News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leakycap on Friday October 10, 2025 @12:22PM (#45540677)
All this so a handful of passengers a week can wait for the extremely small pool of vehicles in a dusty hole
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by daemonologist on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:51PM (#45541775)
There was a CityNerd video (which you may take or leave in general, but I found the anecdote interesting) in which there appeared to be one vehicle in service on the entire system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VPjODKUxV5g

I assume though that they would adjust the capacity depending on time of day and whether there's an event or something going on, to some degree.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by themafia on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:27PM (#45542773)
> adjust the capacity

It's a single lane tunnel and is thus one way. The parking are can only hold so many waiting vehicles and queued passengers. Their options for adjusting capacity are severely limited.

Then you consider what might happen if the lead vehicle in a convoy becomes disabled, or worse, starts on fire.

It's the same reason planes are safer per "passenger mile traveled" but aren't as safe per "total journeys taken." If you crash a plane you stand to injure or kill hundreds of passengers at once.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by 1718627440 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @06:45AM (#45548071)
> It's a single lane tunnel and is thus one way.

Maybe they should have asked some railway engineers. Also why throw away the benefits of cars over railway when you inherit non of the benefits.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by tallowen on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:07PM (#45541962)
Thanks for sharing this, I had understood prior to this video that the combo of self driving tech + dedicated tunnels might have capacity that rival a light rail system like Seattle has but that's clearly not the case in the current system. I'm curious why more of the autonomous driving tech isn't being used in what I might have thought would be an "easier" place to do it.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by everforward on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:04PM (#45543165)
> I'm curious why more of the autonomous driving tech isn't being used in what I might have thought would be an "easier" place to do it.

There's no real need in a static environment, and much simpler ways to do it. Children's toys can follow a line painted on something; they just need proximity sensors and a basic signalling system (RF or also painted on the road) for where to stop and done.

There's no real need for the car to "see" beyond "am I going to run into something" and they operate at speeds where stopping is very feasible.

They're also a bad rival for light rail because they already have to dig a tunnel and the conveyance operates on a fixed path. They picked a domain that light rail is already incredibly good and efficient at.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Veserv on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:01PM (#45543142)
If they have autonomous driving technology that works for “harder” problems, then why do they not use it for “easier” problems? You answered your own question; it does not work safely for those “harder” problems.

Zoox has permits to operate autonomously on Las Vegas streets. Tesla is unable to get permits to operate autonomously on isolated, one-lane, one-way streets with no pedestrians, cross-traffic, or even vehicles not under their control. That should tell you everything you need to know about how far reality is away from their corporate puffery.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by jcotton42 on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:40PM (#45542917)
> had understood prior to this video that the combo of self driving tech + dedicated tunnels might have capacity that rival a light rail system like Seattle has but that's clearly not the case in the current system

Not to disparage, but how did you come to that conclusion? A train will always be able to fit more people/m^2 than several cars of equivalent length, due to things like ability to stand, not needing to have multiple engines and trunks, etc.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by tallowen on Saturday October 11, 2025 @11:28AM (#45549894)
> Not to disparage, but how did you come to that conclusion?

I did some math and you're clearly right. I think I imagined that with driver-less vehicles leaving much more frequently (10s per minute) one could catch up to the capacity of a small light rail system but that's clearly not the case. I had imagined that _maybe_ it could be an approach for a lower capacity system in the future.

My math as someone who is not knowledgeable in how to get this data is as follows:

In Seattle is running 4 car trains at 8 minute headways at peak which works out to 7500 people per hour at crush load (4 cars, 250 people per car, 7.5 times per hour). This would require 125 vehicles with 5 seats leaving every minute which is clearly impossible.

Looking at Portland's MAX, it looks like they often run 2 car service with 160 passengers of capacity each with service every 15 minutes so 1280 people per hour (2 cars, 160 per car, 4 services per hour).

1280 people per hour could be served by a 5 seat vehicle leaving every ~15 seconds. This I suppose is what I had expected would happen when I tried to imagine the best case scenario for this service.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by zimpenfish on Sunday October 19, 2025 @07:37AM (#45633506)
> In Seattle is running 4 car trains at 8 minute headways at peak which works out to 7500 people per hour at crush load (4 cars, 250 people per car, 7.5 times per hour). This would require 125 vehicles with 5 seats leaving every minute which is clearly impossible.

7500 isn't that high - the Manchester Metrolink did 46M user journeys in year ending March 2025 (~5250/hour assuming 24/7 which it isn't.) Docklands Light Railway did 97.8M (~11000/hour ass.24/7)

Numbers from https://www.gov.uk/government/statistical-data-sets/light-ra...

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:52PM (#45542411)
They come to the surface to switch tunnels and Tesla FSD is not a viable technology for automated driving beyond a sunny highway.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by duxup on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:21PM (#45542717)
It's hilarious how the quality of stops just degrades until you just get a typical car taxi pickup spot ...
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by antonvs on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:39PM (#45542299)
> there appeared to be one vehicle in service on the entire system

I watched that video the other day, pretty sure it didn’t say that. What it did point out though is that in most of the system, other than the one main line, there’s just one single-lane tunnel so that when a car is in a tunnel going one way, cars going the other direction have to wait to enter the tunnel until the tunnel is clear.

The title of the video seems pretty accurate: “The Vegas Loop Is Getting Progressively More Stupid.”

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Calavar on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:21PM (#45542715)
He does say that around 5:32 in the video. He says his driver told him there were two cars on the loop that day, and the other car wasn't in service because it was being used for training.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by duxup on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:22PM (#45542723)
When he rode his driver told him there should be two cars operating at a time but one was training and couldn't take riders, so there was just one car running.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by kstrauser on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:38PM (#45542279)
When we were in Vegas for Def Con, one of the tube stations was next to one of the Las Vegas Convention Center entrances. I'd occasionally hang out there with friends, and once every half an hour or so, we'd see a lonely Tesla weave through the traffic cone path and disappear into the nethers.

Based purely on my own observations, I'd guesstimate that station sees about 50-75 cars per day.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by stogot on Sunday October 12, 2025 @05:01AM (#45556634)
What does this cost to use?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by cedws on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:48PM (#45542377)
I just hope there is never a battery fire down there, because there appears to be no evacuation tunnel or safety procedures. I don't think you can even get the car doors open in the tunnel.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by cryzinger on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:52PM (#45542417)
Or a flash flood. The only other tunnels we have here in Vegas are storm drains, and for good reason.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by lo0dot0 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @08:11AM (#45548536)
Do the cars not have a trunk door on the back?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by EA-3167 on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:16PM (#45542665)
More accurately all this so Elon Musk could keep peddling the lie that boreholes and cars are the future of public transit. What’s a little fraud and environmental harm compared to such a lofty goal?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by paulsutter on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:33PM (#45542829)
If you’re curious, this is a demo/experiment. The long term goal is tunnels so inexpensive that they can go 30 levels deep, letting us travel within cities at 200kph with no stop signs (even eliminate automobiles from the surface of cities)

This will require considerable progress in tunneling r&d, which is their primary activity

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dzhiurgis on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:39PM (#45542909)
IMHO Tunnels for bicycles make a ton of sense - similarly to EVs low ventilation requirements, small diameter means cheaper build and most importantly protects you from weather elements.

Takes most of the biking joy away tho.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by lo0dot0 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @08:06AM (#45548516)
Tunnels can recoup their cost easily if they are used massively by many people every day. Any reason why you are against building a subway / underground railway?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:39PM (#45541618)
Have you ridden the existing Vegas tunnel?

Tens of thousands of riders when I was there and not a spec of dirt. Very far from perfect, but a long way from useless.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by AgentK20 on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:44PM (#45541699)
There were tens of thousands of riders _when you were there?_ Or there were tens of thousands of riders over the lifetime of the system?

Most videos I've seen recently show a system that, while functional, typically only has a handful of vehicles running simultaneously, each with carrying capacity for one party of up to 3 people.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:23PM (#45543364)
When I was there. During SEMA, the worlds biggest automotive show.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Moomoomoo309 on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:47PM (#45541734)
Tens of thousands of riders in what time period? Please, look up how many people it is capable of moving per hour, and compare that to any light rail or street car service in any city. There is no way the loop makes sense to build.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by chrisfosterelli on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:44PM (#45542331)
> Please, look up how many people it is capable of moving per hour, and compare that to any light rail or street car service in any city.

I have a hard time understanding this criticism. Why not do both?

It seems to me like underground highways make sense as an alternative to above ground highways in urban areas, not that they're an alternative to rail. There's lots of cities with excellent public transport that also make use of underground car travel (Melbourne for e.g.). If a company can figure out how to (safely) make underground highways more quickly and more affordably, it seems like that means we may need to do above-ground roads less frequently -- why would that not be a good thing?

Further, obviously Musk has a PR angle in facilitating tesla traffic here as the test bed in early days, but I don't see any reason that this couldn't be repurposed to rail use at scale.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by everforward on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:12PM (#45543266)
In urban areas, they're usually an alternative. If you're going past the city, you could build a ground level highway around the city for a lot cheaper. If you're going into the city, it makes more economic sense to leave your car at the periphery of the city and take a rail system in because of the difference in throughput per $ spent building it (as well as the space occupied by parking for people who need to leave their cars in the city). Plus the people leaving the highway will get onto surface streets, and back up the highway.

Being able to make underground tunnels cheaper and faster is cool. Using them for cars is mostly a boondoggle with clearly superior alternatives.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by chrisfosterelli on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:44PM (#45543587)
I think that's reasonable. I suppose I also think it idealist that cities will actually act that way in practice in the short term. I'm specifically thinking of examples like the Corniche highway in Alexandria or Marine drive in Mumbai which shows cities are willing to give up gorgeous public space throughout incredibly dense areas to support car traffic. But there's also examples like Boston's "big dig" which shows cities are willing to spend extra to move those auto pathways underground. At least in the short term it seems that 1) cities aren't giving up entirely on cars, but 2) are willing to pay more to have them underground.

I suspect in practice the actual approach is going to be a mix of all of the above. So my reasoning is primarily that if all cities won't give up cars anyway, it seems objectively better to make it easier to at least move more of them underground. I suppose one case where I would change my mind is if there was evidence that more affordable underground roads reduced the investment in public transit.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by everforward on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:43PM (#45545388)
> I suppose one case where I would change my mind is if there was evidence that more affordable underground roads reduced the investment in public transit.

It's Friday night so I lack the motivation to go on a stats-finding expedition, but anecdotally this seems like a circular issue to me. Public transportation sucks, so no one wants to fund it and we invest money into car infrastructure. Traffic gets worse, but public transportation is still bad because we haven't improved it, so we dump more money into car infrastructure, and etc.

I do hear you about the practical realities, though. Most people will drive if they can, because it is more convenient (so long as we can keep building more roads, even at exorbitant prices).

I think there would be far less support if people could see what they're actually spending on car infrastructure. At least in the US, it's currently so fractured it's hard to get an idea. Registration fees, gas taxes, federal taxes that get pumped into highway maintenance, etc. There's no clear "we spend $X on car infrastructure, and we could have really good public transportation for $Y".

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:53PM (#45541796)
> Please, look up how many people it is capable of moving per hour

…what is it?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by foxyv on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:56PM (#45541830)
Peak ridership is about 1300/hour. About how many people you can fit in two trams. Or 10 Disneyland people movers.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Retric on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:02PM (#45541901)
That seems high for what it is. Is that hypothetical peak or actually measured capacity?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by foxyv on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:33PM (#45542824)
That is the peak spontaneous ridership per hour. So about 22 people per minute. Probably measured during a convention or something. Most of the time it's probably half of that.

So essentially they made a ride comparable to Space Mountain that takes about 2200 passengers per hour.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dagmx on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:49PM (#45541761)
The LVCC Loop has demonstrated a peak capacity of ~4,400–4,500 passengers per hour in testing.

How did you arrive at tens of thousands of riders?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:25PM (#45543388)
I was at the world’s biggest automotive show. It was packed.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dagmx on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:23PM (#45543936)
So then saying “ Tens of thousands of riders” is a lie since they weren’t actually using the tunnels to ride in at the time.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:29PM (#45543982)
I didn’t say anything like at the same time.

In my week in Vegas for SEMA from 8am to well after dark it was always jam packed. That’s tens of thousands of riders.

What was it like when you rode it?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dagmx on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:35PM (#45544040)
I’m not in LA so I haven’t ridden it but that’s a moot point to the discussion.

Having tens of thousands of drivers over an unspecified time period rather than simultaneously isn’t really a flex imho.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:48PM (#45544180)
I didn’t intend it to be a flex.

I was stating what I saw when I rode it.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by serf on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:07PM (#45544849)
>Tens of thousands of riders

You saw tens of thousands of riders?

That anecdote just doesn't jibe with the throughput numbers -- that's why it seems like a flex, it's grossly inflated.

Now before we go into pedantry and you talk about how 'riders' meant 'all willing participants who are sitting in line' , fine -- i've been to SEMA and I understand those crowds , but those aren't riders. It's a misreporting of the situation, and frankly it seems intentional.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @11:32PM (#45546380)
I did.

I was in and around multiple stations for a week, from early till late, and never saw a single one anything other than packed. Lineups up the turned off escalators topside were extremely common. Many tens of thousands of people were riding.

FWIW I was at the event that caused the worlds biggest event centre (the Vegas convention centre) to expand, because it wasn’t big enough to host the event.

Millions and millions of people in and around the convention centre, all serviced by the loop.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by olyjohn on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:05PM (#45543783)
I didn't realize they could fit tens of thousands of people in the waiting areas. Those stations must really be something to behold.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Veserv on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:22PM (#45543351)
In 2023-03, they did passenger 1,000,000 [1].

In 2024-05, they did passenger 2,000,000 [2].

So 1,000,000 passengers in 14 months or ~420 days. That is a average throughput of ~2,400 passengers per day.

In comparison, the Tokyo Marunouchi line averages ~1,100,000 passengers per day [3]. That is ~420x the rate. Every single day, they do what the Las Vegas Loop does in a year.

The peak capacity that they claim without evidence is ~32,000 in a day [4]. The Maruonouchi line does in a day what the Las Vegas Loop at maximum capacity could theoretically do in a entire month.

[1] https://www.teslarati.com/elon-musk-boring-co-vegas-loop-1-m...

[2] https://www.teslarati.com/boring-company-2-million-passenger...

[3] https://www.japan-experience.com/plan-your-trip/travel-by-tr...

[4] https://www.boringcompany.com/lvcc

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:25PM (#45543383)
You are 100% correct. It’s small fry right now.

You might be shocked to learn the first airplane couldn’t take passengers.

Things improve, or at least attempt to. Even if it fails, I’d rather live in a world where new ideas are being tried and tested and not always talking about how good my horse and cart is.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by AgentK20 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:31PM (#45544001)
I don’t think most people are arguing against the concept, or even implementation, of the system as developed. Obviously it’s both a publicity stunt and beta test as they learn how to build and operate a tunnel system like this. The concern is that much of the environmental harm that’s being done (according to the EPA) is repetitive, and that The Boring Company (TBC) actively pledged to hire an environmental inspector three years ago and is now being fined for having not done so. Given that, who knows how many violations that don’t leave a permanent mark are going unnoticed.

Do you think that they are going to ignore environmental laws for JUST this project, or do you think that is their modus operandi? I’d be happy to have a tunnel system installed near my home, even if there’s temporary disruption during the construction process. What I wouldn’t tolerate is active, and unmonitored (by TBC’s insistence on “self-monitoring”), pollution occurring near my home. Fines only cover so much, and un-polluting something after the fact costs far more than the fines that are being levied and, when it comes to pollutants that harm humans (like improper disposal of chemicals from digging, as they have been fined for), you can’t just “undo” the human harm with a fine.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by terminalshort on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:52PM (#45544209)
What I think is that environmental review rules are so convoluted that almost any project you would investigate breaks plenty of them. I also don't trust the definition of "environmental" when it comes to environmental regulations. When you hear "environmental" you think dumping toxic chemicals, but in reality environmental reviews have components like a building casting a shadow on a playground for 1 hour a day. And on top of that I don't trust journalists for counts of number of violations. In this case they get to 800 by counting one real violation 700 times:

> The letter also accuses the company of failing to hire an independent environmental manager to regularly inspect its construction sites. State regulators counted 689 missed inspections.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by 1718627440 on Saturday October 11, 2025 @07:01AM (#45548152)
> as they learn how to build and operate a tunnel system like this.

Yes, why do they even do that. Not that they are never any improvements, but this pretty much a solved problem. They have a stupid amount of NIH syndrome, but apply that to the physical world and that always results in fatalities.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Veserv on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:32PM (#45544012)
I would rather live in a world where you do not get to cause hundreds of times more environmental violations than others just because you imagine your new horse and cart idea is way better than cars.

You can, in fact, not discharge your sewage and contaminated water into public spaces even if you are trying something new. What a concept.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:15PM (#45544451)
At no point did I suggest anything like that.

Clearly they broke the law, and will be punished for it as the law demands. Good.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by mschuster91 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:16PM (#45543885)
There's that, but attempting to run around regulations despite numerous violations just doesn't fly either.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:27PM (#45543967)
And they will be punished for it, exactly as defined by the law.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by mschuster91 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:35PM (#45544047)
A fine that isn't based on income isn't a fine, it's a cost of doing business at the expense of workers, the environment and society at large. 242k, that's peanuts for someone with Musk level wealth.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by testing22321 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:47PM (#45544170)
So you’re angry that fines are not based on income?

What are you doing to fix that?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by rainsford on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:51PM (#45545449)
But it's not really a new idea. Vehicles transporting people through tunnels is something we already know how to do and we have many examples going back decades that are more efficient and higher volume.

This isn't some new early stage innovation that can grow into a great new thing, it's a shittier version of something we already have.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by paulddraper on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:17PM (#45543891)
> Every single day, they do what the Las Vegas Loop does in a year.

Tokyo Marunouchi is a multi-branch line totaling 17 miles; the Las Vegas Loop is a (not yet complete) single tunnel just one-tenth that distance.

This is a strange comparison.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by scienceman on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:47AM (#45546649)
Yamanote line is a single line and does around 5 million every day.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:41PM (#45541653)
It is sad to me to see this website attract users who are so anti-progress and anti-technology.

Imagine framing up all technological innovation this way.

"All this so you can take slightly sharper pictures of your children."

"All this so a few people can go to space."

"All this so a screen be a little brighter."

Lots and lots of little things add up over time to make big technology gains. It is cool to companies like Boring trying shit in the real world.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by enaaem on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:59PM (#45541866)
Indeed! I think the Vegas loop has immense potential. There are many ways we can iterate on this concept. Perhaps we can use bigger cars, in a bus like shape to transport more people at once. Or we could remove the batteries to save cost and weight and supply the cars with an external power source. There is immense potential here and I believe this will revolutionise transport.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:02PM (#45541897)
The Boring Company’s mission is in its name. Better boring tools. The Teslas running around inside it are dumb, but that’s almost the point: it’s a PR project. We wouldn’t be talking about it if it were a train.

From what I can tell, TBC has failed to revolutionize tunnel-boring machines to date.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by preisschild on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:47PM (#45542368)
But that just shows they didnt really do anything. While european and other companies are building extremely long rail tunnels, this company built a short single-lane car tunnel with LEDs...
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by antonvs on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:50PM (#45542393)
> From what I can tell, TBC has failed to revolutionize tunnel-boring machines to date.

Also, if you look at those Vegas tunnels, they’re just wide enough for a single car. Every single subway system in the world has better tunnels than that, and many of them have existed for well over a century.

The BC “mission” seems to be marketing hype that’s not quite as bad as “Mars colony”, but it’s still very far in the future at best.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by s1artibartfast on Friday October 10, 2025 @08:18PM (#45545263)
Cost. The boring tunnels are basically free to the city. Just permission to build. Look up SF or NYC or Seattle cost per tunnel mile.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by antonvs on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:06AM (#45555404)
That's just financial structuring. The tunnels still have a cost to build, which I'm guessing is unknown since BC is private. It's received on the order of a $1 billion in funding, though, which might give some idea of just how much those tunnels cost.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by s1artibartfast on Sunday October 12, 2025 @01:39PM (#45560106)
Cost to the customer is not just financial structuring. It is how much you have to pay.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by EasyMark on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:32PM (#45544013)
That's what I thought too. Boring equipment that could dig tunnels for extremely cheap. Don't know the current status, but I didn't think it was set up like picturing set of interconnected tubes like, for instance, the interwebs.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by atlantic on Friday October 10, 2025 @06:30PM (#45544578)
How did you reach the conclusion that it is a PR project? Since Elon Musk is pushing ahead to colonize Mars - and Martian cities will probably be built underground - it is just as likely that he is using this company to develop one of the critical technologies for interplanetary expansion.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dzhiurgis on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:43PM (#45542952)
Batteries are far cheaper than tram lines.

You need to free yourself from the agenda.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by olyjohn on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:13PM (#45543850)
Tram lines are far cheaper than having miles and miles of tunnels in a vacuum.

Actual trains can be loaded and unloaded faster, and don't need one driver for every 4 people. In fact, trains have been automated with no drivers for well over 50 years in many parts of the world.

These cars, despite being on an extremely limited access roadway, still can't be trusted to drive themselves. They are literally in the most ideal environment for self-driving. This should be the first place they have self-driving cars.

You need to free yourself from being such a fanboy.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dzhiurgis on Friday October 10, 2025 @07:24PM (#45544953)
Shifting goalposts.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by LargoLasskhyfv on Saturday October 11, 2025 @12:49AM (#45546660)
Tram lines can have battery powered rolling stock, too. With supercharging at the endpoints, and/or topping up at some stations in between.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by enaaem on Saturday October 11, 2025 @05:17AM (#45547723)
How are batteries cheaper then... no batteries at all? Since the routes are fixed anyway you can attach a cable to the sealing of the tunnel and connect it to the Teslas. You can then drive the Teslas around like slot cars. Requires no charging, weight reduction, no battery degradation and no energy conversion loss.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dzhiurgis on Saturday October 11, 2025 @06:47AM (#45548077)
Tramway lines are extremely expensive. Batteries are dirt cheap. Is that so hard to grasp?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by enaaem on Saturday October 11, 2025 @08:05AM (#45548507)
Why are you so anti-innovation? So anti-progress? There is no reason why the slot car concept cant work. Just plug the car to a long cable. I call it the hyperslot.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:12PM (#45542005)
Cool, who is building this in America? Anyone? Is there a single new subway system being built anywhere? If not, why?

I hate this "if you're not doing the perfect thing don't do anything at all" mindset of the degrowth group.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by mikestew on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:54PM (#45542435)
It's not about building the perfect thing, it's about not building the dumb thing that blocks discussion of building something that will actually work. What's currently built is not even workable, IMO, let alone anywhere near perfect.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by taco_emoji on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:38PM (#45542277)
Just because Musk is doing something new in this space does not mean it represents progress.

> I hate this "if you're not doing the perfect thing don't do anything at all" mindset of the degrowth group.

800 environmental violations would suggest it's a little bit worse than "imperfect"

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by myko on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:23PM (#45542728)
Interestingly one of the reasons some areas _aren't_ building these out is because of the promises Musk made re: the Hyperloop system, they felt it would be better to wait and see.

Freezing actual good mass transit progress seems to have been his goal, unfortunately.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by preisschild on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:48PM (#45542373)
Didn't Musk explicitly make up the hyperloop concept, just so that CAHSR doesn't get built?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by wahnfrieden on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:16PM (#45542052)
Musk uses his resources to lobby against mass transit in America.

He is degrowth in ways that suit his selfish preferences (contracts for his companies over better alternatives, and wanting to avoid any proximity to other Americans in public).

edit due to rate limiting: Yes Musk is one of the reasons we don't have high speed rail in California at least. He admitted to creating Hyperloop as a fake and hopeless project simply as a campaign to get high speed rail canceled. And he used DOGE against it to further cripple the project. He used government authority to contribute to regulations against mass transit. His projects are literally fake psyops that don't deliver transit and exist to spoil mass transit options from growing.

We had mass transit before he got rich. Are you opposed to it because it's not perfect so we shouldn't do it at all instead of doing more of it? I don't understand the degrowth attitude of preferring luxury options that scale worse.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:20PM (#45542092)
Ok so Musk is the reason mass transit isn't a success?

So why didn't we get mass transit before Musk was rich?

In Austin we approved an enormous rail project and the taxpayers approved billions to build it. Years later, they have descoped it by 75% and they haven't even come close to delivering that small bit they reduced it down to.

Was that Musk too? Or is overregulation destroying our ability to innovate?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by EasyMark on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:34PM (#45544038)
Yeah it's a weak argument. Public transportation is weak in the US because support for it is weak. It will take a dramatic shift in the Average American view of mass transit or some breathtaking price decrease in trains/tunneling/trams along with comfort of travel in said methods.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Yhatsupuj on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:41PM (#45542307)
People are not anti innovation or anti tehcnology.

People are against bullshit.

We KNOW how to build these type of things. We KNOW what it would cost. We KNOW how to do it right.

Musk had enough money to build something which is worse of everything we already know and dangerous.

You are ignorant and Musk didn't prove shit.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Ekaros on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:36PM (#45544056)
If you know how to do things in decent way. There is no point of doing them poorly. Each large investment should reach previous level if not improve from it. Or have reasonable trade off when not doing that.

Should next time we build say water infra, instead of burying pipes underground we build massive aqueducts to deliver water to each house?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by owenthejumper on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:17PM (#45542072)
so, a subway?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by cheschire on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:21PM (#45542108)
Sounds like you got the joke.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dzhiurgis on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:45PM (#45542977)
Yes the thing that costs insanely more and only used by 10% of people. Also subsidised by government and is source of crime and disease.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by throwaway-11-1 on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:07PM (#45541960)
love how you're slowly working your way to describing a train, I think most people around the world would agree is the optimal solution here
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by oblio on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:10PM (#45541989)
OP is being extremely sarcastic.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by throwaway-11-1 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:50PM (#45543633)
my bad, I am absolutely struggling to detect it anymore on anything pertaining to Elon
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by rafterydj on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:51PM (#45541779)
everybody knew and voiced their knowledge before, during, and after the Vegas tunnel that Boring Co and the Hyperloop were just bad concepts. You didn't need to waste money to try it, because it's not new tech. It's a tunnel. It's a solution to traffic. It's for riders, not drivers. But instead of calling it a train and therefore being _lame_, you slap a fresh coat of paint on it with _self driving cars_ and _insane_ promises you could never deliver on.

Calling out snake oil, for being snake oil, and lamenting that it sucks all the oxygen out of the room for _real_ , _serious_ technology and progress? That's a good thing.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:13PM (#45542016)
Ok, so they should build a train/subway. Who has done this? Is anyone doing it? If not, why?

Should we stop all other projects that are short of the perfect solution?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by rafterydj on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:26PM (#45542154)
This is why I use the phrase "sucking all the oxygen out of the room" where the proverbial oxygen is funding:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_High-Speed_Rail#Hyp...

Musk literally admitted he wanted to block progress on new rail projects, and the Hyperloop was his PR project to do so. Snake oil.

There are many people who want new train infrastructure. Musk is not one of them.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by mikestew on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:55PM (#45542448)
I can almost hear the sea lion barks from here.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Animats on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:39PM (#45542289)
Not self driving cars. The Las Vegas loop has human drivers.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by munk-a on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:04PM (#45541923)
As someone who works enthusiastically on new ground breaking technology... a dumb idea is a dumb idea - and when we pour this many resources into a dumb idea it prevents us from funding good ideas.

This tunnel has been used as a continued excuse for NIMBYism to block an extension of the monorail which is the actual solution that Las Vegas needs. In fact, the entire boring company appears to, after the fact, have been an effort dedicated solely to derailing SoCal high speed rail efforts.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by MrDarcy on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:45PM (#45541707)
They aren’t just trying shit in the real world, they are literally boring holes into it causing significant harm to people and the environment.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:13PM (#45542021)
Can you list the significant harm to people and the environment? I read the article and I'm struggling to find anything.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by cheschire on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:24PM (#45542139)
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/26184164-tbc-state-l...

Looks like its mainly related to waste water and not cleaning up after themselves.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by red-iron-pine on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:45PM (#45541709)
this is the news blog for a tech incubator. there is an awful lot of snake oil in this sector, and which is pushed hard here, and an awful lot of high-end talent here, too.

which means the snake oil tends to be called a lot.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by jncfhnb on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:46PM (#45541731)
“All this” refers to 800 violations damaging the environment.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by taco_emoji on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:34PM (#45542236)
Is the technological innovation in the room with us right now?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by jmuguy on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:04PM (#45541926)
What technology and progress has the boring company enabled?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:13PM (#45542030)
A breakthrough in tunnel cost and speed per meter. Have you read into this at all or is this just another snarky comment?
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by Supermancho on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:25PM (#45542150)
Almost every bored tunnel project has unique constraints. Lots of breakthroughs could be achieved by ignoring regulations and external considerations. This is not innovation or a particularly interesting result.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by idiotsecant on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:32PM (#45542819)
This 'breakthrough' appears to have mainly been achieved by ignoring health and safety regulations. Not so impressive.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by jmuguy on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:22PM (#45542122)
I've seen Musk and TBC make those claims, I haven't seen evidence from the industry that they're actually having an impact.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by kstrauser on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:40PM (#45542301)
Ignoring environmental regulations to externalize costs, apparently.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by antonvs on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:47PM (#45542361)
People laugh at the Boring Company precisely because what is not doing anything meaningfully new, and what it is doing is worse than every other comparable system. There’s no “progress” there that makes any sense.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by dtjb on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:58PM (#45541856)
They're not being held back by anti-progress haters, they're just straight-up ignoring the environmental agreement they voluntarily signed.

When companies have complete disregard for public welfare and dump the cost onto everyone else, that damage needs to be part of their value equation.

FTA -

>That agreement, signed by a Boring executive in 2022, was intended to compel the company to comply with state water pollution laws. Instead, state inspectors documented nearly 100 alleged new violations of the agreement.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by FireBeyond on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:45PM (#45541710)
This is a fleet of sometimes-self-driving vehicles following a nearly straight route in a closed environment with very few variables.

There's little to describe "progress" or "technology" in this.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by antonvs on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:52PM (#45542421)
Apparently the Vegas loop cars are all driven by a human driver currently.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by preisschild on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:42PM (#45542310)
Car tunnels are neither "progress" nor "technology" lol

Proper rail-based public transit has existed for centuries and its miles ahead of this.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by fragmede on Friday October 10, 2025 @01:59PM (#45541858)
It's possible to be pro-progress while being anti-this specific thing. In particular, Elon Musk came out and admitted that he hates trains and busses and admitted that he just made up Boring Co to distract from giving money to them. The Boring Co tunnels in Vegas are a boondoggle and not even well designed (whether that's due to lack of funds or stupidity or corruption, who knows!). The problem is the opportunity cost. The millions that went into the Vegas tunnels could have gone into improving the existing monorail system, but instead there's this stupid thing.

The tunnels are cool and the technology is neat. I'm not in charge of anything, but no thanks.

Here's where I'm coming from: https://youtu.be/VPjODKUxV5g

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by leetharris on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:16PM (#45542053)
In the last 50 years, well before Elon was involved and supposedly sabotaging all this great subway progress, how many new subway projects in America were started and successfully finished?

Maybe Elon's solution is a requirement to make ANY progress because the other ones have stalled out?

I would love a subway. Here in Austin, they proposed a bunch of new trains and subways for billions of dollars. We all voted yes and funded it. After a multi-year study, they revised it to about 1/10th the scope and doubled the cost. It still hasn't materialized.

Do you all realize the problem here?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by tredre3 on Friday October 10, 2025 @04:08PM (#45543225)
> Was that Musk too? Or is overregulation destroying our ability to innovate?

Texas isn't known (to outsiders like me, at least) as burdening itself very much with regulations. It's possible that a blue city like Austin might apply extra regulation over state regulation, but still, are you sure that overzealous regulation is what prevents Texas from building transport? I would have tought complacency, nimbyism, corruption. But not regulation.

If you're right then it's pretty much game over for America, isn't it? Because almost all other states have even more regulatory pressure, right?

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by idiotsecant on Friday October 10, 2025 @03:33PM (#45542831)
>> Making infrastructure is hard, so making dumb infrastructure that doesn't work is better.

Not really following if you're making some other point here.

Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by fragmede on Friday October 10, 2025 @02:38PM (#45542278)
I don't know who "you all" is. What I'm saying is that that the money spent on the Vegas tunnels could have been better spent on the monorail system. I'm not in charge of anything though, so me saying that doesn't affect anything.
Re:Boring Company cited for almost 800 environmental violati... by groundzeros2015 on Friday October 10, 2025 @05:13PM (#45543845)
Yes. There has been a distinct cultural shift. Some of it is politics for sure, but this forum is generally less optimistic about the future and technology than 2012-2016