News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:44AM (#47386101)
What a strange article, from somebody who should understand the underlying technology (click on the “books” tab - the author is a technologist).

This is not about AI, the author is mostly just pointing out that Spotify was not designed for classical music.

This is a product issue. Spotify DJ is essentially “shuffle with some voice interludes”. There’s probably some non-AI code in there to explicitly prevent it from playing an album end to end.

Besides, AI is not one thing. It’s weird to generalise “This beta spotify feature doesn’t serve me, hence AI is useless”. For example, when the author says “if it can’t do this, how could it compose music?”, that’s a category error.

Honestly the whole post and tone are just baffling. It’s mixing up all sorts of opinions and trying to put them under one umbrella, and about 50% of the text is just name dropping specific classical pieces.

I happen to agree that the Spotify DJ feature is terrible, but I think this is a very ineffective way of presenting the argument.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by alberto467 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:15AM (#47386674)
Who would even DJ on classical music?

If you have the slightest knowledge of classical music you would know it should not be mixed like in a dj set, and you would not optimize your dj algorithm for it.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by PaulHoule on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:27AM (#47386741)
I think you could pick out a movement from this and then a movement from that. I can see somebody wanting to have classical music playing all day without having to pick out specific tracks, like listening to the radio.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by alberto467 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:55AM (#47386961)
I think the auto DJ feature is already well capable of that: having tracks playing the all day.

But if you want to preserve the original composition of classical music, you have to play the track start to finish, preferably with a small pause between tracks as well.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by PaulHoule on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:38AM (#47387270)
I have to admit that my rock and pop music listening is still album-oriented whether it is The Kinks or The Super Furry Animals or Charlie XCX.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by pimeys on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:27AM (#47386749)
And then we have artists such as Gas who famously mixed classical with dub techno.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by alberto467 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:48AM (#47386909)
Interesting, i never heard of anything similar before, but i'm quite sure the classical music fans would also hate on him for ruining the original compositions.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by slfnflctd on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:40AM (#47387843)
Remixing art has been done since the invention of art. It doesn't ruin anything if the original work is preserved.

No one is required to like it. But the word 'hate' is a bit extreme, even in your example. Also, the group comprising "the classical music fans" is certain to include many who disagree with you.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by pimeys on Friday March 20, 2026 @04:17PM (#47460057)
I consider myself a "fan of classical music". We go to Philharmonic a few times a year and I own a remarkable collection of classical music. And I do go to parties and love techno...
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by pimeys on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:51AM (#47386930)
He is a very influential artist in the techno subculture. I don't think anybody hating him for making those masterpieces...
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by wussboy on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:05AM (#47387513)
The blend of classical and techno must come from the techno side. I remember many years ago listening to CBC Radio as they breathlessly talked about some avant garde classical piece that purported to blend classical and techno. It was a mid tier modern classical composition with occasional cheap synth sound effects. And this was ten years after Portishead released their entire first album, recorded with an orchestra, or all the work that Massive attack was doing.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by recursive on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:17AM (#47388234)
William Orbit did an album of electronic arrangements of classical music 25 years ago. Not that it prevents anyone else from doing it. But it's not a completely novel idea.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by mixmastamyk on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:22PM (#47388898)
Yes, at least 50. Folks applied electronic instruments to classical music shortly after they moved out of the experimental phase.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switched-On_Bach

And there was this fun disco version as well: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Fifth_of_Beethoven

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by yareally on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:44PM (#47389117)
I love electronic renditions of classical music. Trance does this often (Tiesto, Armin van Buuren, William Orbit, Ferry Corsten and others) and it's some of the best work they put out. To me, it's like a natural progression from classical minimalism, such as Phillip Glass or Max Richter.

I've played the violin since I was a kid (only for fun now). I can find something I love about almost any musical genre and I'm sure I'm not the only one.

BT is a trance dj that's classically trained: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BT_(musician) and Armin van Buuren has classically trained parents

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6yFanGv_ReU

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=S1YwlPH_o50

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=j2fNloJAge0 (same chord progression as la folia https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7v8zxoEoA_Q)

La folia itself has been "remixed" many times by both classical and modern composers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folia

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by pragmatic on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:47AM (#47387350)
Why would you even have a classical music station? What is public radio even doing?
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by dylan604 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:04AM (#47388090)
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by santoshalper on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:25AM (#47388308)
I believe the person you are responding to was being facetious.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by drewbeck on Sunday March 15, 2026 @01:25PM (#47389574)
What the AI doing now is in fact what classical radio DJs do; the author wants a general purpose smart music playing robot, not a “DJ” per se.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by paradox460 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:52AM (#47388581)
Deodado?
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by jcgrillo on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:01PM (#47388687)
> you would know it should not be mixed like in a dj set, and you would not optimize your dj algorithm for it.

Yet the computer program happily tried to do it anyway. It would be much better to fail with a clear error message than to try to proceed and emit garbage.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by thayne on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:16PM (#47388840)
I think it is totally reasonable to want something that plays all movements from one work, then finds similar works to play after that.

Sure, that might not be what a DJ algorithm is optimized for, but a more generalized AI like an llm should be able to figure that out.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by spunky2342 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @05:06PM (#47391921)
You are very right, using a generalized LLM in combination with good music search and metadata tools works very well for this sort of thing. I know because I built a platform that does this. The big limiter isn't the tech, it's what the rights-holders will allow. They maintain tight control over their catalogs because renting that intellectual property is their entire business model. This makes them very cautious about letting any actually useful AI near their music and metadata.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by prmoustache on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:30PM (#47392688)
It is not uncommon to have parts of a classical music movement in a DJ set, even if it lasts only a few seconds.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by code_duck on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:42PM (#47393304)
Yeah, if he wants to listen to your complete albums, it’s unclear to me why he would be using a DJ feature or expected the DJ to do that. Just play the albums manually or set up playlist. It’s like having a six CD changer and putting it on shuffle and then complaining that it shuffles.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by Terretta on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:03PM (#47394302)
Until 2009, WGBH FM… then they shuffled it. Which went about as well as this tool.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by timthorn on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:59AM (#47386197)
> click on the “books” tab - the author is a technologist

That's rather underselling him. Charles Petzold wrote the canonical reference works for programming Win32 and MFC.

It's like calling Donald Knuth a lecturer.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by OJFord on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:56AM (#47386554)
His 'Annotated Turing' (a reproduction of On computable numbers, with an application to the Entscheidungsproblem, with explanation and walk-through) got me into CS vs. prior interest mainly in EE.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by rrr_oh_man on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:31AM (#47386379)
For the curious:

> Microsoft provides two frameworks for developing Windows applications: MFC (Microsoft Foundation Classes) and Win32. MFC (Microsoft Foundation Classes) is a Microsoft framework for developing Windows applications in the C++ programming language. Win32 is a collection of functions and data structures provided by Microsoft for the development of Windows applications. [0]

[0] https://www.tutorialspoint.com/article/difference-between-mf...

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by okanat on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:02AM (#47387487)
That's old info. Now there is also .NET Framework, .NET (Core), C++/WinRT and more. In the end all of them use either pure Win32 APIs or COM APIs including MFC.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:02AM (#47386214)
Apologies, I wasn’t familiar with his work.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by singleshot_ on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:20AM (#47387626)
I wasn’t familiar with yours until you posted.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:21AM (#47387638)
Not sure what you're trying to say. I'm not arguing from authority. I'm just a guy giving my opinion. That's what comment sections are for.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by singleshot_ on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:34AM (#47387769)
Thinkin about it from my point of view: would I prefer a comment section full of people who don't know what they're talking about, reciting opinions? Generally speaking, I come here to interact with people who are familiar with the subject matter, and it's disappointing to see the community getting diluted.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:34AM (#47387777)
I'm familiar with the subject matter. I'm not familiar with the author.

I love classical music. I've been singing in a choir since I was 7, playing the piano since the same age, and compose music myself (https://youtu.be/7Tex-OUk6ZM). I’m actually on my way to church right now to sing some Howells.

I use Spotify every day

I use AI every day

I have enough familiarity with the subject to have an opinion and express it. I'm sorry that I haven't read the author's book.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by ctxc on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:29AM (#47388352)
You're not wrong. If comment sections were restricted to people who knew the subject matter AND the author, it would be empty indeed.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by scrollop on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:10AM (#47388156)
Snobbish and elitist defined.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by santoshalper on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:24AM (#47388298)
I love classical music, and I am convinced that 90% of the reason people think they don't is because of people like the Charles Petzold. Deriving your self worth from being an enjoyer of art that someone else created is the high pretention.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by paradox460 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:50AM (#47388568)
I've learned, sometimes through hard periods of self reflection, that attempting qualitative evaluation of others choice in music is a fools errand.

To put it bluntly, and quote Duke Ellington, by way of Peter Schickele, if if it sounds good, it is good

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sutterd on Sunday March 15, 2026 @03:28PM (#47390975)
I was surprised to see a post by Petzold on this subject. I know who he is. But I don’t think you owe an apology here. I think you made a thoughtful comment. A post like his should be critiqued for what it says, not for the author’s previous work. And, fortunately, other people could give context on the significant work he has done.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by ahoka on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:12AM (#47386273)
The MF what?
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by eps on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:35AM (#47386397)
Classes. MF classes.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by zeristor on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:16AM (#47386682)
That stuff will never wash out of my mind.

Pascal, C, or C++, it depends what mood they were in.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by jrmg on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:26AM (#47387691)
His book ‘Code’ is his masterpiece, IMO.

It’s a tour de force in technical communication. A fascinating book for both the Computer Science novice and expert.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by tambourine_man on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:46AM (#47387902)
“Code” is one of the best books I’ve ever read. I don’t usually read 500 page books but this one flew. Even if you know most of what’s being discussed it’s such a delightful ride.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by raincole on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:11AM (#47386650)
> For example, when the author says “if it can’t do this, how could it compose music?”, that’s a category error.

Given the author's background I believe it's intentional ragebait. It's as ridiculous as saying LLM can't count the number of Rs so it cannot generate grammatically correct sentences. No way he really thinks the logic is sound.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by WarmWash on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:36AM (#47388419)
Spotify's DJ also isn't an LLM. It's just a shuffle with structured interludes and a TTS engine. IIRC it launched in early 2023 and has been the same since.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by snoman on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:26PM (#47388948)
That explains why it is always/only wanting to play stuff that I listened to recently, or in 2023.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hansmayer on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:51PM (#47389194)
The 'author' is not some random social media influencer, he'd probably scoff at your silly comment. Ffs, educate yourself folks.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by raincole on Sunday March 15, 2026 @01:09PM (#47389390)
> Given the author's background
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by technothrasher on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:55AM (#47386550)
> For example, when the author says “if it can’t do this, how could it compose music?”, that’s a category error.

That isn't really a category error. It's more begging the question. It makes the assumption that the ability to DJ music is the same ability as being able to compose music, and uses that assumption to suggest the conclusion that a failure to DJ classical movement would necessarily result in the failure to compose same. A category error would be assigning a property to AI that it cannot have. It would look more like, "if AI can't DJ music, we have no way to know what color it is."

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by navaed01 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:02AM (#47386587)
I’m fairly certain Spotify’s core meta data adheres to the US music industry largely set / reinforby Nielsen. I’m curious why the author would want to happen with the feature if not move from 1 artist to another
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by oasisbob on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:24PM (#47388916)
For chart reporting? Am unfamiliar with the Nielsen standard, but given the state of musical metadata more broadly it's probably not very sophisticated.

Would expect any provider like Spotify to just export the reports Nielsen requires, not design their core systems around it.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by ErroneousBosh on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:05AM (#47386610)
> It makes the assumption that the ability to DJ music is the same ability as being able to compose music

And yet an awful lot of musicians are also DJs. It's almost like spending a lot of time playing music and watching how people react to it give you a good sense of how the underlying processes of creating it can work.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by dalmo3 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:00AM (#47388043)
GP was obviously talking about AI's abilities, not people's.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by smelendez on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:26PM (#47388939)
Also, a DJ isn’t typically tasked with playing an entire symphony (or pop album, for that matter) on request from start to finish. I’m sure there are a handful of DJs in niche situations who do this at listening bars and on the radio, but it seems pretty rare.

Honestly a human DJ might well do what the Spotify DJ does — play a popular piece that matches the outlandish request and then transition to other music.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hirsin on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:39PM (#47389064)
To torture the metaphor further - it's also a personal dj, with an audience and customer of 1. Somewhat by definition there can be no outlandish requests, certainly not "play this entire piece".

If I told the DJ at my wedding to play an album front to back, and they transitioned to Aerosmith, I'd be tapping a friend to run the music the rest of the night.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by DonHopkins on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:09AM (#47386637)
There is a long history of using AI to analyze, compose, and perform music.

Atari Cambridge Research- part 5: David Levitt shows Music Box on his Lisp Machine

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocwsVkqEKys

Atari Cambridge Research- part 6: Music box with Tom Trobaugh and drum machine with Jim Davis.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhA0FGsin_s

Cynthia Solomon has shared a treasure trove of rare classic videos of Seymour Papert, Marvin and Margaret Minsky, kids programming Logo and playing with turtles, and many other amazing things at the MIT AI Lab, MIT Media Lab, and Atari Cambridge Research:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28604629

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by WickyNilliams on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:00AM (#47386206)
Mr Petzold's book, Code, is marvel and you should read it btw
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by vasco on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:55AM (#47386172)
When "me" is most classical music and this is a music platform I think the critique is not unwarranted. They could adapt it with special system prompts for classical.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:01AM (#47386210)
Probably 50% of my listening is classical. If I want to listen to classical I just listen to albums. I’ve never had a problem with this. The concept of a DJ for classical music is just kind of weird.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by johanvts on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:01AM (#47386585)
Spotify is still bad for classical music because you can’t ex. search by composer or label of find alternative recordings of the same piece etc. If you know what album you want already its ok, but if you like classical you should really consider IDAGIO.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by PaulHoule on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:29AM (#47386764)
Isn’t fundamentally the issue that for any symphony by Beethoven or whoever that there are thousands of recordings of performances? So if I decide I want to listen to a certain one then I also need to pick a particular performance that a particular orchestra did a certain time?
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by zukzuk on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:54AM (#47386951)
Apple Music has a totally separate app for classical music. It was specifically designed to address exactly this.

For each composer, it shows all their well known works, and then you can tap on each to see all the recordings of that particular piece.

Smart move on Apple’s part, if you ask me.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by allears on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:03PM (#47388708)
As mentioned above, they bought Primephonic, which already had all those features. For myself, I used Primephonic until Apple bought it, then switched to Idagio, in order to minimize my connection with the Apple machine.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by clickety_clack on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:39AM (#47387830)
I always wondered why there were separate apps, and this makes total sense.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by mingus88 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @03:49PM (#47391160)
I love that app. They have Dolby atmos mixes which seem like overkill but I was completely floored putting on a double bass work and being completely immersed in the center of the sound. Obviously great for large ensembles but surprisingly awesome at solo works

And the play history integrates with the main Music app

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by systoll on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:09AM (#47387051)
And if you want one subscription for popular & classical music, Apple Music is miles ahead of Spotify.

Music.app is already better than Spotify at handling the relevant metadata. But the dedicated Apple Music Classical app is roughly the same as IDAGIO.

(They bought IDAGIO's former competitor Primephonic to do it)

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by parpfish on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:40AM (#47387835)
building recommendation systems for classical music has a simple data problem- most recommendation systems (for spotify and others) are based on simple user listening histories that look at "people that listened to X also listened to Y".

this is a problem for classical (and jazz) for two reasons a) these genres are not particularly popular on the platform so there are few unique users and b) the songs are LONG so listening sessions contain fewer songs.

track cooccurance based recs work well for popular genres, but these other genres need a different approach to recs and that's actually where AI could do really well by digging into the unstructured data associated with the tracks (sonic analysis of the song, biographical information about the composer, details about featured soloists, etc) rather than relying on piles of user behavior.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hnlmorg on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:59AM (#47386576)
There’s plenty of rest stations that specialise in classical music. So it’s not that weird of an idea to have a “DJ” for classical.

It’s just a different kind of DJ. Like how HipHop DJ is different from a trance DJ. And a wedding DJ is different too.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hnlmorg on Sunday March 15, 2026 @01:42PM (#47389781)
By “rest stations” I meant “radio stations”.

I missed that autocorrection early. Sorry

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by moron4hire on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:07AM (#47387044)
You never listen to NPR?
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by rhdunn on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:12AM (#47388178)
I'm not in the US, but have listened to various of their tiny desk concerts that they put up on YouTube.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:10AM (#47387057)
I’m British so I guess the equivalent would be Radio 4. But no, not really tbh. I just find what I want and listen to it. I know some people really like Radio 4 though.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by BoredPositron on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:54AM (#47386164)
Sorry but at this point this beta product is over 2 years old. It should be better by now. Unlike your "baffling" comment at least he wrote the article himself.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by bbor on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:13AM (#47386658)
The article isn’t about the DJ feature at all, despite claiming to be. It is very clearly and openly about Spotify not catering to classical music in general. It starts by calling all people who listen to anything other than classical music “illiterate”!
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by mrob on Sunday March 15, 2026 @01:15PM (#47389484)
>It starts by calling all people who listen to anything other than classical music “illiterate”!

It does not. The only reference to literacy is the following:

"The use of the word “song” for instrumental music — that is, music that is not sung and hence is not a song — is borderline illiterate."

That is entirely reasonable and correct.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @06:59AM (#47386194)
The Spotify DJ feature is terrible, I agree. That doesn’t mean I find the linked article compelling.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by noodletheworld on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:20AM (#47386306)
What a baffling take.

There is no confusion as to which “AI” the OP is referring to.

The author wrote:

> Or does the AI work in so mysterious a way that the programmers need no longer take responsibility?

They are pondering, in general, if the non deterministic nature of AI is an excuse for bad products.

The Spotify DJ is a recommendation engine.

Its bad.

Its a lazy, bad implementation that relies on AI, instead of deterministic algorithms; eg. identify requested music and play it.

Instead it wants to “try something different”.

If you press play on the music player on your phone, do you expect it to “try something different?”

…or, is AI making developers and product managers lazy?

It is not a complicated take, and the example is, to me, pretty compelling.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by bbor on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:11AM (#47386654)
There’s a reason there’s no deterministic recommendation engines. How would that even work?

Doing something previously impossible isn’t “lazy”.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by noodletheworld on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:32AM (#47387757)
Don't try to deflect with pedantry.

The system is clearly resolving the users query.

Mixing that with the deterministic “play the songs requested instead of random crap” or even “play related classical music instead of random crap” is clearly not an impossibility.

It actually almost did the right thing. …but no, rather than handling the difficult edges cases like this, just do whatever for edges cases.

It is lazy.

Handling complex difficult edge cases is what differentiates good products from lazy ones.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by bbor on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:03PM (#47388705)
You don’t use a DJ feature(/any recommendation feature) to play specific songs, you use the search bar. Again, a recommendation system that gave you just exactly what you asked for wouldn’t be a recommendation system!

Re:”play related music”, yeah clearly Spotify isn’t built for classical music. Maybe it should be — I certainly would vote for it to be a priority for a state-operated alternative! But calling a specific feature lazy because of a high-level corporate priority concerning content isn’t valid, IMHO.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:24AM (#47386335)
I guess I’m just separating out the fact that I agree with the OP from my criticism of the way the argument was presented.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by Barbing on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:55AM (#47386962)
>If you press play on the music player on your phone, do you expect it to “try something different?”

I expect it to make a playlist containing the opposite of my taste, like I asked! :)

(YMMV on how good it is at this)

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by lxgr on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:10AM (#47388154)
> The Spotify DJ is a recommendation engine.

Is it?

Having recently tried Spotify's presumably related "prompt based playlists" feature, I've been wondering:

Is the "AI DJ" maybe not a recommendation engine, but rather an LLM prompted to be a recommendation engine?

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by Hnrobert42 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:53AM (#47386945)
Whoa. Poor form. You give no evidence of either claim in your last sentence.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by BoredPositron on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:24AM (#47387161)
It has Geminis verve the "baffling" was the hint.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:25AM (#47387170)
I am human, sorry

Baffling is a common word in Britain and the first term that sprung to mind when reading the article

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by michaelbuckbee on Sunday March 15, 2026 @08:49AM (#47386917)
Perhaps not so strange in that from a practical standpoint many "AI problems" are actually "Data Problems" when you start peeling things back.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by leoc on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:23AM (#47387155)
> There’s probably some non-AI code in there to explicitly prevent it from playing an album end to end.

Google’s Nest speakers have or had similar issues: they’d start any requested piece of (at least multi-movement) classical music somewhere in the middle and simply defy any instructions to start at the beginning, bizarre behaviour for a smart speaker.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by jrjeksjd8d on Sunday March 15, 2026 @09:33AM (#47387227)
Every modern streaming platform seems to be focused on the relationship between contemporary singles - who featured on what, what's trending, if you like this current pop artist you'll like this other one. Setting aside OP's interest in classical music this approach doesn't even work for popular music from the 60s to 90s when the primary format was the album. God help you if you try to use voice commands to play Help! (the album by the Beatles) and instead get Help! (the title track by the Beatles).
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by jrm4 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:23AM (#47387650)
I think quite the opposite for precisely the reason you're saying?

Which is to say, he's doing a very good job of reminding you/us nerds that "there should be no excuse for this, technical or otherwise." The technology exists to make this work very well and has for sometime; I GET why it's not working now, but that doesn't make it any less garbage.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 15, 2026 @10:39AM (#47387825)
The problem with this article is there are more than one way to be a DJ

>This is a product issue. Spotify DJ is essentially “shuffle with some voice interludes”. There’s probably some non-AI code in there to explicitly prevent it from playing an album end to end.

And I would argue that is one of the stupidest ways.

https://medium.com/luminasticity/the-complete-playlist-e8eb3...

The Complete Playlist argues for shuffling and serendipity for achieving accidental surprise and delight and clever juxtapositions, something that if you had an actually competent DJ could be guided and not left to chance.

A competent DJ makes musical arguments in relation to an aural environment in the same way a competent Philosopher may make intellectual arguments in relation to an environment of ideas.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by gzread on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:55PM (#47389228)
I can tell you're a philosopher, because I do not think of DJ music as an "argument"
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by j45 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @11:47AM (#47388543)
Seems pretty harsh for somethign it may not have been designed to be good at.

Maybe Spotify works more off lyrics, and classical music usually doesn't have lyrics.

I'd love to have AI that could hear music.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by t0bia_s on Sunday March 15, 2026 @07:06PM (#47392976)
I'd like to have Spotify without videos and podcasts. Simple, but forbidden to do it.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by chihuahua on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:09PM (#47388772)
Totally agree. And also, this limitation of Spotify probably affects 0.00000001% of their users. In other words, it just doesn't matter (except to those 3 people)
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by pc86 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:45PM (#47389127)
> This is a product issue.

The product organization at Spotify is a master class in dysfunctional product organizations. Compare the feature parity of the desktop and mobile applications and you'll find random features available in one but not the other. Try to do basically anything in CarPlay other than select a different recently-played playlist and you'll be able to do it 10x faster by picking up your phone and doing it there.

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hansmayer on Sunday March 15, 2026 @12:48PM (#47389165)
> from somebody who should understand the underlying technology

I am really looking forward to the day when the software industry implodes and VC capital withdraws, so all of you coding-bootcamp-types finally drop out of it and leave it to people who always did it primarily out of intrinsic interest and not for the money. Some random mmoron on the Internet calling out none less than the legendary Charles Petzold has to be peak of the absurdity that the current tech industry represents!

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by sd9 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @01:35PM (#47389681)
Chill out, you don’t know anything about me
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hansmayer on Sunday March 15, 2026 @04:29PM (#47391527)
Indeed I don't, but your comment was very revealing.
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by apublicfrog on Sunday March 15, 2026 @05:25PM (#47392114)
I have an intrinsinc interest and have been tinkering, fiddling, hacking and learning for 30 years. I've done it for money before, I've I've always done it for fun every spare moment I have.

I've never heard of your man here. Does that make me a lesser from your perspective?

I'm sick of this arrogent gatekeeping. Why does someone have to memorise names, dates and achievements to qualify as someone who loves what they do?

Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by hansmayer on Monday March 16, 2026 @04:23AM (#47396362)
No, it does not make you any lesser. But if I were attacking "my man" (not my man), I´d do a bit of basic research. And I´d learn how to properly write "arrogant".
Re:The Appalling Stupidity of Spotify's AI DJ by spunky2342 on Sunday March 15, 2026 @04:44PM (#47391690)
Spotify is definitely not trying very hard, the author is justified in complaining. I had a very similar experience. They are in a perfect position to be able to make something amazing, but they (and other streaming companies) are somewhat limited in what they can do because of their music licensing relationships. I was able to build something 100x better than their DJ using an off-the-shelf LLM and some well-crafted search/metadata tools. It has no problem doing what Petzold wanted. It's a much better way to interact with music than what the general public has access to now, and I would love to commercialize it, but the rights-holders (UMG, WMG, Sony, etc) are very protective of what they own. If you want to know more reply here or reach out to me at [email protected].