News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by adverbly on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:23AM (#47193819)
Well hopefully this is short, minimally lethal, and leads to regime change for all those involved.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Zealotux on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:29AM (#47193874)
>leads to regime change for all those involved

Including for the U.S. and Israel?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Revanche1367 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:59AM (#47194162)
Pretty sure he chose his words carefully.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by gambiting on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:40AM (#47193980)
We can only hope.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by methyl on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:59AM (#47194159)
It’s possible
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ActorNightly on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:30PM (#47198630)
Possible but unlikely. The midterms are going to get actually stolen by Republicans, 100%.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:00AM (#47196095)
I did not see the US butchering 30k protesters in 2 days.

And no, stop your American exceptionalism, ICE is not the same.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by cosmicgadget on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:34AM (#47197298)
Your threshold for desiring regime change is the murder of 30,000 people?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by LtWorf on Sunday March 01, 2026 @05:54AM (#47205592)
Then israel is way past it…
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by lm28469 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:24AM (#47196387)
Nah you just bully your allies and illegally tariff the entire world, no biggy
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nullocator on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:54AM (#47196801)
The US mostly isn't interested in butchering it's own citizens, slavery is the approach we went with À la the U.S. prison system.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:09AM (#47196976)
> The US mostly isn't interested in butchering it's own citizens, slavery is the approach we went with À la the U.S. prison system.

I hate to break it to you, but US prisons, while maybe worse than Scandinavian ones, are on par with France, and way better than like 70% of the world.

This is not a competition who has it worse. You can acknowledge terrible things that IR does without trying to portray yourself as a victim.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nullocator on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:00PM (#47198292)
You are conflating issues. As a foregone conclusion the U.S. bombing the sovereign citizens of Iran is acceptable to you, only afterwards are you and other's justifying this by cherry picking recent events. If Iran hadn't just killed protesters, it'd be because they were working on nukes, or because they've launched missiles across borders.

You blind yourself to the dozens of countries around the world doing these things and worse every day while picking and choosing enemies that are acceptable for the United States to attack like al la carte menu items. Justifying those attacks is an after thought.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by runako on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:49PM (#47199418)
> on par with France

The US per-capita incarceration rate is ~5x that of France.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tt24 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:32PM (#47201689)
How is this related to what the person you’re replying to said?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by runako on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:22PM (#47202596)
They were responding to this:

> The US mostly isn't interested in butchering it's own citizens, slavery is the approach we went with À la the U.S. prison system.

To the extent that one is addressing slavery, the point is generally the number of the enslaved and not particularly their conditions (there is not a "good" way to own people).

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by watwut on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:13AM (#47204742)
> are on par with France, and way better than like 70% of the world.

French system is quite different from USA one. And the 70% of the world claim is based on what exactly?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:35PM (#47198694)
We killed far more Indigenous Americans than that. I agree with you on the prison system though.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by unethical_ban on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:32AM (#47196484)
Protesters that took to the streets, according to what I read, because the US president said he would back them. Sounds like he led them to a slaughter to generate justification.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:44AM (#47196647)
Protests started way before Trumps tweet.

Second, why are you legitimizing gunning down thousands of people?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by unethical_ban on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:03AM (#47196904)
I'm delegitimizing the US president saying things he can't back up, causing death, and getting the US into another war that the American people didn't ask for.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:11AM (#47197000)
> I'm delegitimizing the US president

No. You are saying that these people died because of Trump's tweet, and not because the IR goons gunned people on the streets. Seems to me that you place the fault on Trump, rather than on those who pulled the trigger.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by FilosofumRex on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:12PM (#47202532)
you, Trump & Satanyahu are not entitled to your own peaceful counter-revolution - if you want to overthrow the democratically elected government of Iran, you must bear the necessarily sacrifices
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Jensson on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:34PM (#47202679)
Ali Khamenei won one election and has sat there as a supreme leader ever since, that is not democracy. Deposing him is needed for democracy, there has been many protests against him.

Iran is not a democracy, it is a fake democracy since the supreme leader cannot be voted away.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by danny_codes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:18AM (#47197086)
I mean we just killed a bunch of children. So give it a bit of time I’m sure we can get those numbers up.

Trump is the kind of person who would kill protestors to stay in power. We all know it

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by waffleiron on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:36AM (#47197325)
Have we forgotten the huge amount of covid deaths?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by qup on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:48AM (#47197464)
Iran says we did.

I saw a report that it was an errant Iranian missile.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:36PM (#47198705)
This is the Zionist modus operandi. Bomb civilian targets, then claim it's a "stray weapon". When the truth comes out, just ignore it. Zionists have been the aggressors in this region since Zionism was invented.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by helaoban on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:35PM (#47198689)
If you instigate a war you are responsible for all casualties.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by qup on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:28PM (#47199205)
I can understand that viewpoint, but the stories are reading as if the school was targeted.

I'll wait for some non-iranian confirmation.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by almosthere on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:49AM (#47204076)
I'm so over the reddit shit on hn.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tim333 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:25AM (#47196400)
True but a lot of people would like to see Netanyahu and Trump replaced with other leaders.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by greggoB on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:05PM (#47198368)
> And no, stop your American exceptionalism

I don't think you intended to use this the way you did

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:34PM (#47198681)
You didn't see anyone butchering 30k protesters in 2 days, because that didn't happen.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:14PM (#47203287)
I did see. It is sad that you've decided to look away.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Sunday March 01, 2026 @11:42AM (#47208257)
Look away from something that never happened?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by almosthere on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:48AM (#47204070)
It definitely did happen, it might have been 40k.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sosomoxie on Sunday March 01, 2026 @11:42AM (#47208262)
It definitely did not happen. If you're going to make a claim, you'll need to provide some proof.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by almosthere on Monday March 02, 2026 @12:05AM (#47214082)
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by alex43578 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:51PM (#47201883)
You don't understand: they are getting held in civil detention before being sent back to the country they came from on a chartered plane!
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:51PM (#47198192)
It is difficult to instigate regime change for democratically elected governments.

Iran has an unelected supreme leader.

Israel has a large portion of its population completely disenfranchised.

The US has a generally democratically elected government.

If one of these governments is going to fall during military instabilities, it would most likely be Iran. The US will have significant regime change in November if polling holds.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:26PM (#47199191)
> Israel has a large portion of its population completely disenfranchised.

Care to elaborate? As far as I know, this is false. All Israeli citizens 18 or older can vote; there are no voting restrictions based on race, religion, gender or property; prisoners can vote (unlike in many US states for example); permanent residents who are not citizens cannot vote in national elections but may vote in municipal elections (not the case in the US). National turnout ranges between 65% and 75%.

Minorities are well represented: Arab and Druze citizens vote and have representation in the Knesset.

I struggle to find any dimension in which your statement is correct.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:38PM (#47199311)
Very obviously, I’m referring to the Palestinians in the “Palestinian Territories” being de facto governed by Israel and are not allowed to vote in Israeli elections.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:09PM (#47199666)
There is nothing obvious about that statement. In fact it's catastrophically wrong.

Palestinians in Gaza have been governed by Hamas since 2006. Before that, they had been governed by the Palestinian Authority (Fatah) since 1994.

Palestinians in Judea and Samaria ("West bank") have been governed by the Palestinian Authority continuously since 1994, with the exception of Area C.

Palestinians who live there are NOT "de facto governed" by Israel. They pay taxes to the Palestinian Authority; receive birth certificates, IDs, business licenses and social security payments from the P.A.; Go to schools, hospitals, courts, police stations and jails run by the P.A. And most importantly, they vote in elections run by the P.A. To say that they are "de facto governed" by Israel is ridiculous, and shows a lack of basic understanding of Israel and Palestine, and the conflict between them.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by squibonpig on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:45PM (#47200030)
The person you're responding to said they were unable to vote in Israeli elections. You said "no, they're able to, uhh, not vote in the case of those under Hamas and they're able to vote in elections held by the Palestinian authority in the case of those in the west bank." I don't know a ton about this, but I don't believe the Palestinian authority elections are the same as the Israeli elections. As I understand it, the right to vote is gated behind a citizenship process that is restrictive enough to generally prevent Palestinians from obtaining it.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:15PM (#47200328)
> The person you're responding to said they were unable to vote in Israeli elections.

They said Palestinians are "a large portion of the Israeli population [that] is disenfranchised". That is a wrong statement. Palestinians are not part of the Israeli population and there is no expectation (on either side) that they would participate in Israeli elections. That issue has been largely settled by the Oslo framework in 1994.

> As I understand it, the right to vote is gated behind a citizenship process that is restrictive enough to generally prevent Palestinians from obtaining it.

I'm not sure which elections you mean.

- Israeli elections are for Israeli citizens. The 20% of Israelis who are Arab (sometimes loosely referred to as "Palestinians" as a loose synonym for "Arab living in former mandatory Palestine") can participate normally

- Palestinians in the West Bank vote in Palestinian elections. ' not aware of any citizenship-related restrictions there. Possible issues might be: logistics of getting to polls because of Israeli checkpoints; or simply the absence of elections (PA hasn't held a national election since 2006, although there are municipal elections).

- Specifically in East Jerusalem, on which Israeli claims sovereignty, Palestinians are classified as permanent residents of Israel. They may apply fot Israeli citizenship but that's probably a difficult process. As permanent residents they can vote in Israeli municipal elections, and as Palestinians they can vote in Palestinian national elections. But not being Israeli citizens they cannot vote in Israeli national elections. Perhaps that is what you're referring to?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by pyrale on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:55PM (#47201909)
> That issue has been largely settled by the Oslo framework in 1994.

A process that's alive and well, just like Yitzhak Rabin.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:57PM (#47202418)
The peace process that Oslo initiated is certainly dead. But Oslo itself, as the last bilateral agreement between Israel and the Palestinian Authority, is de facto the law of the land, even though it was meant as an interim agreement. For better or worse...
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mvdtnz on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:59PM (#47200167)
This is like saying Australians are disenfranchised because they can't vote in New Zealand elections. They're not governed by Israel in any meaningful way.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by hirako2000 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:25PM (#47200436)
Correction: It is like saying Australians can't vote in general elections after being pushed out of 75% of the territory, except a small percentage who are tolerated in the major land since they won't make a difference.

The ostracized Aussies then can vote for their own leaders but will be blamed if they vote for the wrong ones and embargoed, regularly shot and even bombed from time to time to remind them who the place belongs to.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:01PM (#47201963)
It would be like if Native American tribes could not vote in American elections, but the federal government still controlled the ability for those nations to access the external world.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by datsci_est_2015 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:47PM (#47200047)
Counterpoint, Palestinians (many of whom were not alive in 2006, as they are children) are not exactly drenched in sovereignty at the moment.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:18PM (#47200356)
I agree. But it is not Israel who is disenfranchising them - it is the Palestinian Authority (in West Bank) and Hamas (in Gaza).
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tovej on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:45PM (#47201822)
Oh yikes, that is either the most ignorant or the least honest argument I've seen anyone make on this topic.

Shame on you.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:32PM (#47202254)
In the absence of a counter-argument I can only assume that you don't have anything of substance to offer on this topic.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tovej on Sunday March 01, 2026 @02:23AM (#47204487)
This is a little bit like arguing against someone saying the earth is flat, or that the sun isn't in the sky.

There's not really any point. They are too far gone.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Sunday March 01, 2026 @04:57AM (#47205290)
Thank you for confirming that my assumption was correct.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by iw2rmb on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:08PM (#47200244)
Nakba.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:21PM (#47200390)
I shouldn’t even have to argue here. Access to the West Bank is controlled by Israel. That is de facto governance.

At best the Palestinian Territories have “quasi-governmental control.” I’m saying this as someone who isn’t particularly pro-Palestine. Pretending that Israel isn’t de facto the government of the Palestinian Territories is an unserious position.

By de facto I mean explicitly not de jure.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:57PM (#47200723)
> I shouldn’t even have to argue here

If you don't like to argue, may I suggest not making controversial claims on controversial topics, in a place that encourages constructive debate?

> Access to the West Bank is controlled by Israel.

That is mostly true. On the border with Jordan it is jointly controlled by Jordan and Israel (like most international borders).

> Pretending that Israel isn’t de facto the government of the Palestinian Territories is an unserious position

I already explained in great detail the specific ways in which the Palestinian Territories are, in fact, governed by the Palestinian Authority. Taxation, elections, justice, police, education, healthcare, roads, sewers, business regulation, population register...

So far your counter-argument is that Israel controls the border... and therefore Palestinians should vote in Israeli elections? Should they also vote in Palestinian ejections? Or should the P.A. simply stop to exist? What point are you even making exactly?

Calling me "unserious" doesn't make you automatically "serious", or right.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:16PM (#47200882)
You are confusing de facto control and de jure control. That’s why I’m arguing the position is unserious. I don’t know anything about you personally.

You’re making my point anyway, by conceding that the West Bank is effectively governed without representation in the governments controlling them.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:55PM (#47202401)
I don't think the terms de facto and de jure mean what you think they mean. At this point it appears you're just throwing fancy words at me, and are not able to make a coherent point or meaningfully address mine. So, let's just agree to disagree.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by mtsolitary on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:54PM (#47200693)
"The exception of Area C" is doing a lot of work in this argument. That's 61% of the territory of the West Bank ("Judea and Samaria") (those scare quotes also doing a lot of work).

To counter your list of things that the PA does de facto control, I will add: who controls the criminal court system? The checkpoints which lead to the outside world? The airspace? The ability to import and export goods? The roads? The territorial contiguity of Areas A and B? The decisions on building new settlements?

Aside from the municipal things you mentioned, which in most places in the world are controlled by subnational entities, Israel is in de facto control of the lives and futures of all 15 million people "from the river to the sea", roughly half of them Jews and half of them Arabs, while only one of those groups has what anyone in the West could consider to be a normal existence.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:22PM (#47202167)
> "The exception of Area C" is doing a lot of work in this argument. That's 61% of the territory of the West Bank

Area C is less than 10% of the Palestinian population in the West Bank, 6% of Palestinian population if you count Gaza. Interesting that you chose to focus on territory! Last I checked, square kilometers do not vote, people do.

In any case, you are right that Area C is more complicated, since it is controlled by Israel and there are Palestinians who live there.

However, Palestinians living in area C can also vote in Palestinian elections. So although it is true that they live in a territory governed by Israel (unlike the other 94% of Palestinians), it remains false that they are a "large part of the Israeli population that is disenfranchised" (the original statement).

> ("Judea and Samaria") (those scare quotes also doing a lot of work).

Obviously the choice of name for this region reflects a political preference. But that works both ways. I prefer to call it Judea and Samaria because that's what it was called until 1948, when Jordan invaded and annexed it. "West bank" is a relic of Jordanian occupation, chosen by King Abdullah to absorb the region into his kingdom, not just politically but semantically. Jordan hasn't controlled the region in 60 years - longer than the occupation itself. It seems reasonable to stop calling it by its colonial Jordan name.

You seem to take particular issue with my use of the term "Judea and Samaria". That is also a political preference. Do you care to explain it the same way I explained mine?

> To counter your list of things that the PA does de facto control, I will add: who controls the criminal court system?

In areas A and B, the Palestinian Authority.

> The checkpoints which lead to the outside world?

On the Israeli side: Israel. On the Jordanian side: Jordan.

> The airspace?

Israel

> The ability to import and export goods?

The Palestinian Authority, but subject to stringent security control by Israel.

> The roads?

In Areas A and B: the Palestinian Authority.

> The territorial contiguity of Areas A and B?

That was jointly defined by the bilateral agreement at Oslo. So, both sides agreed on that.

> The decisions on building new settlements?

In area C: Israel.

In areas A and B: there are no settlements (Jews are not allowed to live there).

> Israel is in de facto control of the lives and futures of all 15 million people "from the river to the sea"

We're straying from the original topic of disenfranchisement... I will just say that, in my opinion, your view is simplistic and manichean. The closest we ever got to a resolution of the conflict, in 1994, was with a bilateral agreement. Neither side is fully in control of the outcome. Denying that Palestinians, too, have responsibilities and agency, is the surest way to perpetuate this conflict.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by revenant718 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:13PM (#47202891)
>> Israel is in de facto control of the lives and futures of all 15 million people "from the river to the sea"

> We're straying from the original topic of disenfranchisement

What a laughable statement. This is entirely the point of the disenfranchisement claim.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:52PM (#47203141)
In what way is it laughable? Please contribute something of substance.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by webstrand on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:13AM (#47204741)
To wit, if you get to vote for the HOA board but not for the government that can override every decision the HOA makes, are you meaningfully enfranchised?

They're arguing that due to the failure/stalling of the two-state solution, the PA is effectively not a national government. It administers local services, like policing, courts, infrastructure. But it doesn't control borders, tarrifs and duties, or airspace. The Israeli military operates a parallel legal system that can detain and prosecute them, all under a legal framework that they have no vote or say in. I think its fair to call this a kind of disenfranchisement?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Sunday March 01, 2026 @04:44AM (#47205216)
I understand where you're coming from, but this is a flawed analogy.

The legal framework for the Palestinian Authority's existence is a bilateral treaty. Israel did not unilaterally create this flawed administrative entity: it was jointly created with the PLO, as an interim step towards a fully sovereign Palestinian state. The negotiations that followed were also bilateral. These negotiations failed, leaving both sides with an incomplete interim solution. As a result Palestinians are neither citizens of Israel, nor of a wholly sovereign state. They are stateless, that is undeniable. But the reason they are stateless is not that they "have no vote or say". They had a say at the negotiation table in Oslo. They also had a say in Camp David in 2000, when Yasser Arafat walked away from a deal that would have given him a state with its capital in Jerusalem, and started the second intifada instead. They had a say in 2005 when they elected Abbas over reformist alternatives. They had a say in 2006 when they elected Hamas in Gaza. And they have a say now, as Abbas maintains the "pay to slay" program that rewards attacks against Israeli citizens with welfare payments to the attacker's families. There's a reason Israel insisted on overriding security control in the interim state. They couldn't trust the PLO, the very group that killed countless Israeli civilians in shootings, stabbings and bombings, to become the sole guardians of Israeli safety overnight. In Oslo the Palestinian Authority accepted the responsibility to prevent terrorist attacks against Israel. They are free to deliver on that commitment anytime.

My issue with your framing ("the PA is like an HOA"), the parent comment's framing ("Israel solely controls the fate of Palestinians"), and the original comment that started this whole debate ("Palestinians are a disenfranchised part of Israeli population"), is that it strips Palestinians of agency and shared responsibility. It's annoying when you do it. But it's tragic when Palestinians do it to themselves. By perpetuating this myth that they are helpless, blameless victims of external forces, they are making internal reform impossible ("what is there to reform? All our problems are Israel's fault") and any resolution to the conflict impossible ("we are the rebels, Israel is the empire. The only resolution is to blow up the death star").

To tie this back to the original topic of disenfranchisement: even in the flawed interim state created in Oslo, Palestinians have had the opportunity to vote. Not in a state, but in an institution created specifically to chart a path to a state. They elected a president, who then proceeded to cancel presidential elections (the last one was in 2005). They elected a legislative body, who started a civil war and established one of the most violent theocracies in the world. None of this was Israel's doing. To the extent that Palestinians are disenfranchised - denied the opportunity to vote - it is by their own leaders. If anything, it makes me glad Palestine isn't a full-blown state: with leaders like that, the more limits to their power, the better.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by bbshfishe on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:31PM (#47202666)
Wow can you stop spreading misinformation.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by danny_codes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:12PM (#47202882)
Palestinians living in the Palestinian Territories are not Israeli citizens and cannot vote. I would say the Palestinian Territories are occupied, not part of Israel (though Bibi definitely has a sizable camp in his government that would love to make it so).

Do we expect occupied peoples to have a vote? sort of depends how you define democracy. Under an American interpretation (no taxation without representation, 1 person 1 vote) there’s a good argument that you should count occupied peoples.

It’s never so simple is it

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:01AM (#47203892)
If we are talking about Democracy—which is where I started this—yes, if occupied peoples don’t have representation in the government occupying them, yes, that’s very obviously undemocratic. Quite literally by definition. This shouldn’t be controversial.
[dead]
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Sunday March 01, 2026 @10:39AM (#47207671)
I’m talking about Gaza and the West Bank. Israel blockading the Gaza is very obviously de facto governance.

If you can’t enter and leave your country freely, you don’t that autonomy.

I’m not even some Palestinian political advocate. We still cannot pretend that Israel isn’t effectively in control of the Palestinian Territories.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by bbshfishe on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:27PM (#47208705)
How many times were they offered statehood. How many times did they attack Israel? Why is there a wall? You know what happened when the wall went up and security blockades went in? The number of Palestinian suicide bombings dropped. Palestinians have decades of history of terrorism. They could have been like Singapore. But they chose terrorism.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:17AM (#47243808)
Palestinians already have statehood: Palestine is a state, just like israel is a state. They are exactly equal in value and in their right to exist free from coercion by the other.

The issue is that israel is attacking, invading, occupying, annexing, and genociding the state of Palestine.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:00PM (#47203191)
> Under an American interpretation (no taxation without representation, 1 person 1 vote) there’s a good argument that you should count occupied peoples.

Palestinians are not taxed by Israel. They are taxed by the Palestinian Authority, and participate in Palestinian elections. So they do have representation - just not in Israel.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by skywhopper on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:37PM (#47201086)
Yes, but how many adults in land controlled by Israel are Israeli citizens?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by pedalpete on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:12PM (#47200287)
For democratically elected governments, doesn't regime change occur when any sitting politician loses the next election to their oponent?

In my thinking regime change doesn't only refer to the complete collapse of the political system, just change in direction of the leaders.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:04PM (#47201391)
If the legislature changes party, that party —-“the regime” if we can use that term—- will be unseated from power.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by robin_reala on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:11PM (#47199041)
The US is at “flawed democracy” in the Economist Democracy Index: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Economist_Democracy_Index
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by edgyquant on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:48PM (#47199412)
The US is a republic with some democratic institutions, but the economists index isn’t some platonic indicator that gets to define who’s a good government and who isn’t. Several of its higher ranking countries have outright banned extremely popular political parties in recent years.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tovej on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:47PM (#47201843)
Care to tell us what the politics of those parties were?

Because a functioning democracy would ban a nazi party.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by groundzeros2015 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:07PM (#47200238)
democracy is a lower form of government in the ancient world
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Andrex on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:55PM (#47200702)
I wonder who those critics were and what they were motivated by. (Rhetorical)
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by groundzeros2015 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:49PM (#47201223)
If you want to talk about rhetoric look at the idea of a “democracy index” - a score suggesting a scientific approach for determining how good/free a nation is.

We can play the “whose saying it game”, or look at the arguments. Democracy is rule by the lowest - and it’s easily manipulated by the popular. Buying votes, focus on the carnal, and immediate is a clear sign of democracy in decline.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Andrex on Sunday March 01, 2026 @06:21PM (#47211885)
I was more wondering about these emperors, kings, barbarians, and those in their influence who were casting aspersions at Athens. Why are we giving these historically incorrect people the time of day?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by groundzeros2015 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @10:45PM (#47213644)
Once again, looking at incentives can help you find hidden motivations. But at some point you have to look at the arguments at see if they make sense or not.

The US founders didn’t believe in democracy. More people do today, mostly out of a sense that it’s moral obligation. Very few actually will argue it leads to better government outcomes.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nebula8804 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:06PM (#47199615)
So is France.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by seszett on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:42PM (#47201144)
And both have a similarly executive-centric form of government where the president and the majority party hold a disproportionate amount of power. Although the US is even worse than France on this regard as far as I know.

I think it makes sense that both are categorised as flawed.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by refurb on Sunday March 01, 2026 @02:39AM (#47204591)
I wouldn’t assume some any index from a magazine is the end all authority on what a nation state is.

I mean I can start my own magazine and create my own index however I want. Doesn’t mean it’s right.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by hedayet on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:56AM (#47204965)
I guess if your magazine's index reaches the height to have its wikipedia page, then, although it might not be right, but it will be pretty credible.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by refurb on Sunday March 01, 2026 @08:40AM (#47206607)
Anyone can have a Wikipedia page? There is no hurdle.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by chinathrow on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:53PM (#47199475)
You still believe the US regimes will allow elections as the they know it?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by throw0101c on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:46PM (#47199385)
> It is difficult to instigate regime change for democratically elected governments.

Just ask the folks who tried on January 6.

> The US will have significant regime change in November if polling holds.

Assuming elections are held fairly. "Trump, seeking executive power over elections, is urged to declare emergency":

* https://archive.is/https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by diordiderot on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:26PM (#47199195)
> Israel has a large portion of its population completely disenfranchised.

Does it?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by runako on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:46PM (#47199382)
Consider the meanings of the following words:

- sovereignty

- border

- population

In that order, in the context of that region. Then consider their meanings in the context of (say) Canada. Consider how conventional applications of those terms are different for the two.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:08PM (#47201440)
The Israeli government has de facto control of large sections of the Palestinian Territories. The people in those territories, however cannot participate in the elections of that government.

The distinction being de jure and de facto control is something worth debating, but it’s trivially true that Israel controls large swaths of territory where people are not eligible to participate in that government.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by bbshfishe on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:30PM (#47202654)
Prior to October 7th this is simply not true.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Sunday March 01, 2026 @12:10AM (#47203925)
It is very obviously true. Literally movement in the West Bank is controlled.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by austin-cheney on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:56PM (#47200710)
The US and Israel are elected governments, but that should certainly not presuppose democratic. The Roman Republic was, for example, fully elected but simultaneously it was intentionally autocratic to the elite. That is why it fell to a dictatorship which then increased the liberty and standards of the people.

Democracy is the directness by which social participation equates to governance. The US is a federal republic with only two parties each bound by the same hostile funding system that benefits political contributions over the vote. That is far from democratic.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scoofy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:59PM (#47201344)
Democracy and Republic both mean “normal people are in charge of government” and are in opposition to monarchy. The distinction you are referring to was a contrived interpretation in the federalist papers to make a point.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by austin-cheney on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:09PM (#47201458)
No. Democracy and republic are fundamentally different. You want to equivocate them because there is a vote. They have always been different going back to the Ancient Greeks and Romans who each invented those terms.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by kgwxd on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:47PM (#47201838)
> if polling holds.

And The Constitution.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by petre on Sunday March 01, 2026 @05:22AM (#47205435)
> Iran has an unelected supreme leader

Had. Israel probably has a list with the next 3 or 4 in line to replace Khamenei and is currently working towards eliminating them, like they did with the Hezbollah.

Regime change could also be triggered through impeachment or PM losing support and government coalition getting dissolved in the case of Israel.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by michaelteter on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:14PM (#47198474)
One can only dream.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by nyc_data_geek1 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:23PM (#47198569)
He said what he said.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by FuckButtons on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:46PM (#47198813)
Did he stutter?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by hedayet on Sunday March 01, 2026 @03:58AM (#47204977)
don't know about Israel, but for the USA, it means "midterm is coming"
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shevy-java on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:27AM (#47193856)
Iraq? Afghanistan? Vietnam?

I don't think any of these were short.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thomassmith65 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:32AM (#47193902)
Desert Storm was short. The second Iraq War, the stupid one, was not.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ponector on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:51AM (#47194730)
This does not look like a smart one. A bit smarter would be to strike a month ago to support street protests.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thisislife2 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:19PM (#47199128)
It would have confused the Iranians as the regime would then claim that the foreign military attacks prove that the protests are artificially engineered by the same foreign enemy with the support of the Shah. It would also mean the automatic imposition of martial law in Iran, thus making protests even more difficult to organise.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by invader on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:27AM (#47194474)
However, to be fair, Desert Storm hasn't resulted in regime change. The Coalition bombed the shit out of the Iraqi army, but never committed to the ground operation deep inside Iraq. And Saddam's regime survived until the next war.

That alone hints that it is very hard to bring a dictatorship down with just aerial attacks - the ground component is also essential. Something tells me it is going to be the same here.

Only a land operation or a total collapse of the government, with the armed police and military joining the opposition, can topple the Iranian regime.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by AbstractH24 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:58AM (#47194792)
Counterexanple would be Venezuela
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Braxton1980 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:14AM (#47195629)
What was the regime change there? The vice president is in charge.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by ericd on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:00PM (#47199550)
Well, she started releasing lots of political prisoners. So it does seem like the regime acts a bit differently now?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by djeastm on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:56AM (#47196052)
Are you sure? They removed one guy they didn't like but the regime remains.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by platinumrad on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:53PM (#47198212)
Was Saddam's Iraq (post Desert Storm when he no longer had the ability to wage offensive war) really that bad compared to what came after?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by marcosdumay on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:30PM (#47199902)
For a large share of the population, yes, by a huge margin. For an even larger share, no, by a large margin.

Both regimes were deeply racist.

Anyway, I don't think that information entered on the US decision making in any way.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Marsymars on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:26PM (#47199863)
You mean immediately post Desert Storm when this happened? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Iraqi_uprisings
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by datsci_est_2015 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:58PM (#47200153)
> That alone hints that it is very hard to bring a dictatorship down with just aerial attacks.

This has been painfully obvious since aerial bombing became possible, but we’ve had so many generals and executives obsessed with the concept that it continues to be a core doctrine, like Kissinger and Curtis LeMay, neither of for whom I have anything but deep contempt.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by UncleMeat on Saturday February 28, 2026 @07:09AM (#47194286)
Desert storm didn’t attempt regime change. Iran is not currently invading anyone.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Jtsummers on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:29PM (#47197931)
I'm glad someone else remembers. Desert Storm was fast (kind of) because it had a limited objective: Repel an invading army from another nation. It did not lead to an invasion (long term) of Iraq. Comparing any war with the objective of regime change to Desert Storm reveals that the commenter is grossly ignorant of recent history (36 years ago, it's not that far back to be so ignorant).

Desert Storm also wasn't really fast, it led to containment operations lasting a bit over a decade in total, ending only when we decided to invade Iraq with the objective of regime change and nation building. And that one, predictably, turned into a quagmire.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by torlok on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:48AM (#47195980)
That's because Desert Storm was launched by people who remembered the Second World War. Current wars are started by draft dodgers.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by fuzzfactor on Sunday March 01, 2026 @11:26AM (#47208126)
Desert Storm was mainly the US fighting for the Kuwaiti way of life.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:05AM (#47195536)
Well hopefully this is short, minimally lethal, and leads to regime change for all those involved.

That would be ideal but unfortunately not likely. Nobody will like this comment but US ships are sitting ducks. They have minimal ammo per the pentagon and no oilers. No oilers and low ammo means no prolonged conflict. Only two of the ships are nuclear powered not counting submarines. Most of Iran's military and weapons are deep underground in a massive series of underground cities and tunnels. The US would require boots on the ground if they manage to breach the tunnel openings under the mountains. Should that fail the only viable targets are civilians and that won't win favor with anyone or accomplish anything.

Iranian military could just wait it out if they wanted and then smoke Israel with supersonic missiles when the US leaves. Then we find out if Israel does have the nukes for the Samson option and that would result in the destruction of Israel. Iran's military could survive a nuclear strike but would have to clean up the fallout and I am not sure they could. Anyone not underground would likely get Acute Radiation Sickness and Cancer.

On a positive note if the US can manage to get into the tunnels and send in enough munitions to start detonating the missile stockpile a chain reaction could crack all the concrete and collapse the tunnels. Satellite could detect which tunnel they try to evac from. They have less than 5 days to accomplish the chain reaction assuming this is the plan. From the videos I have seen the missiles are literally lined up like a double-strand fuse.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by cosmicgadget on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:38AM (#47197352)
I can't imagine a world where the US military only has the logistics for a five day offensive.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:01PM (#47197617)
It is odd. Trump has been receiving advice on Iran from General Dan Caine. It was suggested Caine warned of risks and limited munitions Trump refuted these stating Caine believes a conflict would be easily won. Other senior officers were in shock that he said this could be done. The pentagon objected due to the lack of ammo and oilers. This is one case where I wish he would listen to the senior officers with substantial experience instead of the guy that often agrees with him.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by petre on Sunday March 01, 2026 @05:56AM (#47205606)
As perfectly echoed by Bob Dylan's Highway 61 song.

"Now the rovin’ gambler he was very bored / He was tryin' to create a next world war / He found a promoter who nearly fell off the floor / He said I never engaged in this kind of thing before / But yes I think it can be very easily done / We'll just put some bleachers out in the sun / And have it on Highway 61"

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thisislife2 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:10PM (#47199027)
There are some factors - this is an offensive being done to prop up Netanyahu's regime in Israel and distract the Americans from the Espstein files. The US thus means to keep it short-term. Moreover, in the middle-east, the American logistic chain runs through its Arab allies in the middle-east, and Iran has explicitly said that it will not hesitate to target its Arab neighbours, hosting American military bases, if the US attacks it. (And that's why it has retaliated against these American allies when it was attacked). Except for Saudi Arabia, these countries do not wish to get into a war with Iran for Israel, and have no interest in joining the war because Iran's missiles are quite precise and effective at short ranges (meaning they and their people will be facing the brunt of the war that they have no interest in). Thus, the US military is actually hampered because it cannot do anything without the host governments permission. (For example, during the last Iran attack, some allies did not allow the US to implement a nationwide jam of the GPS over its airspace). All this highlights the really hard balancing the US has to do to even agree to bomb Iran for a few days - one wrong move and the whole of middle-east can explode, and both the US and Israel will find itself on the receiving end as American and world public opinion turns against it.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Sunday March 01, 2026 @09:52PM (#47213308)
Related HN discussion [1]

[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47211487

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tim333 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:29AM (#47196445)
The US military has seldom had problems with the blowing up the enemy bit. It's providing peace and stability after that happens where they tend to run into problems.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:38AM (#47196573)
The US military has seldom had problems with the blowing up the enemy bit.

True however AFAIK they have never once been in this situation. Iran has spent 40+ years digging in and hunkering down. There were plenty of bunkers in WWII but this is a whole new setup, deeper under mountains, higher quality concrete assuming they knew what they were doing and dug in much deeper. To get this done in 5 days will be quite a feet. If they manage to do it I will be very impressed.

It's providing peace and stability after that happens where they tend to run into problems.

I think you are correct, what happens afterwards is usually a crap-fest. That would require a lot of boots on the ground to maintain stability for a very long time. It's not a great example but Korea is one such example. The payoff may be worth it if many of the Iranian funded terror groups are drained of resources as a result. Keeping boots on the ground for years will require funding from congress. Short of that it will just be another power vacuum filled by yet another zealot. The "if's" are doing a lot of heavy lifting in my comment.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tim333 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:17PM (#47197782)
I think the crap-fest bit could go better with Iran. The Iranians are closer to European in culture than many places.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by TulliusCicero on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:00PM (#47199558)
They don't necessarily have to kill all the Iranian military, just suppress internal security enough to where the Iranian people came rise up in rebellion. It's hard for the IRGC to suppress widespread protests/rebellion if they're constantly stuck hiding in bunkers and tunnels.

I imagine that's the strategy, anyway.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Sunday March 01, 2026 @09:36PM (#47213210)
I think you are right. I imagine they take shifts. Some above, some below for R&R. IRGC have been offered immunity or certain death.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by scrollop on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:21AM (#47197123)
What yt channel?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:45AM (#47197438)
It's hard to find them now with all the AI slop being propped up but the best search terms may be "Iranian tunnel bunkers full of missiles". It is mostly YT channels run out of India. The oldest video I have seen was from CNN ten years ago. Iran will occasionally let journalists see their latest tunnel.

This is a short one showing the 2nd to last generation of tunnels. [1] The latest tunnels are painted white including some that are under water. The older tunnels are not painted and one can see what appears to be reinforced concrete. When completed every tunnel is lined on both sides with missiles. This one [2] shows a couple generations of the tunnels. Found the old CNN video. [3]

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YQ1R7ZAKxE [video][1m]

[2] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQtSPFrnKvo [video][5m25s]

[3] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_Gu_TjmV0E [video][2m12s]

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by InMice on Saturday February 28, 2026 @05:57PM (#47201317)
Seriously? Those videos look like they were made with Blender
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:29PM (#47201657)
Quite possibly. All of the propaganda films I've seen in the last decade look like they were generated and staged on a very low budget and in a hurry.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by weatherlite on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:33PM (#47198662)
I know you won't believe me here but dude you are absolutely full of shit
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:59PM (#47198933)
I clear it out with Cheesecake and Beer. I'll save some for you my friend.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thisislife2 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:40PM (#47198751)
Yeah, the possibility of a regime collapse / change due to this military action is unlikely. The military goal seems to be to destroy Iran's military-industrial complexes to hamper its missile production. Note however that while Iran has potent missile capability, Iran's underground complexes where it is stored presents its own problems - in the absence of adequate air defence and an Air Force, its enemies can just bomb the openings of these underground complexes, making it very, very difficult for the Iranians to use its missile arsenals from there. (This is what Israel did the last time). As for the scenario you outlined, I highly doubt the US would be willing to send boots to the ground to blow up their missiles manually - urban warfare takes a heavy toll and I doubt if the Trump administration can withstand the criticism if body bags start coming home. Even the MAGA crowd has been unexceptionally hostile to Trump's attack on Israel.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:10PM (#47199036)
I highly doubt the US would be willing to send boots to the ground to blow up their missiles manually - urban warfare takes a heavy toll and I doubt if the Trump administration can withstand the criticism if body bags start coming home.

You could be entirely right. Honestly I hope you are right. We lost far too many in Iraq and Afghanistan. I was probably just being cynical. I trust the decisions of the senior leaders in the military but their commander and chief tends to trust the wrong advice.

The only possible correction I might add is the Air Force probably will not drop bombs but would have to fire missiles. The openings are on the sides of mountains and require horizontal access or I suppose incredibly massive bombs. Earth shattering bombs. Something closer to tactical nukes which the US has not stockpiled in a long time AFAIK.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:05PM (#47198991)
[Update]: It seems my dear leader is hitting all the cities... [1] I am not OK with this. Save the handful of leaders and scientists for ground recon instead of whacking all the citizens. Take out the missiles first. Most of the military and religious leaders are under ground. Take out those underground complexes and Iran is yours.

[1] - https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/2/28/us-and-israel-attac...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by YZF on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:50PM (#47200078)
I wouldn't trust Al Jazeera here (or anywhere else) but "hitting all cities" doesn't really say much. If the attacks are going after the IRGC and the Basij then presumably you need to go after them fairly broadly. If the attacks are going at ballistic missiles and drones the same applied. The question is what are the targets and what's the plan. I'm sure they're going after those complexes as well.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by arunabha on Saturday February 28, 2026 @03:53PM (#47200110)
> Take out those underground complexes and Iran is yours.

And how exactly would Iran be 'ours' without boots on the ground in this scenario?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Bender on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:28PM (#47201643)
Yes just like all the other places we have to maintain control congress would have to authorize boots on the ground, quite possibly for many years. Otherwise some other zealots just fill the voids.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by franktankbank on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:07AM (#47195550)
Won't there be boots on the ground? We already bombed their facilities and at the time they said best that bombs can do is fuck up the entrance to these tunnels.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Braxton1980 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:14AM (#47195618)
Based on previous American wars in the middle east wouldn't you say that's unlikely?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jari_mustonen on Saturday February 28, 2026 @09:16AM (#47195642)
There is nothing ideal about that outcome. The "regime change" people talk about is intended to look like what happened in Libya: A failed state that falls in anarchy.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:01AM (#47196109)
> look like what happened in Libya: A failed state that falls in anarchy.

This comment just shows that you have no idea what Iran is, and how it differs from Libya.

Libya is a loose conglomerate of tribes. Iran majorly Persian that see themselves as one nation. Completely different dynamics.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thisislife2 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:21PM (#47198544)
It doesn't matter - when a strong and stable political structures suddenly collapse, the state fails and disintegrates due to the political infighting. While I agree with you that the chances of Iran becoming a completely failed state is unlikely, I do see an imminent civil war in Iran's future if a regime collapse happens, and the Americans and Israelis install their Shahi (royal) puppet there. A regime collapse will of course mean Iran will lose its sovereignty (probably for a decade or more), till a truly independent stable polity emerges form the ashes.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by enraged_camel on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:35PM (#47198687)
Iranian regime is neither strong nor stable though. Or did you miss the recent round of nationwide protests that led to a desperate brutal crackdown?
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by thisislife2 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:53PM (#47198868)
That's just simplistic western propaganda. Sporadic protests, nationwide or otherwise, don't mean anything unless they are backed by long-term-opposition with strong grass-roots and singular political goals. Iran's regime remains strong and stable - it controls all the political institutions, it controls the civilian government at the local level, it controls the religious / cultural institutions, it controls the military and it has substantial support from the people. Why do you think Israel or the US isn't sending boots to the ground? Apart from the official military, the IRGC has a voluntary civil force, that can be armed by the Iranian military, in every district - if Israel or US send their soldiers to Iran, they will face a very brutal urban warfare with a high death toll.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Jensson on Saturday February 28, 2026 @08:40PM (#47202713)
All of that was true for Japan as well but it went very well there, so your analysis is flawed. The more organized a country is the easier it is to change it, the more primitive the harder it is.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by reliabilityguy on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:26PM (#47203370)
> Iran's regime remains strong and stable - it controls all the political institutions, it controls the civilian government at the local level, it controls the religious / cultural institutions, it controls the military and it has substantial support from the people.

I see two issues with this assessment. First, I am not sure how substantial is the support from the people. And second, Assad also had all this control over the military, the local governments, etc., etc., and then his rule collapsed in a week.

While Islamic Republic's repressive machine in the form of IRCG and Basij are in much better shape than Assad's, it is not that great if they had to bus in Iraqi militias to help with the suppression of protests.

I do agree that it is not clear if there are viable opposition figures inside Iran, on the other hand it is naive to expect it to be the case given the tight grip IR had on the country.

I guess we can hope that all this war is not for nothing.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by littlexsparkee on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:30PM (#47201667)
I could see the water crisis, notably absent here, being what tips it. Iran is facing water bankruptcy and acquifers / groundwater recharge takes decades to centuries.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by root_axis on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:53PM (#47203513)
> Iran majorly Persian that see themselves as one nation

This reductionist narrative is absolutely ridiculous and does not at all reflect reality.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sudo-umar on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @08:32AM (#47247152)
You dont understand Iran either then
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by markus_zhang on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:05AM (#47196161)
You can’t be short, minimal lethal AND regime change. Gotta be pretty bloody to make that happen.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tim333 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @10:31AM (#47196460)
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tokai on Saturday February 28, 2026 @12:36PM (#47198009)
Nothing even close to regime change happened in Venezuela.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by BurningFrog on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:39PM (#47200567)
It's the same regime, but they now take orders from Marco Rubio.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jasomill on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:45PM (#47201821)
Fomenting a coup is very different than toppling a regime through military force.

My biggest concern has always been that US military action against Iran would undermine domestic factions pushing for democratic reforms, at best leading to the installation of a different autocratic regime more amenable to US interests, at worst leading to a wellspring of support for the existing regime both internally, and externally in the form of alliances with other nations who stand to benefit from a reshuffling of the existing world order.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by alex43578 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:57PM (#47201918)
"At best leading to the installation of a different autocratic regime more amenable to US interests" seems like a pretty fine outcome in US eyes, doesn't it? Outside of Israel, is democracy in the Middle East even realistic?

An autocrat regime friendly to US interests, who we could do business with, who won't pursue nuclear weapons, and who won't imperil US allies or the Strait of Hormuz would be a drastic improvement over the current state of affairs.

We don't need to nation-build to have a good outcome for the US: that's something we should've learned after Iraq and Afghanistan.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by jasomill on Sunday March 01, 2026 @02:12AM (#47204422)
Sure, and probably no worse for the world at large, or for the majority of Iranians.

An improvement over the current regime isn't exactly a high bar.

Even speaking as a someone who generally detests the policies of both Trump and the current Israeli administration, while I don't expect the entirety of the IRGC to go quietly into the night, I can't help but see the removal of the Ayatollah as a good thing.

As for the broader question of democracy in the Middle East, I believe the answer is yes, though not quickly or easily. But an independent, democratic Iran coexisting peacefully with Israel and the US, however unlikely, would certainly be a good start.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by rambojohnson on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:26AM (#47197173)
u sweet summer child.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by plaidfuji on Saturday February 28, 2026 @01:58PM (#47198916)
> Minimally lethal

“Israel strikes two schools in Iran, killing more than 80 people”

https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2026/2/28/israel-strikes-...

Welp, better luck next time

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @02:11PM (#47199047)
This reminds me of the Al-Ahli hospital incident in Gaza, when a mysterious explosion at a hospital was immediately blamed on an Iraeli strike - first by Hamas, then by the international press. A precise death toll was immediately available: 500 killed. Israel urged caution as they investigated, but were ignored.

Eventually, it was established that 1) the casualty number had been a fabrication, 2) the explosion was in the parking lot, 3) it was NOT caused by an Israeli strike, but by a Palestinian Islamic Jihad rocket that had fell short.

Soon the press was forced to issue corrections - New York Times [1] , Le Monde [2], BBC [3]...

This incident looks VERY similar. Which is not surprising, since Hamas was trained in information warfare by the IRGC. Note that Al Jazeera (the media arm of Qatar, who funds Hamas and hosts their leaders in Doha) is enthusiastically amplifying this story with no apparent effort to cross-examine Iran's official source.

I predict that this story will turn out to be fabricated as well.

UPDATE: preliminary reports from the OSINT community seem to indicate that the story was indeed a fabrication... https://x.com/tarikh_eran/status/2027784301840846939

[1] https://www.poynter.org/commentary/2023/the-new-york-times-e...

[2] https://www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2023/10/24/a-no...

[3] https://deadline.com/2023/11/bbcs-international-editor-grill...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by I-M-S on Saturday February 28, 2026 @04:43PM (#47200602)
What the comment fails to mention is that Al-Shifa hospital was ultimately destroyed by Israeli forces, with grave civilian casualties, and no Hamas tunnels ever found: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Shifa_Hospital
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Sabinus on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:09PM (#47201457)
The Wikipedia article you link says that Hamas tunnels were found under the hospital, and did have entrances near the hospital, but that no proof was provided that they were using the hospital and nearby tunnels as a 'command and control' centre.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by shykes on Saturday February 28, 2026 @11:01PM (#47203564)
My comment is about Al-Ahli, not Al-Shifa. Those are two different hospitals.

> Al-Shifa hospital was ultimately destroyed by Israeli forces

It was damaged by a series of battles between Hamas and IDF, because Hamas militants embedded themselves within it - like they embedded themselves within all civilian infrastructure. That is the reality of urban war against a terrorist group.

> with grave civilian casualties

Hamas alleged grave civilian casualties. Israel contests it. Again, just like the Al-Ahli incident, Hamas rushes to publish suspiciously precise casualties and reframes an urban battle as a genocidal massacre; naive newsrooms uncritically publish it; wikipedia editors quotes it; then people with an axe to grind endlessly reference it in online arguments like this one.

With Al-Ahli, we got lucky. Independent evidence made it impossible to ignore that Hamas was lying. In many other cases, it is impossible to independently verify how many civilians were truly killed in this or that battle. You have to either believe the IDF, or Hamas.

> and no Hamas tunnels ever found

Al-Shifa was controlled by Hamas and used as a military facility. Hostages were held there. After the ceasefire, Hamas used it as a jail and torture center for Palestinian dissidents.

Or do you believe Israel sent troops inside a hospital in a warzone, at great risk to their safety, to destroy a random hospital with no military value?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by tovej on Sunday March 01, 2026 @02:56AM (#47204661)
The Palestinian rocket story was never confirmed, and it seems unlikely that the rockets from PIJ were the cause. Their ballistic trajectory did not match with the hospital, and most or all their fuel had burned [1]. I recommend you read the whole text, it's quite short.

In other words, the new "established facts" about Al-Ahli are also questionable, and part of Israeli propaganda. It remains to be seen what the truth is in either case.

The fact of the matter is. Eventually Israel destroyed a fuckton of hospitals and schools in Palestine, on purpose. So this particular story in itself does not really matter.

[1] https://forensic-architecture.org/investigation/israeli-disi...

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by plaidfuji on Monday March 02, 2026 @09:24PM (#47227137)
> Analysis of the area shows the school is in a middle of a military area full of IRGC bases.

Isn’t the far more likely explanation here that they (Israel / US) tried to strike an IRGC base and missed?

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by sschueller on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:02PM (#47201371)
There is no such thing but I guess the US still has not learned this after so many conflicts.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by steve-atx-7600 on Saturday February 28, 2026 @06:52PM (#47201891)
Regime change is not the same thing as a "forever war". I don't think you read the post that you replied to.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by Aeolun on Sunday March 01, 2026 @01:57AM (#47204357)
> minimally lethal

The US and Israel are involved. The only way it’s going to turn out is maximally lethal to all those not involved at all.

See… basically any military operation participated in by those nations in recent history.

We got a couple strikes and already managed to hit an elementary school. Nothing I’ve seen in Gaza or Iraq leads me to believe this will be any different.

Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by throw102225 on Sunday March 01, 2026 @04:55AM (#47205268)
See Israel’s take down of Hezbollah.
Re:Israel launches strike against Iran, declares state of em... by cman1444 on Monday March 02, 2026 @02:37PM (#47222997)
Wouldn't you consider the Maduro capture a minimally lethal operation?