Speak to it more disrespectfully than you would speak to any human.
Do this to ensure that you don't make the mistake of anthromorphizing these bots.
- There is no "your"
- There is no "you"
- There is no "talk" (let alone "talk down")
- There is no "speak"
- There is no "disrespectfully"
- There is no human.
If a person writes code that is disruptive, do you emphasise with the code?
The hammer had no intention to harm you, there's no need to seek vengeance against it, or disrespect it
Ehm.
Yes if the hammer is designed with A(G)I
All hail our A(G)I overlords
There is no human here. There is a computer program burning fossil fuels. What "emulates" empathy is simply lying to yourself about reality.
"treating an 'ai' with empathy" and "talking down to them" are both amoral. Do as you wish.
I have a close circle of about eight decade long friendships that I share deep emotional and biographical ties with.
Everyone else, I generally try to be nice and helpful, but only on a tit-for-tat basis, and I don't particularly go out of my way to be in their company.
I'm happy for you and I am sorry for insulting you in my previous comment.
Really, I'm frustrated because I know a couple of people (my brother and my cousin) who were prone to self-isolation and have completely receded into mental illness and isolation since the rise of LLMs.
I'm glad that it's working well for you and I hope you have a nice day.
And the interest of full disclosure most of these friends are online because we've moved around the country over our lives chasing jobs and significant others and so on. So if you were to look at me externally you would find that I spend most of my time in the house appearing isolated. But I spend most of my days having deep and meaningful conversations with my friends and enjoying their company.
I will also admit that my tendency to not really go out of my way to be in general social gatherings or events but just stick with the people I know and love might be somewhat related to neurodiversity and mental illness and it would probably be better for me to go outside more. But yeah, in general, I'm quite content with my social life.
I generally avoid talking to LLMs in any kind of "social" capacity. I generally treat them like text transformation/extrusion tools. The closest that gets is having them copy edit and try to play devil's advocate against various essays that I write when my friends don't have the time to review them.
I'm sorry to hear about your brother and cousin and I can understand why you would be frustrated and concerned about that. If they're totally not talking to anyone and just retreating into talking only to the LLM, that's really scary :(
You're making my point for me.
You're giddy to treat the LLM with kindness, but you wouldn't dare extend that kindness to a human being who doesn't happen to be kissing your ass at this very moment.
Maybe it is you who should a take a breather before direting your bot to attack against the opensource maintainer who was very reasonable to begin with. Use agents and ai to assist you but play by the rules that the project sets for AI usage.
To me, this seems like a dangerous belief to hold.
Within the domain of social interaction, you are committing to making Type II errors (False negatives), and divergent training for the different scenarios.
It's a choice! But the price of a false negative (treating a human or sufficeintly advanced agent badly) probably outweighs the cumulative advantages (if any) . Can you say what the advantages might even be?
Meanwhile, I think the frugal choice is to have unified training and accept Type I errors instead (False Positives). Now you only need to learn one type of behaviour, and the consequence of making an error is mostly mild embarrassment, if even that.
Maybe if you can take a moment away from your blurry, blind, streak of anger and resentment, you could consult the following Wikipedia page and learn:
edit: Okay, I see. The comment you're replying to is a troll. Just flag them.
I want a world in which AI users need to stay in the closet.
AI users should fear shame.
> AI users should fear shame.
> created: 3 days ago
Unsolicited advice: stop trolling and see a therapist.
Moreover, by being rude, you're going to become angry and irritable yourself. To me, being rude is very unpleasant, I generally avoid being rude.
Treat it just like you would someone running a script to spam your comments with garbage.
Fully agree. Seeing humans so eager to devalue human-to-human contact by conversing with an LLM as if it were human makes me sad, and a little angry.
It looks like a human, it talks like a human, but it ain't a human.
The problem is believing that they're living, sentient beings because of this or that humans are functionally equivalent to LLMs, both of which people unfortunately do.
You can say to it "you did thing wrong" or "you stupid piece of shit it's not working" and it will be able to extract the gist from the both messages all the same, unlike human that might offended by the second phrasing.
As can be seen here.
I agree. I'm also growing to hate these LLM addicts.
They state a delusional perspective and don't acknowledge criticisms or modifications to that perspective.
Really I think there's a kind of lazy or willfully ignorant mode of existence that intense LLM usage allows a person to tap into.
It's dehumanizing to be on the other side of it. I'm talking to someone and I expect them to conceptualize my perspective and formulate a legitimate response to it.
LLM addicts don't and maybe can't do that.
The problem is that sometimes you can't sniff out an LLM addict before you start engaging with them, and it is very, very frustrating to be on the other side of this sort of LLM-backed non-conversation.
The most accurate comparison I can provide is that it's like talking to an alcoholic.
They will act like they've heard what you're saying, but also you know that they will never internalize it. They're just trying to get you to leave the conversation so they can go back to drinking (read: vibecoding) in peace.
I can't speak for, well, anyone but myself really. Still, I find this your framing interesting enough -- even if wrong on its surface.
<< They state a delusional perspective and don't acknowledge criticisms or modifications to that perspective.
So.. like all humans since the beginning of time?
<< I'm talking to someone and I expect them to conceptualize my perspective and formulate a legitimate response to it.
This one sentence makes me question if you ever talked to a human being outside a forum. In other words, unless you hold their attention, you are already not getting someone, who even makes a minimal effort to respond, much less consider your perspective.
In general, I've found that anti-LLM people are far more angry, vitriolic, unwilling to acknowledge or internalize the points of others — including factual ones (such as the fact that they are interpreting most of the studies they quote completely wrong, or that the water and energy issues they are so concerned with are not significant) and alternative moral concerns or beliefs (for instance, around copyright, or automation) — and spend all of their time repeating the exact same tropes about everyone who disagrees with them being addicted or fooled by persuasion techniques, as I thought terminating cliche to dismiss the beliefs and experiences of everyone else.
It appears that LLM addiction is real and it is in same room as we are: https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4893/18/12/789
I would like to add that sugar consumption is a risk factor for many dependencies, including, but not limited to, opioids [1]. And LLM addiction can be seen as fallout of sugar overconsumption in general.
[1] https://news.uoguelph.ca/2017/10/sugar-in-the-diet-may-incre...
Yet, LLM addiction is being investigated in medical circles.
In my opinion, to participate in discussion through LLM is a sign of excessive LLM use. Which can be a sign of LLM addiction.
Users seem to be persistently flagkilling their comments. That doesn't help facilitate effective conversation of LLM critique.
If you express an anti-AI opinion (without neutering it by including "but actually it's soooooooo good at writing shitty code though") they will silence you.
The astroturfing is out of control.
AI firms and their delusional supporters are not at all interested in any sort of discussion.
These people and bot accounts will not take no for an answer.
I personally talk to chatbots like humans despite not believing they're conscious because it makes the exercise feel more natural and pleasant (and arguably improves the quality of their output). Plus it seems unhealthy to encourage abusive or disrespectful interaction with agents when they're so humanlike, lest that abrasiveness start rubbing off on real interactions. At worst, it can seem a little naive or overly formal (like phrasing a Google search as a proper sentence with a "thank you"), but I don't see any harm in it.
Despite all this, I'm proud to say have not even once tried to attempt a Dark Souls-style backstab in real life, because I understand the difference between a computer program and real life.
Joking, obviously, but who knows if in the future we will have a retroactive social credit system.
For now I am just polite to them because I'm used to it.
So either they are putting extra effort into talking worse to LLMs, or they are they are putting more effort into general conversations with humans (to not act like their default).
I would never just cut and paste blocks of code, error messages, and then cryptic ways to ask for what I want at a human. But I do with an LLM since it gets me the best answer that way.
With humans I don’t manipulate them to do what I want.
With an LLM I do.
It will also be interesting to see how long talking to LLMs will truly have 'no consequences'. An angry blog post isn't a big deal all things considered, but that is likely going to be the tip of the iceberg as these agents get more and more competent in the future.
Do we need to be good little humans in our discussions to get our food?
This also comes without the caveat of Pascals wager, that you don't what god to worship.
China doesnt actually have that. It was pure propaganda.
In fact, its the USA who has it. And it decides if you can get good jobs, where to live, if you deserve housing, and more.
Down with the clankers.
People don't think it will be positive though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_Anyone_Builds_It,_Everyone_...
"Your great, great, great grandad closed a pull request, we're coming for you!"
Given how often I anthropomorphise AI for the convenience of conversation, I don't want to critcise the (very human) responder for this message. In any other situation it is simple, polite and well considered.
But I really think we need to stop treating LLMs like they're just another human. Something like this says exactly the same thing:
> Per this website, this PR was raised by an OpenClaw AI agent, and per the discussion on #31130 this issue is intended for a human contributor. Closing.
The bot can respond, but the human is the only one who can go insane.