday August 28, 2026 @07:32AM (#49477098)
Nah. I'm pretty clear about not agreeing.

People have goals they work towards...

Sometimes they have success/failure.

That's different from "making stuff up"

Re:Starbase, LA by sixothree on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:35AM (#49444421)
> I don’t care about Musk as a person.

How convenient. You have to ignore him on a personal level to be a supporter like you are. Because you know he's a repulsive individual on every level. And if you didn't qualify your support for him you'd debase yourself.

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @02:02AM (#49444626)
I’m not a supporter.

I’m simply stating facts That are easily verifiable.

Re:Starbase, LA by n4r9 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @04:37AM (#49445715)
"Incredible" is a subjective word. It describes how one feels about his achievements. It also has a strong connotation of positivity (you don't usually hear people say that the Holocaust was an incredible achievement despite the unique amount of planning and effort that went into it). This is not in the realm of facts.

It could be factual to say "I find his achievements incredible" or "many people find his achievements incredible". But not "he has achieved incredible things".

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @11:48AM (#49451194)
> ”Incredible" is a subjective word

And subjectively, launching more to orbit than the rest of the world is an incredible achievement. So is reusing a first stage rocket 300 times. So is building the world’s best selling car.

These are incredibly difficult things to do, hence, “incredible”

Re:Starbase, LA by n4r9 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @12:58PM (#49452329)
I'm not sure what you're saying here. That he's launched so many rockets to orbit is a fact. That this is an "incredible achievement" is a subjective interpretation.
Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:29PM (#49452808)
How would you describe the achievement?

Personally I describe nuclear weapons as incredible (though also horrific).

Re:Starbase, LA by n4r9 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @06:41AM (#49462609)
Remarkable, perhaps? I'd hesitate to use "incredible" because his background privilege and wealth makes it all... well, more credible; and using such an unalloyed, positive word feels wrong given the costs to his relationships and his promotions of far-right groups and conspiracy theories. His path is unique, but it's believable and nuanced.

That's beside the point though, which is that you can't say something being "incredible" is a fact. It's a subjective judgement.

Re:Starbase, LA by testing22321 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:46PM (#49468523)
So I should have said “remarkable”?

Sure, I can do that.

Re:Starbase, LA by n4r9 on Friday September 04, 2026 @08:43AM (#49563780)
No, you're still missing the point. "Remarkable" and "incredible" are not objective ways to describe something.
Re:Starbase, LA by inemesitaffia on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:44AM (#49463205)
Isreal isn't committing genocide though. It's clear to anyone who isn't innumerate that it's implausible
Re:Starbase, LA by xboxnolifes on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @02:28PM (#49438453)
Of all of Musk's ventures, SpaceX seems to actually do things and not just say they do things.
Re:Starbase, LA by mcculley on Wednesday August 26, 2026 @01:29PM (#49452805)
More of Musk's ventures need a Gwynne Shotwell. Imagine what Tesla could do with a full-time adult at the helm.
Re:Starbase, LA by sneak on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @06:27PM (#49441548)
I sit in my car and I push the lever and it drives from my house to my partner’s house ten miles away without me touching the control inputs once.

It seems things are getting done.

Re:Starbase, LA by mrcwinn on Tuesday August 25, 2026 @03:06PM (#49439011)
Heck. Yeah. I'm with you. This is GOOD.

Social media is unhealthy. You know what else is unhealthy? Hacker News' constant bashing of every. single. thing. ever.